46 min · 3,442 words · 8 February 2007 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A striking doctrinal distinction anchors this 47-minute session with Geshe Pema Tsering: one can attain deep calm abiding — even be reborn in the god realms of the form and formless realms — without renunciation, and so remain entirely within cyclic existence. The class opens by mapping the eighteen constituents (earth, water, fire, wind, space, and consciousness, together with the six sense powers and six sense consciousnesses) and twelve sources, noting these are simply different frameworks for categorizing the same phenomena, comparable to biological classification. Geshe Pema Tsering then unpacks why renunciation — genuinely seeing the faults of all saṃsāra — is indispensable for liberation in a way that deep concentration alone is not. The discussion closes on mindfulness and alertness, drawing on a verse from the Way of the Bodhisattva, as practical tools for guarding the mind against self-cherishing and erroneous thought. Suited to practitioners already working through a Lamrim curriculum.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 17 2007 02 08 M and MF (2).mp3
UUID: 2053515d-8c0b-4aed-b4eb-91762807800d
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Mind & Mental Factors (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2007-02-08
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 46.8 minutes
Words: ~3,440
The first paragraph. Page thirty two. There are four ways of reasoning for differentiating faults and good qualities. Yeah. And we’re going to start the functional reasoning or Yeah.
Yeah. Etcetera, etcetera. That’s what I thought. I just checked. Yeah.
Okay? Yep. I couldn’t find any salt for Gishma’s teas. Salt. No.
It’s very bad. Just didn’t do this. It’s okay. No problem. Thank you.
But he still prefer salt when he gets some. There’s no Yeah. He says that there’s a there’s there’s a difficult one because there’s only there’s only him who who drinks tea with salt around here. So it’s gonna be difficult to find the salt. I’ll bring some next time.
Yeah. In my country, we put salt on watermelon. Watermelon. You have any questions? Out.
After the full. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. What is it?
Top of page thirty one, it says. Yeah. Underneath those four numbers. Oh, okay. Okay.
In that next paragraph, So then when we’re talking about where is this here? How did aggregates observation eighteen constituents, observation twelve sources. So then we these constituents that are being referred to here are the the objects of observation of the sense powers of the sense consciousness and sense powers. And the and the twelve sources are, again, the the the sense consciousness and the sense powers themselves. So then there is there is as for this the constituents which are eighteen and you have you have air you have earth you have fire, you have water, you have space, and all these objects of observation of the senses and the sense powers.
Okay? That’s earth, air, fire, and water in that’s five there are eighteen and involves everything that the the sense powers apprehend and it’s it’s tactile objects and and and visual and and and odor and and sound and also So then So then there is the the four the four which are earth, water, fire, and wind, and then there is space, then there is consciousness So then all all of the constituents, they are included in these six, which has the the four elements, and then space, and then the the constituents of consciousness, which is not which is not to say, I wasn’t saying, it’s not to say that that consciousness itself is a constituent, but that there are the constituents of cons constituents of consciousness. And all of them, they are included. All there are eighteen. Right?
So all of them are included in this in this six. Included in this in this six. Okay? So then so then there are the the six object constituents which are obvious observation. There are the six constituents which are of of consciousness, and then there are the six constituents which are of the of the the six sense powers also.
And then you make up. So then you have this this I can’t remember. There’s another word for for constituents. Okay? But I can’t remember right now.
But then the the word which is in Tibetan, come. And then so then you have the four elements and the space and and this this consciousness. And then you will have you will have then the the the the six sense powers, which is then, how do say, eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mental sense power. And then you have the six sense consciousness. And then you have eye, ear, nose, tongue, body, and mental sense consciousness.
And you you have this eighteen constituents in this in this fashion. And then as for as for the this other the the the sources, which is translated here is the twelve sources. Again, the nose, ear, eye, tongue, body, mental sources and so forth So then the the Geshe-la was saying that they they are not exactly different. It is just a different way to to analyze or to know the same thing. So it’s just a different way to categorize the same thing.
That’s all there is. So then the the what is translated here is the the constituents. They are just is using another word, which which is to say, they are just types of of things. They’re just they’re just merely, how to say, scientific categorizations of of phenomena as you have in in in biology and stuff like that. So this is this is a mammal or reptile, etcetera.
So just a different division of of of reality. And Phenomena. Yeah. Different different division of phenomena. Yeah.
Isn’t it? Yeah. Or or existence. Of phenomena. Of reality.
No existence. Reality, of No existence. Yeah. Is that okay? Yeah.
Yeah. So then so then each each individual will have a different combination of this of this constituents and, yeah, which varies from individual to individual. So then that is to say so I was giving them so everybody has the constituent of of Earth. Everybody has it. But the constituent of Earth that that Geshe-la has and the constituent of Earth that I have, they are different.
Okay? So then because because there are many because there are all these different these variations of the constituents, then there are different. Then there are different. And then because because of the differences in in the constituents that that everybody has, then people will have different inclinations. Oh, you know, some people will like one thing more than others and and so forth.
Okay? Did did you did you understand? Yes. Yeah, Like like the the the what you when you have what you’re having in in Greece, the humors, the different humors. That’s that’s what it is.
DNA in modern science. Yeah. I’ve not translated that into Tibetan. That’s why saying this. Yes.
We all have different stuff. Yes. But it’s it’s just that that sort of reasoning, actually. It is that’s on in that line. Yeah.
This one? Yeah. Now he said he’s gonna drink his tea. Do you have questions? No.
No? I have a question. You know, is the leading the leaving behind in one’s mind the objects that desire on to attain that special concentration, is that the same as renunciation where one really ceases to care about the basics of food and appearance? Yeah. Yeah.
Good question. So then I asked what I asked is, does does stopping the the minds of the desire realm and renunciation, do this do this to have any relationship? And then the Geshe-la says that it might be that in some cases, it has a relationship because renunciation, it has to do with those those when you develop renunciation, you want to be free from cyclic existence. But once you once you are striving to attain a certain concentration, a certain the first absorption, the second absorption, and so forth, or just calm abiding, then it’s not necessary that the person has renunciation. So then the so then there are there are people who do not see any faults within cyclic existence and go strive to attain the qualities of a concentration which is within cyclic existence so then they just they do not have renunciation and the renunciation involves seeing and understanding the faults of all of cyclic existence.
So then there are beings who attain concentration and stop the minds of the desire realm, but do not have renunciation. Did you say faults? Fault? Yeah. Shortcomings.
This is a very important distinction to make that when we are meditating that we should we should understand the faults of cyclic existence, the faults of saṃsāra because only with with this understanding we we will develop the wish to attain liberation and we’ll be able then to attain liberation. But without it, we we won’t we won’t be able to attain liberation. So then there are many many many people who strive to attain the first second third and fourth concentrations places there are places that are realms of existence the form realm and the formless realm of existence which are related to these levels of concentration absorption in each of these realms there are many pleasures, the godly godly pleasures. So there are many people who strive only to attain those pleasures, to attain those existences, and they do not have renunciation, did not see the the faults, the shortcomings of cyclic existence. This one?
The text that says first seek calm abiding that is achieved through taking joy in non attachment to the world, if it doesn’t mean that renunciation, does it mean, like, the eight worldly concerns? Sorry? You were saying it’s not necessary to have renunciation. Right? Yeah.
This line that is achieved through taking joy and non attachment to the world, does that mean non attachment to the world, non attachment to the concerns. Let me see if I can find this in the on page thirty two at the top. You know, I have to find it in the Tibetan. But I I know what what you’re talking about. I know what you’re talking about.
What is it? It’s the that quote from the the Way of the Bodhisattva, isn’t it? Yes. It is. Yeah.
Okay. What’s Geshe-la is explaining it in in in different ways, and the text is giving one explanation which refers which Geshe-la has explained already this interpretation, which refers to in order to attain calm abiding, in order to attain to the higher concentrations one has to see the faults of the lower realm where one is at which is then the desire realm and then see the qualities of the higher realm which is the form realm or the form or the first concentration second concentration and so forth so then one has to stop this desire for worldly things of the desire realm. And then on the other hand, Geshe-la was giving an alternative interpretation to that, which was then saying so then saying that what what verse is telling us is that having developed a calm abiding and special insight and having destroyed then with this having destroyed afflictive emotions then because because one can do that with calm abiding special insight, and one should one should search for calm abiding. And with this one, we’ll be able to get rid of attachment and so forth. That’s another interpretation that Geshe-la was giving as an alternative.
But then do you understand the the first one of those two? Sure. Yeah. That’s what it is. Yeah.
So can you achieve calm abiding outside of the desire realm? You can Can you like, can you do you need to be in the desire realm to actually achieve calm abiding? Me. So it has to be human being. It has to be in the desire realm in order to attain from first, one has to be in the desire realm in order to be able to attain to calm abiding.
Yes. So then in the so then of the three realms of existence the desire realm the form and the formless so then those beings of the form and the formless realm they who are there already they already have attained calm abiding they already have they were born there because they have attained calm abiding and they have attained to the up to the concentrations absorptions they are relative to to the to the realm that they that they exist. So then there is no in in other words, there is no no one in the form and formless realms who does not have calm abiding. So then you need to attain it so then so then yes you need to attain calm abiding while you are here in the desire realm and then once you are once you are there in those in those god realms, then you already have concentrations which are even beyond calm abiding. So Okay.
Does that that doesn’t include the god realm in the god realms in the desire realm, though, does it? No. Obviously not. Because there’s no No. So then if I was in the sense then the gods they also die and that’s that is a sign of also of the deterioration of their of their concentration and the the both the the the calm abiding, the absorption that they are in, and the special insight that they have.
So it deteriorates. So that that also that is also when they die and they fall down to lower realms of cyclic existence. Yeah? He says it sounds a bit strange, doesn’t it? So then so then, yes, they are within cyclic existence and furthermore, Geshe-la said that the same happens to to human beings when the the the consciousness of of human beings then deteriorates and then the the lifespan ends and and when human being dies.
If that consciousness deteriorates, then it will be born. It will fall down to lower realms, below the realm of humans. And the same way with gods and and so forth when their when their consciousness deteriorates, then they will fall down to realms that are lower to the ones that they are abiding at. So to human realm or or or even lower than that. And then and then Geshe la just said of of all the the consciousness that there are, there is one which I do not recollect the the name in English, which is a specific consciousness which has existed since beginningless time, and and the transmigrates from life to life, and that that remains unchanged from life to life.
But there are other consciousness develop on top of that that deteriorate or or or or how to say what’s the opposite of deteriorate? Increase. Increase or they they can deteriorate or increase, but the very clear and knowing consciousness, that that that clear part of it which which which is very fundamental and subtle and which has existed since beginningless time, that that doesn’t change. And then within within that that that clear consciousness, which I cannot recall the specific name, then all other consciousness developed and the the the consciousness of human beings and gods, etcetera, etcetera, and then develop and increase, deteriorate, and so forth. So then just like a a field where one throws rice or apple seeds and so forth.
If one plants rice seeds, then rice will grow. If one plants apple seeds and apple will grow. If one plants whatever fruit there is, and all the fruits will grow. And the same with that fundamental consciousness, then whatever it is that plants will need, that will develop from that. Okay?
That make sense? So then there is the there is the demigods, the so called demigods which are below the gods of the desire realm and then there six different classes of gods in the desire realm. And then and and demigods, they’re below all of those six. And then besides that, there is the the four classes of gods of the form they are the gods of the form form realms, and then they are the gods of the four formless realms. And all that is within cyclic existence.
So then every all of them, they are within cyclic existence. There’s none of them who is not within cyclic existence, Geshe-la says. So, Geshe-la says, so then this this cyclic existence is is very vast is a is a condition which is very pervasive, very vast. And then for the most fortunate ones, we all have been in all these places already. So then you might have you might have attained calm abiding, but you haven’t attained renunciation.
Haven’t. Yeah. Haven’t. Have not. And then because you haven’t attained renunciation, then you come back here.
Really? Really? So then if if if having attained renunciation, if one then attains calm abiding even though one might not attain to to buddhahood then one one will already be an Arhat We we we have attained to calm abiding already innumerable times. So, therefore, we need renunciation. Therefore, we need a concentration.
That’s what we need. Renunciation. Yeah. Renunciation. Concentration.
All of it. Then, as I said, we we So then we we haven’t attained to to renunciation because of that. We haven’t attained to to the mind of enlightenment and so forth so because of that we are still being impelled by karma and then whatever it is that that we do is always permeated with how to say good and bad things even though we we have we’re doing something good with with our hands we’re doing something bad with our legs and in in this way we we keep on going so then without renunciation it’s very difficult to stop this situation but once one has attained to this contrived mind of renunciation, then then everything is alright. So then he says, Now, as for renunciation, and it’s it’s something which is very difficult to attain, isn’t it? And then we we in order to attain renunciation, we have to see the faults of everything we think exactly exists, even even those those things that we regard as as as as good.
And and then we have to to develop a mind which completely forsakes all of those things. But instead, in the situation we are right now, we are actually striving to obtain those things which are regarded as good within existence is very difficult. And then it is it is that that I, the the self, which is then stopping us from from being able to to attain renunciation. So then that that self-cherishing mind and it does not understand what suffering is and then not knowing what suffering really is and thinking, believing it to be actually happiness, then it actually strives in order to obtain it. Yes?
Can I this is why it says on page thirty in this text here that there’s a that there’s with the quote from the Bodhicaryāvatāra, I urge you above all, guard mindfulness? Yeah. Mindfulness is that why mindfulness is so important What do I have in here? In view of the importance of developing renunciation. So then then this this is this this verse is talking about, okay, these two mental factors which are mindfulness and and and guarding alertness.
And it’s just so then is telling us that whatever it is that that we are that is occurring in our mind, we should be watching over it. And if it is something bad is is coming forth, then we should stop and and get rid of it. So if, for example, attachment arises, then we should stop and get rid of it. Or in in the other hand, with that that same mindfulness and guarding alertness, if something a virtuous mind comes about, then we hold on to it, we cultivate it and nurture it. That’s what it’s referring to.
So then if one can practice mindfulness and alertness and guard one’s mind well then eventually we’ll be able to guard it better and better and avoid non-virtues and so forth. And but but we we we ourselves, we do not do that. We we let we always leaving our minds loose, and then all sorts all sorts of thoughts occur to us, and there’s no control. We’d have no control over them. So then it is it is very important to guard one’s mind with mindfulness and guarding alertness.
So then if if one does not guard one’s mind with mindfulness and guarding alertness, then whatever it is that one’s mind is is most used to, that will that will keep on occurring to one’s mind. And if so then if it is that self-cherishing mind, it will only get worse and worse. It will not get any better. So then there are many many many minds or erroneous or mistaken minds occur to us all the time and and and we just let it be we don’t we we we never do anything about it isn’t it? So then if if if if if the cause is which is that mistaken, erroneous ignorance is is because of that cause, is a mistaken, erroneous ignorance, then we always collect the result, which is which is a mistake and erroneous thoughts and or minds.
So then when in order to to to arrest, to stop all those those erroneous mistaken minds, to arise one has to to to start cultivating correct, pure correct minds and virtuous minds then through a lot of reasoning then avert the erroneous and mistaken ones but that takes a lot of work also Okay. Yeah. No. You do the dedication.
Key terms in this teaching
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- eighteen constituents dhatu (Skt); kham (Tib)
- The six sense powers, the six consciousnesses and the six objects. LYWA
- form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
- The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is leaving behind desire-realm objects to attain special concentration the same as renunciation, where one ceases to care about food and appearance?
Not necessarily. The two may be related, but they are not the same. Renunciation is the wish to be free from cyclic existence, and it comes from seeing and understanding its faults and shortcomings. Striving for concentration, such as the first or second absorption or calm abiding, does not require renunciation. Some people see no faults in cyclic existence and strive for the qualities of concentration, which lie within it. They may be drawn to the godly pleasures of the form and formless realms. So beings can attain concentration and stop the minds of the desire realm without having renunciation.
Can calm abiding be achieved outside the desire realm, for example in the form or formless realms?
No. One has to be in the desire realm, as a human being, in order to first attain calm abiding. Of the three realms of existence (desire, form and formless), beings in the form and formless realms already have calm abiding. They were born there because they had attained it, and they have reached the concentrations and absorptions relative to the realm they live in. So there is no one in the form and formless realms who lacks calm abiding. This means calm abiding has to be attained while one is here in the desire realm. Once in those god realms, one already has concentrations that go even beyond calm abiding.
What does the Bodhicaryāvatāra verse urging us to guard mindfulness mean, and why is guarding the mind with mindfulness and alertness important?
The verse speaks of two mental factors, mindfulness and guarding alertness. Whatever occurs in the mind should be watched over. If something bad arises, such as attachment, one stops it and gets rid of it. If a virtuous mind arises, one holds on to it, cultivates it and nurtures it. Ordinarily we leave our minds loose, so all sorts of thoughts occur with no control. Without this guarding, whatever the mind is most used to keeps occurring, and self-cherishing will only get worse. Mistaken, erroneous minds arise all the time and we do nothing about them, so we keep collecting mistaken results.