1 h 32 min · 8,052 words · 7 July 2003 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Starting from the claim that wrong views — not anger or desire — are the deepest root of all affliction, Geshe Pema Tsering uses this 92-minute public talk to argue that ignorance of emptiness is the single cause underlying all suffering. He maps this onto the Four Noble Truths, then guides listeners through Buddhism’s five philosophical schools in order of increasing subtlety, explaining why the Prāsaṇgika consequentialist view — that things exist only by being labeled onto collections of parts — is the understanding required for liberation. A sustained Q&A explores the difference between intellectual conviction and direct non-conceptual realization, why compassion and bodhicitta are needed to reach Buddhahood rather than mere liberation, and how the Buddhist denial of an inherent self differs from Hindu conceptions of Ātman. Framed explicitly as a foundational introduction to Buddhism for newcomers.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 06 PT 2003 07 07.mp3
UUID: 55dd027d-852e-42cc-8fbd-3b59cbb4d885
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Public Talks (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2003-07-07
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 92.4 minutes
Words: ~8,061
Because of those different states of mind we engage in, then we collect different types of karma. The six root afflictions are attachment, anger, pride, ignorance, negative doubts and wrong views. Among these six, the root of these six, in fact, is having wrong views. If we didn’t have wrong views, we wouldn’t engage in the other five root afflictions, so the most negative and the most destructive of all the root afflictions is afflicted views or negative views. So normally this wrong view is also called ignorance.
When we talk about ignorance, we usually talk about ignorance being things we don’t know. We’re ignorant about things because we don’t understand these things. But when we talk about ignorance in terms of it being one of the root afflictive minds, we are actually talking about the ignorance that doesn’t understand the true nature of reality, that doesn’t understand the way that things actually are. That’s the type of ignorance we are talking about here. Because we don’t understand the way that things actually are and we superimpose the way that we think they are onto the way that they actually are, then we are misled into doing negative things, we create negative karma because of our misunderstanding of reality.
The thing that we are ignorant about is the true nature of reality. What we mean by the true nature reality is that things are empty of true existence or empty of inherent existence. What this means is that things don’t exist the way that they appear to us as existing. That is not to say, on the other hand, that they don’t exist at all because things do exist. They just don’t exist the way that they appear to us as existing, because the way that they appear to us as existing is as if they are inherently existent, as if they have some energy from their own side that establishes them, when in fact all that they exist by is by us labeling them, by us perceiving them as being an inherently existent thing.
That’s how they exist. Because we see things as being inherently existent, including we see ourselves as being inherently existent, then we we develop desires for things, develop anger when we don’t get things we want and we develop negative states of mind. If we completely understood the true nature of reality, the way that things actually exist in that they are dependent on causes and conditions to come about and they don’t exist solidly as we think they do, then there would be no reason for us to have desires to satisfy ourselves because we understand that we don’t exist the way we think we do. Then there wouldn’t be any anger when we don’t get what we desire. None of these things would come about.
Beings who understand the true nature of reality don’t experience the other afflictive thoughts or negative thoughts. They don’t experience attachment or desire. They don’t experience anger, pride, ignorance or doubts because they understand the way that nature is, the true nature of reality. They understand that there is no being that needs to have their desire satisfied, that needs to get angry. They understand that that doesn’t exist the way that we think it does.
Therefore, they can’t develop these negative ways of thinking. So because of this because of this negative way of thinking, that makes us create karma. Because we create karma, then we experience suffering. We talked about the three different types of suffering that we experience. We talked about that previously.
What we need to understand from that is that those three different types of suffering, their root or their cause is the karma that causes them to manifest. The reason that we create this negative karma is because of these afflictive emotions or afflictive ways of thinking, negative ways of thinking. The reason that we have these negative ways of thinking is because we don’t understand the true nature of reality. So if we look at the real cause for us experiencing suffering, it’s our ignorance to the true nature of reality. Okay, so we have to understand then that the reason for us experiencing suffering is this misunderstanding of reality, it’s our ignorance.
What we need to do then is to get rid of that ignorance, to understand properly the way that things truly exist. If we spend a lot of time analyzing and we spend a lot of time using different modes of logic and experience in order to understand that the understanding of the nature of reality is an actual possibility, when we understand that it is a possibility, then we will start working towards it. Once we have achieved that understanding, then we have completely stopped any cause for us to experience suffering. That is what we call liberation or the attainment of nirvana, being able to stop the experience of suffering, so therefore getting rid of the cause. From amongst the four noble truths, it’s what is the third noble truth, the truth of cessation, what we’re talking about here, the complete abandonment of ignorance that causes the stopping the creation of negative karma and hence the stopping of the experience of suffering, that is the truth of cessation.
So this experience, this cessation of suffering, this cessation of suffering because of the cessation of the cause of suffering and the cause of suffering is gotten rid of because we understand the true nature of reality. Now, this formula is what the Buddhists salvation or what the Buddhists call liberation. All different types of religion talk about salvation or liberation or something like this. When we are talking about it from the Buddhist point of view, then this is what we are actually referring to: this is the Buddhist salvation or liberation. In order to be able to achieve this cessation of suffering, once we have established that it exists, then we practice what is called the fourth noble truth, which is the truth of the path, in order to achieve this cessation.
So when we are talking about the truth as a path, what we mean by the truth as path or the path towards achieving the cessation of suffering, the main principle or the main practice that is involved with the path is developing an understanding of emptiness, developing an understanding of the way that things truly exist. Because this is the key to stopping suffering and therefore achieving cessation of suffering, then that is the key. That’s the main focus of the truth as a path or the path in itself. Okay, so this understanding of emptiness, the way we achieve this understanding of emptiness is by doing a lot of analytical meditation using myriad different lines of logical reasoning or lines of reasoning. We use those in combination and we spend a lot of time and energy and we work incredibly hard to try and get this understanding.
For us to understand emptiness isn’t a very easy thing it’s something that’s difficult to achieve, so therefore it’s something we have to work incredibly hard towards achieving. But we have to keep remembering as well, though, that that’s the key to stopping suffering. Now, we may think that understanding emptiness would be a fairly logical, easy thing because we have to adjust the way we think. In fact, it’s incredibly complicated thing to try and understand and it’s perhaps made more complicated by the fact that, within Buddhism, and specifically within Tibetan Buddhism, there are many different what are called tenets, which are basically philosophical schools, systems of tenets or philosophical schools, ways of thinking, that approach emptiness from different perspectives. To these schools that came from India and according to them, there is what is called the Cittamātra or Mind Only school.
Is one of the types of schools, and they have their own philosophical system as to how emptiness exists. There is a different system developed by the people called the autonomous school or the Svātantrika school. There is also another system developed by what is called Prāsaṇgika school or the consequential school. They all talk about different ways of how reality is different to the way we perceive it in terms of different things. For example, the mind only school says that reality is devoid of separateness from our mind, and the autonomous school says that reality is empty of inherent or natural existence and the consequentialist school says that reality is only established by us labeling each other, so there are these different schools.
There are also two other philosophical schools called the sūtra school or the Sautrāntika school and the Vaibhāṣika or the Particularist school. Now, the Sautrāntika school say that there is no self of person. They don’t posit or they don’t say emptiness as a philosophy exists, but they say there is selflessness of the person, so that there is no inherent person with us. Then there is another school called the particular school, which believe in something similar to atoms, that everything can be broken down to its smallest particles, and hence there is no such thing as an inherent person, so that they also present a view of selflessness, which isn’t emptiness. So As you can see, it’s very complicated and there are all these different presentations of the way that things actually exist.
But in order to achieve liberation, in order to achieve the cessation of suffering, then we need to understand the way that things exist, so we need to understand these complicated philosophies. The way that they are set up is in an order which is getting subtler and subtler. The way that it is presented is that, in order to understand Sautrāntika school or the Sūtra school, we need to understand the school that has a grosser interpretation of reality, which is the particular school. First of all, need to understand the people who say everything is atoms. Then we need to understand the school that says that everything isn’t atoms and that we don’t exist.
That’s the sūtra school. Once we’ve established an understanding of their philosophy, then we can go on and try and understand the mind only school, which is the school that says that there is no distinction between subject and object, or mind and the things perceived by mind. Once we have established an understanding of that school, then we can try and gain an understanding of the autonomous school, that is, that things don’t exist inherently, that they exist because they merely exist in a conventional manner as being a bunch of characteristics. Then, once we have understood that concept of emptiness, then the final school, as presented by Tsongkhapa’s tradition or Geshe-la’s school is the consequentialist school, who say that nothing exists at all apart from the labels that we give them. So there is this more refined and more subtle understanding of emptiness that is understood as you work your way through the different schools and all the different presentations of emptiness.
So from saying this, in order for us to understand emptiness properly, then we have to understand this highest school or the most subtle school that we are talking about, the Prāsaṇgika consequentialist school. We are not just understanding it intellectually, but in order to achieve liberation we have to realize it or know it without conception. So that is the final presentation, the subtlest level of school. Now, what they are actually saying is that things don’t exist at all from their side, so they don’t project anything that is intrinsically existent towards us. Things become into existence because we perceive them as such, we label them as being truly existent.
That isn’t to say that they don’t exist at all, but they don’t exist the way that we perceive them to exist. They merely exist because we have labeled a group of different groups together as being something. That is all phenomena, not just some phenomena being truly existent and another phenomena being non truly existent. All phenomena are said to be not established from their side or not inherently existent. They don’t exist the way they appear.
That includes us, it includes our thoughts, it includes all the things that we see, all the physical objects that we interact with. Everything is said to be not truly existent. So even though this may be the way that they truly exist, the way they appear to us is not in that way. We take things to be truly existent. They appear to us as being truly existent.
Now, if we want to work on something, if we want to analyze something to see if it is truly existent, if we want to meditate or do analytical meditation to understand the true nature of existence properly, the best place to start is with ourselves. We can see that we think that we truly exist. We can see that think that we are incredibly important as well, if we watch the way we think. If we watch the way we think, we notice that we always are saying, I am going here, I am doing this, I am that. If someone says, Hey, you, we say, and we think that’s us, know most of our thoughts revolve around what we are going to do.
If we are going to explain something to someone, we always relate it in terms of I, so we have a very strong sense of who we are. We think about what we are doing and what we are going to do fairly regularly. We have this thought in our mind. We can see that we consider ourselves not only to be existent, truly existent, but very important as well. So this is a hard thing for us to get our head around.
We think, ‘Look, I’m here, I’m sitting here. I know I’m sitting here. I’m thinking I’m sitting here, so I am sitting here. I came here by car. I’m sitting here now.
I’m trying to listen. I’m a little bit tired. All of these things, we have a very strong sense of who of us being here, and we think, therefore we are. We have this idea in our minds. Because we have this strong idea that we exist the way we think we exist and that are truly the way we perceive ourselves to be, then it is very strange for someone to say to us, you don’t exist the way you think you do.
You are empty of inherent existence. We think, No, I’m not. I’m here. I’m thinking. I’m here.
I’m listening. I’m here. So it’s very strange for us to try and think about this. So the reason that we think it is so strange and the reason that we think that it is difficult to understand that we don’t exist is because we don’t know the way to think about it. We haven’t learned how to analyze whether we actually do exist the way we think we do or not.
The way that it is usually described to analyze ourselves is to first of all think, Okay, if you exist, what are you? Are you your body? Is that what you are? And we have to think, No, because if there is just a body and there is nothing else, that is not me. Then there is what is called in Buddhism the five collections, or the five groups of things.
The first group is the group of forms. We have to look and see, is my form me? Is that me? Then we have to come to the idea that that form itself is not me. The next one is my feelings are my feelings me or is there more to me than that?
If we can’t be just our feelings, therefore am I my ideas or my ability to discriminate? Then we have to say no. And then is it the consciousness? Are we just our consciousness? If we are just our consciousness, that means that we have no physical form.
Our physical form isn’t us. So by doing a process of elimination, then we can see that we don’t exist within any of these different groups of things that make up us. So it shows you that if we do this analysis, then we understand that we don’t exist as a solid entity the way that we think we do, because we are made up of all these different bits. Now, that is the way that emptiness is explained. Another way of saying that something is empty of inherent existence is saying that it is dependent on its parts, or it is what is called dependent arising, which basically means that there are groups of different things that come together and then we label onto that something.
So, for example, with us, we have this group of different types of mind, consciousness, we have a physical form made up of bits, and we have feelings made up of different types of feelings. Then the group of those together, we label as being us, and then we say, this I is what is going to drive somewhere, this I is what is going to eat my food, this I is what is going to sleep. But in fact, that is just the label that we put on a collection of different bits. This labeling process brings something into existence. It solidifies something as truly existing.
Understand that it’s merely the label that’s making it existing, because if there’s no label there, we are only left with bits. So this is the way that it works. We label this combination of groups of things groups of things coming together, we label that as being something, and that makes it exist. Now, what we have to understand is that it doesn’t exist inherently it only exists because it’s been labeled as such. So by establishing a view of reality like this, his school is presenting the idea that things do exist, but they don’t exist the way that they appear to exist.
So if we understand this properly, then we cease to have a concrete view of ourselves and cease to do negative things. But in order for us to understand this view properly, we can’t just have one idea and then get it. We first of all have to try and understand it intellectually, basing it on the lower the lower school and do a lot of analysis and put it into practice. Then we have to do a lot of analytical meditation. Through the process of analytical meditation, then our idea of this philosophy, or the idea of this presentation of reality, will change from being merely an idea to become something that we understand directly, something that we see directly, something that our senses can perceive directly, and not something that is just an idea.
So this is something that we should be meditating on ourselves, because if there is no self, then we don’t do any negative things in order to please the self or associate the self’s desires. But this understanding of selflessness or phenomenon of us, or lack of inherent existence shouldn’t just be applied to ourselves but to all phenomena, everything that we encounter, everything that we think, everything we should perceive as being empty of inherent existence, as being only coming about when a collection of causes and conditions that have come together are labeled something. We have the result of a cause and the result of conditions bringing a group of something that comes together, and then that group of some things is labeled one thing, and therefore, that’s how it comes into existence. So another way of explaining this is to say that every single thing that exists comes about in dependence on something else. It is what is called dependent origination or arising.
What it basically means is that anything that exists comes about because of another cause that caused that to come into existence or because a group of things have come together. So everything that we experience comes about because of being dependent on something else. Therefore, that means things don’t exist from their own power or their own side as their own entity. They come about because of other things or other phenomena and other causes. They don’t exist because they have the ability to make themselves exist.
But that is the way that we see them. We see things as being inherently existent, as coming about from their side, especially when we are referring to ourselves. We see ourselves as being something that has the power to make itself exist, and the same with all other phenomena we encounter. So, therefore, we have to understand that everything comes about in reliance on something else. That’s what’s called we talked about dependent origination.
Because everything comes into existence on reliance on something else, or is labelled in reliance on the parts that make it up. Then these things can’t exist from their own side, they can’t be inherently existent, they can’t exist truly without anything else infracting on it or influencing that. They can’t exist solidly from their side. They have to come into existence because of other things. So if you have something that is coming into existence because of other things, then it can’t be truly existent, it can’t be inherently existent.
It has to be a dependent origination or arising. It has to come about on other causes and conditions. In this way, we see that dependent origination, or this coming about because of causes and conditions, is actually a synonym or the same thing as emptiness. Because for something to be dependent on other things to come into existence, then it has to be empty of its own inherent existence. Those two things work together they become synonyms for it.
If we can understand these two things, if we can understand dependent origination and emptiness, then we have what is called the wisdom understanding emptiness, and this wisdom understanding emptiness is what we need in order to stop suffering. So we talked about before how the root of afflicted thoughts or the root of negative thoughts was this non perception, this ignorance of the true nature of reality. So we see now that an understanding of emptiness, the wisdom understanding emptiness and this ignorance are mutually exclusive. Are opponents of each other. You can’t have one and not the other.
You can only have one you can’t have both. If you have wisdom, understanding you don’t have ignorance that doesn’t know the true nature of reality. Understanding emptiness cuts through the base or cuts through the root of the other negative ways of thinking that we may develop, because they’re all dependent, they all come about because of our wrong view of reality. And then what also happens is because this mind or the thoughts, the way of thinking that understands the true nature of reality, its base is actually something that is true, that means that it is a steady mind, a mind that is correct and unable to be eroded. On the other hand, the mind based on ignorance, the mind that we have that seems to be truly existent, that mind doesn’t have a steady base, doesn’t have what is called a valid cognition or it doesn’t have a valid base.
It has got something that is made up as its base. Its base is fake. Therefore, its ability to withstand an insight into emptiness is impossible. It doesn’t have ability to understand it. Because it’s based on a lie or an incorrect thought, the understanding of emptiness completely wipes that idea out, wipes the idea of us truly existing out, wipes ignorance out.
So this mind that is looking, the wisdom that understands the true nature of reality, because it is true, it is a mind understanding or a thought pattern understanding the way things actually are, and because it is not dealing with lies or misthought or misunderstandings, if we keep focusing on that, if we keep meditating on this mind, then the mind if we keep meditating on this way of thinking, then the other ways of thinking that we have, the ways of thinking that are based on incorrect interpretations of reality and lies, basically, that we have incorporated into the way we think, then they will be completely wiped out. They don’t have a valid base. They don’t have anything that will strengthen them if we are actually looking into the true nature of reality. They don’t have the weight of truth behind them. Therefore, when we apply analysis to them, we will see that they are not true therefore they will fade away.
That means that this continual meditation or analysis of the way things truly exist acts as like a stopper or a wiper-outer of these negative ways of thinking, these incorrect ways of thinking. They will disintegrate if we keep thinking about the way that things truly exist, because the way that things truly exist is a much more powerful way of looking at things than the advantageous or the temporary negative or incorrect ways that we are thinking about things at the moment. What this means is then that if we do understand, we will keep doing the mindfulness of stop doing things that are going to cause us to experience suffering in the future. Because if we see the way that things truly exist, there’s no reason for us to to be if we see the true nature of reality, there’s no reason for us to do negative things. We see that there’s no point to doing that.
So we’ll just stop doing it. So once we’ve understood the way that things truly are, the way that things truly not the way I think truly is because I just said we just said they didn’t, but the way the the true nature of reality, the the final nature of reality. Once we’ve understood that, then we destroy our grasping at this our sense of self, which is the cause for us to do negative things. And then after that, if we keep meditating on it, even after that, we destroy the the imprints, the tendencies in our mind in our mind stream to to do these kind of negative things. We destroy those completely.
Once we’ve done that, then we achieve Buddhahood. We achieve omniscience because we’ve gotten completely rid of all the negativities that are clouding our that have cloud our mind. So this is all achieved by meditating, is by understanding the true nature of reality. So what this means is that we get this understanding of the way that things really exist, and we get an understanding and have direct perception of the way that things are not inherently existent, are empty of inherent existence. As we develop this understanding and we get rid of even the tendencies towards thinking in that way that we have in our mind stream, this means that we never do anything negative again.
We never do any we never have any pride. We never have any of the other afflictive root afflictive ways of thinking, and we never have anything like spite, jealousy, any of the secondary secondary afflictive ways of thinking. We don’t have any of those in our mind stream anymore. Therefore, we don’t create any more karma. Therefore, we don’t experience the results of any more karma, which is we don’t experience any more suffering.
And this all comes about because we have this understanding of the way things really are. Now what happens after that is we develop this way understanding of the way things actually are, that we keep meditating on that more and more and acclimatizing our mind to it, customizing our mind to it, then our understanding of the way things are becomes much more subtle and more subtle and more subtle and more subtle, until eventually it completely understands the way everything is, and we achieve liberation or we we we get rid of we achieve complete cessation of suffering. So in this way, we can understand that the whole of the teachings are presented in these four noble truths that we talked about at the beginning. From the one hand, we have the things that we need to get rid of. We have the suffering and the causes of suffering.
So first of all, we understand that we’re suffering. And once we’ve understand what’s causing to suffering, then we start getting rid of the things that are causing us to suffering. Then we realize that the root reason for us to suffer, the main cause for us to suffer, is behind all the other things that make us suffer, is this idea of true existence, of grasping at true existence. So once we get rid of that, then we’ve achieved this true cessation. So in order to achieve the true cessation, we follow the path, which is developing an understanding of emptiness and developing that understanding until it becomes subtle and subtle, until it’s completely clear and we’ve achieved liberation.
If we do it by just focusing on emptiness and understanding the nature of reality, then we achieve liberation. If along with this mind of searching for liberation and understanding emptiness, we also develop, first of all, compassion and then the mind wishing to achieve enlightenment to benefit all beings and not just ourselves, then what the end end goal is is, in fact, Buddhahood, complete Buddhahood, not just liberation. So either way, whether it’s liberation or trying to achieve Buddhahood or achieving Buddhahood, then that is the whole way of the noble truths. Mhmm. So that is the four noble truths, and if anyone has any questions.
Did you did it make sense? I said How would you help me? He said it’s hard. So Yeah. But the consumer Yeah.
You mentioned about the different levels? Uh-huh. The different schools. Yeah. Yeah.
Are they in order? Okay. Yeah. Yeah. The one that you mentioned that The consequence list.
Yeah. Mhmm. Subtle. Yeah. So we’re trying to understand Uh-huh.
Jump to the top one. Okay. Absolutely. I’m just gonna put a note in here. Consequentialist means pointing out other the consequences of other people’s arguments.
So the whole understanding of it is based on other people’s arguments. He said you have to start with the first one, which is the Vaibhāṣika or Particularist school. If you don’t understand that, then there’s no way you can understand Sautrāntika or the Sūtra school. If you can’t understand that, you can’t understand the next one. If you can’t understand that, you can’t understand Mādhyamika or the Middle Way school.
If you can’t understand that, then there’s no way you can understand Prāsaṇgika or consequentialist school. Because their philosophy is pointing out why other people’s arguments don’t work. So if you don’t understand the arguments, then you can’t understand the result. The thing that they’re pointing out doesn’t work. The you mentioned about the dependent arising.
Uh-huh. Uh-huh. Yeah. Okay. He said the way that he was explaining it was from the point of view of the consequentialist school.
He was explaining it, but the other schools talk about dependent origination and dependent arising, but they do it in a different way. So it gets really complicated because, for example, the mind only school talk about dependent origination as being with reference to the things coming about because they are the same essence as mind. And the Sautrāntika school, the Sūtra school, they say and the Vaibhāṣika, the Particularist school, they say things come about because of causes and conditions, and that’s their explanation of dependent arising. So all of them say this is dependent arising, but actually have a different description of what dependent arising is. He said that at this stage, you should probably try and develop imprints of what the highest school, the consequential school, is talking about.
So you may not understand it completely, but if you keep trying to understand it and you develop, like, the imprints, and then if you understand it properly, then you go back and do the other ones. Yeah. What do you mean by reality? Because he wasn’t talking about reality. He was talking about phenomena.
Phenomena. Yeah. So you mean, like, is okay. Okay. So so so, basically, they have this idea of the you’re talking about Ārya Yoga and everything because they talk about everything being, like, the body of Brahman.
Yeah? Or that I was relating to the idea of self. Yeah. Right? That what you see as the body or what, you know, that is the real self.
Yeah. And that’s it. So that that that they talk about yourself as being that which is is like Ātman. Yeah? Is that what you’re talking about?
Oh, yeah. You’re starting up from a resume. Yep. Okay. See, that one I can do.
Explain to him. Guess who said that he can’t he doesn’t know about he hasn’t ever studied aboriginal philosophy or Hindi philosophy, so he can’t speak with expert things on those. Even what he was saying here, he wasn’t saying what he thinks. He was saying what it says in texts that the prasangika thinks, because he doesn’t have the ability to know reality enough say which one he thinks it is. He said, there’s this thing put forward by the Buddhist the definition of a Buddhist is one who doesn’t accept a singular, independent, permanent self.
And that’s the difference. There is nothing that doesn’t that isn’t merely labeled like in the description of the prasangika or consequentialist school. There’s not a sort of a soul that they’re talking about. It doesn’t there’s not one of those, and that would be the main difference between the Buddhist view and those views. There is nothing So so from the Buddhist perspective, something that’s permanent is something that doesn’t change, something that is is usually a negative, a description of something not existing, Right?
Is is something that’s permanent. Something that is existent is always in a state of change. Therefore, it can’t be permanent because it’s continually changing from moment to moment to moment. Therefore, it doesn’t abide, if you like, in a singular type of way. Therefore, they say that it can’t be a a single entity that’s permanent because it’s constantly changing.
So but that’s the slight that was just getting at the idea of what they were saying. So you wanna know, like, a brief description of what reality is? Okay. It’s all a state of flux. Right?
The everything is perm perm is is permanently changing. It’s constantly changing everything. So whether it’s us, whether it’s the world, whether it’s everything, it’s all in a state of constant change. The only thing that will outlast the the only thing that will outlast everything that’s in constant change is emptiness. That is, the only thing that will outlast everything being in constant change is the lack of inherent existence of everything in con in constant change.
So so that’s the catch do kind of thing. You know what I mean? It’s Oh, no. You didn’t say that. No.
But that’s it includes someone here that I can’t be comfortable. Okay. But, yeah, then there was there was more to it, though, because he also said that everything is is constant state of change, but there’s things that there there’s the the emptiness of things is not in a constant state of change. So you have these two things working together. He said he he said he doesn’t know for certain, but then he doesn’t ever experience anything that contradicts it.
He said, everything’s in a constant state of change. Can you say anything that was in a constant state of change? You were young once. What happened? Not like you.
Like, little. Like, terrible things. Little and what happened? Yeah. Yeah.
But that that is not that old. Sorry. Yeah. So you were little once. What happened?
How did that change? The everything has to be and he hasn’t seen anything that hasn’t been in a constant state of change, so he thinks, therefore, he has to accept that everything is in a constant state of change. And he can’t imagine how anything wouldn’t be in a constant state of change. He he said he doesn’t know. He he doesn’t know, but he’s read he doesn’t know that emptiness is is the thing.
If he knew that emptiness was real, then he would be enlightened and he wouldn’t have anything to worry about. He knows that it’s in texts that they describe emptiness and they describe different ways of analyzing emptiness. By using the analysis that he has learnt, then he hasn’t seen anything to disprove it. Therefore, he can’t say it does exist — because if he could see emptiness directly, he would be a Buddha, but he said that he hasn’t seen anything disprove it, and all the other stuff that they’ve said seems to work, so why wouldn’t that? And he said the other thing was, it’s not up to him to tell you what to believe.
It’s up he’s trying to figure it out for himself, and you have to try and analyze for yourself as well. He says so Buddha said in different texts, he said, Buddha said, it’s like this and it’s like that. So he says, Buddha says this, but I don’t know anything. Yeah. He does, I don’t know what it is.
Everything if you have liberation. You understand how it works. How the nature of reality Yes. That one. Compassion.
Yep. Yeah. The reason that you need compassion So the reason you need compassion is because there isn’t just you. There is sentient beings. All sentient beings like yourself want to be happy and don’t want to experience suffering.
So if you achieve liberation, you’re only dealing with yourself. If you’re just dealing with yourself, then you’re not taking into account that there are these other beings out there that don’t want to suffer. You’re just working for your own benefit. So if you only achieve liberation for your own benefit, you can’t be of benefit to sentient beings. Yeah?
So the idea of compassion comes about with seeing that other beings are suffering, and that they have connections to you. They have helped you, therefore you don’t want them to suffer. So therefore you have to achieve enlightenment or complete Buddhahood. Because as a Buddha, you have your own and others’ benefits. You’re working for both.
Therefore you can be of benefit to sentient beings. You can show all sentient beings how not to suffer. You can be of benefit to them. So because there are other sentient beings, then we need compassion. Okay.
So the if we have two things, if we have the mind realizing the true nature of reality, if we are able to perceive the true nature of reality and bodhicitta, which is the thought to achieve enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings, which comes is developed after compassion, a great compassion. With those two things together, then they work with each other to take us to enlightenment. They help each other to develop different states of realization in our mind, and we achieve enlightenment. If we only have wisdom, understanding, emptiness, if we only have that kind of wisdom, then we can only achieve liberation or nirvana, which is our own cessation of suffering. But if we have this compassion, then we achieve compassion and bodhicitta, then that working along with emptiness takes us all the way to enlightenment or Buddhahood.
So there’s a difference. Okay. Yeah? bodhicitta and emptiness, both means you achieve Buddhahood. Just understanding emptiness means you achieve liberation.
Yeah. What’s the difference between a realization and just having, like, a really deep understanding of something with the feeling of conviction, and where does one become the other? Okay. So one is realization. Yeah?
And the other one’s when you have a A understanding of something. A deep understanding. So an analogy the feeling of and that conviction. Okay. Okay.
I think, again, the deal Right. In general, when we talk about a realization, we’re talking about a direct perception of something. So when you have an understanding of something, it’s like an intellectual understanding and a deep conviction that it exists. Right? And then you do meditations and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings on that, over a long period of time and familiarize with it, then what you are basing your meditations on in your analysis is what is called an inferential cognizer, saying, therefore, there is something that is, for example, there is smoke on the hill, there is smoke, therefore there is fire.
Right? So you are basing your understanding of emptiness on an analytical process. So if you keep meditating on that again and again, and that’s a conceptual mind, you’re conceiving of that. So you keep meditating on that and that again and again, eventually your understanding ceases to be conceptual and becomes non conceptual, in the same way that we see a chair, then we see emptiness. Yes?
It’s a non conceptual mind. It’s not a concept we’ve arranged in our mind that’s based on analysis. It’s a direct perception of something. That’s a realization. Doesn’t that mean you have direct like a realization of, like, an understanding of harm or a direct realization of it?
You know? Yeah. Any of those. First of all, you have a conceptual understanding, and then you develop a non then it clears away to a non conceptual understanding. Yep?
Another pretty question, Patricia. Even harder than last one, Kathy, do you have ultimate compassion for all the sufferings? The only way to end the suffering of sentient beings is for all sentient beings to become Buddhas. That’s the only way that you can end the suffering of sentient beings. Just you cannot destroy a sentient being.
You cannot Buddhas cannot destroy sentient beings. They can because it’s this consciousness that goes on and on. The only way for all sentient beings to be destroyed is for all of them individually to attain Buddhahood, and then they cease to be sentient beings. They’ll become Buddhas. So if there’s so that you can’t destroy Oh, he’s he he wanted to know what you wanted to do.
Yeah. Said there ‘s no other way to to get rid of sentient beings than to to to all sentient beings to become Buddhas. Thought that’s all right. Okay. So does the guest ask? If you have the five contaminated aggregates with, like, five combinations of things that have come about because of negative karma, then you’ve got suffering.
If you don’t have any of those but that he’s including mind in that as well. Yeah? If you have and if you don’t have any of those, if they’re not from didn’t come about because of negative karma, then there’s no suffering. But he doesn’t think that just having a physical body that that a physical body is the only base for suffering. He thinks if there’s mind, that is a mind that’s being propelled along by karma, then there’s suffering.
I don’t know. I just that’s because I know the answer to this. It’s gonna be scary. Okay. Right.
So if you have a body that’s come about, right, because of negative karma, alright, the result of negative karma, then you’re going to experience suffering. But Buddhas have bodies. Buddhas have different types of bodies to us because their bodies come about because of positive actions and the two collections of merit and wisdom. Alright? So they’ve collected all this positive karma and they have all this wisdom.
And because of the wisdom and the positive karma, they have bodies which are there to benefit other beings. Therefore, is no suffering because there is no grasping of self. Suffering for a Buddha. That was the first question, even though they have bodies. Second question, can you achieve Buddhahood in a human body?
He said, from point Sūtra schools, you can’t. From the point of view of the Tantra schools, you can, so therefore we’d say yes in general. Well, it would have been hard. You had to learn Tibetan first. He said because it’s put up as a beginner’s introduction to Buddhism.
Yeah? Or then he should thinks he should teach the Four Noble Truths because that’s the best introduction to Buddhism. What where would we go now? What’s the next step out? Studying.
Okay. So in the next there’s a break for a couple of weeks now. Yeah? And then in the next turn, there’s, like on Tuesday nights, there’s a what’s called discovering Buddhism, and that has different units that you can do. There’s also a Wednesday night class, which may be a bit trickier.
Geshe-la’s teacher is coming to teach here, who is a lama who lives in Adelaide. That’s the path, but it may be a bit more difficult to understand. And then in the class on Thursday night, Geshe-la said, I don’t I think that might be a bit trickier Thursday night class. And I said, yeah. I don’t understand that.
Sorry. Yeah. Yeah. Thursday night class is like, what are you talking about, Geshe-la? Yeah.
Yeah. So you said yes. No. Yeah. Yeah.
That’s fine, he said. You can hog the time. The way that he’s presenting it, it’s not jigsaw puzzle. It’s Yeah. But I’ll just double check that.
Because I don’t know if it’s Tibetan for jigsaw puzzle. So I said, is it like a ladder? And then I was trying to think of something that was like a jigsaw puzzle. But he said, no. No.
It’s like a ladder. And there’s with things being more subtle but, yeah, the Buddha taught different ways of explaining the truth. He explained the truth in different ways because there was people with different understandings. So, yes, he said different levels of what’s called faculties or ability to comprehend things. Not only that, but different dispensations.
So some people had a would work towards their own liberation but wouldn’t necessarily be interested in in the in other people. So therefore, there was a the path presented for that. Yeah? So he did he he made up all these different ways of explaining the truth or to help different people with different ideas and different different dispensations or different abilities. Buddha Śākyamūni and other Buddhas, when they teach, they don’t teach the same way as he does.
When they teach, they teach so every single person that is listening, their potential will be fulfilled. So know exactly what to say to every mind and whoever they are teaching to. So if there is one person that is having trouble understanding emptiness, they will hear a discourse on emptiness. And if there is one person having trouble understanding compassion, then they will hear what it is they need to hear in order for them to understand compassion. Because the Buddha has fully developed all qualities, then they know exactly what each student needs to hear in order to develop their understanding.
He said if you actually met a Buddha who was manifesting as a Buddha alright? Because there’s Buddhas that manifest as all sorts of things. But if you met a Buddha who was being a Buddha, yeah, then there’d be nobody who met them who didn’t know that they were a Buddha. Yeah. Yeah.
But it depends on what the Buddha is being. Yeah. But he said that because they not only would know what exactly it is you needed to know, but they’d know everything. So you then nobody who met them would nobody who met them would be able to say would hang on. It’d be plain as the nose on your face.
Can you please
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is the difference between a realization and a deep intellectual understanding with conviction, and how does one turn into the other?
A realization is a direct perception of something. An intellectual understanding, even with deep conviction that something exists, is still conceptual. When one meditates on a teaching over a long time and becomes familiar with it, one is relying on an inferential cognizer, reasoning like "there is smoke on the hill, therefore there is fire." Understanding emptiness in this way rests on an analytical process and is a conceptual mind. By meditating on it again and again, the understanding eventually ceases to be conceptual and becomes non-conceptual, so that one sees emptiness the way one sees a chair.