31 min · 1,941 words · 1994 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Khensur Rinpoche opens this 32-minute commentary by tackling a specific obstacle in mind training: our instinct to treat strangers with indifference. Using careful reasoning — that in countless past lives every being has both helped and harmed us equally — he argues that distinguishing friends, enemies, and neutral people reflects confused rather than wise thinking. He illustrates equanimity’s foundational role with a vivid image: block the source of a river and nothing flows downstream; neglect equanimity and bodhicitta cannot arise. He then corrects a common Western misconception that compassion is merely attachment in disguise, arguing genuine compassion must be grounded in equanimity first. The session closes with step-by-step instruction on the “all beings as mother” meditation, beginning with one’s own mother of this life before extending the recognition outward to every sentient being.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 10 GS 1994 Easter.mp3
UUID: 86e066d8-43d6-4b3f-bbc7-5abfe04e9f94
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: The Great Scope (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 1994 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 31.7 minutes
Words: ~1,937
On those two ways of transforming cause. To the neutral person then one thinks in this way that presently I seem to consider this person with negligence, indifference, leaving behind, on the basis that the person in this life apparently haven’t harmed me nor inflicted nor helped me. But yet, like my parents and relatives and those who have helped me in this life, equally this person as well in many lifetimes, on many occasions in the past, being my parents, relatives, and people who have helped me. So in this way one first developed a kind of no need to be indifferent on the basis of not having helped. And now one looks at the other way, that there had also in the past been equally times where the person has, like the other case in the case of enemy, that this person as well has inflicted harm on me many times, killed me, and so forth.
So in a way, one then thinks that these all three types of beings are not to be seen with any difference at all because they all if if help has been rendered to me, then they all have helped me. If harms have been inflicted on me, then all three have inflicted harm on me. There’s no need. It’s not right to be attached or or with anger to one or another. There is it is not right to harbor attachment and anger against any of these three types of beings.
In this way, make one’s thought level and apply one’s thought thinking. Because of such reasoning, if one considers these three with certain difference and hold attachment hatred, then it is a way of thinking of people who don’t have brain, people who don’t have wisdom to think in the right way. So with all these sorts of applying the right reason, one then tried to develop an equal attitude to all three. This needs to be meditated for long duration because obviously it is no doubt easy. They do take long duration of meditative familiarization.
So one needs to think over it again, meditate over it again, apply reasoning again and again, and then it will become possibly strong state of one’s thinking that that is really so. In this way, is necessary to again and again repeatedly familiarize in consistent manner. And then one will come to the conclusion that all sentient beings of any of the three groups are equal, that they all equally have been kind to me, have all equally been of harm to me. There’s no reason to be of any different attitude from my side. Following that, then one makes the thinking that all three types of sentient beings have been my parents, father and mother, brothers, sisters, wife, husband, all they all have been one time or another in the past been kind to me in this way.
Through this way, one maintain an equal attitude to all to all three. And through this all equal attitude, one stops attachment and hatred, the discriminative of attachment of hatred towards the three. Now this is extremely important and it needs again very repeated familiarization to make it a very strong basis. Once if that thought or equanimity free of attachment and hatred is developed, then it is possible for all the subsequent realization on the remaining of the thought development in this generating of precious mind to become possible. If that part is not done properly, then it is like the blockage in the very source.
For example, if we a source of water from which we need the water to flow down, either an irrigation system or whatever circumstances it be. If the water is blocked from the very source, then obviously there will be no flow down the plane and so forth. It has to be cleared from the very beginning of the source. Similarly, in the case of context, meaning the bodhicitta mind of enlightenment is like at the very end, which depend on each of the preceding training in the mental development, which had all to be started from the part of equanimity. When that is developed, then it won’t be, what’s called not that extremely difficult to develop the following after that.
In this way, yes, it is as extremely important as that And one needs to look at all three types with equal attitude. Oh, one has then developed the equanimity free of attachment of hatred where one’s attitude is one with reference to all types of sentient beings. Now when that is developed that itself is not enough. Next is one has to develop loving kindness and delightful loving kindness. What delightful loving kindness means is one needs to first see not only the sentient beings are to be seen as one, but they have to be seen as a delightful, dear, and dear, cherishable, and destitute.
What what does that mean is that they are dear or cherishable because they being tormented by suffering. And they are destitute because they are destitute or deprived, naturally deprived at the present, destitute or deprived deprived of happiness. So one sees them as delightfully cherishable and destitute. And through that way one has to develop delightful, loving kindness. It is not enough to remain only on the equanimity level.
One has to go next to that stage. Now the delightfulness which comes about from having developed equanimity is the genuine delightfulness, meaning sentient beings appearing as delightful. That is genuine vision, outlook of others being considered as delightful. That is a genuine one. What generally we see others as delightful, likeable is not a genuine delightfulness because when we when we our partners, friends, relatives, people we seem to consider as likable, there is a delightfulness that they seem to appear to you and you like them, but that’s not genuine.
In that case it is a delightfulness of attachment. It is not genuine delightfulness from one’s side. Now the real delightfulness has to be one based on having developed equanimity, and that delightfulness is synonymous with loving kindness. Now here in the West, people talk about compassion is no different than attachment. Compassion is no different than clinging on to attached.
Well, there is these talks being raised, but it is a talk of not having understood the actual nature of what that compassion in the practice is being described as about because compassion is a thought preceded by equanimity as just now described. What generally people say are compassion in the sense of sympathy for others and so forth without equanimity as a basis. That’s not the genuine one. It is more something based on lust, attachment, and others similar group sort of attitude when one to one’s partners and so forth. Therefore, genuine compassion is something which is based on having developed the thought of equanimity, and people seem to have misunderstood that point.
Therefore, equanimity is extremely powerful in developing compassion, loving kindness, and thought, wanting to benefit others. In a way, it is then extremely powerful thought. To be able to develop the attitude of sentient beings being delightful, cherishable, and destitute, one needs to firstly ascertain that sentient beings, whoever are the finest of one’s dear ones, the ultimate of one’s dear ones, the most dear ones, because unless one establishes, unless one finally comes to the conclusion that all sentient beings are the most dear ones to oneself, it is not possible to have the attitude and the thought seeing sentient beings as a delightful, cherishable, and destitute of happiness, that is not that’s not possible. Now in order to develop that delightful, cherishable, and destitute attitude towards sentient beings, one needs to first establish the fact that sentient beings are most dear ones. They are the dearest of all.
Now, who is and who are the most dearest of all? In worldly convention and in world, it is considered that mother is the dearest of all. There is no other being who is more dear than one’s mother. In that way, mother is considered the dearest of beings. Well, now in this way, one has to meditate on the fact that all beings are dearest.
Dearest. In that way, all beings are like all beings are mothers, as mother is the dearest of all. Now how dear a mother is? She dear has the connotation not separate from kindness on an interpretive note. So how dear she is as well she is dear because she is the kindest of all that in the beginning she carried us in her womb for all those months, bore pain and so forth, and then in brief what we now stand as a human matured matured and grown is what she has made us into as a person by looking after nurturing and so forth.
In this way, such way of thinking mother as dearest and kind est, one shifts the meditation thinking all sentient beings are one’s mother. When one does that, then one thinks all sentient beings as dearest. When meditation is done then that brings automatically the delightful loving kindness, the resultant thought, the delightful loving kindness. Now the the question, how should one meditate that all sentient beings are one’s mother? That is done as answer that is done in this way where first one starts with one’s mother of this life.
By keeping in one’s meditation one’s mother of this life in front of oneself, meaning in meditation, and then think about how one has been nurtured by her since infancy and before that in womb, and in brief how I, as a human, now grown up as I am, is due to her nourishing. One comes to the conviction that in this life she has been my mother. Now there must like this life there must have been in the previous life, there must been occasion that she had been my mother. And like that in the past, in the past, untraceable, there has been countless times that she has been my mother equally as now. In this way one comes to the proving that she must have been one’s mother countless times.
Similarly one thinks about the sentient being on the right whom one thinks that that sentient being as we must have a mother in the past and similarly mother in the past. Likewise, one similar reasoning that like this mother of this life, this person or sentient beings being as well, countless times, been my mother in the past, dating back to life and life before and before. And same to the person on the left, that that person, like my mother of this life, has been many times in the past been my mother, in brief, come to the belief, come to the understanding through these reasonings that all sentient beings equally equally been my mother. In this way, one in relation to this life’s mother, one then brings about the understanding that all sentient beings must have been one’s mother and meditate on all sentient beings as one’s mother. Now it might be wondered how is it possible for sentient beings to have been one’s mother.
Well, that can be come to understood by going through the analysis about the continuous flow our mind has been coming. For example, our present mind as an adult has been a mind continuously coming in flow from the mind when we were a child and that preceding at the time when we conceived in mother’s womb and that the mind at that state.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.