51 min · 2,755 words · 8 June 1997
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches the contemplation of impermanence in its coarse and subtle forms, using reasoning about the smallest components of time and matter. It then covers the general characteristics of impermanence, suffering, emptiness and selflessness applied to the body and feelings, and the specific characteristics of the four elements and of mind. It closes by contrasting the common and uncommon manners of meditating mindfulness of the body in the hearer and universal vehicles.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 52 min
UUID: 0eacb0bc-e898-4c85-b413-360bb5d92143
Date: 1997-06-08
Words: 2,751
That is the nirvana is peace. So, in this first characteristic, all compounded phenomena are impermanent. By compounded phenomena, we mean phenomena which arise as a compounding of causes and conditions. Through coming together of causes and conditions, a phenomenon is produced. So all that is produced out of a compounding or coming together or collecting together of of causes and conditions is impermanent.
So whatever is a compounded phenomena is necessarily impermanent. And by impermanent, we mean momentarily arising and disintegrating. So first a compounded phenomena arises, that is to say it comes into creation, and it disintegrates. It is destroyed. So with regard to impermanence, there are two levels, coarse and subtle impermanence.
What we mean by coarse impermanence would be, for example, the death of a person, or the collapse of a house, the breaking of a cup, or the wearing out of clothes. These would all be examples of coarse impermanence. We don’t need to think a great deal about that. We can actually see that for ourselves. When we we talk about something being coarse and something being subtle, generally this implies that that which is coarse is easy to realize, whereas the subtle is difficult to realize, so subtle impermanence is difficult to realize.
So for those who for those who are ordinary individuals in this context, that would mean that one who has not realized subtle impermanence previously, and is seeking to newly, or freshly realize subtle impermanence, it’s necessary that they employ a process of reasoning, that by means of examination, using pramāna cognition, and the process of reasoning, using the signs of impermanence, one can come to a new understanding. But the initial new realization of subtle impermanence necessarily requires that we use a process of reasoning. So how are we to proceed in contemplating subtle impermanence? Well, in terms what is minutest component? The minutest the smallest component of, for example, time, looking at what that is, the smallest interval of time in terms of form, the smallest particle, in terms of building block of which these are built or made out of.
In terms of name or language, the building blocks would be letters. For example, A, B, C’s or in Tibetan, it would Those are the building blocks of the components which build these more complex components. We can look at the minutest, the smallest component of time, of form, the various particles, atoms, for example, and in terms of language, the letters. So, for example, in terms of language, what the word is here is names, but perhaps we can think of it in terms of language. The smallest component is letters.
A language does not consist of a letter, but it is developed out of combining letters to form words and to form names. So the component that is, it’s built out of letters. The same holds true for form, or the things about us. These large, mass of things about us are built out of small particles, so a combination of particles builds up into large forms. Time, there are various structures of time.
For example, years, there’s months, and we can work down to hours and minutes, and these are all built out of the smallest durations of time. For example, to give you an idea of what the smallest duration of time would be, that there are 65 moments within the 65 of these durations of time, or 65 of these moments within the time of a snap of a finger. So the finger snap is regarded as the smallest interval for an activity, and within this activity, and even over the duration of the smallest activity in terms of its time that it takes, there are 65 of these moments or intervals of time. Can begin to appreciate how very minute are these components, these smallest components, which build up into time. So this is what subtle impermanence is referring to, one of the smallest durations of time, is one sixty fifth of the time of a finger snap.
So just as, you know, when look at the time on our watch, that the time never stands still, that it never, even for the slightest, briefest of possible time span, it never remains the same. Likewise, that immediately upon our birth, that we are undergoing this subtle impermanence. That from the very first moment to the second moment, we have not remained the same, to the third moment, that there is no remaining the same even from these minutest of time spans. So there’s a great deal of benefit in to be realized in terms of our Dharma practice. There’s a great deal of benefit in our in terms of our Dharma practice if by realizing impermanence.
Now as to the causes of creation and disintegration of an object, there is, within our own tradition, is held that once having come into existence, no other cause is needed for an object to disintegrate. That the very cause of creation is itself cause for an object’s destruction, that no other cause is needed. But there are other traditions which hold, for example, we’ll take the example of a cup, that in order to destroy the cup it’s necessary that there be another cause. For example, we take a stone and we smash the cup, we destroy the cup, and therefore another cause has to be introduced in order for disintegration to take place. But in our own tradition we say, No, in fact, in order for, at the level of subtle impermanence, for the disintegration to take place, no other cause needs to be introduced.
Its cause of coming into being created is necessary cause for it to go out of existence through its disintegration. So in meditating the subtle impermanence of the body, we we should try to understand that in in the very second moment, the body is disintegrating, that it does not remain the same even for another moment, but even that from moment to moment, it is disintegrating. So what is what is the reason that we we can supply establishing that the body is impermanent? The reason that we give is because it is causally created. So this is the reason set forth by Dharmakīrti, when he says, Why is the body impermanent?
That is, say, in terms of subtle impermanence, because it’s causally created. By causelessly, it means it does not need another cause. It is created from its own cause, and that very cause leads to its going out of existence. So why is impermanence and suffering a general characteristic with regard to the body? Because it applies to all bodies, not only our own bodies and bodies of others, that bodies in general are impermanent and suffering.
Why do we cultivate this understanding in order to overcome our holding the body as permanent. We have a wrong conception which holds that the body is permanent. Conception, and this holding the body as permanent is overcome by realizing its impermanence. So this as was mentioned in the teachings on lojong, or mind training, that it was this conception of that I’m not going to die today, I’m not going to die, and when that day comes, I’m not going to die today. This constant thinking that one is not going to die today, that is to say, which is holding oneself as being permanent, is said to be the root of all our inappropriate conduct, and is a great obstacle to our practice of Dharma.
So then secondly, the characteristic of suffering. Why is the body in nature of suffering? The body is not under its own control. It is other-powered, that is to say, it is under the influence it exists under the influence of karma and afflictive emotions that we that we, the body, is generated, or is born out of karma and afflictive emotions. So what is it that that that understanding stops or blocks?
This is in order to stop stop the conception that the body is pure and is happy is a is a source of happiness. So, is it that this understanding is able to stop the conception of holding the body as pure. If we look at how the body comes into existence, it arises from the combining of impure or unclean substances. The ovum and sperm of our parents unite, and then through the force of karma and afflictive emotions, our consciousness enters into this combination. Consciousness enters into the combination of sperm and ovum, and this constitutes our, the sperm and ovum constitutes our body, and so can we say that the source of our body is clean or unclean.
And we are bound by afflictive emotions and karma, and the body is bound by karma and afflictive emotions, and therefore can we say that the body is a source of happiness? Someone were to someone else were to tie you up with a rope, would would would you be happy tied up? So here, we are trying to bring an end to the conception of the body as pure and as happiness. So then we apply the characteristic of being empty to the body, This is done in order to overcome the assertion of other tenet systems or philosophic systems which hold that the body is not empty. How is how is it that they are able to refute these those assertions?
The the the other tenet systems hold that the self is permanent. Is. So how does this understanding of applying the characteristic of being empty to the body overcome this perception of a permanent self, this assertion of a permanent self. That first, that the self is not permanent, because it is impermanent. It is impermanent because it’s continually being generated and disintegrating from moment to moment.
Momentary arising and disintegration of the self is a mark of impermanence. The assertion of the other tenet system is that the self has no parts, its existence does not rely upon parts, but in fact that the self relies upon its parts, that the self relies upon its parts. The assertion of the other tenet system is that the self and the aggregates are different entities, But in fact, the the self and the aggregates are the same entity. They are one entity. So then it’s necessary that we establish that the selflessness in terms of the body, and then to overcome the conception of the self of persons, that it is due to the conception of the true existence of persons that we accumulate karma, and due to the accumulation of karma that we continue to circle within cyclic existence.
So, selflessness is to be understood in order to overcome the conception of self with regard to the person. And here the conception of self, or the existence of a self, the self which is to be refuted here, is a self in which which is independent, does not rely upon the five aggregates or the continuum of the five aggregates. That such a self does not exist. That this self, which exists independent and does not rely upon the five aggregates or the continuum of the five aggregates does not exist. So these characteristics of impermanence, suffering, empty, and selfless are general characteristics since they apply to all phenomena.
So then is the analysis of these of body’s feelings, consciousnesses. Now follows an analysis of the body in terms of specific characteristics. The specific characteristics are the individual entities of the body, feelings, etcetera. These are the uncommon characteristics of each of these. For example, the body, the feelings, etcetera, they have specific or uncommon characteristics, and as was mentioned yesterday, in terms of the specific characteristics of the body, that would be the four elements, the earth element, fire, earth, fire, water, and wind energy along with the evolutes, those which arise out of combination of these elements.
So the body is composed of combination of elements and evolutes. For example, if we look to our body, which arises out of a combination of sperm and ovum, actually it’s more literal here to say the blood and substances. For example, our flesh arises from the blood of our mother, whereas our bones and skin arise from the substance of our father. There are other various constituents such as the channels, etc, but we don’t need to go into that. This is the mode of or the manner of meditating the specific characteristics of the body.
If we went on like this and talked about all the parts of the body and what constitutes the body, we would probably get a good laugh out of it. So then we can apply these general characteristics in the same way to feelings. We apply these characteristics of impermanent suffering, emptiness and selflessness in the same way to feeling. So with regard so we are to meditate both the general and specific characteristics to each of these, including the feelings, and the specific characteristic of feeling is that of experience. So a happy feeling is a happy experience, or pleasurable feeling is a pleasurable experience.
An unpleasurable feeling is an unpleasurable experience. A neutral feeling is a neutral experience. So the specific characteristic of feeling experience. So with regard to the mind, specific characteristic of the mind, or to say the uncommon characteristic, is that of being a knower. That a mind is a subject observing objects, so it takes objects and knows them.
This is the specific characteristic, the quality of being a knower. So, with regard to the specific characteristics of phenomena, there are a great many, and because there are a great many phenomena within this category, for example, all the various mental factors, are 51 mental factors, for example, then there are non associated compositional factors, and then there are unproduced phenomena. So each of these, according to which of these are taken as your object of observation, then you would have to determine particular entity. Each would have its own specific characteristics according to each its own entity. So this manner of meditation is common to both the individual vehicle and the universal vehicle.
We said that there were two manners of meditation, that which was common and uncommon, and what was meant by uncommon manner of meditation was that which is exclusive to the universal vehicle. With regard to the exclusive manner of meditation, of meditating the close placement of mindfulness, there are three characteristics. That of oh, yeah. Here it is. Objects of observation, mental engagement, and attainment.
So these are exclusive characteristics of the mode of meditating in terms of the universal vehicle, objects of observation, mental engagement, and attainment. So the difference between these two manners of meditation is that whereas the individual vehicle would take as its object of observation, for example, the body, it would be analyzed in terms of both its general and specific characteristics, but it would only In terms of the body, it would be only the body of the practitioner him or herself. But in the case of the manner of meditation within the universal vehicle, the body, you know, analyzed both in terms of general and specific characteristics, be both the bodies of oneself and others. Then the second exclusive manner of meditation is that of mental engagement. This means that in terms of the general characteristic of selfless, the common mode of meditation was that we understand the selflessness in terms of selflessness of persons.
So we went through these various objects of body, etc, in terms of selflessness of persons, but the exclusive manner of meditation of universal vehicle. Here, the selfless is not only the selfless of the person, but it also includes the selflessness of phenomena. Then the third uncommon quality of the, this third quality of the uncommon manner of meditation is that of attainment. The hearer seeks, through his meditating, the close placements of mindfulness, freedom from the contaminated body and the attainment of an uncontaminated body, whereas in the exclusive manner of meditation of the universal vehicle, the practitioner is seeking to attain the unsurpassed, passage beyond sorrow, that is to say, Buddhahood. So there is a difference in results of practice, since there is a difference in motivation for engaging in the practice between the hearers and solitary realizers on the one hand, and the bodhisattva on the other.
Then the reasons for meditating.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- tenet system drubtha(Tib)
- A general term for a religious and/or philosophical system, whether Buddhist or non-Buddhist. It is often used as shorthand to refer to the four major Buddhist tenet systems that emerged from India. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.