Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-11-25

Buddha House Adelaide

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 — 2001-11-25
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Kopan 2001 11 25 Tape 49 Side 2 Bodhicitta.MP3

UUID: e2666e02-12cf-4a9c-a190-28c30ee106a7

Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub

Collection: Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)

Date: 2001-11-25

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 44 min

Words: 4,943

Pride exaggerates some supposed quality that we have or characteristic that we have, then what it does, it has the function of preventing the attainment of any higher virtues, any higher qualities, because we have so much pride that what we have is already so fantastic, that it prevents us being able to learn and advance any further. So, especially from a spiritual point of view, this is a great obstacle that this can very easily arise after like when we first hear the dharma, we may have pride that we already know what life is all about, but then when we hear the dharma, maybe our ordinary pride gets humbled and then we start learning the dharma, but then we learn the dharma, then we get proud about our dharma understanding. And then it becomes difficult to listen and hear because we already think we know, we’ve heard it before and we can explain it better to others. So, rather than hearing, we’re kind of explaining it better in our own mind or waiting to jump and add something and so on. So, it becomes a great obstacle to learning.

And because pride inflates oneself, one has a low opinion of others anyway, so pride is telling us, I can’t, even without hearing the person teach or say something, or one already has decided that one is superior to this person. So, it’s a great obstacle. So it has the function of preventing the attainment of higher virtues and causing disrespect and looking down on others. So, there are different kinds of pride. They basically all have the same aspect but it can manifest in different ways.

When we think of pride, what we normally think of is the mind looking down on others, so that’s one kind of pride feeling superior to others who we perceive as being lower. Conventionally speaking, they may have lesser qualities than us, but even so, pride, the mind looking down, thinking one’s superior because of that, is a harmful mind. But it also may be that one may be totally deluded, and what we think the person has lower qualities, in reality they don’t. So this becomes an even more harmful kind of pride. Then there is a kind of pride that I’ll try and get these in order if I can.

Yes, a kind of excessive pride that feels superior to those who are in fact equal to oneself, basically our peers, but we feel superior to them. And then there’s the very excessive arrogance, which even when we’re around beings who, at one level, we recognise have superior qualities of some kind, but we feel pride that, Oh, I’m just as good as them, if not better. Yeah, they’re kind of holy but, Oh, you know, I’m holy too. Yeah, I’m just as holy, I’m more holy somehow. There is this kind of pride.

Then there is the pride of showing off, which comes from believing that one has some quality that one doesn’t have, and one is very proud of this quality. Is also a very great danger. I mean, all of these kinds of prides are harmful in ordinary, in worldly life, but when it comes to following the spiritual path or trying to follow it, all these kinds of prides become even more damaging because in engaging in the spiritual path, or we think we’re engaging in it, and doing meditation practices, and different retreats, and learning different things, then we may think we’ve got some quality and we become immensely proud of it, and try to influence other people and so on, but the reality is we don’t have that quality at all. We may think we have that quality, we’re not actually lying, we may be totally convinced ourselves that we have this quality, but we don’t at all, and we get incredibly proud about it. We have some kind of minor meditation experience and we think we’ve had a major realization, and we get incredibly proud of it.

It may even be a good meditation experience, it may actually be a negative one, but one thinks it’s a positive one and generates all sorts of pride. Again, I always tell the story that when I was living at Chenrezig Institute in Australia, when I was first a monk, and I’d been a monk a short time, this young guy came to stay at the place for a short time, and as soon as he arrived, came to see me and he wanted to see the resident Geshe, because this young man, he said that he’d become enlightened, so he wanted to compare his enlightened state with the Geshe’s. At first I thought he was just insane, just kind of like seriously mentally disturbed, but by talking to him a little bit, kind of got some idea he was actually okay, but just had made some big mistake about some experience he’d had. And he was saying how when he was meditating he’d fallen into this black hole. And so when he came out of it he realized he was enlightened.

So he was quite proud of that at first, but then he went to see the Geshe. And then his pride collapsed. There was also some other Western person around, I mean, there’s quite a few, but there’s one I’ve think, sort of a little bit famous, I’ve forgotten his name, who was claiming he was enlightened, and so some of the Tibetan monks, just the first thing they asked him, or one Tibetan monk said, What’s my mother’s name? And, of course, he didn’t know the monk’s mother’s name. He was quite shocked, I don’t know.

He said, But you said you’re enlightened, and you don’t know my mother’s name? If you’re enlightened, know everybody’s name. Anyway, so there’s the pride of showing off. Then there’s also perverted pride, which is, as I mentioned before, is pride based on actual negative qualities, such as thieves who are very proud of their abilities, or soldiers who are very proud of their abilities to kill and so on. So this is a very harmful, extremely harmful kind of pride.

So anyway, we should check ourselves whether we experience pride, what causes it to arise, and are things that cause our pride to arise, are they meaningful or meaningless things? And even so, to try and look at what pride does to our mind. What is the feeling of pride? Is it comfortable feeling or not? And how does it affect our relations with others?

Is it a beneficial way to relate to others or not? So we should check out. Then, the fifth of the main afflictive thoughts, the little group of six most dangerous minds, is doubt. So, this is not just ordinary doubt about I’m not sure if this is my book or not. Here, that’s kind of not an afflictive mind to not be sure whether this is one’s book or somebody else’s book.

But the afflicted doubt is referring to really meaningful things that affect the spiritual life. So, there are three kinds of doubt just a moment So, the definition of doubt is to be in two minds about what is true. And it has the function of serving as a basis for not getting involved with positive things, that which is positive and meaningful. It is to be in two minds about the truth, to be in two minds about what is true, and its function is to serve as a basis for not being involved with what is positive or virtuous. So, there are things that which are conventionally true or ultimately true, but one doubts these things.

If something isn’t true, to doubt it or not doesn’t harm oneself. But if something is actually true, conventionally true, or ultimately true, and we doubt it that it is true, then this acts as a basis not to get involved with what is meaningful because we doubt it, we doubt it’s true, so we don’t have the energy to be involved with it. So, the more doubt, then we won’t get involved at all. This is why, especially in the Gelugpa tradition, it’s emphasised that we need to study the teachings to have a correct intellectual understanding of them and to check the teachings, to analyse them again and again in order to overcome doubt, because that doubt, however much doubt we have, will interfere with our spiritual life, will cut the energy of our spiritual life, make it more difficult to practice. And so this is like in the Gelugpa tradition, it’s really only in the Gelugpa tradition that the debate system is engaged in so strongly.

In the Sakya they also do it a little bit, think, but not as much as in the Gelugpa tradition. And this debating system originated in India, as it wasn’t invented by the Tibetans. All this ritual clapping and everything, it all has some meaning. This originated in great monastic universities of India, of Nālānda, and the other one, Viksramakila. What is it called?

Viksramakila, yeah. It originated there and was brought to India and was particularly preserved in the Gelugpa tradition as a way to really gain a very clear understanding that eliminates doubt. So there are three kinds of spiritual doubt. There is the doubt that so this is again regarding something which is true. So there is the doubt that tends so the mind is in tune, you know, doubt is wavering between yes or no.

So there is the doubt that is tending towards no, you know, that is tending towards thinking that what is true is not true. So that’s the worst kind of doubt. There’s a little bit of thought that maybe it’s true but it’s probably not true. Then there is equal doubt where it’s equal that maybe it’s true, maybe it’s not true. And then there is the doubt, the third kind of doubt, is tending towards believing it’s true.

The mind is tending towards thinking it’s probably true but there’s a slight chance it’s not true. This is the third kind of doubt. So if we have to have doubt, this is the best one. So from the point of view of gaining faith in the Buddhist teachings, then this third doubt is okay. That it’s probably true.

I don’t completely believe it, but it’s possibly, probably true. Why? Because the Buddha taught it. Of course the Buddha said, don’t believe what teach just because I say it, check up. But if one also checks up and comes to some belief, intelligent belief that enlightened mind exists, that it has the ability to see that which is true, then it is wise to try to encourage the mind to gain that view of that which is true, to have the mind that tends towards that which is true, tend towards that which the Buddha taught as being true.

Even if we can’t completely believe it, rather than thinking, Oh, it’s probably completely wrong. But if we compare the nature of our mind and the nature of the Buddha’s mind, who is more likely to be right? But you may think, well, I’ve never seen an actual Buddha, maybe they don’t really exist. But then one can think that myself, how much time and energy have I put in this life in looking at my mind? How often am I able to maintain a concentrated mind?

Like when I meditate on the breath, how long can I actually keep my mind on the breath without any distraction? And there’s sneaky distractions where the mind is mostly on the breath but there’s these little sneaky thoughts going on, When’s lunch coming? I wonder what’s for lunch? The breathing is going on but there’s also this little, I wonder if we’re going to have that again today, you know? So that is not concentration.

So do we have concentration? Because this is possible, this is not just a Buddhist belief, this is possible to achieve. So, have we achieved it? And the clarity that comes with that mind, with that ability, and then use that kind of mind to investigate things deeper and deeper. So, are people who’ve done that for possibly lifetimes, who’ve come to some conclusions about how things are.

So, what do we know in comparison to what do we really know? Because we don’t even know who we are, right? We’re not even sure who’s having a shower, remember? Is it me or just my body? So, maybe it’s good to it’s okay to doubt, but maybe it’s trying it’s good to have the doubt that tends towards what the Buddha taught, maybe, than saying, Oh, he hasn’t got a clue.

I’ve read this book, it doesn’t say that. My grandmother never said that. So anyway, these are the three kinds of doubt that disturb our mind, and especially if we have generated some faith in a particular path, taking for example the Buddhist path, then what really is a big obstacle to really intensively engaging in that path is our doubts. First we have some faith, Oh, this is fantastic! We take a tantric initiation and then we do the retreat, and then we think, My God, what am I doing this for?

What is this? Why am I visualizing this thing with all these arms and it’s holding that and it’s holding that? And why am I reciting this mantra, you know, so all these doubts come. So while the doubts are there, there’s no way to do the practice well. No way.

Even if you’re driving in your car and you doubt, Oh, I’m not sure if there’s enough petrol to get where I’m going. Oh, the indicator says there is, but I’m not sure if the indicator is working anymore. Someone doubts and there’s no way to enjoy the journey at all, just gets in the way. So, and you may just stop, you don’t want to be stranded in the desert, so you stop where it’s comfortable. Doubt acts like that on the spiritual path.

It just really cuts our energy continuously. So then the sixth of main afflicted thoughts is wrong views. Of which there are six kinds, six major types of wrong views. So maybe we’ll go through from the Lamrim Chenmo where it says the first one is they have such long names. So good that in Tibetan they’re so short, but when you put them in English they get unbelievably long.

Well, it can be called something like the wrong view of the aggregates. In Tibetan it’s called jikta wa, and it’s the wrong view of the perishable aggregates. So what this is referring to is we have these five aggregates: the form aggregate, feeling, discriminations, compositional factors and consciousness. And so there’s the wrong view that thinks that one or all, one or some or all of the five aggregates are me or the basis or mine. We reify, we create the illusion of this truly existing me that is the five aggregates, one of the five aggregates or all of the five aggregates.

So it’s called the view of the perishable aggregates or the transitory collection because this body, these five aggregates, are just a collection and they’re transitory they’re perishable, they’re impermanent, changing and decaying moment by moment. But on the basis of those, the wrong view believes that there is this permanent, truly existing person that is the body or is the mind. So according to some interpretations, this wrong view of the transitory collection is the same as ignorance, the root ignorance. Some interpretations say it’s slightly different, but I think generally one can say this is basically the same as the root affliction of ignorance, this wrong view. Sorry, not six wrong views, are five.

Five main ones, there’s infinite numbers of wrong views but there are five main ones. So this is the principal one. Then the next one is holding to an extreme view. So this is the view that thinks that, on the basis of the first wrong view, that I am the five one or all of the five aggregates, and is truly existing, the extreme view is thinking that this I, this person, is either permanent, eternal, or how do you say it? Or subject to annihilation in such a way that there will be no rebirth from this life into a future life.

So this is the view of the extreme, that I am either permanent or will be non existent. So, I will not exist, yeah. I will permanently, eternally exist, or I will not exist in the future. So, this extreme yesterday I was talking a little bit about the actual right view that we are trying to achieve from a Buddhist perspective, and there are four philosophical schools and the highest one is the Mādhyamika school. So the Manjamika school, of which there are two parts, but the Manjamika school in general is called the Mādhyamika means the middle way, it is the middle way school.

So this is it is the middle way that avoids this extreme view. There’s the extreme view that says that I will always exist as I am, eternally go on and on and on, have a fixed permanent self, or there is the extreme view that says I won’t exist. One totally extreme view of that view is that I don’t exist anyway, nothing really exists at all, everything’s an illusion. Which is like a philosophical view that has been held, and even some people still hold this view, but this is so kind of extremely ridiculous, very few people hold that view. But there is the extreme view that I will come to an end.

If one believes there’s only this life, then of course I will come to an end. So there are these two extreme views. So the middle way view avoids those two extremes. The middle way doesn’t mean it’s halfway between those two, like a line in a road that is in the middle of the road, it doesn’t mean that. The middle way means it has got absolutely nothing to do with the extreme of saying I am eternal, and it’s got nothing to do with the view, the wrong view that says I will not exist at all.

It is a view, it is a middle way that is totally free of those extreme wrong views. The middle way is not a halfway house, a mixture between those two, it is a view completely free of those two extreme views. Then another of the wrong views is believing that In that hold on. Excuse me. Well, it’s believing that a false system of ethics and religious discipline, which is actually harmful, is a supreme practice, a supreme view.

Examples that are given in the Buddhist tradition of this wrong view is that there are certain Indian beliefs in the past, I don’t know if they still exist, but there was one Indian philosophical school or religious system that believed that the whole purpose of religious life was to train to the point where you would undergo all these ascetic practices and everything, and you would train yourself and your mind, and then one day you would take a trident, this three point trident, you’d stick it in the ground, then you’d get it in a high place, then you would jump on it, and then if it went through your crown chakra, you would become liberated. So, to Buddhism, this is an extreme wrong view that leads to suffering. There were also, at the time of the Buddha, there were ascetics who went around acting like dogs. They would only eat food on the ground, like lick it up, like a dog, they would walk on all fours, in the belief that if you acted like that now, you would escape the karma of being born a dog in the future. So this was the best way to behave.

And there’s also like the views of standing on one leg and holding your hand in the air, and by that you get liberated. So these views, there are still yogis who do that. So from a Buddhist point of view, this is holding a false ethical system as the highest, because it requires quite a kind of ethical discipline to do that, but it doesn’t lead to liberation and enlightenment. It’s just wrong view. Then another of the fourth of the wrong views is the believing a wrong philosophical system itself is the right one, is the highest view.

Which could include, for example, believing that killing is good. Sacrificing animals is good, That by sacrificing animals, this creates the cause to achieve liberation or enlightenment. So, such so and believing that this is the highest thing, then this is a harmful wrong view. There are there are there’s views that also that it is perfectly okay and even good to steal from someone who is not of the same religion as yourself. This is also what I don’t know if this still exists, but in India there was this view of one religious tradition that it was bad to steal from people within your own religious system, but it was okay.

It was good to steal from others outside that. So this is wrong view. Stealing is stealing is negative karma. And then the last wrong view is And then the last wrong view is called perverse views. So this is the wrong view that denies the existence of past and future lives or karma and its effects.

Or that there is true existence, I can think you’d say. So it is belief that holding these wrong views acts as the basis sooner or later to create all sorts of negative karma. And the more strongly we hold them, of course, the more that is true. So, we may have some of these wrong views to some extent, but we may not be holding to them very strongly. But in the case of when we talk about the ten non virtues to be avoided, there are the three of body, the four of speech, and the three of mind, so there, there’s also what are called wrong views, the negative karma of wrong the negative action of wrong view, creating the negative action of holding wrong view.

So, that case, there the wrong view can be any of these, but in a very extreme form, where one holds them extremely strongly and totally rejects any consideration that there could be any other possible truth whatsoever. So we may have some wrong views about future lives and karma and various other things, but because we may not be holding onto them strongly, and certainly holding onto them strongly as our views are the highest, then this is not the same as the wrong view, which is one of the ten non virtues. So, from these six root afflictions, then all the other disturbing thoughts arise, but mainly from desire attachment. From desire attachment, all the others come. Like, for example, pride is mainly coming from attachment.

The wrong views are also coming from difficult to say wrong views. What was the other one? Is coming from ignorance, it’s a type of ignorance. But then we have other disturbing thoughts such as, what? All sorts of irritation and annoyance and things like that, negative minds which are coming from anger.

We have the mind of concealment which is a type of attachment. Then there’s jealousy, which is coming from from is based on attachment. And it’s kind of mixed with pride. We have some pride or attachment to things, and then we see that someone else has better qualities than ourselves, possesses things that we want, so we’re incredibly jealous. Develop this mind of envy, wanting those things.

Our mind can’t bear to see this person having these things, can’t bear to see the good qualities of another person, can’t even bear to hear about the good qualities of another person or someone because of jealousy, so it torments our mind. Then also there’s the mind of miserliness coming from attachment. Then there’s smugness coming from attachment, Being smug. Self satisfaction, like very So anyways, these are some of the disturbing thoughts. Traditionally it says there are eighty four thousand disturbing thoughts.

I was told one time that self esteem is actually a form of pride, but it also looks like it could be the first of the wrong views. What I mean low self esteem. Low self esteem. It’s a type of pride. It is?

Yes. You’re saying yourself? Well, just the it’s the pride of thinking low. One holds onto it. It’s a type of inverted pride, thinking, I’m so bad.

You take pride in being so low, not in being humble, but I’m so poor, I’m so hopeless. It’s a kind of inverted pride. Dwelling on a low quality. Oh, it’s not just in the US. But yeah, sure, competitive.

Is there an exact I haven’t heard that word yet. Oh, does exist. Not all the disturbing thoughts are labelled and specified in the Buddhist teachings. They talk I don’t think this is no, this is not competitiveness, I mean this is a mixture of pride and attachment. Yeah, can also act as a basis for anger, of course, as well.

But there’s so many disturbing thoughts which are compounded on the basis of these principle thoughts. If we understand these principle ones and work on those, then a lot of these other ones sort of start to get taken care of. Think, yes? What was three and four? One is mainly belief in a wrong ethical system and holding that as supreme or an ethical system or way of behaviour, thinking that is the supreme system.

And the other one is believing an actual philosophical system, not so much the ethical system, but a whole philosophical system. Could you give examples from today? Scientific materialism. Okay, that’s a philosophical It’s philosophical system, I think. Well, I mean, you could put it in that category.

Only what you can see with the senses exists. Is a scientific view, and scientists exalt that as the highest view, that everything can be known through this view. But if you check this scientific view, it has very fundamental assumptions. So anything that doesn’t fit in with that assumption is ipso facto non existent, which is not very scientific. That’s maybe a book that also Yeah, which argues that completely refutes the existence of mind.

A fundamental assumption of scientific materialism is that mind does not exist. Some scientists, holding this for you, say it’s not even necessary to use the word mind. There’s even an expression for it, it’s a categorical it’s a categorical what? Anomaly. Anomaly.

No. Not anomaly. Something else. It’s a categorical something or other to to use the word mind because of this brain. Oh, what behaviour is?

Possibly, well, yeah. Wrong view, anger is good, you should express anger. This is a minor wrong I mean, it’s just not a whole philosophical system, but it itself is a wrong view. Yes? No, no, the eight mundane, the eight worldly concerns are like expressions of those six root afflictions.

So, in fact the other way around? Yes, yes. Because we have these six root afflictions, we generate the eight worldly concerns. Yes? Oh no, we’re not conscious of it, no, no, no.

Okay, so when I see something that I think is beautiful, that’s automatically labeled? We’ve done it already. Yeah. Yeah. No, it would be so easy if we knew we were putting on the labels.

But isn’t it through certain cultures and upbringing you have preference for things, and how does that Same thing. There’s cultural labels and then there’s layers of labels. There’s our own personal ones, but also our personal ones are conditioned by our like the generation we’re in. The young generation are always hopeless. The good old days were always not just exaggerating.

Like the time we’re in, the culture, the country, many things like this condition But we also create, even if we are born in a particular culture, we may have completely contrary ideas or perceptions to what the culture we’ve been born in, but we still are conditioned by our cultural labels. But then there are the instinctive ones, one could say. Well, in the Abhidharma where it talks about the virtuous and non virtuous minds, there are the twenty virtuous minds to be cultivated, and there are two of them called, for want of better words, shame and embarrassment. So, there are positive minds of shame and embarrassment. I mean, can be just worldly minds of being embarrassed and ashamed for worldly reasons, but there are two virtuous minds where shame is the virtuous mind that prevents us doing negative things because of in relation to ourself.

Oh, I’m a basically good person and I’m a follower of the dharma and I’ve made these commitments to myself so I shouldn’t do that. So taking our own ourself as an example, we are ashamed to do certain things because we know it’s not correct and we’ve decided it’s not correct and so on. Embarrassment is thinking, I shouldn’t do this because this will upset the minds of others. So it’s a virtuous mind to cultivate.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top