1 h 35 min · 6,568 words · 11 September 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 95-minute Lamrim session, Geshe Pema Tsering makes a striking claim: practitioners at our level benefit more from the similitudes of the Three Jewels — our ordinary lama, our studies, our fellow practitioners — than from the actual Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, because the actual jewels lie beyond our current reach. He grounds this in the two causes of refuge (fear of samsaric suffering and conviction in the Three Jewels), then identifies the true Dharma jewel with true cessations and the realization of emptiness, walking through how one progresses across the paths of seeing and meditation by incrementally uprooting objects of abandonment. A Q&A section addresses what true cessation means in practice, whether bodhicitta is required for Sangha jewel status, and how hearers and solitary realizers differ in what they realize according to the Mind Only school.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 32 2008 09 11 BP.mp3
UUID: f9f76be6-7faa-4126-a9a4-92fb89364004
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2008-09-11
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 95.4 minutes
Words: ~6,557
So, again, Geshe is instructing us to give rise to good motivation and with the intention of establishing all sentient beings in the state of enlightenment, then we are going to study to listen to the teachings on the stages of the path and then practicing practice according to the teachings on the stages of the path. And this way, we give us proper motivation. And then with the wish that we find a a cheap, comfortable, sizable house for Buddha house. And, again, we we recite the Heart Sūtra. Cheap.
Yes. Last, the insistence insistent advice to achieve certainty with regards to the Three Jewels, but that would be our topic. We have been discussing the Three Jewels of refuge and the developing certainty with regards to Three Jewels. Again, I guess I was going to the text. Therefore, think about sorry.
Think about the Buddha’s positive qualities again and again. And Geshe-la was pointing out that we have been going through these qualities already. So when we think about those positive qualities again and again and strive to achieve as much certainty as possible. If it develops, you have reached the main point of going for refuge. Because a similar certainty will come with respect to the Dharma that arose from him and the Sangha of those who accomplished that Dharma.
Without it, there is no way that going for refuge, a tamed mind, let alone other paths, will will come either. And the basic point, Geshe-la says, again, if we do not have the mind of refuge, then the other paths will not develop. So we need the mind of refuge in order to be able to develop the other paths. Explaining again the heart, the essence of refuge are the two causes of refuge which is then the fear of the sufferings of cyclic existence and suffering of the lower realms of existence. And then and then the the conviction that the Jewels of refuge, the Three Jewels of refuge, the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha, of the qualities are able or capable of of providing refuge from these sufferings.
And so, again, it’s very important that we understand the qualities of the Three Jewels and we have been going for the qualities of the Buddha and we’re going for the other two Jewels following, the Dharma and the Sangha, the Dharma and the Sangha so that we can develop that conviction, that certainty that they can protect us, they can they can provide the refuge for us. So this is saying, again, with regards to the to the essence, the very heart of of refuge, developing that having that fear, then developing the certainty, the conviction that the Jewels can can provide the refuge. And Geshe-la was making reference, with expression, to a particular kind of faith. We’re talking about the faith of conviction. Again, the faith when one needs to have the faith of conviction in the Three Jewels, that the the Three Jewels can provide this refuge.
And in order to develop this faith of conviction, these teachings that we are going through are given to us. So we we approach the positive qualities of the Dharma, I guess I was going through the text. On account of your respect for the Buddha, you should be mindful, thinking of the fact that the Buddha has limitless positive qualities arose from manifesting and meditating the Dharma of scriptures and realization through veneration and true paths at the epitome of the abandonment of faults and the achievement of positive qualities. And Geshe lah is explaining that, you know, the the the Buddha has attained all the the great qualities, the limitless qualities that the Buddha has because of practicing the Dharma jewel, because of practicing the true paths and accomplishing the true cessation. So by practicing the true paths, the Buddha has accomplished the true cessation and the ultimate the ultimate end of the the true paths and the true cessation is is enlightenment itself.
And again and those again who help oneself along this path to enlightenment are the Sangha jewel. So Geshe lah was explaining with regards with regards to the true paths and the true cessations which are which are the true Dharma jewel, the actual Dharma jewel are the true paths and true cessation. And again, I wasn’t saying this is something that we do not presently have in our mind streams, true path and true cessation. And when we finally can eradicate one thought so that it doesn’t ever arise again in our minds, then we have that is to say we have attained a cessation. Geshe was explaining so right now because of our we are overwhelmed by this ignorance that does not perceive the actual nature of reality, the actual nature of phenomena and Geshe-la was explaining so by the force of that all our minds are our wrong minds, wrong consciousness.
So we need to attain a realization of emptiness in order to correct that, in order that we can eradicate that ignorance. And Geshe-la was saying in order to And so and by meditating by meditating on emptiness, then we when we eventually are able to rid ourselves of one object of abandonment through through that meditation, because we need the realization of emptiness to to eradicate it from from the very root of completely uprooted. And, again, when we have when we have accomplished that and that object of abandonment cannot arise anymore, then we have attained a cessation. And Geshe-la was saying, so again, I was explaining the etymology of the word gokpa. Gopa, which is translated as cessation here, and then denpa, which is translated as true or truth.
So then the true cessation. And gopa, the cessation, is when we when we stop, when we arrest, and when a a object of of abandonment from arising, when when the object of abandonment ceases to arise for good. And then and the true paths, again, the true paths, which Geshe-la says, the true paths here are is the the realization of emptiness itself. The mind realizes emptiness itself. So then for the true paths, we develop the cessation of each and every object of abandonment.
By the force of realizing the true paths, when we cease or when we arrest or when we stop one object of abandonment and we have attained one cessation and then through and when and we go on eradicating or ceasing. So I’m not sure if this is very good grammar, but ceasing, so to speak, each and every object of abandonment and we’re going we’re going we’re going in this way attaining developing these different cessations. Okay? So, again, Geshe-la was going through the whole thing again. So for the true paths, we attain the true cessation.
And, again, Geshe-la was explaining it because we do not have the true path, because we do not have this realization of emptiness, which are the which is the true path. Again, and we also don’t have any true cessation, so we do not have the actual Dharma jewel within our mental continuums. And, again, we are not the actual sangha jewel because of that. Because the actual sangha jewel are those who have true path and true cessation. So someone who has in the path path of seeing, have please correct me if I’m wrong.
Have the uninterrupted path of seeing. Right? And then when someone which is the first. Right? It comes first.
First, we have the uninterrupted path of seeing. And then when when one fruit that attains the the what’s the the the right English? The release path of seeing of release? No. On path of release or the path of seeing.
Yeah. The path of release. And when when the after after that unobstructed path of the path of seeing, then one attains the path of release of the path of seeing. And then when when one has attained the path of release, it means one has attained a cessation. When actual actual realization of emptiness and one has attained a cessation.
And then every being from from that point upwards is a a is a and is is counted as a Is that okay? Is that is that yep. And I forgot to mention I’m gonna add add in, but Krishna was gonna say, so we need then what we need to do then is attain realize emptiness. That’s all we need to do. Geshe-la said previously that we do not have any we do not a realization of emptiness.
We do have a direct realization of emptiness. We do not do not even have a realization of emptiness by means of an inferential sorry. By means of a meaning generality, by a general concept conceptual image. So and so we need to realize emptiness. And in order to realize emptiness, we need to study.
We need to study a lot. We need to go through a lot of reasonings in order to ascertain the meaning of emptiness. And then when when when we have ascertained that, when we have consolidated ascertainment, when we we develop a realization of emptiness by means of a meaning generality or generic conceptual image and then again we we keep on meditating on that meaning generality, the generic conceptual image time and again until we develop a direct realization of emptiness and when we have we have accomplished that, then we become then from by then from that moment onwards, we are the the sangha jewel. We are sangha jewel. Saying, so so we need we need to realize emptiness, and we need then in order to realize emptiness, we need to engage in a lot of study and contemplation, reflection upon upon those teachings.
But then Geshe-la was saying, that alone will will not not be enough. We need we need to to develop, how to say, something that is gonna help to to increment the potency of that realization. We need we need to accumulate to accumulate merit. We need to engage in the collection of of merit. So and that is to say, if I was as I say, that the collection of merit is going to give us a power or develop as a make it easy for us to realize emptiness.
Is it gonna help our realization of emptiness? So we need to accumulate merit. In order to accumulate merit, what we have is is to what we do to cultivate this collection of merit is we cultivate bodhicitta. We cultivate we we develop how to say? Develop how to say?
We take joy. We rejoice. We rejoice, and we cultivate in, you know, love and kindness, compassion, and so forth. So again, we need again, we need to engage in this accumulation of merit. So that that is to say, we need to cultivate bodhicitta.
And if we if we cultivate bodhicitta and then together with that, we cultivate our understanding, our realization of emptiness, then eventually, we we go on purifying our minds and make our realization more stronger and and clear until eventually we develop an inferential cognition of emptiness. Then we we we continue then we start placing our minds continually on on that inferential cognition until we develop a direct realization of emptiness. And then when we have developed that direct realization of emptiness, we become then ārya beings. We become the real sangha jewel. And in this way, you know, soon it’s hard.
I was gonna say it’s hard even to talk in terms of moments. There are many different moments after the realization of emptiness, but then when when when as soon one develops for the of emptiness, one one then gets rid or ceases or puts an end to a a object of abandonment. And then from then on, one keeps on practicing this way. So and then when when and let me put it in a specific way because I was inputting a very specific way. So one is meditating on emptiness.
And one has a one is engaging one is going through what is the the uninterrupted path of the path of seeing. Seeing. And one one then one one then develops when one attains a cessation that coincides with the attainment of the path of release. One has attained the path of release or the path of seeing. And then one and then that is the very moment when one becomes an idea of being, a noble being.
This one. And then when when one has attained that path of release of the path of seeing, then one has attained one has one has abandoned the object of abandonment ment of the path of seeing. And then and then so then one has attained one’s one’s first cessation. And then the and that’s then marks again the the attainment of becoming not being so forth. And this gets very technical, but this is nice.
It’s a nice topic in your head. So Geshe-la was gonna say, so one has then attained the path of release of the path of seeing. That means one has attained the cessation of the object of abandonment of the path of seeing. So then again, one is again an ārya being, one is a true Sangha, whatever whatever way you want to have it. If one then keeps on cultivating the realization of emptiness, one keeps on accumulating merits and we’re creating one’s collection of merit.
Then one will eventually start developing a capacity with the realization of emptiness to harm the next object of abandonment in the path of meditation. And we are in the path of meditation. In the path of meditation, have nine different objects of abandonment or stages of of of abandonment. And each one we have three major ones, the the the, how can I say, the great, the middling, and the smaller? Or and then each one of these has, again, has three great, middling, and small.
So when we develop if we continue meditating on emptiness in that way, then we are going to develop the uninterrupted path when we start then harming that object of abandonment of the the path of of the the great great path of meditation. Then again, we we are we are then developing cultivating that the uninterrupted path of the path of of meditation, of the great great path of meditation. Is that is that more or how it goes? And then pardon? Small small.
Small small. Oh, okay. The small small. Sorry. The other way around.
Upside down. The small small. And then when one finally puts an end to that of abandonment of the small small path of meditation. Sorry. What was what?
Say that again? The small, small path The small, small path of meditation. To great. To the great, great object of abandonment. Yes.
Thank you for that. So one one then develops the path of release of the small, small path of meditation, which then rids oneself of the great, great object of abandonment of the path of meditation. One. Yeah. And then when finally, Geshe-la was saying when so we started with the the great great object of abandonment.
Right? Of the path of meditation. And Geshe-la was saying when we finally are able to rid ourselves of the small small object of abandonment of the path of meditation. And when we when we cease when that ceases then to be, then we attain enlightenment. Okay?
So we can see then how important the realization of emptiness is as it is then the true paths. As a true path, the realization of emptiness is very important. Then again all the other such realizations as bodhicitta, the realization of impermanence and death and momentariness of phenomena and so forth. All these other realizations in which the realization of emptiness is steeped on, they are also called paths. And, again, a being who then has all these paths, including the path of of the true paths, is a is a is a noble being.
So then we move on to the next topic. So the positive qualities of the sangha, which I was emphasizing here, we’re talking about the actual sangha. This mainly refers to persons who are aryas, who are noble beings. Regarding the positive qualities of the Dharma, be mindful of those who accomplish it correctly. That is the meaning of the community of the Dharma, Duskama.
And then and then we move on to the next topic, which is understanding the distinctions. And la was written for the text, as as is apparent from the companion, go for refuge, aware of the mutual distinctions between the Three Jewels. And Geshe-la was gonna say, so one has to understand what are these these these distinctions amongst the Three Jewels themselves. What is the what is the Buddha? What is the Dharma?
What is the Sangha? So we have gone through that. I said, we have seen that we have seen that the Sangha is composed of those beings who have direct realization of emptiness. We have we have seen that the Dharma is composed of the true cessations and the true paths. So again, every time we have when we have ceased, when when an object of abandonment has ceased to be or ceased to ever arise again, then again, have attained a a the true Dharma.
We have the true Dharma. And then again, and the Buddha is someone who has developed every good quality and read and is rid of every fault, so then has has developed every true path and and and and accomplish every true cessation. Then we move on to the next topic with the distinctions. Again, I will go through the text. As is apparent from the extensive commentary on we should go for refuge in terms of considering the Buddha to be the one who teaches refuge, the Dharma to be nirvana, which is the actual refuge, and to the Sangha to be the companions who accomplish refuge.
So then again, the I guess I was going for the text again. The Buddha is the one who who teaches the who reveals who teaches the refuge, who teaches the the method of attaining the cessation of attaining nirvana. Again, the the Dharma is is the the true cessation, which is the nirvana itself. The actual which is the actual refuge. And, again, the the Sangha are those who who help us along the path of accomplishing that.
So Gesela is pointing to us that we do not have, you know, an actual Buddha teaching us, the refuge or giving us the teachings. Again, we do not have the actual Dharma because we do not have cessation or nirvana in our mind streams. And we do not even have the actual the real Sangha because we do not know of anybody who has attained realization that realization emptiness. But we do have, how can I say that? A relative.
We have the relative teacher, which is we have we have we have the a refuge which is which is which is, how can I say, concomitant with the the actual jewels, which is in accordance with the actual refuge jewels? So we have a an ordinary being who is our our virtuous friend, who is our teacher, who is then giving us the teachings. Have even though we do not have the actual true cessations in nirvana in our mind streams we have all these teachings especially the three trainings which then we study and apply to try to avert, to subdue the manifest forms of the afflictions of attachment, aversion, ignorance and so forth. And we have our friends ourselves here helping each other and supporting each other in whatever way we can and so then in this way we have what’s the proper word? Sorry?
It’s a multitude. It’s a multitude of the actual Three Jewels of refuge which is in the similitude which are in the corners of Which are concomitant. Can I say that? Concomitant? Yeah.
With with the actual Three Jewels. Okay? Is that okay? This one. So Geshe-la was saying, so we do not have the actual Buddha Jew.
We don’t have the actual Dharma Jew which is the true cessation, we don’t have the actual Sangha Jew. What we have is a Lama which is an ordinary being, a teacher who is an ordinary being. We have only our own study and our own little learning and practice of the Dharma teachings as the Dharma jewel. We have the similitudes and we have only our colleagues here as the Sangha jewel, as our similitude of the Sangha jewel. So we see there’s a big difference between the qualities of the actual Three Jewels and the similitudes.
There’s a very big difference but still and if one asks how much we benefit from one and the other, Geshe-la was saying that we actually benefit benefit more from this than from the actual ones. And English license, so again, if and if we think about it, we will see how we actually do benefit more from those similitudes of of of the the Three Jewels of refuge. We can see how we actually obtain the teachings from that lama who who is an ordinary being. You know, we we do obtain the actual teachings from from them. And again, we we we can see for that through our listening and for our for our studies and for our contemplation of the teachings, understanding, develop some clarity and some benefit derives from that.
We can see it for ourselves and we can see how our colleagues here help us in accomplishing that. So we can see how we do actually benefit directly greatly from these similitudes instead. Similitudes in terms of figure or does similitudes mean? Again, I was saying that we do not have we do not have an actual Buddha or we do not have the actual Dharma in terms of the true cessations in our minds and we do not have the actual Sangha in terms of beings who have the realization of anything. What we have are Jews of refuge which are similar, which are in concordance so that we are they are not the actual refuge Jews but they are submitted to, they are similar, they are in accordance with the actual Jews which are is instead of having a Buddha teaching us we have an ordinary being with a Lama teaching us.
Instead of having a true cessation in our mind streams, we have whatever understanding we have developed through our own efforts studying contemplating upon the teachings. And instead of having aarya beings who have direct realization of emptiness as our Sangha jewel, as our friends, we have ourselves here as the as our Sangha jewel helping each other. Do you understand that? Yes. Understand that.
That’s it. Just just a simple question. What’s To be similar. Yeah? Do you understand?
Instead of having an actual Buddha teaching us, we have an ordinary Lama teaching us. That’s what he’s saying. Yeah? Instead of having the actual Dharma in our minds, have our studies. Do you understand that I have the offer of our studies?
They’re not the actual things, they’re similar and we benefit greatly from those things. Because like I saying, said if we ask sorry Yes What’s the word for for the similitude again? So I was asking first So I was asking with regards to the meaning. First, I was asking a hero’s question here. With regards to the meaning of the word that we are translating here as similitude, there’s something which is similar.
Okay. So Gyuntumba, Geshe-la was saying. Similar. We’re talking about have we the refuge that we have is a refuge which is similar to the actual refuge. The actual refuge is a real Buddha.
The actual Buddha refuge is a real Buddha. The actual Dharma refuge you is the actual cessation, nirvana. The actual Sangha is somebody who has realized the emptiness. We do not have the actual one, but we have something which is similar to those. Have something which is similar to the Buddha, is a teacher who is giving us the Dharma.
We have something which is similar to the true cessation, which is the teachings themselves that we are being able to. We have something which is similar to the true Sangha Jews which is, you know, you and and Kama Sonam and everybody who is giving help to supporting us here, we ourselves. It’s similar and that’s the meaning. Is that clarifying? That’s what Geshe was saying.
Is that okay? Then your question is how can we benefit more from the So the Geshe is asking you to then to to see see see, you know, see after him, follow after him. The the the actual Buddha jewel, which is the Buddha Śākyamūni, is he teaching you right now? Are you are you receiving teachers from him right now? The actual Dharma jewel, the true cessations, are you can you see the true cessations in your mind?
The again, as to the true paths, can you see the true paths in your mind? You cannot. Right? Now now on the other hand, you know, we have the Dalai Lama, our virtuous friend, giving teachings. He’s giving teachings to us, isn’t he?
And you listen to the teachings, you understand those teachings, don’t you? And then if you by reflecting and studying and reflecting upon those teachings, you gain an understanding of them, and you and you you see some benefit inside your mind, don’t you? So now between the the Buddha Śākyamūni and the Dalai Lama, who is benefiting you more? That’s a rhetorical question. I do not know the word for rhetorical.
So so in in Geshe-la is explaining it, so then the one who is directly benefiting you is the Dalai Lama. Indirectly, of course, it came from from the Buddha. Because what the Buddha is teaching is what the Buddha so what what excuse me. What the Dalai Lama is teaching is what the Buddha has taught. The Dalai Lama is is is, you know, saying the the Buddha is benefiting us.
Yeah. So in taking refuge in the similitude, are we not then taking refuge in the real thing? So yes, by taking refuge in the similitude, we do take refuge in the actual because the similitude is is is giving to us the actual teachings. It’s transmitting to us the actual teachings. Okay?
And this one. So again, we we we we can see how we do benefit greatly from we are benefiting greatly from from the Buddha Śākyamūni indirectly, but we we derive this benefit directly from our from our actual teachers here who are who we can see. We cannot see the Buddha. We can we have no way to see the Buddha and receive his teachings. We can see only our teacher here.
And for by practicing this, when we eventually realize the teachings that we are being given and we realize emptiness, then we will have maybe enough clarity to see to see other things. The fault is is is in us. The the we are how do say? The fault is is is in us that we cannot see the actual Buddha jewel, that we cannot we do not have the realization of the actual Dharma jewel, and that because we do not have any realization of emptiness, we cannot recognize other beings who have realization of emptiness also. So the fault is in us from our side.
Is that okay? Just giving us a sort of a an analogy or or an illustration to to help us understand the difference. So if, for example, we were there were to be someone without any food who was dying of starvation, so to speak, and who was about to die. And if if if then somebody else came who was giving just a little bit of food, just enough for the person to get just a little better and not die, again, that that will be that will be that what that is what Geshe-la is comparing to the similitude of the refuge, similitude of the Sangha jewel, this of refuge. And then if if there was someone else who then came and gave us so much food and medicine and and care that we could actually, you know, you know, stand back on our own two feet again again and and and go about our lives by ourselves again, then there will be like it’s like comparing that to the strength of the actual refuge, just how much the actual refuge will be benefiting us and helping us.
Is that okay? So then so we can see how how the the the similitude of the refuge is extremely important. It’s very important. Very precious. How how again how we can see how very important, how very precious, how how very essential it is that we rely on the similitude of that we have.
How important it is that we show respect and courtesy to those people who are helping us in our practice, are supporting us in our practice. How important that we pay respect and reverence and and and study at the feet of our teachers, our lamas, ones who are actually revealing the teachings to us. And how important is that we, you know, study, contemplate, and practice those teachings that are being given to us. And it is by relying on this similitude of refuge of the in this way that we will eventually be able to actually get in touch with the actual refuge jewels. And if we do not if we do not first rely in the similitude of refuge in this way, as the Geshe-la is telling us, we will never be able to actually get in touch with the actual refugees, the real refugees, the real Buddha, the real Dharma, the real Sangha.
Okay? So Geshe-la is going for then for the next topic, again, not going back to all other ones. Was going for the text. Through understanding the superiority, inferiority of Buddhists and non-Buddhist teachers, teachings, and students, you should consider the Three Jewels alone to be a refuge and should not, just a minute and should not consider teachers and so forth who are incompatible with them to be a refuge. So, Geshe-la, I was going back for the text again.
Geshe-la was making reference to the the words nangpa and chi nangpa, the Buddhists and non-Buddhists. So then Buddhists and non-Buddhists. What just wanna say here is bodhis and non bodhis. So the bodhis teachings, again, making reference to the non-Buddhists, again, reference like Shiva or Īśvara and so forth. It’s Shiva.
Right? Shiva. Right? And just like I saying, and then one shouldn’t go by by word-of-mouth, making decisions about what refuge one will take if but just by hearing what people say, oh, this one is good, that one is bad by by opinion of others, following the opinion of others. One should investigate and examine carefully which one is best for oneself and having seriously pondered and considered considered one’s choices and so forth.
And one one makes a choice and one goes for refuge with the one or the other, but one has to think about and investigate and not just go blindly. Now if one is a Buddhist, Geshe-la was gonna say, if one is a Buddhist, then one goes for for refuge. One takes refuge in the Three Jewels and will not take one will not take refuge in any other object of refuge, which which are not the Three Jewels. With respect to the difference between the two sets of Buddhist and non-Buddhist teachers, again, the difference between the teachers is that the Buddha is without faults and has complete has completed the positive qualities, while other teachers are the opposite to that. And then guess I was going through the text in the praise of the particularly exalted one, it says, having abandoned the other teachers, Bhagavad, I take refuge in you.
If you ask for what purpose? Because you have no faults but have qualities. And again, the reason Michel just puts in in in in different different order. Again, the reason, he goes for refuge with the Buddha is because the Buddha has rid himself of all faults and and developed every good qualities and that’s why he goes for refuge in the Buddha. And I was reading through the other verse again.
The more I’ve thought about the scripture traditions of others, the tirthikas, the more my confidence in new protector has grown. Those whose minds whose minds are wasted by the faulty tenets of the non omniscient, whose thinking is wasted, do not see faultless teachers, not even you. So we it’s about It’s just about twenty to nine, so we reached the point of question time. Is that okay? Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Eleven. Yeah. Doctor.
Vajragiri. Wants to know if you have any I would ask what is true cessation? So to give an illustration, so when we are able to completely eradicate a object of abandonment, so take for example attachment. Attachment as it is, when we can not only subdue the manifest forms of attachment, when you can completely uproot and eradicate even the seeds and the imprints of attachment. The seeds.
Right? Even the seeds of attachment. When we can completely eradicate that so that it it never arises again, then we have attained the cessation cessation of attachment in this case, in this illustration. That’s what it’s meant. That okay?
And then in the same way we have, you know, the other afflictions, attachment, anger, jealousy, ignorance, so forth. Again, when you when they’re all objects of abandon, when we can eradicate them points in a way that they will not be able to arise again, then we have attained the cessation of each one of them. And, again, it’s through again, through by meditating on emptiness that we are able to uproot them in this way and attain true cessation. Does that answer your question? Yeah.
So, Geshe lah is saying, when when we first develop a realization of emptiness, that first that beginnings of realization of emptiness can only it has only enough strength to to rid, to eradicate the the greater, the more coarser afflictions. Then by continually familiarizing oneself with that realization of emptiness, by continually strengthening, making that realization of of emptiness, the mind realizing emptiness stronger and stronger and stronger, then we’ll be able to then rid and eradicate stronger and stronger objects of abandonment or or or so to speak, maybe subtler and subtler objects of abandonment. And that’s how it goes. And And then and then when you have through this process, been able to rid yourself of every object of abandonment, then you have attained enlightenment. That’s what enlightenment is.
That’s the end result of this process, not the beginning. Yeah. Is that okay? So, Geshe-la is saying, it’s very it’s very difficult to, you know, rid oneself. Excuse me.
Eradicate all all objects of abandonment. I was I was gonna say, well, it’s difficult to eradicate one. Geshe-la was gonna say, yes. It is very difficult to eradicate completely eradicate, uproot these objects of abandonment. We might be able to, you know, temporarily subdue them, or or if if if we have attained the realization of calm abiding, have developed calm abiding, then we might be able to, how to say, stop the more coarse manifestations of these afflictions from from from arising again.
But the only way to completely uproot them so that they won’t arise again is through the realization of emptiness. Okay? You wanted to ask something? Yeah. Well, my question was whether the the the true cessations are achieved or realized in the context of already having achieved or achieved that.
Okay. So, no, it’s not it’s not necessary it’s not necessary the case. It’s not necessarily the case that you need to have bodhicitta before realizing emptiness. And Geshe-la was giving the illustration of, you know, the the the hearer solitary realizer sorry. The the hearer The the the the hearer.
The and solitary realizers who do have aria, hearers and aria solitary realizers who do have realized emptiness, but they do not have bodhicitta in the mind streams. Also, again, the the a greater example of a hearer or solitary realizer, foe destroyer, somebody who has completely eradicated every afflictive emotion through his realization of his or her realization of emptiness, but still does not have bodhicitta in his or her mind stream. Does that mean that that is still to the extent that it’s it’s that means that is still to the extent that it’s it’s the ārya that means? No. No.
So perfectly right. Here. So, yeah, the Sangha jewel is not composed only of beings who have bodhicitta. There are other members of the Sangha jewel, know, hearers, how can I put that in English, beings, hearers who are in the path of seeing or solitary realizers in the path of seeing hearers in the path of meditation or solitary realizers in the path of meditation? And even for these hearers, foe destroyers, and solitary realizers, Arhats, Shravakas, they they have direct realization of emptiness, but they do not have bodhicitta.
And, again, this this just to remind you what what what makes a Sangha jewel is a being who has in his or her mind stream a true path and true cessation, who has a realization of emptiness. Is that okay? Yeah. Yes. Yeah.
No? Okay. So Sangha jewel doesn’t have to necessarily have bodhicitta generated. No? Yes.
Exact that’s that’s exactly what we said. Yes. A Sangha jewel does not have to have bodhicitta. Does not have. Yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Not have. That’s good?
What is the word for? Maybe you need to help me. It’s getting a bit technical. I think so. The difference So Geshe-la was explaining, and I’m gonna need I’m gonna need help with the the the precise definition in Geshe-la was explaining.
According to the mind only school, we have we have the the selflessness of the person, the selflessness of phenomena, the selflessness of phenomena, you have a coarse selflessness of phenomena and a subtle selflessness of phenomena. And then this the the coarse selflessness of phenomena is the lack of difference in substance between the subject and the apprehended object. Is that correct? And that is what the solitary realizer, the Pratyekabuddha, realizes on top of the selflessness of the person. He realizes this coarse selflessness of phenomena.
Whilst the the the hearer, the Śrāvaka, he only realizes the selflessness of the person. He doesn’t realize he doesn’t realize this coarse selflessness of phenomena. Okay? According to the mind only school, that’s how they explain this distinction between Shravakas and Pratyekabuddha or hearers and solitary realizers. Is that okay?
Yeah? This one. Okay. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
- The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is true cessation?
True cessation is attained when an object of abandonment is completely eradicated so that it never arises again. Using attachment as an example, it is not enough to subdue its manifest forms; one must uproot even its seeds and imprints. The same applies to anger, jealousy, ignorance and the other afflictions, each having its own cessation. This uprooting comes through meditating on emptiness. Calm abiding or temporary subduing can only stop the coarser manifestations. A first realization of emptiness is strong enough to remove only the coarser afflictions. As the realization is strengthened, subtler objects of abandonment are removed, and when all are eradicated, enlightenment is attained.