1 h 2 min · 8,663 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 62-minute seminar, Ilia Durovic recapitulates the three principal aspects of the Buddhist path and introduces Buddha Śākyamūni’s teachings from the Udānavarga, a collection of his direct words. Durovic opens with a penetrating comparison between Western and Eastern civilizations: the West has pursued mastery of the material world for twenty-five centuries, creating extraordinary technological achievement but now facing ecological collapse, antibiotic resistance, and financial instability. Eastern traditions, by contrast, have focused on training the mind to manage experience rather than control the outer world. He argues that a hybrid approach is realistic for modern practitioners. The core teaching centres on definite emergence, the fundamental Buddhist mental transformation that begins with renouncing attachment to this life through meditation on death and impermanence. Durovic emphasizes that this foundation is more important than advanced practices like emptiness meditation, and illustrates its power through personal stories of encountering death and dead bodies. He then explores how karma works across multiple lives and addresses the question of religious commitment, noting that the Dalai Lama does not encourage Western conversion without genuine conviction. The seminar is pitched at serious practitioners willing to examine whether Buddhist teachings can work for their own lives.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 19112016Ilia Seminar part1 3 – IS.mp3
UUID: 94583159-f5eb-4a24-82f4-74743c976f14
Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic
Collection: Ilia Seminars
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~8,658
Welcome everybody to the final in our series with Ilya The three principal aspects of the path. It’s great to see you all here and welcome to our guests. Everybody else here knows Ilya and as we know we’re very privileged to have Ilya being the conduit to us for us loud speaker if you like for Geshe-la every week. As you know, we’ll have a short break for cup of tea and because I’m sure there’ll be a lot to get through you’ll be able to bring your tea or coffee into the Gompa just please don’t spill it. So yes, without further ado, I’ll hand over to you, Ilya.
Thank you. Thank you very much, Chris. It’s a pleasure to see you all here today. As Chris said so rightly, this is the last conference of the year. And as a result, and to thank you all for the effort you have made, I have a small present for you.
It’s a Christmas present. No, Chris. It’s not an exam. Because I told Chris that maybe Geshe-la will give you a Christmas present in the form of a small exam on the last class of the year. But, you know, I try not to spring those things on you because we are all sensitive.
We have weak hearts, you know. So I thought we would recapitulate the three principles of the path and then I thought it would be very nice at the end of the year to read actually what Buddha Śākyamūni taught. So I translated for you a series of passages from what is known sometimes as the Tibetan Dharmapada. It’s the Udānavarga. I’ll tell you a bit later what it is and we’ll try to see how to put these words, these are the words of Buddha himself in practice in our lives and how they relate to the three principles of the path.
But first, I wanted to recapitulate a little bit. And since I see that we have some new students, I think it would make sense to start pretty close to the source and to try to understand what exactly dharma is. And here we have to try to understand a very fundamental distinction between Western and Eastern civilization or Asian civilization, at least until recently. The roots of this one are very far in the past. I mean, you have to go back easily 25, 30 centuries.
But basically, Western civilization, and this is Greco Roman civilization, and the Jewish heritage we all have from our Christian background, and this would also include within Western civilization, Muslim civilization, considers the outer world to be real, physically real, solid, and considers that our destiny lies in the interaction with this outer world which is real. As a result, there is a focus on learning how to do material things. This is at the root of what became known as Western science. As you know, scientia in Latin means knowledge, and technology is a very interesting term. Techne in Greek means a craft, and logos means science.
It’s a science of doing things. Western civilization is rooted in this. The idea that human happiness and human destiny is fulfilled through control of the material world. And this is true but only true to a degree. I mean all of us in this room have marvelous conditions.
I can talk to you with a loudspeaker because basically Western scientists developed these technologies. We can say, and I express my apologies to our Asian students for putting it this bluntly, that science and technology are Western creations. Mathematics, physics, chemistry, biology, more recently electronics, molecular biology, these are Western sciences. It is only now that they have spread to Asia and the Asians come to our school to start to learn how to do this. The best Chinese students go to America until recently.
Think now in China things are changing a bit, you know. So why is this the case? Simply because for 25 centuries, and especially the last five centuries since the Reformation, and more specifically since the end of the eighteenth century, the totality of the focus of Western civilization has been on domination of matter. And if you want to find the roots of this in religion, in Western religions, you find this in the Old Testament, the very first verses of the Hebrew Bible of Genesis, which read in Hebrew In the beginning, God created the earth and the heavens. And somewhat later on the text, God makes man the intendant of heaven and earth.
This is in the background of the totality of the Western worldview. The idea, therefore, which all of us in this room deep down share, that if something goes wrong, seriously wrong in our lives, it has to be addressed materially. Then there are very major limitations to this worldview, but we’ve only recently become aware of them. For instance, in our pursuit of domination of this earth, we have created a situation where we are turning the environment we live in into something which is toxic. We are actually responsible for the destruction of many of the life forms on this earth and species.
It is, anthropo paleologists consider that we are in the sixth extinction at present because of the collapse of the number of life forms. All of us take for granted extraordinarily high levels of medical care. These levels of medical care are seen as the rock foundation of our happiness. And while it is often very difficult to raise funds for a Buddhist temple, is very easy to raise funds for a hospital. No one ever protests.
Medical care is taken for granted. Then one of the biggest advances which changed the way every one of us in this room lives is the discovery of antibiotics. My father was trained as a surgeon before antibiotics. He got his medical degree in the late twenties. And he was introduced to antibiotics at the end of World War II as a practicing doctor.
And he told me it was a revolution. We could do things, he said, I could never do before. It was just too dangerous. Now we have entered the post antibiotic age. I just read today in the BBC that forms of pneumonia which are resistant both to carbapenems and colistin, which are the last ditch antibiotics, exist throughout the South Of Europe.
Basically from France through Spain, Italy all the way down to Romania. Now once we reenter into the world of pneumonia, of tuberculosis, of gonorrhea, once we enter into a post antibiotic world where minor surgical interventions become impossible, in other words, most of us in this room can probably say goodbye to hip replacement surgery, knee replacement surgery and most forms of intervention against cancer because chemotherapy depresses the immune system and is only possible with very high levels of antibiotic support. Most of us in this room will be facing an old age which will once again, as it was in the nineteenth century, be marked by infectious diseases. You have all heard of MRSA, you know the flesh eating bacteria, it takes one scratch. Right?
Now these are the limitations we encounter through trying to control the exterior world. There are other limitations on the financial front. Many of us in this room are on the receiving end of the aftermath of the GFC, the collapse or near collapse of the world’s financial system in 2008. The issues have not been settled. We are still dealing with a potential banking crisis on the horizon, maybe as early as next year.
And we’re dealing with a crisis of sovereign debt, with state debt. Sovereign debt is the last ditch, the last fortification. Once you put in question sovereign debt, if you ask an economist what is left, there’s only two things left, gold and silver. Once government debt becomes open to doubt, nothing is left. So we can see therefore the limitations of the world we are entering in and it is precisely for this reason, because we as Westerners have bet the house, the car, and maybe our children on such a future, that it is very interesting to look at an alternative model for happiness and this comes to us from Asia.
And when I say Asia, it is really Asia up to the eighteenth century, you know, specifically India. So this model of happiness is rooted in the reality of India twenty five centuries ago, which was that there was no control over the exterior environment. You had no control over disease, no control over poverty, no control over famine, no control over pain or suffering. As a result, when one deals with the experience of happiness or suffering, there are two components, if you wish. There is the world out there and there is a precipitant, the person who experiences this.
Now, you can either try to control the world out there or you can try to control the experience. As Westerners, I think our civilization has, as I told you, been built under control of the world out there. And overall, it has been an extraordinary achievement. We now see the downside. Much of traditional Asian society was built on the control of the mind.
In other words, control of what experiences the world out there because the world out there could not be controlled. And I would put it to you that this is extremely important for us in general because it’s a compromise between these two approaches, which is a realistic approach to human happiness. Retiring in a hermitage in Bhutan is not a realistic approach to human happiness for ninety nine point nine nine percent of people. No one in this room will last. On the other hand, forgetting any type of mental training and focusing exclusively on money and health is again not realistic because it carries in itself the seeds of its own destruction.
So a hybrid, a compromise, is a realistic approach for our future as human beings. In this country, in America, in Europe and this is where I think the great teachings of ancient Asia and specifically those of the Buddha which are focused on mental training are so important for us. Specifically those of the Buddha because what is very interesting in Buddha Śākyamūni as a thinker is that Buddha Śākyamūni was basically a scientific thinker. Buddha Śākyamūni was empirical in his approach. You can say in many senses of the term that Buddhism is not a religion, but more a philosophy.
As his holiness always says, there is Buddhist science, Buddhist philosophy, and Buddhist religion. Probably the most important component is Buddhist philosophy. Then in Buddhist countries, Buddhism is lived as a religion undeniably. Whether Buddha Śākyamūni will be happy with what he saw about that, I don’t know. So I was would go frequently to Chinese temples when I was a major.
You see people going like this, right, with the sticks. Right? And I often thought my goodness what would Buddha think if he saw that? I think he would scold them myself. I think that a big scolding, you know.
Because the core of Buddha’s message is training the mind, training the recipient of experience to eliminate suffering. And the Buddhist claim is it’s possible to eliminate the totality of suffering in this way. Now whether that is true or not, we have to investigate. But this is why Āryadeva said in his famous passage I’ve shown to you a couple of times, the high suffer in their minds or the simple suffer in their flesh. Daily is this world overcome by these true sufferings.
Āryadeva is saying that the world is overcome by suffering, but the poor suffer physically through hunger, disease, poverty and the rich suffer mentally. And certainly if we take the case of most Australians who by global standards are very rich, Australians suffer mentally. There’s great mental suffering largely because of unrealistic expectations and the incapacity to accept failure. To accept that expectations are not always fulfilled, sometimes they simply aren’t. Then, this quote is quite interesting for us because it provides a path for human development.
The poor suffer in their flesh, and the solution for this is scientific development, material development. When you’re dealing with someone who is hungry you have to give them food. I’m not quite sure Dharma is terribly beneficial to them in that state. The high suffer in their minds, their Dharma is of benefit. Dharma referring to this process of mental training which Buddhism perhaps is the foremost exponent of.
It is precisely this we have been trying to cover. So Australia has been spared the worst of the GFC since 02/2009. It’s in the last two years, especially in this country, that I just as a translator in a Buddhist center have started to see a very big impact of the GFC on our students, largely through the cuts and benefits. Australians are one of the most privileged societies in the world at that level. To be an Australian is to take for granted that the government is gonna help you out with a check.
Right? Then that has had to change. And that change has been very painful for students who are not accustomed to any type of hardship. So we have seen in the last two years at TBI a steady stream of students with mental problems. I mean, there’s been a steady stream of hospitalizations, students who are basically controlling bipolar disorder with drugs, students with nervous depression.
In every single case, that is what I find a bit sad, the student basically relies on medicine to control a mental situation. Now this is a clear sign of lack of dharma. Hardship comes. Then, if one is unable to control one’s mind when hardship comes that means there’s really no dharma in the mind. So the first strategy to deal with this new world we are entering to in which, take my word for it, there will be levels of hardship you cannot begin to imagine.
We are returning to the world of my father’s childhood. It will not be possible to solve all the problems through scientific research, through funding, through the because the money is simply no longer there. A large number of my friends have been fired from universities, lost their jobs. The axe is being swung. The same thing I believe, Chris, is true in the medical profession in Australia.
The same thing is true in the banks. The same thing is true in government. Well, the good old days are over. Alright? So, all you can still breathe is the time to learn something about mental control.
Because when you’re thinking, it’s late. It’s too late, actually. So before one starts thinking, one has to learn how to subdue the mind, how to think differently. And in this respect, Buddhism has 25 of experience. Then it’s up to you whether you choose to become Buddhist or not.
His Holiness of Dalai Lama does not encourage the religious conversion of Westerners, largely because more often than not it fails. We had a case just a couple of weeks ago. Someone took Avalokiteśvara initiation after studying Buddhism for almost a year here. So took what? Refuge, Bodhisattva vows, Avalokiteśvara initiation.
And three weeks later, we got a postcard, a whole very sweet postcard, Hormuz postcard. I’m terribly sorry. I’m no longer a Buddhist. And this has been happening regularly. Right?
So this is a clear sign of a lack of stability among many of our students, and therefore, a more realistic approach, instead of converting to Buddhism is to first see what of Buddhism we can use in our lives. And then if really deep down we feel that we can take the Buddhist worldview on, then we can become sincere Buddhists. Otherwise, it is harmful for everyone concerned. It’s harmful for the spread of the teachings. It’s very harmful for the reputation of Western students which has really collapsed in my lifetime in thirty years.
And it’s harmful for the students themselves because they take pledges, commitments, vows and at the end of it all it is all broken. A large number of my personal students at TBI, in Tibetan for instance, have ceased being Buddhist to the best of my knowledge. And these were people, some of which said to me, I will never do this to my face. Right? Then I worry for them.
You know, what happens to the person. Right? So for this reason, the approach we encourage at TBI is that you study Buddhism carefully, you take your time. Tenzin has formally asked Ilya to give refuge less frequently because Tenzin feels our students are not ready for the type of commitment involving refuge, especially after what happened with this student who gave up refuge three weeks after taking it. And then the best approach here, His Holiness says, is to study quietly, to think quietly.
And once one has some type of certainty, then at that point, if one wants to become a Buddhist, that is possible. Otherwise, it is perfectly possible without ever being a Buddhist to attend Lamrim teachings and to see what of Buddhism can be put in practice within one’s life. So we’re telling to you, you don’t have to buy the supermarket. You can pick from the shelves at your convenience. But if you buy the supermarket, you are legally responsible.
Now, let us recapitulate a little bit definite emergence. Definite emergence, sometimes said called renunciation, is the major step in mental transformation. The first major step taught in Buddhism. There are, as you remember, three types of definite emergence. The definite emergence of the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope.
And we have covered the definite emergence of the being of the small and the middling scope. The definite emergence of the being of the great scope is bodhicitta. So the definite emergence of the being of the small scope is renouncing this life. The definite emergence of the being of the middling scope is renouncing all lives. The definite emergence of the being of the great scope is endeavoring to attain full enlightenment for the sake of every suffering sentient being without exception, and then working endlessly for their welfare.
Then, these are extraordinarily vast goals. So, just the incomplete thought of definite emergence or the definite emergence of the being of the small scope, turning away from this life is something we can only begin to imagine. I don’t believe any one of us has it. Turning away from this life means that the person is completely indifferent to whatever happens in this life, the good and the bad. The person is completely focused on future lives.
Such a being has the attainments of a being of the small scope. Then we talked about this in great detail in my third presentation here on death and impermanence, when we talked about the ten topics of the Kadampa tradition. For us, the most helpful form of mind training at present is that. Turning away from this life and the way one trains in it, we will talk about that briefly, is through meditation on death. Death and impermanence.
Change, in other words. Coarse and subtle change. It is not a difficult topic. It is not intellectually demanding, but it is what does transform the mind. As Buddha Śākyamūni said in the Mahāparinirvāṇa Sūtra, just as the footprint of the elephant is the greatest of all footprints, likewise meditation on death is the greatest of all meditations.
So in our case, an understanding of emptiness is very far removed for most of us. It calls for very deep studies. The risks of misunderstanding are very great and therefore it is wisest to set it aside. Meditation on death, meditation on subtle impermanence do not lead to any misunderstanding and they lead to a profound and instantaneous transformation of the mind. The main way to know if one has reaped the benefits of meditation on death or not is by seeing whether one still is responsive to the eight worldly dharmas.
So if one still reacts to praise, to blame, to happiness, to unhappiness and so forth, then meditation on death has not borne its fruits and one should go back to one’s meditation cushion. There is no point in engaging in more advanced meditations until the basics are there. Once one has reaped the fruits of meditation on death and impermanence, then there really can be no suffering because of the ups and downs of this life. How could there be? Once one is certain that oneself will die, that the time of one’s death is completely uncertain, and that at the time of death only dharma will be of benefit, because one will have to give up material possessions, friends and this body, what is there in this life which can harm us?
What disease? What enemy? How could poverty harm us? Nothing can harm us. For so long as you fear disease, for so long as you fear poverty, for so long as you fear your interaction with others, the insults of others, for so long as there is anxiety in the mind, the fruits of the meditation on death and impermanence have not been reaped.
And for us this should be the focus of our practice. Death is a reality for all of us. Everyone in this room, not 50 but maybe twenty years from now apart from some of the young ones will be gone. So whether we meditate on death or not, death is meditating on us. Death will come.
And whether we cry or do not cry makes no difference. Death still comes. What we do have some control over is how our mind reacts at that time because that is the first moment in our life where we will be facing something which can no longer be averted. So this is why meditation on death is the beginning of Buddhism. It’s the first aspect of life which cannot be controlled by scientific development.
We can prolong human life as long as you have money. You must have money to live a long life. Others are no longer gonna pay for it for you. But death will come and therefore just as if you’re at university and there’s an exam, then you’re a foolish person if you don’t prepare for the exam. Right?
At the end of the year there is the exam whether you like it or not. It’s up to you to prepare or not. If you don’t prepare you will fail. People don’t pass exams for not preparing. If you prepare, you may pass or not.
There’s no guarantee. But the guarantee is if you don’t prepare, then you will fail. Then you do your best, right? And if someone, let’s say, Geshe-la said, there is an exam, and I’m not telling you when, and at the exam you can’t take any books, then you would be studying every week. Right?
That’s the level of practice which meditation on death and impermanence should lead us to. And then once one has generated this capacity to turn away from the vanities of this life, then it is not that difficult to realize that all lives are like this life. They are higher or lower, but the basic template is the same. And then what the Buddhist texts describe as a tremendous weariness, a sadness arises. In my own case, it always arises when I think I would have to go back to kindergarten again.
Again and again and again, learning to read, learning to write, you know, to count, you know, the whole process. And as you know, schooling seems to become longer. Each century, they add a couple years, you know. So when you think of what we call cyclic existence, which is a reincarnation, just in human terms, setting aside the animal realms, as an endless process where you actually never achieve anything. You keep going through the basics over and again until nausea occurs.
You go to school, you graduate or you don’t graduate, you go to university, you graduate, you meet a girl or a boy, you get married, you have children, it doesn’t work, you divorce, you meet someone else, you marry again, then it works or doesn’t work, maybe. Right? At that point, disease sets in, your parents die, and eventually you’re facing old age and wondering, will I be able to afford my old age or not? And this is going to happen not once, but again and again and again and And this is the good scenario. The bad scenario is we end up in one of the lower rounds as an animal.
And then, we become food for someone else. A slave. Or as in my family, a toy. Our two dogs are toys, they’re slaves. Given a very very, you know, fancy treatment because they are cute, you know.
But we reserve the right to cut their tail, to cut their ears, to castrate them, to sterilize them. What did you think of human beings treating other human beings like that? And being reborn like an animal is a possibility. If you look at animals, some animals manifest quasi human features which are unlearned. Very difficult to understand.
Animals manifest levels of intelligence which are near human. There’s a declaration I showed you a while back, the Cambridge Declaration of Animal Rights, In which a group of scientists from Cambridge University said that certain animals such as grey parrots should be given the rights of human beings because they were part of an intellectual continuum which led to human beings. I mean, the capacity to count was demonstrated. If you have the capacity to count, well, there are many mentally retarded human beings who cannot count. We give them the full rights of human beings.
So if you look at it this way and you accept the possibility of reincarnation, then the notion that you might be reborn as an animal and not understand how to get out of that state and therefore remain in that state indefinitely is a frightening one. And then one must wonder what one can do to get out of this cycle of lives, and this is definite emergence. So when one thinks about it, you can see it is quite rational. There’s one core premise that the mind is non material. I won’t enter into that here.
I’ve done so extensively at TBI. You have to decide by yourselves. It’s the most fundamental decision of your life, most fundamental philosophical decision you can take. If the mind is material, then go forth and enjoy yourselves. If the mind is non material, then you have to try to figure what is happening after.
And the world religions have proposed a series of solutions. All of them agree on one thing. Ethics has consequences. And lack of ethics has consequences, they all agree. Then the rationale for this is different.
For instance, the monotheistic traditions Buddhism, excuse me, Judaism, Islam and Christianity, view God as the administrator of ethical consequences. One commits a non virtue, God punishes in this life or in the afterlife. The great Indian traditions view karma as the administrator of ethical consequences and spread ethical behavior over a multiplicity of lives. But there’s a marvelous passage in a Jewish text, the Pirkei Avot, the sayings of the fathers, which is one of the treatises of Mishnah, in which a Jewish rabbi, I think it was Rabbi Hillel actually. This is around two thousand years ago.
The Mishnah is second century. Was walking by a stream and he saw a skull floating in the stream. In front of his disciples, he addressed the skull and he said, you drowned others, now you are drowned and those who drowned you will drown. Then, in terms of the operation of ethical consequences, this is not fundamentally different from Buddhism. Even though for Rabbi Hillel probably God administered karmic consequences or the consequences of ethics.
Then this is only the case obviously if one believes that there is an immaterial mind. If one believes that the mind is just the brain, then before this life there is nothing, and after this life there is nothing. You have to ask yourselves if you are able to take this on board. It’s, in my opinion, a position which calls for a huge amount of courage. The one great French philosopher Albert Camus who endorsed this position, He was by all accounts a bon vivant.
He enjoyed wine, women and food. Then I never really understood how he could myself. If you really believe that the end of consciousness is extinction, then it’s almost catastrophic. And this was the experience of the great physicist, the Hungarian physicist, John von Neumann, perhaps the greatest mind of the twentieth century, certainly on par with Einstein. For Neumann, despite all his research, at the end of his life remained convinced that his mind could only be reduced to the brain.
He died young, very young, in his late fifties. By all accounts it was an extremely painful and harsh death. Those who were present said that he cried and he screamed most of the time. Largely because he had probably identified very powerfully with his mind and his mind was facing extinction in his eyes. Then, some of us in this room work in palliative care, Chris works in palliative care.
You might want to ask him over the break what experiences he has of how people die in Australia, in this country. And, I think he will tell you that in many cases it is not easy. Because at the time of death it is no longer possible to lie to oneself. One may have lied to oneself and others all one’s life. At the time of death, we Buddhists say Yama, the Lord of death, holds a mirror to your face.
Then he weighs. Right? The good and the bad. So we will proceed onwards. I will skip some of the material we have covered extensively.
Mention that Je Tsongkhapa in his three principles of the path says that one should generate definite emergence at the beginning. In other words, this is the top priority. The top priority is not meditation and emptiness, nor is it bodhicitta, which we are unable to generate at present. The top priority is generating definite emergence for ourselves. As Śāntideva says, if you have not even in a dream considered accomplishing your own welfare, how can you pretend to accomplish the welfare of others?
In our own case, we do not understand how to enact our own happiness. How on earth can we pretend to understand and wish to enact the happiness of others? It is just another one of the lies we tell ourselves. So, the first step therefore, as Tsongkhapa says, is since without definite emergence there is no means to pacify the striving for the happy fruits of existence, initially you will search for definite emergence. So if you want to ground your practice on a solid base, as opposed to just studying the totality of the material initially, you must meditate on definite emergence, and when we speak of meditation on definite emergence, it has to start with meditation on death and impermanence.
And then, once one gains a sense of that, one can extend that to all lives. I remember when I was at Sera, you know, a longtime student of the center, Tripitaka. She came to Sera. She’d been on a yoga, up in Allahabad, then she came down to Sera to see Rinpoche. Saw Rinpoche in the morning, went to Kushinagar that afternoon, had a stroke in the streets of Kushinagar and died.
And they took her to the village hospital. She was in her fifties, I think. And I think, Nick, actually, you had to jump in a jeep and had to take the body to Mysore. Where you basically were in the back of the taxi with Tripitaka wrapped in a a shroud basically. Not wrapped at all.
How long did that last? About the drive, two hours, three hours, two hours. I would imagine it was food for a lot of thought for you. When it’s someone you know, it’s another story. In my own case, it really hit home when I saw Geshe Rabten die and then my own father die.
Then if you’ve ever touched a dead body after they’ve been kept in the morgue, you will know it’s it’s quite a horrific experience. I don’t know if it’s happened to any one of you. The body is freezing and moist. Right? Then we automatically associate human bodies with warmth.
You touch a human body, it’s warm. Right? When you touch something which has the texture of ice cream in a sock in that temperature, and this is a human body, it is deeply disturbing, especially if it is someone you knew. Then it is precisely this sort of reflection which will usher us into some type of, I would say, spiritual practice. The more we reflect on death and impermanence, the more solid and grounded our foundation will be.
When I was young, I was a novice monk and I wanted to bolster my practice. And I thought the best thing I can do is volunteer to work in a morgue. Then they weren’t keen. You needed all sorts of training, and I didn’t didn’t realize it was that complicated. But if you have the opportunity to volunteer to work as Chris is doing with dying people, to volunteer to work with dead bodies, for your practice, this is the best possible thing.
Now I know in Asia there is a belief that contact with the dead brings bad luck, ill fortune. And I think this is naive. Contact with the dead is really the best way for us to transform our own minds. For myself, it is what has helped the most. Everything else comes after.
So when I was at Sera, I my room was not far from the cremation ground for the monks. In in India, there’s not tons of wood. Right? So they use a little bit of wood and a lot of gasoline, you know. And the whole thing really, excuse me, smells like a barbecue until you know what is being cooked, you know.
Then I would go there after the cremations and I found what’s a very nice piece of bone. You know? The bone of an old monk. You know? They don’t burn completely.
You know? And then I put it on my altar next to the statue of Buddha. You know? And honestly, that piece of bone was much more helpful for my mind than the Buddha. I would look at that bone and my mind would be rooted like this.
Just look at him, there I go. Give it however many number of years, there I go. No one will remember, no one will care. So for yourselves, in your own way, this is what I strongly suggest. A very simple way of doing this is to go in graveyards.
Just sit in the graveyard quietly, look at the tombstones, read the names. So and so lived, they died forty years ago. You can see often the tombstone is cracked and decrepit. No one cares. No one knows who they are.
No one is interested. It is as if the person had never been. Then you look at the new tombstone and you can almost see the tears on the tombstone. Right? Of granite with gold and, you know, the bereaved family and a poetic statement again.
It makes no difference. And when you think, me too, I will go that way, then this is very powerful for your mind. And then you ask yourself, what is meaningful in this life? Is my running around, going to pubs, going to the beach, playing the guitar meaningful? Or is there something else?
And if so, what? And that is a path, a quest all of us have to engage in alone. We may have been raised in one religion, but find it is not compatible with us, or the opposite. Being raised in one religion and find it’s profoundly compatible. In my case, was raised in no religion, you know, so I had the good fortune of having great freedom in my investigation.
And we have to ask ourselves, do the great spiritual traditions bring answers, partial answers, or is it just nonsense? As many people believe nowadays, is it just the throwback to a dead age where people were not well educated? I had a very nice neighbor when I lived in Underdale. Very nice man, Bob. I suppose half the Australians are called Bob.
He’s very very nice of me. Was a carpenter, you know, and I bought some furniture from him in his eighties, you know. And he never talked about these things. It was very striking. He learned I was a Buddhist and was sort of really took him aback, but he figured it’s fairly decent even though he’s strange.
You know? And one day he said to me, well, you know, I used to be an Anglican, but I, you know, I gave it up. And I’m quite sure science is gonna have the answers for it all someday. And I suppose that’s a dominant viewpoint. Right?
Is it good enough for you or not? You have to see. It’s called, in philosophy, promissory materialism. Promissory means promised and materialism. Promissory because it’s like the promise of the second coming, you know, each year it’s next year.
Right? Promissory materialism promises that science eventually will find the rationale for consciousness, the reason for which we are here and so forth. Then see for yourselves whether this makes sense or not. So as Tsongkhapa says, initially one must generate definite emergence. Therefore, you wish to start practicing, you should start training in definite emergence, mere definite emergence, in other words, meditation on death and impermanence.
And you train until there is transformation. It will typically take years. Unless you have, I suppose, the good luck to be in a situation where your own life is under threat. Then, when your own life is under threat, if you, heaven forbid, at least from a material standpoint, end up in a war zone, your mind will change. Soldiers have a natural realization of death and impermanence.
Where they go from there is an open question. That is definitely there. When you see people around you being killed at random, and you yourself experience the fear of death at random, you become a different person. You look for answers. This is what we ourselves have to try to generate within ourselves.
Then, as Australia is a particularly safe country, it is difficult. But it’s a given that this will come your way at the end. It’s a given. Whether you try to forget about it or not. So it makes more sense to become habituated to it now than to try to make believe it’s not going to happen.
Right? And you owe it to yourselves to try to find some answers which satisfy you. And they have to really satisfy you. Fifty fifty is not good enough. So I was very fortunate in my life.
I came two times close to dying. And both times, for whatever reason, my mind was at peace. Perhaps because when I was young, I had a very old father who almost died when I was 13, so I started thinking a lot about this. And I went to graveyards, I would sit in the graveyard as a child, you know, and just think about the passing of people. In those days, we didn’t have access to Buddhist texts, you know.
Then I searched in Western philosophy, which philosophers talked of death, you know, try to understand, you know. And then this has served me in very good stead in my life. So when I met the great Buddhist teachings on death and impermanence, it felt like coming home. Here was a great spiritual tradition which formally taught how to meditate on this. Which is at the end of the day, the only question worth asking.
The Greek philosophers used to say that one had to live one’s life in the light of death. It’s a beautiful line. Now, and I’m recapitulating since we covered this during this year. How do we generate definite emergence? As was said, there’s two definite emergences.
We have mere definite emergence, which is the realization of our impermanence, and we have complete definite emergence, which is a rejection of cyclic existence. For mere definite emergence, we must meditate on two topics. That this human rebirth is rare and does not last, and on death and impermanence itself. So when we meditate on these two topics together, it is particularly powerful for the mind. It’s a little bit as if, let us imagine Andy for instance, Someone comes in the door and says, Andy, you have just won the Spanish lotto.
Here is a check for €40,000,000, and he gives it to you, and someone at that moment grabs it and says, no, this is mine, and starts running. This psychologically is what these meditations do to you. You are told you have something extraordinary precious and rare, a human rebirth. And just after being told that, you are told that it’s gonna go at any moment. So what does this do?
This triggers the quest for a means to make this human rebirth meaningful while you have it. To turn a human life into something of meaning. And that is why one must meditate on a human rebirth of leisure and endowment and death and impermanence together to generate renunciation of the vanities of this life. Then when we say renouncing the vanities of this life that means everything, right? So we tend to tone it down during the teachings so as not to frighten you on, not have a mad rush of students tearing through the doors.
But basically, it means that you live this life focused on future lives. And if future lives exist, this is the realistic stance. In this life, for instance, if you meet someone who during their thirties and forties is working for their retirement, you say this is a sensible person. Right? A person who understands how life works.
They are working now for later on when they will not be able to work. But if future lives really exist, that you have to decide. Right? If they really exist, then now what we have the possibility, the independence to do so, is a time to work for them. And for this we must understand what the relation between this life and future lives is that is karma and causality.
That I was going to present to you today, but I thought it was more helpful to go back to the basics together. You can always study this in Lamrim Chenmo, the detailed presentation of karma and causality, which once you want to make this life meaningful, is the most important thing you can do. It’s realistic. How to use this link between this life and future lives for you and not let it work against you? It exists.
Whether you believe it exists or not, unfortunately, makes no difference. But you can make it work for you or you can let it work against you. So if we live randomly, it works against us. If we live strategically, it works for us. Strategic living is living in the light of karma.
Understanding what so called virtuous deeds and so called non virtuous deeds are. Virtuous deeds are simply deeds which lead to happiness. Non virtuous deeds are leads deeds which lead to unhappiness. Then understanding how karmic amplification proceeds, how some deeds become heavier. It’s a critical point.
And then the goal is obviously for us to try to put a maximum of white stones in the basket and a minimum of black stones. Everything is not possible. And for the white stones to be big and the black stones to be small. So the key is to engage in the practice of as much virtue as is possible. And in addition, through understanding karmic amplification for this virtue to be powerful, for your white stones to be big.
So if you engage in ethics, how to amplify ethics? If you gauge engage in generosity, how to amplify generosity? If you have a bad moment and you hit the town and go drunk, how basically to reduce the karmic weight of that? People do that. We ask for the donation of bottles for the bottle caps at TBI.
It was, like, five, six years ago. You know? And I went in the back once. You know? These are all students of TBI.
We’re a 100 members, Buddhists. You know? And there was a big bottle, a big heap of Johnnie Walker and whatever brand of whiskey and all these sour mashes and I thought, my goodness, like, just a couple bottles of lemonade, you know. So, obviously, you know, the Buddhist teachings are stressful and people need, you know, scotch on the rocks to relax. Right?
But you see the key here is realistically we’re in this for ourselves, especially at present. Anyone who says they’re in it for others is basically deluding themselves. Then it’s a pity if dharma becomes your enemy. It’s a real pity. A dharma should be your friend.
Dharma should enable you to progress from life to life. If dharma becomes your enemy, and through external observance one breaks vows. And, eventually, one experiences things one would not have experienced if one had gone and just have fun at the beach. That’s really sad. Really sad.
And that’s why we have to understand how karma works. And then, once one understands how karma works, to use the metaphor of the two baskets, there are many things we can do. We try to put more white stones in one basket than black stones in the other. We try to put bigger white stones in one basket and smaller black stones in the other. We have the possibility having put a white stone for every white stone we put in to add ten, twenty or 100.
That’s basically rejoicing. Right? We have the possibility of taking black stones out of the basket through purification. So once we understand these strategies, this is what we should be putting in practice in our life. And it’s realistic, and it’s feasible.
It’s only possible if we believe that this is the way things are. If we don’t believe this is the way things are, it is never going to happen. That you have to ask yourselves. So if you really believe that not the details about Mount Meru and trivia, right? But that the core Buddhist teachings are true, then you should put them in practice.
And if you don’t, why are you here? Why are you wasting your time? Go do whatever you want to do, enjoy life, you know? There’s no meaning, there are no consequences. As Somerset Maugham, a great British short story writer said, my philosophy of life is to do what I want with due regards to the policemen around the corner.
Why not? If you believe in nothing. Okay? Try not to be in between, because in between you don’t reap karmic benefits and you don’t have fun. So it’s lose lose.
Right? Try to choose the one or the other. So therefore, first one should turn away from this life, and as we said, this is how one proceeds. The object of abandonment is this life, the means of meditation on a human rebirth of leisure and endowment and death and impermanence, and the goal is a happy rebirth. Now you’re not going to start this process if you don’t believe in rebirths.
So, it’s fundamental that you generate a profound conviction in the existence of past and future lives. If that isn’t there, none of this makes any sense. Then you can do what I said at the beginning, is take elements of the Buddhist teachings to try to put them in practice in this life to calm your mind, instead of going to the therapist. Why not? But that is not Buddhism.
And then after this, as we said, fully characterized definite emergence in the second part of the verse is through reflecting over and again on the infallibility of causality, in other words karma, and on the sufferings of cyclic existence, in other words the repeated sufferings, life after life after life after life, turn away from the vanities of future lives. And here the object of abandonment is all lives. One meditates on causality and the sufferings of cyclic existence in general, and the object of attainment is liberation. Now this is an extraordinary goal. I knew a very fine Geshe at Sera, a very close friend of Lama Yeshe.
He was a chant master of the group of the protectors, the Hayagrīva Chant. And I never forget once we were talking and he said to me: I wish I could become an Arhat, but I don’t have the capacity. Now this was, for me, a very strong statement. This is a Lharampa Geshe. It’s a very realistic assessment of who he is.
He’s at the end of his life, and he is saying, I am not a being of the middling scope. Definitely a being of the small scope he was. Definitely. Then that contrasts very sharply with what we hear in so many centers, where people posture as practitioners of the great scope. This was truth.
And I saw when he met with his holiness, you know, how close the relation was. That tells you an awful lot. That’s a true practitioner. He’s going up the ladder quietly step by step. It takes the time it takes.
Takes the lives it takes, but you get places. So, what is the criterion for having generated the thought of definite emergence? If through such habituation, as with such meditation, longing for the marvels of cyclic existence does not arise for even an instant, and if the mind striving for complete liberation arises day and night, at that point definite emergence has been born. In other words, when it is in the backdrop of all one’s thoughts, awake or asleep, then one has generated definite emergence. If you’re speaking of the definite emergence of the being of the small scope, when death is in the backdrop of your thoughts day and night, you have generated the definite emergence of the being of the small scope.
Then I think you can see how this would make you totally immune to any hardship in this life. I think it’s evident. And then someone who has fully characterized definite emergence, who has given all up all lives, then these are extraordinary beings. They have entered the path. You know?
Then if you are good fortunate enough to meet one, you know, it’s the event of one life. I think we’ll take a short break. I’ll raise some debates after the break on this topic and then we will study the Udānavarga together. And hopefully the words of Buddha Śākyamūni, you know, will resonate within you.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
- The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mount Meru
- The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.