Seventy Topics — 2003-02-20

45 min · 3,381 words · 20 February 2003 · Buddha House Adelaide

Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Seventy Topics — 2003-02-20
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Geshe Pema Tsering opens this 45-minute session with a Lama Tsongkhapa verse: an expert’s non-virtue, however heavy, becomes light — “expert” here meaning skilled in purification, not academic achievement. He unpacks this through the four opponent powers: recognition (going for refuge and developing compassion toward those we have harmed), regret for misdeeds across all past lives, resolution never to repeat them, and applying the antidote through practice up to bodhicitta. A restaurant story — one diner dies, one nearly dies, the third is consumed with regret at having eaten the same meal — illustrates the quality of remorse required; the story of Deshek Gao, who killed his mother yet achieved arhatship through these powers, shows their scope. The session then returns to the Seventy Topics, tracing peak applications from the path of preparation through the ten bodhisattva grounds to the last moment of a sentient being’s continuum before Buddhahood.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 01 ST2 2003 02 20.mp3

UUID: c50f5f2c-6fdb-4839-87ef-3e13cc1ee37d

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Seventy Topics (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2003-02-20

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45.1 minutes

Words: ~3,378

An expert’s non virtue even though An expert’s non virtue even though heavy becomes light. An ignorant person’s non virtue even though small becomes heavy. This is Lama Tsongkhapa said in Lamrim Chenmo, the Lamrim Chung, and the Three Principal Aspects of the Path. So that’s exactly right. An expert in virtue, even though it’s heavy, becomes light.

But an expert isn’t necessarily an expert like we see on television or an expert, a scientist or an expert in anything else. It’s someone who’s an expert in clearing away negativity, expert in purification. In a like manner, an ignorant person isn’t necessarily someone who doesn’t know anything because someone could know the five sciences completely or the five arts completely and still be an ignorant person if they didn’t know how to purify how to regret properly because even if you do know what the five even if you do know the five sciences properly, if you don’t know how to regret and you don’t know how to purify properly, then it’s not going to help you that much. So since beginningless time, we’ve created we’ve collected a large number of non virtues. If we don’t try and purify these, just get heavier and heavier.

So the non virtues we may have collected that were small become middling and the ones that were middling become large and it works in this way. If we don’t purify them, then they create suffering that we all have to experience in the future. So in order not to experience this suffering in the future, we have to become an expert at purifying all our non virtues. So the way that we become an expert in purifying our negativity is through the four opponent powers. They’re actually called the four antidotes, but because they are very powerful, we call them the four opponent powers as well.

So if we understand these four opponent powers properly, whatever it is that we’ve accumulated, whatever the negativity is that we’ve accumulated, no matter how big it is, we can purify it if we’ve understood them correctly. Okay. There’s someone, Deshek Gao in Tibetan, I don’t actually know the translation for it, Deshek Gao, who’s a person who’s around at the time of the Buddha, and he actually killed his mother, which is one of the five heinous deeds that you can do. There’s five deeds that the Buddha said were the most serious of crimes and one of them is to kill your mother or your father and he actually killed his mother. But because Buddha taught him the four opponent powers, because he taught him how to regret and how to purify, this Deshek Gao was able to achieve — he became an arhat in that lifetime.

So on the basis of this, the four opponent powers and the power of regret, he was able to purify even this, the most heinous of deeds and achieve arhatship in that lifetime. So no matter how if he was able to do that, then no matter how great a greater negativity we’ve accrued, then we also have the ability to be able to purify that negativity. So the four opponent powers, the four powers that we use in order to purify our minds are either basis or recognition, regret, restraint or resolution, and practice or applying the antidote. The practice or applying the antidote are two different ways of translating the same thing, and so is restraint or resolution. So the first one being the basis or recognition.

Most of the misdeeds that we do, most of the negativities that we accrue are by way of doing negative things towards people or Buddhas. So the way we use this basis of recognition is in the first instance to prostrate and go for refuge and develop devotion for the Buddha and towards sentient beings develop compassion, loving kindness and ultimately the mind of bodhicitta wishing to achieve Buddha to save them from suffering. So the next one being the power of regret is developing this deep this deep feeling of of regret for all the bad deeds that we’ve done. And then some people will think that, well, I don’t haven’t done anything bad. I didn’t kill anyone in this life.

I don’t have anything to regret. But this regret isn’t just for this life as well. This regret has to be for all our lives since beginningless time. So even though we may think that I haven’t done much wrong in this life, there’s a fair there’s a it’s a fair bit that we’ve done lots of bad things in previous lives. So to get to regret all of these these negativities that we’ve accumulated since beginningless time, you have to feel this deep sense of regret of realizing wreck like realizing that what we’ve done is wrong.

So if we’re trying to look for things that we’ve done in previous life, we can look at a television where we see lots of shows about animals, and the animals seem to spend their whole lives killing other animals, whether it’s fish killing other fish or big animals killing other animals, they’re in the constant pursuit of flesh. So therefore, if they if that’s how they spent their lives at some stage in the past, that’s what we did with our lives. That would be something that we could concentrate on in terms of developing regret. So then, if we’re watching the television and we see this happening, then we should have this thought of, Oh, I did that before I caused this suffering. What I did was negativity in terms of the Buddhas and in terms of the sentient beings that I hurt.

So the first instance we should develop some kind of faith towards the Three Jewels and prostrate and go for refuge to Three Jewels. Then we should think of all the sentient beings that we cause suffering to and then think, I’m sorry that I caused them suffering and try and develop compassion for the sentient beings and their sufferings and then try and develop bodhicitta from that. So this this developing this sense of regret, developing this sense of the the this it is I mean, it’s the same word. The same this sense of regret that comes from, deep within us isn’t something that’s easy to do. Just if we look casually at the animals and think, Oh, I did that before then, that’s not really what we’re talking about here.

since beginningless time, we’ve developed habits that are negative. So in order for us to develop a really strong sense of regret, it’s not something we can just do on the spur of the moment. It takes a lot of work. We have to do a lot of meditation and a lot of familiarization with the things that we’re trying to be regretful for. We have to work at it.

It’s not something that just happens because we have to go against our mind’s habit since in order to develop this regret, but if we can develop it, then this is the best thing for purification. So when we’re talking about regret, the best way to illustrate what this regret actually is is to tell the story of three people who went into a restaurant to eat, and they all ate exactly the same meal. And when they walked out of the restaurant, one of them dropped dead, and then the second one was really, really sick, alright, and about to die. And then what the third one was feeling at that point was regret, that he’d eaten a meal. So it’s this sense of we’re the same as that person.

The things that we’ve done in beginningless lives are like eating that meal and there is so much suffering because of the things we’ve done. So we have to have that sense of, I shouldn’t have done that. Okay. So we we actually don’t usually do a very good job of regret. We don’t we don’t really understand what it means.

Like, Geshe-la says, for example, he if he eats meat, he he enjoys eating meat, but after he eats meat, he thinks, man, that was not a good thing to do. And I think he tries to develop regret for eating the meat, but then if someone puts a really tasty plate of meat momos in front of him, he’s instantly thinking about eating them, and before he knows it, he’s he’s almost eaten them. Even though he knows that last time he did, he had this sense of, Oh, yeah, that wasn’t a really good thing to do. So he doesn’t have he said that he hasn’t developed a sense of regret to its fullest potential. It’s difficult to.

So if we have this kind of half regret, if we have this sense of, well, really shouldn’t have done that, but it isn’t complete, then it only has the effect of purifying some of the deeds that we’ve done. It is definitely a benefit, but unless it’s complete regret, then it doesn’t wipe out the deed completely. So if we do have this regret, though, the other side of that, if we do have this really strong regret come up, really regret something from the bottom of our hearts and minds, then it does have the power to cleanse or to purify a lot of the negativity. Yeah, so that also goes for the idea of applying the antidote or putting the opponent’s powers into practice, in if we really had regret, then, we would do anything, in order to, to take back that action to get it right. So that means, if we really had regret, we would put into practice anything that it took to get rid of that.

And that would mean that could mean going for refuge, that could mean, meditating, that could mean anything after renunciation and trying and developing bodhicitta and achieving enlightenment. If if we really had regret, we would go even that far in terms of applying the antidote or putting it into practice to get rid of the negativities we’ve accumulated. Okay. I’m meaning — I still — sorry, I left one bit out before I went on to the front.

He said, so if we really have this regret, then we will vow never to do that again, and apart from never doing it again, we will also do whatever it takes to purify it, which was the, you know, prostrating everything up to enlightenment bit. Whatever it is that we’ve done that’s bad, if we apply these four opponent powers, we can purify them. But without purifying them, there’s no way that we can stop ourselves suffering the suffering that will come from those negativities that we have accumulated. So this is what the quote meant when it said an expert’s non virtue, even though heavy, becomes light. Is that no matter what it is that they’ve done, if they know how to purify it properly, then they can completely eradicate that.

They completely eradicate the negativities they’ve done and not have to experience their suffering. So Buddha Buddha Śākyamūni or any Buddha was once like us and even they were once like all the animals that we see on television. They would they were they were gorillas. They were snakes. They they were gorillas.

Yeah. Gorillas and snakes and all sorts of animals. And they spent all their time trying to get meat, they causing destruction to other sentient beings. But because they developed this way of purifying their negativities and because they understood how to purify them completely, then they were able to achieve Buddhahood. So because we have this ability to be able to get rid of our negativities, whatever it is that our negativities were, we should that should bring some kind of happiness to our mind.

And the happier our mind is, the better we are at, using these four opponent powers because we have, our mind is more uplifted so we can we can do this. So, we if we think in this way that even the Buddhas did all these really bad things but they are able to purify them properly and get rid of them, then I am able to purify them completely and get rid of them as well. So I should try really hard to purify properly and that should bring some kind of happiness to our mind. Okay. But this doesn’t mean that we can think, well, I can do whatever I want now, and I can do a bit of this, bit of that, because later on I can purify it.

That’s not the kind of mind that we should be developing here. Because, I mean, this is something that that we have to, actually keep regret. We have to, keep, having this sense of regret for the things we’ve done in the past and thinking that because of our regret for the things we’ve done in the past, will do what we can to try and purify them properly. That includes developing renunciation, going for refuge, doing any kind of practice that we’re going to do, and trying to think about compassion for sentient beings as well. Okay, so we’re having this sense of, okay, I’ve done something wrong in past, now I’m gonna try and do everything I can to make it, to purify that, and then not only that, to, because part of the purification practice was to promise not to do things in the future, to try and stop ourselves wanting to do it in the future, then we should try and do any of the practices we can.

And not only that, we should try and do any of the practices we can with the mind of bodhicitta, with the mind that we try and that anything we’re doing, we’re doing in order to be able to achieve Buddhahood, in order to help sentient beings. So whether it’s studying, the Heart Sūtra or studying the seventy topics or doing our own private practice, any of these things should be done with the motivation of trying to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. So with this thought in mind that we will try and do anything we can in order to achieve Buddhahood to help all sentient beings, then we should try and meditate with this mind. May I please, please attain enlightenment quickly, quickly in order to be of benefit to sentient beings? And I’ve been all over the place.

So he said, Please think well about it. And please practice well. That your mind isn’t really the problem. Your mind is the same sort of mind that Buddha had before he achieved enlightenment. So just put in the same way that Buddha was able to achieve enlightenment, then that you’ll be able to do the same thing if you do the practice and and have the and have the and try and do it.

I just wanna articulate that I have never I’m so emotional about Yeah. That’s okay. That I have never enjoyed this translation as much as I’ve been doing. Thank you. Okay.

We’re gonna start this bit now. Okay. We were at the which bit was it? We’re at the application. So last week we were doing the peak application.

We’re at the peak application, still in the introduction to the seventy topics, and we’re up to the divisions of the peak application. Does everybody know where we are? Yeah. Yeah. This one.

Is that okay? Yep. Okay, so the peak applications actually go from the path of preparation, go through the path of accumulation. Hang on. I’ve got it wrong.

Yeah. Path of preparation up until the the last moment of this continuum of a sentient being, and they’re not on the path of accumulation. So we have to start them at that second path being the path of preparation. Okay, so the next division apart from the first division was the peak application of the path of preparation. The second one is the peak application of the path of seeing.

Now, the first path that someone enters when they enter their Mahāyāna, vehicle is the path of preparation. No. Sorry. The path of accumulation. One does so by developing bodhicitta in the mind stream.

So after the so after the developed bodhicitta in the mind stream, you go from the path of accumulation and the path of prep onto the path of preparation. In both of these, have the mind that understands emptiness, but you don’t see emptiness directly. And then on the path of seeing, you see emptiness directly. So this second division of the peak applications being the peak application of the path of seeing is where you’re seeing emptiness directly. So there’s Okay.

There’s three divisions of the path of seeing, and they are the uninterrupted path, the path of release, and a third. Okay, so on the path of seeing, we have the uninterrupted path. When all of the things that need to be abandoned on the uninterrupted path are abandoned, then we have the path of release. Then there is another state which is called the meditative state — that is neither the uninterrupted path nor the path of release. So it’s three.

Right? Okay. On the path of meditation, there is ten grounds. Geshe-la said them very quickly and said, If I didn’t want to say them all, I didn’t have to, which is good because I don’t know them. But the first one is the the path of joy, the ground of joy, the first one is the and the tenth one is the clouds of Dharma, the ground of the clouds of Dharma.

That’s the ten grounds of the path of meditation. The fourth one, the uninterrupted peak application, is actually the last moment of the continuum of a sentient being and the last moment also of the path of meditation. It’s still on the path of meditation, but as it’s the last moment of the path of meditation and the last moment of the continuum of a sentient being, it’s separated out and called the uninterrupted peak application. Okay, so the border of the peak application is from the heat part of the path of path of preparation up until the last moment of the path of meditation, which is the last moment of the continuum of sentient being. It’s got it. Is that okay?

Oh, yeah. I could get a very, brief explanation of path of abandonment. So the path of abandonment. The path of abandonment. The What was first one that you’ve been mentioning?

A path of I said path of accumulation. Okay. The path of release is also called the path of abandonment. Didn’t know that. Sorry.

And it’s because when you finished all the abandonment on the on the Yeah. On the non interrupted path, and you have the path of release, which is also called the path of abandonment. Yeah. It is the abandonments of the path of seeing.

Before you reach enlightenment, you have to have two different types of abandonments. There’s another way of dividing the abandonments. It’s the abandonments of the path of seeing and the abandonments of the path of meditation. So the abandonments of the path of seeing include such things as anger and attachment and things like that. But that’s not the aim of them.

The aim of them is the meditations and teachings of the path of seeing. So therefore they’re called the abandonments of the path of seeing. And they’re not the ten non virtues. But they’re yeah. So the the there’s the last moment of the path of seeing, you’ve abandoned the abandonments of the path of seeing, you move on to the path of meditation.

The last moment of the continuum of a sentient being, which is the last moment of the path of meditation, you abandon the abandonment of the path of meditation and become a Buddha. That is what? Is that okay? So, yeah, so the the the other end of the

Key terms in this teaching

five sciences
Within Tibetan Buddhist education, they are: grammar, logic, medicine, arts and crafts, and religious philosophy. LYWA
four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
four powers
The four types of attainments often described in tantric initiations. They are: pacification (of delusions), increase (of realizations), control (of whatever needs controlling) and subduing (of negative forces). LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top