Mind Training — 2005-08-21

1 h 12 min · 6,174 words · 21 August 2005 · Buddha House Adelaide

Mind Training (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Mind Training (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Mind Training — 2005-08-21
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. A slogan offered midway through this 72-minute session captures its whole thrust: “even when your coffee’s cold, it’s your fault.” Geshe Pema Tsering continues a series on the Seven Points of Mind Training, moving past the Tonglen section into the third point — transforming bad circumstances into the path. He explains why the practice was historically taught in secret: the claim that self-cherishing causes all our suffering, and that other beings are the true source of our happiness, is genuinely difficult to accept. He unpacks the root text instruction “drive all blames into oneself,” grounds it in karma and personal responsibility, then contrasts the fleeting happiness of saṃsāra with the stable happiness that arises when self-grasping is abandoned. Q&A covers crafting personal training slogans and whether watching television can serve as dharma practice.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 16 2005 08 21 MT.mp3

UUID: 4f10cb45-0624-47bc-a61b-44e2f77c4342

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Mind Training (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2005-08-21

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 72.2 minutes

Words: ~6,176

So please take a moment to have a look at your motivation for listening to the teachings on mind training, and try and remind yourself that the best reason to listen to a teaching on mind training is to develop understanding of it and therefore be able to put it into practice. By putting the mind training into practice, this means developing or working towards the development of bodhicitta. And through developing bodhicitta, we’re then able to traverse the paths and grounds of a Bodhisattva and become a fully enlightened Buddha and therefore be able to lead all sentient beings out of suffering. So, this means that mind training acts as our path or acts as the cause for us to become a fully enlightened Buddha, someone who can lead beings out of suffering. And this should be the motivation with which we look at this text or we look at studying mind training.

So, we’ve been through in the previous teachings, we’ve been through the first two points of the seven points of mind training. So, we talked about the preliminary practices which focus on developing an understanding of karma precious human rebirth, death and impermanence and the shortcomings of saṃsāra. We looked at the practice of Tonglen of giving and taking. And the end of the Tonglen practice talked about the way that we can train in post meditation through remembering slogans or remembering words or reminding ourselves of ideas that strengthen our ability to focus on others when we’re not in meditation. So, this method of training giving and taking through reminding ourselves of slogans, reminding ourselves of quotes that we know should be based around the idea of what I’ve called the four bases or the four practices.

Now, these four practices refer to the idea that when you are giving in Tonglen, it’s really important to not only give or meditate on giving happiness, but also the causes of happiness and when you are taking in a Tonglen meditation, it’s really good to remember not just to feel like or visualize yourself taking the suffering of others, but also the causes of suffering. So, the happiness causes of happiness, suffering and the causes of suffering are the four things that we need to focus on in giving and taking meditation. So, these four things should be contained within the quotes or the slogans that we tell ourselves. We should remind ourselves of these things through quotes or slogans. And actually, Buddha talked about this in his sutras where he talks about meditating or familiarizing ourselves with words of loving kindness.

And so, that’s what he was referring to in that sūtra. He went on to explain that we can remind ourselves about love and kindness through reminding ourselves of quotes or the slogans that we’ve come up with to to train in this way. So this idea of using words to remind us how to train our mind isn’t something that’s isolated to the mind training practice. It’s something that we should use in our practice to Buddhist practice in general. So, usually we we learn things and then we have to try and put these into practice.

So, the idea is to make words into action or what make words and to use the words of the scripture or to use the words of the teachings to inform and to guide our actions. But if we just leave them as words and we don’t incorporate them into our behavior, then they don’t benefit as much. So this this this idea of training slogans or training in quotes is a way that we can incorporate what’s taught into our behavior and that’s actually the last part of the That’s the last bit that deals with the giving and taking meditation section of the the seven points of mind training. So of Tonglen, this practice of giving and taking is something that is actually very difficult if we’re doing it properly, if we’re doing it, if we’re actually trying to get somewhere with our mind. Because what we’re doing is we’re transforming our natural tendencies to, look to ourselves in order to, find to look to ourselves first, to find happiness for ourselves first at the expense of others.

And so, this is why the next point of mind training is called transforming bad circumstances into the path or into the way to enlightenment. Because this process of transforming our mind is actually something that’s very difficult. So, we need to be able to use difficulties in order to progress and not to shy away from difficulties. But it’s a difficult thing to do, to train our minds in this way, to train our minds to give to others and take suffering for ourselves. It’s difficult, but it’s necessary.

And one of the reasons it’s necessary is that this process by which we take suffering onto ourselves or we visualize ourselves taking suffering into our self and giving others happiness is actually more in line with reality than the way that we act we behave at the moment. So the way that we behave at the moment is that, we think, well, I’ll I’ll look after myself, I’ll do everything to focus on myself and that’ll make me happy. And if I ignore others, then I don’t have to worry about them and they won’t interfere with my happiness. That’s not actually the way it happens. The problem, the thing that causes us suffering is ourselves, is our self-cherishing.

And the thing that makes us happy is being able to do things for others. It causes us to create good karma which we experience the results of as happiness and it’s in dependence on other people that we experience, our happiness. All the moments of happiness we have if we look at them come about because other people have done something to give us something. Alright? So, we create whether we look at it from the point of view of what we’ve whether we look at it from the point of view of how we’ve had to depend on others to create positive karma and therefore we’re experiencing the results of that, or whether we look at it from the point of view that every moment of happiness that we have, comes from what others have done in some way or another.

Then, we come to see that this idea of taking happiness for ourselves and giving suffering to others or defending that happiness from others is actually not the way that things work. And if we start doing Tonglen, then we’re according ourselves more, we’re aligning ourselves more with reality with the way that things are. And this is why it’s really important to train in Tonglen. It’s because if we’re taking others suffering and the causes of their suffering, the negative things that we do and we imagine them dissolving into our self-cherishing, then the suffering is going back to its source. The suffering is going back to the source being the holding onto the idea of self, the self-cherishing.

And if we give away happiness, if we give away our causes of happiness and happiness, we’re sending them back to their source. We’re sending them back to where they came from. So, it actually lines up more with the way things work than the way that we think about things which is mistaken. But because we are so ingrained in thinking about things in a mistaken way, it’s very difficult for us to do this. It’s very difficult for us to to change the way we think like this.

It’s much easier for us to keep thinking about ourselves and to not think about others and to focus on making ourselves happy and, think that we can we’re actually able to do that. So turning that around is a is a hard process and and we shouldn’t kid ourselves and think it’s going to be easy. But, we’ve also been given instructions, especially in the next section, about how to use difficult situations and how to transform difficult situations like this thing that we’re engaging or that we’re entering into this practice of Tonglen. We’re taught how to transform that and the difficult situations that we may experience into the path to enlightenment as well. So this is this is the key to it, and this is why it’s difficult, and this is why we have to keep working at this idea of giving and taking practice and learning to think of others.

Because the way that we think or we spontaneously or instinctually ually think, if is it, other people create my problems and, I create my happiness. Alright? This is the way we think. All the problems I have in the world, they’re they’re other people’s fault and all the happiness or the good things that have happened is because I did it. Yeah?

And this is the this is the way we naturally think about things and we need to learn to to to think in exactly the opposite way to that. So because we’re learning to think in exactly the opposite way to what’s instinctual to us, it’s difficult, and we need to put effort into it. And because it’s so difficult, this is the reason that the first person to teach this practice specifically, which was an Indonesian teacher called Serlingpa. He taught it secretly because he thought that if you went around telling everyone, You’re the cause of all your problems and other people are the cause of your happiness, everyone’s going, Oh, give me a break, I’m not listening to that. And then they wouldn’t have a very good reaction to it.

So for many years, the teachers who taught this practice were very careful about who they taught it to because it’s hard to hear. So the the the usual way usual way or the unrestrained or untrained way that we tend to think of things is that every negative thing that happens to us is a fault of something else, whether it’s our environment, whether it’s our house, it’s the other people, whether it’s our body, whatever it is, it’s always something else. It’s never us that did it. And the hard thing to hear is that every single experience of suffering we have is our responsibility. We created the causes for that.

So, it says all the things that we blame on other sentient beings and all of the it says the container for other sentient beings, but that means the environment we live in. All of those things come about because of the negative things that we have done in the past life, we’ve created the causes for in the past life. And that’s why we experience the results of those in this lifetime. Alright. So we have all of these things happen to us, and our natural tendency is to say that’s not my fault.

Yeah? That was the house’s fault. That was the other people’s fault. That was the bank’s fault. Whatever it was, it’s just not my fault.

It’s my body’s fault. It’s not my fault. Alright? But all of these things that can happen to us, all of these things that says that are results of the negative things that we’ve done in the past don’t have to be a problem. They don’t they’re only a problem obstacle for us if we don’t understand the dharma properly.

If we don’t understand how to transform them properly. If we understand how we can use any negative situation that happens to us, then there are no negative situations for us. Alright? So, if you’re able to, it says, abide in the door of Dharma. Geshe-la said, if you’re able to practice mind training or transform things, it means that every time something negative happens, you see it as another opportunity to practice.

Because without negative things happening, you don’t develop understanding. Without experiencing suffering, you don’t develop the ability to want to renounce suffering. Without the experiencing an obstacle, you don’t develop the ability to strengthen your courage and so on. Alright, so the thing that, transforming problems in the past means working towards is seeing or developing the ability to see every problem of our external environment or our mind, everything that comes up as actually being, it says, a blessing or a source of inspiration that’s given to us directly from the Buddha, the Dharma and the Sangha in order for us to develop as a person and to develop our abilities, to develop our Buddha’s practice. So it’s difficult to do that.

It’s very difficult every time something goes wrong or you find yourself experiencing illness or some other situation to think, Ah, this is a blessing. This is giving me another opportunity to practice. And it goes very much against the way that we naturally respond to things. But if we’re actually able to practice properly, that’s what we’ll be able to do and that’s what we actually are trying to work towards that we think this problem, this difficulty is a blessing, is an inspiration from is a source is a a cause for for me to celebrate or be happy, and it’s a or it’s a gift or it’s a it’s a gift that’s given to me from the three jewel Three Jewels and my teachers, and it’s a friend that I can transform into the path to Dharma. This one.

Mhmm. I don’t know about you guys, but I I find that tough. That we may have spent years doing mind training practice. We may have spent years trying to transform the way we think. But if if we get an illness or something, we’re going, okay.

Which hospital do I go to? Which medicines do I need to take? It’s hardly ever amongst all these ways of getting out of the illness do we think, Oh, what a blessing. Now I get to purify my negative karma. It’s not something that we think very regularly.

I mean, it’s not the usual response that we have. We have to work hard to actually have that response. And so what they’re talking about here is having that as a spontaneous response. Oh, fantastic. Now I get to purify my karma.

So he said he has the experience where he’s thinking, I have guess I said personally, he thinks, how do I get rid of this headache? How do I get rid of this illness? And so he thinks if he’s having that and he’s been trying for years, that probably you guys have been had the same experience. And he says, not that teaching is saying that we shouldn’t try and do everything that we can to get rid of an illness that we have, that we shouldn’t try and do everything we can to to clear away problems that we have with our bodies. So, you know, going to hospitals, taking medicine, we should do all of those things.

It’s just that what we’re trying to do is to mix that, those actions with an understanding of what’s actually happening, with an understanding that we created the causes for this illness, that we can use this illness as an opportunity to practice Tonglen, as an opportunity to think through this suffering may all sentient beings suffering be gotten rid of through this me taking on their suffering, may they experience happiness. Alright? So it’s not that we shouldn’t take medicine. It’s not that we shouldn’t go to hospitals, but we need to be aware when we’re doing that what caused the illness and how we can use it at the same time. Alright.

So this process where we’re trying to transform negative things into a a help or a friend friend that can help us practice Dharma, means learning how not to respond by thinking this is everybody else’s fault and or everybody and everything else’s fault. But learning how to take responsibility for what’s happened to us and transform our experience of suffering into something that’s positive and can help others. It’s said that training in that way has two different parts. The first part is learning how to think about bodhicitta in these circumstances, learning how to remind ourselves of bodhicitta in this instance. And the second part is learning how to use the experiences of suffering, whether it’s mental suffering or physical suffering or situational suffering, to purify negative actions and, create positive, potential.

Mhmm. Okay. So the first way that we look at it then is from what’s called the approach of relative bodhicitta. So we can approach and relative bodhicitta is conception or the idea of working towards enlightenment, so we can benefit all sentient beings.

Now, the way that we transform negative situations or difficulties into the path to enlightenment from the perspective of that thought, is to remember that since beginningless time, since time without beginning, we’ve had an enemy and we’ve had a friend, but we haven’t recognized the enemy and we haven’t recognized the friends. And in fact, we we’ve changed them around. We’ve mixed them up. And we’ve thought that the enemy was our friend and the friend was our enemy. So the enemy, the problem that we’ve had since beginning of this time is self-cherishing, self grasping, holding on to an idea of self and thinking that we’re the most important thing.

The friend that we’ve always had that we haven’t recognized is all sentient beings. But that’s not the way we’ve looked at it. Instead of looking at, how to get out of saṃsāra to get rid of self-cherishing and work for sentient beings. What we’ve been doing is looking at how to work for ourselves and not take not not paying much attention to other beings unless we can get something out of them. So we need to learn to transform that to to turn that around.

And there’s two parts to turning that around. There’s learning what our enemy is and learning what our friends are, who our friends are. So learning what our enemy means, it means recognizing that that we ourselves are to blame for all our problems because we are the ones who’ve been holding onto, the idea of a self, and we’re the ones who’ve been creating the negative karma based on that idea of a self. So that’s a very hard thing to learn. It’s a very hard thing to to listen to, and it’s a very hard thing to digest.

But it’s a necessary thing to do in order to become a Buddha is to recognize that. And the other thing is learning to recognize that it’s sentient beings that bring us happiness, that it’s dependent on sentient beings that we experience happiness, so all other beings so that we need to start looking at at them as being the source of our happiness. So, this is why the root text goes on to say: drive all blames into oneself. And that is to say that if we’re looking for the cause of all of our problems, we’re looking for the cause of all of the suffering that we experience, then we need to look to ourselves. We need to look to our grasping at a sense of self, the karma that we’ve created, the situations that we’ve established, and it’s our fault for that.

We have to take the blame ourselves. So when it says drive all blames into oneself, it means recognizing that we created this situation, we created this karma, and not blaming anyone else. So all of the even the littlest experiences of suffering and discomfort that we experience come about because we have been holding onto a sense of self, holding onto this idea that we’re more important than others and therefore created the karma to experience that result. This means that the suffering that we experience, we can’t blame on anyone else. Our natural tendency is to blame it on other beings, situations, and other environments, but it’s all about us.

It’s all the things that we need to remember that we did this, we created this situation and accept the responsibility for our suffering ourselves. Okay. Okay. So if anyone has any questions? Uh-huh.

So Geshe-la said that you can find quotes in all sorts of quotes and slogans in all sorts of different texts. Alright. So there’s a text that say, things like, May, all of the happiness of, that I’ve accumulated in all of the three times ripen on on all my kind mother sentient beings right now, and may they experience true happiness and be free of suffering. So he said, you can get quotes like that, but sometimes they can seem a bit un us, not like what we’d say or not like what we think. And so he said that if that seems strange for you to walk around like quoting things that don’t quite sound like you, then to make up something yourself, you know.

All the suffering I experience is from my self-cherishing, all the happiness I experience is from other beings. So may I have the strength to give them all my happiness and take on suffering. I mean, it’s something that you can make up yourself that sounds like you, and you can repeat it to yourself. So he so I guess to say, you you end up having a little bit of a argument. Your mind’s having an argument because your natural tendency is to go, well, it’s all about me, and I need to be happy and stuff everyone else, and I’m gonna make myself happy.

And then this part of the mind bit is going, oh, wait a minute. They’re actually the causes for your happiness and you’re just abandoning them and you’re getting caught up in self-cherishing and that’s not helping you any anyway. So you have an argument with yourself and every time the the, instinctual thing to be about you and to to about us and to think, oh, it’s about me, comes up, then you go, oh, hang on, and you argue back with it with one of these slogans. I found one once that’s just telling Geshe-la that said, even when your coffee’s cold, it’s your fault. Yeah.

Yeah. Really? Yeah. Alright. So the happiness that we experience at the moment, right, is something that we attribute a lot of attributes to that it doesn’t have.

Alright? So we experience happiness and think, okay. This what’s going to make me happy, I’ll keep searching after that, and it doesn’t continue to make us happy. It’s, it only makes us happy for a short time. So it’s a temporary happiness.

It’s not to say that it’s not happiness, it’s just not happiness that we can rely on. That’s why it’s called the suffering of change. Yeah? So it is happiness, but it’s not reliable happiness, and it’s not something that leads us to maintaining happiness. It’s what’s called contaminated happiness.

So it’s not a matter of trying to trick ourselves and say, that isn’t happiness. It’s learning. It’s not it’s just not real happiness. It’s not something we can rely on. You know?

And so we have to go, okay, this isn’t gonna get me anywhere, so there’s no point chasing after this kind of happiness. But this is very difficult for us to do because it’s the only happiness we know. It’s the only happiness that we experience. So we think, oh, if I’m going for a picnic, always a picnic, or going to watch a show or or whatever it is, and that’s a way to make myself happy and and that’s what we know about. Yeah?

So that that’s what we think, okay, this is this is happiness. That’s the only thing I know about happiness. So to actually take a a broader view of it and think, well, wait a minute. This if this happiness isn’t lasting, maybe I should be looking for something else. It’s something that’s very difficult for us to do, especially when we consider that true happiness only comes about only exists when people have, completely gotten rid of sorrow and they’re an arhat, or they’ve become a bodhisattva who’s realized emptiness.

Yeah? But what we can get a glimpse of is that a bodhisattva who has realized emptiness, for them, even suffering becomes a cause for happiness. Yes? And so, if you’re working for others, if you’re truly becoming happy making yourself happy by working for others, then suffering isn’t a cause of suffering. It doesn’t make you sad.

It doesn’t make you suffer. So we can develop an understanding of what we’re actually working towards when we can see how working for others can actually make us happy. Is a contaminated happiness in that it comes about because we’ve done positive things, but they weren’t positive things with an understanding of emptiness. Alright? So they’re not positive things that are directed towards a developing Buddhahood.

They are positive things that only have one result, that only manifest happiness in us experiencing the happiness that we do in a temporary way. Alright? So if we are able to experience happiness that isn’t dependent on adventitious causes, then that means that it will be a happiness that lasts, a happiness that we can rely on, a happiness that is devoid of sorrow, that is devoid of changing into suffering. So, what we need to develop an understanding of then is hang on. By developing an understanding that our happiness at the moment is very fleeting and unstable, then we can develop an understanding of what the opposite of that would be, to experience contentment that’s, based on getting rid of all suffering.

Alright. So at the moment, because we have this idea of self and because we even if we have a good motivation for doing something, it’s still based on the idea of a self. It means that when we experience the results of doing a positive action, there it’s a it’s a contaminated experience in that we weren’t we’re we’re still the part of the motivation for which we did that action, was based on the idea of self which is the perpetuation of saṃsāra. So the happiness that we experience as a result of that positive action is still going to be a samsaric experience. So if we think, even if we subtly are holding onto this idea of self and thinking I’m working towards enlightenment, that we may have developed part of a positive action that’s focused on enlightenment, but we still have this idea of self, so the the strength of that positive action, is going to be, we’re not going to experience results of it continuously.

But if you do something like for an arhat, they not only have done a positive action, but they’ve done a positive action with the understanding that hang on, I started in the wrong spot. Someone who’s realized has renounced Samsāra has is working towards is working towards nirvana with no holding on to the idea of Samsāra or no holding on to the idea of self. When they do something, there is no subtle cling to the idea of experiencing happiness in Samsāra. All of the positive potential from that action comes back to them as nirvana. It doesn’t come back to them as as adventitious, fleeting moments of happiness in saṃsāra because it comes back as the experience of nirvana.

So as long as we hold on to that self, when we do a positive action, we’re creating the cause to experience a fleeting moment of happiness as opposed to nirvana. Alright? When you’ve gotten rid of the idea of self, then you’re creating the experience for causes for happiness, but without any of the clinging, any of any of the contamination which makes it unsteady, which is is is wrong. And when you’re doing something in order to attain Buddhahood, you’re not only doing it motivated by something that is but you’re not only doing it to do something positive without a clinging to self which makes the action a cause for Samsāra, but you’re also focused on all sentient beings. So the force of the action is much stronger.

Alright? So at the moment, even when we do positive things, it’s still contaminated with this idea of self. So even our positive actions are a cause for saṃsāra. Yeah? So the the happiness we experience as a result is fleeting.

If we have this idea, is no me, saṃsāra is not worth working for, and we’re actually totally working for nirvana, then that’s what we experience as a result. And if we add to that by focusing on all sentient beings, it becomes an even an incredibly stronger action, an exponentially stronger action. So that so that’s why we like, he said, we as being people who are teaching teaching, spend so much time going on about our motivation and talking about the importance of motivation because it’s not something that happens to us spontaneously at the moment. If we want to do something whether that’s going to be a cause for true happiness, we actually have to work pretty hard at it. Alright?

So we have to work hard to have a moment where we’re thinking, I’m doing this to get enlightened. And if we do something even based on a moment of that thought, truly having that thought and not having, and I’ll be happy in this lifetime or anything else, then that is a a cause for true happiness, for for for permanent happiness. But we have to work hard at it, and that’s why for especially for people who haven’t developed for beginners who haven’t developed bodhicitta, that it’s very important to focus on the idea of motivation all the as much as possible. Oh, I did it, though. Two words also.

Yeah. You’re just staring at me as I do. Yeah. There’s just this one point. Yeah.

Yes. He actually looks quite into what he wants to abandon before he abandons it in the film. So I was just saying probably, Kesley, that you don’t probably wanna watch it. Said, but he actually thinks that watching movies or shows and everything can be a really good practice. Because when you’re watching television, you get to see all sorts of things.

Alright? And you get to you get more of an insight into what Samsāra is about than just from looking at your own little experience. And he also said that televisions can be or watching shows can really good for thinking about emptiness, and because you’re watching something, but you know it’s not there. So he said TV can be a very good fit. It depends on your motivation.

So he said, if you think about TV shows really well how Samsāra is suffering, and there’s not any essence of happiness that we can hold on to in it. If we watch it properly, he said, you can see that on the television. And then you can see how you can watch yourself grasping at things as if they’re real, and grasping at things as if can get happiness from them, but then you can’t. And so it’s a good it’s a good learning experience, he said, if you approach television in that way. It depends on the way you watch it.

Oh, yeah. Geshe-la said, sorry. Someone gave him tea. He’s gonna drink the tea. So he said, you can go and then he said, you guys can watch the show of of me drinking tea.

He’s trying to figure out what, and then I was like, oh, that’s what he said. Don’t worry. But but, honestly, he said it that he said also, if you have questions while he’s drinking his tea, please ask them because you’re. Please finish finish this. So I guess I said, it’s really important to be really happy about doing good things, alright?

But that isn’t self-cherishing, yeah? And the other thing is that we have to work really hard to make sure that we don’t get arrogant about our good deeds because it’s really easy for us to do that. It’s easy to think, oh, well, I got a precious human rebirth. Right? So we should think, yes, I got a precious human rebirth.

That’s great. But then also think, so did all lots of other people. And if we expand it out and we think all of us did something really good, then that makes it a much an antidote to our self-cherishing as well as rejoicing or being really happy about what we’ve done that’s good. Yeah? So the thing is, it’s easy for us to think we’re doing a good job.

It’s much more difficult for us to look at our faults. So we have to be when we’re rejoicing, we try and make our the being happy about what we’ve done very expansive to include as many people as possible, and also not to be a cause for arrogance because it’s it’s easy for us to do that. So we have to rejoice but be careful about the way we’re doing it. Yeah. Uh-huh.

Put in jail and stuff? Sure. Uh-huh. Okay. So guesses that he he actually thinks that this if a system of law, yeah, of breaking the law and paying for breaking the law is done very ethically, that it’s very similar to cause and effect.

Alright? So that if when it doesn’t involve people’s egos or people’s agendas, then it is very similar to cause and effect. Yeah? So if you do something negative, you experience the results of it. So the law says that.

It says if you do if you steal, you go to jail for stealing. And that’s very straightforward, and that’s very much like cause and effect. And now the reason cause and effect works is because of dependent origination. Because causes and conditions come together to create an experience or some or a phenomena. And this is the same thing with the the law.

Yeah? If certain causes and conditions come together, then the law acts in a certain way. So he thinks that the law itself cause and effect act in very similar ways. Alright? So so then to try and get a like a clear answer, I said to him, so if you’re a judge and you’re sending someone to jail for doing something wrong and they’re gonna experience suffering in jail, are you doing something negative?

Yeah? And Geshe-la said, that depends on the judge. Yeah? If the judge is enjoying the idea of causing suffering for someone, then that’s negative. If the judge he he said, if the judge is taking a bribe, and I said, it’s not India.

And because that happens in India all the time. So I was seriously. If the judge is taking a bribe or if the judge is pushing an agenda, then that’s negative. If the judge is just saying this is the law, you broke the law, you experienced the results, and isn’t pushing anything from their own side, that’s not a negative action. So it depends on the motivation of the judge.

Yes. If someone does something to you, created the causes for that. So if do something negative to them means you’re creating more negative causes. I was just gonna say, sadly, in the law, there there very often is an element of vengeance, isn’t it? The victims or or Mhmm.

Very often to see the perpetrator pay. Yeah. Yeah. So Geshe-la said that, he would think that that’s why you would have judges. Judges.

The whole idea of judging, he said, was to investigate to see what’s going on and what response the victims have and how much of that is based on revenge and how much of it is based on what actually happened and and to look to see exactly what the law says about crimes that are committed in this way. So that you can respond in a way that isn’t based on vengeance and that you’re acting by the letter of the law as opposed to acting to an emotional response to the people that are involved in the court. And he would think that a a judge shouldn’t be appointed to judge unless there’s someone who knows the law thoroughly enough to be able to differentiate between emotions vengeance and the law. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Okay. If everyone else is okay, we can stop, and you can have the mic. Okay. So we’ll offer the mandala to give thanks for the teachings at the bottom of page twenty-four, and then over the page to twenty-six, the dedication and long life prayers.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
thought transformation lojong (Tib)
Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Is there often an element of vengeance in the law, and how should judges deal with it?

The purpose of having judges is to investigate what is going on: what response the victims have, and how much of that is based on revenge rather than on what actually happened. A judge also looks at exactly what the law says about crimes committed in this way. This allows a response that is not based on vengeance, acting by the letter of the law instead of reacting emotionally to the people involved in the court. A judge should not be appointed unless they know the law thoroughly enough to tell the difference between emotions, vengeance and the law.

Scroll to Top