33 min · 3,998 words · 8 November 2001
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk introduces the law of cause and effect (karma) as a basic Buddhist principle that contains all the teachings. It explains that karma refers to intentional mental activity, that an effect must have a prior cause of the same nature, and that Buddhism rejects both uncaused existence and a first creator, since a first cause would have to be independent and so impossible. It also notes that Buddha mind is omniscient but not a creator.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 2001-11-08
Duration: 34 min
UUID: 8007734c-b865-4df5-8e06-f63474330eea
Words: 3,998
Mahāyāna path, that wisdom has a greater power because it is empowered by Bodhicitta. This incredible yeah, by Bodhicitta, put it simply like that. And the merit that one has this this merit, this this virtuous energy that one has generated under the influence of Bodhicitta. That virtuous merit, that virtuous energy gives greater strength to the wisdom, and that stronger wisdom then eliminates step by step these very subtle imprints of the delusions that exist in our mind. So these subtle delusions, as I said, are called the obstacles to omniscience and are also sometimes referred to as the dualistic mind because these subtle imprints create this dualistic appearance of of a self and other, this dualistic appearance of self and other that obscures the mind, prevents omniscience.
So on the path to enlightenment, these subtle imprints are totally eliminated, and when they’re totally eliminated enlightenment, the fully enlightened mind arises, which is completely omniscient, knowing knowing all phenomena all the time. This is what the Buddha taught. This is the potential of our mind to know everything and know everything that exists and to know the past, present, and future of everything simultaneously. This is the omniscient, inconceivable, omniscient mind that we have the potential for. To know the minds of every sentient being.
The Buddha mind, it is said, knows the mind of all of us right now without any mistake. It knows the past, present, and future of our minds right now. Therefore, that mind is able to guide us to enlightenment because it knows everything. It is omniscient and omnipresent. It’s omnipresent because it’s mind, because it’s formless, without any dimension, any restriction.
This is what we are being encouraged to discover, the potential for that within our little mind now. Within our tiny little mind, there is this potential for this amazing big mind. This omniscient, wise, compassionate mind is within us, but it is obscured by all these ridiculous, disturbing thoughts that we have. Right. Okay.
So the next point I’d like to try to talk about briefly is about the law of cause and effect, karma. Just as an introduction for the new people, maybe as a refresher course for the older students, because this is a fundamental aspect of the Buddhadharma, actually the law of cause and effect. I’m only going to talk about one aspect. Hello? Sorry.
Yeah, please if someone if you can’t hear, let me know. So I really want to talk a little like I give one basic point about the law of cause and effect now, and I’ll talk about it later in the where it traditionally comes in outline of the path to enlightenment. But it is important to introduce this idea, this concept now. But the law of cause and effect is a fundamental aspect of the Buddhadharma and it actually contains within it all aspects of the Buddhadharma. When we take refuge, which is the official process of becoming a Buddhist, following the Buddhadharma, of taking refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, the essential refuge is the Dharma, the teachings.
And within the teachings, the most crucial essential teaching that the Buddha gave is about the law of cause and effect because it contains within it all of the Buddha’s teachings. All of the Buddha’s teachings and practices are connected to understanding and observing and practicing the law of cause and effect because the Buddhadharma is about developing wisdom and compassion. These are the two qualities that the Buddhadharma is about. This is what is going to free us and benefit us, wisdom and compassion. And wisdom and compassion based on another quality, which is called renunciation, is giving up our obsession with the things of this world.
While we’re obsessed with this external world, there is no way to develop real wisdom and compassion. So these are the three essential qualities that the Buddhadharma is about, that we need for happiness, what the world needs, everyone needs, and all of these are contained within the law of cause and effect. Observing the law of cause and effect is being wise. I’ll explain this more I go on, I repeat myself many times. I don’t make any excuse for this.
I do it deliberately, sometimes I can’t control myself and I repeat myself anyway. But also, just to make some excuse about this, it is the tradition, in the Tibetan tradition of presenting the teachings that in each talk you’re supposed to repeat everything three times. First you give a brief explanation, then you give a middle length explanation, then you give a full length explanation. Well, don’t do it exactly like that, but that’s my excuse for repeating myself. Okay.
And so the point is to for it to go into the mind more and more because also the reason to repeat oneself is you didn’t hear for the first ten times. So now I’ve lost my point again. Yes, is Yeah, so observing, understanding and practicing the law of cause and effect in one’s life is being wise and it leads to the development of wisdom. It is the practice of being kind and compassionate to oneself and it increases one’s love and compassion, and therefore acts and enables one to be more loving and compassionate to others. And in order to observe the law of cause and effect in our life, we have to renounce, we have to give up things.
So it contains everything that the Buddhadharma is about in the law of cause and effect. I’ll try to explain that in more detail later. But the law of cause and effect is about creating karma. The Sanskrit word karma literally means activity. It’s just a Sanskrit word, it’s not an exclusive Buddhist word, but it’s just an Indian term, and the Dharma originated in India, the Buddha had to use the language of the time.
So there is this word karma, which means activity. But in the Buddhist context, it is referring to the activity of the mind. And as I did mention, also in the Hindu tradition, also talk about karma and future reincarnation and so on, but there is a slightly different view than in the Buddhist presentation. Also, always make the same worrying joke that there is California karma, and this is also slightly different than the Buddhist view. So please don’t mix these up.
Know, there’s the idea of instant karma. This is not Buddhist view. So karma is referring to the activity of the mind, and the activity essential activity of the mind, of the ordinary mind, is thought, intentional thought. So karma is referring to intentional thought. Before I go on, I have to say this point, that of all the teachings of the Buddha, the most difficult to prove is karma, the law of cause and effect.
One would normally think that the wisdom teachings of the Buddha about the nature of reality, emptiness, are the most difficult to understand and prove, but they are relatively easy compared to the law of cause and effect. The workings of karma of the mind is a very subtle phenomena that our ordinary mind cannot see because karma is also talking about the the incredibly long term effects of our actions, which of course we cannot see at all, And we cannot even see our mind yet. We do know we have a mind, we have a very gross experience of our mind, but we’re not able to directly experience our mind right now. So the subtle workings of our mind are far beyond our perception at the moment. So the law of cause and effect is something that requires faith, but it doesn’t require a blind faith.
One can generate some faith in these teachings based on logic. Again, this is not something that can be proved in any way, but if one thinks about it, there are many indications that the law of cause and effect as the Buddha taught is true, and it explains so much about how we experience life, what happens to us. So the basic point of karma that I want to talk about this afternoon is the simple fact, the simple point, the first point about the law of cause and effect, which is that for an effect to occur, the Buddha taught, for there to be an effect, there has to be a cause. This is the fundamental view of Buddhism. If there is an effect, there must be a cause.
What is an effect? Everything is an effect. Looking at this bunch of flowers is an effect, it’s a result. Every experience, good or bad, physical or mental, is an effect. It is a fruit, it is a ripening, and it has a cause.
From Buddhist point of view, it must have a cause. And that cause logically must exist before the effect. The effect the cause cannot come after the effect, and it is not simultaneous with the effect. If these were real flowers, which they’re not, For the effect of real flowers to arise, you have the cause of a prior seed. The seed doesn’t exist at the same time as the flower.
The flower that produces the seed that produces this flower does not exist at the time of the flower. Right? It exists before and and the flower can only exist by the destruction of the seed or the transformation of the seed. Right? And the seed does not exist after the flower, the seed that produced that There’s another seed that comes after the flower but not the seed that produced the flower, right?
The cause comes before the effect. Just to go back a little bit, this gets into very heavy philosophical territory which I’m not really capable of dealing with, but just to just generally talk about this, Buddhist scholars argue that for things to exist, there are only three possible explanations why why everything exists, three choices, three possibilities. First possibility is that there is no reason for anything to exist. So there were Indian schools of thought that believe followed that system. Long before there were modern skeptics and materialists and everything, there were Indian philosophers who were called no, it wasn’t the Tīrthikas, no, no, wasn’t it Tīrthikas, which were anyway, one group who denied that there was any cause for anything, things just simply existed, and there was no cause for anything.
The second possibility is that there is a creator, something, someone created everything. There is a first cause of everything. And the other explanation is the law of cause and effect the Buddhadharma, and of course Buddhism accepts this third view, that there is not a first cause of everything, but everything has a cause, and that cause has a cause, and that cause has a cause going back and back, but there is no first cause. So just very briefly, Buddhist scholars refute the first argument that there is no cause for everything because, well firstly, at a physical level, at an ordinary physical level, can see there are many causes for things. There are many causes for things.
We can’t see the cause of many things, but we can see the cause for some things, such as seeds produce flowers. And if one investigates, one starts to see that in some ways, at least at some level, we can see that a seed causes a flower, but things have caused the seed, and that seed is connected to the soil, the moisture, and the moisture is connected to this, and this is connected to that, and that’s connected to this, and that, and that, and everything’s connected to one another. So if something is a cause that produces effect, then it’s logical within this system that there is causes for everything. Also, if there is no real cause for anything, Buddhist scholars argue that if there is no cause, and logical causes, a logical way that things work according to a law of cause and effect, then well the traditional argument is that a purple elephant could appear floating in this room right now. Why not?
It doesn’t need a cause, there’s no things can happen without a reason, so why not a pink elephant floating in the room right now? Or we could all turn into pink elephants, why not? No, there’s no cause for anything. Or, you know, here we go. I pour this water, try to pour this water into here, but because there’s no real cause for anything, it just doesn’t go in there, it just stays there.
Why not? If there’s no cause for anything, if there’s no consistent cause, if there’s no consistent law controlling, regulating things. Buddhist scholars argue that if we investigate more and more, we can see, we can discover that things are have causes. Things don’t exist arbitrarily for no reason whatsoever, independently, separately. So the second explanation, which is getting very tricky, is the concept that there is a creator, a creator, a god, that is responsible for everything.
So Buddhism refutes this view, not as a way to put down other religions that view this, have this view, but the Buddhadharma is about, as Lama Yeshe said, it is an active, alert confrontation with reality. It is trying to discover what is true and why is it there suffering. The first truth, the noble truth that the Buddha taught, the first truth of noble beings that the Buddha taught was that there is suffering, there is dissatisfaction. This is undeniable. Well, it is denial, many people deny it, but it’s You can deny it but it doesn’t go away, there is dissatisfaction.
And the Buddha discovered, looked, and wanted to know why, why this existed. What is the reason? Because if we can discover the reason, if there is a reason, then we can eliminate suffering. And that’s what the Buddha Dharma is about. So although the Buddha has presented a whole set of views and beliefs, it’s not that we should just gobble these up wholesale, it is our responsibility, as the Buddha himself said, to not believe what I say, but check up just because I who I am, you check up yourself.
So the Buddhadharma has always been about really honestly trying to find out what is the cause of suffering. Why does suffering exist? It has come through that investigation, both through logical understanding but through direct experience, Buddhist scholars, practitioners, the Buddha himself has come came to the awareness that a created God doesn’t exist. One can think of, you know, God and Buddha. Buddha mind is omniscient, like the Christian concept of God.
Buddha mind is omnipresent, like the Christian concept of God. But the big difference is that Buddha Buddha mind is not a creator. It has not created this world. Buddha mind does not control this world. Buddha mind did not create suffering.
Buddha mind simply observed it and tries to tell us how bad it is and how we can get rid of it. So Buddhist understanding refutes the idea of a creator god, a creator of this universe, of any universe. Why? Because if there is a creator, this is just a very simple this is my excuse for this presentation. This is a very simple simple summary of the Buddhist logic.
There are huge tomes about this that one could try and study. But the basic idea is that if there is a creator, a creator this universe, then this creator, what that means is a first cause. The creator is the first cause of everything. Right? Before the creator there was nothing.
If there was something before the creator, then the creator isn’t the creator. The thing before the creator was the creator. So you have to go back and finally agree, well, there’s a there must be, probably to explain everything, a first cause. So what does a first cause mean? According to Buddhist scholars, what a first cause implies, means, is that by definition, a first cause of something, of everything, is an independent phenomena, a totally independent phenomena.
Because if it is if a first cause depends on something, it’s not a first cause. So a first cause has to be an utterly, totally independent phenomenon. We talk about our countries as being independent countries. You know, the United States is an independent country, America, Australia, France, Italy, are independent countries. In a general way, this is true, but in reality, they’re not independent.
Every country is dependent on everything else. Depends on importing food, importing all sorts of goods, services, people, ideas. The weather isn’t comes from somewhere else. The weather just the and everything just doesn’t stop at the borders, you know, and so on. The birds fly back and forth, they don’t have passports, and they affect the agriculture and all sorts of things.
So actually, the idea of an independent country is a vague idea of independence, but a first cause, the very first cause of everything means utterly, utterly independent of absolutely everything because there isn’t anything. There’s absolutely no thing existing whatsoever. So this thing, this first cause, is utterly, utterly isolated, unconnected to anything, because if it’s connected, it’s dependent. As soon as you’re connected to something, you are dependent. So a first cause is utterly isolated and separate, utterly separate from everything.
That is what first cause means, if you logically analyze. And also, if a first cause has to be independent, not dependent, and if something is independent, it cannot change. If it’s independent, it is permanent. It is completely fixed, because for it to change it would depend on something to make it change. Therefore, since an independent phenomena is permanent, it cannot change, it therefore cannot create.
This this is Buddhist logic. From Buddhist understanding, an independent phenomena is utterly impossible to exist. There is no such thing as an independent phenomena. A first creator is a logical impossibility. And also, if there is a first creator, it is completely contradictory to the idea of emptiness, the view of emptiness, the Buddhist view of how things actually do exist, which is something that one can investigate and study and experience.
So these two things are actually contrary. There’s many, many similarities between all the different religions that propose the idea of a first cause, of a creator, but there is one unique difference. There is something totally unique about the Buddhist view, which is the view of emptiness. Some other schools talk about emptiness. Again, remember emptiness is just a word, but then there is a each school uses words, cultures and whatever use words in different ways, with different meanings.
So just because somebody says the word emptiness, it doesn’t mean, oh, it’s the same thing as Buddhism at all. Because also in Buddhism, there are different schools of views of emptiness. They use the same word, but have completely different understanding of what that means, what that word means, implies. So through investigation, through logic, and also through direct experience, Buddhist scholars, yogis, practitioners, from the Buddha, through all his great disciple practitioners have come to the conclusion that things do not exist for no reason. They do not exist because there is a first cause, they exist because of the law of cause and effect, that everything has an effect every effect exists depending on a cause, and that cause is not a truly existing independent phenomena.
That cause is also an effect that has causes, and that cause is an effect that has causes, and that has causes, and that has causes going back and back and back. And just as you posit a previous moment of mind, a previous moment of time, you can go back to what looks like a first cause, but you can always discover there is a cause for that cause. There is a cause for that phenomena. This is basically what the law of cause and effect is talking about at one level. That’s one basic point to think about.
Can’t prove it, but this is the fundamental view of Buddhadharma. So now we need to apply this we’ve got half hour, to the mind. Because the law of cause and effect is, of course it applies to physical phenomena as well, but the law of cause and effect is more profound than that. It is particularly talking about the way the mind works. So, as I was trying to hint, and maybe I can’t really explain because I haven’t studied the Buddhadharma properly well enough to be able to know it well enough to explain it properly enough, but just generally speaking, what I’ve been trying to say is that in talking about the mind as the source of all phenomena, that even at one level one can make a very clear distinction between consciousness, which is formless, and physical matter, which is form, which is made up of atoms and subatoms and etcetera, etcetera.
At another level these two things are not really so different, and even the physical matter, this physical universe we experience is experienced through our mind. This cup, this glass, at one level one says is a physical phenomena, but it is experienced through our mind. If you analyze, we will say I don’t know why this is better, but anyway. This is a bowl. Okay?
We all agree, more or less, it’s a bowl? We can all see this bowl, but in fact, we cannot see this bowl. You can never see a bowl, it’s impossible to see a bowl. What we see, literally see, is a shape because seeing is eye consciousness. What our eye consciousness experiences is shape and color.
That’s all our eye consciousness can experience. Yeah? And we can’t hear the bowl, we can just hear the sound with our ear consciousness. Doesn’t smell so much, and the taste I’m not going into the taste. And we say we can feel the bowl, you know, the bowl feels smooth, yeah, and it’s hard, but we’re not actually feeling the bowl.
There is just a physical consciousness, a physical awareness of something smooth and hard and cold, And that is happening as we are seeing shape and color, and our mental consciousness is putting all that information together and based on previous experiences of bowls generating a generic image of bowls, we experience a bowl that has a particular shape and color, sound and touch. But all of that is generated by different consciousnesses all coming together, being brought together, and there’s no other way this bowl exists for us, no other way whatsoever. Please experience a bowl without your eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body or your mind. So, this bowl is an effect, it is an experience. Therefore, it must have a cause.
It is an effect, it is a fruit, it is a ripening, it is a ripening in the mind, it must have a cause. Since the cause has to be the same as the effect, remember cause, I was talking about this this morning, for there to be an effect, the nature of the effect is determined by the nature of the cause. If you have cold water and you want the effect hot water, you have to have a hot cause. Right? Hot cause, hot result.
Sweet cause, sweet result. Bitter cause, bitter result. Also, if I want if this was you know, this is a pot of water, if I want to make this water hot, not only do I need a hot cause, but the cause has to be continuous with the result. If the fire is here, there’s no point putting the water here, there’s no connection between the cause and the desired effect. There has to be some continuous relationship
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.