40 min · 3,390 words · 11 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains taking refuge as based on a wise fear of causing suffering and on trust in the Three Jewels, grounded in knowing their qualities. It presents refuge as a step-by-step path that gradually leads to one’s own pure mind as the ultimate refuge. Inner development and outer activity are presented as complementary, with the greatest gift being freedom from the causes of suffering.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-11
Duration: 41 min
UUID: b13a6506-be15-4131-9b61-4f9e48743c6a
Words: 3,390
Fear, the causes of suffering. When suffering arises for a bodhisattva, they have incredible courage to deal with it. But bodhisattvas are terrified of creating the cause of suffering. We are terrified of suffering. We completely panic even when a little mosquito lands on our skin.
We can’t bear that. But we have incredible boldness, not courage, but boldness in creating the causes of suffering. Whack. Very brave to do that. Very bold to do that.
No restraint whatsoever. So, there is a wise fear that it is necessary to have because that wise fear protects us from suffering. If we don’t have it, we will not restrain ourselves from suffering. So even fearing that the future suffering of this life is the basis, we can say, to begin to take refuge. If we fear the possibility of suffering in future lives, especially in a non human realm, this is an even stronger reason for taking refuge.
And if we fear, if we begin to have this wise fear of the possibility of all the suffering of saṃsāra, of circling around and around again and again endlessly, this is an even stronger form of refuge. Then the highest form of refuge that we can generate is not fearing suffering for ourselves but realizing that all sentient beings, all the kind mother sentient beings are trapped in suffering. How appalling that is! So one takes refuge in order to be able to develop the mind that can help free all living beings from every kind of suffering. So this is the Mahāyāna refuge that we can try to eventually generate.
But all of it is related in some way of developing this wise fear of suffering, and especially the wise fear of creating the causes of suffering again and again. The fear of causing suffering to oneself, the fear of causing suffering to others. Fearing that, we take refuge, outer refuge, in perfect mind, the perfect teachings come from that mind and these wonderful beings who who have practiced the Dharma intensively. By doing that, we begin to take refuge in our own basic goodness, own basic wisdom that doesn’t cause harm to self and others. We do refuge.
We recognise moment by moment that there is this basic goodness within us that doesn’t harm self and others. There is this basic wisdom within us that enables us not to cause harm to ourselves, that is able to recognise what causes harm to self and others. And by following it, we create that harm. So, is one aspect of twofold reasons for taking refuge, this wise fear. The other aspect of taking refuge is that we have trust in the object of refuge.
We have some intelligent reason for believing that what we’re taking refuge in can protect us from suffering and eventually totally protect us from suffering. And that protection is the outer Buddhadharma and the ultimate protection is our pure mind. And then there is the path linking that mind to the ultimate state of Buddhahood. That’s what we can take, we can trust Him. Faith So, refuge depends on having faith in the Buddha, faith in the Dharma, faith in the Sangha, faith in our Buddha nature, faith in our essential wisdom and goodness, basic goodness and wisdom or intelligence or clarity of our mind.
How does this faith arise or what is faith? Faith knowing the qualities of something. If we know something has qualities, we have faith in it. If we want to buy a car and we know something about cars and we don’t just look at the outside of the car, we look at the engine and check the engine and we check all the qualities of it. The engine and the chassis and the this and the that, all the bits and pieces and we check, oh, this is really good quality, this bit is really strong and this bit is really well designed and this and that and the other, we see all the qualities of the car and we generate faith that this is a good car.
I can trust this one, this will be a good buy. So, by knowing the qualities of something, we put our trust in it or by knowing that this thing has got really lousy qualities or no qualities, we have no trust in it. Also, the usual joke about used car salesmen, Would you trust this guy? What qualities does he have? You check the guy, Does he have any qualities?
Don’t trust this one. Don’t trust what he would sell. So, by checking the qualities of something and knowing the qualities more and more, we develop trust, faith, confidence. So, the more we study the qualities of Buddha mind, the more we study the qualities of the teachings of the Dharma, the more we study the qualities of the Aria Sangha, the more we know these qualities, then we can develop this faith in them, this trust, this confidence in them. And the more we develop that faith, we can then develop, which is the basic kind of faith, we can develop this longing faith which aspires to have those qualities.
Just as the more you see a car, with an ordinary mind seeing a car that has fantastic qualities, the more you aspire to have that car. The more you see something like Buddha mind that has these amazing qualities, the more one aspires to have that mind oneself because we have the potential for it within us. And so the more we aspire to these things, to these virtuous qualities and states, The more we aspire to that, the more we lay the foundation to actually engage in doing the things that will generate those qualities. So the final reason for taking refuge in the outer Triple Gem is so that eventually our own mind is our perfect refuge. Realising that our own mind, this purer level of our mind, is our best friend.
Our ordinary mind can be our worst enemy, but the purest level of our mind is our best friend, is our real refuge and it won’t betray us. And there is this method which won’t betray us that can lead us from that outer refuge to this indwelling mind state of perfection, wisdom, compassion. So, any questions? Sorry, I can’t hear you at all. The wish of everyone is to achieve happiness.
Yes? Yes. So with Buddhahood you can achieve happiness? I’m just repeating it so people can hear and the translator can hear. When we reach Buddhahood, we go beyond?
Yes, yes. Okay. When we talk about wishing perfect happiness, our mind has a very limited concept of happiness and certainly when we achieve enlightenment, the state we experience is nothing like the happiness that we conceive enlightenment is like. It’s not happiness. It’s something far, far beyond anything that we can conceive.
But for our own mind, it’s okay to label the state of enlightenment perfect happiness because there’s no other way to deal with it with our ordinary mind. It’s just a carrot to dangle in front of us to go towards. But it’s not bad, it’s certainly It’s better than happiness. Enlightenment is not something worse than happiness, it’s better than happiness. It’s something inconceivable.
Good question. Probably very young monks really don’t take refuge but with some time, having learnt the Dharma, they do. Well, even in the monastery you experience the outside world. Samsāra is everywhere. It’s amazing.
You can’t escape it even in monasteries. It just drops on your head. My first confession, I looked in the So this man is saying in the Dutch dictionary the meaning of compassion is something like feeling sorry for. This is not the meaning of compassion in Buddhism. It has a very simple definition.
Basic compassion is the thought not wanting suffering, not wishing suffering for self and others. When we take refuge, we’re also acknowledging that we are limited, we are suffering, we are limited, our mind is selfish and we have anger and jealousy and all sorts of petty thoughts. We’re acknowledging that, but at the same time we are acknowledging that we have a far greater potential. So, we’re not trying to like in the act of prostrating, we’re not trying to humiliate ourselves or by putting ourselves on the ground, give ourselves a hard time because I’m so bad whereas I should be really good. Refuge is the acknowledgement that one is in a limited state, but that limited state can be wisely, compassionately, skillfully, step by step reduced and eliminated.
And there’s no reason for guilt and self hatred and loathing and thinking, Oh, I’m not compassionate now. I should be compassionate, I should be wise, I should be totally realized. We shouldn’t be. It’s ridiculous. We’re not.
We can’t be. It can only happen step by step. And that’s what refuge is about acknowledging that and giving ourself a chance to be wiser and more compassionate than we normally are because if we give ourselves the chance, we can be. And if we use the right methods, we can be. And that’s all refugees are saying, I can do this bit by bit, I can do it.
I’m not a hopeless case. Incremental as opposed absolute. Yes, yes, it’s incremental as opposed to absolute if you didn’t get that. Yes, step by step, lam rim. Lam is path, rim is graduated.
Everything is a graduated path. This is what the Dharma, this is what the Buddha is telling us. This is what this inconceivable wonderful being, Lama Tsongkhapa, came here to tell us. Everything is a graduated path. Step by step.
So it’s okay, it’s okay to be deluded in one sense. We don’t have to punish ourselves for being imperfect. But we don’t have to wallow in that state. We can aspire, inspire ourselves to, step by step go beyond it. There’s nothing to feel guilty about.
It’s okay to be deluded in one sense. In one sense it’s not okay at all, but in another sense it’s totally okay. If you understand what I mean, yeah? I can’t explain that. So I lose track.
Who was first? The study is saying taking refuge means mainly getting out of the outer activities of life. Mother Teresa was working all her life. Is it sometimes better to do external work? So, haven’t explained myself properly.
What am I trying to say? The point of letting go of the external world means our obsession with it, our mind that is obsessed with the world, the external things, and the mind that exaggerates the value of things of the external world. So when we take refuge, we’re starting to see the flaws of that and to see that happiness lies within. But of course, we have to operate in the external world and the whole point of the Buddhadharma is to benefit others who exist in the external world. It’s not to reject living beings.
Mother Teresa was doing many things in the external world but because she had this incredibly powerful inner world, No one could do what she did if she didn’t have this inner work. How she had this compassion for others is because she had developed the quality in her mind and that quality of compassion can’t be developed by relying on external things. And when you have this strong inner world, you can do all sorts of things in the external world and be unaffected by it, like the lotus grows out of the mud. And one can do external things as a means to develop positive qualities. I mean, compassion isn’t developed solely by just sitting in a cave thinking, Oh, I love all sentient beings.
Have to one has to also check with real beings, do I love them? By interacting with them. Slowly, slowly, I hope it makes sense. Because also one I’m not saying again, it’s a graduated path one suddenly cannot go from being someone who is totally relying on the external world, totally believing only in the external world, to suddenly someone who is completely withdrawn from it all. Compassion is a quality we need to develop.
It is a quality directed to other beings. The more that quality of compassion is developed, the more it goes out to benefit others in countless ways which involves working physically working for sentient beings as well. But this is one point I’d like to make, is that what is happening even among the religions of the world which all emphasise the need to develop some inner quality. It’s viewed in different ways. But what is happening, for example, in Christianity now, so much emphasis of different Christian schools is to do external activities, feed poor people and this and that, which are very good things to do.
But just relying on external activities doesn’t develop the mind. One runs out of inspiration and energy, one gets burnt out. One has to work with the inner mind. One has to, at some point, spend some time by oneself developing one’s inner qualities. And the more those inner qualities are developed, the more you can then work for sentient beings.
But just thinking loving kindness and compassion is feeding poor people, curing sick people. This only has a very limited view of suffering because you feed poor people that they’re going to get sick and they’re going to die. Feeding poor people doesn’t change their mind. You cure sick people but they will die anyway. So the ultimate gift to sentient beings that the Buddha taught, which is the Buddhist view, the Dharma view, the greatest gift we can give to sentient beings, other mother sentient beings, is not curing their sicknesses, not giving them food, not giving them an education, clothes, all these things, but freeing them from the causes of suffering.
This is the greatest gift and very few people and the only way one can give that is to purify the mind and develop the mind. So one withdraws momentarily from the world in order to give to the world the very greatest thing that it needs. But if we just run around only being nice to people, smiling, chatting, curing their diseases, there’s no time to develop the mind that can give the greatest gift. But this is not to say that we also don’t do. That the Buddhist doesn’t do these small things, we only do the great things.
It’s not saying that at all. We can do these small things in order to develop the courage, the compassion, the love and so on, to finally develop these inner qualities totally. Okay. One more. Yes.
Oh, sure. Definitely. Yeah, absolutely, there’s no question of that. Why do you call it the dharma practice? Sorry?
Why do you call it the dharma practice? Yes. There’s the two things that go together, there’s the external activity and the inner mind, the inner work and the outer work going together. Okay, we’ll take a small break, a short break, a leg stretching break and a couple of minutes and then we’ll do a very short meditation checking meditation. So the basic idea of these short meditations after the talk is basically just to go over what’s been said, to recall in your mind, either try to remember as much as has been said, either from memory or you may have taken a few notes, so one can read those notes and reflect on different points.
So, basically, just for a short time, we sit in a comfortable position, keeping the body still, we generate good motivation and then we just do simple analytical meditation checking meditation as Lama Yeshe used to call it, just checking on this point that if I’m beginning to consider following some spiritual path or I’ve already started to embark on this in some way, then the path that I’m following there are many ways, paths to happiness are presented, many different ideas so on, by different teachers, many similarities and so on, but they may all be the same, who knows? But to follow the path, that path has to be an unmistaken one. Just consider this, as I said. A pure method can only come from a pure mind that is completely unmistaken, has perfect wisdom, perfect compassion, free of all faults. We can only rely on someone like that, some being like that, and teachings that come from such a pure mind.
So just consider this point. And that these teachings must lead us to a total understanding of our mind, the potential for suffering in our mind, the potential for happiness. It needs to present every possible way to overcome those causes of suffering, every possible way to develop the potential of our mind, and in a way that doesn’t cause harm to myself or any living being. And then check whether it is a possible, intelligent thing to do to believe that enlightened mind, free of all fault, possessing every possible virtuous quality, completely omniscient. Is it possible to believe that such mind exists?
Exists right now, has always existed. If we can perceive some basic wisdom and goodness in our own mind, and we can also see that things obscure our mind, can we imagine somehow that it is possible that these limitations, obscurations can be eliminated and this basic wisdom and goodness totally developed? If so, there are beings, maybe there are beings who have done that and therefore there are minds existing in this state free of all obscuration, all obstacles and therefore possessing all good qualities. We can also spend just a short time checking how in our life, so far, we have taken refuge in so many different things, in different people, different things, places, objects and so on. How many of these things that we’ve taken refuge in, we’ve relied on to help really help us have been able to do that as we really want?
Or have they let us down, betrayed us in some way? Maybe not willingly, but simply because the thing we the person we took refuge in simply wasn’t capable of being able to do what we hoped they could do. So we can maybe come to the conclusion how essential it is even for our ordinary happiness, let alone our lasting inner happiness, that we have to rely on true refuges. Something perfect, pure, wise, compassionate, unbetrayable. So then we can dedicate the merit that, by this positive energy generated in my mind, may become a cause for me to always meet the perfect refuge, to be always able to practice that perfect method and achieve the perfect result, complete enlightenment that perfectly benefits myself and continuously benefits, in a perfect way, all living beings.
So the dedication prayers are on page ninety two. If we could say the other English version of the Bodhicitta prayer, the people could slowly copy down from the prayer on the board at the back. The precious bodhimind, not yet born, arise and grow. May that born have no decline, but increase forevermore. And then on page something or other is the food offering prayer, which is page sixty.
So, it’s really good as a way to be more mindful and cut one’s attachment and so on. When one collects the food, to sit down and offer the food, either using this prayer or just generating one’s own thoughts, offering a blessing of food, trying to see it not as something ordinary, but as like nectar that is totally satisfying the body and mind, and offering that nectar to the Buddha inside us, our Buddha nature or our Buddha potential which we can visualize as a Buddha sitting at our heart chakra, in the center of our chest, surrounded by all the sentient beings, offering them this nectar as well. And thinking that to eat this food, not just the pleasure of eating, but to eat with a thought that to energize the body, that the body needs this energy, and I use the energy of my body to practice the Dharma for the benefit of all living beings. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Can you achieve happiness through Buddhahood?
Our mind has a very limited concept of happiness. When we achieve enlightenment, the state we experience is nothing like the happiness we imagine it to be. It is not happiness as we know it, but something far beyond anything we can conceive. For our ordinary mind, though, it is fine to label enlightenment "perfect happiness", because there is no other way to deal with it. The label is just a carrot dangled in front of us to move toward. It is not a bad label, since enlightenment is not worse than happiness but better than happiness. It is something inconceivable.