Seventy Topics — 2003-10-30

44 min · 3,568 words · 30 October 2003 · Buddha House Adelaide

Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Seventy Topics — 2003-10-30
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Geshe Pema Tsering opens this 45-minute commentary with a verse from the First Dalai Lama’s prayer to Tārā, in which doubts are called “flesh-eating ghosts” haunting those striving toward enlightenment. He explains why doubt is so corrosive: rooted in the ignorance that grasps at inherent existence, it leaves us trusting worldly rewards we can see clearly while remaining uncertain about karma and the Three Jewels, and that uncertainty quietly undermines commitment to practice. The antidote is deliberate conviction built through study, contemplation, and meditation — a demanding but cumulative process that grows easier as familiarity deepens. The commentary then moves into the Seventy Topics curriculum, working through the resultant truth body of a Buddha: the nature body with its two purities (intrinsic and adventitious), and the enjoyment body with its five certainties, including a careful unpacking of the three distinct senses of Akanishtha pure land. Suited to practitioners with existing doctrinal background.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 05 ST10 2003 10 30.mp3

UUID: 3045d442-1069-4afa-b50d-c41ae56a4fdd

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2003-10-30

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45.0 minutes

Words: ~3,563

Okay. In the request of Tārā by the first Dalai Lama Gendun Drub, he says something like, The complete delusion is like the sky. It is an intense or powerful cause. To actually strive towards enlightenment is very difficult. To the person who is striving towards enlightenment, please bless or grant me the ability to stave off or protection from the flesh-eating ghosts of doubt.

What this means is that when it says, for example, that their ignorance is like the sky, what it s meaning is that nothing stops us from falling into ignorance. This ignorance is the ignorance that perceives things to be inherently existent. The metaphor for the sky is that the sky doesn’t stop us from doing anything. There’s no resistance there when we walk against the sky. This ignorance is stuck.

This ignorance is like the sky, and we don’t need much cause to be able to pass through it. On the other hand, when we’re trying to work towards the things or the path that’s gonna lead us to liberation or Buddhahood. And so this means the method and wisdom, the six perfections, the three higher trainings, the six perfections, the three higher trainings, etc. This is very difficult for us. It’s very hard work.

We have to put in a lot of effort. Then it s saying, to the person doing this, putting in the hard work in order to get there, may they be protected or grant may you grant may Tārā grant her protection or guidance or blessings that we don’t fall prey to doubts. Because in actual fact, the person who wants to follow this path, the thing that they need to do first is to get rid of the doubt. The doubts are like ghosts that that scare us. So the thing that we need to do is to get rid of doubts.

So, these doubts is the thing that we’re dealing with the most. If we didn’t have any doubt, then we would be striving towards liberation and enlightenment with a single pointed mind. We would have that much focus on what we’re doing. Because of our doubts, because of our doubts about karma, because of our doubts about the qualities of liberation, because we don’t have any experience of Buddhahood or liberation or the positive outcomes of practicing Dharma, then we’re not as concentrated on striving towards that. We don’t understand properly how the final happiness is we have to ask about that, so therefore we don’t concentrate on it properly.

On the other hand, we know we get a temporary happiness from doing saṃsāra things for working towards worldly ends. We know that there is a temporary happiness there. Something we don’t have doubts about is something we realize clearly, and because we realize it clearly, that means that we work towards that without much effort. We don’t think that strongly about it. We don’t have to convince ourselves results of our efforts.

We just do it automatically because we understand what we will get from it. The problem is we don’t have doubts about this small happiness that we’re getting, and we do have doubts about the big happiness, the final happiness, the liberation of Buddhahood, so we don’t strive towards that properly because we we we have doubts about what the outcome will be. So this this doubt that we have, the doubt starts with our sense of refuge. We have doubts about refuge because if we didn’t have doubts about refuge, then we wouldn’t be focusing on anything else. Would be just following the example of the Buddha, the Dharma and Sangha, the Sangha.

That would be our focus. We wouldn’t have question marks or lack of understanding about what is happening because are the same as not understanding. By not understanding things, we have doubts. By not seeing qualities clearly, we have doubts. We have doubts about our refuge, we have doubts about the qualities of Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, we are going for refuge too.

We also have doubts about karma, cause and effect. We experience karma again and again and again, but in actual fact, to see karma clearly and to not have any doubt about karma, to see it clearly, we have to be a Buddha. Karma is the most difficult thing to understand, the subtle workings of karma. We experience karma again and again and again, but we don’t understand it. We have doubts about it.

We can’t see it properly. It’s different. We know if we do something, we’re going to get money for it. We know if we do work, we’re going to get money for it. We know how things work in this life, and we can see the results of things in this life.

But because karma is so much more intricate and expansive and goes through different experiences, through different lifetimes, then it’s very difficult for us to not have doubts about karma. So we in this way, we can see that doubts really are really bad. They’re they’re really unhelpful, and they’re really a cause for us to create the conditions for more suffering in the future. And so if we wanna look at the cause of our doubts, the cause of our doubts is our ignorance as regards to the inherent existence of persons and objects. That’s the cause of our doubts.

That’s the cause of all of our negative emotions, whether it’s doubt or desire or anger or pride. Any of these things come about because of our grasping at inherent reality, the ignorance of grasping at inherent reality. So this means, once we understand how negative doubts are and how doubts can play havoc with what we’re doing, then we absolutely have to convince ourselves to believe in these things. We have to convince ourselves to believe in karma. We have to convince ourselves to believe in the Three Jewels and the idea of refuge.

If we can convince ourselves to believe in these things before we do the practice, then our understanding will become deeper and deeper and subtler and subtler. In this process, we will work towards developing the clear perception of things. But what we need to do is to be able to stop the doubts that we have about things. So we have to believe in the believe in these actions we’re doing, refuge, of developing bodhicitta of doing virtuous actions. We have to try and believe in it, believe in karma.

Because if we do this, then we’re going to do things with commitment, with focus. Now the way that we do this is if we keep thinking about it, keep analyzing, we keep convincing ourselves of the way things are, and we realize or we recognize that doubts and other negative emotions aren’t beneficial to us. They don’t create causes for us to experience happiness, and therefore, they’re things that we need to abandon. What we do is we keep working on it. We keep convincing ourselves, convincing ourselves, and we keep recognizing the negative things that we may experience, doubt, pride, desire, these things, we more used to it and more familiarized with it, our understanding becomes subtler and subtler.

And if we keep doing this, then we will come to a clear understanding, I think. So because we have all these doubts, because we have all these negative emotions, the actual hardest part of the path is the one that we’re on at the moment. As beginners, as people without the habit of thinking in this way, without the habit of concentration, without the habit of thinking about compassion and loving kindness, then this is a very, very difficult part of the path for us. We have to keep working at it. We have to put in an enormous amount of effort to get used to the ideas and develop faith in the ideas.

We have to put in so much work to do that. But as we progress, as we become, our understanding becomes more and more, the effort becomes less and less. So eventually when we come to the path of seeing, the path of meditation, there is no effort. We do these things effortlessly. We work through the things effortlessly.

So we have to remember, as beginners, working to get that habit, working to get that familiarity with the ideas, the concepts, the patterns is very, very difficult. So this this means that we have to work hard. It’s basically what it comes down to. We have to work hard. We have to work hard.

We have to study hard. We have to we have to try and meditate hard or put a lot of effort into meditating. The process that we need to engage in usually comes down to these three things, studying and listening, contemplation and meditation. First of all, need to know what it is that we should be contemplating on, so we need to study, we need to listen to the teachings, and we need to think about it. Then we go and contemplate on what the teaching said, and once we’ve understood these things, then we meditate on them.

This process at the beginning is hard, but we have experience. We understand that once we start doing something, it’s difficult at the beginning, and the more we do it, the easier and easier it comes. We know that from our general experience. The same thing applies to when we’re doing these three different aspects of Dharma practice. So so we should so this means that we should we should set our motivations well as well.

So our motivation needs to be in order to lead all sentient beings to a state beyond sorrow where they experience complete happiness, then I myself must become a Buddha, one who has completely gotten rid of all faults and completely accumulated all positive qualities. So we should meditate on that motivation for a few minutes. I actually have to make an apology because I didn’t understand what you’re talking about last week. So and then I said spent half an hour going through it with you. And the last one, right, where it says the I’m talking about the momentary application at the end of the continuum of a being.

Yeah? And the last one of those is nondual momentary application. Now the thing is that this text, the ultimate body is actually taught from the perspective of the Sautrāntika Yogachara school. Yeah? And according to this school, there is these two different aspects to emptiness.

It has both the non-defined, the non-characteristic emptiness, like the lack of characteristic, where they say it is the lack of inherent existence and the lack of characteristics at that point. But because this this text is taught from the other school’s point of view, then this is why that has this four different topics. Does that make sense? And it’s compendium as well. I’m busy.

Just one. Do you work? Not compendium. Okay. So we’re up to the the last topic, topic number eight, which is the four topics of a resultant truth body or the final bodies — what’s he got?

The the the final bodies the final bodies of the Buddha. So resultant truth for your final body of of final bodies of the Buddha. The first of which is what’s called the the nature body or Svabhāvikakāya. Oh, that gives you Oh. Svabhāvikakāya.

And the definition of this is a final sphere possessing the two purities. Now in this bit where it says a final sphere, a sphere is something that’s like the is the nature of something. For example, we say the dharmadhātu, that’s the sphere of phenomena, which means the place where things happen in. In actual fact, it’s a synonym with the dharmatā, which is the nature of reality. So it’s another way of saying emptiness.

So a sphere is an emptiness. Yeah? The so but this isn’t the emptiness of any any old thing. It’s the emptiness of the the final emptiness, which possesses the two purities. The two purities being intrinsic purity and adventitious purity.

Right. Okay. So the two divisions of this are the nature truth body that is a factor of intrinsic purity and the nature truth body that is a factor of adventitious purity. Now this is basically referring to emptiness and the truth of cessation. The first one is referring to emptiness.

It’s talking about the non affirming negative that is the emptiness of inherent existence. The reason that it’s called a non affirming negative is because there is something that is being completely negated is absent from that instance, and so because there is something that is absent from that, then it’s saying it’s not there as opposed to saying it’s not that. Does that make sense? That’s what a non affirming negative means. It’s saying it’s not there as opposed to saying it’s not that.

So from Gelug School’s point of view, then the emptiness of the Cittamātra view, the emptiness of this school’s view, the Svatāntrika or autonomous school’s view, and the emptiness that’s as described in the Prāsaṇgika or consequentialist school, all of those are non affirming negatives. So the second one, a nature truth body that is a factor of adventitious purity. Now what this is referring to is the truth of cessation in the mind stream of a Buddha. And this means that because a Buddha has no obscurations to omniscience or obscurations to liberation, the fact that those two things have been gotten rid of means that there are true cessation there. Now, these true cessation, the reason that they’re described as being the lack of adventitious purity.

What this is referring to is that all of the negative things in our mind, whether it’s ignorance or doubt or desire, any of these things are all adventitious. They come and they go dependent on causes and conditions. Are not inherently existent. Are not established from their own side, so therefore they can go away again. They are not permanent, therefore they are described as adventitious.

The absence of these, because they have been abandoned in the mind stream of a Buddha, is called the nature truth body that is a factor of adventitious purity. That is all of the adventitious negativities of the obstructions to omniscience and the obstructions to liberation have been eliminated, and this is synonymous with the truth of cessation. So the ground of this, or the scope of this, is it exists only on the Buddha ground? Ground. Okay.

So the next one that we have of the four topics of resultant truth of truth body is the enjoyment body. The quote from the root text says, along with the complete enjoyment, this is saying that complete enjoyment qualifies this body or pervades this body. Definition of enjoyment body is a final form body possessing the five certainties. So this means that this body is the body of Buddha by being final form body, but it has five certainties or five definite characteristics. Alright.

Now this first one, the certainty of the abode, it abides only in the not-low pure land, which is called the Akanishtha. Now this Akanishtha that enjoyment bodies abide in is not somewhere you can drive to or get a car to or something that exists in some kind of solid, stable physical way. This Pure Land, the Akanishtha Pure Land comes about when you have a Buddha. Buddhas achieve enlightenment in Aka Nishta pure land. It’s the it’s the reality that they generate when they achieve enlightenment.

So we can’t say, for example, that there’s definitely not an Aka Nishta pure land in this room. We just don’t see it. Yeah? And so the enjoyment bodies abide in this state. When bodhisattvas have pure enough perception to be able to see the enjoyment body, that means that they are perceiving an enjoyment body in an Akanishtha state.

Yeah? So for example but this isn’t the only way that Buddhas who appear to people come about. So for example, Asaṇga had a vision of Maitreya. Although he appeared in what looked to Asaṇga as a enjoyment body in the form of a prince and yada yada, that wasn’t in fact an enjoyment body. It was an emanation body because it was an emanation of Maitreya’s main state, which is as a incarnate emanation body in Tuśita.

Okay? Yeah. Because he’s the next person come down, so that makes him an emanation body. He’s the next Buddha to come to Earth. So if if bodhisattvas have a vision or have a have a are able to see enjoyment bodies, that means that they are able to perceive Akanishtha, the pure land of that Buddha.

And ordinary beings can never perceive enjoyment bodies. Because the way that this Akanishta comes about, right, is that the the people achieving Buddhahood have created the causes to experience a pure a pure realm. So that’s what they are experiencing. But it’s not like a physical it’s not the same physical realm as we talk about the, like, the six realms of existence or going to different countries or going somewhere on foot or driving there or whatever it is. Those physical realms that we experience in this way are caused because of karma and delusions.

Because of karma and delusions, they have this gross physical form. There are these gross experiences that come to people who are born in those states. For example, they say that in particular school, it says that the eight hot and cold hells are a certain distance below the vajra seat in Bodhgaya. They say that that is where they are located, and that is the way that they present things. They are giving a physical place to where the hot and cold hells are, but, in actual fact, the hot and cold hells come about because of the karma and delusions of the people in them.

It’s the same way as this world comes about because of the karma and delusions of people in it. So if you have a Buddha who’s existing in this world or in a hell or whatever, they’re not actually of that world. They haven’t created the karma and the causes to be born in that world because they have purified all their karma and all their delusions. So what they are existing in is this Akanishtha Pure Land. So even though they may be emanating or having an experience somewhere else, because they haven’t created the causes and conditions to be, say, a a person of Earth, then they we say that they’re not actually in Earth.

They’re in Akanishtha Pure Land. Okay. So there’s Okay. Because it becomes confusing because there’s three different types of Akanishtha, this place. One of them is actually a a place.

It’s the highest realm of existence, the peak of Samsāra. Therefore, it has the name not low or none higher. That’s one. There are four different levels in the form realm, four different levels in the formless realm, and sometimes the highest level of the formless realm is called this. Beings in that realm are not out of saṃsāra, and they can go back into the lower realms after dying.

Yeah? Because they’ve only achieved certain levels of concentration, which are not based on anything stable. There is another phase of pure land where nobody lives apart from aryas and Bodhisattva aryas, which is also called Akanishtha. Yeah? So it’s a pure land like Dewachen or Tuśita or any of those.

Yeah? Another pure land. Then there’s also this which is the what a Buddha creates, what we were talking about before, the the environment or the situation that they create once they achieve enlightenment. So there’s these three different types. Okay.

So the next one, a certainty of body. It is adorned with full manifest and complete signs of exemplifications. So this is talking about the different signs that are supposed to indicate that a being is a Buddha. They talk about the Buddha Śākyamūni having all of these signs even though he was an emanation body instead of an enjoyment body. All of the enjoyment bodies and the emanation bodies have these signs, although they come in different shapes and sizes.

But there are certain signs and symbols that they have on their bodies to indicate what they are. Certainty of retinue, it is surrounded by only by Bodhisattva superiors, which means that only Bodhisattva superiors can have an audience with or experience a a enjoyment body. So that means that it’s not likely we’re gonna run into any enjoyment bodies. We are able to see an emanation body. So however, we just may not be able to perceive that they are emanation bodies because of our karma and delusions.

So the the the thing that the type of body that we’re gonna have the most connection with or the most contact with at the moment is an emanation body. We just may not always be able to tell that it’s an emanation body. I’m really sorry about this, guys, but I am in pain. I have to go to the toilet now. You said go for two minutes.

K? Yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
five certainties pañcaniyata (Skt); ngepa nga (Tib); nges pa lnga Wyl)
The five definite attributes of the sambhogakaya, the enjoyment body of a buddha. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
sambhogakaya enjoyment body; long ku (Tib)
The enjoyment body; the form in which the enlightened mind appears in order to benefit highly realized bodhisattvas. LYWA
three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top