Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 11 Tape 17 Side 1 only

41 min · 4,537 words · 11 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 11 Tape 17 Side 1 only
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches that hatred toward others, even those who have harmed us, creates negative karma and suffering for oneself, and that compassion for all beings, including enemies, is the Buddha’s ideal. It then explains emptiness through the analogy of mistaking a rope for a snake: things appear to exist truly but do not. Questions follow on compassion for enemies, one’s mother, and whether violence can be justified.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-11

Duration: 42 min

UUID: 71dd87f0-9272-4e8a-9d3e-4ec64ec6b769

Words: 4,537

We will never be happy. Never, never be happy. Rejoicing in wanting to harm someone who has harmed us, thinking it’s beneficial to harm anyone who has harmed us, is only suffering and the source of suffering. This is what the Buddha taught. To hate Mr.

Bin Laden is to damage ourself. It doesn’t hurt him, it hurts us. Not just now, but forever. We generate hate towards him, we generate karmic negative seeds in our mind, these produce suffering in the future and we may end up exactly like him in a future life. All the hate that we direct to hateful people, evil people, turns us into one of those people in a future life.

We’ve all been Mr Bin Laden before, exactly like him. We have done every single conceivable terrible thing in a previous life. And yet, Buddha loves us. We are objects of compassion. This is what the Buddha taught.

This is what the Buddha means by compassion, not this kind of, this cute stuff. This fuzzy, nice, warm feelings for cute babies and fluffy bunnies and things like that. Anyone can like a fluffy bunny. It’s very difficult to like Mr Bin Laden, but the Buddhas do. And to hate him damages our mind, right now and in the future.

This is what the Buddha taught. So this compassion and the teaching show how we can develop that compassion and how it’s essential to develop it. That we have to have that mind if we don’t have it. Even there’s one person, one sentient being in this entire universe that we dislike for one moment, we will never be happy. Never be happy.

Because that one moment of dislike generates negative karma that produces suffering, which we develop aversion to, which produces more negative karma, which produces the whole mess again and again and again. Of course, it’s very easy for me to say these things that we should do this. It’s very difficult to practice but the Buddhadharma shows a way to do it and argues the necessity of it. So these teachings indicate an incredible mind. Isn’t this an indication of a truly, truly amazing mind, an all encompassing mind that loves every sentient being and has compassion for every sentient being?

That’s something we can trust. Because if I’m a sentient being who’s done lots of lousy things in this life and past lives, this being has compassion for me. This being is actually working for my enlightenment right now, Always has been. Because that being has never generated a negative thought to me, a thought of aversion to me, ever, ever, ever. You know, we may think Buddha mind I’m sort of raving a little bit here, but anyway, come.

One of the standard questions that is always asked in Buddhist teachings, Well, if Buddha exists, if there’s millions of Buddhas and they’re so compassionate and wise and skillful, why aren’t they helping me? How come I’m not enlightened? The news is, they are helping and they’ve always been helping. Our mind is just obscured from it. Why are you here?

For many, many reasons, in your life has brought you here. Somebody said something ten years ago, you’ve probably forgotten it, but it may have made an imprint. The person who said that may have been a Buddha or a bodhisattva. You can’t say it’s not. And you read a book about Buddhism.

Where did the book about Buddhism come from? From the Buddha. If there hadn’t been a Buddha, there’s not a book about Buddhism. Right? Difficult to have a book about Buddhism without Buddha, first.

Or you saw an image of Buddha. Many people have when they were small children, saw images of Buddha, didn’t know what it was, but it intrigued them. Something nice about Granny’s statue that they used to see. Many people saw images and Granny had a statue of Buddha and made a strong imprint in the mind. Where do you get If there wasn’t Buddha, there wouldn’t be Buddha statues.

This is the working of the Buddha itself, even that is the working of the Buddha. And also, if you see for example, my teacher, Lama Zopa Rinpoche, whenever he has an opportunity and meets with animals, insects, and whatever, he teaches them the Dharma. He says mantras over them, sometimes hours. Rinpoche has a place in Dharmasala where His Holiness lives, he has a centre there. Many years ago, Lama Yeshe, when Lama Yeshe was alive, particularly Lama Yeshe had all these dogs, many dogs.

And Rinpoche used to, every now and again, buy Tibetan momos, these meat momos down in Dharmasala, and feed the dogs. So the dogs would go berserk when the momos were you know. And so, while the dogs were being fed the meat momos, Rinpoche would read the Prajñāpāramitā, the Heart Sūtra, Mani Mantras for the imprint. Yeah. So I would like to thank Cecilia in the Vajrasattva retreat in California a few years ago when she said something that really I thought was really very profound because I can’t remember she said something like, you know, when you see someone hold an ant in their hand and recite the mantra over them.

I think you said that in the med retreat, something like that? Anyway, which is what Rinpoche does and blows over it and makes the imprint of the mantra in the mind. So, at some point, we were ants and lamas picked us up, Buddhas picked us up, bodhisattvas picked us up and recited mantras over us, recited the Prajñāpāramitā when we were dogs. Of course, we don’t remember that, but it happened. Buddhas are taking care of us all the time with total accepting, non rejecting compassion, all the time, even when we’re chopping people to pieces, murdering them, stabbing them, poisoning them, raping them, stealing from them, the Buddha is there trying to help.

Not do those things, help us not do those things. But the mind never stops that. That is great compassion, and that’s what the teachings are about, aspiring to that mind. So, teachings, they’re only the teachings, there aren’t it’s true, we can’t see Buddhas. All we’ve right now they say two and a half thousand years ago, people saw a Buddha, but I don’t know.

But what we have now are these words, these ideas, these teachings, and what they indicate is something truly sublime that an ordinary mind couldn’t conceive. You know, I can talk about these things, but, I mean, not in a million years would I have ever thought of them. No way would I think that you could be nice to an enemy, that you should be nice to an enemy. You should be nicer to the enemy than to your friend. It wouldn’t have occurred to me in a billion years to think like that.

Now I try to think, at least put those words in my mind. And so that is the benefit of the Buddha. But no ordinary mind can even think of those thoughts. The fact that we can try and think those thoughts is because of the inspiration of the Buddha, because Buddha mind has appeared in this world and left these words, but not the words. There’s the whole lineage of real practitioners who have these experiences in their mind.

And there’s the idea in the teachings to work, to benefit one sentient being forever. A bodhisattva forget about it, no, don’t forget about it. Set aside the Buddhas. Bodhisattvas are willing to select not just select, but for way of example, there’s one sentient being here that I have a strong karmic connection with. Okay, I will follow this one forever until I enlighten them.

I will go to hell with them. I will go everywhere. I will be with them every moment, endure every possible suffering in order to I will spend a million years waiting so I can say, ‘Be nice.’ Yeah. I will sit here for a million years until this person comes along and I will say, Be kind. Don’t kill.

I’ll be willing a bodhisattva is willing to do that. Yeah? To wait there in the freezing rain for a billion years, to be chopped to pieces for a billion years in order to say to one person, Don’t kill, be kind. This is what the Buddhadharma teaches, that there are beings like that. Maybe this is just all fantasy garbage, but maybe it’s possible because of the nature of our If a little bit of compassion is possible, why not this kind of compassion if there’s nothing restricting it, if we don’t have, if we don’t follow our delusions?

So we have the words, and if you meet some of the great practitioners of these words, there’s an indication that Buddha mind really exists. And then there’s the wisdom aspect of the Buddha’s teachings. These amazing teachings that giving so many logical explanations to look at the nature of reality, of what we experience, even to suggest reality is maybe not the way we appear, the way it appears to us. Even to suggest that, to check that. Many teachings don’t even talk about that.

They assume, because it’s created, that it’s really real as it appears. But maybe it wasn’t created by something other than us, maybe it’s created by us. Or maybe it’s a group effort. But these amazing teachings just suggest to check up. Don’t just gobble reality like a dog like a god no, no.

Like a dog gobbles a bone, a lump of meat without even thinking. Check up. Stand back. Make the mind clear, calm and just look. Check objectively, wisely.

Start to purify the mind to try to look at reality in another way or maybe reality starts to change as we purify our mind. The only education of the mind that we know is learning concepts, More concepts, we go to universities and learn stuff, things, more concepts. That’s the only education of the mind we have, basically. But dharma education of the mind brings about transformation. There’s this purification, not just developing the intelligence, but purifying the mind so that the intelligence works in a completely new way or in a new field, so that it’s possible to experience other things that beyond our concepts now.

Because what we see are limited by what we conceive right now. So, the Buddhadharma talks about there is a conventional reality or a conventional truth and an ultimate truth. I’ve never thought about that before. A conventional truth and an ultimate truth. The Buddhadharma points out that maybe much of the time we don’t even see the conventional truth, let alone the ultimate truth.

For example, conventional truth, one of the examples of the conventional truths of things is that they are impermanent, changing moment by moment. We don’t see that. We don’t allow ourselves to see it. We reject it. And that’s just a conventional truth, it’s not the ultimate truth of things.

And then there are the amazing teachings on the ultimate truth of phenomena, indicating the failure to experience that ultimate truth that is the source of suffering. This is really interesting. It may be worth investigating. It’s a completely different explanation than any other system gives. It seems to indicate an incredibly vast pure mind that is perceiving something that we have no idea of.

Not only is it able to perceive it, it is able to explain it in a way that we can understand, so that we can practice and experience the same thing. So these are some indications that what is called the Buddhadharma actually comes from Buddha mind. But this is something to check for yourself. Did I decide to go for ultimate truth yet? I haven’t, I’ve carefully avoided it because it’s too complicated.

Okay, just in words, the ultimate truth is that everything is empty of true existence, of inherent existence. Things are empty by nature. They exist but they are empty of truly existing from their own side, independently, having their own characteristics. The way things appear to us now is if the way things appear to us now was true, then things would be inherently existing, truly existing, independently existing from their own side with their own characteristics. That’s how things appear to us.

Or the way things appear to us, if it was true, means they were independent. Things don’t actually directly appear to us as being independent but the way things do appear to us now, if that appearance was true, it would mean, logically, that things were independent. But if we use the Buddha’s teachings, we can start to discover that everything that exists depends on something else. That is not it. Everything arises depending on many things, on causes and conditions, depending on parts, and especially the most subtle aspect of dependent arising, everything the Buddha taught because he perceived it depends on the mind.

And depends on the mind and the way our mind labels things, conceives things. So this absolute truth or the actual way things do exist, do not perceive And don’t even see certain aspects of the conventional truth of things. We see things that are not there, which is kind of amazing. I’m never getting to the topic of refuge, I’m sorry, we will never finish this course, we may not even start it. But since we’re on this topic, I try to talk a little bit about it day by day or something.

This is an escape vows of not having to try to explain it all at once and anyway, it’s a way of putting some small imprints. But there’s this famous analogy of the snake in the rope. It’s not unique to Buddhism but Buddhism has a unique view of it. If you take a coiled, a multi colored coiled rope and it’s outside the door. It’s a dark night and you walk quickly out the door and you see this coiled, colored thing on the ground or you can just barely see it because it’s dark and you’re walking quickly and the mind’s very agitated.

That coiled piece of rope or a piece of hose can appear as a snake. The mind generates appearance in the mind of a snake. There is a definite appearance of a snake in the mind. Without question, it’s really appearing to our mind. Because it appears to our mind, our mind reacts to it with fear, body starts sweating, we run away screaming and so on, because we’ve seen a snake.

We’ve really seen a snake, unquestionably seen a huge, vicious, man eating or woman eating snake. But that snake is not there at all. Not even one scale of a snake is there, but we see it. Our mind sees it, creates it, and grasps that it’s real unquestionably. What is not there at all, we see.

This is not Buddhist fantasy, this is what we’ve all done things like that, made mistakes, seen somebody in the distance who we thought was an old friend who turns out to be a complete stranger. In the countryside, in Australian countryside, there are stumps all over the place, old tree stumps or old posts. Looks like a human being. You start talking to it, you discover it’s a stump. Yeah, it really appears.

Only after half an hour. So, we mistake a book. This is my book, no, it’s your book. Okay. But it appeared, for some time, to be mine.

It appeared to be an old friend. A tree stump appears to be a person. We make these mistakes all the time. Our mind creates this vivid appearance and we grasp it as real and the thing that we’ve created in our mind is not there at all. It’s only there as a creation of our mind.

The thing is not there at all. The snake is not there at all. And what is interesting also, what is actually there? There is a rope there. The rope conventionally is there, we do not see it at all.

We do not see what is there. The rope is there, we do not see it at all. What is not there at all, we see. The Buddha said that that process is happening right now. What is appearing to our mind right now is not there at all other than being a concept in our mind, created by our mind.

What is appearing right now to our mind, to our senses, to all of our senses and to our mental consciousness is not there at all. And what is existing because this is not saying there is nothing because what is there, what is actually existing in some very subtle way, what is actually existing, we do not see at all. This is hard to believe, but this is what the Buddha taught and the Buddha’s teachings explain that, explain the false appearance that exists in our mind right now, why it appears, how it appears, how to reduce it, minimize it, eliminate it, and how to recognize what is actually there. And the Buddha taught that this the fact that we are creating these false appearances in our mind moment by moment and believing them to be real, that is the source of suffering. This false appearance that we generate in our mind, which we grasp at as real, it’s because of that, that that, the creation of that, is the root source of all suffering.

It’s because of that creation, that false appearance that all the disturbing thoughts arise. Because we create the appearance of a truly existing flower that is truly beautiful from its own side. And that flower that truly exists from its own side that is truly beautiful, such a flower does not exist at all. The truly beautiful person that we see does not exist at all. The truly evil person that we see, the truly ugly thing that we see does not exist at all.

And what is existing there, we don’t see. The person that we grasp at as me now does not exist at all, other than being just a thought generated by our confused mind. But we don’t think we’re a thought. We think we’re real. We think we’re something really serious, solid, concrete.

But maybe it’s just an illusion or like an illusion. So the Buddhist teachings are about these things. And I indicate that this mind these teachings indicate there is a mind that has an incredible clarity, stillness, concentration and perception of things that we haven’t even begun to think about. This time. Ten five.

Ten five. Alright. Questions? Yes. We see a rope as a snake.

Yes. Sorry, what was the second bit? Yeah, let’s wait. We mistake a Yes, we mistake a rope for a snake. There’s a little bit of obstruction to clearly knowing here.

Is there true existing behind there any true existing reality behind what we perceive? There’s actually a rope. Can there be a snake without anything, just created by the mind? Oh yes, there are. Hold it.

The question is, we mistake a rope for a snake but there is the reality of the rope, right? But are there things that have no reality at all, just purely manufactured by the mind, that have no reality whatsoever. Yeah, is that the question? Or part of the question? Yeah, I mean, it’s the view of emptiness that we see something which is only created by the mind just out of nothing?

Or is there something that exists? No, no, okay. No. In talking about the snake that doesn’t it appears to the mind but it has no essence, it has no genuine reality. So that is false, but it does have a basis.

The basis is the rope that does exist. On the basis of the rope, we create this false appearance. So a person exists, me, I exist, and there’s particular way I exist, that my mind which you can take as the example of the rope. That my mind, my confused mind sees the rope but then creates the appearance of a snake. So there is a way I exist.

My confused mind sees that first but then distorts that and creates the appearance to my mind of a truly existing me, completely independent and separate from other things. So, there is a flower here but on top of that my mind creates the illusion, which I believe to be real, of something that is truly existing, separate from my mind, that is truly beautiful or truly ugly from its own side, an independently existing phenomena, that phenomena, a flower is there, there is a you know, an artificial flower is here. That acts as the basis for our confused mind to create the illusion of another kind of flower, the flower that is appearing to us. Big topic, very confusing. To make it more confusing, when you give the analogy of the rope and the snake, the snake is totally an hallucination.

The rope exists, the snake does not. The snake only exists totally as a mistaken concept, and in this analogy you can say the rope exists. But the rope also doesn’t truly exist from its own side. It does exist but it’s not a truly existing phenomena. There is no thing the Buddha taught that truly, really exists by itself, not depending on anything else.

So we have a month to think about that, the rest of our life to think about that. But monks in the Gelugpa tradition spend years and years and years trying to understand the meaning of this. So relax, it doesn’t matter. And again, it’s not something that is necessarily intellectually graspable. If we purify our mind, it becomes easier to understand. Things are here but not the way we think they are.

And the way we think they’re here causes a suffering. When we directly experience the way things actually exist, we experience bliss, liberation. No way to feel attachment for anything, no way to feel aversion to anything utterly impossible. One can only feel attachment and aversion when we see things in the wrong way, when we experience things in the wrong way. Yes?

So the question is that I was saying, well, the dharma says that our mother and father are particularly potent karmic objects, so how does that relate to developing equanimity towards friends, enemies and strangers and also the fact that everyone has been our mother? Of course, the aim is to develop firstly this equanimity that doesn’t separate friends, enemies and strangers, that is able to treat everyone as a friend. Especially we should treat our mother as our friend. Through that one generates stronger good karma. Yeah.

The argument is, since it’s difficult to generate compassion for the enemy, wouldn’t it be more karmically powerful to generate compassion for the enemy? I think, yes, this is also true. This is true because I don’t know how to explain All this point is saying is that just because the strength of karma, good or bad, relies on many factors and one of the factors is the object. So mere fact that someone is our mother means the karma we create within is stronger, good or bad. It doesn’t mean that therefore we should put all effort into taking care of our mother.

It doesn’t mean that it just simply means that the good will energy we direct to our mother, because of the very nature of who she is for us, creates more good karma. It doesn’t mean we should put all our effort into our mother, we should generate compassion for the enemy and the effort of generating compassion for the enemy is really incredibly worthwhile, most important. For example, the good karma that we generate in caring for our mother, our father and so on, that good karma can be dedicated, the energy, the good energy we generate with that can be dedicated to develop compassion for the enemy. The question is, is the way you see the flower your conventional reality? No, no.

Not necessarily. Because I was saying that the conventional truth of this phenomena is that it’s impermanent, so we don’t experience that. We tend to see this thing, especially because it’s plastic, as permanent. So, yeah. Cheating this.

Sorry. Yes. Have you managed to achieve achieve that real and true compassion towards someone who has been given a normal feeling? Do you develop real compassion for someone who has killed your mother or father? This is a good question.

Maybe we can answer that during the course. Maybe that will become clearer when we talk because we’ll talk about developing compassion and how to develop it more and more. And how to practice patience. One short, quick yes? From a police point of view, no.

No. Excuse me? Yes. The question is, even if is violence justified in any situation, for example, if our life is threatened? So, the ideal is the fundamental aspect of Buddha’s teaching is do not harm, and this means even when you’re being harmed, when we are being harmed.

This is what we aim to achieve that mind. Of course this is an incredibly exalted state to achieve, But the Buddhadharma gives many arguments why that is so essential and however much our mind can aspire to that ideal and practice it in any way, there’s so much more benefit for ourselves and others, just because we cause less harm. And the Buddhadharma teaches that this mind is possible. If you could stop You mean killing them by killing them? Shoot them.

If you can shoot the other person who is trying to kill you with compassion, it’s okay. It is not negative karma. If one is genuinely, not just you think you are, but if the mind that causes you to kill the person, the mind directing that action of killing is in reality, not in your fantasy, but is in reality an incredible concern that by killing me, this person is going to have an unbelievable suffering result, then if you can kill the person with that genuine thought, it is not negative karma. And you’re helping yourself and the person. But it’s unbelievably difficult to get to that point possible, but you have to be a bodhisattva, you have to have wisdom and Bodhicitta to be able to do that.

Thanks very much. So, we can dedicate the merit that through this merit and understanding that we develop, may we be able to meet the perfect spiritual path in this life, in all future lives, perfect spiritual masters fully qualified in every possible way who can guide us on the path not just to liberation but complete enlightenment, the state that benefits not only ourselves but every living being without exception. May the precious Bodhicitta, none yet born arise and grow. May the unborn have no decline, but increase forevermore. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
Gelug
The Virtuous Order. The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded by Lama Tsongkhapa and his disciples in the early fifteenth century and the most recent of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top