1 h 51 min · 6,809 words · 12 March 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. “Spine curved like a bow, head white like a conch, forehead creased like a dried-up lake bed” — Geshe Pema Tsering opens this nearly two-hour Middle Lamrim commentary with the text’s unsparing portrait of aging, then works through the sufferings of illness, death, meeting the unpleasant, separation from the pleasant, and unmet desire, each in five structured points. Contemporary examples ground the analysis: doctors restricting your diet, biopsies performed whether you want them or not, skills and companions all abandoned at death. The session traces all these sufferings to their root in ignorance, self-grasping, and self-cherishing. A Q&A closes with a careful distinction between attachment and faith — illustrated by wanting a car for prestige versus buying one for aging parents — and a copper-nugget-mistaken-for-gold analogy showing how realizing emptiness dissolves self-cherishing altogether.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 05 2009 03 12 BP.mp3
UUID: 4bc8a4cd-60cb-4fbb-979f-da91aabb8fde
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2009-03-12
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 111.7 minutes
Words: ~6,807
So Geshe is then instructing us to give us a good motivation, then with the intention of establishing all sentient beings in the state of enlightenment. Is this working? Then we’re to study these teachings on the Lamrim. We’re to study. We’re going to contemplate them.
We’re going to meditate upon them of enlightenment for the sake of the well-being of all sentient beings. And with this mind, we start with the Heart Sūtra and the seven-limb prayer and so forth. So we are going to start with now the suffering of aging. We have an extensive explanation and a summary of the essence of the meaning. I guess I was going say, we’ve through already the suffering of birth.
And then after experiencing birth, then one has to experience aging. And this is then the topic that we’re approaching now. Parts to this extensive explanation. And the first one then is deterioration of the body. So because I was just going through the text, the complete deterioration of the fine body is such that your spine becomes curved like a bow, your head becomes white like a conch, your hair becomes white like frost flowers, your forehead becomes covered in wrinkles like a dried-up lake bed, and so on, whereby the splendor of youth deteriorates and you become ugly.
Oh, yeah. This is Geshe-la, this is Geshe-la again. With aging, we just don’t remain as we wish to remain. We just don’t remain looking as fine, looking good as we wish to remain. We grow old.
Our hairs do not remain dark as they were, as we wish them to remain. Again, they grow white and so forth. So basically, with aging, we experience all these changes which are undesirable, which are not what we desire, which is not what we wish for. So, and then the second point is the deterioration of power and strength. So again, the deterioration of power and strength is such that when you sit down, you resemble a sack of soil when its rope is cut.
When you get up, you resemble three roots being pulled out. And when you speak, you babble unintelligibly. When you walk, you are completely bent over, and so on. So again, you just heard the Geshe. The Geshe was saying, so again, when you sit, you just fall.
When you’re standing up, it’s like uprooting a tree, which is very difficult, very hard. And when you speak, again, mouth does not work together with your thoughts. So you hear, you hear, blah blah blah blah blah. You’re thinking, and you’re you’re babbling. So again, one cannot speak one is thinking according to what one is thinking.
So it doesn’t come in synchronicity. So again, all that amounts to the loss of one’s power, of one’s strength. So again, and then the next topic is the deterioration of the senses So the deterioration of the senses is such that your eyes and so forth are not clearly perceived forms and so forth anymore. So again, you do not your eyes, again, do not perceive forms very clearly. You do not you cannot hear very well.
You know, the taste, the smell, all the senses, all the five sense powers, they deteriorate. And also your mindfulness, also, and so forth diminish as you grow forgetful and so forth. So again, your mindfulness, your memory deteriorates also. And immediately you do something, immediately after that, you just cannot remember what has happened or what you have done and so forth. And then fourthly, we have then the decline in sense pleasures.
So again, the enjoyment of sense objects declines, such that food and drink become difficult to digest, and you can no longer enjoy other pleasures. Visualizing. So again, as you grow old, you eat, and you cannot digest the food properly, you eat a little bit of that and you don’t feel good. You eat a little bit of this and you feel some pain. On the other hand, again, you wish to eat something and then you are unable to eat it.
So again, you have all the suffering from not being able to get that which you desire. So all that, again, comes with aging also. And then again, we have last and then the complete deterioration of the lifespan. So the suffering of the lifespan having deteriorated completely is that due to the lifespan having been largely spent, you face death. And Geshe-la wasn’t saying again, it was if there was a length of time or a distance, you know, all the way up to death itself, so by when as you reach old age, as you are aging, you are stepping, you are stepping closer and closer to death.
And as you grow old, again, you are closer to death. So, you know, soon enough in the in the soon enough, you will reach the end of of this path, the end of this stretch of time or the end of this path, you’re going to die. And so there is no reason to stay at ease. We cannot stay at ease anymore. One because one soon is gonna die.
So again, and we have the summary of the essence. Again, the next topic in Geshe Chekawa. Geshe Chekawa says, the suffering of death is bad, but brief. This aging is also bad. But aging, he says, it’s also bad, but it lasts for one’s whole life.
One is always growing old, one does not perceive it. It’s hard to notice, but it’s happening all the time. We have then this quote from the Karmapa, which says again, it is good that old age comes gradually, gradually. If it came in a single moment all at once, it would be unbearable. And just a lot of them just saying again how that is actually the case, how that is really so.
Again, if that it comes, that this aging comes gradually, moment by moment, and almost unnoticeable, unnoticeably. Again, it is better than if one were a child and then suddenly I guess I wasn’t saying if he were a child and suddenly he had age he was as old as he is right now, and that would be really unbearable and even unthinkable, hard to conceive itself. So it comes aging comes, you know, with this momentary change gradually and and and almost imperceptibly. And Geshe-la was saying, again, this suffering of aging, all of this that we have been going through is a potential suffering of aging. The suffering of aging comes in dependence on the appropriated aggregates.
And again, these contaminated aggregates, they arise out of contaminated actions and the afflictions. So it arises out of ignorance, is a result of ignorance. And so with it comes all these undesirable sufferings, all these undesirable pains. And because it is this contaminated aggregates, there is no way that one will not experience these sufferings. There’s no way that one will not experience these sufferings.
So the next in the list of sufferings is the suffering of illness. And again, it has five points, this topic has five points. The first one is the bodily changes. So the nature of the body changes in that the body’s flesh becomes loose, the skin dries up, and so forth. So again, the body changes, it doesn’t remain as it is.
So then, secondly, then again, the suffering and mental unhappiness increase, and you predominantly abide in them, and that the bodily constituents, water, and so forth, the four elements, again become disturbed in strength and imbalance, as they lose their balance, producing pain in the body, which in turn brings mental unhappiness that lasts day and night. So then, again, I was going say it was I read it already, right? So Geshe-la was saying, with regards to suffering and mental unhappiness, Geshe-la was explaining that when we talk about suffering, we talk about the suffering feelings. And then we talk about feelings, Geshe-la, about feelings, Geshe-la says, we can divide it into five different types of feelings. So you have pleasant feelings I’ll say pleasant feelings, and you have suffering feelings.
Then you have mental happiness, mental distress, and then you have neutral feelings. So Geshe-la was saying. So we have all these sufferings which are associated related to the body, such as the aging of the body, the illness, the hurts, and the pain, so forth. And all those fall under the category of suffering feelings. And all the distress, all the sufferings that pertain, that are related to the mind, then there is mental distress.
And you have another way to refer to all these other sufferings that are related to the mind, then they are referred to as mental distress. So again, with all this aging and all this bodily sufferings, again, mental distress increases, again, with the imbalance of the constituents of the four elements of the constituents of the body. Again, this physical suffering increases, and again, mental distress increases dependence on that too. So one then what we are told again, all brings producing pain in the body, which in turn brings mental unhappiness that lasts day and night. So again, I guess I reiterate, in dependence on this, all this bodily physical pain, again, mental distress occurs day and night continually.
So then we have the next one, the restriction of enjoyment. Again, you lack desire then to enjoy pleasant things. Having been told that pleasant things are harmful when you are ill, you do not have the power to indulge in them as you wish, and likewise, you cannot do whatever you want. And again, Geshe-la shows us how we can see again how all this is true. We have, for example, with relation to food, again, we still have the desire to eat all these delicious, different types of food.
But still, the doctor will tell us that we cannot eat certain types of food. We cannot eat this and that. So we remain just our desires are frustrated. We cannot eat what we desire, what we want. And in the same vein, again, if you want to go somewhere, again, it becomes difficult to do that.
If you want to go to watch a performance, a show, or something like that, a sports match or something like that, sports event or something like that, again, it’s difficult to accomplish that. Hard to get there and so forth. So again, we can all see how that applies also. For unpleasant measures,. Again, you need to undergo the unpleasant against your will.
You have to employ unpleasant medicine, food, drink, and the like. Likewise, you need to rely on rough means of examination, such as being burned with fire, pierced with sharp instruments, and the like. And so again, Geshe-la is just going through. Again, we can see how that applies also. We have to, even though we do not wish to eat certain medicine, we have to take the medicine, even though it might not be pleasant or tasty or anything like that.
And again, we’ll have to go through this. We’ll have to go through medical checkups, and that can be very painful. Can think of biopsies and all that. I can tell you all that in English. Biopsies and so forth, which are very painful, where you have to go through Geshe himself has to burn sometimes has to burn these moles on his face, and you have to burn that with liquid nitrogen and all that.
So you have to go through these instruments and procedures, and you are really it’s not in your hands anymore. I guess I wasn’t saying, you know, you don’t have the control control over over. It’s not your choice anymore. You have to wait the unpleasant thing. You have to go for this unpleasant experiences.
So then, again, as a separation from life, the last one of this suffering of illness, you will be separated from your life. Having seen that the illness is incurable, then suffering arises, more suffering arises, because one will have to die. And again, Geshe-la says, all this again arises in dependence on the contaminated appropriated aggregates. Okay. So so then again, we have then the the suffering of of death, the next suffering the suffering of death.
So the consideration on the suffering of death, again, have five points. And you are separated from your wealth and possessions, relatives, companions, and your splendid body. And again, Geshe just goes through these four things that we’re going to have to be separated and say again, we’re going to have to be separated from all our possessions. It doesn’t matter how much wealth one might have. One can have all the wealth in the world.
And again, in the end, one will have to leave it all behind. There’s one of the words here that was translated as relatives, and Geshe-la was explaining to me, again, one’s skills, the skills that one have cultivated in this life. Again, all these skills, one will not be able to carry over with oneself. One will have to leave all that behind. So if one is an expert in whatever field, the sportsman or whatever, one will have to leave that behind.
Again, one’s companions, one’s retinue, however many people one have around oneself, following oneself, helping oneself, oneself, and so forth, again, one will have to leave all of them behind. And again, one’s body, that one has relied, independent, so forth, all of Again, one will have to leave it all behind. And at the time of death, you experience then suffering and intense mental unhappiness. So again, as long as you have not become mentally disenchanted with these sufferings, you should think about them again and again. And the way in which the first four become suffering is that having seen that you will be separated from those four, you suffer.
So now we will follow on to the next topic, the suffering of meeting with the unpleasant. So first we had the suffering of being separated from the pleasant, the desirable, and now the suffering of meeting with the unpleasant. So again, Geshe-la was going through the text. Again, the suffering of meeting with the unpleasant has five points. Again, so then by simply meeting, for example, with an enemy, then suffering and mental unhappiness arise.
Then Geshe-la is stopping there and saying, we can see how that actually does happen. When we meet with somebody that we dislike, again, we can see how mental suffering immediately arises, how we are distressed, and so forth. Again, due to that, you are beset by fear of being punished or being hurt. Then your fear of bad talk, you know, gossiping and harsh speaking, so forth. The fear of dreadful death, and fear due to the misgiving that you will go to a bad migration after death because of transgressing the dharma.
So you should think about these types of suffering. And again, moving on to the next topic, the suffering of separation from the pleasant. Again, the suffering of separation from the pleasant again has five points. Due to being separated, say, from close ones, dear ones, who are very dear to you, again, in the mind, sorrow arises. In the speech, there is lamentation.
In the body, harm arises. Through remembering the good qualities of the object and longing for it, there is mental torment. And you miss the pleasure of it. And again, you should think about these types of suffering. And then again, have the suffering of seeking what you desire and not getting it.
Seven. Again, the suffering of seeking what you desire and not getting it has five points that are similar to those associated with separation from what is pleasant. So then again, seeking what you desire but not getting it is the depressing suffering of not getting what you have been hoping for despite your efforts in seeking it. So just doing farm work, but not reaping the harvest, and doing business, but not accruing profit, and so on. So again, all these come in dependence on having acquired this contaminated appropriately contaminated aggregates.
And we all read about these things, and we all can easily understand how we are all experiencing that. But we do not actually give it any serious thought. We do not give it any serious consideration. We don’t want to think about it. We just want to we just don’t want to think about it, Geshe-la was saying.
Then again, we have next topic again in brief, the five appropriated aggregates are suffering. And we have a brief presentation and an extensive explanation of that. And so, again, thinking about the meaning of the statement, again, in brief. So again, thinking about this statement, which is a statement proclaimed by the Buddha, about the meaning of the statement, in brief, the five appropriated aggregates are suffering. This has five points again.
They are a vessel of suffering that will become manifest. They are a vessel of suffering that is the base for that which has already become manifest. They are a vessel for the suffering of suffering. They are a vessel for the suffering of change. And they are in the nature of compounded, all pervasive suffering.
So you should think about these points again and again. So, again, Geshe-la, I was just making reference to the statements again. So again, they are a vessel of suffering that will become manifest. So Geshe-la is explaining again, making reference to all compounded phenomena because they arise out of contaminated actions and afflictions again. They are all a vessel.
They are not suffering, but they are a vessel for the manifestation of suffering, upon which suffering can manifest. And again, these five aggregates, they can be they are seen as a vessel for the manifestation of this for manifestation of suffering. Again, it was the five aggregates having been having come about, having come into existence, dependence on contaminated actions, on karma, and afflictions. Again, the results, having then attained a birth, in which one acquired this aggregates. And again, the contaminated actions, the results of those previous actions can then arise, can then become manifest.
So again, this present contaminated aggregates are then a vessel for this suffering in this way. So again, we’re and then we have the suffering of suffering, again, is suffering that arises in the body and the mind. Again, we have the suffering of change, again, a result of the aggregates being a product of actions and afflictive emotions and conceptions. And again, all these being in the nature of pervasive compound of suffering, which is then the fact that all these, the aggregates, all of it, are the product of contaminated actions and afflictive emotions and conceptions. And so again, Geshe-la was saying, the whole point being it all boils down to the fact that all of these things, the whole of the five aggregates, contaminated aggregates, they arise out of contaminated actions and afflictions.
So all these sufferings, all these experiences that we have, they arise out of contaminated actions and afflictions. Or even the happy experiences that we have, even the pleasant experiences that we have. They arise out of the contaminated actions and the afflictions that have been accumulated in the past. So who is in control of these experiences of suffering and happiness pleasure and pain, so forth. It is these contaminated actions and the afflictions.
And other than that, oneself is not in control of these experiences. Okay? So so all ordinary beings, then again, have no control over this experience. We like to think and again, I’m going to use what we usually say in English. We have no free will.
We like to think that we do have free will, that we do have control over our experiences. But as ordinary beings, we don’t really have any control. We do not really have this. Sorry, Gengesha, I was saying if we did have this control that we talk about, if we did govern our lives in the way that we think about, if we didn’t have this free will, then again, we would all be happy. We would would all be intelligent.
We would all be wealthy. We would all be rich and healthy, and we will never be serving anybody or slaves to anybody. But because we do not have this control, because we do lack control, we do not govern our lives and so forth. Then again, some people are rich, some people are poor, some people have more than others, some people are more learned than others, some people are more healthy than others, and so on and so on. This one.
So Geshe lah is saying again, there none of us whatsoever who all us, we only wish for happiness. We do not wish for any suffering. But even though we only wish even though we only wish for happiness, we still experience suffering. So it is not in our hands. And in whose hands it is, it is in the hands of contaminated actions and afflictive emotions and conceptions.
So again, Geshe-la says, so who who is in control? Geshe-la is saying, is attachment is in control. Aversion is in control. Arrogance is in control. So we we are under the power.
We are governed by these three afflictions. And Geshe-la was saying, so again, Geshe-la is saying, the strength of attachment arises. Attachment arises. Then we have, say, attachment for a car. We lust after a car.
And then we think, then, I must have that car. There and then, we have already accumulated mental karma. We have performed this mental action of intention. Then, in dependence on that, we start engaging in activities, physical activities, in order to obtain the then we create physical karma. And we start also engaging in speech in order to obtain the karma again, and we create then actions of speech.
Due to that attachment, we accumulate all three types of karma, mental, physical, and verbal karma. So again, out of that attachment, out of that lust, again, worked. And eventually, we obtained the car. And then having obtained the car, we think, how cool am I,? I have a very great car.
And then immediately, we are proud. We are arrogant. And if anything happens to the car, if it gets dirty, somebody scratches it, or somebody cuts in front of you, then you get angry. And then here we are governed by these three afflictions. So again, if it was up to us, and again, all that wouldn’t happen in this way.
But we are governed, we are overpowered by attachment. And then we create the karma. We engage in these contaminated activities. And then we are overpowered by anger, and we’re overpowered by pride. We’re overpowered by the afflictions in this way.
And in this way, we engage in activities, in actions, whilst overpowered by those afflictions. So we accumulate contaminated karma. And this way, we accumulate the causes of more rebirths. And this way, we accumulate the causes of more suffering. What we need to do then is not to give control to to attachment, to aversion, to anger, to pride, and so forth.
And so we need to then apply the antidotes. Need to take control. We need to take hold of our lives. English I was going to say. So if when attachment arises in relationship to the car, in the case of this illustration, we have to start contemplating, Okay, attachment has arisen.
Attachment is no good. It’s harmful. It’s an affliction. Again, that car is true suffering, is in the nature of suffering. That car is not going to give me any real happiness.
Whatever it is that I perceive as happiness in relationship to that car is not actual happiness. So one has to contemplate in this way, give rise to these thoughts in this way, in order not to come under the control of attachment. But it’s very difficult difficult. It’s very difficult to for us to actually think in this way, acting this way in relationship to the afflictions. And then, then excuse me.
In case, I was then saying, so in so in order to avoid all all these troubles, again, if one then realizes the the lack of inherent existence of the car. Or if one realizes the lack of inherent existence of the self, you know, realizing the selflessness of the person, or the selflessness of phenomena, then it’s easy. Then It’s all easy. It’s all good. And no more trouble.
And again, by realizing the lack of inherent existence of the car, again, how is it that it helps us in this situation, relationship to attachment, again? Because by realizing the lack of inherent existence of the car, one realizes that the car or the car’s qualities do not actually exist in the way they appear to exist. They’re not actually real as they appear to be. So one realizes, and one actually sees the car for what it is, and one actually sees the actual faults and the shortcomings pertaining to the car. And in this way, one’s attachment greatly diminishes again.
And by cultivating a familiarization with this realization, one continually diminishes attachment. And they are all in the nature of compounded suffering, as we have here. And you should think about these points again and again. And Kesha was just reiterating again the importance of thinking about it, bringing to mind again and again, familiarizing myself with this. So again, we have the extensive explanation.
Again, here, the first point is that, in dependence of taking these appropriated aggregates, the sufferings of the next rebirth onward are induced. So again, by taking this present rebirth, the future are induced in the same way that this present rebirth has been induced by previous rebirth. Again, the aggregates that have already been established become the basis of the suffering of birth, aging, death, and so forth, to arise dependence upon them. The third and the fourth ones, again, the aggregates give rise to these two types of suffering due to their relationship with the negative tendencies of the true origins. And then in the fifth one, due to the mere establishment of the appropriated aggregates, they arise in the nature of compounding suffering for all compounding phenomena under the control of other previous karma and mental afflictions are compounded suffering.
So there’s no happiness to it whatsoever, Geshe-la says. So suffering. And then last, again, advice to cherish this manner of meditating on the essence. So again, if no genuine disenchantment develops towards cyclic existence, which is of the nature of the appropriated aggregates, there is no way for a genuine awareness striving for liberation to develop, nor for great compassion for the sentient beings roaming about inside the existence to develop. Therefore, these considerations are extremely important whichever vehicle you enter, the Mahāyāna or the Hīnayāna.
So again, we have to avoid the stop future rebirths. So again, need then to see, to understand the sufferings of cyclic existence, see the faults of cyclic existence, of saṃsāra, all the faults and shortcomings, because if we do not have this understanding, if we do not see the sufferings, again, the desire to stop future births will not arise. The desire to be free from to attain freedom and liberation from psychedelicism does not arise. And in this way, again, one is not able to develop, give rise to the paths of both Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna. So it’s very important to contemplate these sufferings of cyclic existence. And then again, independence sorry.
Again, in dependence on not contemplating the sufferings, again, also compassion does not arise. Because if one does not gain an understanding of one’s own sufferings, and the values of this wish to be free from suffering, one is unable to develop this understanding about the sufferings of others, and wish them, others, to be free from suffering. So again, if the great vehicle also depends, both the lesser vehicle and the greater vehicle, they both depend on renunciation, on this mind of renunciation, which is a mind that fully understands the shortcomings and the faults of cyclic existence. And Geshe-la was saying, when we’re talking about attaining freedom from cyclic existence, giving up cyclic existence, giving up saṃsāra, And we see the householders, and those who have given up the householder’s life, who say, I have given up on cyclic existence. I have given up of saṃsāra.
I have given it up. So we hear it said, Okay, I’m giving up samsaric life. And then becomes becomes renunciate, becomes ordained, so forth. And so I have given up. I’m giving up this samsaric life.
And we hear that said, but it’s not saying, it is not just as it is just like that. It’s not as easy as it sounds. In English, that was the same. We’re talking about saṃsāra, exactly, existence, we’re not talking about the environment where we live in, the place where we live, the people we live with, our friends and family and relatives. So when we talk about cyclic existence, we’re talking about one’s own continuum.
We’re talking about one’s own aggregates. That is what is saṃsāra for oneself, one’s own aggregate. That is what we’re working with. And Geshe-la was saying, we we have this saying about What’s what’s the you know, wandering through cyclic existence? But is that a better word that conveyed the powerlessness involved in this?
So we have this saying, this expression, wandering in cyclic existence, Geshe-la was saying. When we’re talking about wandering in cyclic existence, we’re talking about wandering in the six realms of existence, in the six types of rebirth, and how beings, spirits, animals, humans, and gods. And again, this wandering happens. This wandering is propelled or is driven by contaminated actions and afflictive emotions. And so propelled by these contaminated actions and afflictive emotions, we attain these contaminated aggregates of the hell realms, of preta realms, of the animal realms, of human realms, and so forth.
And in this way, we keep on wandering. We wander through a cyclic existence, through the ocean cyclic existence. So then again, this wandering is propelled, is driven by the contaminated actions. emotions. So again, in this way, if one has performed very grave, very grave, very bad contaminated actions, and again, one is propelled, one’s wandering one to the hell realms.
Again, if one has committed some not so grave non virtues, some average non virtues, and again, is wandering, ends up in the leads one to being born in the preta realms, the hungry ghost realms. Again, if one’s non virtuous, contaminated actions have been lesser non virtuous, again, one will wander into the animal realm of existence. And again, if one’s contaminated actions have been virtues, if they were great virtues and one wanders into the god realms, again, if one’s virtues were average, again, one wanders into the demigod realm of existence. And again, if one’s virtues were lesser virtues, again, one wanders into the human realm of existence. And again, in dependence on all these contaminated actions that have been performed, again, all the afflictions arise, in dependence on that, have attained the aggregates, the contaminated aggregates, and in dependence on those actions?
Geshe-la again illustrating our powerlessness, our helplessness in this regard. Again, if one has if one has performed some very grave negative action, then again, that action is gonna make us wander into the hell realm of existence. And there is no how can I say? There’s no way to just to wish it to wish it away. We cannot just say, I don’t want to be reborn there.
Because if what you could just say that and wish it away, then nobody would ever be reborn there. But it’s not really up to us. Again, if one if one’s actions, negative actions haven’t been so grave, and one those actions are going to propel one to be born into the hungry ghost realm, there is no there’s no wishing it away again. There’s no way to say, again, I don’t want to be reborn there. Otherwise, again, nobody would ever be reborn there.
So it is completely up to the action, to the contaminated actions and afflictive emotions. We are helpless in this regard. We are powerless in this regard. This process is wholly powered by contaminated actions and the afflictions.
And again, I was saying again, so saṃsāra, cyclic existence, is this process which is powered by contaminated actions and the afflictions. So as long as one is overpowered by, or one is propelled or driven by, these contaminated actions and afflictions, one is in saṃsāra. And once one free, once one has abandoned these contaminated actions and these afflictions, then one is free from cyclic existence. One is separated from cyclic existence, one has given up cyclic existence. And so contaminated actions and the afflictions are what propel us.
And of these two, again, the contaminated actions originate, arise, in dependence on the afflictions. And of all the afflictions, all of them arise in dependence on the root affliction, which is ignorance. So the very root of all this trouble is ignorance itself. And so again, the origin of all the sufferings that we have been going through today, the very root of all the sufferings that we have been going through today, is this ignorance. The ignorance of self grasping.
And the ignorance of self grasping has a very good friend, very powerful friend helping it, which is the self-cherishing mind. So these two are always, Geshe-la was saying, talking with each other, scheming, to keep us around for a little while longer. So again, we we we have to look into ways of abandoning or getting rid of ignorance. And then once we get rid of ignorance, we get rid of all these troubles. So again, can arrest ignorance, then we can arrest all these other faults, all these other shortcomings that follow from it.
Tomorrow. Two thousand nine. Yes. So you had a question that you wanted to ask earlier? Attachment to the car.
When did we go for a demo? Last Sunday, we did that? Last Sunday, we did that. Yes. Should have come here on Sunday.
You have that question answered? So I just put forth the illustration that you gave. Right? You say, okay. I have I’m going to go and see the His Holiness in Sydney.
I must go and see His Holiness. Then you work and you speak and you talk and arrange ways to do that. So Geshe-la was saying, so that is not attachment. Okay? That desire, that wish that you have to go and see His Holiness in Sydney is not attachment.
That is faith. That is aspiration. That is a virtuous mind. So again, and I just asked them, so we should to just talk about the difference between attachment and faith, for example. Geshe was saying the difference comes in dependence on the object.
And Geshe-la was just giving another illustration again. So for example, say, let’s not talk about car, Geshe-la was saying. Let’s talk about one’s girlfriend. So one girlfriend is in India, and you want to go and meet your girlfriend in India. You have this wish, this desire to go and meet your girlfriend in India.
So then you work, you save money, and you talk and all that. And you go to India to visit your girlfriend. And on the other hand, you could be wanting to go to India to attend his teachings. So again, you want to go to India to attend his teachings. You work, you save the money, you do everything that you have to do, and you get there to India.
One, you are going to attend his teaching. You are going to attend the teaching of his holiness, to learn the Dharma. His holiness is a real object of virtue with real good qualities. And the other one is just going after your girlfriend, just out of lust or whatever. So one is attachment, and the other one is faith or aspiration.
So there’s a difference then in in the in the with regards to faith and attachment, there’s a difference then in in relationship to the object of each of those minds and the quality of the motivation and the quality of the relationship. So again, even with regards to one’s parents, for example, if one has a liking, a mind that likes one’s parents, and that is virtue. On the other hand, you should have a car, and you see all these have all these ideas about the car and how happy it’s gonna make you and all that, and I must have it, you know, it’s great and all that, and it’s all attachment. And then on the other hand, when your parents grow old and they are not very mobile anymore, and you are concern, out of care, then you say, you know, they cannot go around, so I’m gonna get them a car so they can go around and do whatever it is they have to do. And when you do it in this way, that’s not attachment.
And so that’s a virtuous motivation. So again, in this last illustration, the object is still the same, it’s still a car, but the motivation is completely different. This one. Is that okay? Yeah, yeah.
Is that okay? Okay. Any more questions about motorbikes, cars? No? All good?
Okay. Oh, yeah. Do you have any questions, You wanna throw some more in? You can hear. You haven’t quite I haven’t quite done you.
Very long time. Good. Good. I don’t know yet. So what’s the relation between self and So the self-cherishing mind is a mind that cherishes oneself as the most precious, most important thing.
And this self grasping mind so that self-cherishing mind is cherishing the self, is cherishing the I. And it cherishes it, it holds as if it exists in the way that appears to exist. So the self grasping mind is the mind that is grasping at that self as existing in the way that appears to exist. And then the self-cherishing mind is the mind that cherishes that self that appears to exist, that cherishes that self, which appears to exist in the way it appears to exist. Does that make sense?
If the self did not appear to exist in the way that appears to exist, in the way that it does appear to exist, then there wouldn’t be such an overt self-cherishing. There wouldn’t be such a great, strong cherishing of the self. How was that? If the self didn’t appear, So if one didn’t grasp at the self as existing in the way that it appears to exist, then one wouldn’t cherish it. Is that all right, That’s pretty much it, isn’t it?
If you want to get rid of them, yes. So again, realizing emptiness, and one realizes that the self does not exist in the way it appears to exist. By realizing that it doesn’t exist in the way it appears to exist, then again, one realizes how it is not so precious and important, so the cherishing goes away also. Is that Okay? And Geshe lah was giving you illustration.
So it’s like finding a how can I say that? A nugget of copper? How do you say that in English? Say it again? Nuggets.
Nuggets. So it’s like when you find a nugget of copper, but you think that it is gold. Gold. You think it is gold. So you think of it as being gold, and you think it is very precious.
And you take care of it, and you want it, and you hold on to it, and you cherish it. So that is like seeing that nugget of copper as being gold is like the self grasping mind. And cherishing it is like the self-cherishing. And once you realize emptiness, the realization of emptiness is just like realizing that that which you thought was gold is actually just copper. And then you lose also all the attachment towards it, all the cherishing.
You don’t cherish it anymore. So it’s more or less the same relationship, the same thing happened there. Okay? So yeah, it goes more or less like this with self grasping, self-cherishing. Anything else?
This one? Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- five appropriated aggregates
- The last of the eight types of suffering; how we suffer because the aggregates are "appropriated" or controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.