1 h 37 min · 4,611 words · 24 October 2000
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the meaning of the title Heart Sutra, the Perfection of Wisdom Gone Beyond. It covers the sense of ‘gone beyond’ (path, text and resultant wisdom), the heart as the essence of the teaching, and the wisdom realising emptiness as the mother of all Buddhas. It ends with a brief account of emptiness as lacking inherent existence and a short question session.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 37m
UUID: 63387998-a32f-46ca-8b09-bac37d4c739b
Date: 2000-10-24
Words: 4,607
So along with the mind of altruistic intention or bodhicitta, we’ll set up a proper motivation. And by doing so, practices of listening and giving teaching as well as meditation with a good motivation of altruistic intention, we accumulate a huge number of great, huge merit, and as a result of that, it will produce a good Like us, wishing happiness is not oneself like all other sentient beings, animals, and so forth are same as us wishing happiness and do not want suffering. But the human beings have a very good knowledge that they understand the happiness and its causes as well as suffering and their causes, they have a knowledge to distinguish the happiness and the suffering and understand how to cultivate the happiness and its causes and abandon the suffering and its causes, whereas animals, being like animals, have no awareness or knowledge to distinguish the happiness and the suffering, therefore they don’t have knowledge to cultivate the causes of happiness. So, if we perform a meditation here with a meditation here with cultivating the compassion and the love, focusing on the sentient being as well as oneself, wishing them to have happiness in their causes and free from suffering in their causes.
Such a meditation is very beneficial. So, not just develop a wish of compassion and love, but along with it develop a special intention, the wish of taking the responsibility of bringing the sentient beings free or out of suffering and bring them towards the ultimate happiness. So in order accomplish this, I shall clear proof of all negativities and attain the entire good qualities and attain enlightenment. For that purpose I shall hear, listen to the teachings of emptiness and bring all the hearings into contemplation and meditation through to develop motivation. So we shall do a couple of meditations on such motivation.
We recite the refuge prayer starting from page one, verse three, and then do the same page one, the Seven Limb prayers. After this, we do the Heart Sūtra in English, which was page number. Lord Buddha Śākyamūni, before he left, had stayed twenty-nine years in his kingdom and had a son called Rahula. He has said this verse of prayer, homage to the emptiness, saying, I bow down to the mother of conquerors of the three times, the perfection of wisdom inexpressible by words of thought which is unproduced and unceasing like the entity of the sky. The object of the wisdom of unique knowledge.
This verse of homage to the emptiness is set forth to be very precious that in the Sera Monastery before the recitation of Heart Sūtra or the perfection wisdom sūtra, this verse has been said before. So it’s been the verse has said that the inexpressible by words and thought, which means it’s inexpressible in words which it’s, for example, like a sweet and we eat a sweet and it’s very tasty and it’s very sweet and one tastes the sweet of the chocolate. One wishes to express how sweet it is as it tastes in one’s tongue, but the fact is one can’t express the sweetness of the chocolate by words. So likewise, the emptiness which is realized or made use by the wisdom realizing emptiness and it wishes to express but it can’t express in words how it tastes by realizing through the wisdom realizing emptiness. Also it is very profound that it can’t be actualized or realized by conceptual wisdom.
Example, if you ask a question to somebody how sweet it is and the person with it is very, very sweet, how sweet it is, it is very, very sweet, can’t So that conceptual thought can’t actualize or realize that wisdom realizes emptiness or realize the emptiness. But through the practices of meditation and contemplation, gradually one develops in one’s practice of meditation and finally realize the wisdom which directly realizes emptiness. Whenever one realizes emptiness directly then it’s called the wisdom gone beyond which has gone beyond the cyclic existence of saṃsāra developed and then that wisdom realizing emptiness can clearly see the nature of the empty or emptiness. And that wisdom directly realizing emptiness can see the emptiness clearly and pure without elaboration. So, the explanation of the verse continues and it says that through such a wisdom, the wisdom directly realizes emptiness itself is not inherently exist by its own entity and likewise other phenomenons also do not exist inherently by their own accords.
So therefore not existing, not inherently existing is called the emptiness. And such emptiness or empty is very pure and it’s like the expanses of the sky, therefore it can’t be negated or therefore been therefore it is a negation of being established by the way of its own echo. And who realizes that emptiness is that the wisdom realizing after having the wisdom which realizes the emptiness directly and such wisdom realizes the emptiness and that wisdom which realizes the emptiness through the deep meditation, through the meditative equipoise on emptiness. And that wisdom directly realizing emptiness is like a mother that in the past the numbers of Buddhas have been past and there are many who currently attained Buddhahood or become enlightened, and there will be in future. And this wisdom is being called mother because the wisdom directly realizing emptiness is the one, is the cause or a mother to produce all the buddhas of the present, past, and future.
For example, the mother there being a child who has been born in the past the children, say, are born in the past are still coming in present as well as in future, all the children, the children of the past, present, and future comes or being produced from the mother and likewise the emptiness, the wisdom realizing emptiness is like a mother to give rise for the Buddha or present past and future Buddhas. So therefore it’s reason it’s been called yum in Tibetan word which is called mother and ma the and yum are same. It’s a synonym in the Tibetan word that the yum is an honorific word, right? The queen has been called yum of the prince because of prince or princess. So, Without mother there is no child.
There’s no child, and the great master, Padmasambhava, is exceptional case. He was said to be born from the lotus and it’s an exceptional case. Master Padmasambhava was said to be born through the emanation, so was a great yogi born without a mother. So ordinary person, they can’t the ordinary person can’t be born without a mother. Likewise, without wisdom, the Buddha’s arhats, the superior beings of the great vehicle, the superior beings of Hīnayāna school, solitary realizers can’t be produced without, can’t be born without wisdom realizing emptiness.
Therefore, wisdom realizing emptiness is like a mother and without it all the Buddhas and Arhats and so forth can’t be born or produced. It’s called superior beings because they are superior than the ordinary person. And if we bring it towards the sentient being or ordinary being, then in order to free in order to free sentient being from the sufferings and free of disturbing emotions or afflicted emotions, one needs the wisdom realizing emptiness. Without wisdom realizing emptiness, the sentient being can’t be free suffering and the disturbing emotions, so therefore in order to attain happiness one needs to have the wisdom realizing emptiness. So, briefly speaking, in order to overcome all the suffering and attain the happiness, one needs to have the wisdom realizing emptiness.
So, wisdom, the emptiness and the view of emptiness is set forth to be very profound and the secret teaching, secret Buddhist teaching. Therefore, it was set forth that one should not teach the emptiness or a view of emptiness teaching to those who have no respect and faith in the emptiness teaching. So I hope everyone has a slight devotion and faith in the teaching of emptiness. And it’s been set forth that one should not teach emptiness teaching to those who have no faith and devotion, and it was not said with the lack of affection. It’s been because of his compassion and affection, it’s been said should not teach towards those people who have no respect in the teaching.
So, yes, it’s been said for quite the hard or risky practice and it’s said for they should not teach to those who have no respect in the teaching and that was said for to be very compassionate means. It is because, for example, if someone has attained, has gained a certain powers within the person and he or she can play around with the snake through the magic. They play with the snake and no matter how much the snake bites the person, the person can’t be harmed and the person who tries to play with the snake without a magic or certain power just by one bite of the snake, the person will be gone. Likewise, if one has a good understanding of the teaching of emptiness very clearly and in the right way, then the person receives numbers of benefits from practicing the emptiness. If the person creates a wrong thought by saying that this teaching is not a good teaching, it just exaggerates all the Saying something is because the teaching says something exists which is not in fact and it says and something doesn’t exist which fact it does exist.
That sort of wrong thought comes out of the lack of understanding. If one develops a genuine such thought, then one cultivates huge negativities. So you should try to pay good attention and listen to the teaching with a neutral state of mind and openness of mind. And the beginning of the teaching or beginning of the text, there are numbers of discourses about the history of how the teaching was set forth before or after Ananda and so forth, as we don’t have much time, we better not spend much time on all this investigation or discourses on when the teaching was set forth. So we go to start from the main actual part.
Now, with respect the second main subdivisions, which is called the explanation of the text, and it has two subdivisions: the preliminary and the actual parts. So now the first one is called the meaning of the title and it’s been called in Sanskrit, it’s called the Bhagavati Prajñāpāramitā Hridaya, whereas in Tibetan it’s called the heart of the Chomden Dema, the victorious perfection of wisdom. So the translation of the Sanskrit word, Bhagavati Prajñāpāramitā Hridaya. The Bhagavati is called the great destroyer, Prajñāpāramitā, the wisdom gone beyond, and here they are called the essence. So it’s called the Chomden Dema, the great destroyer.
So what it destroys is called the four maras and called the maras of disturbing emotions, maras of death, maras of devas, maras of body, which means that the four maras, the disturbing emotions like hatred, anger, which causes disturbance in our practices, as well as the second mara is called death, that without giving any time to practice and without independent one passes or one does, and the mara of body, which means we face difficulty of tiredness to practice and feeling tired, getting sick and so forth, and it’s called the mara of body. The mara of devas, which means they are the external spirit or devil which causes harms. When one does the practice, they are the external causes like the devils which set forth to be sending arrows towards us which encourages us to let us go through the sleep while in the practice and so forth. So the Tibetan word is called Chomden Dema, which means mother beyond or destroyer, which means it destroys all the four maras and it is with the qualities which means the qualities, the teaching qualities of six perfections and so forth. Gone means it’s gone beyond sorrow in which sorrow is called the disturbing emotions.
Because of this having disturbing emotions and through ignorance and so forth we cultivate numbers of actions which lead us into suffering. So it is beyond the suffering or beyond the sorrow and called mother. So here, it’s Chomden De which was one of the names of the Buddha in the Tibetan word, but here the Chomden doesn’t mean the Buddha, it means to us the wisdom realizing wisdom directly realizing emptiness which we said before, which is the mother of all Buddhas of three times. So, Chomden Dema Sherabki Paroltu Chinpa Chomden Dema, which means the great destroyer mother which is wisdom gone beyond. And it’s been called the heart, the teaching has been called the heart as well.
It is because, for example, there are the numbers of awareness or consciousness which pervades our entire body, but the main source of that consciousness or awareness is at the heart. It merges from the heart and where it also gathers at the heart. So likewise, the emptiness, the wisdom realizing emptiness is the heart of the teaching. The numbers of teachings that have been set forth are taught by the great master Buddha, Śākyamūni, saying the sutras and the tantric teachings, but all the essence of the teaching is the wisdom directly realizing emptiness is the gist of all entire teaching. Therefore it’s been called heart.
So, the reason why title has been given to the text is because it is to realize what the teaching contains. It is, for example, like a person we are labeled or given a name to a person and because of that name we recognize who the person is and say he or she has arrived, and such and such is gone. It’s because the purpose of giving the name is to recognize who the person is. But this title of the text is not given or not set forth by the Buddha Śākyamūni, it’s been set forth or produced by the translators who translate it in Sanskrit as well as in Tibetan. So as for the wisdom going beyond, it’s set forth to be three types that are called the path going beyond, the text going beyond, and the wisdom going beyond or like resultant going beyond of wisdom.
So it has been said for because the actual wisdom going beyond is the wisdom directly realizing. Emptiness is the main resultant one. So the parts which the bodhisattva paths, the five paths of the great vehicle as the mantra goes, Gate Gate Pāragate which shows the five paths. Those paths have been called the wisdom gone beyond of through which, through those paths, one attains or one realizes or gains that wisdom realizing truly and directly realizing emptiness. The text which all the path has been instructed or been given is called the perfected or gone beyond text.
So the first two gone beyond, the path and the text, are set forth to be a method to attain the wisdom directly realizing emptiness and the resultant gone beyond which is the actual one, that wisdom directly realizes emptiness. So, for example, if you go through the mantra itself, gate gate paragate parasangate bodhi svaha, the bodhi svaha is the actual resultant going beyond, which is wisdom directly realizing emptiness. And up till parasangate, from gate gate paragate parasangate, those four are called the path, the going beyond, which is the path through which one attains the wisdom directly realizing emptiness. And the text which consists of all these teachings of the five paths has been called the text gone beyond. So as for the texts, there are set forth to be numbers of texts that are more than 100 volume texts.
Within the 100, the main, there are 21 volumes which specifically set forth the teachings of emptiness. And within the 21 topics or 21 volumes, they set forth the three textual teachings the wisdom perfection sūtra in three versions of the large, medium, and the short versions. So as for the three versions of large, medium, and short wisdom perfection sūtra, the the large one, has the 100,000 shlokas in Tibetan words. So shloka has the different ways of counting. For example, like the one verse saying the refuge verse, the true Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, I go refuge until the attainment of enlightenment for the sake of entire sentient beings, and such verse, just the one four lines has been set forth to be guess considered to be one shloka.
The large version of the wisdom perfection sūtra consists of 100,000 verses and the medium one has 20,000, the short one has 8,000. So the perfection sūtra, the Buddha Śākyamūni taught at Vulture Peak, Rajgir in India was this perfection sūtra of large, medium, and short versions. So the Essence Heart Sūtra is the text which consists of entire gist or the essence teachings of the large, medium, and the short wisdom perfection Sūtra. The Buddha Śākyamūni, at Vulture Peak, he doesn’t teach only Heart Sutras there. He taught all the large medium and the short discourses of the perfection wisdom sūtra.
And how Buddha Śākyamūni gave the teaching of perfection, wisdom, sūtra at Vulture Peak. If one asks that question then there are different types of disciples in the Vulture’s Peak during that time that the disciples of great middling and the sharp faculty and the middling and the lowest. Normal. So as there are different types of the disciples within the audience and those with the sharp faculty do not need to receive the very detailed teaching just by starting there will be the teachings coming up on the later part of the text of teachings on five aggregates, 12 sources, 18 constituents, and so forth, and those with the sharp faculties, just by explaining the first one of the five aggregates, the person understands the rest without explaining. And for the middling one has to be more explanation, and for the last one, then we need to go one by one.
So therefore, because there are the different levels, three types of levels of the faculty within the disciples, the teachings of great middling and the short version comes. But when Buddha gives the teaching, he does not need to give the teaching separate for the sharp faculty and the middling and the small or lowest one. Buddha teaches all three types of disciples at once. For example, like saying, likewise all the five aggregates are also not truly existent or not inherently existent. So just by the word saying, the reason of saying each and every word in Tibetan called dik kyang also not inherently existent, just by their word, the person with the sharp faculty understands the rest of the teachings because of the sharpness of the faculty, whereas the middle and lowest faculty will not understand straight away but understand there are remaining topics as well and they gradually train and take longer time to realize or understand, but the Buddha taught them all three types of disciples at once.
So, yeah, and for Buddha, Buddha has very unique power that because he has achieved enlightenment, therefore he has omniscient wisdom, a mind which realizes all the teachings and has attained speech which can express all the teachings. So therefore, when he taught in the audience in number of 100, if he said the I is impermanent, and within the disciples they have different thoughts, individual thoughts, and what they will hear is according they will hear the teaching according to their wish or what they want to hear. For example, if he said the I is impermanent, those who want to know that, understand about the impermanence of the I will hear the teachings on impermanence of the I, and those who wish for the I is suffering can hear about the suffering, and those for whom those who wish who want to understand on the selflessness nature of the I will hear the selflessness teaching, and those who wish to know about the emptiness nature of the I will hear the teaching on emptiness. So, likewise, the 100 people can ask the question at once to Buddha and for him, by giving one answer, will give the answer according to the different questions at once.
He doesn’t need to listen to each and every one taking a turn. So now there are a number of discourses about establishing the size of the text and where so it’s in Tibetan word called shloka and the bampo two words. The shloka is set forth to be one full line one verse, and the bampo is the size of the text. The bampo is the size of the text, so there are numbers, different ways of counting the size of the bampo. Some texts say one bampo includes 300 verses, some say it’s 900 verses.
According to the Heart Sūtra, the Heart Sūtra is said to consist of 25 shlokas, which is one bampo. So the reason explaining the size of the text or the bampo is because to realize the greatness of the text, saying that ancient times, how many bampos are in this text, or somebody who composed it, if it says five bampos, it’s a short one, if it’s got 300, it’s a great one. It is like if we say, he or she has million dollar on his rich person. So in terms of wisdom gone beyond, there’s the gone beyond has the four types of gone beyond.
The being so, it’s called the superior, the ultimate, the nirvana, and the knowledge. We set forth the superior is the going beyond a common being is called the superior being, who is gone beyond the ordinary or common being that when one realizes the emptiness not realizes, say, the understanding, the teachings of the emptiness is called the person who’s gone beyond the ordinary being, which is the first gone beyond. And the second one is called the ultimate, which is called the beyond the conventional. Beyond the conventional is the ultimate, the gone beyond. And the third one is the attaining nirvana is called the nirvana which has gone beyond the cyclic existence.
And the last going beyond is knowledge, which is going beyond ignorance. So in terms of the wisdom going beyond, in the Buddhist schools of tenets they are set forth to be four schools of the Buddhist tenets called the Particularists and the Sutrantika schools, and particularly the two are the Cittamātra and the Madhyamaka school, so the Mind Only school and the Middle Way school. About the wisdom going beyond so those first two classes are the schools of the Hīnayāna school and the next two, the mind only and the middle way schools are the Mahāyāna school. So the wisdom going beyond is only set forth within the Mahāyāna teaching Mahāyāna schools of Chittamatrin and Madhyamaka, the middle way schools. And there are two ways of establishing the view of emptiness within those two schools.
The mind only school says the difference in considering the wisdom realizing emptiness or wisdom going beyond, and the only establishes the wisdom realizing emptiness different than the Middle Way school. The mind only schools, the wisdom of nondual subject and object is the wisdom which realizes emptiness or the wisdom going beyond, whereas in the Madhyamaka, the middle way school, is the or the way of establishing emptiness is the emptiness nature of not existing, not inherently existent is the emptiness of in middle way school. So today we spend our class to explain on about explaining the meaning of the title of a name, and from the next week we start the actual part of the teaching starting from the text Thus I have heard, and so and so. And now, here we conclude the class, and it is good to, know, very fortunate of you to have the chance to receive the emptiness teaching and the emptiness teaching is very profound and it is also the wisdom realizing emptiness is also the seed or is like a method to attain enlightenment, so therefore for the betterment, if you realize the emptiness through the teaching, which is very, very good, even if you don’t realize the emptiness directly by listening to the teaching, there is still a huge benefit of listening to the emptiness teaching.
By listening to the emptiness teaching, you sow a seed inside or implant a seed within your mind stream and in future just by hearing the emptiness teaching which becomes like water to the seed and on the basis of that seed of emptiness, just by hearing and teaching one will realize the emptiness quickly and quickly and as a result of that one will overcome all this get rid of the sufferings and attain happiness and become arhat or attain arhathood, bodhisattvahood, can become Buddha. And then in future, just by hearing the word emptiness, one feels very developed with huge joy and happy, and out of that joy and happiness, automatically tears come out of your eyes and then all the hairs of the body stand on end and you have such feelings and those who have such feelings have a seed to become enlightened or become enlightened, yes. Okay. So at this stage, it’s quite squashed here and it’s a bit hot and you have a bit you suffer a little bit here, but the result of bearing this suffering is huge. In the future, you will have a great benefit of doing this, and we suffer a little by working hard outside so forth, but the result or happiness of that hardship is much, much smaller than what you did right now here.
Okay. We’ll take a couple of questions. The consciousness that moves on, the mind stream, does that No, it doesn’t exist on its side. It’s not a single phenomenon which exists on its own accord or on If it exists on its own side or its own if it exists inherently or by its own accord or entity, then there is no emptiness. Because it doesn’t exist on its side therefore the entity comes In terms of listening, it sounds like the observer in the sense could be called the apperception or self-awareness which observes the internal phenomena.
There’s different ways of saying except for the middle way school, the rest, they agree with a word called rang rig, self-awareness which realizes the internal phenomenas, whereas the middle way school, they don’t agree with such. They said that the consciousness itself or the wisdom itself, the works or realizes the things, it’s not something different. Yes. The middle way called the Consequentialist school yeah So the emptiness here, doesn’t mean the empty like a space and so forth. What it means actually its meaning is empty means it’s empty or free of its negation, which means that the negation of the emptiness is the existing by its own characteristic is the negation.
So the things do not exist by its own characteristics, is called the emptiness in which it is free of existing by its own characteristic, that’s called the emptiness. It’s not something to do with the space. So therefore in the Heart Sūtra text, all the five aggregates are not inherently existent. It means one should see them as not inherently existent, which means that the five aggregates who do not exist on their own characteristic or exist by their own accord, and that doesn’t exist on their own accord is the emptiness of the five aggregates. Good.
Very good.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- four maras du zhi (Tib)
- The four external and internal hindrances or obstacles to our spiritual progress. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.