43 min · 4,867 words · 19 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches that awareness of impermanence and death, and of the likelihood of lower rebirth, motivates renunciation and a wise fear of creating negative karma. It urges checking one’s own mind for the causes of lower rebirth and presents the Three Jewels as refuge, with the Buddha as doctor, Dharma as medicine and Sangha as nurses. It ends with the qualities of the Three Jewels and the root ignorance of believing in a self that exists independently.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-19
Duration: 43 min
UUID: 6efea1b4-35ac-48b9-88d6-4013abfdee0c
Words: 4,867
The spiritual path, the graduated path to enlightenment, begins with recognizing the existence of our mind and its amazing Buddha potential, or Buddha nature, but also recognizing that it has great potential to cause us harm, to cause others harm. The more we see this, we need a method to overcome the negative aspects of our mind and develop the positive ones, and to take refuge in that method. And we see that because the path is not something simple, one can’t compare the path to enlightenment to any kind of worldly accomplishment or activity or worldly knowledge. So even in acquiring worldly knowledge and worldly skills, need a teacher. So especially in following the path to enlightenment, we need a perfectly qualified teacher possessing great wisdom, compassion, and so on.
Having met such a teacher, we are encouraged to recognize that the nature of our existence as a human being, with the Eight Freedoms and Ten Endowments, we have the optimum chance to start this spiritual life and complete it either for our own sake or especially for the benefit of all living beings. What prevents all this are our worldly preoccupations based on ignorance that generates, in turn, this self obsession or self-cherishing. So what helps cut through all of that is our understanding on the one side, we waste all our time being obsessed with the external world and its contents and so on. So the more we realise its impermanence, we develop this basic renunciation. From our side, realising that we ourselves are impermanent, that we are going to die, and especially that we could die at any time, and at the time of death only genuine spiritual or mental qualities will be able to keep us calm at the time of death and ensure a good rebirth, then it becomes clearer and clearer that we have to follow the spiritual path, the path of mental development, at least in its most basic form of avoiding negative actions which are the cause of suffering, rebirths, and creating and accumulating positive karma or merit, which is the cause not just for happiness in this life, but is the cause to have better future lives and access the condition to be able to follow the path to enlightenment.
So, I’d just like to go back a few to make some more points that I feel I’ve left out that I should make. In the life of Śākyamūni Buddha, itself is worthwhile studying and reading the life of the Buddha. As you probably all know, when Prince Siddhartha, who was born here in Nepal at Lumbini, just on the border between Nepal and India, was born according to the story. It was predicted by this yogi, this wise man, that if this person, when he grew up, saw four things, then he would renounce the kingdom and become a great ascetic, a spiritual teacher, renowned throughout the world. But if he didn’t see these things, then he would inherit he would become the king, inherit the kingdom, and make the kingdom even greater.
So, of course, dad wanted that, know, what dads are like. So, the father, the king, wanted his son to inherit the kingdom and so on. So he made great according to the story, put great effort into preventing his son from seeing these four things. But at some point, despite all his efforts, he was kept in the palace all his life and surrounded by beautiful things to distract him. I’m not sure exactly what age he was, but anyway, can’t remember.
When he managed to get out, escape one time, out into the city in his chariot with his chariot driver, and then he saw on four occasions these four things, I can’t remember the order. The first was that he saw a sick person. He’d never seen such a being in his life, and he was horrified by this person who was so sick. And he had to ask his chariot driver he’d led such a sheltered life, he had to ask his driver what this was, and the chariot driver had to explain. And then the prince said, Is only this person suffer like that or do other people get sick?
And the chariot driver had to explain that everyone gets sick sooner or later. This shocked the Prince very much, so he went back home and he looked around at all his family and friends, his beautiful wife, his son, all his other wives, his parents, all his friends, all enjoying life. He thought, How could they do this and just ignore the fact that they’re going to get sick? Then he went out again and saw an old person, a very old person. Again, he was very shocked and again the driver had to explain to him, because Prince Siddhartha seemed, was not very smart, not very intelligent, that everyone got old.
It wasn’t just unique to this one person, that everyone got old. This, the Prince found incredibly shocking, went back, looked around at all his family and friends, and thought, how can they waste their lives ignoring the fact that they’re going to get old? And then he went out and he saw a dead person, and again it had to be explained to him he was about thirty when he saw this but it had to be explained to him that everyone dies. And this was the most shocking thing of all. And then he went back to the palace and looked around at his wife, his child, all his other concubines, his mother and father, all his friends, and they were all singing and dancing and carrying on.
And he thought, how can they possibly do this when they’re going to die? How can they possibly waste their life like this when they’re going to die? So the prince gained the realization of these things. He didn’t just simply saw them, but he realized the import of it. And having saw the fourth thing, which was a person who had renounced ordinary life and was following the ascetic life of renunciation, he was inspired to do the same.
So he left the palace, his wife that he loved, his child, all his other concubines, his parents, and went off looking for something that could solve old age, sickness and death. And he did. He achieved enlightenment. So there are various versions of the life story of the Buddha, and some are so extreme that they are myths. But myths, although they may not be literally true, have great psychological meaning.
And the extreme versions of this myth, the king, order to prevent his son seeing old age and death, even when the flowers in the palace started withering away, they were all taken away, so the prince never saw that. And of course, if you think about it, this is not possible. A thirty year old person could not, and like he must have been able to see, that his parents were ageing. They were older than him and ageing and that things around change and die. But actually, the more unreal that myth is, the more it makes the point that we ourselves are like Prince Siddhartha living in the palace.
We ourselves, our delusions try to create this palace. We are living in this samsaric world that is impermanent, suffering, and full of disease and various things, but we create the illusion that it’s not like that at all. And we work so hard to create that illusion, and we don’t see old age, sickness and death. We just don’t see it. And we certainly don’t see what it means to us.
We just live in this little palace, our own fantasy. But sometimes, if we’re lucky, we can send our mind out on a little chariot with a little wise being who can tell us, That’s going to happen to me. And maybe we can get it. So we see all these things around us, but we just don’t want to know what they really mean. Milarepa said another thing, he said many things.
This thing we call a corpse, so fearful to behold, is already right here. It’s our own body. So if we live our life with an awareness that we are definitely going to die and could die at any moment, and therefore practice the Dharma. It is said that for those who have become great practitioners, when they die, they are able to die happily. For those who are medium level practitioners, they can die without fear.
And for those who are mediocre practitioners, at least we can die without regret. So the more we think about death oh, okay. Yeah, the other thing. Right. So, as well as meditating on death, and the time of death, and the death process, it’s also, as part of that, and to practise this awareness of death in our daily life, there’s some things we can think of that are really helpful.
For example, can think that so whatever we’re experiencing moment by moment in our life, we can use it to think about our death, if we want to. For example, right now we may be very healthy, but then we should think, we shouldn’t think that this is permanent. We should realise our health, our good health is impermanent and definitely a time will come when our body will decay. We have this expression in English, I don’t know how it’s expressed in other languages, but we say we grow old. We grow old.
So it sounds like you’re adding something to the life, like you grow a flower, it grows up, but you get something more and more. But we don’t grow old, we decay old. That’s what we should be saying, we decay old. I’m decaying old. And also when we say, Oh, this person’s eighty four or eighty five, it sounds like we’re adding something to us but actually, the older we get, the closer we are to death, the more certain we are going to die.
For example, when we are with our friends and family and enjoying our friends and family, we should try to have the awareness that it can be helpful if we are really trying to practice the Dharma, that at some point a time will definitely come when I am going to be completely separated from all of these people, all my friends, all my family, everyone I know, a time will come and I will be separated from all of them. When we’re eating and enjoying what we eat and drink, we think that definitely a time will come when I will have no appetite whatsoever, I won’t be able to swallow a single thing, I won’t be able to swallow a drop of water. This time is definitely coming. When we buy some nice clothes, brand new clothes, and put them on, and we’re enjoying wearing these nice clothes, we can think that a time will definitely come when they will wrap me in a shroud. When we’re sitting in a nice room, a nice comfortable room, we can think definitely a time will come when my body will be in a coffin.
When we’re sitting in a car, driving a car, sitting in a bus, in an aeroplane, something like that, moving along, we can think that definitely the time will come when I’ll be in a hearse, that we’re driving my body in a hearse. This time will come. Whatever enjoyment, comforts we are experiencing, we can think definitely a time will come when this body won’t be able to experience anything whatsoever. It will be either thrown into a hole in the ground and buried, or it will be burnt. So these are some of the things that we can think to remind us of what is happening, not to depress us, but to cut attachment to these things, not our affection, not our enjoyment of these things.
It is possible to have affection and love for family and friends, but to cut our attachment to them. Also to enjoy the things of this life, we can train to enjoy the things of this life but not get attached to them. And what really helps in all of that is having this understanding of the impermanence of those things and the fact that definitely we’re going to die. So we don’t get so totally obsessed, and it’s a reminder to practice Dharma. So it’s our choice if we want to do these things, of course.
But this is the method that the great practitioners followed. So then, in terms of of after death, it is said That if we want to know what we did in our previous life, we should look at our present body. And if we want to know what will be in our future life, in our next life, we should look at our mind now. And if we are honest, we can see that it is so easy to create negative karma and much more difficult to create positive karma, especially pure, purely virtuous actions free of the eight worldly concerns. And even in this life, we have probably created more negative karma than positive karma.
And in all of our previous lives, we’ve created probably more negative karma than positive karma. Therefore, the chances of going to the lower realms are far higher than taking rebirth as a human being. Much, much higher if we haven’t practiced, if we haven’t purified. His Holiness the Dalai Lama says, Since it is certain that we have all accumulated all sorts of negative actions in this lifetime, our undergoing the experience of the lower realms is only a matter of time. But this means, of course, if we don’t do something.
With this precious human rebirth, definitely we can do things, we can purify our mind, we can stop these negative actions, we can purify the mind, we can accumulate merit, we can generate refuge, a valid refuge in something that really holds us back from the lower realms. And it’s also, in terms of this, to see whether this is true or not, it’s important to check in our own mind honestly and see, Do I have the causes of the lower realms in my mind right now? Do I generate anger? How often do I get angry, and how often do I get angry strongly? How often do I generate craving desire for things?
Follow the dissatisfied mind. Rather than generating contentment, a wise contentment and satisfaction, generate desires and generate dissatisfaction within our own mind? How much do we practice sharing our good fortune with others and practice generosity? Or how much are we kind of, you know, miserly and clingy? How often do we really allow ourselves to be wise and intelligent?
Or how much do we follow old habitual patterns of not challenging our mind or trying to waken up our mind and also just getting caught up in laziness and sleep. If we can see that we follow these things, we can see that we are creating, there is some potential there to experience. If only these states of mind imagined that we were trapped somehow, the causes and conditions came about, one day, one moment, we’re following one of these habitual negative ways of thinking, and then it just goes on. It doesn’t stop. We don’t wake out of it.
We don’t stop ourselves from doing it, and there’s nothing out there that can bring us back to a more virtuous state. Just our anger goes on, our depression, our self obsession, our grasping, our discontent, our dullness, and so on. It just goes on and on. Maybe then we can see that perhaps we do have the potential for these lower realms, that we’re not generating the potential to have a human rebirth. So, the more we think about these things, then generate this wise fear of suffering, And this causes us to look around to see if there is something that can protect us, not just from the suffering of this life, but particularly the great suffering that we can experience in our future lives, particularly in the lower realms.
All of us have fear, according to the teachings. Why do we have fear? According to the teachings it says, because we have negative imprints in our mind. If we didn’t have negative imprints in our mind, there would be no reason to have fear. Why do we fear death?
If there’s nothing after death, why do we fear it? If we’re totally confident that there’s not the slightest problem, that if there is something after death, whatever good thing there is, we’ll have it, we’ll experience it. Why do we fear death? There’s absolutely no reason. And if death itself is not a conscious process but just suddenly everything goes blank, black, why should we fear it?
But all of us do, all of us have some fear. Probably we don’t even know it because we don’t even think about death. Why don’t we think about it? Because actually we fear to think about it. So why should we have that fear?
I think there’s some kind of biological explanation that fear protects the species, but if one really checks, you don’t need it to protect the species. And since death is going to happen anyway to every member of the species, why should one fear it? According to the dharma, even why is there suffering at all? Why should there be suffering at all? Is proof of past lives.
Why should suffering exist in this world if there wasn’t previous lives? If there wasn’t previous existence. Then the biological answer, I think, is, Oh, because also that helps life, but we don’t need that much suffering to protect us. You know, we could get a little twinge by putting our hand in the fire to warn us. We don’t need all the suffering that we have.
In this life, we’re capable of generating so much pain and torment within this, it just doesn’t make sense in a context that there’s just this life. Anyway, so we do have fear, but the way we follow our fear in a completely unwise way, and it generates panic, anxiety, and negative actions. Either it causes us to do nothing positive or often it causes us to do something stupid. Whereas the fear we’re trying to generate in thinking about wasting this life by not thinking about death, therefore the possibility of having a worse rebirth, that fear is an intelligent fear that all the wise beings of the past have generated, and they’ve used it to practice the Dharma, to take refuge in something meaningful. If one fears death, what refuge is there to stop that fear?
To stop death, to stop the fear of death? What valid refuge do we have? Pretending it’s not going to happen? Some drugs? Our friends, our family, our fortune, our reputation, our knowledge.
So we need this wise fear to fear future misery rather than just the problems of this life. The fear we have now that drives us is the fear of just the problems of this life. But what we need to develop is this wise fear of future misery cause it could be far greater than anything that we experience in this life. And the wise fear we need to develop is the fear of creating this negative karma, following the disturbing thoughts in our mind that create these negative imprints. We need to fear that, fear creating negative karma more than suffering.
So these are the wise fears we need to develop, and with those we try to look for valid refuge, and then we can come to look at the Buddhadharma as a valid refuge that can protect us from the fear of this life, all the fears and suffering of this life, the suffering of the lower realms. It can not only protect us from those things, but that refuge can lead us beyond all fear to the fearless state, to the deathless state, to the great peace of liberation and enlightenment. So it’s worth checking out. So earlier in the course I tried to talk about how the triple gem of the Buddha, Dharman Sangha, is a valid refuge that we can really trust. And I keep repeating the point that whatever spiritual path we’re looking for, we should really check it out carefully and see whether it’s something that we can really rely on.
Not just in this life, but if there’s future lives, in all our future lives, no matter where we are and what we do, is there a refuge that we can really rely on? This is really important point that any method that we use, it needs to be something perfect, and that can only come from perfect wisdom, perfect compassion. Anything else will sooner or later let us down. There are people who follow various kinds of they contact beings out there somewhere who talk to them, and they seem very impressive because they’ve got psychic powers and clairvoyance and this and that, and people are very impressed by these things, but they don’t really check the nature of that being, and eventually one can be betrayed by that. Because the being itself may think it is perfect, but if it’s not, if it doesn’t have perfect wisdom and compassion, then sooner or later we will definitely suffer.
So I’m talking something more about what can I say about So when we take refuge in the triple gem, we have this understanding that we have this terrible disease of ignorance that is going to cause suffering again and again, every kind of suffering, until we get rid of it? When we take refuge in the triple gem, we see the Buddha like the doctor, the Dharma as the medicine, the perfect medicine that we have to take, not just put it on the shelf, but we have to take this medicine by practising the Dharma. And as I’ve mentioned, when we take refuge, the essential refuge for us at our level is the Dharma, the practice of the Dharma, and the essential Dharma practice, Dharma understanding, the essential Dharma teaching and practice, is the teaching on the law of cause and effect. Understanding that, being mindful of it in our daily life and living our life in accordance with it, that in itself is the main refuge and that will protect us from the lower realms. If we’ve observed the law of cause and effect properly in this life, that itself will protect us from the lower realms.
And at the time of death, if we generate faith in the triple gem, hold the thought of the Buddha in our mind, having this mind of admiration, of great wisdom and compassion, which is what Buddha is, if our mind is actually in that state of admiring what Buddha is, not just saying the word Buddha, but admiring what Buddha means, this all encompassing wisdom, purity and great compassion and so on, then our mind, that thought, saves us from the lower realms. Our negative minds, our negative karma can’t ripen if our mind is admiring those qualities. And so also, the dharma is the medicine and the aryasangha are like the nurses who can encourage us to take the medicine, to inspire us to take it. So, the aryasangha are the ultimate nurses, but they’re all the other levels of Sangha refuges down to just ordinary, ordained monks and nuns, who, because of even their appearance of wearing the robes, similar to what the Buddha wore, reminds us of the Buddha, because of keeping the vows, then this is the basic practice. So this is an inspiration to us, can act as an inspiration to us to practice.
Just the ordinary monks and nuns show us that we can do something as well. So this is some kind of refuge. It’s not the ultimate refuge, but it’s some degree of refuge that we can take. So the Buddha functions to transmit the Dharma perfectly, effectively to every living being. The Dharma itself is the truth, highest truth, by experiencing it, eliminates all suffering and all the causes of suffering.
That’s what the dharma, its purpose is to eliminate all the afflictions. So anything which eliminates, subdues and eliminates our disturbing thoughts, that is dharma. If something is actually effectively subduing our disturbing thoughts, is actually, not apparently, but actually eliminating our disturbing thoughts. That is Dharma. It doesn’t matter what it’s called, what it looks like, but that is the Dharma that we take refuge in.
And the Sangha exists to inspire and energize us and to prevent discouragement. So we can see the Buddha as like the boatman who saves us, the Dharma is the boat that we need to use to save us from drowning in the sea of saṃsāra, and the Sangha are the companions escaping in the lifeboat, so we should join them. So, some of the qualities of the Buddha jewel, I’ll just go through the eight qualities. There are many ways of talking about what Buddha is. There are, for example, the eighteen qualities unique to a Buddha, but then one can just generally talk about the eight qualities of the Buddha jewel.
The first is that there is the dharmakaya and the empty nature of that omniscient mind. Buddha jewel is effortless, spontaneous accomplishment of enlightening influence. It has inconceivable realizations, it has complete omniscient awareness, it has intense loving concern for all of us, for all beings, at all times. It has a total range of all powerful abilities, it possesses what is meaningful to benefit ourselves, it possesses what is meaningful to benefit others. Then the dharma jewel, the qualities of the dharma jewel, is that it is completely free of any impulse that could throw us into any kind of suffering situation.
It is free of any kind of disturbing attitude. It is free of giving rise to any disturbing type of conceptual thinking. The dharma is pure, it’s not mixed with any kind of mental defilement. It is completely clear, it is a perfectly clear presentation about reality and the dharma clarifies what is reality in our mind. It is the opponent to counter all mental obscurations.
It has all the characteristics of being a true cessation, that is, it is a true cessation of all suffering. That is what the actual Dharma is, it is a complete cessation of all suffering. And it also has all the characteristics of being a true path of the mind, that is, it brings about the true cessation of suffering. And then the qualities of the Sangha jewel, which are the true cessation, the collection of all these realizations of the true paths and true cessations in the minds of realised beings. The qualities that we take refuge in are this deep awareness of how all things exist.
It is a deep awareness of the extent of what exists. Because we may think there’s only this world, but the aryasangha or the Sangha jewel has this deep awareness of everything that actually does exist. It is an inner deep awareness that there are no truly existing, unimputed entities, that there is nothing that can exist without being labelled by the mind? We can try and understand this later on. Hopefully, Lama Zopa Rinpoche might talk about this.
I might try to work up the courage to talk about it, I’ll probably only get totally confused and confuse everyone else. When we talk about ignorance, there are many levels of ignorance, and there is the very root ignorance of, as I’ve mentioned before, one level of our ignorance is sometimes we believe, I am the body. Sometimes we think, I am the mind. Sometimes we try and think, we grasp that, Well, I’ve got to be the body and the mind. Sometimes we think that we’re not any of those things, that there is something else that is not the body, not the mind, not a combination of both, that is me.
So this is getting close to what is the root cause, the root ignorance, the root of saṃsāra. But even that is not quite the most subtle refuting object, the subtle ignorance. The most subtle ignorance, which is the actual root of saṃsāra, is the mind, this ignorant mind believing that there is a person that exists without even having to be labelled, without even having to be conceived as existing. That is the refuting object. That is the root of saṃsāra.
That is the root of all suffering. From a nervous twitch to the fires of hell, the source of all that is this unbelievably sneaky, subtle mind that believes that there is an I that exists, that can exist even without being conceived, thought of. It can exist totally by itself.
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.