46 min · 2,532 words · 25 August 1992
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk is a commentary on the Heart Sutra explaining that the wisdom of meditative equipoise on emptiness perceives no sense objects, sense faculties, or consciousnesses, and no twelve links. It then sets out the twelve sources and eighteen elements and explains how the twelve links of dependent origination, from ignorance through to grasping, perpetuate cyclic existence.
File metadata (for organising)
Date: 1992-08-25
Duration: 46 min
UUID: b9af0ca8-e95e-476f-9346-d682c3f84c6a
Words: 2,532
No. And he said that if conventional phenomena, conventionalities, appear to the superior’s meditative equipoise on emptiness, then phenomena would necessarily be truly existent. Because conventionalities do not appear to a superior wisdom of meditative equipoise on emptiness indicates that they do not truly exist. So as it has been, as it is stated in the text, that because conventionalities do not, that the the only object which appears to the wisdom of meditative equipoise on emptiness over the ten grounds is emptiness. Therefore, for such a wisdom, there is no form, no feeling, no perceptions, no mental constructions, and no consciousnesses.
And it goes on to list the fact that for such a wisdom consciousness, there is no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind. That is to say, the six inner faculties because they’re contained within the continuum of the individual, their inner faculties or inner powers. And the text goes on to say, that there are no forms. Here it says there are no spheres of the eye. No, it doesn’t.
It doesn’t say. Anyway, the Tibetan: there are no forms, no sounds, no smells, no tastes, no objects of touch, no phenomena. And it says there are no forms. That is to say, there are no objects of the eye consciousness. The objects of eye consciousness are visible forms such as which are constituted of shapes and colors and colors and shapes such as red, white, short, long, various shapes. There are none of these.
And it goes on to say that there are no sounds. Our translation doesn’t have these. That is to say, there are objects of the ear consciousness, that is to say sounds. There are various types of sounds, such as pleasant sounds, unpleasant sounds, articulate sounds, and sounds which have meaning, inarticulate sounds, which are sounds which do not have meaning, such as the sound of a bell, etcetera. And there are no objects of the nose consciousness, that is to say smells.
The various types of smells, pleasant smells, unpleasant smells. There are inherent smells such as — or I guess natural, natural smells such as the smell of sandalwood, and there are artificial smells and odors which are compounded, aren’t natural to the object. With the nose consciousness, we are able to be aware of smells. We we we aren’t with the eye consciousness. So there are no objects of the nose consciousness such as smells.
And there are no objects of the tongue consciousness, that is to say taste, the various types of taste, such as sweet, sour, astringent, and hot. There are no objects of touch. That is to say objects of — there are no objects of the body consciousness. That is to say objects of touch. There are no objects of touch.
Objects of touch are not experienced by the eye consciousness or by the ear consciousness, by nose consciousness, by tongue consciousness. Objects of touch are experienced by the body consciousness. And such types of objects as smooth, rough, heavy, these are objects of touch. It goes on to say that there are no phenomena. And these are a class of objects which are not known by the sense faculties.
That is, such types of objects such as emptiness, selflessness, impermanence, past and future lives, liberation, omniscience, the four noble truths. These are known, but they are not known by the sense faculties. By what are they known? They are known by the mental consciousness. So there are no objects of the mental consciousness such as these phenomena.
So what we have just listed are external phenomena, or they’re termed external sources. They are not contained within the continuum of the being. If they are in some way damaged, the being does not experience any sort of pain. On the other hand, the prior listing in terms of there are no eye, no ear, no nose, etcetera, those organs, those faculties, are all contained within the continuum of the being, the six internal sources. So the reason that these are termed sources is by the combining of these two, the object, the external source, and the internal source, the sense power, a consciousness is generated.
That is to say that these two act as the source of consciousnesses. For example, by the eye sense power or faculty coming in contact with visual forms, a consciousness apprehending forms is generated. By the ear sense faculty combining with sound, an ear consciousness apprehending sound is generated. So there there are six consciousnesses. There is the eye consciousness which knows visible forms, ear consciousness which knows sounds, nose consciousness which knows smells, tongue consciousness which knows flavors, body consciousness which knows tangible objects, and the mental consciousness which knows phenomena.
These six consciousnesses arise dependent upon the combining of the six external and six internal sources. And then there are — so these are what I term the twelve sources. But there’s additionally a listing called the twelve — the eighteen elements. Here, they’re called spheres. Eighteen elements.
So there are the eighteen elements. So these are simply another labeling where we can label. For example, the eye sense power is referred to as the eye element. Then there’s the ear sense power is referred to as the ear element. Nose, tongue, body, mental sense power referred to as the mental element. Then there are the objects of each of these.
The object of the eye element is form, and this is referred to as the form element. So the object of the eye sense power, which is visible form, is referred to as the form element. So then there are six objects, which are a grouping of six. Eye element, form element, sound element, odor element, taste element, tangible element, and phenomenal element. This is — in the case in the English language, they call this a flower.
In Tibetan language, they call it a metok. It’s different distinct names, but having the same meaning. And then there’s the listing of the six consciousnesses, each of them referred to as elements. There’s the eye consciousness element, ear consciousness element, nose consciousness element, tongue consciousness element, body consciousness element, and mental consciousness element, six consciousness elements. So there are three groupings of six.
There is the six sense faculties, the eye sense faculty, etcetera, the objects of each of these sense faculties, the form, and then the consciousness which is generated by the combination. So there is the — these are referred to, each of these are referred to as elements: the sense faculties such as the eye are referred to as the eye element, etcetera. The objects of these, the form, is referred to as the form element, etcetera. And the consciousnesses generated are the consciousness elements such as the eye consciousness element, etcetera, making a total of eighteen elements. So we have this listing of twelve sources and eighteen elements.
And though, actually, they have the same sense. They’re just different names. Though they have different names, they have the same sense in their meaning of what they’re referring to. We said that the sources have the idea that by the coming together, the combining of the sources, these act as a source for the generation of consciousnesses, therefore the name sources. The idea of the term element is that these, such as the eye sense faculty, that they have a similar type, that they are perpetuating a similar type with respect to themselves.
They are elemental. The eye sense faculty gives rise to another moment of an eye sense faculty, which gives rise to another moment of an eye sense faculty. So the result is similar in type to the previous, and there’s these continuums of the same elemental type, therefore termed element. So for the wisdom of meditative equipoise on emptiness over the ten grounds, these twelve sources and eighteen elements do not exist for that consciousness. Then it goes on to say there are no twelve links of dependent origination. For such a consciousness, there are no twelve links of dependent origination.
There are no twelve links of dependent origination. The twelve links of dependent origination are first ignorance, then actions, then consciousness, then name and form, and sources, contact, feeling, attachment, grasping, existence, birth, aging, and death. So this is the process which perpetuates cyclic existence. That all of what we are listing thus far, the sources, the elements, are established independently by the power of karma for ordinary beings. Therefore, all of these within cyclic existence are termed to be true sufferings.
And the twelve links of dependent origination are the means by which they are brought into existence. So the twelve links of dependent origination describe how the process by which the cycle of existence comes into being. It initially arises in dependence upon ignorance or misknowledge. That is to say, a lack of understanding of the nature of phenomena, a bewilderment due to which which acts as a motivation for engaging in actions, that is to say karma. Due to bewilderment of ignorance, we act — it acts as a motivation, we engage in actions, that is to say we create karma, all the various types of karma, negative karma, positive karma, and neutral karma.
Karma, that is the action, is a mental factor, a secondary mental factor, and therefore is momentarily arising and disintegrating. But the action leaves an impression, that is a latency of the potential of this action on the consciousness. So there is a latency implanted on the consciousness. So we have latencies of various types. There are skillful latencies, unskillful latencies, neutral latencies. So we have a consciousness which has implanted within it various latencies.
So we now have a consciousness which — so we’re talking about the third of these twelve links of dependent origination. And this third link is consciousness, but consciousness more than simply consciousness, consciousness which has implanted within it various latencies of past actions. And this third link, consciousness, has two parts. There is the causal consciousness and the effect consciousness. The cause consciousness is the consciousness which was present at the time of the commission of the action. That is to say, the consciousness wherein the action was implanted. And then the effect consciousness — this is the consciousness which, after having taken rebirth, for example, if the being were to take rebirth as a human, having a relationship with a particular parent, the consciousness which has entered into a particular union of sperm and ovum.
That consciousness is the effect consciousness. Then the consciousness, the effect consciousness having entered into the combination of sperm and ovum. There then begins the development of the embryo. First, it’s in a very liquid state, and slowly after two to three weeks, the zygote begins to firm, become firmer, to take shape, firm, solidify, yeah, solidify. And it’s at this point then it’s referred to as name and form, the fourth link, name and form.
The form is the actual physical mass. The name is used to refer to the latter four of the five aggregates. They are not physical. They are referred to with the term name, form and name. Then as the fetus begins to develop about the seventh week of gestation, there begins to form the limbs.
The limbs, the arms, legs, and the head begin to differentiate from the mass. And the sources, the inner sources, the — so the faculties of the eye, ear, nose, tongue begin to form. This fifth link is referred to as sources. The sources are now being expressed, manifesting, beginning to take shape.
Once the sources are formed, then the eye sees external objects. That is to say, various sense faculties begin to experience their respective objects, such as visible forms, sounds, smells, odors, smells, tastes, and objects of touch. This experiencing of the sense faculties with their objects is the sixth link, which is called contact, where the external and internal sources come together. There’s this contact. Probably during while the child is developing in the womb, there’s no eye consciousness generated.
But there would be, for example, a body — what do I say, body consciousness generated. Because, for example, if the mother drinks hot tea or if she becomes cold, the child feels a sensation of warmth or coldness. And therefore the body consciousness is generated in dependence on this contact. And in dependence upon contact arises the seventh link of dependent origination, that is to say feelings, pleasurable feelings, painful feelings. For example, if the fetus becomes hot, it experiences a painful feeling and different feelings.
And in dependence upon feeling, the eighth link. In dependence upon the feelings, the eighth link arises, which is attachment. Sometimes it is translated as craving, attachment or craving. And there are two types. There is the attachment which desires the object, and there is attachment which desires to be separated from the object, depending upon whether the feeling which is experienced is pleasant or unpleasant, that one of those two varieties of attachment or craving will arise.
According to a verse by Vasubandhu, in dependence upon the three types of feeling, there arises the three types of attachment giving rise to three types of afflictive emotions. In dependence upon pleasurable feelings arises a craving desire, a craving which generates attachment, we can say just a desire, a craving attachment. In dependence upon feelings of suffering, there arises a craving to be separated from which arises the afflictive emotion of anger. In dependence upon indifferent feelings, arises a confusion, which gives rise to the bewilderment of ignorance.
Then, so in dependence upon feelings, attachment or craving arises. In dependence upon craving, grasping. That is to say, the ninth link arises. Grasping, the ninth link. So grasping is a form of craving or a form of attachment, but it’s a highly increased form.
So the difference between attachment and grasping is simply a matter of degrees of the power of the craving or the attachment. Both are attachment or craving but it’s an increasing power. It is due to this grasping that this ninth link grasping is like pouring water on seeds. It serves to activate the previously implanted karma, karmic potentials within the consciousness. Grasping serves to activate, like watering a seed, the previously implanted karmic latencies within the consciousness.
So at the eighth link, from moving from the eighth to the ninth, there was an increase in the force of the attachment or the craving which would serve to, at the ninth level, to activate the karmic latencies. Now, there are three types of karmic latencies which could be activated. These would be latencies of skillful actions, unskillful actions, and unspecified actions. And the unspecified actions have little power to determine the rebirth. So the type of rebirth is going to be determined by either the skillful or the unskillful action, the latencies of these which are being activated.
So these latencies are being activated at the ninth level, at the ninth link at grasping. Then at the tenth link, the latency is just ready to express
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.