Letter to a Friend — 2005-02-01

45 min · 3,597 words · 1 February 2005 · Buddha House Adelaide

Letter to a Friend (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Letter to a Friend (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Letter to a Friend — 2005-02-01
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 46-minute commentary, Geshe Pema Tsering works through Nāgārjuna’s verse “Form is not the self” from the Letter to a Friend, examining why a self cannot be located in any of the five aggregates. He offers three arguments: the body is plural while the self is experienced as singular; a “self” is categorically distinct from both mind and matter; and form is impermanent while a true self must be constant. He applies the same logic to feelings, discrimination, and consciousness, then turns to how the aggregates actually arise — not from will, primordial substance, or a creator God, but from ignorance, karma, and grasping. The commentary closes with a vivid image: karmic potential is the seed, and grasping at solid existence is the water that makes it germinate.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 23 LF 2005 02 01.mp3

UUID: 2a07d072-bf37-4128-b39d-813f1d8b4310

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Letter to a Friend (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2005-02-01

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45.6 minutes

Words: ~3,592

We are up to the section on the meditation of the path that is unworldly from Nāgārjuna’s letter to a friend. Geshe-la said that before we start the teaching please develop the right motivation for listening to the teaching so please understand and please reflect on the four reasons for listening to the teachings, the best reason for listening to the teachings being that it will act as a cause for us to achieve enlightenment in order to lead all sentient beings into the same state. And then, we should also remember that it’s not just the motivation that we need to focus on. We need to focus on the motivation, we need to focus on the actual act, and we need to dedicate our actions properly. So if we first of all think about why we’re doing it, then concentrate during teaching and then after the teaching dedicate the positive merit that we have developed in the teachings to the goal that we set out to achieve.

So the way we can develop the best motivation is the motivation to attain enlightenment in order to lead all sentient beings to that state. If we are unable to develop this motivation, then we should try and develop the motivation that we are listening to the teachings in order to liberate ourselves from saṃsāra and attain nirvana. If we are unable to develop that motivation, we should try and develop the motivation or that we are listening to the teachings in order to attain a positive rebirth in our future lives, positive rebirth of a god or a human. So if we listen to the teachings with this motivation, with any three of these motivations then our listening becomes the practice of Dharma and it becomes the practice of good Dharma so we should at least develop the least of these motivations. So in order for us to develop this idea to have cultivated this understanding of working towards a liberation for the benefit of all sentient beings.

In order that we have this as our motivation for doing any of the hard work that we need to do in order to reach that state, then we need to understand why we would want to do that. We need to have a reason for doing this. We need to have an insight into what it is that we’re actually going to achieve by leading sentient beings to Buddhahood. Now, the place that we should start to develop this understanding, first place that we should look in order to develop this understanding is to ourselves and to our own experience of suffering. Because the reason we want all sentient beings to reach Buddhahood is because we want all sentient beings to be liberated from suffering.

And if we want to know their experience of suffering, then we can look to our own experience of suffering as an example. If we understand our own experience of suffering, then it’s easy for us to extrapolate that out to all other sentient beings. If we don’t understand our own experience of suffering, then it is difficult for us to understand others’ experience of suffering. So the first thing we need to develop an understanding of and insight into is our own reality, our experience, and how it is by its nature’s suffering. So having reflected on this, we should think, in order to liberate all sentient beings from this suffering, in order to establish them in a state of happiness, in order to bring happiness to all sentient beings, Then we’re going to listen to these teachings, we’re going to develop understanding based on these and progress towards Buddhahood.

And it’s especially important, and something I’ve got to say earlier, it’s especially important to develop this motivation today as it’s the first teachings that we’re having this year. First of all, the text that we are going through is called Nāgārjuna’s letter to a friend. And within Nāgārjuna’s letter to a friend, we are up to the stage where he describes the view or the path in order to, first of all, develop an understanding of what’s called the way the world works or worldly activity and then what’s called transmundane or non worldly activity. Now, in terms of non worldly activity, we’re talking about that which leads us out of saṃsāra. So the worldly activity is the way that saṃsāra works, and what leads us out of saṃsāra is the view of emptiness.

So if they are talking about transmundane experiences or non worldly experiences or whatever, it means something outside of saṃsāra, something that leads to a state outside of saṃsāra. It is talking about a view that is developed by Aryas who have or supreme beings who have perceived the nature of reality and therefore don’t suffer because they’ve because of a misperception of reality. So we’re up to the state within this which is called recollecting selflessness or meditating on selflessness. So in general, when we talk about emptiness, we talk about the emptiness of two different things. The emptiness of subject and the emptiness of object, the emptiness of self, of persons, the individual, and the emptiness of objects, or the emptiness of phenomena, the emptiness of an inherent independent self, a person — an ātman of person and an ātman of objects.

I’m trying to think of a way because self confuses people. A solid, reified thing that we think is us. So we’re talking about how that doesn’t exist. In this verse Nāgārjuna said, It was declared that form is not the self, and the self does not possess form or is not seated in form form is not seated in the self or is not possessed by the self. Understanding the remaining four aggregates as similarly empty.

So the form is the grossest of the aggregates or the collections of things that make up our idea of self. And it’s saying that this form, our physical form, doesn’t make up a self. We can’t find an I in a physical form. We can terminologically designate this physical form that we have as I, this is me, we can say this is me and from this relative or this conceptual perspective there is a sense of I. We do experience a sense of I but that I isn’t something that we can say is inherently existent or is able to exist from its own side without the label.

In this way it doesn’t inherently exist, it doesn’t exist in any real solid way, but the term ‘I’ or the way we perceive ourselves as ‘I’ does exist. In the next verse, Nāgārjuna exhorts the king to understand that the aggregates do not arise at random, that is, that they don’t arise with no cause, sorry, don’t arise for no reason, they don’t arise from time, they don’t come about just because time exists, they don’t come about from some kind of a primordial substance or their own nature, they don’t come about from their own essence or their own entity and they don’t come about because a God that existed before them created them, They also don’t come about without a cause. So what the cause of the aggregates, what’s the cause of our experience is, first of all, ignorance, karma and desire or the urge to exist. So Nāgārjuna says that the king should understand this. So in brief it means that our experience, form, consciousness, our form and consciousness, our mind and body come about through afflictive emotions and the karma that we create through afflictive emotions and the result of this is our experience that we have in Samsāra.

So the cause isn’t anything other than that, than those two things. Okay, so the meaning of these verses, if we go to the description of their meaning, it says that, first of all, from a sūtra that, it was declared that form is not self, self does not possess form. Now the reason, the main reason that it’s given that form is not self and self is not form is that form is not one thing. Our physical form isn’t one singular entity. Our physical form is made up of different types of form.

We have different parts to our body. We have different substances within our body. So if we’re going to say that our physical being was our self, was the thing that made us into a solid, into an unchanging, everlasting entity, solid doesn’t work there, anyway, then we would have to say that there are many selves as well, for every cells as well, for every part of the body, for every substance in the body, we would have to posit a different self and as we don’t experience our self as being plural then we can’t posit the self of we can’t say self that is form exists. So our form cannot be our self because our form is many and the way we experience self is as one. So in this way there is no self in form.

Okay, so there’s one reason that the body can’t be the self, as we understand self. The next reason is that we the self isn’t by its nature or its entity form. It because self is a Because a self is a non associated compositional factor and form is form and form and non associated compositional factors are non compatible or don’t have any overlapping characteristics, then the self cannot be form and the form can’t be self. Okay, so was like, Geshe-la, I’m not sure they know what a non-associated compositional factor is. And he said, well, a non-associated compositional factor is something that is neither mind in that it isn’t consciousness.

It isn’t a feeling. It isn’t a discrimination between this or that, and it isn’t form. Alright? So it’s something that’s neither of these things. For example, time and a self or a person is an unassociated compositional factor, so it’s still composed of other things, but it’s not associated with either mind or physical form.

In Buddhist logic or in Buddhist it’s actually in this group of texts called the Abhidharma, which is like the way that the world and consciousness is separated. They separate all phenomena into one of three things. You can either have mind, you can either be body, or you can either be a non associated compositional factor. A form, mind, a non associated compositional factor. Now, non associated means not associated with mind and it’s not associated with body, alright?

Hence, we have all these three things. The first argument that was put forward was that body cannot be our physical form cannot be ourselves because our physical form is many and the self is one, so therefore they’re incompatible that way. The second argument is put forward is that self cannot be physical because one is non associated compositional factor and the other is form, and these two things are mutually exclusive. Okay? Second argument why self can’t be body.

The other thing is that self can’t be physical form because of its nature, because it doesn’t abide. That is to say, if the self was our physical being inherently or without distinction, then it would always abide as a single unit. That isn’t the way that our body exists, that isn’t the way our physical form exists, so therefore by nature form can’t be the self either. Okay, so another reason that self can’t be by nature our physical form is that there are physical forms that we don’t consider to be our self, like external forms. We could define ourselves as a physical form, why is it a certain physical form and not other physical forms?

Therefore, because we can define physical objects or physical forms as saying they are not self, then this is another reason why we can’t say that the nature of a self or the nature of an ātman is form. So we can’t find the self of a person in a physical form because physical form isn’t something that abides. Our physical form is constantly changing, and not only our physical form but the external objects that we would have to posit as self if we were saying self whose physical form also come about or are generated and destroyed. So, our physical body is generated and destroyed and it goes through much transformation, and for us to say that our physical self was ourselves, we would have to have something that is constantly abiding because our sense of self or our idea of a self is something that is a permanent, something that is a constant. So that doesn’t work.

And it’s also true of the other aggregates that make up a person, that make up a being, so, for example, our feelings. We can’t say we are our feelings because for the same reasons our feelings are multiplicitous, I can’t get it out. Lots of them. We have lots of feelings, so if we are going to define ourselves by our feelings then we have to pick a feeling, or we have to say there are many selves if there are many feelings. There is also the idea that feelings are not the same thing as a self because a self is a non-associated compositional factor and a feeling is a feeling.

Therefore, it doesn’t work for feelings. It doesn’t work for discrimination either, because there are many different forms of discrimination, and there are thoughts, or for consciousness or for compositional factors. If there’s something that’s plural and the self is singular, then we can’t find our true self in any of our aggregates or any of the collections of things that make us up. If it doesn’t work in terms of its entity, doesn’t work in terms of its nature, it doesn’t work in terms of its number, then we can’t find a self anywhere. We should go over this idea again and again and again until we stop clinging to the idea of self.

Mhmm. So this this then we need to look at what this means for the aggregates. The thing that they’ve translated is they do not arise at random seems to be a bit weird as a translation, because I guess what’s explaining it is that they don’t come about because we want them to. They don’t come about by our will. It’s not as if we can say, I’ll have this form and this consciousness and this and these feelings, and then they come about because of that.

Alright? So the the aggregates don’t come about at will they don’t come about because we want them to come about. This is the first thing that we need to recognize when we’re establishing the nature of the aggregates or the way that they are. Don’t abide permanently they don’t come about because they’ve been around forever. It’s not as if our physical form or our feelings or our or our perception of objects is something that has always abided and has always existed and, therefore, will continue to exist.

We can’t say that the aggregates come about because of time or through permanence. They don’t come about naturally, as in they don’t appear by themselves, as it here, from a primordial substance. They don’t come about by their nature, not as if they can naturally establish themselves and exist in that way. They don’t come about because of their entity either or their essence. They have an essence, but their essence is emptiness.

We can’t say that their essence is established their nature or their essence is empty of inherent existence their nature is not something that is truly established. Because we say that they’re essenceless, Okay. So Okay. So there’s this word that is usually translated as as entity, and there’s this philosophical school, which is the Mādhyamika that is sometimes described as the school that says things are entity less. So they’re the school of entitylessness, which is very clumsy English, but anyway.

What means is, what it’s talking about when it talks about this entity or the lack of an entity, entity is if something has an entity or something has an essence or a nature that is its own doing, it means that it doesn’t come into being based on causes and conditions. It abides because of its own ability. So an entity is something this very specific instance. An entity is something that has the ability to self exist. Other words that are used to describe this is also a nature or a or an or an inherent existence.

Alright? So if something is inherently existent or if something is is its own entity or something has it it abides by its own nature or from its own side, What this means is that it can bring itself into existence. It doesn’t come into existence because causes and conditions have come together, and therefore it comes about. It comes into existence by its own power. Now, if something’s going to come into existence by its own power, it means that it can abide by itself and doesn’t necessarily come to the stage where it disintegrates or it is destroyed.

Something comes into its own entity, it comes into existence by its own entity. It doesn’t ever disappear. If we’re saying something has an entity or it has an inherent existence, it means that this is the way that we view the world, that things come into existence by themselves, and we don’t think of everything. We don’t naturally react with everything as if everything is only existent because of causes and conditions. Okay.

So the next thing that it says isn’t the cause for reality or isn’t the cause for our experience of reality through our aggregates is a god. Now the god that they’ve put here is Īśvara, a literal translation of it is Tib. wangchuk, Īśvara. In Sanskrit, it’s generic term for god, but it’s also used sometimes to refer to the creator aspect of Brahman. It’s talking about the one Hindu version of the creation of our existence. Now, problem with positing our creator God as being the source of our experiences is that we have to say then that they are responsible for all our suffering.

If someone was able to make us what we are, why would they make us suffer? Why would they make being suffer? Why would that why if they were had their if they were omnipotent and had the ability to make us any way they wanted to, why would they have created beings who suffer in such diverse and different ways? It’s problematic saying that our reality, our existence, comes about based on the creation, or it comes about through the creation through creation by a god because it means we have to blame them for all the bad bits. The other thing that we can’t say is that things come about without a cause.

If something comes about without a cause, what then it has to either fall into it has to be something that exists forever or something that never existed. If there’s no cause for something, a causelessness phenomena either has to not exist, or it has to be able to abide forever. If there’s no cause for something to come into existence, it has to have always been there, or it cannot come into existence. Because it falls into these two extremes, then we have to say that it’s not possible for things to come into existence without causes. So if if our existence, if our collections that make up our being don’t come about from any of these things, then it says, Where do they come from?

The last line of this verse explains how they come about, and it says, The first thing is from not knowing or from ignorance, so from ignorance about the way reality is. So Instead of looking at the way reality is, we interact with the way reality appears, and this appears to us. This is a form of ignorance, of grasping at things as being inherently or solidly, permanently existing. This ignorance, this confusion, causes us to create karma or to perform actions. Through these actions, these actions result in the experience we have in this form.

It says that the result of this action coming about is brought on by what is called the moisture of grasping, or the moisture of desire or attachment. So what this means is that the karmic action that’s a tautology. The karma that we have performed in the past resides its imprints or its echo or its potential abides in our mind stream or is accumulated in our mind stream. Then, through a condition of grasping, of holding onto reality, of holding onto this solid existence, we end up experiencing the aggregates as we do. It has a This grasping onto existence, or grasping in general, has a similar effect as water does when we are trying to plant a seed.

Karmic potential is like a seed, and our grasping onto inherent reality is like the water that we pour onto the seed. If we don’t have any water to pour onto a seed, the seed doesn’t grow. In the same way, the karmic potential needs the condition of grasping in order for that predisposition to ripen in the form of our physical and mental being.

Key terms in this teaching

atman dag (Tib)
Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

What is a non-associated compositional factor in Buddhist philosophy?

A non-associated compositional factor is something that is neither mind nor form. It is not consciousness, it is not a feeling, it is not a discrimination between this or that, and it is not form. Examples are time and a self or a person. Such things are still composed of other things, but they are not associated with either mind or physical form.

Scroll to Top