Kopan Course 2001 – Kopan 2001 11 07 Tape 05 Side 1 The Mind

45 min · 4,761 words · 7 November 2001

Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Kopan Course 2001 - Kopan 2001 11 07 Tape 05 Side 1 The Mind
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains that mind is a clear, knowing process that the brain conditions but does not create, and that ordinary perception is distorted by confusion and filters. It teaches that the mind’s subtle nature is like a mirror able to see reality fully, that Buddha minds are the same in nature, and that this blissful, wise potential is Buddha nature present in everyone.

File metadata (for organising)

Date: 2001-11-07

Duration: 45 min

UUID: 89eab7e6-ff23-4ab9-a55b-a10752a7c07d

Words: 4,761

You will know the mind I’m experiencing. And when I’m a Buddha, I will know exactly the mind you’re experiencing. Buddhas. Yes. No.

You’re Buddhist? No. We’re not that bad. The propaganda isn’t that bad. Yes.

Is it not being experienced by someone else? I mean, just because we are not experienced in the sense we mean it does not exist. Right, this is true, yes. Yes. Yeah, that’s why trees don’t totally disappear when we’re not looking at them because there’s someone else looking at them.

But to try and sneak out of this very complicated thing because I’ve jumped into some very complicated things from the very beginning. But one thing Lama Yeshe used to say many years ago when he was alive was that it’s kind of pointless to worry about how did he say? Something like the reality of other people or some independent reality. What we have to be concerned is the reality that is appearing to us, our reality. And what we should try to understand, begin to understand, is that our reality is totally dependent on our mind.

I’m sorry, I’m not being very logical, I’m jumping here and there, but For example, in the world today we have this horrific conflict that is developing, what has been developing over a long period of time, which then became very obvious suddenly on September eleventh. Many people of course knew about this before, but then it erupted in this very horrific, terrible way on September eleventh. And one of the reasons why this conflict exists, whether these two sides I’m sorry if I offend anyone, but Mr Bush said at one point, side is good and they are evil. Yeah. There is this truly existing good and there is this evil.

And he believes this, but also the other side also knows, Mr Bush knows he is good and they are evil. But also the other side knows that they are good, and there is the great Satan, there is the great evil. They know that. And we all have this situation because unfortunately what appears to our mind, we believe is true. There is this reality, it is so directly in front of our face, it appears so obvious, and we believe that what appears to our mind is reality.

It’s true. And that’s why we fight, why we argue, why there’s all conflict in the world, because we never go a step beyond our own little world. There is me and my reality, and that is reality. And there’s no most of the time we never have the ability, or use our we have the ability, but we never use our ability to go beyond ourself and have some awareness that other people are seeing this room, this reality, in a different way. So when we argue about anything, about the smallest thing to the hugest thing, why we argue is because we know we are right.

We are right, why am I right? You know, this is beautiful. You say it’s ugly. I say it’s beautiful. You say it’s ugly.

But I know it’s beautiful. I know it’s beautiful. Why? Because it appears beautiful to me. To me, it’s appearing unquestionably.

It’s not a good example. But beautiful. So I know unquestionably that this is true. And so everyone if I know it’s true, then of course everyone else knows it’s true, that this is beautiful. So when someone this person comes along and says it’s ugly, this person is really, really stupid.

Or they are just nasty. They’re just trying to cause me problem because it’s obvious that this is beautiful. Yeah? I’m correct because it appears to my mind. And my mind is unmistaken.

So we all make the mistake if we think about the mind. Please sorry, wait. Let me have my little rave. If we ever think that we have a mind and we think, What is my mind? We assume our mind is like a mirror that just reflects what is there without any mistake.

So this is a complete mistake. Our mind at the moment is not a mirror that reflects reality as it is. The Buddha taught that the nature of our mind is like that. When we get rid of all the confusion in our mind, when we stop shaking the mind and let it be still, which it never has been, then the mind, the subtlest level of our mind is a mirror, like a mirror, that has the ability to spontaneously experience everything as it is, without any mistake, any addition, any omission. But our mind is not doing that now.

Sometimes it gets very close to it, but it never completely sees reality totally, unmistakenly. But we think that we are seeing things because things are appearing vividly to us. So we never think that what is appearing vividly to another person may be different, That in fact it may be vastly different for all sorts of reasons. So that’s why we have wars, that’s why we have conflicts between two people, why we have wars. Different cultures see things differently.

And each is convinced that we’re right. One thing at least hopefully we can learn in this course is that what we are perceiving is just arising in our mind. It’s not necessarily one hundred percent true. We have the potential to see what is true, to develop this vast, vast, clear mind that is able to see reality, but right now we are not seeing it. So, just to try to sum up, when we talk about the mind as being clear, it doesn’t mean that this is referring to some kind of light or something like that.

It just means it’s referring to it is a process or an action of being clear about something, or it is that which enables something to arise and to be experienced. And when we say this clarity enables something to arise and to be experienced, it doesn’t mean that what is being experienced is appearing clearly and perfectly to us, because at the moment many things are not. This clarity is just what enables things to arise and to be experienced. But right now, what is arising in our mind is not necessarily perfectly clear and accurate. It can be, that is the potential of our mind, but at the moment that is not necessarily happening.

Okay. Anyone desperate to say something, have a question before we take a break? Are Buddha minds the same reality? Are all Buddha minds able to? Yes, definitely.

In Buddhism, talk about there are two truths. There is the conventional truth, and there is the absolute truth. So all phenomena are characterised by an absolute truth, a particular aspect of them which is completely true. This quality or aspect of phenomena is what we are failing to see at the moment. And this is what realised beings, even before you achieve enlightenment, become a Buddha, one is able to see this absolute truth of phenomena.

Right now we’re not even seeing the conventional truth correctly. Certain aspects of the conventional truth we’re seeing, like we all agree this is red, but even the conventional truth we don’t often see correctly. Someone who hasn’t yes, yes. When people ask questions, could they try to speak loudly because Jean Francois Venerable Jean Francois has to try to translate for French people. Also other people might be having difficulty hearing.

There are different views of this in Buddhism, but generally, of course one can say, what is agreed is that Buddha minds are identical. Because as I’ve been trying to say, all minds, whether they’re Buddha minds or ordinary minds like ours, are the same in nature, having this quality of being clear and knowing, that is their conventional nature. And Buddha mind what is a Buddha is someone whose mind is completely purified of all thoughts and is seeing reality as it is. And so the minds of all Buddhas are the same, operating in the same way. But there is some debate within Tibetan Buddhism whether there are separate Buddha minds or there is one big Buddha mind.

The technical term for the mind of a Buddha is the dharmakaya, so there are different debates that there is one dharmakaya, meaning all Buddha minds merge into this one dharmakaya or there are many separate ones. But I’m not particularly interested in this debate, it’s very academic, I think. But from Buddha’s point of view there is nothing beyond Buddha mind. This is the ultimate state, one could say. Okay, we should take a short break, ten minute break.

Oh yes, because we have to finish on eleven. So we take a ten minute break, means sixteen past. Do you think you could maybe it would be good to tape put some tape in your light? Yeah, something like that would be good. So just to, to hammer — what’s the word?

Repeat the point again, just drive it in. To make some distinction between mind and physical form, our physical body, of course, is organic matter, physical organic matter, such as just as this table is organic matter, basically the same stuff. In fact, think if my physics is correct, my physics dates from way, way back, so it may have changed a lot since then. But I once read that atoms are flying off our body all the time and also on other physical particles are inter reacting all the time, something like that. I’m not sure about that.

Anyway, but this body is physical matter, this table is physical matter. But if I hit this table, it doesn’t know anything, it doesn’t know it’s being hit, it doesn’t experience being hit, and it doesn’t feel anything. But if you hit this, there is a knowing of something, there is a knowing of being hit, there is an experience of being hit, and there is a feeling, an unpleasant feeling that arises from being hit. Why? This is physical matter, this is physical matter.

How come this physical matter knows something and this doesn’t? The answer is that this physical matter, this body, this stuff here, doesn’t know about being hit. My arm actually doesn’t know it’s being hit, my arm doesn’t experience being hit, and my arm doesn’t feel anything, just as this doesn’t. What is knowing that? But there is a definite knowing going on, I know something is going on, I experience something and feel something, and what that is, is my consciousness.

The body consciousness is knowing that, not my body, the body consciousness is experiencing that. And my mental consciousness is knowing that I should stop doing that if it Again, I just have to make these points, can’t prove them in any way. There is this argument that it is the brain that does that. But and there are I mean the basic proofs or some of that there is just the brain that explains the existence of mind. Some of the most basic proofs revolve around the fact that if you damage the brain, then the mind is damaged, doesn’t work in the same way.

If you place electrodes in certain parts of the brain, then certain memories are recalled and certain responses take place. So this seems to indicate mind and brain are the same thing. If you have certain mental diseases, they perform a lobotomy and it all goes away. Yeah, this seems to indicate that the mind and the brain are the same thing. But no matter what scientists discover about the brain and its amazing functions, Buddhism doesn’t deny any of those things.

What Buddhism says is something else is also happening which is much more subtle. Buddhism does not deny, the Dharma does not deny that the mind is operating through physical phenomena at the moment, especially, as I said, this ordinary gross mind that we’re using now. That mind is definitely operating through physical phenomena. From a dharma point of view, the pleasure of eating food is a mental experience. But to have that pleasure, that pleasure is a state of mind.

But to have that pleasure you have to have the physical substance there. So, in dependence on that physical matter, a mental experience arises, there’s no doubt. To have a human level of mental experience, you have to have a human body. There’s no doubt about that, no question of that. But if you take an example, a rough analogy, remember it’s just a rough analogy of the mind and the brain is something like you can take the analogy of a television set and the signals it receives.

So if you have a television set, if the vows start to wear out, the picture goes all wobbly. So you could believe that that picture is something completely created by the television set. Someone from some, I don’t know, who’s never seen a television set or heard about one, and they see the images and they see there’s this stuff behind, one could imagine that the images on the television set are produced inside the television set. And this would be even further proved by the fact that if something inside the television set goes wrong, then the picture goes away. Proof that the television set, what do you call it, Insides the what do call the insides, it’s not the set, the system is producing the images.

And if you get a better valve then the picture gets clearer. Proof again that the image is produced by the electronic thing inside the box. So this is, from a Buddhist point of view, what scientists are saying about the brain. It comes down to not much more than that. And what they don’t see, understand or accept, or are even willing to accept, because scientists claim to be scientific but they’re very unscientific because the scientific model has all these assumptions that they refuse to go beyond.

But the point is, as we all know, with the television set, the image is coming from elsewhere, it’s not created by the television set. But that image can’t exist without television set. It depends on that television set. Roughly, it’s like that. The mind that we’re experiencing now depends on a physical base.

But that physical base is not the creator of those images. It just enables them to arise. So our brain and nervous system and this body and the blood and everything in it is what enables experience to arise, but it is not the cause of it. It is the condition, but not the cause. Also, if you think about in a television set, different kinds of images appear, images of war, images of love, and this and that.

So when the images of war and horror are going on, does the television set freak out? Does it feel it? I don’t think so. Right? But mind, when it generates various images and experiences, it has feeling.

People are working on creating artificial intelligence with computers. It is never going to work. You can never produce a computer that will feel and know, actually know, experience things. It can do things, but it can’t know. So this is the mind.

We have this amazing thing, this insubstantial process of experiencing, knowing, feeling, that is arising moment by moment. It has always existed. It has never come into existence. This is very difficult to grasp, but it’s always been there. It is what gives rise to the universe.

The universe didn’t exist and then sentient beings bopped along and minds came along. Mind is there and mind gives rise to the universe. The universe is the collective result of all the minds of all sentient beings. And this mind just keeps going on and on and on. So, as I said yesterday, if it is indestructible, then it goes beyond this physical mechanism.

It just simply can’t be destroyed. And if it goes on, it’s existed before. And if it’s existed before, it’s existed before before. Inescapable. So if this is true, it’s worth thinking about because not only is there an intellectual presentation of the existence of mind, but more importantly, the whole Buddhadharma and also the Hindu tradition is also about working with the mind, of experiencing it.

Because no matter what intellectually we say yes or no, subjectively there is mind, subjectively experience is undeniably arising moment by moment. There is the subjective experience moment by moment of suffering and happiness. But this is undeniable. When scientific materialist is working on the brain, proving the brain is the mind, what is he doing it with? With his mind, her mind.

Inescapably. So scientists may give some intellectual proofs that there is no mind, but these proofs cannot refute the subjective fact of mind existing. And the Buddhadharma, among some other spiritual traditions, especially the Buddhadharma, has specialized in investigating that experience through meditation, of working with the mind, coming in contact with it, and all its different aspects, positive and negative. Which, with all due respect, for example, to the Christian tradition is not generally the case. For example, I’m not sure exactly which one it was, but one of the great Christian saints, it was either St Thomas Aquinas or St Thomas Aquinas, there’s another one, St Thomas Aquinas.

No, no, no, before St Thomas Aquinas. No, no, way before that, before the time of St. Thomas Aquinas, one of those. St. Augustine, it was maybe him who said that it was impossible to concentrate the mind for more than a few seconds.

So, one of the greatest Christian philosophers said that from his experience because there’s no system of working with the mind, no methodology, but in Buddhism there is, and one can discover that it is possible to concentrate the mind for more than a few seconds. It’s possible to concentrate the mind for minutes, hours, days, years. And when one is able to concentrate the mind, one discovers the nature of the mind more and more. And to discover that the mind, actually the deepest level of mind, not even the deepest level, but the most subtle levels of the mind, have got nothing to do with a television set, nothing whatsoever, existing quite separate. You don’t need the set, you don’t need this thing, this suffering lump of stuff, it’s unnecessary.

In fact, the mind works much better, apparently, without this thing. So this may sound very strange, but this is the Buddhist tradition, and one will have to say that all these people were schizophrenic. Thousands and thousands of people over several thousand years were totally out of their mind. But as Professor Robert Thurman says, Maybe they were mind scientists. These yogis, these great meditators are the real mind scientists who discovered things that we haven’t got a clue about.

What they discovered is that we have mind, and mind, because it has the ability to know, can know everything. Like I said yesterday, we can’t even listen to someone properly and know what they’re saying. And even when we listen carefully, we also listen through all the there is the ear consciousness that is hearing something, but then there is all these endless not necessarily endless, I won’t get too negative, but a whole number of filters through which we hear what I’m trying to say something, but each person here is hearing it through so many filters of their culture, their education, their life experiences, and I say something and I try to mean something and people think, Oh, he means that, oh yeah, because he means that, But I may not mean that at all. Your understanding may be much better than what I’m trying to say, which I hope it is, but there are so many filters, so many concepts that we put projections and concepts and so on that we put on this basic information that is coming to us. And we distort everything.

But the mind has the potential to know perfectly. If you could imagine, like if we’ve all done, at least in past two days, a little bit of meditation for a few minutes, an hour or something, and if we’re honest, what happens, unless there’s some really exceptional people here, I hope there are but for most of us, what happens is that it’s difficult to keep the mind on the object. The breathing is going on, it’s there, but to observe it completely is extremely difficult, such a simple, you would think such a simple thing. You know, I think we all think we’re all quite educated, sophisticated people in some way, cool twenty first century people, can use computers and cars and this is and we know how to do this and that, but we can’t watch our own breath for a couple of seconds. It’s kind of disappointing, depressing, really.

We’re not that cool after all, really, yeah. Really, it’s very difficult. All this stuff is going on. And some people may think, Well, it only started when I got here, I never noticed all this stuff before. They’re processing me, they want my money.

But the point is, all this stuff that we start to notice when we sit down to try to watch the breath is actually going on all the time. When we’re talking to people, when we’re reading books, when we’re watching television, when we’re working, all this stuff is going on and we don’t even notice it. And it’s affecting us, it’s directing us all the time and we’re hardly aware of it. But imagine if all of that went away, all this static, this garbage, this endless stuff, even just the pains in the body that detract us. Noise arises, we can’t help but follow it.

Even when it annoys us, we follow it even more. I can’t stand that noise but we chase after it, you know? So little control. But imagine if all of that left the mind, was not there, and there was just this maybe we’ve glimpsed a little bit where the mind for one second stayed on the breath. There was some awareness, this clear awareness of something.

It doesn’t have to be when we were meditating, but we’ve had the experience where we saw something, we’ve had this feeling that we saw it for the first time. Or sometimes even you hear a word and you kind of, Oh, sometimes all the words we use and then sometimes they sound so strange. Just a word, what a strange noise I’m making and it means this. Or you see a word written down, you kind of see it for the first time, kind of clearly. The mind is focused on it.

Imagine that the mind was like that all the time, for everything. Absolutely one hundred percent focused on whatever was happening, with control, complete control. I think we can imagine that to some extent, have some vague idea of what it would be like. We can’t really even conceive actually what it would be like, but we can get some idea, and that actually is the potential of the mind. The mind can do that.

That is the potential, the nature of our mind. And when the mind is doing that, when it is still completely clear, then all positive qualities arise, no suffering can arise because basically all suffering, confusion, worry, fear, anxiety, aversion, jealousy, pride, doubt, all of that is because of this, of not experiencing things correctly, clearly, totally. So when the mind is seeing things as they are, all this suffering and the pain and the confusion is not there. And what is there is this blissful nature of the mind. The Buddha said that our mind, in its very nature, is blissful.

It’s not some boring neutral state like looking at a glass, but it is actually blissful, there is this bliss in our mind all the time, but it is continuously suppressed by all this stuff going on. When it stops, this bliss can manifest. And this bliss is not just like one shouldn’t compare it with like having a good time, blissing out, having like fun, fun, fun type of bliss. This bliss is this kind of utter clarity and purity of the mind which is also not excited, but completely clear and completely wise, all encompassing mind, non rejecting mind. When we know things in false ways, we respond, especially we don’t know ourselves.

So we put up all sorts of barriers to protect this idea of who we are and to maintain that idea of who we are. So, we see everything through those filters and barriers. So, there is fear and anxiety and aversion and anger and regret and all these things that we respond to, to the external world and others because of not knowing, not knowing who we are, not really knowing others. We don’t know the mind of another person, even if we’ve lived with them for our whole life, we don’t know their mind. We have some insights occasionally, we have some general ideas, but we can never really say we know another person’s mind.

So, we respond with anger and with attachment to things, grasping at things, and it’s all agitating the mind. But if we know things as they really are, I think it makes sense even logically, if you know things really completely, there’s no reason to fear anything. If you really if we really know who we are, especially that our true nature is mind, if we if we know ourselves as a body, there’s a lot to fear because this body, even if it’s really big and strong and muscular, can be chopped to pieces very easily. A little insect can destroy it. Yeah.

So, if we know ourselves as a body, there’s lots to fear. But if we know ourselves as mind, as essentially this insubstantial process of experiencing, there’s not much to fear because you can’t harm the mind. So, there’s nothing to fear, nothing to protect. And if there’s no fear, there’s no reason to be angry, to hate, to doubt, to worry, to be confused about anything, about anyone, because we know ourselves, we know everything. And we know we know.

This is a very interesting thing. There’s a point where one can reach, where one knows that one is knowing correctly. So, when one is doing that, then there’s no, in relation to external things, there’s no basis, no reason to feel grasping at things, to be attached, to be dependent on things. But we can just simply appreciate what is arising. And in relation to sentient beings, when we know sentient beings, their conventional nature, their ultimate nature, how can we not respond to every sentient being with love and compassion?

This is the actual nature of our mind. To be wise, wisdom is seeing things as they are. This is what our mind can do. And when the mind is doing that, it experience other beings only, there’s no choice, but to experience all living beings with love, compassion, tolerance, patience, generosity and so on. No matter what they are like, whether they are kind to us or hate us, when we are seeing them, if we see what motivates their hate, if we see the suffering that they experience because of their hate, there’s no way hate can arise to sentient beings, we can only feel compassion, experience compassion for them.

It’s impossible for the mind to respond any other way, that is the nature of our mind. This is our Buddha potential, our Buddha nature. Within our mind right now there is wisdom, there is the potential for wisdom, love, compassion, tolerance, generosity, sensitivity, All, every possible positive quality you can think of exists in our mind right now. It is the nature of our mind. It exists in its potential form in our mind right now.

Because mind is knowing. If there is mind, there is Buddha nature, and if there is Buddha nature, there are Buddhas. It’s very simple. If there is brain, there’s no Buddhas, there’s nothing. But if there is mind, there is Buddha nature, and there are Buddhas.

So mind has always existed, and mind has always possessed this Buddha nature, but interestingly,

Key terms in this teaching

buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top