44 min · 5,107 words · 28 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching explains that labelling others as friend, enemy or stranger, driven by attachment, aversion and indifference, blocks love, compassion and bodhicitta. Equanimity towards all beings is presented as essential for both liberation and enlightenment, and as a basis for a stable mind not swayed by worldly concerns. The talk also clarifies the twelve links, especially intentional thought and karmic imprint, and answers a question on doubt.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-28
Duration: 45 min
UUID: 3a7ddd4d-d79d-4fb7-923a-29ce90472794
Words: 5,107
So our self-cherishing thought is working out, is this other harming or helping, good or bad, happiness or suffering? So because of that, because of our delusions, instinctively, from beginning of time, we label sentient beings, mother sentient beings, as either friend, enemy or stranger. Uncontrollably, we do that all the time. Already, during these three weeks in this course, we have some friends, strangers, and enemies in the course. Yeah.
There’s some people here we’ve completely ignored, hardly even looked at, probably haven’t even said hello to yet after three weeks. Some people we spend a lot of time talking to and some people we totally avoid. That’s what we do. Always, friend, enemy little boxes, friend, put friend box, enemy box, stranger box. Stranger box is the biggest box, very small box for friends and a small box, only a small box hopefully, for the enemies.
Who knows? Maybe we have a very big box for the enemies, but that’s how it goes uncontrollably. Afflicted desire, attachment creates the friends, our aversion creates enemies, and our indifference creates strangers, and we do that all the time. So, while we’re doing that, while we create we continue to create and believe in the existence of truly existing friends, truly existing enemies, and truly existing strangers, there is no way we can generate Bodhicitta, no way we can get enlightened, no way we can be really beneficial to living beings, no way, impossible. Everything is possible, but it is not possible to achieve enlightenment while we generate this mind of partiality, that there is there are real friends, there are real enemies, and there are real strangers.
Because if we think they’re real friends, all all our good energy goes to them. But actually, what we think is our good energy is actually just our attachment. We get attached to our friends. So our our attachment to our friends blocks us from feeling generating love and compassion for our friends. We have a friend, Oh, I love my friend, I enjoy being with my friend, but then my friend decides to become a monk and go away, or become a nun and go away.
Oh, don’t become a monk or no, go go don’t do that, that’s ridiculous, you’ll be miserable. Stay here and be my friend. So this is desire attachment, it’s not wishing the person to have happiness and the causes of happiness. So our attachment and desire for our friends, family, while that is strong, it actually blocks our love and compassion for our friends and family. So if our love and compassion is blocked for them, it’s certainly blocked for all others.
And because we follow our afflicted desire and attachment for friends, of course we create enemies, people who harm my friends, my family, my this, my that, are my enemies. And so the aversion comes out, and then the vast majority of living beings don’t seem to help me very much, they don’t seem to harm me very much, so who cares about them? The mind remains indifferent. There’s no care, there’s no wish to harm, but no caring. There’s this kind of indifference.
Indifference doesn’t sound very bad, but actually what it does, it does something terrible. It blocks our ability to express our love and compassion. It blocks we have this potential to feel love and compassion for all living beings. Our indifference blocks that. And it ends as a product of our ignorance.
So while we get caught up in friends, enemies and strangers, it just perpetuates our delusions of attachment, aversion and indifference again and again and again. And So there’s no way to to to wish all sentient beings to have happiness, for all sentient beings to be free of suffering. Because while we have enemies, the the mind thinking enemy, the the truly existing enemy, that enemy does not deserve happiness. Even but while we while we are generating this person as enemy harming me is bad, we can’t even wish them worldly happiness. We don’t even want them to have even a piece of chocolate.
So, no way. Our love and compassion can’t develop, it’s blocked. As I said before, if we hate one ant, there’s only one sentient being left in the universe and it’s one ant we can’t stand. No Bodhicitta, no enlightenment. So what we need to do is develop this mind of impartiality towards all living beings, whereby we reduce our attachment and desire, afflicted desire, to friends and family.
We don’t reduce our love for them, our affection for them, but we try to reduce our attachment to them, increase our affection for reduce our indifference to the strangers generate some affection for them and reduce our hatred for the enemy and generate affection for them, so that we try to develop this equal affection for all living things, whether that whether conventionally they still may appear as friend, stranger, or someone who wishes to harm us, or at one level we recognize that we dislike them, but still we can try to oppose that with a thought that may they be happy. So we develop this equal yeah, this equanimity, seeing all beings as basically the same. Same in the sense that they all deserve happiness and and they they do not deserve suffering. This is the the mind of equanimity that we need to train in. And this mind, this practice is, apart from being crucial to achieving enlightenment, it is also an essential practice in the path to liberation because while we have friend, enemy and stranger, we have we have anger and attachment.
And while we have anger and attachment, we can’t develop wisdom and achieve liberation. So it’s essential to both the spiritual paths and even in our daily life, even in ordinary life. There is more peace and happiness in our mind if there is this more equal feeling towards sentient beings. If we think about it, the vast majority the human beings that we experience, we experience as strangers. We cut ourselves off from all sorts of positive experiences with the vast majority of people because we just label them strangers, and therefore we can’t be bothered to put any energy into them.
So that that itself is very limiting. And and and if you think about the nature of desire attachment, which we should, if we investigate its its its nature, another aspect of it is that what what is it? Well, it’s about as I mentioned before, we’ve had a pleasant experience, so we get attached to that and therefore desire it again. And so we have expectation of it being like that. So we desire attachment locks us into this old pattern, into this rut, into this groove, that thing you know, we want this kind of thing to happen again and again.
So, you know, we have this kind of friend, so we look for similar kinds of friends. So, all our friends are basically the same kinds of people maybe. So we have the same kinds of experiences and we go to the same places with the same friends at the same time and drink the same things and smoke the same things and so on, talk about the same things with the same friends. So we just go, you know, it’s just a rut. There’s just this one one I mean, there’s of course, there’s some variety, you know, know that.
We have different friends. But it’s of just one one area. So desire attachment just keeps us in the same old pattern again and again and again. And we think that’s it, this is wonderful. So the more we’re stuck in that, the more difficult to think there’s anything outside that, and more difficult to work to experience what’s outside that same old pattern.
So, you know, so we’re blocking ourselves even from in an ordinary way from so many experiences of of of meeting of of knowing strangers. And, of course, you know, we want to know the interesting looking strangers, but that’s the desire to turn them into friends. But when there’s the boring looking strangers, we don’t want to know the boring looking ones. Yeah? But may it may be really incredibly interesting to know a boring person.
Even if they are totally boring, it may be very interesting in a completely new way. Or despite their boring characteristics, there may be something fascinating about them. The fascinating thing is they are a sentient being with Buddha nature, wishing happiness and not wanting suffering. This is unbelievably fascinating, interesting thing about all sentient beings. Okay.
I’ll stop here. If you have any questions? Yes. Sorry, what was that last bit? No, you said assuming the enemy isn’t a dharma person.
Yeah, then? Right. Right. Maybe. Even with your friends that you could apply that to friends and strangers too.
But think I mean, we there is this ideal that we are aspiring to. This ideal is not just but it’s something that can become real, but we also have to work with where we are and we can’t give this perfect lasting happiness to our friends, enemies or strangers yet, but we can try and help them have some some less suffering, a little bit more happiness in their life and that is good to do. At first, yes, with the hope to be able to do more, And with the hope that by this person, like the enemy having a little bit of even more worldly happiness in their life, may that become some kind of springboard for them to discover the real meaning of their existence and their potential. Maybe what just while I think about in relation to talking last night and just one maybe clarifying one thing about the twelve links in the twelve link, the second link is called compositional factors. So this is referring to because when we talk about karma, this word karma is used very loosely, but it has different meanings.
So there is karma, which is the actual action that we do, the action of our body, the action of our speech, the action of our mind. And particularly in these cases, that what the term karma is referring to intentional thought, intentional conscious intentional thought directed to an unmistaken object. So we have the thought of anger directed to someone. Consciously we direct it to someone and then because of that we say something to that person, we direct it consciously to that person to cause harm, and then also we consciously direct our fist to the face of that person to cause harm. So this is the main meaning of karma as intentional thought.
So this is the second link. But when we talk about then there’s karmic imprints. I’ve been talking about because of that karma, this intentional thought. Because of negative intentional thought, we create karmic imprints. Imprints created by karma, which is negative intentional thought.
So, the second link, karmic, you know, intentional thought is consciousness, but the imprint, the karmic imprint, is not consciousness. It is what I in Tibetan, dem min du che, that which is neither form nor consciousness. I hope that clarifies something somewhere for someone. Yes. Rather than in the bardo Sorry?
Those imprints in the bardo No. No. No. They don’t ripen. No.
In in you have the the second link is this this the intentional thought, and then then the third one is consciousness, which is the consciousness in very moment, the consciousness that holds or registers that imprint. And that karmic imprint we’re talking about there is a throwing karma that has got not an incomplete karma, but a complete throwing karma that has the potential to throw us into another life. Right? So then that consciousness so that that third link has two aspects. That moment of consciousness that is registering the imprint or holding it, and then the other aspect of that consciousness is it is that consciousness holding the imprint which craving then starts to nurture.
Just like in the example, you have the seed in the ground, the ground is the consciousness, the seed is the karmic imprint from the connecting karma, And then there’s the moisture the heat or the fertilizer that starts nurturing that. So the craving is that happening at the time of death, that is during the death process, that is nourishing this karmic imprint in the consciousness. Grasping makes it stronger and stronger, it’s like more fertilizer, you’ve got water, then fertilizer. And then existence is the very it’s just like with the example of the mother, the child, the womb, the baby in the womb, it’s not a complete baby out yet. Existence is referring to the very last moment of consciousness of this life where this this seed, this throwing karma is just about to ripen, is just about to ripen, it’s just about to come into existence.
And then in the next moment is birth, which is the consciousness going into the womb. And then birth gives rise to aging and death. Antidote sorry, I cover that one. The antidote to doubt is faith, knowing the qualities of something, studying more and more so you one knows. Because why we doubt is because we don’t have enough knowledge.
Like, if you hear the twelve things first time, you can doubt this is this is a load of nonsense because it’s it’s we haven’t studied it enough, all the details, what it means. So we can have a lots of doubts about it. But then by studying, gaining the knowledge and seeing all the connections, then one’s faith, one sees all the qualities of that explanation and other teachings. So the more we see the qualities, we develop faith and that eliminates doubt. Doubt, like one thing that under holds supports doubt, I mean many things is pride, Our own, I know that thought.
So we doubt. The more we hold to our own opinion, then then it’s very easy to doubt. So we we can dedicate the merit of this time by thinking about Bodhicitta. May this become a cause for us to to fill up the mind aspiring to generate Bodhicitta, and through that aspiration, actually be able to generate Bodhicitta, and therefore follow the path that leads to complete enlightenment for the benefit of all living beings. All.
May the precious Bodhicitta mind, not yet born, arise and grow. May that which is born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Then we can do the food offering practice. So we can try to eat with the Bodhicitta motivation, thinking that to energize the body and mind in order to be able to practice today and all this life for the benefit of all living beings. Thank you.
The purpose of the teachings of the graduated path are to lead us step by step away from a mind that is completely absorbed in worldly life, believing there is only this life and the things of this life. Slowly we can extract our mind away from that obsession towards having a broader view, a vaster perspective that includes the existence of future lives and the need to work for those, and then we can develop this perspective that this itself is still limiting, and that we can actually work to achieve complete liberation from all suffering, this is possible. And then when we’ve generated that mind, this great renunciation, then we have the valid basis to develop the most amazing, revolutionary and positive mind possible, which is the thought to devote all the energy of this life and all future lives to achieving enlightenment in order to repay the kindness of all sentient beings in the best way possible, which is to lead them away from suffering and to lead them onto the path that leads to complete perfection, their own enlightenment. The Bodhicitta thought is the unique characteristic of the Mahāyāna path and Mahāyāna tradition. In both paths to liberation and to enlightenment, is the need for renunciation and the need to develop wisdom.
But what distinguishes the Mahāyāna path is the development of Bodhicitta, this great compassionate thought wishing to achieve enlightenment, which is extremely rare to generate. So we are incredibly so fortunate to meet these teachings that give us the method of how to do that and show that it is a valid thing to aspire to because we have Buddha nature. So we are so fortunate to meet these teachings. So although we have met these teachings and some of us maybe have taken refuge in them and trying to practice this path in some way, and we may have even started doing tantric practices, we shouldn’t make the mistake of thinking that although we’re following a Mahāyāna tradition, we haven’t actually we are not actual Mahayanists yet. The definition of a Mahāyāna is who has generated Bodhicitta, actually generated Bodhicitta.
Then one is a mahayana, then one has actually entered the mahayana path, the actual path that leads to enlightenment. It starts when one actually generates Bodhicitta. The path that leads to liberation starts when we generate the great renunciation of all of saṃsāra. That puts us on the path that leads to liberation. What puts us on the path to enlightenment is when we actually generate Bodhicitta.
So this is the entrance, the doorway, to the Mahāyāna path. There is no other way to enter the Mahāyāna path than generating bodhicitta. So this is one of the benefits of generating bodhicitta, that one enters the Mahāyāna path, and one actually becomes a bodhisattva through generating Bodhicitta. Another great benefit of generating Bodhicitta is that through it one is able to amass an enormous amount of merit very easily. It also purifies all negative karma and obscurations it doesn’t purify it completely but it starts from the moment we generate Bodhicitta, then all of our negative karma, all our obscurations begin to be purified.
Through the power of Bodhicitta we are able to accomplish whatever we wish, and through the power because Bodhicitta is the most virtuous mind of all, then it protects us from harm or hindrances from within ourselves, from the outside environment, from other beings. And of course, through generating Bodhicitta, one is able to quickly complete all the stages of the path to enlightenment. And when one has Bodhicitta, one actually has generated that mind, then one becomes an endless source of benefit to others. There is a prayer that we can make which, at one level when one first hears it, can sound very egotistical, but it goes something to the effect that whoever hears me, sees sees me, touches me, and so on, may they experience happiness and benefit and so on. So, this is a prayer that we can make because when we were a bodhisattva, this is actually the case, that to see a bodhisattva is beneficial.
Just to hear them, just to visually see them, or to hear them, to be able to touch them or something, anything to make any kind of the smallest kind of offering, such as a glass of water or a cup of tea, is unbelievably beneficial for that person. So right now, because our mind is controlled by delusion and karma, it’s not particularly beneficial for any person to see us, touch us, hear us, or anything like that, or particularly beneficial to offer us a cup of tea, or anything like that. But we can pray that by generating Bodhicitta, then just our mere existence will be beneficial to others. It will be beneficial just for people to see us. Wouldn’t that be wonderful?
That it would make people happy just to see us. So these are some of the benefits of generating the bodhicitta mind. And so incredibly important to be able to generate anything like it in this world as it is now, where there is so much delusion, so much self-cherishing, where the thought to cherish others is almost non existent. And because of that, there is so much suffering and and and so many problems of every economic, social, every kind of problem because of that lack of empathy towards others. So, for our meditations on Bodhicitta to be really effective, powerful, and to actually lead to the generation of Bodhicitta.
We need to prepare our mind by generating the two kinds of renunciation: purifying our mind, accumulating merit, praying to generate Bodhicitta, asking for the blessings of the Guru, having the guru’s guidance, developing devotion to the guru, because the guru is a very embodiment of Bodhicitta. A true guru, a true mahayana guru, is the very embodiment of the bodhicitta mind. The true Guru, spiritual master, is an embodiment of all the qualities of the path. So when we meet a qualified teacher and generate devotion to them, we always have with us. It doesn’t have to be physically with us, but in our mind we have the inspiration of a living bodhisattva, you know, to guide us and inspire us.
And it cuts through all sorts of intellectual stuff because we see immediately, when we have our Guru, it’s just so inspiring just to see such a person. Just to see their shoes is inspiring. Even when their holy body is not in the shoes, just to see the shoes of one’s Guru is uplifting. Yeah, it is. The guru is the embodiment of what Bodhicitta is all about, so it cuts through a whole lot of intellectual nonsense and complications and doubts and whatevers.
Just one knows that that’s what one wants to be, like that. So the direct practice we need to achieve for our meditations to work on the basis of having some kind of renunciation is the practice of equanimity, which I said this morning is essential on both the Hīnayāna path to liberation, to enlightenment, and it’s just so helpful in our daily life, in our daily spiritual life, even in our daily worldly life. It’s so helpful to have this mind as much as we can, where we even if we haven’t got perfect equanimity or impartiality to others, at least we’re trying to minimize this mind that so rigidly compartmentalizes others into being friend, enemy or stranger, which is the basis for our delusions of attachment, anger and indifference to arise again and again. So, again, one way to help us develop the mind of equanimity is to see the benefits, to think about all the benefits of having this mind of impartiality. It’s not the mind of indifference, but this stable mind that doesn’t get excited when one is with one’s friends, one doesn’t get upset when we meet the enemy, that doesn’t get bored when we’re surrounded by strangers, but it’s a stable mind.
So, just as we need this stability, this impartiality or equanimity in relation to living beings, also, although it’s not so strongly emphasized as a meditation practice, also we need that with objects, to have impartiality or equanimity with objects. With the worldly concerns, when we get something, we get excited, when we don’t get something, we get unhappy. The mind goes up and down like a yo yo all the time. When there is praise, the mind goes up, when there’s the criticism, the mind goes down. This is the yo yo mind, there’s no equanimity, no impartiality, no stability in the mind.
And the slightest thing can make us excited, slightest thing can upset us and make us depressed. And when these things aren’t exciting us, we get bored. Impartiality, the stable mind that doesn’t go up and down so much in relation to what’s going on in the external world, such a mind is incredibly important and worthwhile and beneficial to have. Just think how wonderful would it be wonderful or not? Well, if our mind remained at ease no matter what happened, a major disaster happened, a major wonderful thing happened, basically our mind remains the same.
Stable, not stably bored or depressed, but stably at peace, at peace, calm, clear, at peace. A great mind to have, I think. So, we can generate this mind particularly in relation to other people by contemplating equanimity. So, is like clearing the ground in order to develop this incredibly positive love and compassion towards all living beings. So before we can do that, firstly we have to minimize these gross discriminations we make between people.
So, in order to meditate on equanimity, to generate this mind as much as we can, we ask ourselves, why do we label a person as friend, enemy and stranger? Because really, at first, there’s just a human being there, and then there’s not a you know, again, this really helps if we’ve understood a little bit about emptiness, and particularly how the mind merely labels things, and things exist depending on the way we label or conceive things. Maybe this is just to make a small but relevant sidetrack that when one studies the lamrim, it’s set out sequentially, linearly, from the beginning to the end, from starting with Guru devotion, precious human rebirth, then it goes up, the last topic is the topic of developing wisdom. Once one has gone through all of that and thought about what this wisdom is and dependent arising, then the more one has that understanding which comes at the end of the path, you go back to the beginning, everything else takes on another flavor, another dimension, becomes much more meaningful and richer and deeper, and more easy to understand and and work with. So, right now, we experience ourselves and others as truly existing, that they’re really like that from their own side.
Things are really beautiful. It’s got nothing to do with me. This is unquestionably beautiful and this is unquestionably ugly. Everyone knows that. There’s there’s no doubt about that.
That’s how we experience the world, most of us, most of the time, even when we have the Buddhadharma tucked under our under our arm. You know, we forget or or, you know, but of course, we shouldn’t to actually gain that experience, things that are otherwise, takes time. But that’s how things are appearing to us. But, for example, someone when we have an enemy, the person we dislike, remember, don’t get too worried about the word enemy, when we have an enemy, it appears unquestionably that that person is bad and so on, from their own side and permanently like that. If that was true, if that appearance to our mind was true, that enemy is truly like that from their own side, it’s got nothing to do with me, I’m just simply a pure mirror reflecting what is there.
If that was true, that was true, then everyone would see that person as an enemy in the same way I do. If that person was truly, existingly an enemy, Everyone would agree in the same way, would hate them, dislike them in the same way I do. But no one has that feeling. Know, many people may agree with me that this person is bad, evil, and terrible, but not everyone does, not everyone, especially the person’s mother. Every enemy has a mother and the mother loves them, thinks they’re great.
But if things were the way they appear, everyone would see them that way because it wouldn’t depend on anything from our side. There’s no dependency whatsoever, there’s this truly existing independent phenomena that is like that from its own side. If you check at lunchtime, there’s all these pots of food laid out, we all get the same food, but everyone takes different things and different quantities. Everybody’s plate is different. Everybody’s plate is different.
Because this looks nice, I like this more than that, and I want more of this than that, and it really looks like that, this is really delicious and that, not so good, and whatever, but if it really was like that, we’d all take the same thing, a large quantity of that one and leave that one behind. If it was really like that from its own side, check up. So that’s how things appear to us that there’s really a friend, really an enemy, really a stranger, but actually the reality is that we have put something on what is just a human being. Our mind, controlled by ignorance and a self-cherishing thought, puts something on to another human being. And what we put on there, that label that we put on, that idea, that appearance, which we then believe is real, depends if we check on how they behave to us.
As soon as this person does something that makes me happy, in the moment, in the moment, in the very moment, person does something to make me happy, feel comfortable, not threatened, this person is good. I like this person, this is my friend. Stranger walks down the street, looks very grim, grim, grim, don’t like. If they smile, a little smile appears, friend, it’s okay, I like this person. Then if a nasty look appears, you know, enemy.
In the moment, it may only last a moment, but in that moment, if there is something pleasant coming, something non threatening, pleasant, whatever, this is friend. And if it continues to be like that, this is really my friend, I like this person, this is a very good person, a very special person, completely different than all other sentient beings, my friends are very special people, completely different, another class by themselves from all other sentient beings. So it’s just this momentary response that we label the friend enemy, the person friend, and then we put all our attention into that person. We try to make them happy, so they make us happy, so we keep putting the label on them. That is the friend, and we want to be with them most of the time.
And then, again, if we check the enemy, the person we dislike, is because in the moment they’ve done something that doesn’t agree with our self-cherishing thought. And so in that moment, when that person, that human being, is contradicting what I want, what I think, what I feel is right, I think what should happen and so on, that person becomes the enemy and appears to be the real enemy. And then any human being who is
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.