44 min · 2,185 words · 30 June 1992 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 45-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche shows how to understand the Heart Sūtra’s central claim—that the five aggregates are empty of inherent existence—through the practice of dependent arising. Rather than treating emptiness as abstract philosophy, he explains why dependent arising is the Buddha’s primary method for realizing emptiness without falling into the extremes of nihilism or eternalism. He grounds the teaching in a vivid analogy: a face reflected in a mirror arises only when both mirror and face are present; each aggregate (form, feelings, perception, mental formations, consciousness) similarly arises only in dependence on causes and conditions. He then presents three levels of understanding dependent arising, from the basic (causality) to the most subtle (all phenomena are merely imputed by concepts), the latter unique to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school. For practitioners with some background in Buddhist philosophy.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1992-06-30 – Side 2 – KR.MP3
UUID: 89456c4b-5969-42cb-b744-207125863e8d
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Heart Sūtra
Date: 1992-06-30
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,182
Taking the five aggregates as the basis for meditating, for the meditation of emptiness to proceed on. And that these, we’re looking at the five aggregates in terms of their emptiness, that they’re empty of a mode of abidance of existing from their own side. They’re empty of self defining, self definition. And why are the are the five aggregates empty? Because in dependence upon causes and conditions and the parts, they are merely imputed by conception.
So because the five aggregates are merely imputed by conceptions and reliance upon their parts and causes and conditions, therefore they are empty of existing from their own side. As was mentioned previously, in quoting from Je Tsongkhapa where he said that the main method which was set forth by the Buddha in coming to an understanding of emptiness is dependent arising. And here we have just presented the dependent arising in terms of the explanation that because phenomena are merely imputed by conception, it relies upon their parts and causes and conditions. Therefore, they must be empty of inherent or natural existence. The dependent arising is taught because for those initially meditating on emptiness, it’s extremely useful.
It’s very beneficial and one cannot be led astray. There will be no fault in terms of one’s meditation. So the reason dependent arising is of great benefit. But there is a degree of difference in degrees of subtlety of presentation of dependent arising. There are at least three different degrees of subtlety with respect to dependent arising as presented.
The first is that of causes and conditions. And the reason of dependent arising in terms of causes and conditions is it commonly asserted by all tenet systems or philosophic systems of Buddhism, whether it be the Great Exposition School, the Sūtra School, the Mind Only School, the Middle Way School. But a more subtle presentation of dependent arising is in terms of parts. That is to say that phenomena are established in dependence upon their parts. And this is an uncommon assertion of dependent arising.
The uncommon assertion is dependent arising of the middle way school. So the middle way school presents an uncommon assertion as to a dependent arising in terms of phenomena are established dependent upon their parts. But the most subtle presentation of the meaning of dependent arising is set forth exclusively by the Consequentialist Middle Way school. And this is presented in terms of that all phenomena are dependent arising because they are merely imputed by way of terms and concepts, that all phenomena are merely imputed by means of terms and concepts. This assertion, the most subtle presentation of the dependent arising, is exclusive to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka school.
So the common assertion, the assertion which is common to all the tenet systems, that is to say dependent arising as meaning relying upon causes and conditions, is made use of throughout the method and wisdom of the universal vehicle. That, for example, we say that the five aggregates do not naturally exist because they are dependent arising. In here, we can always consistently make use of the interpretation of dependent arising as meaning because of relying upon causes and conditions. Not only that, but by means of the reason of dependent arising, as meaning arising in dependence upon causes and conditions, we can set forth the presentations of actions as causes and their results. The whole sequence of cause and result arises out of this interpretation of dependent arising.
If we understand this interpretation of dependent arising, then we can proceed in our meditation on emptiness without any danger. That is to say, if not understanding the way to proceed in meditation and emptiness, there is some danger of falling to either two extremes, the extreme of nihilism or the extreme of eternalism. And by understanding the presentation of dependent arising as meaning arising in dependence upon causes and conditions, we can understand the actions in terms of their acting as causes, bringing about results, and thereby we eliminate the possibility of falling to the extreme of nihilism. And if we understand that the five aggregates are empty of natural existence, then we will not default to the extreme of eternalism. So this is, in seeking to follow the middle way, we are seeking not to abide in either of the two extremes.
If we abide in either nihilism or eternalism, then we have missed the middle way. By not abiding either of these two extremes, that is to say taking a central position between these two, then we are abiding in the middle way or Madhyamaka, which would be very good. One is an expert at the Middle Way. Great. And in becoming an expert in the middle way, one would be likened to those such as Nāgārjuna, Śāntideva, and Candrakīrti.
So, is one of the benefits that arises from using dependent arising as a reason establishing emptiness. But the other benefit to be derived by making use of dependent arising as a reason is that emptiness and dependent arising mutually assist one another. That is to say, one’s understanding of emptiness will assist one in coming to an understanding of dependent arising, and one’s understanding of dependent arising will assist one in coming to an understanding of emptiness. Therefore, it’s extremely excellent to proceed in one’s meditation in terms of dependent arising. And how would one proceed in meditating that way?
Beginning with the subject, the five aggregates, they do not naturally exist because in relying upon causes and conditions, are dependent arising. Because of the reason dependent arising in terms of that the five aggregates rely upon their existence, the existence of the five aggregates relies upon causal conditions, then we are able to negate the five aggregates being independently existent, self-definingly existent, or truly existent. If something is dependent arising, its existence relies upon something other than itself. If the existence of something relies upon something other than itself, then it cannot inherently exist. It cannot exist by way of its own nature.
What we mean by inherently existent or a naturally existent, we mean a way of existing which does not rely upon any other factor outside of itself. It exists independent of everything else. But the very fact of dependent arising is mutually exclusive with the possibility of being independently existent. That these two, independently existent and independently existent, are mutually exclusive. For example, we’re always looking in the mirror.
And when we look in the mirror, we see the reflection of our face. The reflection of our face in the mirror arises in dependence upon causal conditions. We need, for that reflection to come about, we need a mirror and we need a face. If we had a mirror but no face, then a reflection of a face would not arise. On the other hand, if we had a face but no mirror, then a reflection of the face would not arise.
So we need both of these conditions in order for this reflection of the face to come about. The reflection of a face in a mirror, the existence of the reflection of a face in the mirror relies upon a mirror and a face. And dependence upon these two, the reflection of a face arises. But if, on the other hand, if the reflection a face were naturally existent, then it would not rely upon anything other than itself for its existence. It would somehow appear like the rising of the sun out of nowhere.
If our reflection of our face was always appearing to us, we wouldn’t like that in the least. Even when we didn’t look in the mirror, there was always this reflection of our face appearing to us. So the reflection of our face in fact arises in dependence. It’s a dependent arising. So we can take as our subject, the reflection of our face of the mirror, it does not naturally exist, or let us say it does not define itself, it does not inherently exist.
Why? Because it is a dependent arising. Why is it a dependent arising? Because it relies for its existence on face and on the mirror. So we use this reflection in the face of the mirror as an illustration.
Taking it back to the main subject that we’re discussing, the aggregates, we can then proceed to say that the aggregates, they do not naturally exist because they are dependent arising. That is to say, they arise in dependence upon causes and conditions. And if we look at the aggregate forms, the aggregate of forms arises in dependence upon causes and conditions. It arises in dependence upon the sperm and ovum of the mother and father. It arises in dependence upon food, arises in dependence upon the aggregation of various elements, such as the earth, water, fire, and wind energy elements.
It relies upon all those factors for its existence. Again, the aggregate of feelings. Relies upon various sensations, good and bad, attractive and unattractive sensations. It relies upon earlier and later moments of consciousness and dependence upon those acting as causes and conditions, then aggregate of feelings arises. So it is also a dependent arising.
Therefore, we can say that the five aggregates do not naturally exist because they rely upon causal, they are dependent arising in that they rely upon causal conditions just as reflection in the mirror of a face relies upon causal conditions. If we proceed in this way, then we will eventually come to realization of emptiness. If we don’t proceed in meditating in this way, then we won’t realize emptiness. So if we want to look at others who have actually realized emptiness, can look to the Buddhas, Avalokiteśvara, Ārya Tārā, Mañjuśrī, they all realize emptiness by proceeding in this fashion and there’s no reason that we ourselves cannot achieve this. We will not be able to if we are not able to meditate in this way.
In the future teachings we’ll be continuing where it says form is emptiness, emptiness is form, etcetera, the extensive method whereby to meditate, proceed on meditation on emptiness. We’re going to stop there and if you have some questions, we’ll take some questions. But just in general, during the break, you should meditate on emptiness and come back with your realizations. You should at least come back with the idea, wow, one thing is very strange. Okay.
So there’s a relationship between your understanding of the aggregates and your understanding of the object of negation in terms of the aggregates. One makes use of conventionalities in order to come to an understanding of the ultimate. In this respect, the conventionalities are the aggregates. So in the syllogism, the five aggregates do not truly exist because they are dependent arising. In order to to generate the wisdom which understands dependent arising, it’s necessary to have the wisdom which understands what the five aggregates are.
So there’s a relationship between one’s understanding in terms of the subtlety of one’s understanding of the five aggregates and the subtlety of one’s understanding of emptiness of the five aggregates. Yeah. So the object of negation is inherently existing aggregates, forms,. Feelings. Feelings.
That’s the object of negation. Do you want an example? Whenever we look at the table, the table appears to be inherently existent. And the same would hold true for our feelings. Whatever feelings arise, be they pleasurable or displeasurable, various feelings are arising from time to time.
And they appear to us to exist from their own side objectively and not to be imputed by means of terms and concepts. When you eat a piece of cake, you get a pleasurable feeling. That pleasurable feeling appears to you to be existing from its own side and not to be dependent upon being imputed by terms and concepts. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. Do you mean by ultimate nature?
How come we have to experience bad karma? If it is because our actions do not inherently exist that we undergo the experience of the result, such as in the case of an unskillful action. The unskillful action is empty of inherent existence. And therefore, it is able to give rise to a result, that is the experience of suffering. If on the other hand, actions were inherently existent, then they would not give rise to any result.
Or even if they were, even if an inherently existent result in suffering existed, it would have no relationship to the action. It would be independent. The causes and results would be independent of one another. They would not exist in relationship to one another. It’s only because actions do not inherently exist or empty of inherent existence that they are able to give rise to results.
The mind is able to realize the mind. You know your own mind. I’m thinking this. Today I had some skillful thoughts. Today I had some unskillful thoughts.
This is the mind understanding itself. Is emptiness a nonexistent phenomenon? Is that right, Raj? Emptiness is not nonexistent.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.