Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 08 Tape 09 Side 1 only Cause & Effect

21 min · 1,920 words · 8 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 08 Tape 09 Side 1 only Cause & Effect
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains the law of cause and effect: disturbing thoughts leave bitter imprints that ripen as suffering, while virtuous thoughts leave positive imprints that ripen as happiness. It argues that good and bad karma have a universal basis, since all minds share a Buddha nature and suppressing it causes suffering. It ends by noting that negative actions can be purified and that dedicating the merit of listening to the Dharma leads toward enlightenment.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-08

Duration: 22 min

UUID: a0cbabb8-e0f7-4254-b51a-e03f96a83294

Words: 1,920

In our mind, the disturbing thoughts of desire, attachment, anger, ignorance and so on, jealousy, pride. These disturbing thoughts are imprinted in our they create, just an analogy way of speaking, they create an imprint in the mind. No matter how tiny the disturbing thought is, no matter how briefly it arises in the mind, it is registered in the mind, it is imprinted in the mind, it generates a potency, an energy in the mind. And that acts as a cause that produces an effect in the future. These disturbing thoughts are suffering, we can discover that ourselves, are agitating, they are like bitter seeds.

They create bitter seeds in the mind that can only produce bitter results, in other words, suffering. Every time positive thought arises in our mind, thoughts of loving kindness, compassion, thoughts based on wisdom, some correct perception of reality, thoughts of tolerance and generosity, Chenrezig and so on. Every time those thoughts arise, no matter how weakly or briefly they are registered, imprinted in the mind as virtuous positive seeds. And they act as causes to produce an effect in the future and that effect can only be positive resulting in happiness or the causes of happiness. This is what is basically meant by the law of cause and effect in the Buddhadharma that all our thoughts, positive and negative, generate these karmic imprints karmic seeds, karmic potencies, karmic potentialities in our mind and they ripen.

Sooner or later they ripen. And they ripen according to their very nature. The positive imprints can only ripen as some form of happiness, pleasure and so on. The negative imprints can only ripen as suffering. Bitter fruit produces a bitter seed produces a bitter result.

Heat makes hot water, ice makes cold water. This is the law of cause and effect and this is universal for all minds, this is how all minds work. All minds have the same nature and they all work in the same way. There’s not much time to make this point but anyway, in talking about karma we always talk about positive karma and negative karma or we could call it good karma and bad karma or virtuous karma and non virtuous karma. So the good, virtuous, positive karma produces happiness, the bad, negative, non virtuous karma produces suffering.

So in hearing that, one could always say, But you talk about good and bad, virtuous and non virtuous. These categories are very superficial things that change with time and place, with culture. What one culture believes is good, another culture thinks is bad. Even within one culture what people think of as good at one time is bad at another time. So, what’s this good and bad karma?

But, I think we can validly say that there are valid ways of talking about universal and what’s the other word? Applicable at all times, categories of good and bad that apply to all beings at all times in all situations in all cultures. Because when we’re talking about good and bad karma, we’re talking about what determines good karma or bad karma is what motivates the thought. If the thought is motivated by anger, ignorance, desire attachment, it creates bad karma. Why?

Because if we investigate the natures of those minds, they are suffering, they are painful. And they’re not just painful for Europeans or Chinese people or Malaysians, they’re painful for everyone at all times and they’re not just painful for human beings, these these states are painful for all sentient beings. They are unwanted, they are unnatural states of mind. Although we have them arising all the time, they are unnatural. There’s no valid reason for them to be there.

There is a reason for them to be there, ignorance. But that ignorance is an invalid mind. All of these are unnatural states that obscure the mind. If one can get to a point of believing, understanding that, especially based on some kind of experience, that mind has this blissful nature, this basic purity, anything that is obscuring that, even for a moment, even in the tiniest way, is negating what we are, is negating our happiness. It is negative, it is bad, it is unwanted.

And that applies to all beings at all times. Anything that suppresses our potential for happiness, real happiness, not happiness that arises by killing people or harming them or taking One can become happy by stealing from people. There’s an appearance of happiness from stealing people. Stealing from people. Also stealing people sometimes.

Yeah. But that’s not happiness, that’s just the illusion of happiness. If there is this genuine happiness, anything that is suppressing that, isn’t that bad? Isn’t that negative? Isn’t that unwanted?

Who wants that? Who wants their happiness to be suppressed, prevented, taken away, destroyed? Nobody ever at any time in any culture there’s no culture anywhere devoted to being miserable. Yeah, maybe. Yeah.

Animals don’t want to be unhappy. Yeah? There’s no being that wants to be unhappy. Unhappiness is bad, right? It is negating what we are.

It is there is a valid basis for talking about what is good and bad, what is virtuous and non virtuous. It’s not something superficial that’s just thought up by some human being. It’s something there is some universal criteria and that is related to how the mind works and we all have minds and all our minds are the same. There’s no such thing as an inherently female mind and a male mind, a human mind and an animal mind, a white mind or a black mind. Minds are all the same, just clear and knowing.

That is their conventional nature. Their ultimate nature is empty of true existence and that’s why we can become Buddhas. All our minds have this Buddha nature. To suppress that is terrible. So there is a valid basis for talking about positive and negative, good and bad.

So when we generate these negative states of mind, they create these negative imprints that can only produce suffering. When we generate these virtuous states of mind because they are arising from our true nature, when we generate a little bit of loving kindness even with effort, it’s because that potential exists in our mind and it’s arising because we’ve got rid of some of the negating stuff that prevents it from existing. We haven’t generated this love, generosity, compassion out of nothing. It’s been allowed to arise because it’s there. All we’ve done is got rid of some of the garbage that suppresses it.

So that is a positive mind. It’s something creative, a creative mind connected to our true nature. So that is virtuous, positive, good and it produces happiness. This is what the Buddha taught. A little bit over time but if we have one or two quick questions.

Yes? Did you have a question in green? What is the cause of ignorance? The cause of ignorance is a previous moment of ignorance and also ignorance exists because we fail to be aware of it. Ignorance flourishes in darkness.

Yes Fred? Yes. A dark mind? A permanently dark mind? No, no, no, absolutely not.

The question that I was talking about was minds and clouded minds. Is there such a thing as a dark mind or like a permanently dark mind? And the answer is sorry? Well, all minds have because of ignorance can become dark and we all have experienced that and some people get darker than others and that darkness in the mind gets thicker and lasts longer. But what I’ve been trying to say as to explain from what the Buddha taught is that all of these things are superficial.

There’s no such thing as a totally negative person, a totally negative mind. All of us can experience very strong negative states that may last a long time, but that is not the true nature of our mind. This is why I was trying to say, maybe on the first night, when people say, I am good and you are evil, you did something bad, therefore you’re evil. This is not true from a Buddhist point of view. When these aeroplanes crashed into the buildings in New York, that act was definitely a terrible act, that was negative karma, but it doesn’t make the person doing it an evil person, a truly existing evil person, they are just deluded.

A mind, you know, the believing that killing and directing incredible hate to a group of people will solve problems, believing that and believing that this is a religious view, that this is what God wants, this is a really obscured mind. Yeah? It’s not an evil mind, it’s a temporarily obscured mind. That mind has Buddha nature. And it doesn’t help us to think anyone is really evil.

There are plenty of people who do evil negative things but they are not no one is truly evil. Unclouded? Sure, yes, yes. Yes, yes. This is what the whole thing is about because we’ve all done some sick, nasty things either in this life or previous lives and the Buddha said that despite that we can purify all that, we can eliminate all of that and achieve enlightenment because that is our true nature.

And the point is not to identify with those negative aspects of our mind because they are not our true nature. Although they’re there and they’re very strong, they are actually unnatural. It is not natural to be ignorant and confused and full of desire and attachment. It’s very common. It’s not natural.

It is natural to be wise and loving and compassionate even though it’s not very common. But that is what is really natural. Well, tried to answer that before. I think it really you just have to try and think about it a bit more. Don’t know if I should repeat my answer again.

Anyway, it’s an example of what I was saying, we can’t try to understand everything at once. Yes, one more. Are going to cause more negative things to ripen in the future. Yes. And that has to ripen, so how do we ever get out?

We will get to that. Like I said, I can’t put it all together immediately, step by step, but definitely I’ll try to explain, this is one of the basic things. Firstly, we have to stop creating negative actions, right? And in that space when we’re not creating negative actions, we have the time, the opportunity to purify our mind of the negative imprints that we’ve put in out of confusion and lack of awareness. So I’ll try and explain that later on.

But this is something definitely we can do. The Buddha said that the very worst actions that have ever been done by any human, any living being, all of those can be purified. Okay, I think we better stop now, it’s getting late. Oh yes. Yeah.

Okay. So the action of listening to the Buddhadharma is creating karma. Especially if we do it with good motivation, it creates even better good karma. And to protect that good karma we dedicate it and direct it that this good karma ripens the effect it produces. It’s not just some ordinary happiness, but it produces the effect of not just liberation but complete enlightenment, our complete awakening to our true nature and the ability to help all living beings awaken to their true nature.

Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top