1 h 0 min · 2,834 words · 7 June 2016
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching explains where the path of preparation fits within the path of seeing and the difference between wisdom arisen from thinking and wisdom arisen from meditation on emptiness. It argues that emptiness understood only through thinking is easily forgotten, while meditative realisation, a union of calm abiding and insight, is stable. It then outlines how the tenet schools view the self as imputed on the aggregates and introduces the four subdivisions of the path of preparation.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 1m
UUID: 6d1f204d-8291-44e7-8010-37ddeeb1c21b
Date: 2016-06-07
Words: 2,830
So where precisely does the path of preparation fit within the 37 facets of enlightenment at the level of the five powers. Now why are the five powers in this context referred to as powers? Because they have the power to give rise to their effect which is the path of seeing. So within the three paths, the path of preparation, the second path, the path of seeing the third and the path of meditation the fourth. The path of preparation is the preliminary.
The path of seeing is the middle path and the path of meditation comes after these. The path of preparation is called preparation or prayoga in Sanskrit because it prepares to the attainment of the path of seeing. Now, why precisely is the path of seeing? Darshan Marga in Sanskrit called the path of seeing. Because at this point, one sees reality.
In other words, one generates for the first time a direct yogic perceiver of emptiness. Now a direct yogic perceiver is a direct perceiver which arises in dependence on an uncommon controlling condition which must be a Samādhi, which is a union of calm abiding and insight. At which level does this Samādhi, which is a union of calm abiding and insight occur for the first time at the level of the path of preparation. And therefore you can see the linkage between the path of preparation and the path of seeing. So in other words, this concentration which is a union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness is the uncommon cooperative condition within the two causes, cooperative conditions and substantial causes.
It is an uncommon cooperative condition of the path of seeing. Now, at which point is this concentration generated at the level of the path of preparation? Below the path of preparation, in other words, the level of the path of accumulation, does there exist an insight which is focused on emptiness? No. So it is the case that there are instances of generations of minds arisen from meditation focused on emptiness.
In other words, calm abiding focused on emptiness at the level of the path of accumulation. Is this however of benefit? Not really. It is certainly not the case that merely through giving rise for instance to a realization of emptiness such as a mind arisen from hearing focused on emptiness at the level of the path of accumulation that there will be benefit in future lives for that person. So, Khensur Rinpoche said repeatedly and you yourselves perhaps did hear this from his mouth that the mere realization of emptiness is of little benefit.
For instance, it is true that one should receive teachings on emptiness and it is also listen to the topic of emptiness and in dependence on this, one can give rise to a wisdom arisen from thinking of emptiness. In other words, a valid cognizer ascertaining emptiness. But this alone is insufficient. If we had this alone without generating a wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, then very probably in future lives, we would forget this experience of emptiness. Therefore, we must at least attain the path of preparation.
So let alone future lives, in this life for that matter, if we do not gain repeated familiarization with a wisdom arisen from thinking of emptiness, we will forget emptiness. And the reason for this is that our minds at present are minds of the desire realm. In other words, they are extremely troubled minds, minds which are easily distracted. Then we can see this with our own personal experience. If we take, let’s say a child age six, his projects will probably still be things he remembers around age seven, maybe eight.
Then most of that will be forgotten. Then the projects he makes around age seven or eight may last until age nine, maybe 10. Then again, they will be forgotten. And as he develops over time, much of his past will be forgotten. Then if we reach our own age and look back at our lives, most of our lives have already been forgotten.
For that matter, for those who live to the ripe old age of 80 or 90, generally speaking, the person becomes an infant again. They understand nothing and their memory is totally lost. Well, this is a clear sign that our minds are minds of the desire realm and they are unstable and fragile. So among you, quite a few I suspect have parents, fathers or mothers who have reached the age of 80 or 90. Probably none of them have stable memories.
Then forget our parents. If we ourselves were to reach that age, probably our minds would become totally empty. So if we do not repeatedly become familiarized with topics like the Lamrim, what hope do we have to gain the stability of mind of our great teachers such as Khensur Ugyen Tseten or Khensur Rinpoche whose mind was very stable well in his 80s and for Geshe-la up to 90. So it is therefore critically important to understand the distinction between the wisdom arisen from thinking and the wisdom arisen from meditation. Now regarding the defining characteristics of the wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, Abhisamayālamkāra says that whatever one sees, one experiences as the nature of a dream.
In other words, one apprehended as unreal and as of the nature of a dream. However, Je Tsongkhapa’s Legs Shad Nyingpo, the Golden Rosary of Eloquence adds that even in the dream state, one also experiences phenomena as unreal. So this is a criterion for having obtained the wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. So I gave you an example to illustrate the difference between these minds clearly through depending on a mind arisen from thinking focused on emptiness. If one does not engage in repeated habituation with emptiness, one risks in this very life to forget the topic emptiness and therefore one must generate a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness.
It’s pretty difficult, isn’t it? Because first, one has to gain an understanding of emptiness but that is not enough. One then has to generate a valid cognizer ascertaining emptiness. That is still not enough because one can if one doesn’t familiarize repeatedly with the topic, forget it. So one must generate an experience arisen from meditation focused on emptiness.
That is only of benefit. Therefore, it is critically important to gain such a wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. However, if one has attained the middling or the great path of accumulation, probably one will not be reborn in future lives in a lower realm. And therefore, initially, one must endeavor through understanding emptiness to give rise eventually to a valid cognizer which realizes emptiness. This is a mind arisen from thinking focused on emptiness.
But as was said, it is doubtful whether this will be beneficial or not. And as Khensur Rinpoche said repeatedly, one must generate stable karmic imprints regarding emptiness and this can only be done through a wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. This is therefore what we should try to generate. At that point, one will have entered the path of preparation and from that point onwards, one progresses smoothly upwards. And therefore, one must rely on a wisdom arisen from meditation focused Now a wisdom arisen from meditation focused on on emptiness, a Samādhi which is the inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness are one and the same thing.
Now as was said, if one tries to rely only on a wisdom arisen from thinking focused on emptiness, it has been seen that those who have generated it will forget it either in future lives or even in this life. This is not the case with a wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness and therefore I’d like to ask you to reflect by yourselves on why there is such a difference. So here we talk about emptiness but really one has to provide an introduction to emptiness. If however, I were to provide directly an introduction to emptiness, I think you would find it very difficult to understand. So let us approach the problem differently.
Let us address the issue of the I and the mind. So here at present, we all have a natural sensation of I. For instance, when the heating unit of the air conditioner functions, then we all say, I feel warm. This is the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensation, the I which manifests. Likewise, when the air conditioner shuts off, we all say, I feel cold.
Likewise, the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations is the I. So therefore, it is a given that such an I exists. Such an I is established based on our experience. If for instance, we are warm, we say I feel warm. Likewise, if someone offers us a delicious meal, after eating it, we say this was delicious.
I loved it. So in this respect, the I exists. The difference between the Buddhist and the non-Buddhist philosophers of ancient India arises as far as the understanding of the mode of existence of this I is concerned. For the non-Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, this I is in a relation to the aggregates as a ruler to a subject. And it exists independently of the aggregates.
For the Buddhist schools of tenets, without exception, the I exists in dependence on the aggregates. The four schools of Buddhist tenets all agree on this. They disagree as far as the mode of dependence is concerned. Some lower schools of tenets assert that the I is to be found within the aggregates but Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika asserts that the I is a mere nominal and conceptual imputation on the basis of the aggregates. So it is very, very pleasant to engage in these lines of investigation to see the differences between the various modes of positing the I in the various schools of tenets.
They differ as far as their understanding of its mode of existence. Now returning to the path of preparation. The path of preparation is subdivided into four. And you should know these four subdivisions. The first is warmth, the second is peak, the third is forbearance and the fourth is supreme phenomena or supreme Dharma.
Now this fourfold subdivision of the path of preparation is presented from the standpoint of the way in which the antidote to the object of abandonment which is self grasping operates. So the first of these is an apprehension of the object as thoroughly afflicted. And this apprehension of the object as thoroughly afflicted refers as far as the object is concerned to the grasping of the object as being established from its own side or as being truly established. The second is the apprehension of the object as thoroughly pacified or thoroughly purified. This refers to the apprehension of objects such as the noble truth of cessation or the noble truth of the path as being established from their own side or as being inherently established.
The third is the apprehension of the object as grasping a substance and this refers to substances being truly established or established from their own side. And the fourth is the apprehension of imputed existence as being established from their own side or as being established inherently. But this doesn’t matter. What really matters is that you understand that the mind arisen from meditation occurs at the level of the path of preparation and that the path of preparation is subdivided into four as was mentioned, warmth, peak, forbearance and supreme phenomena. Then we will enter into the detailed presentation of these four topics next week.
Now in the context of generating the motivation, please reflect on the fact that if you give rise to a valid cognizer ascertaining emptiness. In other words, a mind arisen from thinking ascertaining emptiness, it is possible to forget emptiness. Whereas if one gives rise to a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. In other words, a Samādhi which is a union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. Is not possible to forget emptiness.
Number six Mandala offering. Verse one and three. Thank you. Then if you have questions, please ask your questions now. I’ll only take two, three questions, short questions please.
In relation to the lower schools of tenets, if they believe that the I the mode of existence of the I is within the aggregates. How do they manage the idea of rebirth and reincarnation? If the aggregates at the point of death go, what happens to the I for those schools? So basically as we die, the various aggregates dissolve. The form aggregate disappears in the aggregate of sensation of discrimination, composition of factors and consciousness dwindles until all that is left is a subtle consciousness which passes to the next life.
Now, I would suspect the lower schools of tenets would accept such a subtle consciousness. Another question. Could, Geshe-la, please, explain again, the second level with regard to generating emptiness, the valid cognizer generating emptiness as between so the distinction between the first level at the level of thinking and the third level at the level of meditating. What’s the valid cognizer generating emptiness? Could you reformulate your question?
You want to think an explanation of the second level or the difference Well, between the first and the at the second level and how it is different from the first and the third. So the wisdom arisen from hearing occurs when one thinks about emptiness, one receives teachings about emptiness, one reflects about it for so long as one has not generated a valid cognizer realizing emptiness. Now when through repeated analysis, eventually one eliminates all doubt regarding emptiness at this point, one is said to have generated a valid cognizer ascertaining emptiness. This is the wisdom arisen from thinking. Then Je Tsongkhapa said numerous times that once one has eliminated or severed all doubts regarding emptiness and one has in other words generated a valid cognizer which has ascertained emptiness, one should focus on the object of meditation in solitude.
Now in brief, once through repeated habituation by means of a wisdom arisen from thinking focused on emptiness, the mind is focused and ascertains emptiness without any effort at all from its own side. Then the wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness has arisen. So for instance, regarding stable or uncontrived definite emergence, we said that this stable or uncontrived definite emergence is a mind arisen from meditation. Since as Je Tsongkhapa says in the three principles of the path, once it arises day and night continually, true definite emergence will have been generated. So at this point indeed, definite emergence arises without any effort whatsoever.
Likewise, once the mind focused on emptiness arises spontaneously and without any effort, then we can say that a wisdom arisen from meditation focused on emptiness has been generated. Now for ourselves, it is probable that we have no experience whatsoever of wisdoms arisen from meditation. However, in our own ordinary experience, we have spontaneous states of mind which arise. For instance, when we think of our father, of our mother, of our children, of our boyfriend, girlfriend, then immediately, spontaneously, a perfectly clear image arises to one’s mind’s eye, doesn’t it? Now I’m not saying that these are minds arisen from meditation.
But minds arisen from meditation share that spontaneity and that clarity. I’m not saying it’s an experience arisen from meditation. It’s an example. Then when such an experience of emptiness, of selflessness, of the four noble truths of definite emergence arises, one is relying on a wisdom arisen from meditation. So today the topic of discussion will be the difference between a wisdom or a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness for which emptiness is unforgettable and a mind arisen from thinking focused on emptiness which can forget emptiness.
What is the difference? Why is there such a difference? Why does the mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness find it impossible to forget its object? Why does the mind arisen from thinking focused on emptiness find it quite straightforward to forget its object? So I will explain a little bit but not everything.
Otherwise, you will sit back on your haunches and do nothing. So the little bit I would explain is that the reason the mind arisen from thinking is able to forget its object is precisely because such a mind is a mind of the desire realm and as a mind of the desire realm, it is affected by agitation and distraction. And the rest is up to you to figure out. Then Khensur Rinpoche always said, one must rely on a wisdom arisen from meditation. Otherwise, it will be very difficult.
So one has to seek a wisdom arisen from meditation. Okay. Then let us start discussion by pairs as usual.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- five powers
- The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
- The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
- The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.