Middle Lam Rim — 2009-02-12

2 h 0 min · 7,994 words · 12 February 2009 · Buddha House Adelaide

Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Middle Lam Rim — 2009-02-12
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. “Isn’t ignorance beneficial?” — Geshe Pema Tsering poses this rhetorical question near the end of this nearly two-hour Lamrim session, then dismantles it: only by seeing the unripened suffering stored through past karma can we find the will to purify and restrain. The session first covers purification — how even definite karma can be weakened through the four opponent powers, and why avoiding faults from the start outweighs confession after the fact (illustrated with the image of a healed but permanently weakened limb). Geshe then completes the lesser-scope section — defining its attainment as the moment future lives displace this life as one’s primary concern — and clears the misconception that seeking favorable rebirth contradicts renunciation. The talk closes by opening the intermediate-scope path, defining liberation as freedom from contaminated actions and afflictions, and distinguishing contaminated from uncontaminated virtue in Q&A.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 03 2009 02 12 BP.mp3

UUID: 89842f55-514e-42b3-b260-589b2b033f9d

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Middle Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2009-02-12

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 120.8 minutes

Words: ~8,029

So I guess she’s then instructing us to give rise to a good motivation and with intention then of accomplishing enlightenment for the sake of benefiting all beings. And we are going to listen and study to these teachings and with this motivation in mind we give rise to proper motivation. So if we give rise by giving rise to a good motivation, then, you know, our spiritual practice will turn out good and that will bring about also good results in the future. Motivation that then is intent on freeing all sentient beings from every suffering and endowing them with every happiness, establishing them in the state of enlightenment. In order to accomplish that, one myself must attain enlightenment.

And that is is the way to give rise to motivate. That is the best motivation to give rise to before we engage in these teachings today and before we engage in actually any activity every day in life. And Geshe-la is saying that this thought of enlightenment, again, if we do not give rise to it deliberately give rise to it, you see, because, because we have been habituated since time immemorial. Have we have been habituated only with, our own interests and our own benefits and and and well-being. We have only been intent on, realizing our own desires, own personal desires without any regard for others. And again if we do not deliberately produce this thought of enlightenment we will not be able to bring it about.

We’ll not be able to accomplish those results of the the thought of enlightenment. So that’s why it is very important that we realize that this self centered attitude that we have, it is is thinking oneself is more important and precious is fundamentally wrong, is fundamentally distorted. That in actuality, we are not as precious as we think we are, as important as we think we are, and other sentient beings are actually more important and are very precious indeed. And so Geshe-la is saying. And all other sentient beings, they are precious.

They are important because it is in dependence on them that we have experienced and and will ever experience every happiness that we have. It is in dependence on the kinds of other things that we experience, that that we obtain, that we experience happiness. And every suffering, on the other hand, comes in dependence on the on ourselves, on on the thought of I or my or me on that thought, dependence on that mind, then every suffering comes about in dependence on that. So, but we do not actually understand this this fact. So it is important then that we contemplate, that we give rise to this thought of enlightenment that, you know, one must work for the welfare, the well-being, for the happiness of all other sentient beings.

And and one must do that not only one time because doing that only once will not be able will not be enough to generate that thought. Because of one’s habituation, one must do it to the best of one’s ability as much as one can. One must habituate oneself in this way. So then, again, Geshe-la says, then we with the intention of benefiting us, then I myself must attain enlightenment. In order to accomplish that, I’m going to recite the Heart Sūtra.

I’m going to listen to the teachings. I’m going to meditate and so forth. And in this way, start. So we start with the Heart Sūtra. Thus, did I hear one time?

It is like that. Is like that. One should practice the profound Perfection of Wisdom just as you have indicated, even the Tathagatas rejoice. The Bhagavan have been thus spoken, the Venerable Śāriputra, the Buddha, Mahasattvas, the Bodhisattva Avalokiteśvara, those surrounding their entirety along with the world of gods, humans, asuras, and Gandharvas were overjoyed and highly praised as spoken by the Bhagavad. And we move on to the dispelling of hindrances.

I and all surrounding sentient beings go for refuge to the Buddha, go for refuge to the Dharma, go for refuge to the Sangha. We prostrate to the great mother Prajñāpāramitā surrounded by all the children, by the assemblies of Buddhas and bodhisattvas of the ten directions. By depending on my prostrations to all of you, may these words of truth be actual ized. In the past, the deva king Indra dispelled the Maras by reflecting on the profound meaning of the wisdom gone beyond and reciting the profound words in daily recitation. May that same may I also realize the profound meaning of the great Maha Prajñāpāramitā and recite the profound words on daily recitation.

May all diseases, spirit possessions, bad conditions, all the negative directions, that which happens due to past karma and immediate conditions. May all of this be dispelled, may become non existent, may be pacified. You can if you speak louder. To explain the quote from the text. Look.

I I I do not have that quote in front of me to be able to use the exact words that should use, but so I I translate it in the best way that I I could. And if I’ll ask Damchoe Gyatso to to give any input later on. But, basically, every, Dharma practice there is, you of course, you have to investigate, and develop and gain an understanding of what the practice is so that you can actually practice it properly and accomplish something. If you do not investigate, if you do not check, if you do not study, if you do not understand the meaning of what is being said, you’re not gonna accomplish the benefits unless you’re very lucky. So and and that goes for any skills.

I mean, if you have to do a job out there in the world that involves writing, If you do not properly learn how to write, read and write, then you won’t be able to fulfill the job. You need to learn. So in the same in the case of confession, you need to learn what confession is. You need to understand the words of the Buddha. The Buddha had said in this regard.

You need to understand the qualities of of those thirty five Buddhas. You need to understand the purpose, the meaning, and the way to practice and everything so that you can so you need to investigate. You need to check first. You need to investigate. You need to develop an understanding before you actually, you know, appropriately engage and develop a practice, whatever practice may be.

Does that help? Is that good? Do do do you would you like to add anything to that in terms of explaining the meaning of what Adam was trying to say to the Gethe? Sorry? Yeah.

And I was just saying the Buddha Śākyamūni also says things like that, like what Pabongka Rinpoche had said and and what about purifying negativities and so forth. Yeah. So we are on page one hundred and seven, and we move on to the we are moving on to the next topic. We we’ve been going through the manner of purifying that has a few divisions to that. We’re going to the second one, which is how how even karma that is definite to be experienced is purified. purified from the root.

And we have seen in the previous class how, you know, the the quality of the intensity of one’s purification practices, the duration, and and so forth, how they, determine the quality of the purification, of the result of purification, or how how much one has purified with negativity. So if one has done one’s purification practice with intensity, with a constancy before a good length of time, then one will attain more purification than if one has done with less intensity, less constancy, and less, amount of time and so forth. And that being said, now we go for the next topic and how even karma that is definitely to be experienced is purified from the root. So Geshe is explaining that So Geshe is explaining that we we’re talking about in this in this topic, we’re referring to definite karma. karma which is we are definitely going to experience without choosing.

So then those are those are results of of very strong negative deeds, very strong negative actions. But and then we’re being told that even even, those negative deeds, even the results of of these such negative deeds or such great negative deeds can be purified by by the proper by proper by engaging the proper purification practices, engaging them appropriately. Mhmm. This one. So, again, we start we start with this statement from that we find in the sutras and in the Vinaya scriptures.

It says that actions are not lost even in a hundred eons. So we we find this statement. And on the other hand, we are we are just being told that we can actually purify those actions. So it seems so it seems that there is a contradiction here. And and the text goes on saying that the the intention of that statement is that that is without cultivating the antidote of the four opponent powers or the four powers.

However, in the commentary on the eight thousand verse Perfection of Wisdom sūtra, it says that through the antidote of the four opponent powers, if purified in accordance with the explanations, even karma that is definitely to be experienced is And then, again, we move on to the next topic. Again, that even if the one doing the purification does not completely purify karma of little strength of little strength, its effect will not come forth due to the full ripening effect having been weakened. And goes on reading the whole text saying again in in this text called the Blaze of Reasoning, it says that once you have thus weakened the potential to bring forth a fully ripened effect by means of confession, the resolve to exercise restraint and the like, then the fully ripened effect will not come about even if other conditions are met. Likewise, the destruction of roots of virtue by wrong views and anger is also similar. Also also works in a similar way.

So, Geshe lah, just explain. So what what is being said here again Geshe lah explains in in the case of for example the roots of virtue that we have accumulated that we have that we have accumulated in the past again those roots of virtue they can be damaged or harmed by anger attachment and so forth. In case that wasn’t clear. So the results that we would experience of those roots of virtue, those results harmed in that, for example, if it is if we have a great affliction, anger, or so forth, then we we experience a great diminishment of the results. And if the the roots of virtue are weak roots of virtue, then and and we can even, not experience any, results from those roots of virtue whatsoever.

In the same vein, again, in the purification of negativities. Negativities. So the same the same it works in the same way. So what is what we Geshe lah is saying what he thinks is most likely being said here is that those actions, those negative actions that we have performed, those imprints we we do not completely eradicate them by this means but we can, by means of the confessional practice, the four opponent powers, we can either greatly diminish the results of those negativities the suffering results of negativities or depending on the quality of the intensity and the power of the negativities and the quality and intensity of the purification practice, we can actually completely, stop those any results, any suffering results from arising whatsoever altogether. And get but I say again, Geshe-la was saying in the end that he thinks it is not that we completely eradicate the the action itself, the imprint of the action itself by these means of confession, but that what we damage, where we damage, is the results, the negative results, the suffering results of of those negative actions.

Is that okay? Is that making sense? In English, I move on moves on to the next topic. How it is necessary to make an effort from the start, not to be tainted by faults. Although, through confession and the resolve to exercise restraint and so forth, you may be able to purify karma so that nothing at all remains.

There is is there is still a great difference between the purity of not being tainted by faults from the beginning and the purity after confession. So and we are giving them this example. For example, in the Bodhisattva levels, it it is said that when a root downfall has occurred, it can be restored by taking the Bodhisattva vows again. However, it will be impossible to reach the first ground, the first Bodhisattva ground in in this life, in that in that life in which that happened. So, Geshe-la was saying, one can one can restore the vow, one can retake the vow, one can actually, completely eradicate any ripening effect from the the negative action, but still one will not be able to attain to reach to the first Bodhisattva ground in that life, in in the life in which that happened.

And Geshe-la goes on again. Also in the sūtra gathering all the threads, it says that once the negativity of abandoning the dharma, which is explained in that sūtra, has occurred, if one confesses it three times a day, over seven years the negativity will be purified. But still it will take even at the quickest to attain the level of tolerance of patience or forbearance of the path of preparation. And and goes on again, therefore, the purification without exception means that the production of unpleasant effects is purified without without exception. However, since the arrival of the realizations of the path and so forth will be much delayed, you should endeavor not to be tainted from the beginning.

Goes on. Also also for that reason, it says that do not knowingly engage even in subtle negativities or downfalls even for the sake of their lives, even if their lives is at stake. Otherwise, if there was no difference between purifying them through confession and their non arising from the beginning, there will be no need to act like that. And and again, we we have an illustration, a point that is given to illustrate that this point in in the world to even if a wounded arm, leg, and so forth heals again, it still will not be as if from the start it had never been wounded. And, again, Geshe-la was just saying that we we so we all know that from experience that even if we break an arm or a leg, you know, knee injuries, especially, I mean, if you even if you recover from such an injury, it will not be as good as it was before you had the injury.

Then we move on to the next topic. Then the measure of the attitude of lesser beings of beings of a small scope having been developed. So all these topics that we have been approaching to the path of the beings of which is common to beings of small scope. And then so then what what is the measure of having developed that attitude and motivation that they have? And Geshe goes on for the text again saying, previously, you had an uncontrived interest in this world only.

So I was gonna say, and that’s how and that’s how we live our lives, isn’t it? With this uncontrived spontaneous motivation that is focused on this life only. So, know, immediately when we get hungry, we think only of getting food for ourselves. When we get cold, we think only of making ourselves warm and and so forth. When we meet hardships, we won’t think of alleviating ourselves and so forth.

And your interest in future lives was just a vague understanding, fascinated with the words with the words. Having exchanged these two attitudes when future lives have become the main interest in this present life is nothing but a byproduct, the attitude of lesser beings of the attitude of beings of of smaller scope has developed. As as nevertheless, needs to be made stable, you should strive, that is to you should train your mind in it even after it has arisen. And so, again, with regards to that last to the very last sentence, as this nevertheless needs to be made stable, you should strive. There is in it even after it has arisen.

So, again, even, after one has developed that mind, one shouldn’t give in, to to such way of things that says to oneself. I know now I have I am a being of small scope. I don’t have anything else to do in this regard. You know? Once once you have developed that attitude, there’s no concern with this life and it’s concerned only with the future lives.

You shouldn’t think like that. You should keep on training. You should keep on develop a develop a a stronger and stronger familiarization, a more clear and clearer familiarization, and, you know, more stable habituation with the whole mind, this this whole attitude. Because if you don’t, if you just, you know, let it be, you know, there’s a danger that it might it might degenerate and you might lose power or you might lose it altogether. And then just pointing out was how how actually how difficult it is to realize this attitude of the beings of smaller scope.

You know, we we let we put aside the whole understanding that we already have the difficulty of realizing the the the motivation of the beings of middling scope or of greater scope. This motivation of the beings of small scope or smaller scope alone is already very difficult because it it is asking us that we disregard any interest for the things of this present life or the comforts and the pleasures of this present life and and instead be concerned solely with, the welfare of future lives, accomplishing the well-being, accomplishing the good of future lives. And our present attitude is an attitude that is solely concerned with the pleasures and comforts of this present life and has total disregard for the experiences or the well-being of future lives, which is an attitude which is directly opposite to this attitude of the beings of small scope. So, Geshe-la is explaining. So, again and and we we all say we think to to ourselves, and we say, you know, we are, you know, Mahāyāna practitioners.

You know? We are, you know, we we think of the mind of enlightenment, and we think we are Mahāyāna practitioners. And Geshe-la is is is explained to us, but it is but still, we we have this enormous difficulty to give rise even to this mind of the beings of smaller scope. And is saying by developing, by cultivating the mind of enlightenment in the way we do, we do accomplish a great amount of benefit, and we leave very powerful imprints in our mind stream and so on. But in order to fully accomplish the mind of enlightenment and to develop an uncontrived, spontaneous mind of enlightenment, one needs to have accomplished or have developed as a preliminary.

One has to have developed these minds of the beings of middling scope and of lesser scope or smaller scope. Otherwise, one cannot fully accomplish the mind of enlightenment itself in this uncontrived spontaneous way. So, again, we we shall start again saying how, you know, how how difficult it is to develop this attitude of the being of beings of a smaller scope with with a with a smaller scope. There is an attitude which is intent on accomplishing the welfare of future lives and and not concerned with this present life. So but and so but we should we should still train our minds and engage in every opportunity to do develop, to give rise to this thought, to this attitude.

And and by any time that we can anytime that we are able to give up concern for the things of this life and give rise in this in a place of this attitude, we give rise to this other attitude which is concerned with the welfare of future lives, then we have we have then every time that we have we think in this way that we have this attitude, then we have then this attitude of the being of small scope of a smaller scope. So we move on to the next topic, eliminating misconceptions about the attitude of of the beings of smaller scope. So there’s two topics to that. First, setting out their assertions, the assertion, and then refuting that assertion. This assertion then is in the scriptures, it says that it is necessary to turn the mind away from all the excellences, from all the excellent things of cyclic existence.

Whereby having become a basis of confusion, some people think it is inappropriate to develop interest in the high status of an excellent body, possessions, and so forth because they are part of cyclic existence. So we we are told in the scriptures that, you know, we we the entirety of cyclic existence is in the nature of suffering, and we should attain freedom from the entirety of it. And and and with with that, with that in mind, some people come to think that it is inappropriate, to to develop this interest for attaining a high rebirth as as a god or a human being or goddess. And then so then The refutation has two parts. How a continuous succession of excellent bodies is necessary.

And so with respect with respect to that which is to be striving for striven or striving for. They are both temporary and ultimate goals to strive for. Even those who strive for liberation from the excellences of a body and so forth of cyclic existence need to temporarily strive for them since the definite goodness of liberation and enlightenment needs to be gained in the end from continuous succession of such basis, of such supports, these bodies. So still, Geshe-la explains, we need the succession of of this support in order to be able to accomplish the goal, the ultimate goal. So still, the ultimate goal is liberation, complete liberation, but still and we need an appropriate support in order to accomplish that goal.

And we need then the succession of this favorable support, and that is alright then. So it’s not inappropriate in this in this context. And then we move on to the next. Again, the the second half of the the refutation, looking at ultimately high status. Not Not all that is the high status of an excellent body, possessions, and retinue are included in cyclic existence.

For the combination of an excellent body, etcetera, etcetera, is the form body of a Buddha, the wealth of its fields, the mandala, and and its retinue, the the bodhisattvas and so forth. So Geshe is explaining. So there there are high status bodies and environment and possessions and so forth which are including cyclic existence which are propelled by contaminated actions of afflictive emotion conceptions and there is also high status of of bodies, environment, and possessions, and so forth, which is not included in cyclic existence, which is beyond cyclic existence and is not propelled by contaminated contaminated actions and afflictive emotion conceptions. And it is with this intention that the Ornament of the Sutras says that the first four perfections that the first core the first four perfections accomplish the highest status of an excellent body, possessions, retinue, and undertakings and so forth. And that many other scriptures state that they accomplish the form body.

And this then concludes the explanation of the mental training in the stages of the path, which is common to beings of a smaller scope. In English. You have it in English? Yeah. Oh, I don’t have.

Didn’t know I had that. Excellent. And, Geshe-la, I was just explaining then. So what is the main point, the main difference in the thank you. The what is the main difference between the these beings?

Why why is it that we call beings we have these titles, these different labels of beings of greater scope, of of of of smaller scope. And the main difference being that beings of great scope are beings who aspire to attain the full enlightenment full enlightenment of a Buddha. Then beings of middling scope are beings who are mainly motivated who are motivated to attain liberation from cyclic existence for for themselves alone. And then beings of smaller scope are beings who are intent, who are motivated to attaining higher rebirth in future lives as either humans or gods, goddesses. Is explaining some of the terminology.

So then now we start with the explanation of the training in the stages of the path common to beings of intermediate scope, of a medium scope. Oh, I know. Was explaining explaining so that the two momma which is which is common common. So this is those trainings, the practice of the meditations and teachings of the beings on the path of greater scope also engaging. So the trainings which are common to both beings of middling scope and of beings of greater scope.

And and the more we are studying before, the path which is common to beings of a smaller scope. Again, those are stages, steps, meditations and teachings that we cultivate, that we develop, as beings of on the path of of of greater scope, but which are trained, which are common to beings of lesser scope. Okay? So so we have done the training training the mind in the status of the path which is common to beings of intermediate scope. We have then first the transition where this was translated as a transition, and then we have the actual training.

As for is referred to as a transition, Geshe-la was explaining is is the reason, basically, is an explanation of why we have to, engage in this training after we have accomplished the training of the path which is common to beings of smaller scope. So having developed that attitude and those all all those foundational practices of the path which is common to beings of smaller smaller scope, there is a reason. We are going to be given a reason why we should continue to develop further into the path and the trainings of the beings of middling scope. So Geshe is going through the text, again, saying with regards to the transition here, have, thus having become mindful of death and reflected on the way in which you will fall into the bad migrations after death. You have turned your mind away from this present life and developed a striving for the happy migrations, for a happy future rebirth.

Then through the common going for refuge and the certainty regarding, positive and negative actions and the results, you will give up negativities and then by putting everyone engaging and abandoning the ten non-virtuous and so forth. And by putting effort into accomplishing virtue, giving up the ten non virtues, accomplishing virtue, you will indeed you will indeed attain the state of of the happy migrations. You attain a happy rebirth in the future. However, there is not how to be sufficient here. Rather, once you have developed that the attitude of lesser beings, to beings of a smaller scope and have developed that the attitude of intermediate beings which contrasts with and turns the mind from cyclic existence as a whole, in depends on in dependence on them, you will develop the mind of enlightenment.

So, again, you will be in dependence on them, will develop the mind of enlightenment and be led into the path of the beings of greater scope. The purpose of training in the attitude of intermediate beings of of beings of intermediate scope is that even though you attain the state of a god, goddess, or human being in this manner, you will not have passed beyond the compounded suffering conditioned existence. Therefore, holding to these as happiness by nature is mistaken since in reality, they are devoid of happiness. These phenomena are are devoid of happiness, and in the end, they are bad because you are certain to fall into the bad migrations again. And I guess is explaining how Geshe is saying how that is actually so, how the this this higher state of of births as humans and gods is they are not actually reliable.

They do not give us any lasting happiness. In the end, they are not, they are in the nature of what we refer to as compounded suffering. And in term when we talk about suffering, we we have three, division of three general types of suffering. The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change, and what is referred to as the all-pervasive compounded suffering. And these higher rebirths, these higher rounds of existence, they are not beyond beyond this this all pervasive compounded suffering so in the end we’ll even though we have attained those states in the end we will have to experience more suffering in the end, which is not different than the condition that we have now then because we we are we have this relative happiness.

We’re gonna have to experience suffering also. And then therefore if you go on from the text and the actual training the the text goes on in the Tibetan says therefore the training of the mind in the stages of the path which are common to beings of intermediate scope has four points. So then again, so with this understanding in mind, we understand we have to engage in this path and this training of the beings of intermediate scope. And this path has four main points. This training has four main points.

So we have then the actual training in that in in that attitude, the measure of its development, then the elimination of misconceptions about it, and finally determining the nature of the path leading to liberation. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah. So so this goes on the explanation of how to develop the mind striving for liberation.

The actual training in that attitude has two parts. Again, the identification of the mind which strives for liberation and the methods for generating the mind that strives for liberation. So identifying then the mind that strives for liberation has to pass the identification of what is liberation, of liberation itself, and then the mind striving for liberation. So first then, liberation is freedom from bondage. Geshe-la was explaining explaining a couple of Tibetan words.

So one is, is liberation. The other one is, which is then freedom freedom from something, freedom from bondage. And, specifically, that which binds us to cyclic existence is, contaminated actions and the afflictive emotions and conceptions. So we are to be free to attain this freedom from these two bondages of contaminated actions and afflictive emotion conceptions, and that is liberation. So, again, with regards to actions, karma, and the physical emotional conceptions.

Geshe-la was Geshe-la was explaining. So we we have gone through this topic already. So we all know what it is, what actions are. Actions actions karma actions is the are the the is the mental factor of intention. It is thought.

So they are every thought that arises, every mental factor of intention that arises, it is is karma, is action. And every verbal and physical action that is powered by these intentions, by these mental intentions is, again, what is referred to as verbal karma or physical karma, verbal actions, physical actions. So so we are always producing karma. We are always producing these actions even in one minute. We give rise rise to so many thoughts not to put it so many thoughts arise in our mind stream so many intentions arise in our mind streams so all these thoughts are karma so we’re generating a lot of karma.

Freedom liberation is this liberation is freedom from bondage, from the bondage of contaminated actions and conception. So as for as for actions, karma, we have this general division of of three. It fall it falls into under three categories. So virtuous actions, non virtuous actions, and neutral actions. And so Geshe was explaining the So Geshe is of these three, the main thing that we have to free ourselves from is negative actions.

So non virtuous actions. But, also with regards even to virtuous actions, have we can categorize them subdivide these two subdivide virtuous actions in two. We have contaminated virtuous actions, and we have non contaminated virtuous actions. So so again, this contaminated virtuous actions, also, we have to free ourselves from them. So we have to free ourselves from both contaminated virtuous actions and non virtuous actions.

And in their place, have to cultivate uncontaminated virtuous actions. And so we have so we have bondage, which is actions and afflictive emotion conceptions and afflictions. So we have gone through what actions are, and then we have these afflictions. And afflictions as far as afflictions in general, we have these six root afflictions, and we have other twenty or so secondary afflictions and the combination of of them. So we have many, very many different afflictions, and we have to free ourselves from both, again, these actions and these afflictions.

Okay. So so Geshe wants to stop here. Geshe wants to stop here today, and we have time for Here. So, yeah, do you have any questions? Yes?

Virtue which is produced by a being a noble being who has directly realized emptiness is uncontaminated. And and other than that, the virtue of ordinary beings such as ourselves is said to be contaminated. Okay? So, I mean, is it sort of like if those actions are virtuous, but they’re they’re based on a self interest or self? So you could have virtuous actions, but are still self motivated.

Is that the sort of contaminated virtue contaminated virtue a contaminated virtuous virtuous actions that you’re talking about? So, basically, an uncontaminated uncontaminated virtuous action is an action which is informed by realization of emptiness. So in in a contaminated virtuous action then is not informed by that is is a a a an action which is informed by a a grasping at true existence of phenomena, a grasping at at self grasping informed by self grasping, by grasping at an inherent existence self and inherent existence phenomena. Yeah. And so even though this they are virtuous actions and they do the results results of these actions are is happiness.

That happiness is not lasting happiness. It’s not reliable. Is that okay? Good. That’s good.

Something in that line where it says the first four perfections accomplish the highest status of excellent body, possessions and undertakings. Does that mean that each, you know, individual perfection relates to each one listed in order? I perfection of generosity equals excellent body and perfection of patient What is this? Possession and consult. It’s just It’s on the last page of the third book.

Last page of the third book. Yes. So generally speaking, in dependence on the perfection of generosity one accomplishes all the wealth and material possessions and enjoyments. in dependence on the perfection of morality, then one attains the body. in dependence on the perfection.

In the in the perfection of with the perfection of patience, how do they translate that? So one one obtains all this is referred to as the retinue or or all the surroundings also. And then they sort of superimpose each other so with patience also one attains a a beautiful countenance or a handsome countenance. One one is handsome. One is beautiful, you know, and and healthy.

The body is good and so forth. But also and then in in the perfection of, joyous perseverance was referred to as the undertakings. So all these undertakings are attained. Is that okay? That was the only other thing I was gonna query was what does undertakings mean in this context?

So, basically, without without joyous perseverance, without joyous effort, all the other perfections do not come about. One cannot accomplish the other perfection. One cannot accomplish the perfection with generosity, patience, and morality. And so it sort of is a foundation for all of those perfections and the results also. So but all all one’s endeavors, so to speak, are accomplished, are realized.

Yes. So, yes, one can create negativities through oneself by committing suicide, one is killing a sentient being. You know, if you get angry to with yourself, you know, you’re getting angry. And so and and oneself, you know, I speak for myself. In this case, you know, I am a sentient being.

I’m not a Buddha. But I fall under the category of of being a sentient being. So if I perform a negative action source myself, I’m I’m developing negativities in relation to sentient beings. Okay? Is that okay?

Any more questions? Yes? So and and I I So is is that collective collective karma so basically Geshe-la was saying at first Geshe-la was saying so every every good experience and every bad experience that we have is a result of karma that has been accumulated. And yet those beings have all accumulated actions of which the result is that experience of being of dying in the circumstance that they are dying in the fire and all that. Okay?

Okay. You want to ask another question? Just Yeah. That is the case. Yes.

And if we do not purify, we will experience it eventually. And, Geshe-la was gonna say, we we do not like to hear that. We do not like to hear that we are going to experience such things because we we do not want to we’re not pleased by the idea of experiencing such suffering loss. In purification because we are going to experience because we have accumulated karma since time immemorial. There is is we have accumulated all sorts of karma, all sorts of actions since time immemorial.

And we will experience all of it if we do not purify eventually. So we but we do not understand that. We do not know that because of our ignorance. Because of ignorance, we we do not understand that. And that’s And and and this ignorance keeps us I’ll say ignorance is bliss because it keeps us by keeping us unaware of it, it keeps us also keeps us oblivious to it in this, in in a sense.

If if we were to fully understand this fact, this reality, we wouldn’t be able to remain at ease as we do completely oblivious to these facts. We wouldn’t be able to remain in this without any fear. We will actually be really scared and and moved by it. So, Geshe-la was saying, so ignorance is isn’t isn’t ignorance beneficial for us? Geshe-la was going to say.

Because it it’s it keeps us from seeing that, that reality. Isn’t isn’t it beneficial, Geshe-la is asking you? Isn’t ignorance Isn’t it beneficial? Isn’t ignorance beneficial to us? It’s hard to say, well, how is it that it’s not beneficial?

If if we if we were to contemplate the reality that we have contemplated, we have engaged in so many negativities, and we’re gonna we’re gonna have to engage to experience so many suffering results. Isn’t that scary? Yes. So so that ignorance keeps us from that fear, keeps us away from that fear. So it is beneficial, isn’t it?

So those were rhetorical questions by the way so no there’s no benefit to it because by not seeing those facts then we will keep on engaging those actions and we’ll keep on accumulating more and more of that by seeing by seeing those facts and on the other hand by understanding by gaining this understanding and we’ll be able to have the necessary motivation to purify all those negatives that we have performed in the past and to restrain ourselves from engaging any more negativities in the future. So our our not seeing, our not understanding that reality is only harmful to us. So ignorance is harmful. There’s no benefit to it. Oh, yeah.

Just a question. Does the realization of emptiness make it easier or make it more able make it easier to face suffering when there’s a realization of emptiness? So there’s no there’s less there’s less need to be ignorant of suffering or just need to push it away. So my question is, is suffering is emptiness important or the realization of emptiness to be able to face our fears and face the the suffering in the world knowing that there’s no or, you know, there’s no well, straight well, first first, there’s no self at stake. Few.

Right? Yes. I would just I would just stop you there. Just a minute. So I just I was just you I was just I just stopped you because I know you’re you’re you’re very new here.

And I was just asking you actually to explain some fundamental, some basic some more basic things. So ignorance basically is a not knowing. Yeah. So that’s what we refer to as ignorance. And and what is it that we do not know here is the way that phenomenon exists.

So I guess I wanna say, so there are many things that we do not know. For example, when we are children, we do not know the alphabet. Yeah. So we do not know what a, c is. But later, we study and we gain that knowledge, and then we know what the alphabet is, what a, b, c is.

So so we have this this not knowing, this ignorance with regards to the alphabet or a b c, then we study and we learn a b c, so we gain the wisdom that knows a b and c and so forth. The wisdom that knows a, the wisdom that knows b and so forth. So we have, again, in in in in, you know, to more ultimate sense, we have this ignorance that does not know the way that phenomena exist, that does not know about the emptiness of phenomena. Yeah. And then and that’s what we are trying to realize to realize in which way do phenomena exist.

So we do not know if phenomena do exist or don’t exist. But as it is, we think that phenomena do exist inherently whilst in actuality, it doesn’t. So So Geshe-la is explaining. So we we have this this fundamental ignorance. So so take for example, the the self, I, me, mine.

So we take this I and we think, oh, I exist. I exist. I exist. Exist inherently and so forth. We have this conviction.

And and so and we hold on we grasp on this notion that I exist inherent, that I truly exist, and so forth. Whilst, obviously, we do not actually exist. So we are ignorant of the way that the self exists. So again the self does not exist in the way that appears to exist. It appears to exist as an independent entity, a truly existent entity, an inherent existing entity but it is empty of existing in that way it does not exist in that way so when we say that it is empty or it doesn’t exist in that way it’s not that it doesn’t exist altogether it does exist it exists as it exists as an a dependent origination it exists as a mere imputation of of concept and word and so forth.

So it does exist. And so, again, we are but we do not know that. So we’re also ignorant of that in which way it exists. So so and and and so again, this self which appears to exist inherently, which appears to exist in the way that appears to exist, does not exist as such. Geshe-la was saying so if you search, if you are in if you have an an analytical mind, an investigative mind that is searching for the self, you will not find anything.

So you say it doesn’t exist. It doesn’t exist in the way that it it appears to exist. And on the other hand, when you’re not searching for it, when you’re not analyzing in which way it exists, you’re investigating it, then it appears. And that’s what we refer to when we’re talking about it. It it doesn’t exist.

It is empty of that existence, but but we it has conventional existence. So that’s what we’re referring to as the relative conventional existence. So for that mind which is not analyzing, which is not investigating, then it appears conventionally. It exists conventionally. It exists in relatively.

And and so then when one realizes that one has developed the realization of emptiness, what what is called what is referred to as the realization of emptiness. One has developed the wisdom that realizes emptiness. Having developed that one has then eradicated the root of all the other afflictive emotions and conceptions. And in this way, one has eradicated the causes of suffering. Do do you do you get Yes.

What we what we’re we’re going to? So Yes. Ignorance is a what causes suffering is the, you know, the root of every suffering. That’s the root of every afflictive emotion conception. And so eradicating that ignorance, you have that knowledge that phenomena do not exist in the way they appear to exist, that they are all lacking in existence.

And by that wisdom, the knows that by that knowledge, you are free of all the afflictive emotion conceptions which arise out of ignorance. Then you are you are free from suffering. I I think my question was more regards to this. It took I guess she talked about karma and and the this this suffering that hasn’t ripened for us in terms of lots more suffering to come that hasn’t ripened for us. And he’s talked about ignorance and we’re not thinking.

So so facing this this suffering and not being or facing the reality of it. My question was is what’s what is the best way to was to face face it rather than to turn away and be ignorant of it? Or so it was more of a a strength question or a motivation question. But that’s yeah. That was so it was my question was is that if we realize the real nature, we will have greater strength in facing the problems that we see or or the the suffering that we see?

Is that am I sort of going So if you if you realize emptiness, if you realize the way the phenomenon exists, then you realize that everything lacks inherent existence. Whatever is arising, lacks inherent existence. And if that is the case, then there is no suffering that is going to come out of that. There is no worry, no fear Yeah. And no concerns out of that.

And that was that was the mind. Yeah. That’s what I wanted to get across. Right? So you you will not be biased in your relationship with phenomena, whatever phenomena is arising anymore.

You will not be biased anymore, have preference for have attachment towards some and aversion towards others. You realize that all phenomena equally empty or lack inherent existence equally. This

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva vows chang sem dom pa (Tib)
The vows taken when one enters the bodhisattva path. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
four maras du zhi (Tib)
The four external and internal hindrances or obstacles to our spiritual progress. LYWA
four opponent powers nyenpo tob zhi (Tib)
The four practices used to purify nonvirtuous imprints on the mindstream. LYWA
four powers
The four types of attainments often described in tantric initiations. They are: pacification (of delusions), increase (of realizations), control (of whatever needs controlling) and subduing (of negative forces). LYWA
rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is contaminated virtue? Is it virtuous action that is still motivated by self-interest?

An uncontaminated virtuous action is one informed by the realization of emptiness. A contaminated virtuous action is not informed by that realization. It is informed by grasping at the true existence of phenomena, that is, by self-grasping: grasping at an inherently existent self and inherently existent phenomena. Even so, these are still virtuous actions, and their results are happiness. But that happiness is not lasting happiness, and it is not reliable.

Does each of the first four perfections correspond in order to one of the results: excellent body, possessions and undertakings?

Generally, yes, though the correspondence overlaps. The perfection of generosity brings wealth, material possessions and enjoyments. The perfection of morality brings the body. Patience brings a good retinue, or surroundings, and because the results are superimposed on each other, patience also brings a beautiful or handsome countenance, and a good, healthy body. The perfection of joyous perseverance brings the undertakings, so that all one's undertakings are accomplished.

If we realize the real nature of things, will we have greater strength to face the problems and suffering we see rather than turning away?

Realizing emptiness means realizing the way phenomena exist: everything lacks inherent existence, whatever is arising. When this is realized, no suffering comes out of it, and there is no worry, fear or concern. One is also no longer biased in relating to whatever phenomena arise. There is no preference or attachment towards some and aversion towards others, because all phenomena are seen as equally empty, equally lacking inherent existence.

Scroll to Top