Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 22 Tape 41 Side 1 Karma

44 min · 4,619 words · 22 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 22 Tape 41 Side 1 Karma
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The speaker answers student questions on karma, explaining that rescuing beings cannot remove their karma, but improving conditions in the world makes negative karma less likely to ripen. He then teaches that compassion arises from awareness of suffering, and that the ten virtuous actions are a practical daily practice. The session closes with a dedication of merit.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-22

Duration: 44 min

UUID: 0087d6e2-a95a-485a-a238-c01d02b83607

Words: 4,619

Said that. Okay. Yeah. So how If you save the life of something, it’s going to die but you do something so it doesn’t die. So it still has the karma.

Yeah, the karma will have to be experienced in another life. I really have to check up with Lama Lhundrup about that because I’m not really sure that everything was really understood in that question. I mean, generally, what I’ve always understood is that if someone is suffering, you try and stop it. If something is suffering, it is our duty to try to help stop that suffering. That’s why the Buddhas appeared in the world, and that’s why karma ripens depending on the conditions.

If we change the conditions, we can’t take people’s karma from them, we can’t purify their karma, but we can change the conditions in the world, especially in our own small world but also in the world at large. And by changing the conditions in the world at large, it changes what karma ripens and what doesn’t ripen. If we make the world a beautiful place, it’s much more difficult for the negative karma to ripen. I don’t mean just physically beautiful but a nice good place, compassionate place. Then it’s much more difficult for the negative karmas of people to ripen, much more easy for their positive karma to ripen.

That’s what we, as ordinary people, can do. We can contribute in countless small ways to making this world a better, kinder place. And that is changing everyone’s karma. It doesn’t eliminate karma, it doesn’t purify it, but it’s like the thing with the cows at the door. It becomes the condition for the good cows to get out, not the bad ones.

Well, if you’re running a good business or a farm, running a farm well, is that good karma? This is true, but I think these things generally are called worldly concerns. It’s usually done for this life, but if you’re doing it to really benefit sentient beings, if you’re doing it with a really good heart to really benefit sentient beings, then it could be good karma. No, same. We are a sentient being.

Whether we direct it at ourselves or others, it’s the same, pretty much. If we direct negative thoughts to us, it’s creating negative karma. We’re supposed to love ourselves. Not supposed to, we can. We objects of love and compassion.

Especially when we create negative karma. We should love ourselves, not hate ourselves, we should love ourselves and feel compassion for ourselves. I have a few more questions to the drawing and From my understanding that becomes a throwing karma. When all the factors are complete in a karma, can that become a completing karma? A karma.

A ripening karma, no, usually that is a throwing karma. And if you When that lower rebirth finishes? No, because there are the other like we say, what we’ve been meditating on, there are the results similar to the cause and the environmental result. So they all come from that one throwing karma. So, part of the throwing karma is experienced in the lower realms, some is in the human realms.

So, part of the throwing karma causes that lower rebirth and the other part of the throwing karma does cause the human rebirth, because a human rebirth can only be caused by virtuous throwing karma, but in that human rebirth the other parts of the negative throwing karma are experienced. Yes? Doesn’t the saved dog have the karma to be saved? Yes. Does the saved dog have the karma to be saved?

Yes, the saved dog has to have the karma to be saved. But it’s not sure it will ripen if you don’t save it, the karma won’t ripen. Yeah, I think we’ve had this question before but it’s very hard to say. Is a being with consciousness? So all animals have consciousness, plants do not have consciousness, but there are sentient things that look like plants.

More specifically, does it require the anatomy of a nervous system? I don’t think so. No, it doesn’t need a nervous system. But if there is a nervous system, the mind can operate at a higher level. Yes?

Does an animal save a person’s life? Would that create enough merit to be reborn as a human? Oh yes, sure. Animals can create good karma. Good karma can be created in all the lower realms but very difficult.

There is the amazing story of the very first time the Buddha generated Bodhicitta was in the hell realm. So one can even generate Bodhicitta in the hell realm. But this is kind of difficult. Don’t wait. Sorry, this is very arrogant, but can I try and answer your question last night again that you asked?

I don’t know if this is really answering it, but I think you seem to be and maybe many people make this mistake but I try and maybe I haven’t identified the mistake but in the evolution of the species from biological things to fish, I mean, I think there were fish and then they came out, and amphibians and then developed what do call it? And then you have apes and then maybe human beings developed from apes. So, if this is true, scientifically true, then the Buddhadharma doesn’t deny that, that the continuity of this body goes back to other human beings. You know, the genetic material of this goes back to our parents, to our grandparents, back, back, back forty, fifty, one hundred thousand years, maybe back to these, what are the Cro Magnons and Neanderthals and back and back to primates and back and back to things lurking in the deeps of the primordial forests of whatever. So that is the continuity of body, right?

But our minds are separate, possibly, this is what Buddhism is saying. So as bodies have been evolving, minds have as bodies evolve, different kinds of bodies evolve, then minds that have karma, a certain kind of karma, get attracted into those bodies. Right? Beings who have, in the past, who had the karma to be in a neanderthal body reincarnated in those bodies and experience that kind of life, Now, there are human bodies with the human nervous system and brain, so the minds that are incarnating in such bodies have a much greater, higher level of virtuous karma because with this body we can do so much. Our intelligence is much more operative.

A particular body, the mind itself or in a Neanderthal body or an ape body, it’s difficult to develop the mind, purify the mind and so on. But in a human body, even as like my mind is in this particular human body, so I can practice the Dharma and I may gain some experiences in this life, then I die and I decide what’s the word? The best case scenario, maybe I get a little bit realized in this life and I send my mind to a pure land. Maybe difficult to believe that I hang out in this pure land for some time And then I decide after some time that I’ll come back to be a human being to help others. So when I come back, the human body has evolved.

human beings have been recreating not recreating, procreating, recreating and procreating, and bodies have been evolved perhaps human bodies will evolve more and more. So then my mind will come down and be in a more physically changed or it may devolve actually according to predictions, the bodies will get when the time of Maitreya Buddha comes, we will live to be only eight years old, we will only grow to be about a foot high, we’ll be totally deformed. And that’s when I decide to come back. So, my mind comes back into a human body, like human sperm and ovum and when that develops, I’ve got this totally deformed human body. I mean, may not believe that but this is what the dharma is saying, that there are two things happening, there’s minds changing and evolving or devolving and then bodies have a separate continuity.

Yeah? Like I was saying with the mind, can turn into steam, this ice, hail, snow, that has its own evolution and devolution changing back and forwards. And at the same time as this water is doing that, the environment in which that water is changing, changing, changing, that environment is changing. But two different things, but interconnected. I don’t know if that is any way clarifying what you were talking about last night.

Certainly clearer than the work I suppose. I mean, I’m not saying that I mean, you may not believe this, but this is like what dharma is talking about. I think it’s yeah, okay, sorry, we have to finish. Okay, thank you very much for your attention. We can dedicate the merits.

If we believe in karma, we have created very good karma, we’ve had the right motivation, the right object, the dharma. We listened in the right way, hopefully. And now we can dedicate the merit to enlightenment. So this then becomes an incredibly, totally powerful, complete, virtuous karma. So we can joyfully dedicate this, may this energy become a cause of our complete enlightenment to benefit all sentient beings, to have the wisdom, the compassion, the endless, skilful means to lead every sentient being away from creating negative karma, and to encourage them in every possible way to create the causes of genuine happiness and therefore set them on the path to their own liberation and enlightenment.

May the precious body and mind not yet born arise and grow. May those born have no decline, but increase forevermore. Then if you’d like to join in, we can do the food offering practice. Page sixty. Thank you very much.

Please excuse me. I think there’s time. I just have to give one illustration of the point. Please, if you can bear with me. My example, myself, I have gappy teeth.

I have this huge gap in my teeth and I have a large nose. My father had a large nose and a gap in his teeth. So the obvious reason why I have a big nose and a gap in my teeth is I inherited the genetic material from my father, unquestionably, there’s no doubt about that. But, I am not just my body, I am my mind. There’s this mind that came into the sperm and ovum of my parents and therefore now I’ve got this body I’m experiencing, my mind is experiencing a body that has a big nose and gappy teeth.

So that mind came from somewhere else and had the karma to have this body. And my mind could have come may not have been human in my past life. I may have been a dog or something and actually it says specifically, the karma to have a gap in your teeth is to enjoy chewing bones. So, I was probably a dog. Powerful virtuous factor of the dharma itself.

And another factor that we need to apply is our own motivation, so the strength of our motivation, its sincerity and the type of motivation that we have acts as a cause that enables a certain effect to arise, to be experienced. So, the very best motivation that we can possibly have to listen to the dharma and to do anything in this life and all our future lives is to move away from the self-cherishing thought that has caused suffering to our self and others, life after life, and to develop the mind that cherishes others more than self. And the mind that is cherishing others more than self is the mind that is pervaded by all the virtuous qualities of love, compassion, generosity, patience and so on, immediately benefit our own mind. So, the mind wishing to develop like this and achieve full enlightenment can arise depending on following the path. And to understand that path we need to hear the presentation of the path again and again, so we can think that for the benefit of myself and all living beings, not just in this life but in all future existence, I’ll listen to this presentation.

So, we can, in trying to generate this mind more strongly, can visualize the Buddha as our object of inspiration, a symbol of the goal that we ourselves wish to achieve because deep within us we have this Buddha nature. And then we think of all sentient beings surrounding us who are suffering so much and need our help. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Supreme Assembly by the merits I create by practising the Dharma. May I become a Buddha in order to benefit all sentient beings? Then we can spend a little time focusing our mind on the breath.

Thank you. Many people have come to this course, maybe the actual content of the course is quite a shock because often we take interest in a spiritual path, something like the Buddhadharma, maybe thinking because we have this attitude of believing just in this life, that we want something to solve the problems of this life, make this life more enjoyable and so on. But the Buddhadharma is not about that as such. It’s something much more radical and has a much vaster perspective than that. And it’s trying to lead us away from just thinking of this life to having this much vaster perspective, not just of the happiness that we can experience ourselves, but to have a much vaster perspective of what we can do to benefit others and how beneficial that is.

These ideas are very radical and if we are not really familiar with them, then they may be kind of shocking and upsetting and a great challenge to one’s beliefs and so on. I don’t know what I can say other than please try to listen with an open mind and not be too upset by all these things. As I try to say, maybe I’m not doing it correctly, but the Buddha presented it, the Buddha presented it, maybe I’m not presenting it, but the Buddha taught the Dharma to inspire us to a more total, enjoyable, perfect way of life. That’s what it’s about. It’s not there to threaten us, insult us, put us down, make us feel guilty, depressed, or anything like that, if you understand its intention.

And again, when we hear this presentation that we could achieve enlightenment and benefit all sentient beings, this just sounds too much, that it’s just too much, I didn’t come here for that, it’s just too much, and I can’t do that, I just can’t do that, and we tend to depress ourselves with these thoughts. But, of course, I, as I is now, can’t do that. But maybe we should open our mind just in this month to consider the possibility that the I that we think we are is not the I we are. And that the I that we hold onto is such a limited view of what we are. And that maybe we are capable of much more than we think.

And already, having been here for two weeks, maybe I am already a different person than the I that came here. And the I is changing moment by moment, so enlightenment is achieved moment by moment. So, this is a preliminary because of the fact that, unfortunately, much of the first part of the presentation of the path to enlightenment, especially if we’re new to it and haven’t thought about it before, is quite shocking. And we’re also moving to another heavy part. You thought death was heavy and you thought the lower realms were heavy, karma was heavy, now there’s another heavy part to move into, but after that, it should get better.

If there’s any time left, it should get better, so please wait. But also, one thing to remember, even in thinking about being confronted with these very difficult things for our ordinary mind to think about, such as death and suffering of thinking about the possibility of lower realms and horrible suffering and thinking about how easily negative karma is created and so on. The immediate purpose of this is to benefit ourselves, to wake ourselves up to the suffering we have and the potential for it, so we can do something wise and compassionate to free ourselves from suffering. But the ultimate purpose of it is to develop compassion for all sentient beings. Because while we think about impermanence and death in relation to ourselves, as I try to point out, it is actually done in the presentation of the whole path to enlightenment.

And the more we realise our own impermanence and death, it’s the basis for understanding that everyone is under the control of impermanence and mortality. So it’s an object of compassion. So it’s a way to develop compassion. That knowledge, that understanding, not just as an intellectual idea, but something heartfelt, is the way to develop compassion. And then when we think that we ourselves could experience the lower realms, also it opens us up to the possibility of considering that if could, there’s any chance I could experience these states, sentient beings are actually experiencing them now.

So, again, it opens our mind to feel compassion. And again, when we think of how easy I can create negative karma, then we see how all people around us do that and are completely unaware of it. So how sad this is. This again is a reason for developing compassion for every living person, every sentient being, not just the poor, the weak, the downtrodden, the victims and so on, but for everyone. A truly all encompassing compassion.

And then, when we get on to the next topic, which maybe I’ll get to later on in this talk, when we think about the totality of suffering, firstly, the purpose is to think in terms of our own suffering and potential for suffering, to wake us up, to get out of it, to get out of saṃsāra, out of this limited mind, beyond this limited mind. That in the broader context, by thinking about our own suffering, although it’s hard to hear and maybe harder to contemplate, it is the basis of developing compassion and Bodhicitta and enlightenment. Many people like to hear teachings about compassion and Bodhicitta. Oh, these are lovely teachings. Lovely, lovely, lovely, so nice.

But the only way one can generate compassion is knowing about suffering. There is no other way. One can talk about compassion in this vague way. Be compassionate, compassionate is good, compassion is nice, everyone will love you if you’re compassionate. You will love other people if they’re compassionate and everyone will live happily ever after if we’re all compassionate.

One can go on like that but that’s no way to actually develop compassion. The way to develop compassion is feeling suffering. Yeah, feeling one’s own suffering and the suffering of others. It’s the only way because that’s what compassion is. It’s a response to the feeling, the experience, the awareness of suffering.

That’s what actual compassion is. But we haven’t quite got to that point yet. So, we’ve talked a lot about creating negative karma because that’s what we first have to protect ourselves from, and by protecting ourselves from creating negative karma, of course, we stop harming others, all kinds of sentient beings immediately. When we’re not generating negative karma, we’re not harming others. It also important to think a little bit, at least in the course, but always in our life about creating positive karma.

There’s many, many ways. And one basic way is observing the ten virtuous actions which are the opposite to the ten non virtuous actions. And so they, without going into lots of details, if you look at that list that was handed out of the ten non virtues and the karmic results, the throwing karmic results of those and the results similar to the cause and the environmental results, then if you think about the opposites of those, the virtuous states of mind, then one can work out logically what would be the karmic results. Just briefly, we can just sort of think about the ten virtues as things to engage in our daily life. Because these are some things very down to earth, very practical, very basic practices that give meaning to our life, free us from suffering, give happiness, contentment to ourselves and to others, and make this place a better world.

And observing this kind of guideline in our life is the practice of refuge and it’s kind of the lifeblood of our practice. If we’re not doing these things, what else is there to do? So, as the opposite to the non virtue of taking life, there is the virtuous practice that we can engage in, mindfulness of, and engage in our daily life, moment by moment, of not harming. Avoiding harming in any way, harming with our body, harming with our speech, harming with our mind, and also avoiding harming the bodies of others, avoiding harming the minds of others. So this can involve protecting the life of other beings in any way, life, saving life.

So the more we do that, it develops sensitivity, awareness, it is the way to develop loving kindness and compassion. So there are many things that we can do in regard to that. We were talking this morning about freeing animals who are in danger of dying. I have been reminded that, as well as actually freeing them, an important part of that practice to make it really something very powerful is to recite various prayers and mantras over those animals that are in danger of dying because one puts those really good imprints in their mind. Since these beings have such strong karma to die that even if we free them, they may die soon, but they’ve heard these very positive imprints from hearing various mantras and prayers and so on.

So this is adding a very extra powerful dimension to that practice. Things we can do in terms of protecting life and nurturing life and saving life and so on, of course is anything in the health profession and doing things like helping people who have problems with drugs and various kinds of addictions. So by helping those people overcome those things, then this is nourishing their life, nurturing their life, increasing the quality of their life, and so on. So there’s many things like that we can do, and especially use our dharma wisdom to help in that respect. And just putting effort rather than killing animals that we find what’s the word?

Annoying. self-cherishing mind finds certain little sentient beings annoying, so normally we kill them. But maybe it’s we can survive with them. We don’t have to kill them. There are ways that we can take them somewhere else, remove them, or even develop affection for them.

So then, instead of stealing from others, then we can practice the virtuous karma or activity of protecting the possessions of others, caring for the possessions of others, being careful with the property of others, sharing our own possessions, our own good fortune. And finally, beyond actually sharing our good fortune, our possessions, we can actually give what we have to others. So we can try to engage in these types of things more and more in our daily life. And the more we try to do those things of just protecting other people’s property, not borrowing it unnecessarily and being careful with it, this again opens our mind to the fact that other people exist and our behaviour affects them. We become sensitive to the needs of others, so this is the basis of developing love and compassion for them.

And we see how easy it is through our actions to harm others, but how easy actually we can do small things to benefit. Then in terms of avoiding sexual misconduct, we can practice faithfulness with the partner we have, a sensitivity to that person, moderation in our sexual desires, some kind of self control and a sense of contentment. And of course, in terms of the virtuous actions of speech, rather than lying, of course, trying to always speak what is true, what is honest, what is beneficial speaking with integrity. And instead of using our speech to cause division between people, our speech to bring harmony between individuals, between groups, societies, ethnic groups, religious groups, racial groups and so on, to bring reconciliation between people through skilful speech. Then as a virtuous action of speech that is opposite to harsh speech, we can put some effort into making our speech pleasant, kind, rather than using our speech to criticize others and put them down and make them feel uncomfortable and so on.

We can use our speech to encourage others, to inspire them and so on. Rather than being cynical and pessimistic, we can use our speech to be inspiring and encouraging and so on. Praising the qualities of others using I’m not supposed to listen to them because they’re craving for praising words. No, no, they’re used to others. To others.

To everything. No, it doesn’t work like that. One is doing it with a good motivation to bring out good qualities in that person. So, often we make little insults about people and so on, and when there is an opportunity to encourage them or say something, praise them in some way, not for the purposes of building up their ego, but just to give some recognition of their qualities that can help them, then often we don’t say anything, but we can use these opportunities to say encouraging, pleasant things to other people, not with the attitude so people will like us, but to give benefit to the other person, to raise their mind, especially if we see that they may be a little unhappy, depressed, doubtful about their qualities, and so on. So, we can say things that completely bring a person down, or we can say things that bring a person up and into a good state of mind.

So we can do that. We don’t have to be great bodhisattvas to do that, we can do that in our daily life. That gives having just done that one time has made that day meaningful, worthwhile. Days, weeks, years may have gone by where we have never done that. So, this time we do it and we’ve created a new virtuous habit and we’ve put this positive imprint in our mind that can bring great benefit in the future, especially if we dedicate it properly.

In other words, man evolved into the upper realm from a lower realm state. So in terms of the theory of evolution, based on karmic merit, how is that possible? I couldn’t understand. According to scientific theory, the human body evolved from animal bodies from apes. Right?

Yes. Well, according to evolution, man’s been on earth say about one hundred and sixty thousand years at the most. And prior to that, we took on a different form going right back to animals, going right back to the animal body. So at one time we were animals, then we became humans. So that process of evolution, if it’s due to karmic merit, how are the animals in the lower realm able to accumulate merit?

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
possessed result
One of four ways we can experience the result of an action, also called environmental result; possessed result is the environment we find ourselves in when we take rebirth. LYWA
pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
ten virtuous actions gewa chu (Tib)
Actions of body, speech and mind which are the opposite of the ten nonvirtuous actions, therefore, one refrains from killing, speaks the truth and so forth. LYWA
throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is running a good business or a farm well considered good karma?

Running a business or a farm well is generally called a worldly concern, because it is usually done for the sake of this life. However, if it is done with a really good heart, in order to truly benefit sentient beings, then it could be good karma. What matters is the motivation behind the work.

Scroll to Top