Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: Kopan 2001 11 06 Tape 02 Side 2 The Mind…..MP3
UUID: 45109d3a-4acb-4d41-835f-6ff9ddb3e577
Teacher: Ven Thubten Dondrub
Collection: Kopan Course 2001 (Ven Thubten Dondrub)
Date: 2001-11-06
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 45 min
Words: 5,200
So I’ll I’ll just say this one time, and then I’ll I’ll I’ll try not to apologize anymore, but there are some people here who’ve heard me teach before, so I have to apologize that I always say the same things again and again. I’ve been teaching on and off for twenty four years, so I still say the same things, and I’m going to say the same things again. And there’s certain things, like virtually every talk I ever give on the Dharma, whether it’s like a one hour talk or a month long course, I always start with because these are the things that I, when I first heard the Dharma, made the greatest impact on my mind and I found them extremely helpful. And I find it as as really important to think about as as the starting point for making the Buddhadharma really meaningful, to really understand what it’s all about. The basic point, the situation that we are all caught in is that in our daily life, we are seeking happiness.
Everything that we do from the moment we wake up in the morning until the we go to sleep at night is done whether we know it or not, consciously or unconsciously, directly or indirectly, in order to bring about happiness. We may not have any idea what happiness is. We all have different definitions of happiness, but everything that we do in life is motivated in order to be happy. The reason you are here is to be happy. That’s why you came here is to be happy.
You didn’t come here to be miserable. You came here to be happy or to be happier. And at the same time, what goes along with that motivation inseparable from that thought, that wish, is the wish to be free of suffering, to be free of confusion, problems, difficulty, pain, unhappiness. Everything we do is motivated moment by moment to be free of suffering, pain, problems, difficulties. These two things are what direct us consciously, unconsciously, directly or indirectly, all the time.
The reason we go to bed at night is either to be happy or to be free of some suffering. The reason we wake up is to be happy or to be free of suffering. The reason we when we wake up, we stay in bed is either because we think staying in bed will make us happier or it will prolong some suffering, delay experiencing some suffering such as going to work that we don’t want to experience. During this month, you will try to stay in bed longer and longer to avoid hearing me, to avoid experiencing the cold, and all these things. From a Buddhist point of view, we have been doing this not just in this life, but in countless previous lives.
We are just trying to be happy and avoid suffering, or every living being is doing this. Oneself, all living beings, just want to be happy and do not want any kind of suffering. This is the basic point. Of my main teachers, Lama Yeshe, who was one of the first Lama Yeshe and Lama Zopa Rinpoche were the first two teachers I met with, and were are my main teachers. So once Lama Yeshe gave a little talk, a little analogy or whatever it is, I don’t know what you call it, so practically every Dharma talk I give I repeat this story because I found it very effective.
It’s very simple, I can’t do anything the way Lama Yeshe did it, but I try and capture the main point. So once in a talk, Lama Yeshe said he asked everyone in the audience to imagine that he was a great magician, so I would like to request that you imagine that I’m a great magician and that I can can I can give you anything you want without without a doubt. Instantly, I can give you exactly what you want for free. There’s no charge whatsoever, and I’ll give it to you immediately and exactly as you want. So you just have to tell me what you want.
Just Don’t yell out, you know, it’s just just in your mind. You just tell me what do you want, and then I give it to you. What do you really, really, really want? What you really want? What do I really want?
So to simplify things, because being a great magician I can also read all your minds, I can’t really but we’re just pretending, is that what you what you really Whatever you think of, I don’t know if you actually thought of some specific thing, you may have thought of a new car, or a new house, or a swimming pool, or a new boyfriend, girlfriend, or million dollars, or something you may have thought of, something specific, or something very general, I don’t know. But if whatever you thought of, whatever it was that came to mind, that symbolizes for you happiness, Whatever it is, it symbolizes happiness because basically what we all want is happiness. That’s what we all really, really want. It’s not essential, I don’t think, to define what happiness is because, as I said, we all have our own ideas of what happiness is, and also our ideas of happiness can change, and hopefully during this course your idea of what real happiness will change. When we were very small, very tiny, our ideal of happiness was maybe suckling on our mother’s breast, although in these modern times maybe many of us didn’t have the chance to do that, maybe we just on a bottle, but anyway, that was happiness.
Then it changed from that to something else, playing with rattles, then something else. And as we got older and older, our idea of what happiness is changed, but we we always want happiness. Alright? That’s what we want, nothing less. So then Lama Yeshe, he said, so I will say this, but I can’t do this part as well as he did, he said, To simplify things, I have three kinds of happiness because you’re all so confused, you don’t know what happiness is, so I’ll just simplify it and tell you I have three kinds of happiness, and you can have which one you like.
Okay? So first kind of happiness is really very nice, it’s wonderful, but it has some flaws, some flaws, some faults. There will be some occasional suffering problems, little difficulties from time to time. Little twinges, physical pains in the body from time to time, a little bit of mental unhappiness, maybe you get a tiny bit depressed from time to time, have a few tiny problems, but basically a very nice kind of happiness, And it’s free, and you can have it immediately. That’s one kind of happiness.
Lama Yeshe did this much better, I can’t remember, but he made it really very interesting. Second kind of so you can have that kind of happiness. Second kind of happiness is that, again, it’s actually better than the first kind. It’s better because there will be only very occasionally, very very rarely some minor problem, maybe an occasional pain in the knee, maybe just a moment every now and again, just a moment of sadness, just a moment of sadness or worry will happen. So you could have that kind of happiness.
Third kind of happiness is perfect, pure happiness. There will never be In this happiness, there’s not the slightest flaw, not the slightest physical or mental discomfort at all, at all. It’s perfect happiness. Which one would you like? You get it immediately, remember, free.
It’s totally free. Which one do you want? So you all want the best one, right? Perfect happiness. It’s not possible to want anything less than perfect happiness.
Certainly, if it’s possible, how anyone want less than perfect happiness if it’s actually available? It is utterly impossible for our mind to want less than perfect happiness. Even an insane person wants perfect happiness. Their version of perfect happiness may be a little bit stranger than ours, but even if one is totally demented, one is still wanting perfect happiness. Because anything less than perfect happiness is suffering.
It is unsatisfying, unfulfilling, depressing, frustrating, annoying, disappointing, and a pain in the neck, and we don’t want it. No one wants suffering even for a moment. Even the Buddhas and Bodhisattvas don’t want. Even incredibly brave people don’t want suffering even for a moment. There is nothing good about suffering.
We want perfect happiness. Whether we thought about it or not, instinctively we are seeking perfect happiness. Second question that Lama Yeshe asked is, Okay, how long do you want it for? Do you want it just today, during this meditation course while you’re on Kopan Hill? When you go down to Kathmandu for a few days afterwards?
Would you like it for the rest of this year, for ten years, the rest of this life? Or, if you have some idea of future existence, would you like it for a hundred years after this life, a million years after this life, or for eternity, forever? Would you like it for however long you conceive, you think you will exist? Would you like that perfect happiness to last for as long as you last? I can give it to you, right?
Right now, free, this perfect happiness for as long as you want. How long do you want it? Sorry if I’m going on a long time about this, but this is really a very important thing to think about. How long do you want it for? Anybody for the rest of today?
There is nobody that crazy in this room. Again, if it’s available, we would want it forever. However long we can see forever to be, we want our happiness to be forever. Because if it isn’t forever, it means that when it’s not there, there is suffering, pain, problems, worry, fear, anxiety, stress, disappointment, boredom, confusion, depression, agitation, annoyance. You know, we have millions of adjectives in the English language and I think in every language, so all these things that we do not want, even for one moment, we do not want them.
Okay? Conclusion. Whether we’ve ever thought about it or not, whether we admit it or not, what we all are seeking, and we have always been seeking, is perfect, lasting happiness. That is what we all want, and we will never be satisfied, Can’t ask questions yet. We will never be satisfied until we get it.
So the question arises, can we achieve perfect, lasting happiness? Because probably many of you are thinking, Well, this is just a fantasy. This is just nonsense. I didn’t come to this meditation course to hear this kind of romantic idealistic garbage, perfect lasting happiness. I am a twenty first century realistic, educated person, and this is just nonsense.
But the point is, the Buddha said that perfect, lasting happiness is possible, and it is possible for everyone. Every living being can achieve perfect, lasting happiness. And until we achieve it, we are only experiencing suffering, confusion, anxiety, stress, worry, disappointment, dissatisfaction, a feeling of incompleteness, a sense of inner emptiness. But this perfect, lasting happiness is possible. This course is about how to achieve that perfect lasting happiness because nothing else is worthwhile achieving.
Having achieved that perfect, lasting happiness, what is really wonderful is that we will have the qualities that can show every living being how to achieve that state. There’s nothing better to do in life than to work towards this goal. Everything else is kind of meaningless in comparison, and kind of pointless, and frustrating. So it’s time to take a break. So I’ll try and talk about how it is possible to achieve perfect lasting happiness afterwards.
So we take a ten minute break. So ten minute break please, and we could be back on time at fourteen minutes past. Just before I start again, first two days, the schedule will be a little bit different than when we We won’t start properly the exact schedule until the eighth. We won’t do the meditation this morning because at eleven o’clock Venerable Karen will come and to organize a few things. Also, think tomorrow at eleven Venerable Karen will come also to organize a few things, and then from the next day we’ll start with the morning meditation and everything.
So the question can arise if perfect, lasting happiness is possible, and since, as I said, we’re working towards happiness in every moment of our existence, and everyone has been doing that, then why aren’t we perfectly happy? Why don’t we have this perfect lasting happiness? And the Buddhist answer and the answer with most religions is that we’re not looking in the right place for that happiness. Firstly, as ordinary worldly people controlled by the worldly thought, if we check our life, where are we seeking happiness? The answer is we seek happiness.
Every kind of happiness that we try to achieve, we seek it in the external world. We seek it in something external to ourself, in other people, in relationships with other people, with our family, lovers, in friendships. We seek it in, of course, in wealth, as one of the main ways we seek to be happy in acquiring wealth, in acquiring possessions, in acquiring a reputation, in acquiring power of some kind. It may only be within a small group, but we maybe think by being the most powerful group person in our little social scene, powerful in some way, then this is the way to be happy, or we may want to have power over a whole country or whatever, but we seek it in power. So we seek it in many external things.
We seek it in going to places. If I go here Here, where I am now, I’m unhappy, but if I go there, I will be happy. If I travel, I will be happy. And you travel and travel and travel. Because there’s always must be another place where there’s perfect happiness.
But if we look at all the things that we are relying on right now to experience some kind of happiness, hoping, believing that this will bring about some real happiness in our life, we can discover, if we think about it, and this course will go into this in some detail anyway if you haven’t discovered it, that everything that we rely on for our happiness, security, comfort and so on is impermanent, it changes. Uncontrollably it changes, it doesn’t last. Friendships don’t last, other people don’t last, other people’s bodies don’t last, our own body doesn’t last, power doesn’t last, wealth doesn’t last, possessions don’t last, fame, reputation, they don’t last. They may last for a long time, but they don’t last forever. So you can’t base can’t develop perfect, lasting happiness on something that doesn’t last.
If you want to cook a meal that takes two hours, if your happiness depends on cooking a meal, for that meal, that thing to be really perfect, have to cook it for two hours but you’ve only got a gas bottle with five minutes of gas in it, you’re not gonna be happy. You want a gas bottle with two hours worth of gas in it. One is not going to achieve lasting happiness on things that don’t last, and also if we look at the things that we rely on for perfect lasting happiness, these things aren’t perfect either, they are imperfect, they’re not pure, not reliable. So more about that during the course. But just hopefully, for the time being, maybe you’ll agree with that quick analysis that there’s nothing out there that we can really depend on for lasting, pure, perfect, lasting happiness.
So, if this pure, perfect, lasting happiness is possible, where can we find it? What is the basis for it? And the answer in the Buddha’s teachings, in the Buddhadharma, the answer lies within our mind, that we all have a mind. And pure, lasting happiness can be found within our mind. It is the very potential of our mind to experience perfect, lasting happiness.
It is there all the time. It’s just suppressed at the moment. That potential is there right now. It has always been there and always will be there. It is something indestructible, but it is obscured.
If we eliminate, remove those things obscuring our mind, the very pure, perfect nature of our mind can manifest and manifest completely, and when it does so, we experience pure, perfect, lasting happiness. So, what is the mind? There are many views of what the mind is. We all agree that we have a mind. Everyone talks about the mind, but in talking about it we mean many different things.
In the world now, one of the dominant philosophies or religions in existence is the scientific materialist view that says basically that the mind doesn’t exist. There is a brain. We have a brain, and the brain produces, because of chemical impulses and other things like that, which I don’t know much about, that is good enough to explain what we mean by the mind. The mind is a product or a byproduct of the brain. So the modern scientific materialist view presenting that has enormous amounts of complex, sophisticated arguments and scientific evidence to prove that.
So there is no way this hopelessly uneducated monk can disprove all of that evidence, because I don’t even understand all that scientific jargon anyway. And on the other hand, I don’t even understand or have studied all of the Buddhist views that refute it. So I cannot refute this scientific view, and I can’t prove the Buddhist view. All I can try to do is present it in simple, rough way, and you can think about it and contemplate it, because I think it’s incredibly important to think about. Because if the scientific view is true, that there is not a mind, there is just a brain, and this view may be true, I can’t disprove it, If this view is true, it is the most depressing thing in existence because it means that if there’s just the brain, of course this brain is impermanent, it dies, and then there’s nothing.
There’s absolutely nothing after death. And it also really means that if there’s just this bit of grey stuff in the brain that is the source of everything, life is fundamentally meaningless. We are just kind of soft robots bumping into each other, having some momentary bubbles of experience, pain or pleasure, and then we rot, finished. This is very boring and frustrating and depressing and meaningless. You can only bump into each other so many times and then it gets really boring.
Or bump into trees and bump into this and have a look at that and experience this. And after some time and also just then there is no real reason for any morality in the world. Love and compassion just become conveniences. One is kind to people because it’s convenient to get what you want. Everything becomes totally superficial and everything becomes totally dominated by the self-cherishing thought.
And one can see in societies that have tried to totally eradicate any kind of religious view, you get this kind of mind developing where there’s just me and just the moment. And ultimately that is truly, truly horrific. It is a real nightmare. In our world now, I can only speak as a Westerner, there are some people who aren’t from the Western tradition, so please excuse me, but in Western tradition we have things that have developed such as humanism that reject religion, that talk about love, the importance of love and compassion. But I would argue that the humanist view, even though it rejects religion, has arisen because of religion.
The world has always been until very recent times, all human beings have had some religious view. Every culture has had this. And our culture has had Christianity. Many people have rejected it, but the humanist view about love and compassion arises from it, I think. One can’t conceive of this human world free of religious views.
It never has been free of religious views. There never has been just an abstract idea of love, compassion, selflessness, altruism completely separate from a religious view that there is more than this life. But if you just have a view, this world is moving towards a situation where there is just the view that there is only the brain, we are just this physical organism, and we die, and there’s nothing else. There’s just this life. When that view totally dominates the world, we will have continuous nightmare Because human even humanistic views will die out when that view totally dominates the world.
It may be right, it may be correct, but I really, really hope it’s wrong. I don’t believe it’s true. Because I believe in the mind, I believe the mind exists as the Buddha taught. So the Buddhist view is that mind exists, and the mind that the Buddha talks about, that Buddhism talks about, that the Dharma talks about, is not the brain, and it is not a product of the brain. Certainly, the mind that we experience now works through the brain and it works through the nervous system of this body, but it does not originate with this brain or this nervous system.
It is just temporarily using it. It’s just temporarily trapped in that situation. So I would like to try and talk a little bit about the Buddhist view of what mind is, because if it is true, then it brings with it many, many important consequences to think about for our life. It gives a completely different perspective of what religion and the Buddhadharma is, Because many people think of religion or spirituality as maybe a little bit of icing on the top of life. Either it’s totally unnecessary, something completely irrelevant to life, or it’s something that can make life a little bit more interesting.
But if mind exists the way the Buddha taught, then taking care of the mind in the correct way is utterly, absolutely, totally essential. Because if we don’t, there will only be suffering and pain for ourselves and others. There is no way to experience any kind of happiness, any kind of happiness, without taking care of the mind. This is the Buddhist view. And the more we take care of our mind in the correct way, the more we experience greater and greater happiness, less suffering, until eventually we experience no suffering and we eventually experience pure, lasting happiness.
The definition of mind in the Buddhadharma is very short, but very profound. The definition of mind is that which is clear and knowing. The mind is that which is clear and knowing. Very roughly what this means, the term clear is referring firstly to the fact that the mind is formless. It is not a physical thing.
It is not made up of atoms of any kind, even the most subtle kind of atoms. It is not physical. It is without form. It is insubstantial, but it exists. And because of its existence, everything else exists.
Buddha’s view is, if mind doesn’t exist, nothing exists. Because mind is that which knows, and nothing can exist if there’s nothing to know it. Something cannot exist independently without being known. How can we even posit something exists if we don’t know about it? So the scientific materialist point of view is that even if they admit that there is some kind of mind, they argue that first comes physical matter and then somehow there evolves mind.
The Buddhist view is the complete opposite. I can’t prove it, I can just state it, and we can think about it. The mind is the fundamental thing in the universe. Because of its existence, every other thing arises from that. No mind, no universe.
No mind, no body. It’s not because we’ve got a body that we’ve got a mind, it’s because we’ve got a mind, we have a body. So the mind is not something because it’s not physical, you can’t see it, you can’t hear it, you can’t taste it, you can’t touch it, you can’t smell it, because these are characteristics of physical things. But it does exist. There are some things that we agree exist that we can’t see, taste, smell, touch, or hear.
One of these things that we agree, hopefully we agree, does exist, that you can’t hear, taste, or so on, is space. Space does exist. The definition of space. This gets a little kind of maybe boring or academic or intellectual in some way, but I think it’s worthwhile to think about. Not all of what I’m going to say gets so kind of maybe dry, but I don’t think the mind is a dry topic, it’s amazingly interesting and inspiring.
I don’t know if I can present it in that way, but the definition of space in Buddhism is the mere lack of obstruction. Think about that, the mere lack of obstruction. This glass is physical matter and it has the quality of obstruction. Because it’s here, my physical body, which also has a quality of obstructability, cannot go beyond. It is obstructed by this physical substance.
All physical substance has the quality of obstructing. Space is the mere lack of obstruction. And because of the existence of space, things which have the quality of obstruction are able to exist. Here, there’s this solid physical theme, I cannot put this this, this solid obstructing phenomena there because there is already a solid obstructing phenomena here. Remove it.
I can place this physical obstructing phenomena there because there is a lack of obstruction there. This lack of obstruction is not just an abstract concept created by human minds, it is an existing reality. Which with my feeble jokes I always say that even cows and chickens know about. If you’ve ever kept a cow, they’re very good at finding holes in fences. They find the mere lack of obstruction.
If you’ve ever kept chickens, they also are very good at finding a mere lack of obstruction which to go through. It is not just an abstract human concept, it is an existing reality. It is there, but it’s not something you can taste or touch or take home. It simply exists, and it performs a vital function. Without space, all physical phenomena could not exist.
Alright? First point. Second point, space is not created. You never there is nothing that creates space. It simply exists.
It is a mere lack of obstruction. Nobody ever created it. It is just simply existing. If I take this obstructing phenomena away, I haven’t created any space. The space is always there.
The glass hasn’t destroyed the space, it is simply occupying that. It is there where there is the lack of obstruction. So two very interesting things about space which actually exists is that you cannot create it. It has never ever been created. It has always, always existed.
There is not one point in time when space has not existed, it’s always existed. And the other terrific thing about space is you can’t destroy it. It is indestructible. You can’t chop it up, slice it, bruise it, damage it, harm it, blow it to smithereens. You can only do that with physical phenomena.
You can you can drop a bomb in this in this place. It will not destroy the space. It’s just there. There’s this this mere lack of obstruction. That is the quality of formless phenomena.
So why am I going on like this about boring old space? Because mind is like space, It is formless. It exists. If we agree that space exists, but we can’t see it or taste or touch it, it simply exists. It’s forms, but it exists.
Mind is the same, it is not physical, it is formless, but it really exists. Well, this is the Buddhist view. I can’t prove this, but this is the mind we are talking about in Buddhism. We all agree we have a mind, but we make the mistake of identifying with our mind as something produced by the brain. But what if it’s not?
If it’s produced by the brain, we don’t have to worry. We can go out and kill, rape, rob, steal, do anything we like, and just make sure we don’t get caught. But if there is a mind, then there’s lots of things to be concerned with. I’ll elaborate that later on, but the mind is exactly like space in that it is formless, and like space, like formless space, it hasn’t been created. Nothing created it.
It has always existed. Why does today’s mind exist? Because of yesterday’s mind. Because of the continuity from yesterday’s mind. Why does yesterday’s mind exist?
Because of the continuity from the day before us. Why does this year’s mind exist? Because of the continuity from last year’s mind. Why does the mind of this life exist? Because of the continuity from the mind before this life, from last life’s mind.
The continuity arising moment by moment. And why does life’s mind exist? Because of the continuity from the mind before that. And then you go back, and you go back, and you go back, and you go back. And you can take a toilet roll, and you can write one and count countless zeros on that millions and billions and billions of years back.
And you could take another toilet roll and add more zeros and another toilet roll, and you will never there’s still endless time sorry, beginningless time. And before that, however much time we can imagine in the past, go back and back, one can always imagine a moment before. And in that moment before, mind existed, and in the moment before that, the mind existed, and in the moment before that, the mind existed. Because it’s formless. Very hard to believe, but worthwhile thinking about.
I can’t prove it, I wouldn’t even try. Well, will try later on. We’ve been a few things from time to time. Also, what is even more interesting is that because mind is formless, it’s indestructible. You can’t blow it up, you can’t chop it into pieces just like space, you can’t bruise it, damage it, take a part away.
It just goes on and on and on and on, indestructible, like space. You can’t destroy space, you can’t destroy mind. It is formless. This is one of the proofs why it’s beginningless. Because if it keeps going on, if it’s indestructible, then after this life, the mind must go on.
So if there’s another life after this life, there must have been a life before this life. That’s logical. If space is indestructible and mind is formless
Key terms in this teaching
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.