Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 23082016Salam – KR.mp3
UUID: 67cba696-7616-43dd-811a-9615c6b82000
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 43m
Words: 5,206
So, one way of looking at the transitions is as follows. There is a transition or realizations which lead from those who have not entered the path to those who enter the path of accumulation. Then there are transitions or realizations leading from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, from the path of preparation to the path of seeing, from the path of seeing to the path of meditation, and from the path of meditation to the path of normal learning. So the transition from one who has not entered the path to the first moment of the path of accumulation is quite similar to that from the being of the small scope to the path shared with the being of the middling scope. So, therefore, just as the generation of uncontrived definite emergence heralds the entry in the path shared with the being of the middling scope.
Likewise, broadly speaking, the generation of uncontrived definite emergence heralds the passage from being a being who has not entered the path to one who has entered the path of accumulation. Now this is very broadly speaking since indeed, there one must analyze carefully whether the mere generation of uncontrived definite emergence is sufficient to have entered the path of accumulation or not. What are the components of, a thought of uncontrived definite emergence? It is first, a rejection of the predilection, for cyclic existence to understanding its thoughts. And secondly, a heartfelt deep aspiration for liberation.
So this is as far as the uncontrived thought of definite emergence is concerned. Now, in as much as definite emergence is a consciousness, it is either conceptual or non conceptual. Which of the two is it? It is definitely exclusively conceptual. So I would suspect that you understand what uncontrived definite emergence is and in as much as it is a consciousness, consciousness is subdivided exclusively into conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses.
This is an exhaustive division. And here, the uncontrived thought of definite emergence is exclusively conceptual. So, conceptuality is divided between conceptions which recollect past events and conceptions which anticipate future events. Now, these two, where would uncontrived definite emergence fit? It is a conception which anticipates future events.
And within minds which anticipate future events, probably without any exception, all are conceptual. So this should make it easier for all of us, shouldn’t it? Once one understands what the characteristics of uncontrived thoughts of definite emergence are, that they are focused on the future and so forth, their understanding becomes easier. So conceptions are very straightforward to understand here. The uncontrived mind of definite emergence is as we said a conception.
In other words, it is a mind which is blended with a meaning generality, with an which is nothing else but an image to a conceptual mind, an image to an ideation. An image of what? We have attended many teachings. We have heard many times about liberations, about permanent states of happiness. Then obviously, on the basis of this, we construct a mental image of the state, and the striving for that mental image of what corresponds to that mental image is nothing else but definite emergence.
So now within the sevenfold divisions of minds from Loric, which you are probably all familiar with, where does the mind of definite emergence fit? It is probably a conviction, and within the fivefold subdivision of convictions, it is a reasonless conviction, a conviction without a reason, since it is in that respect quite different from the mind which believes that sound is impermanent, which is based on a reason. Here, one is striving for liberation, but actually it is difficult to give a logical or rational grounding for this. So therefore, this uncontrived sort of definite emergence is conceptual and remains conceptual throughout until one attains full enlightenment and obviously in the mind of a fully enlightened being, it is non conceptual, but we shall not talk about that here. Now, why is it conceptual throughout?
Because it is an aspiration. It is a wish. It is not a mind which is involved in the detailed analysis of its object. Do you understand? So, you do understand therefore what an uncontrived, thoughtful mind of definite emergence is.
It is a mind which after focusing repeatedly on the defects of cyclic existence, in an effortless way strives for liberation. Now, once such a mind has been generated, broadly speaking without entering into the details, one has entered the path of accumulation. So once we generate such a mind within our mind stream, we will have become someone who has entered the path and within the five paths, someone who has entered the path of accumulation. So, if one analyzes this from the standpoint of the Lamrim, then this transition from being a being who has not entered the path to one who has entered the path occurs when one passes from the path shared with the being of the small scope to the path shared with the being of the middling scope. Generally speaking, we differentiate salam and the lambe and we are unable to link them or relate them, but the meaning is exactly the same.
Now, when one passes from the path of accumulation, in other words, great path of accumulation to the path of preparation. What is meant here is that the path of accumulation becomes the path of preparation. Turns into the path of preparation. Whereas the transition from being a person who has not entered the path to the path of accumulation is contingent on the realization of the generation of uncontrived definite emergence. From that point onwards, the transition from the path of preparation, the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, the path of preparation to the path of seeing, and maybe the path of seeing to the path of meditation are all contingent on meditation on emptiness.
So I would like to suggest since you are all enthusiastic note takers that you should just note two aspects of what I said. The first is the transition from not having entered the path to having entered the path, the path of accumulation. And the second is a transition from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation. Otherwise, if you take notes of everything, you will not be able to recollect everything. At the time of the transition from the path of accumulation, in other words, last instant of the great path of accumulation to the first instant of the path of preparation, one definitely has a definite ascertainment of emptiness.
And what is this emptiness emptiness object? This emptiness is the person’s emptiness of being established from its own side. This is specifically the emptiness of this object and that is how it has to be understood. Now, what precisely is a person here? It is the I.
And this I in Buddhist philosophy is understood either as the experiencer of the maturation of happiness and suffering or the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations. Be that as it may, it is this I which when it is searched for within the aggregates, when in other words, one investigates whether it exists or not within the aggregates is unfindable. In brief, when we say that the I is not established from its own side, we mean that the eye is not established as findable within its basis of imputation, which are the aggregates. So at the time of the great path of accumulation, what is the mode of realization of emptiness? Emptiness is realized.
Emptiness has been realized definitely at the level of the middling level of the path of accumulation. But what is the mode of realization? It remains an, a contrived conceptual conceptual realization by means of an inferential valid cognizer, which relies on a correct reason and there are numerous such reasons, such as the reason of interdependence and so forth. So, what therefore are the modes of realization of emptiness at the level of the great path of accumulation? Whereas previously, at the level of the middling path of accumulation, one had a realization of emptiness, which was a mind based on hearing.
At the level of the great path of accumulation, one has a realization of emptiness which is a mind based on thinking. But this still remains a realization which calls for effort. The inferential valid cognizer which is generated is generated by the means of effort. What happens when one passes from the great path of accumulation to the path of preparation? At that point, there is a conglomerate of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness.
At the level of the path of preparation for the first time, the experience of emptiness for remaining conceptual is effortless. And therefore, wall at the level of the great path of accumulation, there is a realization of emptiness by a valid cognizer, an inferential valid cognizer. This remains a realization which calls for effort. For effort based on the previous continuum of realizations. Whereas for the first time at the level of the path of preparation, this realization still by means of an inferential valid cognizer is at present effortless.
Therefore, war at the level of the great path of accumulation, even though one does have a realization of emptiness by a valid cognizer, this realization is an effortful realization which relies heavily on the lines of reasoning such as the interdependence of phenomena, the lines of reasoning of the one and many, as well as the scriptural texts one has studied, the instructions of one’s teachers and so forth. At the level of the path of preparation, however, for the first time, even though that realization of emptiness remains conceptual, there is no effort required and one no longer needs to recollect these various lines of reasoning, these scriptural texts and so forth. The realization is spontaneous. So an example will make effortless or spontaneous realization clear. When we see our father or our mother, we recognize them without any effort.
We immediately think this is my father, this is my mother. The same applies to someone one is extremely fond of. These are cases of effortless realization. So, one must understand clearly that at the level of the path of preparation for the first time, one has attained a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. However, minds arisen from meditation are of two types.
They are they can be conceptual or non conceptual. At the level of the path of preparation, one has attained a conceptual mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. And therefore, since all of these transitions are due to emptiness, we have to understand emptiness. And here, I would encourage you to ask questions. Now the emptiness to be understood is emptiness in accordance with the view.
And such an understanding of emptiness, which is an understanding arisen from hearing, can only occur through questions. Then obviously, there are other presentations of emptiness. There are two presentations of emptiness in Sattankhamadhyamika. There are two presentations of emptiness in Svatantrika Madhyamika. Then if you were to study them all, you would become hopelessly confused.
And therefore I suggest that you focus on Prasamikamadhyamika. So the presentation of emptiness and the emptiness of the self in Sotami Kamadhyamika is a difficult one, very difficult. Likewise, the presentation of the emptiness of the self in Chitamatha is particularly difficult since one does not really understand how the presentation of the non duality of mind and the form which is perceived by the mind has anything to do with the surfaces of persons. Yes. Soren as a Dalai Lama in his teachings at Gyume, the lower tantric college pointed out and it’s a very weighty statement.
How precisely does the Chitamatra view of non duality of mind and the form perceived by mind harm the ignorance grasping at a self? It’s a very weighty statement. Then obviously, the view of the emptiness of a substantially existent autonomous self propounded in the two lowest schools of tenets, Vaibhashika and Sautrantika, is a view which is of benefit when one studies the Prasangika view. What is at present the transition from the path of preparation to the path of seeing? Whereas at the level of the path of preparation, we have a mind arisen from meditation which is focused on emptiness and which is spontaneous but remains conceptual.
At the level of the path of seeing, this mind arisen from meditation is not only spontaneous but also non conceptual. Now at the level of the path of preparation, what do we mean when we say that the mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness is conceptual? We mean that it relies or is blended with a meaning generality. A meaning generality of what? Of emptiness.
Now, obviously in this case, the question arises, is it realizing emptiness or not? And the example we gave last week of the reflection of one’s face in the mirror is very helpful in this matter. When one looks at the reflection of one’s face in the mirror, obviously, the face in the mirror is not one’s face. Yet, independence on the face in the mirror, we can clean our own face and so forth. So it performs the functions of a face.
So what is the mode of transition from the last instance of the path of preparation? In other words, the level of supreme dharma to the first instance of the path of seeing. At the level of the supreme dharma of the path of preparation, one perceives emptiness by means of a meaning generality. However, at the level of the first instant of the path of seeing for the first time, one perceives emptiness nakedly in the self same way as one would perceive a color or a shape with the visual consciousness. So at this point, one has not only attained a non conceptual mind realizing emptiness, but it is as well a valid cognizer realizing emptiness because it is the first instance of such a mind.
It is therefore a direct valid cognizer realizing emptiness. Now the path of seeing has its own objects of abandonment just as the path of meditation. What are the objects of abandonment of the path of seeing? So this class is a class which focuses on these transitions from the state of one who has not entered the the path to the path of accumulation. From the level of the path of accumulation to the level of the path of seeing.
The level of the path of seeing to the level of the passive the level of passive preparation to the level of the passive seeing. Now why is this path called the path of seeing? It is called the path of seeing because for the first time, one realizes emptiness directly just as if one was seeing an object. This is also called the path of the direct realization of truth because for the first time one realizes ultimate truth directly. So for the first time at the level of the path of seeing, one is using a direct yogic valid cognizer.
So from the standpoint of the subdivision into conceptual and non conceptual minds and the sevenfold subdivision of minds in Lorig. The mind of definite emergence is a conceptual mind and within these sevenfold subdivisions of mind, it is a conviction. A reasonless conviction. Then the path of accumulation is a conceptual mind throughout and within these seven fold subdivisions of mind of Lurig, it is a subsequent cognizer because it arises independence on previous reasons and valid and inferentially valid cognizers. Then I could say an awful lot about this, but and very beautiful things, but we will drop it.
Now at the level of the path of seeing, what precisely is a path of seeing? The path of seeing is a non conceptual consciousness. But in addition, it is a non conceptual consciousness which is a valid cognizer. Now, from the standpoint of prasanika madiamika, it is a bit awkward to say that it is a direct valid cognizer since the table in front of me would qualify as such from the standpoint of prasanika madhyamika, but we can say it’s a non conceptual valid cognizer. Now what precisely are the objects of abandonment or the abandonment of the path of seeing?
They are abandonments related to the imputed apprehension of true existence. Imputed apprehensions of true existence are apprehensions of true existence which are rooted on reasons or on reasoning, and they are present within our mind streams. For instance, the position of all of the lowest schools of tenets apart from regarding phenomenas existing from their own side is a classic case of imputed apprehensions of true existence. So at present, when we refer to the abandonments of the path of seeing, obviously in our case as we are studying prasanika madhyamika, we pay verbal allegiance to the fact that phenomena do not exist from their own side, that the I does not exist from its own side and so forth. Yet, we see that the moment, we analyze the idea that the I is unfindable under analysis within its basis of designation, which are the aggregates, strikes us as very strange.
And that strangeness and this natural allegiance to the idea that the I is findable, in other words to the view of the lowest schools of tenets, this is a classic case of the imputed grasping at true existence. Otherwise, if we were to think that imputed grasping at true existence was exclusively grounded on formal tenets, that could be quite awkward. So, when we analyze and seek for the I within the aggregates, within the five aggregates, we have an instinctive sense that it is findable within these aggregates and if we analyze carefully that it’s actually the mind. And many of us will say, well, actually why wouldn’t it be the mind? Now this intuitive sense, this experience we have is a reason for which the lowest schools of tenets below Plasanica Madhyamica assert that the example of the person is the mind.
It is precisely this idea that the person is established from its own side within its basis of designation, which is the object of abandonment, the abandonment at the level of the path of seeing. As great scholars of the view said, in our case, our allegiance to emptiness is a merely verbal assertion that all phenomena are not established from their own side. What matters is transforming our minds from deep within and generating a valid cognizer which realizes that all phenomena are not established from their own side. There is one other thing I would like to add, which is that at the level of the great path of accumulation, that even though one does indeed have a realization of emptiness, in as much as this realization is not only conceptual, but non spontaneous, there is coarse non duality between the mind focusing on emptiness and the emptiness focused upon. Since the mind is relying on numerous reasons to analyze emptiness.
At the level of the path of preparation, because the realization world still conceptually spontaneous, the mind is much closer to its object. Finally, at the level of the path of seeing, we have a direct non conceptual realization of emptiness. The mind seems to be one with its object, even though in reality, obviously, the mind realizing emptiness and emptiness are different. So this is rather difficult, but what matters is to generate at least a mind arisen from hearing which understands emptiness as a foundation. Whereas both at the level of the path of preparation and at the level of the path of seeing, one has an experience of emptiness at the level of the path of preparation.
It’s a conceptual experience. At the level of the path of seeing, it is a non conceptual experience. One sees emptiness nakedly. Irrespective of the phenomenon, we need a direct experience of it. Mere conceptuality cannot provide such an experience.
So, let us take an example. Let’s take the case of apples. We all know what apples are. Then in our case, we have both a conception and direct realization of apples. But let us take someone from a foreign land, where there are no apples, who comes to this land for the first time.
Does such a person have a realization of apples? Yes. Does he have a direct realization of apples that we have to examine? That he has a realization of apples is easy I think. Now, through mere conceptuality, we cannot gain an experience of an apple.
An apple is an exterior physical phenomenon. And therefore, to gain a direct experience of an apple, to generate a direct cognizer realizing an apple, we must see the apple, we must taste the apple, we must have a direct experience of the apple. So when someone then comes from a foreign country and sees an apple for the first time, and we tell him this is an apple, he has a realization of apple, but does he have a direct realization of apple or not? To have a direct realization, he would have to know the taste and so forth. So what do you think?
Does he have a direct realization? So obviously, this is clear because we rely so heavily on the sensory consciousnesses. But this person from another country, does he understand that that is an apple? Yeah. He understands this level, does he realize it or not?
So obviously this was someone who had prepared his trip well, who had studied about apples before coming to this country. Like he saw a picture of an apple in his home country. He sees an apple here. They look alike. He says this is an apple.
So he has a realization that it’s an apple. Does he have a direct realization it’s an apple? So, we agree therefore that he has a realization that it is an apple, but he does not have a direct realization because to have a direct realization, he or she would have to have had an experience to have tasted the apple before. Right? Okay.
Let us take the case of emptiness then. So you have studied about emptiness in books, you have read about emptiness, you have received many teachings from your teachers, you understand emptiness conceptually. But according to this line of reasoning, it is impossible to gain a direct realization of emptiness because you would have had initially to have had an experience of emptiness which you have not had. So, then obviously, you could say you have a direct perception of apple because after all apple is a color and you have perceived the color of apple with your visual consciousness. So this kind of reasoning is very helpful.
Let’s take the stand in front of me, the little table. It’s form. Now there are five subdivisions of form. From the sphere of swarm to the fear sphere of tactile experience. Which of the five is this table?
Suki Suki ki The sphere form. Another. Then most of us would say that a table is not a color, It is a shape, isn’t it? What about sugar? Within the five What is an apple?
We’re asking more details than that within form of the five divisions. Object of the eye consciousness, ear, nose, tongue, and tactile. Difficult. This Do apples do apples sing to you, Natalie? So if we set aside sound, apologies to Natalie, apart from that, all the other four could qualify as something an apple is.
So we are what? We are persons. Right? The experiences of happiness and suffering. What are we?
Which way are you talking about? Your person. I. Okay, the unsigned of a lie. So we’re not form, obviously, but within the three form consciousness and non associated compositional phenomena, what are we?
So this issue of non associated compositional phenomena, will cover later. Now regarding what persons are, it is very helpful to analyze persons in terms of the division of existence into substantially existent and imputedly existent phenomena. And in this matter, it is awkward to say that a person is a substantially existent phenomenon, but it is also just as awkward to say the person is an imputedly existent phenomenon. Some schools of tenets assert therefore that the person is both. But we will cover this quietly in this class.
It is very helpful to try to understand what the person is, from the standpoint of the lowest schools of tenants in this present school of tenant. At present, regarding the generation of the motivation in meditation, we shall reflect first on how one passes from being someone who has not entered to the path to a path of accumulation through generating uncontrived definite emergence and what uncontrived definite emergence is within conceptual and non conceptual minds. And then, the transitions from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, and the path of preparation to the path of seeing. Please open the prayer book, page one. We we shall recite one, eight, two, three, four, and also page five, number six.
First one and three. Then I will take a couple pure questions, with those questions on topic. So Geshela, when I try to meditate on emptiness, the emptiness of the inherent the existing eye, always seems to be the case that there’s the feeling of an inherently existing eye there. Like, I can’t get away from the feeling of an inherently existing eye. So when one meditates on the lack of true existence of the eye, the object of refutation, the true existence of the eye appears unavoidable.
Then what is very good is to identify the object of refutation as object of refutation. Following on from Following on from following on from Jumper’s question, when I’m meditating and I feel like I’m actually meditating, then I’ve lost the plot. So when realize that I’m thinking that I am meditating, so I can sort of liken that a little bit to the duality of thinking of emptiness. So once I realize that I’m thinking about it, then it’s become a concept. So is that What is important is not to lose track of the meaning of emptiness.
As long as you are focusing on the meaning of emptiness, then you are meditating on emptiness. The moment you lose track of the meaning of emptiness, you are no longer meditating on emptiness. All your meditation is conceptual. You don’t understand what conceptuality is. When one meditates, one is focusing on an image of the object of meditation.
That image is conceptual. Apart from that image, we have nothing to work with. Meditation means that the mind is focused in a relaxed fashion without distraction on one object. That is meditation. It is a mind which is focused on a virtuous object of observation without being distracted elsewhere for as long as is possible, one, two, three, four minutes.
As I said in the Lamrim, we follow our minds and the minds follow the three poisons, in other words the afflictions. So when our mind is focused in a relaxed fashion on an object without succumbing to the three afflictions, then we are meditating. Okay. And other? Okay.
Alrighty. So the four immeasurables that we just read seem to be to me a request for that, mind of emptiness. Now I just wanted to know between the paths of seeing and the paths of meditation, with such a realization of emptiness, is that just a spontaneous once off or is that a prolonged experience or is the path of meditation the prolonged experience of emptiness? Yes, definitely. When one passes from the level of the path of seeing to that of meditation, then one focuses uninterruptedly on emptiness.
It’s difficult to assert that the four immeasurables are a gateway to the direct realization of but they are a gateway indirectly to the realization of emptiness. Geshe, does entry into the path of seeing correspond roughly to entry into the path shared with the being of great scope? Here, I am not saying anything about the Mahayana or the Hinayana. That is related to motivation. We are only talking about the five paths and the transition from path to path is only related to emptiness.
So first one explains the five paths and these are related to deepening one’s experience of emptiness. Then in function of the motivation, there are three categories of beings. Hearers, solitary realizers, and bodhisattvas. Each has five paths of its own. So if one has a motivation of a hearer, one travels on the five paths of a hearer.
A pratyaka Buddha, the same thing, and a bodhisattva, the same thing. Yeah. I ask, Geshela, because I was trying to link it to the Lamrim, like entry into the path of accumulation is entry into the equates, you said, roughly to the path shared with the middling scope of the Lamrim. So, no, to enter the Mahayana, one needs the motivation of Bodhicitta. These must be upheld by the motivation of Bodhicitta.
So my question is just going back to the person who comes from overseas and has done some homework and knows about the apple but comes to our country and then actually experiences the apple. And so then that is a direct realization of apple. And so that direct realization would be a stable realization because there would be no more doubt about what apple is. So is that the same with the path of preparation transitioning to the path of seeing? Is that naked realization of emptiness is then stable as well?
So as far as apples are concerned, it is not possible to gain a direct experience of an apple without having eaten one first. Then as far as objects which transcend the senses in which we experience by means of a meaning generality are concerned, such as uncompounded space, it is possible through analysis to eventually gain an experience. My question was really, once one has that move from the path of preparation to the path of seeing, is that realization of emptiness which has become non conceptual, is that a stable realization? I take only one or two questions, and I have something to do after as well. The characteristic of uncontrived thought of definite emergence is the rejection of psycho existence based on faults and then also the heartfelt aspiration for liberation.
Krishna said that was conceptual and future orientated. If one is developing that mind by reflecting on the faults of one’s own experience of cyclic existence, would that not also be reflecting on the past? So could it not also include conceptions of the past? Geshela said it was only about the future. Yes, both are present.
The uncontrived mind of definite emergence from the standpoint of the analysis of thoughts relies on the past. The standpoint of the analysis of qualities relies on the future. Another? Okay. Any discussion?
Stop here tonight.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
- Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.