Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 09 Tape 12 Side 2 Samsaric Realms

43 min · 2,744 words · 9 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 09 Tape 12 Side 2 Samsaric Realms
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches that karma is not fixed: a mixed motivation still creates good karma, and collective karma ultimately ripens individually. Because everything changes according to causes and conditions, freedom is possible by working with the law of cause and effect. A guided analytical meditation follows, asking the listener to see that their experiences arise from the mind and to protect the mind from disturbing thoughts.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-09

Duration: 43 min

UUID: 06a0f39a-805f-4d6e-b26a-ba9bc634d8fc

Words: 2,744

Good karma, but it’s still good karma. Because, as I was saying before, we start off with this is the nature of the animal, the situation — that our mind isn’t pure, so our motivation can’t be pure. But even though it’s impure, it’s mixed. Still, by trying to have some degree of good motivation, we are creating good karma. And as we purify our motivation, which is a graduated path, everything is a graduated path step by step, then as our motivation becomes purer, then the karma we create becomes stronger and purer, more beneficial.

It’s the only way things can happen. We can’t create pure, good karma instantly. It’s a step by step process. Ten to eleven is question time, but we’ve had question time. Okay, one more.

No, not with the Generally, the question is if the motivation is impure, it’s a bit mixed, does that mean you’re creating good karma and bad karma at the same time? I don’t think so, no. It just means that the result is not very good, not so strong. There must be some dividing line there. Well, depends what your pure motivation is mixed with.

If it’s mixed with something really nasty, then you may be creating some negative karma. But if it’s just kind of not a very strong positive motivation, the result is not so great. It’s just like if you make a cake and you don’t mix it very well, it’s half mixed and then you bake it, you’ve got a cake! But it’s not the greatest cake. Hold on just a minute, let me think.

What do I want to say? Yes. Yes. Is it okay if we have quite some time more questions? Is it too much for people?

Is there collective karma? Yes, there is. So the question is, is there collective karma, for example, it seems like in the Middle East, and also for Tibetan people to have experienced what they have, this seems to be collective karma. So is there collective karma? And the answer is yes, there is.

But we talk about there is individual karma and collective karma, but actually all karmic situations boil down to being individual karma. Each one creates the cause to experience a particular result. But sometimes a group of people do things either positive or negative so they can it’s possible that the result is experienced together. But of course the result that is experienced together is still experienced individually. And the classic example given these days is, for example, when an aeroplane crashes, all the people who have collectively experienced that result together, but then some people in the plane don’t die because they haven’t created the cause.

An event occurs, but if you haven’t created the cause, even though there’s the condition, if there’s not the cause, you don’t experience the result. It’s possible that all the people who die in the World Trade Center are experiencing because it was a similar experience, the cause they created was a similar cause. But it’s difficult to say whether all those people created the same cause together at some time. It’s more likely that what happens because if start to see the world karmically, then one can see that different countries and even places within countries certain conditions are generated, some very negative suffering and terrible, and some very positive and good in various ways that have been created in a very obviously concrete situation over time, a situation develops. And therefore, if one has created the cause to experience, say, a really happy life, then one is karmically drawn to these very positive environments where there’s a lot of like a very healthy environment where there’s a lot of good food and nourishment and education and this and that, and it’s very peaceful, so one is born into that.

But there are other places in the world where there’s a great deal of poverty, no medicine, no education, or very little education, a great deal of ignorance, war, violence, the legal system has collapsed, so one gets born in that and you experience the suffering result. One has created a cause to experience suffering. We need a condition for that suffering to ripen. There is the interrelationship between mind and matter, and that interconnection produces suffering and happiness. We need the external environment for certain kinds of experiences to ripen.

I’ll go into this in more detail when we get to the topic of karma. Yes? Does that mean everything is laid out for us? No, it doesn’t mean that. We have in our mind both an infinite number think about this we have an infinite number of negative karmic imprints in our mind because we’ve had many lives in which we’ve done many negative things.

But also, at the same time, we have in our mind stream the imprints of many positive, virtuous things that we’ve done in many, many previous lives. So it is not fixed how these things will ripen because everything is changing moment by moment. And especially once we start working with our mind in a positive way, then everything really starts to rearrange completely. If we don’t work with our mind, then especially our negative karma will ripen again and again, strongly and more strongly. But it’s not some concrete fixed thing like fate.

Moment by moment everything is changing. One could say in any one moment one is creating the conditions for a certain karma to ripen. But the conditions can change, and then Because the conditions have changed, then it’s more likely another karma will ripen. And then the conditions change, and it becomes more likely another karma will ripen. It’s very complicated and very subtle.

But it’s not fixed. But it’s operating according to a fixed law and because of that everything is possible. Yes. The question is about this quote from this Japanese Zen master on this sheet, on the opposite side of the Doris Lessing quote, where it says, The absence of a fixed form is freedom from the law of causation. Maybe this is not well expressed, but what it’s really saying is that have to read the whole thing.

Every existence is a momentary form appearing according to prevailing conditions, without a fixed form of its own. It is not truly existing from its own side everything is arising depending on many factors. So because there is this absence of something really fixed because of that, then it shouldn’t really mean that one can escape the law of causation, but it means that one can work with the law. The law of cause and effect is something that one can avoid suffering and generate the causes for happiness. It’s not a situation of fate.

But because everything is arising depending on many factors, then change is possible purification is possible. That’s what I put that quote is what I think it is actually trying to say. Maybe if you read the next quote down from that, it might help your question, which is from Erich Fromm. Our capacity to choose changes constantly with our practice of life. The longer we continue to make the wrong decisions, the more our heart hardens.

On the other hand, the more often we make the right decisions, the more our heart softens or comes alive. Each step in life which increases my self confidence, integrity, courage, conviction also increases my capacity to choose the desirable alternative until eventually it becomes more difficult for me to choose the undesirable rather than the desirable action. So we are in this situation now where we are still controlled by karma, that we don’t have a great deal of freedom. And if we use that freedom choose then we create more and more freedom. On the other hand, if we make the wrong decisions, create more and more negative karma, we obscure our mind more and more, and there becomes less and less choice to do the right thing, the mind expanding thing.

But even that doesn’t become something solid, even when we obscure our mind completely for some time, that itself doesn’t last forever. It’s arising depending on conditions. Those conditions change. So the obscuration of the mind, that heavy obscuration of the mind, also lifts and then there’s some space in the mind again. Everything is changing depending on causes and conditions, but operating according to this law of cause and effect.

And because this law of cause and effect works in the same way, freedom is possible. I think we have to stop here. We’ll take a couple of minutes break and then we’ll have some meditation. Oh, you turn it off there, do you? Oh, okay.

So we’ll do a little meditation on karma. First, we sit in correct posture as much as possible so that we’re comfortable, feel that we can sit for this period of time, approximately twenty minutes or so. Then we generate the right motivation for doing the analytical meditation. So, that if I in order to generate freedom from suffering and enable the positive potentials of mind to arise, I need to understand my mind and what causes suffering in my mind, what obscures my mind, and so on. I need to develop this awareness to protect myself and help develop my mind, But also, I need this understanding, awareness, experience in order to benefit others firstly, begin to cause less suffering to others, and eventually develop the state where I can be of continuous benefit, not just in a temporal in a short term limited way, but in a very long lasting and profound way.

So, in order to gain more understanding of my mind, I’ll do this meditation. So, first thing we do a little breathing meditation first to, again, enable our mind to become calmer, clearer, more concentrated, just focusing on the breath for a short time. One can combine this with as one breathes out, imagining breathing out all the disturbances in the mind, particularly in all the those aspects of the mind that prevent us being able to do the meditation, inability to understand, boredom, and unwillingness to do it, and so on. We imagine breathing out all these obstacles in the form of black smoke that completely disappears. And as we breathe in, we can imagine breathing in the blessings of the Buddhas, or the pure mind, however one wants to understand it.

Blessing our mind to be able to do the practice well with concentration, clarity, understanding, so that we gain some real insight into the working of our mind. So we can begin by considering opening our mind to the possibility that this world that we experience appearing very vividly to us in one particular way as somehow separate from our self, very solid and fixed. Although it appears that way, undoubtedly it appears that way, maybe it exists in another way. That it does exist somehow depending on my mind. That without my mind, it doesn’t exist anyway.

For me, it doesn’t exist. That my experience of this external world comes through my sense consciousnesses completely dependent on them. And then, the way I experience not only the experience the appearance of the world itself depends on my mind, but the way those appearances are experienced as good, bad, beautiful, ugly, painful or suffering sorry, painful or pleasant also depends on my mind. Because if we check our experience, the way we perceive the same thing, the apparently same thing, changes. Especially in our relationships with people, our experience often changes.

Friend becomes enemy, enemy becomes stranger. But if the object is something fixed, how can our experience of it change? It all depends on our mind. When we’re sick, and our mind is affected by that, even our favorite food that we have can appear disgusting. It appears disgusting to our mind.

What normally appears delicious appears disgusting. But if that food was an independent phenomenon, independent of our mind, nothing to do with our mind, it should always be experienced the same way. But it’s not. In this simple example of watching a movie, we can think the movie is really enjoyable, someone else thinks it’s really boring. But if the movie was an independent phenomena existing from its own side, it should appear the same to both.

It shouldn’t depend on our mind. The fact that I see it as interesting, someone sees it as boring, indicates that what arises depends on our mind. The first time I see the movie, it’s interesting. The tenth time I see the movie, movie, it’s boring. It’s the same movie.

If it was independent of my mind, it would be interesting all the time. In that context, then we can consider just as in the external world, we can see that if we investigate enough, everything depends on a cause, every effect depends on a cause. And there is a continuous connection between the cause and the result. And if the external world itself is actually dependent on our mind arising within our mind. It’s an experience of our mind.

Then the cause for that experience lies within our mind. The root cause lies within our mind. Then try and consider, look at this, our life, as in itself an effect, the ripening of something. It must depend on the cause, the cause that preceded the effect, the cause created in previous lives. This body has arisen in this life depending on my parents of this life.

And there is the continuity of the physical genetic and genetic structure and so on of this body going back to my parents, my grandparents, going back and back. But why is my mind experiencing this particular body? If we can begin to see that the experiences of this life depend on the mind, arise within the mind, and the court, therefore the cause, must be of the same nature, coming from one’s own mind, same continuity of mind, then for the effect to be positive, happy, pleasant, then the cause must be of the same nature arising from the virtuous thoughts in the mind. The suffering experiences of this life, physical, mental, have a cause of a similar nature. Even the physical suffering of this life is experienced by the mind.

The cause lies in the mind. The cause must come from the disturbing thoughts. The thoughts that negate the positive, joyful potential of our mind, that obscure it. We can consider that just as a bitter fruit seed produces a bitter result, bitter fruit. So a sweet seed produces a sweet result, a sweet fruit.

So it is with the mind. Similarly, we can consider that when a seed is planted in the ground, placed in the ground, if that ground is affected by fire, the seed is burnt, there’s no result. The result doesn’t come. But if the seed is planted in the ground, the seed made like a seed in the desert. It made it remain there for a very long time.

Gradually, all the conditions come together. The nutrients in the soil, the temperature, and then just the right amount of moisture. And then, suddenly, when all the conditions come, the seed ripens. So it is with the mind. So we can bring the meditation to an end by thinking that if things work according to the law of cause and effect, then it’s incredibly important in my life to protect my mind from the arising of disturbing thoughts.

This is the only way to be free of suffering and to stop generating more suffering, and to do this not just for my own sake, but to protect others from the harmful effects of my mind. And also, by generating positive thoughts and actions, then one is I’m creating the cause for greater and greater happiness for myself, less suffering for others, eventually creating the cause to be able to be of lasting benefit to others. We can dedicate the merit of this positive energy we’ve generated in our mind that it becomes a cause for us to awaken to our true nature, in which state we can continuously, perfectly, spontaneously lead every sentient being away from creating the cause of suffering and lead them on the path that brings about the causes for liberation and complete enlightenment. Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
graduated path lamrim (Tib)
A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is there collective karma?

Yes, though all karma ultimately comes down to individual karma. Each person creates the cause to experience a particular result. A group doing positive or negative actions may experience the result together, but it is still experienced individually. In a plane crash, those who die experienced the result together, while others aboard do not die because they did not create the cause. An event alone is not enough; without the cause, the result is not experienced. Seen karmically, places develop conditions over time, some very suffering and some very good.

Does karma mean that everything in our life is already laid out for us?

No. The mind holds an infinite number of negative karmic imprints, because of the many negative things done in many lives, and also the imprints of many positive, virtuous actions from previous lives. How these will ripen is not fixed, because everything changes moment by moment. Once we start working with our mind in a positive way, everything begins to rearrange completely. If we do not work with our mind, negative karma will ripen again and again, more and more strongly. Karma is not a concrete fixed thing like fate. In any moment we create the conditions for a certain karma to ripen, but when the conditions change, another karma becomes more likely to ripen.

Scroll to Top