Seventy Topics — 2003-08-14

44 min · 3,053 words · 14 August 2003 · Buddha House Adelaide

Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Seventy Topics — 2003-08-14
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Geshe-la’s candid admission that he doesn’t know where hell is located anchors the liveliest part of this 45-minute session. Geshe Pema Tsering opens by working through the 110 knower aspects — specifically the 37 resembling those in hearers’ minds: four close placements of mindfulness, four thorough abandonings, five powers and forces, seven branches of enlightenment, and the eightfold path. He pauses on the five powers and five forces to clarify that they are the same phenomena seen from different angles — one names the capacity, the other the active antidote. The session then opens into Q&A on rebirth and hell: how karma propels subtle consciousness into a new physical form, why not seeing something is no argument against its existence, and the variety of hell realms different karmas can produce. For practitioners engaged with Abhidharma-based study.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 02 ST8 2003 08 14.mp3

UUID: 0df09fe4-e7e4-4261-86af-af5007f4d57b

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2003-08-14

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 44.9 minutes

Words: ~3,051

Okay. It’s good thing you like lists. The next one is the one hundred and ten knower aspects. There’s one hundred and ten of these knower aspects of the exalted knower class that are related to omniscience or the knower of all aspects. There’s thirty seven that are related to the the hearer class.

There’s thirty four that there’s there’s there’s thirty four that are related to the minds of Bodhisattvas, the minds of Bodhisattvas, and there is thirty nine that are uncommon. And what by uncommon, it means that there are other the Buddhists are the only people that have them. Okay. So the thirty four that are the way that they’re related to Bodhisattvas is that Bodhisattvas have them in their mind stream, these different types of minds. So they’re they’re different practices that the Bodhisattva is doing.

So so if you add up thirty seven, thirty four, thirty nine, you get a hundred. Thirty nine. Okay. So because we’re talking about the aspects of an exalted knower, then these minds, the the ones that we’re gonna get onto next, the thirty seven aspects that are the exalted knower of aspects similar to those existing in hearers, minds of a Buddha. They’re not minds that are found anywhere else apart from the Buddha ground.

The first ones, the ones we mentioned earlier, were those related to hearers. There are thirty seven were mentioned in the last paragraph here. There are thirty seven aspects that are the exalted knower of aspects or Buddha’s minds that are similar to those existing in the hearers in a hearers’ continuum. So, four close placements of mindfulness. Now, they’re usually but we have to take into account it’s not just foreplace four close placements of mindfulness, but those which are in a Buddha’s superior’s continuum and are thoroughly investigating objects.

So they’re a mind or a path, but they’re completely investigating phenomena only in the mind of the Buddha superior. Lots of times we talk about the four close placements of mindfulness, and they’re not just referring to those that are in a Buddha’s continuum. You can talk about Bodhisattvas having four close placements of mindfulness in their continuum and all different beings. But because these ones are referring to those that have had all obscuration abandoned from them, then they only have to refer to they can only refer to those in this in the continuum of a Buddha superior. Okay.

So they don’t have a bold type Tibetan. So there’s a the the the what they do instead of that is they they list the main categories at the beginning. Yeah? And then they go back and take one category at a time and explain different things in Geshe la just read out was the first listing of the main categories. Basically, they said, Okay, there’s four close placements, there’s four thorough abandonings, four legs of magical manifestations, five powers, five forces, seven branches of enlightenment, eightfold path of superiors.

And then he goes back and explains it in more detail. But I was just explaining to him that they don’t do it twice in English. So the, yeah, so the four close placements of mindfulness, the close placements yeah. Close placements doesn’t mean much, does it? So the four it’s here, it’s not you can’t say concentration, though.

So the four and it’s it’s it’s it’s it’s like it’s it’s the same word used for mindfulness is the is is the good bit, but foreclose means it just means intense mindfulness. Alright? So intense or very concentrated mindfulness of of body, intense or very close mindfulness of feeling, and minds. It’s being very aware of what you’re doing, being very aware of what you’re feeling, being very aware of what you’re thinking, and being very aware of all phenomena. Right.

Okay. The the thing the other thing is with the with the close placements of mindfulness, there’s actually a lot of detail in them within the main commentary to the fourth chapter of the clear ornament, which I think we’re doing later. There’s more explanation of those different types of mindfulness in that. Now, the next thing is the four thorough abandonings, which arise without effort in the mind of a Buddha superior. First one is the thorough abandoning that is the non generation of non virtues not yet generated.

So basically, what this means is because they have abandoned, right, completely gotten rid of negativities, it’s continually getting rid of something that hasn’t arisen yet. So if you were going to say the thorough abandoning of non virtues that have been generated, then that would be an action of someone who hasn’t completed the path. Right? So because they’re a border, they’re not generating any negativities, but they have this continuous action of not generating this continuous action of not generating negativities. Oh, go on.

Don’t worry. Doesn’t make sense to me either. Okay. Okay. So let’s see if I can get this one in.

The generating, right, the non generation of non virtues. Okay? Yeah. So they’re the the teacher goes, okay. Generating the non generation of non virtues.

So that means that they’re continually they’re not they’re they’re their virtues is getting more and more and more all the time because they’re continually not generating non virtues. Okay. So so this this process that we’re going through before of not generating of generating not generation of negativities followed through in the other three different types of abandoning, that this continuing practice of abandoning non virtue or having abandoned non virtue, not regenerating them, is expanded and therefore virtue continues to increase. So that’s the process that’s happening in the other three categories of the four thorough abandonings. Then we have the four legs of magical manifestations, which is what Buddhists are able to do in meditative stabilization.

So there’s four different types of this. There’s the leg of magical manifestation of aspiration, in that they have this continuous aspiration of of intention, and that’s the motivation and analysis or wisdom. Then there’s five powers, power of faith, effort, mindfulness, meditative stabilization, and wisdom. So, yeah, then there’s the five forces, which are exactly the same as the five powers. So so they’re talking about So they’re talking about different aspects to the one action by these five powers and the five forces.

For example, the five forces are the things that are used in order to act as an antidote to something. So for example, the force of faith is what’s used to get rid of non faith or get rid of doubt. Yeah? And so but the power of faith is the the ability to be able to do that. Right?

So one of them is the force that’s used, and one of them is the ability to be able to do it. Okay. He’s I guess he says the same thing. He’s like, if you have a person driving a car, then they’re a person driving a car. That person may then get out of the car and go in and start working, then they’re a person working.

Then they may come home and read a book, and when they’re reading a book, they’re a person reading a book. But it’s actually the same person. So they are the same person who has different ways of looking at that person. So these are the same process, but there are different ways of looking at the same process. But they have different objects.

For some, the object is faith, and for the others, the object is effort and so forth. Right? Okay. Now the next one, the seven branches of enlightenment. Right?

And every time you have a branch, when something’s referred to as a branch, it actually means a cause. Right? So, this is the seven causes of enlightenment. Seven causes of enlightenment correct mindfulness, which basically means, he said, not forgetting things. Yeah?

And the next one, the branch of enlightenment of correct discrimination of phenomena, which is discrimination or wisdom. It’s sometimes called wisdom, but then something else is called wisdom too. Yeah. So discrimination or wisdom. Correct effort is is obvious.

Correct being joyful and happy about it as well. pliancy as in is the word that’s used when people develop calm abiding. They have this pliancy of body and mind. So that’s that. Branch of enlightenment of correct meditative stabilization, so that’s meditative equipoise, and the branch of enlightenment of correct equanimity.

Now, these may be this is what I was getting in trouble for. These may be the cause for enlightenment, but they have to be in the mind stream of a Buddha as well because Buddhas know everything. Okay? So they’re a cause, but they’re also a mind of a Buddha. Because I said, how can they be the cause and the result?

And he said, because Buddhas know everything. And he said, you’re stupid. I said, I’m not stupid. And he’s laughing at me for saying it, which is a bit scary. Okay.

So the next one, eightfold path of superiors. So that means eight causes that superiors have in their mind stream that will lead them to Buddhahood. Now, for the same reasons as we before, then that means that they are in the mind stream of a Buddha as well as being in the mind stream of a aryans or superiors on the path towards Buddhahood. Okay? So the eight of these are correct view, which is wisdom understanding emptiness, correct investigation, which is the mind investigating emptiness, correct speech, correct aims of action.

That means correct it means correct behavior. Yeah? It’s it’s basically or or you could say correct action, correct correct behavior, correct karma. It’s like but karma means weird stuff. Alright.

Okay. Correct livelihood, Correct effort being happy about doing it because you’re gonna have to do a lot of meditation and so forth. So correct effort means working hard. Correct mindfulness means not forgetting things and being aware of what you’re doing. And correct stabilization or concentration.

So we can stop there then. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. The the I think the eightfold path of superiors is the same.

Same thing. That’s what I’m saying. Yeah. It’s the same. It’s just a different translation.

Yeah. Because I was trying to think of a different way to put it. Yes. He’s telling me it’s really famous from the Theravadin system. But he did it doesn’t they don’t have the same tradition of him teaching it in the same teaching of the wheel as the four noble truths.

You know, He said the first turning of the wheel was the gist of the teachings in the four noble truths. Yeah. In the Theravāda system, I think, teach us. Part of the four noble truths. Part of the truth of the path.

Yeah. They they describe the truth as part of this. Yeah. Well, he said that that’s probably because it’s like the main essence of the practice. I always wanted to know Uh-huh.

Ahead if we die. After we die, we go to a hell or paradise. Uh-huh. You know? And then Yeah.

And then the the spirit coming back to the earth one day. And then I was wondering, where is hell and paradise? And what what how can we understand reincarnation? Okay. So the way that we go from one lifetime to another, right, is that we our body doesn’t go.

Right? Our body dies, and our mind dies as well. And what’s left is a very, very subtle mind. Yeah? Because that very subtle mind has karmic imprints on it.

Karmic imprints? It has it has because it’s carrying karma. It has it is is associated with karma. It’s it’s under the influence of cause and effect of karma. Yeah?

Then it has to take rebirth some way. Yeah? It has to join itself with physical matter again of some kind. Yeah? With a form aspect because of the karma that it has.

Right? And therefore, because whatever its karma is, whatever karma it carries with it, propels it into another life, and it takes a physical form there. I said, Okay, so where’s hell? Geshe-la said, I don’t know. He doesn’t know.

He said, he thinks that hell is there’s some beings on earth, for example, he saw on television right, that there are these small animals in the bottom of the ocean, very small, and they were continually dying, were continually being killed, and they were experiencing extreme cold and suffering all the time. He said that in his mind is what hell is like. It’s just continual extreme suffering. Yeah? So, there’s no way for us without clairvoyance, yeah, without without superpowers.

Superpowers. Yeah. Like like, it was just mental mental powers. Yeah? To be able to see hell unless we’re born there.

Yeah? So we can’t say where it is, but it’s a state created. Right? That hell is created by the karma of the beings who are born there. Yeah?

So the the that that is why they be they’re born there. But we can see other lives that we don’t want to have, like animal lives and these insects’ lives and so forth. But for us to experience hell is difficult for us to see hell is not possible without developing this understanding. Without developing this understanding. This understanding.

A specific understanding. So just just because but just because we can’t see hell and just because we can’t see heaven, the different heavens, doesn’t mean they don’t exist. That’s not a logical premise. It’s not a good enough reason for hell and heaven not to exist. Right?

We accept the the Buddha the Buddha if you have faith in the Buddha, then the Buddha taught these different things. And based he taught reasoning or thinking through things. So he taught how to think through things and come to a logical understanding. Yeah? And so based on the logic on this logic, we can establish that there must be these places.

Because if there’s a if there’s a result to a terrible action, then it has to come back about in this kind of suffering. Alright? And just saying something doesn’t I can’t see something, so it doesn’t exist isn’t logical. So if because Geshe la said, for example, he hasn’t seen your parents. Yeah?

And but he thinks they exist. He thinks you must have had parents, but he’s never seen them before. So just saying you don’t something doesn’t exist because you don’t see it isn’t logical. I think by the way, I am so, arhat. Oh.

I am so, is that hell means something like a state of mind was condition, which is an illusion Uh-huh. Created by wrong belief. Okay. So Okay. There’s okay.

The the concept of a wrong view from the Buddhist perspective is not is not believing or not accepting some higher purpose or some higher force. Right? Right. Higher force like this. So so whether it’s the Three Jewels, the Buddha, or it’s God, or it’s the the workings of cause and effect, something like that.

Right? So by saying you don’t believe in the Buddha, you don’t believe in any religion or any belief system, and that you do something, you don’t have to accept the consequences, then that by the force of that, then you will do negative things here that will you will have to experience the results of. And then by the force of that karma, then a hell is created. But but beings in hell have a physical form as well. It’s not just consciousness.

Physical form. Physical form. I felt physically pain Uh-huh. Right away. Yeah.

Someone coming nighttime. Uh-oh. Is this in in, like, an experience? Or Yeah. Yeah.

I felt pain. Uh-huh. Okay. So, yeah, these kind of sufferings would be very extreme for p for beings in hell hell. And there’s different from the Tibetan Buddhist perspective, they talk about different levels of hell.

So some hells, because of the force of the karma that sent the beings there, some hells have extreme heat, some have extreme cold, and some people get chopped up. Their bodies get chopped up all the time, and they’re experiencing this intense suffering all the time. So he said that there’s not it it doesn’t there’s different levels. Right? But there’s it can be different as many different types of hells depending on the karma of the people.

Right? So if people have like the same type of karma, then they will be born into one hell. But they can be any different number of hells depending on how close people’s karmas are. Right? So he said, for example, you getting your tongue chopped?

Right? If it was like a hell based around that, for some reason, you would have a very long tongue and just they would chop little bits of it until there was no tongue left, then the tongue would grow back and they’d chop again. So you’d have this continual pain of having your tongue chopped in a continual continual pain, and it wouldn’t get any less. But that’s very strong negative karma that would create that kind of a specific result. What I experienced is.

What was It’s very fascinating. Did somebody actually cut your tongue, or did you have an experience? Yeah. That’s what I was Yeah. Felt like.

Felt like. So how does Geshe-la translate that? I don’t know what it means to translate it. What so so this was a you were meditating and had this experience, or it was a dream, or was it it felt like it? Problem.

Mental ah, alright. Okay. Alright. Okay. So any experience that you have being born into a human body is nothing compared to the sufferings that beings have in hell realms.

Alright? So it is a it’s a negative it’s it’s a ripening of some negative negativity, and you’ve experienced this suffering. Yeah? Because it’s whether what suffering your mind’s experiencing, not necessarily what your body is experiencing. But it’s not a hell realm.

Yeah? It’s not hell. It’s not hell. It’s not hell. It’s hell

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
five powers
The five practices to be applied in this life and near the time of death. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top