Heart Sutra — 2000-11-14

Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)
Heart Sutra — 2000-11-14
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2000-11-14 – The 5 Paths. Selflessness of Phenomena & of Persons.mp3

UUID: 5e076b5f-c521-47ec-b4c9-1267de8dc727

Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche

Collection: Heart Sutra (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2000-11-14

Duration: 1h 52m

Words: 5,243

If our practice of listening and giving teachings being done along with the motivation of altruistic intention, then the practice will become very effective and we also cultivate a great store of merit and we’ll have a good result out of our practice. I shall free both oneself and others from all the sufferings and bring them to bring them towards the great happiness. And to develop a mind motivation here that in order to do so for that purpose, I shall here train and perform the practices to remove all the bad state of mind, disturbing emotions, and the sufferings and cultivate entire good qualities through this are fulfilled both the purpose itself and others. For that sake, I shall here practice the Heart Sūtra, the essence with the Heart Sūtra which is the essence of Mahāyāna teaching. So I shall listen to this essence of Mahāyāna teaching Heart Sūtra and bring all the hearings into contemplation and meditation and fulfill both wishes of self and others.

And we shall do a short meditation on this. So we have explained the teaching on how explained about the regarding to the text has been set forth. The the brief brief explanation of the emptiness and the the details or or more profound yeah. The the detailed explanation of the the emptiness. So all these explanations are set forth with regard to regard to how Bodhisattvas, they train or practice in the past.

So the explanation of the five paths are set forth in two types that one, according to the two types of Bodhisattvas with the the the faculties, recall the the the bodhisattvas with the with the sharp faculty and and and with the the general faculty. So the first one is set forth, the individual explanation of the five aggregates are set forth with the first one, which is Bodhisattva with the lower faculty. In general there are five paths, but the five paths are also set forth in 15 parts with regards to the three different schools, the five paths of the Hearer schools, five paths of the solitary realizers and the five paths of Mahayanists. So the path here means the path is like a path, the way or the road. Here the path, it has the same connotation or the same meaning of the way or the road, but the path is after having trained in the small and the middling scope and one develops a renunciation or wish to flee from cyclic existence by seeing the faults or the disadvantages of the cyclic existence or saṃsāra and so and the quality which conjoins with the renunciation is the path here.

So so here, we explain the five paths of the Mahāyāna, and so the first part is that one reaches the first path of the Mahāyāna, five paths, after having trained, after training in the small and the middling scope or doing meditation on a small and middling scope and whenever one develops innately or without any effort, develops a mind to attain enlightenment just by seeing a sentient being. just by seeing a sentient being. So whenever one generates such a wish, it’s a sign one is reaching the first path of the Mahāyāna. So the first path of the five Mahāyāna paths is the path of accumulation, and it’s called the path of accumulation of the Mahāyāna. It’s that one needs to attain enlightenment and to become enlightened, one has to develop or cultivate a number of virtues or good positive actions.

Therefore, the first path is the path where one accumulates it’s been called the path of accumulation. And the second path is called the path of preparation. The reason why it’s called the path of preparation is because when one reaches the third path, the third path is the path where one directly realizes the selflessness of the person, selflessness and the emptiness. The second path is the path where one prepares, one does the preparation to attain all those, they directly realize the selflessness and emptiness during the third path. This is why it’s called the preparation, which is preparation for the third path.

And the third path is the path of seeing. And the reason why it’s called path of seeing is because third path one directly sees the emptiness, selflessness, selflessness, and the four truths. So at third path, when one reaches the third path one directly realizes or directly realizes the emptiness, selflessness and so forth, and the fourth path is called the path of meditation which is where, at the third path one truly realizes emptiness and so forth and doing the fourth path, the path of meditation one familiarizes with all the attainments or all the realizations through meditation, so this is how it’s called the path of meditation. And the last, the fifth path is called the path of no more training or no more learning or it’s the state of Buddhahood. It’s because after having done all this meditation, familiarizing with that realization through meditation, one purifies all the negativities, attained entire qualities, and where one reaches the fifth path.

To be at the fifth path, there is nothing more to learn because one has perfected all the good qualities and have purified the negativities and it is the state of Buddhahood. Therefore, because there is no more to train or nothing to train or learn, This is how it’s called the path of no more learning. Well, one can have big holiday.

So these are called the five paths, and in ordinary path or a roadway we walked, but here the way of walking in those paths are not the way we walked in the ordinary road. Here, one should walk through the training, through developing the qualities, improving one’s knowledge through training with the combination of wisdom and method. So wisdom and method are like our legs. So the method is the bodhicitta or altruistic intention and wisdom is to realize emptiness. So these two are like our legs and where one walks from the first path of accumulation and to the training in the combination of those two, one walks through the second and finally towards the end.

So during the time of path of the accumulation, for those, the Bodhisattva with the lower or weak faculty trains to cultivate or trains in emptiness, in the wisdom part, but they have already generated the method part which is the bodhicitta. And as here called faculty, and in terms of faculty, we are there are five. We we call the eye, nose, ear, tongue, and the wisdom. Yes. I call the five faculties.

And in terms of internal qualities, there are also five faculties as well. And so they are the five called internal yes. It’s called the five determined minds, and which are called the the the mind of aspiration and effort, mindfulness, concentration, and wisdom. So those Bodhisattvas, those who have these five faculties very forcefully or very strong are called the Bodhisattva with the sharp faculty and those who have not that strong are called the Bodhisattva with the low or weak faculties. So yeah.

So during the time of path of accumulation, the Bodhisattva with low faculty cultivates the wisdom. Wisdom. As for the wisdom, because they have to analyze or cultivate the wisdom realizing emptiness. So as for the wisdom, there are three types of wisdoms and the wisdom derived from hearing, from contemplation, and from meditation. So during the path of accumulation, the Bodhisattva with a low faculty cultivates both wisdoms.

So the wisdom derived from hearing, which is not which is that after yeah. It’s derived by listening listening towards the the word of emptiness through teaching again and again, reading books on emptiness and receiving teachings from the teacher or the lama. After having heard that word of emptiness often or again and again, and finally whenever one realizes or understands that the meaning of emptiness by thinking that all right, the emptiness means such and such or this is how the emptiness is being called and during that stage one understands the emptiness but does not mean that one realizes emptiness, but the sense wisdom of knowing emptiness or understanding emptiness is called the wisdom which derive from hearing. So we’re doing the path of accumulation. First one cultivates the wisdom derived from hearing, and after having developed that wisdom, then one cultivates the second which is wisdom derived from concentration or contemplation.

About emptiness, in general there are numbers of emptiness, but one can also combine all the emptiness into two categories and meditate on two topics. So which are these great master Candrakīrti has set forth that one should meditate on the true emptiness or true selflessness, the selflessness of phenomena and selflessness of the person. So we have explained the emptiness of the last previous class, last Tuesday class, for the tech said one should see all the five aggregates or the absence of inherent existence. So here, the five aggregates are called the phenomena and the non-inherent existence of the phenomena — the selflessness of the phenomena. So the non-inherent existence of the phenomena, those five aggregates are the first selflessness which we have set forth before, the selflessness of the phenomena and the selflessness of person.

So the selflessness, the absence of inherent existence of the five aggregates are the first one, which is selflessness of phenomena. And the person or self or I here is referred to as the I or self which was labeled or which comes out from the basis of the five aggregates. So the five aggregates are the basis of imputation or designation where one labels the I on those. The I which comes out or which is labeled towards the five aggregates is called the person or self here. So the person or the self here refers towards all the beings like the humans, cat, horse, dog, and so forth.

So all the names, human, cat, horse and dogs are the basis or labeled on their forms or aggregates. For example, like as a human, because of the aggregates, the five aggregates of the human, the human has been labeled on that, the human has been labeled on the aggregates of the aggregates of the human and so therefore the human is based, the title or named human comes out or is the label of the five aggregates of the human and likewise cat, dog and horse are also the same. So all the emptiness are categorized into two which are the selflessness of phenomena and selflessness of the person. According to, in terms of teaching from the text, the teaching of the selflessness of phenomena comes first, but in terms of meditation, the meditation on selflessness of person is being meditated before the selflessness of the phenomena. So therefore we have to meditate on selflessness of person first.

So where one does the meditation of selflessness of the person Yeah. Is the person itself. So the people in the rest like to meditate, so here today we will talk about how to do meditation on selflessness of a person.

So to meditate on selflessness of person, one can either meditate on self, oneself or in other beings like cat, horse and so forth, but it is better to first, it is better to meditate on oneself and when one realizes the selflessness of a person upon within oneself then it’s easy to understand the selflessness of the cat and so forth. So when there’s the meditation on selflessness of the person upon oneself, first one and the object of meditation here is the self, is the I, which is yourself, that I which was labeled or imputed towards the five aggregates of oneself. And for example, like myself, I was first being called Rabsam and then later comes the Geshe Rabsam Tupten and comes Khenpo and then comes the Khensur. So the one which we hold very strong, we grasp very strongly the I which was labelled towards the five aggregates of oneself. So that I is what one should take as an object of meditation, or focus.

It is not easy to meditate here now. Just by doing this doesn’t mean you’re meditating. So now so how one meditates here is the the I which was labeled. Labeled towards the base well, towards the five being red is is the basis of the meditation where we are here, we are doing the meditation on selflessness of a person. So that I which was labeled towards the five aggregates.

And second, then, so by recalling that I which was labeled toward the five aggregates again and again in one’s meditation or in one’s mind, then one should see that I does not exist inherently or it’s free of inherent existence or it doesn’t exist by its own accord, which was the second meditation. And the third, then once you see the reasons why does not exist inherently or why it is free of inherent existence, it is because first it needs basis of labeling where it should be labeled. And second, it has to depend on the mind which labeled, for example, like Lobsang Tupten, towards that aggregate. Not only it’s it is not enough here as well. And one also needs a third reason for seeing that it should have a mind which grabs that this is or this person is Rabsang Tutan, so they need the three.

The first object of labeling or the basis of basis, and the second one is the mind which labeled the Lobsang Tuptan name. And the third one is one the mind which accepts that this is Lobsang Tupten. So because of these reasons, these three reasons by the company so because the Rabsang Tupten or I comes out by depending. By depending on all these three reasons, therefore it does not exist inherently. So this is how one meditates on the selflessness of a person.

If we demonstrate an example here, for example here, an example like a rope with the white and black color and just rolled it on the floor. Right now it’s okay, we can see clearly it’s very bright here, but for suppose it’s like four or 5AM in the morning, it’s a little bit foggy and pretty dark there, one can’t see clearly. At that stage, somebody walks in and suddenly mistake and see the rope as a snake. So at that time, the rope, the black and white, the rounded rope is like the basis of labeling or where one labels. So this is the basis.

Then one walks in and suddenly because it’s not clear and dark, it’s not clear and very foggy, one mistake it as a snake. And at that moment, one suddenly say from the mouth, one say snake, and then along with that along with that sound of snake, inside one develops a conception or, yeah, conceptual thought. It’s thinking, oh, there is a there is a snake. And with the combination of those two, with the sound of snake and the misconception or conceptual thought inside of thinking it’s a snake and then finally the name, the produced snake has been produced and labeled, and the the the second thought which says, ah, there is a snake, which grabs the rope as a snake. So all these three, the basis of the label labeling and the the sound and the the with concept with say, the conceptual thought, which thinks it’s a snake and finally the mind which produce, finally labels snake completely towards the wall.

So these three, and through these three, one produced the snake. So likewise, for the aggregates, first the aggregates are the object of labeling. Then secondly, thought, like, say, from the mouth we say lopsang, and misconceptual thought said, this is the Lopsang Lobsang Tupten. And then finally the mind produced the I of Lopsang Lobsang Tupten completely. This and through this how the I has been produced.

So although there is not a snake on the floor or on the table early in the morning at 04:00, but for that person within his mind he has produced one snake on the table because, and that snake in his mind has been produced by depending on the basis of labeling and what is being labeled, the name snake and so forth. So likewise, the my aggregates are the basis of labeling and where the name lopsangtuptan and the misconceptional thought, which labels Lobsang Tupten on the aggregates and where one and and the mind which confirms that this is Lobsang Tupten. So by by the combination, but through these three, the Lobsang Tupten has been produced. So for example, like a Dolma, aggregates of a Dolma is the basis and the name Dolma and the misconceptional thought which thinks this is Dolma are the one which labels and that conceptional thought labels Dolma towards her five aggregates. And through this, but depending because of that misconceptional thought which labeled the doubt finally produced or newly produced in his form on his five aggregates, So before the misconceptional thought which labeled Dow towards his five aggregates, the name Dolma did not exist for those aggregates, it didn’t exist. So on the table, by seeing the rope on the table and for that person who sees for that person the rope is a snake and because by depending on his misconceptional thought we perceive that the rope as a snake, he feels scared or terrified by seeing a snake. But the fact is there is no snake on the table. And then at the very first moment, the person sees the rope as a snake and the first moment the person labeled the name snake to the rope. But the very, second moment the person never thinks or perceived that the snake was labeled by him or herself, just at the very second moment how that person perceived the snake is that person perceives the snake as having been produced by its own, by itself.

So likewise, the name Tutten was labeled on my body and because of that, the name Rabsang Tupten and the misconception, conception and thinking this is Rapsang Tutten. So those two, the misconception and the name Lobsang Tupten labeled the Lobsang Tupten on one’s five aggregates. And from the beginning on, from the very first moment and this is through this how the Lobsang Tupten has been produced. But the very second moment of that, then one forgets about how one labeled Lobsang Tupten to the five aggregates. And one acknowledges or perceives that the Lobsang Tupten was just produced.

It was produced or exists now by itself or by its own accord upon these five aggregates. So one should understand or know the difference between these two these two I. I. The first moment that the I which was labeled — how one perceives two I’s within oneself, The first one, by depending, by seeing the five aggregates or taking the five aggregates as a basis, one labeled the name Lobsang Tupten by the conception of thinking this is Lobsang Tupten. So that I, which was called the I merely labeled on the five aggregates is called does exist, that labeled I does exist.

But the second one, the very second moment one forgets about the labeled I and thinks that Lobsang Tupten is just produced or exists by its own accord. It comes from its own entity or its own side. So that I, does not exist inherently, which does not exist — the I that appears to exist by its own accord or which inherently exists is the I which does not exist, then that that I is the one, the object of negation, which we they call the emptiness. And and and if if that I does exist, then that I is called the true existence and so as because we say there is no nothing exists by its own accord or there’s no true existence, So the second I, the I which produced by its own accord is the I which does not exist. So the first eye which I labeled towards the five aggregates is the eye that exists, but the second one, the thinking that the eye which develops on top 10 or eye that exists by its own accord or through or by its own characteristic is the eye which doesn’t exist.

And and so and that I is called the the the the the I and because it does not exist, this is how it comes to selflessness of the person or I. So here the logical proof is that the Lobsang Tupten or I which does not exist inherently or it doesn’t exist by its own accord because it is dependent arising, because without depending on the basis of the five aggregates on the name and the conceptual thought, the Lobsang Tupten or I does not exist. So therefore, because it is dependent and arising, it does not exist by its own accord or inherently exist. And then, should, so this is how, one can also now meditate on the selflessness of the person upon oneself, yourself were thinking that I do not exist inherently or I do not exist by my own accord, it is because I am dependent arising, because I depend on the name, the conceptual and the basis of the basis which are the five aggregates. So therefore, because I myself am produced by depending on my name and so forth, I do not exist inherently or by its own accord.

This is how one meditates on the I, on the individual I. For example, like a little child, a baby was born today and at very first stage when the baby was born, just called, the baby was born and the baby, we just called baby but there was no name at all. So at that time the basis of labeling was just produced at the time the baby was born and also, the name baby was labeled already from the start because the baby is the general name which has been used for other babies as well. So for that reason, at that stage the baby and the basis of the labeling was produced. But hasn’t got name yet.

The baby’s name was not labeled or not produced at that time. Then the people discussed what would we call or give name to the baby or a child and in Tibetan it depends, some names are labeled through the seven days according depends on which day the child was born. It’s been called Pemba, Pasang, Penzom, Nyima, so forth and sometimes called the different names like Tashi, Doma and so forth. Then finally they say that they agreed with the name Tashi and the person, among those the front person has an idea, the name Tashi comes into someone’s mind and then developed a conception thinking what and the name Tashi is good. Because of that conceptual and the name Tashi, these two labels and which label Tashi to the little baby and they said, alright, we will call Tashi to little child.

Everyone calls Tashi and this is how the Tashi is produced or born. So the person’s conception of thinking that the name Tashi is good to that child and the sound which produced from the person’s mouth called Tashi and through this, the name Tashi was labeled to the

To to baby. No? And through this, the new Tashi was produced on the five aggregates of the baby.

And so because the per the person labeled name Tashi to the little child, and the child becomes Tashi, and then everyone started to call Tashi to the baby and start saying Tashi comes and goes and Tashi is happy and so forth. And the child itself must will think, yeah, I am Tashi. So, the Tashi was the projected or labeled on the child But but but it doesn’t comes by its own by by its own by by because the the when the child was born, the Tashi wasn’t born at that time. Then, the Tashi wasn’t born along with the baby from the very first stage and then the baby was born and then Tashi labeled her with the baby and this is how and after, because of the labeling, the Tashi was produced, but later on everyone started calling baby Tashi to that baby and then after a while when the baby walks in, we always think the Tashi comes and Tashi goes and comes and so forth, but we never think that the Tashi was labeled on the person, the little baby five aggregates always have within our mind it appeared to us that the Tashi, the baby, just the Tashi comes or produce, just comes or exists by its own by itself within by its own accord.

So and without depending on anything, and this is what we think and such is called the the the the the true the the the true grasping attitude, which is ignorance. When one meditates on the selflessness of the Tashi, then according how to prove Tashi does not exist inherently or independently, then how the debaters prove through the logical approach is that saying that Tashi which is the basis of debate, saying Tashi, the Tashi does not exist inherently and independently because Tashi is produced by depending on its five aggregates, the name and the conceptual which project the name Tashi to the aggregates. And because therefore it doesn’t exist independently because is interdependent. So this is how it proves. The fault of Tashi being independently exist or inherently existent is because if Tashi exists independently or inherently, then the mistake is, then Tashi can never be old, will never become older, old.

Likewise, we all do not exist independently or inherently and the fault is that if we do exist independently or inherently, then the fault is that we all will never become old and we will never die. Sometimes it’s good when you get older. It’s hard to avoid it. And you can’t become Buddha or enlightened? I really don’t know about it.

You don’t need to go to hell. And then if the seed exists independently or inherently, then it can’t give any sprout. It it it it it won’t give any sprout. Grow. If the virtuous action exist in it inherently, then there is no happiness.

If non-virtuous action exists inherently, then there is no result, no suffering. If we exist independently or inherently, then we do not need to take any rebirths and then there is no happiness, there is no suffering and we remain just like permanent and with no feeling or sense of happiness or suffering. It’s just more or less or it’s like just a stone, no feelings at all. Because of the things, all phenomena or things not inherent, do not exist inherently, the happiness, sufferings comes, taking rebirth comes, the cause and effect comes, the actions of going and staying and leaving and so forth comes. If the things exist inherently, then actions, all these feelings of happiness, suffering, taking rebirths, cause and effects do not exist.

So all this, the happy, the good and bad, happy and suffering or unhappy, good rebirth and bad rebirth, Buddha, hell and so forth are dependent arising and are the results of the causes and conditions. So because they are the production of the causes and conditions or are produced by depending on the causes and condition, they all do not exist, they are all free of inherent existence or do not exist inherently. And so so which means so because they are interdependent arising, they do not exist inherently, and so for this is the reason teaching of dependent arising is the basis and how it’s been considered very important and no. Therefore, the great master Candrakīrti has set forth that this logic of dependent arising eradicates all the wrong views and as a result, the result of removing all the wrong views is that one can remove or abandon, eliminate all the bad actions and the benefit of removing all the negative action is one one do not need to suffer, instead one will have happiness. Okay.

So we’ll take a couple of questions. Yes, please. Sorry? I can’t hear you, please. What does that mean?

Probably the repetition of the word or name within the meditation. Is that what you mean? It’s a It’s a riddle. Didn’t you say that? Excuse me.

Yeah. Yeah. You you told me that when then meditation and the the word or something like that. So it depends on the meditation and any kind of meditation. If one does a very good meditation, if it is a good meditation, it could be any meditation, but all those good meditation is to, meditation helps one to develop one’s wisdom that wisdom is where, but the wisdom, when one develops one’s wisdom, that wisdom is very helpful to realize emptiness.

For example, whether you meditate on emptiness or meditate on impermanence, meditation on sufferings, suffering and so forth. If one does a very good meditation on this, which this all meditation helps one to generate one’s wisdom or develop one’s wisdom and that wisdom will be used or will be very helpful to realize emptiness. You have the second part. If everything is changing moment to moment, how do you how is the gross appearance of objects maintained through time? I mean, why does you

In reality, there is not a time of existence or time of existence of any object. But according to the schools of Sautrāntika and the lower school, they assert about the periods of the object by saying, in three categories saying it’s a time of birth and they say the time of existence and the time of destruction. Whereas in the mind only and the middle way schools, the upper schools, they said that the time of existence does not exist. It and is because they talk that they assert the subtle impermanence that just at the very moment of the birth, it never stays. It exists momentarily within second to second.

And but for us in our ordinary appearances that because of our mind of grasping at permanence, we think that things do exist for a moment, but the fact is that they do not exist at all. The changes, but we don’t recognize it. So the things never exist even for a second, but the continuum of thing exists. So it just produces one by one, but it is very subtle that we don’t realize it. Yeah.

A permanent state. It depends when you say the Buddhist Buddhahood is permanent. It depends on how one said because there are different types, body, speech and mind of the Buddhas. And there is a permanent part within the Buddha, which is called Buddha hood the which abandons all the obscurations and that part is called, is set forth to be permanent and whereas Buddhahood or Buddha’s field, the body, speech and mind and so forth are also, the changes are impermanent and in moment they are changing momentarily. Okay.

Yeah. Oh, good. Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
merely labeled tag tsam (Tib)
The subtlest meaning of dependent arising; every phenomenon exists relatively, or conventionally, as a mere label, merely imputed by the mind. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
selflessness of person gang zag gi dag me (Tib)
According to the Prasangika Madhyamaka school, the most subtle view of selflessness of person is the lack of inherent existence of the person or self. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top