1 h 46 min · 7,299 words · 28 August 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A verse likening virtuous moments to a lightning flash in stormy darkness — brief and easily lost against the weight of accumulated negativity — opens the doctrinal content of this 107-minute session with Geshe Pema Tsering. He uses it to ground the first cause for taking refuge: a felt fear of lower rebirths, rooted in recognising that karma, not willpower, determines our next birth. He then distinguishes the three refuge motivations for beings of small, medium, and greater scope, identifies the objects of refuge, and draws a careful line between ultimate and relative refuge. A job-seeker analogy clarifies the cooperative logic of relying on the Three Jewels. The session ends with Q&A on purification: the four powers, what to do when a negative habit reasserts itself, and how bodhicitta relates to the completeness of confession.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 30 2008 08 28 BP.mp3
UUID: a3fd6c8d-790b-4056-9840-67e6898cef2f
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2008-08-28
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 107.0 minutes
Words: ~7,330
So instructing us to give rise to a good motivation then with the intention of establishing all sentient beings in the state of Buddhahood, the state of enlightenment, then I’m going to study or we are going to study, contemplate, and meditate on the teachings. And in this way, we we give ourselves proper meditation motivation. And, also, with with the wish that we obtain a new home at Buddha House, we start with the Heart Sūtra recitation. I think I think I got the wrong page for you when you take a copy. Is that right?
I think so. It’s sixty eight. Sixty eight, is it? Yeah. That’s right.
Is that right? Yeah. That right? Is this eight? I’m getting ready.
Where did I get this? Oh, yeah. The bottom of six eight. Yes. At the bottom of sixty.
Yeah. Is that okay? Yeah. This one. What was what was that?
You sure? How it is necessary to meditate until this experience is produced? Think didn’t we go for that? We’ve done that. Right?
Then next up. Okay. So so then we approach in the next topic, explanation of how to rely on the methods for the happiness of future lives. Okay. And then there’s two parts to that.
The training in going for refuge, the holy gate for entering the teachings. And then secondly, the root of all well-being and the raising the confidence of firm conviction in actions and their results. So then as for the first one of those topics, is the training going for refuge, again, we can see there is four parts. The causes on which going for refuge depends, depending on them, the objects to which to go for refuge. Thirdly, the way in which to go for refuge as much as one can.
And lastly, the stages of training after having gone for refuge. So then as for the causes, the causes on which going for refuge depends, and we are I guess I was going for the text again. Although in general, are many causes here, it is the fact that, as explained above, we do not stay in this life but soon die, and that after death we will not have control over where we will be born, but will be controlled by our karma. And, Geshe-la was saying, when we talk about the the word in in Tibetan, Khemdro and then to go for refuge or going for refuge. And we we think of of the idea of asking for protection against something or or, you know, that that this or that may not happen to me or protect me against this or that.
Or or we ask for something good to happen instead that that this or that good thing, you know, may occur to me. And the whole point, I just wasn’t saying, is that the refuge is is a help. So if it is helping us in this way. Then we call it refuge. So, Geshe-la is explaining, so then in this in this vein, again, we we realize that we are not going to stay long here.
We’re gonna have we’re gonna die very soon. And then when we die after death, there is no we cannot decide where we are going. We are powerless, and we are we are completely what where we go, where we’re going to be born is determined solely by by our karma, by our previous actions. And that being so, so please, how to say, give me refuge, grant me refuge. Geshe-la was saying, putting it this way.
Geshe-la goes on, again, also karma according to the way of the bodhisattva. And we’ll read the next quote. As a flash of lightning at night amidst amidst the clouds illuminates the darkness for a moment, likewise on the road through the power of Buddhas, a rare understanding of merit comes forth in the in in in the worldly. Therefore, that which is virtuous is always weak, while that which is evil is extremely strong and unbearable. So, again, Geshe-la was going through the through that verse and explaining to us again in this in this in the so the nights are dark, and when it is, you know, foggy or cloudy and rainy and so forth and then the storms again in a flash of lightning and then we we we see a little bit.
We could see a little bit of of what’s around us by the force of that flash of lightning. I guess I wasn’t saying and this is a symbol, an analogy for for our own condition. And when this flash of lightning, which is which is a virtue, again, illuminates our path, again, that’s a very brief moment. It’s a very and and that’s and that’s why Geshe-la was explaining. That’s why it is referred to as as as a weak because it’s just so brief, and it is important that we take advantage of it and do not allow it to go to waste.
And Geshe-la is explaining that in the same way with respect to the to what is said in the in the in the verse that that which is evil, the negativities are extremely wrong and hard to bear. And this life is explaining so and and this is again, this this this is an analogy for our lives. Whatever virtue we produce, they are very rare, and they’re very brief. Just, again, just like like a a lightning strike in in a dark night, and it lasts for that just a very brief moment. And all the other time when we are immersed in darkness, that very darkness is, Geshe-la was gonna say, is compared to to our negativities.
All the rest of the time of of of our days, we we remain remain immersed in this in the darkness of negativities. So Geshe-la goes on for the text again. Thus, by thinking about how you will fall into the bad migrations due to the power of wholesome being small and that of unwholesome being extremely strong, the two arise fear of the bad migrations and the conviction that that which is rare and precious, the jewels, can protect you from them. And this then points out the two causes of refuge. Again, this last point in yes.
To back to the verse where the verse says that the the virtues are very rare and brief, and then the the negativities are very strong and and unbearable, and the verse is saying that. And, again, in the same, if we look carefully at our own lives, we will see that most of the time that we spend in this life is we spend involved with negativities, and very little time we spend involved with with virtuous virtuous actions. So we have accumulated so many causes to be born in the bad migrations. And in this way, we developed this fear of being reborn in such places as bad migrations. And then we and we developed the conviction again that what can protect us from this ever happening are the Three Jewels.
And this is how Geshe-la was explaining. This is how we have to contemplate this topic, meditate on this topic. Geshe-la goes on for the rest of the text. Consequently, if if these two remain but words remain as merely mere words, again, going for going for a refuge will be similar. Again, will remain just as mere words.
However, if they are present intensely and firmly and going for refuge will also come to tame the mind. Therefore, you should strive in those two causes. So Geshe-la is explaining so we have three different classes of beings, three different types of beings, the beings of greater, middling, and lesser scope. For each one of them we have a different type of refuge. This refuge which has been explained here is the refuge beings of lesser scope or smaller scope.
So again, the beings of smaller scope the causes of the refuge of a being small scope is is the fear to be born in the bad migrations and the lower migrations, which are the hells, the preta realms, and and the animal realms. And again, the faith, the conviction that the Three Jewels can protect one’s one from from birth in this in such places. And, again, that being of of small scope, again so then not only that being does not wish to be born in lower realms, again, that that being aspires aims at being born in the in the higher realms of existence in the in the happy migrations as humans or gods. And and this is how they develop their aspiration. May I not be born in the lower migrations, may I be born in the happy migrations.
So again, Geshe-la is then saying, so again this aspiration and this aim that they have attaining a high rebirth, so this is their goal. This fear that they have of being born in the lower migrations and the faith or the conviction that the Three Jewels can protect them from that, this is then makes up the refuge of the beings of small scope. And again, if all of this remains as mere words, again, the refuge, again, will remain just as empty mere words. And if they have but if you’re the if, on the other hand, they have these three components, these three factors strong and firm firm in their minds, again, the refuge, again, will also be strong and firm, stable. And as for the beings of middling scope, Geshe-la is explaining to us on top of having the fear of birthing in the lower migrations and the bad migrations.
Again, those beings of middling scope, they see that freedom from the lower migrations and and then birth in a happy migration, a higher rebirth, that’s not that’s not good enough. Because birth in a in a happy migration, again, they look at their own present birth as a human being, they see that this is not real happiness and not lasting happiness or stable happiness. Soon we’re gonna have to die, and we’re gonna have to be born somewhere else. Again, even the the happiness of gods, the lives of gods, again, it is not to be relied upon because even though it might last long, it doesn’t last forever, and it ends. And after all that happen happiness of god’s ends, that well well, when that is expire when that happiness is exhausted, and, again, one will have to be born in lower migration.
We won’t have to experience suffering. So, again, they see every birth that is, you know, how can I say, propelled or impelled by by contaminated actions and afflictive emotion conceptions as undesirable? They see all of it, not only the bad migration, the lower realms of existence, but even the higher realms of existence, all of all of it which is propelled by contaminated actions and the results. They are all undesirable because no there’s none of it is I would say, none of it provides lasting stable happiness. So they they have the wish then to be free from all of it, all of these births that are propelled by actions and and afflictions.
And in this way, they aim at attaining total liberation from the whole the entirety of cyclic existence. And this then is the ref and and when they go for refuge to the Three Jewels with this in mind and this when when they have the conviction that the Three Jewels can help them and go for a refuge to the Three Jewels with with this in mind, and this then is the refuge of the beings of middling scope. Okay. And then so then again, on top and on top of that, so then this is then is the refuge of the beings of middling scope. And again, on top of that, if one sees that one’s own individual liberation alone is not enough, one’s own individual liberation will relieve only oneself of suffering and will accomplish only happiness for oneself alone and nobody else and no no other being.
And, again, if one sees that that is not there is also under one sees that also is not enough, that also is undesirable, then one, on top of that, wishes to relieve all beings from suffering, establish all beings in the state of enlightenment. And if one then with this intention in mind and goes for refuge to this reduce with the conviction that they will help one to attain this enlightenment, to accomplish this enlightenment, again, this then is the refuge of the being of greater scope. So we can see then how there are three different types of refuge, and each one of these three has has for three for the three different types of refuge, have three different causes. One different cause for each refuge. Okay?
And Geshe lah explains, then again, as for these three different causes Geshe-la was explaining, in terms of the faith, the faith of conviction in the Three Jewels, these three types of refuge beings, they are the same. They they have the same faith of conviction in the in the Three Jewels, the power of Three Jewels to help one accomplish one’s goals and and to provide the necessary refuge and help. On the other hand we have the difference in the aspect of the fear that is to be developed. First one is out of fear of being born in the lower realms of existence, then one goes for refuge to the Three Jewels. And then the second one, not only the lower realms of existence, but out out of fear of of the whole of cyclic existence and wishing to be free from the entirety of cyclic existence, then one goes for refuge to the Three Jewels.
And then the last one, again, the beings of greater scope, again, with with the intention of freeing all sentient beings from suffering and establishing all sentient beings in happiness. And, again, with with that and with the determination that one one self must attain enlightenment to accomplish that, and one goes for refuge and to to provide that that will help one to accomplish that goal. And Geshe-la is giving us, how can I say, an analogy for that? It’s giving say, for example, our jobs, we work we we work to attain our temporary to to attain money obtain money for the sake of temporary happiness. Geshe-la is saying, so we go to to the boss, and we ask for a job.
Please give me this job. I ‘ll do this job and I’ll do it well when you pay me. You pay me the money that I want. And the boss then goes and gives you the job. And if you then does the job well, then you get the money that you work for.
But on the other hand, if you do not do the job well, then you will not get the money. And the same works here for refuge. Again, we the Three Jewels of refuge, they are the boss. Yeah. And we pray to them, for them to give us the job.
And then if we do the job that we were given, that we were told to to do, if we do it well, then we will, how to say, reap the fruits of that of that work which is the happiness and liberation and so and high rebirth and so forth. But if we don’t do the job well again we will not get the results. I will not get our pay. So Geshe-la went on for the for the text. Again, we approach the second topic, which is depending on them, the objects to which one goes for refuge.
Again, the first one, there’s two parts to that. First, identifying what are the objects of refuge. And then secondly, the reasons why they are reasons why they are worthy to be refuges. As for identifying the objects of refuge, we read the those two verses from the one hundred and fifty stanzas. To one in whom perpetually all faults are definitely absent, to one in whom in every manner all good qualities abide.
If someone like that exists, it is fit to go for refuge to him or her, to praise him or her, to attend on him or her, and to abide in what he or she teaches. And, Geshe-la, I think going for the verse, which is again a very literary version of the Tibetan and and putting that into colloquial Tibetan, in English is gonna come more or less the same. Again, if if there is someone who has all good qualities, has again developed all good qualities and just like in this pointing out is which is one who is a Buddha. Again, and and if there is such a person, and if such a person also is is endowed with every sorry. One who has one who is free of every fault and every short and and one who has every good quality.
And, again, if if there is such a one who has and and in the term when we’re talking about all the good qualities and the two clauses and the two little verses, lines of verse, has this all these these good qualities such as, you know, I guess I was pointing out, loving kindness and compassion towards all sentient beings and so forth. Again, if if one has that if there is such a person, then then we ought to go for refuge to such a person. Well, where to take refuge under such a person? And then again, so then that being is fit for one to go for refuge and to be praised, to be attended, and to and for us to abide in what the person teaches. And and then Geshe-la goes on from the text.
Thus, if someone has the intelligence to differentiate between what is a refuge and what is not a refuge, it is appropriate for the person to go for refuge to the undeceiving protector, the Buddha Bhagavan. And this also describes the Dharma jewel and the Sangha jewel. And then again, we have the quotes from the seventy verses on going for refuge. Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha are the refuge of those who want liberation. And Geshe-la was then since when if one wants liberation and enlightenment, then one ought to go for refuge to the Buddha, Dharma, and the Sangha.
And and if we if we if we go for refuge to the to the Buddha, the Buddha Śākyamūni, Geshe-la was saying, and that’s that is that that’s that is enough because the Buddha Śākyamūni himself, he is the Buddha Jewel, and he is also the Dharma Jewel, and he is also the Sangha Jewel. So going for refuge to him is enough to go for refuge to the Three Jewels. So Geshe-la is explaining, as a Buddha again as the buddha jewel then the Buddha Śākyamūni himself does not have any he has completely eradicated any obscuration, both afflictive obscurations and obscurations to knowledge. He has none that and has fulfilled has produced or given rise to all good qualities. And as such, then he is the Buddha jewel.
And then again we can see, Geshe-la is pointing out, we can see how again the Buddha Śākyamūni has again the Dharma jewel in his mind stream, in his continuum he has a Dharma jewel the Dharma jewel is or are the true cessation and the true path and again every mind of the Buddha is a true path and then again every how to say every don’t know how to say that we’re using different words but every cessation of afflictions and so forth that the Buddha has developed again a true cessation and in this way the Buddha encompasses also the Dharma jewel. So he’s the Buddha jewel, the Dharma he’s the Buddha Jewel, the Dharma Jewel, and because he is an Ārya being, a noble being, Ārya beings, noble beings are the Sangha jewel, so he is also the Sangha jewel. Oh, this one? So again, we can see this concludes, so we can see how the Buddha Śākyamūni is Three Jewels, includes the Three Jewels, or the Three Jewels are included in in the Buddha Śākyamūni. Okay.
So Geshe-la is explaining then that the Ārya Bodhisattvas or Ārya Pratyekabuddha, the Ārya solitary realizers, and the Ārya hearers, Shravakas. Again, they are but they are ārya beings. They are noble beings, and, essentially, they are the Sangha jewel, but they are not the Buddha Jewel as And also also so then the the we have when we’re talking about maybe when we’re talking about the Ārya hearer and the Ārya solitary realizer we have those who are in the path of learning and those who have attained the path of no more learning which is the final result of their path. They are solitary realizer Foe Destroyers or hearer Foe Destroyers and they too they are not Buddha Jewels, they are but they are also Sangha Jewels. So again, Geshe-la is explaining, so then we have these various different types of Sangha jewels, so then we have the learners.
Ārya learners, Ārya solitary realizers who are who are learners the path of learning and the ārya hearers who are no more learners, Ārya solitary realizers that are no more learners, and then we have the aryah bodhisattvas. And they are all Sangha Jewels. They’re not Buddha Jewels. They are all Sangha Jewels. So and again also these these five different types of Ārya beings, the hearers, solitary realizers, and bodhisattvas Again also in their in their continuums we find true paths and true cessation.
Have developed some true paths and by the power of that they have ceased some afflictions or some obscurations. And so in this way, even though they might not have all develop all paths and rid themselves or and attained all cessations and, you know, ridding themselves of all obscurations, they still have some. And so then they do have true paths and true cessation. And as such, then Dharma jewel is also included in their continuums. And so Geshe-la is explaining this five ārya beings again, because they do not have all the paths and cessations.
Then, again, they they they are not fit to be Buddha Jewels. They are Sangha Jewels. They are Dharma Jewels, but they are not a Buddha Jewel. So because of that, they are called they refer to as, what I’d say, relative refuge. And again, the there in in in the in the Buddha, a fully enlightened being, again, it will be or as opposed to that will be an ultimate refuge.
They have and and and the the Dharma in in the continuum also will be an ultimate Dharma. They will be the ultimate Sangha in this in this way. Is that okay? Can can you give me a hint here? Because I haven’t heard this before.
So the the the Buddha, which is the he called the Ultimate refuge. But he says the reality which is the final result of the path is the ultimate refuge.
Okay. Yeah. So Geshe-la again is giving the definition of this of what he called ultimate refuge. And he said that that reality, which is the ultimate goal of the path itself, is then the ultimate refuge, which is then the Buddha. And then those those five are the Ārya beings, those five are the noble beings, because they are not.
Right? The the that final the reality, which is the final result of the path, then, again, they are not the they are not the ultimate refuge. They are, again, what he referred to as the relative, but also he just used the word temporary refuge. So, again, Geshe-la was reading for the verse again, Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha are the refuge of those who want liberation. And Geshe-la was then saying again, so we see that this is two two type of refuges, which is then the ultimate refuge, which is the Buddha himself or the Buddha, a Buddha itself.
And, again, we have this temporal refuge or relative refuge, which are these these five types of Ārya beings. And and and and it’s alright to go for refuge to any of them. One can go for refuge to the Buddha, which will be then the the whole lot, the the the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha. And then one can go for a future this all the five types of Ārya beings. Even though they might not be the Buddha jewel, they they have the true Dharma jewel in their mind streams and the continuums, and that is the principal refuge that we have to go to.
So it is alright to go for refuge with them to. Again, we have then in identifying identifying, which is this identifying the objects of refuge. This is was the the heading of the section that we have been going through. So it’s that was the same. So we have identified the objects of refuge.
We have the Ārya Bodhisattvas. And we have also the those who have attained the path of no more learning. Again, the Pratyekabuddha, Shravakas, and Buddhas themselves. And all of them, they are identified as the object objects of refuge.
So then, Geshe-la was reading for the next topic. Again, the reasons why they are worthy to be refuges. And as for the first part of that topic is the actual the actual reasons. Again, Geshe-la was reading: someone who is free from all fear, skilled in the means of liberating others from fear, steeped in great compassion toward everyone without closeness or distance, without bias, and who works for the welfare of all those who help and do not help her or him, such a one worthy to be a refuge. So, again, Geshe-la was going through the text again.
So then someone who is free from all fear, Geshe-la says, such a person who is free from every fear, that is a Buddha. Someone who is skilled in the means of liberating others from fear against such a person can only be a Buddha. Steep in great compassion towards everyone without any bias. Again, who works for the welfare of all, even those who actually help that person or do not help the person, benefit or do not benefit the person. Such a person is worthy of So, again, as long as the Buddha has those qualifications, whilst Īśvara and other gods do not have, then, again, the Buddha is a refuge.
For that reason, the Dharma taught by by the Buddha, which is then, again, the the true paths and true cessation, as well as the Sangha of hearers and solitary realizers are also worthy to be refuges. And again we have a following topic, Geshe-la was going through it. Again, the advice to be persistent persistent in conviction which is a principal cause that being so once you have derived certainty with regard to these objects of refuge set forth in the compendium Again, since when you are able to rely on them with a single point of mind, it is impossible for you not to be protected. Generate certainty from the bottom of your heart. So again, Geshe-la was just pointing out again to those parts of of the text which which are telling us again if we have that certainty, then again there is is impossible for the Three Jewels not to provide the refuge.
All I have to do is generate that certainty from the bottom of our hearts, again, we be we need to have no doubt about it. We will be provided with the refuge. Geshe-la was going for the text again. Of the two causes for being protected. There is no incompleteness in the external cause since our teacher, the Buddha, has already achieved it.
However, since the internal cause taking hold of that refuge trustingly, that certainty, has not come about, that is why we’re suffering. Geshe-la again was pointing out to the analogy that he gave us previously. When we are seeking a job, we go talking to the boss, have to talk to someone who has the power to provide us the job that we are seeking salary and so forth. If the person has the power then again we get the job from that person and again it’s up to us to do the work. The Buddha is somebody, is a being who has the power to provide us with the refuge.
From the Buddha’s side, he has the power, the capacity to provide that refuge. From our side, have to develop that trust, that certainty with regards to that. The lack of that trust, the lack of that wholehearted trust is is what makes us continue to experience this suffering. So, again, Geshe-la was saying, so right now, our refuge is as as mere words, and that’s why we we do not reap the fruits. And then Geshe-la was saying, so what we have to do then is is take refuge in from the very bottom of our hearts, completely wholeheartedly.
And then we need to have we need to have no doubts any in about the capacity of the Three Jewels. So, I guess, I was pointing out again, so we with the understanding that we are all going to die, it’s important that we develop this refuge at the time of our death. Again, we pray to the Buddha to give us this refuge, this protection. Yeah. Yeah.
That we might that we may not be born in the lower realms and that we may attain, again, future rebirth, a future precious human rebirth with all the freedoms and opportunities. And in this way, we we train in our refuge. In order to accomplish this at the time of our death, again, we we need to start practicing now, Geshe-la was gonna say. We need to practice taking this refuge mind in this way from now all the way until the moment of our death. Because and if we do that, if we act in this way, if we train our minds in this way and refuge, then again, at the time of our death, it will be second nature.
It will come naturally to us, this refuge, and we will need not fear death. We can actually we will actually have the chance to to take joy, to rejoice, and be happy about it. So, Geshe lah, is again pointing out the importance of training now in this point of refuge because if we do not train again at the time of death, it’s going to be very difficult for us to think about it because we’re either going to be extremely sick or ill or else dying, you know, with a lot of suffering and discomfort. Again, even in the process of the separation of the body and mind of consciousness and the body again that’s very overwhelming and again it’s going to if we have not trained our minds for a long time again it’s going to be very hard to think about the refuge in this way. So that’s why it’s so important, Geshe-la says, that we train from now on to take refuge in this in this manner.
Okay? So I was just I was just asking, because now it’s it’s like eight minutes and then eight eight hour eight o’clock and thirty nine minutes and then so so that we have some Yeah. Minutes or so for questions, and we do not finish too late, and you are not completely exhausted at the end of this. I asked to to stop now so we have time for a few questions. Yeah, take this one.
Oh, yeah. Sumpara. So Geshe laude is asking if have questions. Would just have to make a note here, just a minute. Today is the twenty eighth.
Right? Twenty eighth. Twenty eighth. Yes? Do we really need some instruction in order to practice purification of a negative karma?
Purify the negativities, you need? Can we do it ourselves as a? Yeah. So, Geshe-la is going to say, no. No.
We do not need to receive any special instructions. What we need the main thing that we need in order to purify the negativity is is is regret regret for the negativity that we have performed and the determination not to perform them again. And on top of that, what we need is a foundation upon which we develop this regret and this determination. So we start with the saying and the foundation is the refuge itself. So then having developed a refuge mind, having taken refuge, then on top of that, we develop regret, a genuine regret for the negative actions we have performed.
And then we do the the we give rise to the determination not to perform those negativities from this moment onwards. And then lastly, we we we perform a virtuous deed to counterbalance that or we’re, you know, making offerings or prostrations or or prayers and so forth. And that’s all we need. Is that okay? Yeah.
Thank you. Yes? We can do that and make the determination not to do that. Next week, we’ll do that then. Do it again?
Do it again. So what you have to do if if that happens, which is, of course, is another negativity. So, again, if if if that happens, then what you have to do is again generate regret again and generate the determination again. It’s an exercise until they become strong enough to stop you from performing that ever again. Geshe-la was saying so, and again, you perform the negativity, the negative action, and again, you confess it.
Confess in this way with the regret and determination and so forth. And again you perform it, and again you confess it. It’s an exercise. Okay? It’s like running, lifting weights, or anything like that.
Alright? Until you become strong. And you do become strong. The more you practice, the more stronger you become. Thank you.
Thank you. So Geshe-la is saying, as Geshe-la is saying, the real the a good purification is very hard to accomplish. This is Geshe-la saying. It’s because you need a good refuge and you need, you know, you know, the mind of enlightenment, and then you need to generate some very strong genuine regret and then a very strong not to perform negative deed again. And I was like, okay.
And then and then, it’s difficult but difficult but just because it is difficult, we don’t just give up on it. We keep on practicing. Again, we keep on exercising that muscle inside our hearts until it’s So then again, it’s very important, because I was just saying, that we have these powers. The the when we’re talking about confessional purification, we’re talking about these four powers. And the first power is refuge and bodhicitta.
So we will have to have a good solid refuge foundation, and we have to have bodhicitta. And even if we do not have bodhicitta, at least refuse a refuge mind, we should definitely have it, Geshe-la was gonna say. And then on top of that foundation, we develop a genuine regret, you know, a healthy regret. And then on top of that genuine strong regret, and we develop the determination the determination not to perform the action again. If you have that, then whatever good deeds, good action, virtuous actions you perform after that, then you have it all.
It’s all good. Okay? Oh, yeah. This one. I’m sorry.
I don’t understand you. How’s that, Jamba? How ‘s that? Who has? Who has?
Who has? That’s the ultimate refuge. And the and the the relative refuge or the temporal refuge is one who has not progressed to the to the end of the day? The final. To the final?
To the final path. To the final path with regards to ultimate reality. Mhmm. Okay. Is that okay, everybody?
It’s a bit obscure, but I haven’t heard that one before. Ultimate reality being with some understanding. Yeah. Yeah. Realizing the lack of inherent existence of phenomena.
You didn’t talk about that. Yeah. I know, but I haven’t heard this before. I’m relying here on on teamwork. So that’s That’s why he was saying.
Okay. Yeah. That’s fine. Okay. Is that okay?
Think so. In things like, you know, before teachings and also in the example of purification practice. Yeah. Says you must have a bodhicitta intention to really, you know, have the most benefit of those sort of things. It’s good to have.
But I guess I would say, even if you do not have, at least you you you ought to make effort in developing a refuge mind. Not you must have. I would say, must have. It’s good to have. It’s ideal if you have it.
Yeah. So we even though people like us have not, you know, developed renunciation to the, you know, fullest extent to certainty, we should still, like, try and drum that up. You know? It’s all sort of Of course. Of course.
Of course. Of course. So Geshe-la was gonna say, if we do not have the refuge, or the full refuge or whatever it is, then Geshe-la was gonna say, what you have to do is then to develop, make sure that you have it. And then and then you engage in the other practices on top of that. If we do not have the refuge, then even though we might do generate the regret and the the the the the determination not to perform it again, and even we might do a virtuous action.
And, again, we we might without the without the the power of the foundation, which is which will be the refuge itself, then our our confessional purification practice will not be will not avert the the the results of the negative actions so well. Geshe-la says, he thinks that it will be very hard to avert to diminish significantly the the results of those negative deeds. So it’s it’s that’s why it’s very important that we then develop a refuge so then our our purification practice becomes complete and powerful in this way. Okay? Can we talk about the the refuge for the the things of so are we saying that we are, you know, at our level?
It’s like a person with blessings going. I don’t sure. I’m not sure if I understand what you’re saying. Well, should we I thought you were saying before we should beings of less scope Yes. We go for refuge to yeah.
The rep the refuge to not have a lower rebirth, but to have a higher rebirth. Beans for beings of a small scope, they go for refuge out of fear of being born in the lower realms of existence and then with the aspiration to be born in the higher realms of existence instead. Yeah. But then but we’re also told we shouldn’t have the aspiration. Beings of of great scope have the aspiration to attain enlightenment for the sake of sentient beings.
So let’s talk about two different types of beings, and they have two different intentions and goals. Yes. Okay. I thought we have been told that we should have that ultimate aspiration. We shouldn’t have just been set for That’s common to the being.
So practicing the path common the common path common to the path of Yeah. Being in those. Yeah. So we have. Yeah.
Oh, I don’t know. I don’t know. I’m not about that. But Geshe-la has been saying, yes, We all need to attain enlightenment. In order to attain enlightenment, you need to attain a higher rebirth because if you are born in lower realms of existence, you won’t have the the opportunity to practice to attain enlightenment.
So we need to attain higher rebirths. And in this way, we develop our aspiration to attain enlightenment. Develop our refuge in this way, and then we may attain enlightenment. And by and by taking refuge with enlightenment as one’s goal, then again, higher rebirths will be will come already as a result of that. It’s making sense?
And again, we are talking about attaining enlightenment, we’re not aiming at enlightenment for oneself alone. We shouldn’t allow, we shouldn’t give in to such thoughts. We should think of attaining enlightenment again for the for the sake of accomplishing the benefit of of all beings. Developing our aspirations in this way, we automatically accomplish also all the positive results that the aspirations of beings of small scope and of medium scope have in mind also. So all the the happiness and benefits and high and so forth that those beings were aspiring for, they are all included as a result of the higher aspiration of enlightenment.
So we go for the heart. So the best deal. Yes. That’s the smartest thing to do, boss. So is the difference in the, like, the certainty, is that the difference, like, the small scope and middle scope being the aspiration?
They just don’t have the certainty that Have I haven’t thought we have just gone through the differences. The differences of the refuge of of of being a small, medium, and greater scope. This motivation you’re talking about is the motivation of a great scope being or be it, you know, just for it’s like this. And that’s and that’s how it is. Refuge, okay, for the for the three beings, okay, the whole lot.
They have the the the two causes of refuge. Of one of the causes, which is the certainty or the trust that you develop in the Three Jewels. It’s the certainty or the trust that you develop in the capacity of the Three Jewels. And you can you can make a difference in that the beings of small scope have to develop a certainty or a trust in the capacity of the Three Jewels to protect them from the suffering of the lower realms. Then the beings of middle scope develop the certainty or the trust that the Three Jewels can protect them from the sufferings of the entirety, the whole cyclic existence.
And again, the beings of greater scope develop the certainty or the trust that the Three Jewels can protect all sentient beings from suffering. Then the fear, the aspect of fear. So again, the beings of small scope fear birth in the lower realms of existence. The beings of medium scope, the fear birth in in the entirety of cyclic existence. And the beings of greater scope fear the suffering of all sentient beings.
Now as for the objects of attainment, their goals. Okay? So the beings of small scope, they aim at attaining birth as a high rebirth. The beings of middle scope, they aim at attaining individual liberation for themselves alone. And then beings of greater scope aim at attaining enlightenment, enlightenment of all beings.
Good. Even though there are these three differences, these differences, if one develops the paths of the being of a greater scope then one attains also all the results all the goals of of the beings of middling and lesser scope. Okay? Okay? Shall we finish before it becomes too late?
Key terms in this teaching
- buddha, a sang gye (Tib)
- A fully awakened being, who has totally eliminated all obscurations veiling the mind and has fully developed all good qualities to perfection. LYWA
- four powers
- The four types of attainments often described in tantric initiations. They are: pacification (of delusions), increase (of realizations), control (of whatever needs controlling) and subduing (of negative forces). LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Do we need special instruction in order to practise purification of negative karma?
No special instructions are needed. What matters most is regret for the negativity we have performed and the determination not to do it again. These rest on a foundation, which is refuge. Having developed a refuge mind and taken refuge, we then develop genuine regret for the negative actions we have done. Next we give rise to the determination not to repeat those negativities from this moment onwards. Lastly, we perform a virtuous deed to counterbalance the negativity, such as making offerings, doing prostrations or saying prayers. That is all that is needed.