2 h 22 min · 8,682 words · 7 August 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Using the image of a person in free-fall who mistakes midair for safety, Geshe Pema Tsering presses the point that every moment since birth is a step closer to death. In this 142-minute Lamrim session he covers the second and third reasons death is certain — lifespan diminishes incessantly, and most of us will die without having practiced — then turns to why the timing of death is unpredictable, citing the body’s fragility and the many conditions that can end life. A key section distinguishes subtle impermanence (the moment-to-moment disintegration of body and mind) from coarse impermanence (their final separation at death), arguing both must be contemplated to build genuine conviction. The session ends with a wide-ranging Q&A on memory of former lives, whether Buddhas die voluntarily, how consciousness threads through the intermediate state between lives, and whether deep concentration on momentary change can open toward a realization of emptiness.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 27 2008 08 07 BP.mp3
UUID: 042cf929-3f7b-4e6c-9f05-b87b5a2c5a0c
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2008-08-07
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 142.4 minutes
Words: ~8,698
So Geshe-la is instructing us to give rise to a good motivation and then with intention then of establishing the state of enlightenment, obtaining enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, then we are going to listen and study these teachings on the on the stages of the path. And in this way, we practice in order to accomplish this goal. Oh, yeah. I didn’t feel like you might have seen this. And then we start with the we start with the with the preliminary praise with the Heart Sūtra.
Thus did I hear at one time, the Bhagavan was dwelling on mass of vulture mountain together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. At that time, the the dispelling of hindrances. I and all surrounding sentient beings go for refuge to the Buddha, go for refuge to the Dharma, go for refuge to the Sangha. We prostrate to the great mother Prajñāpāramitā surrounded by all the children by the assemblies of Buddhas and Bodhisattvas over the ten directions. By depending my prostrations to all of you, may this word of truth be actualized.
In the past, the Devaputra Indra, just called the Mara by reflecting on the profound meaning of the wisdom gone beyond and reciting the profound words in daily recitation. In that same way, I also reflect in the profound meaning of the great mother, Prajñāpāramitā, and recite the profound words in daily recitation. May all diseases, fears, possessions, bad conditions, all the negative directions, that which happens due to past karma and immediate conditions, may all these be dispelled, may become nonexistent, may be pacified. So we we we were approaching the meditations and teachings and teachings and teachings and teachings on on mindfulness of impermanence and death, but the actual reasons, which which are: the lord of death will certainly come, and there are no conditions for warding him off. One’s lifespan cannot be increased but diminishes diminishes incessantly, and he will die without having had time to practice, Dharma while alive.
So we’re approaching the second one of those topics. One’s lifespan cannot be increased and diminishes in in incessantly. Okay. So, Geshe-la, I was reading for the text. Again, for someone with the resolve of contemplation, there are no external objects that do not point out impermanence to her or him.
And Geshe-la was pointing out, was explaining just saying that if someone constantly and strongly contemplates impermanence, then there will be no phenomena which appears, which is seen by that person, which will not seem impermanent. You will see all phenomena disintegrating constantly. And then, Geshe-la is just saying that it is it is that is actually isn’t it? If you constant constantly contemplating impermanence, you will see that everything there is, every phenomena there is, again, they are constantly disintegrated. They’re constantly changing or disintegrating.
And and Geshe-la points out leaving a car. Again, when you get a new car after one month or after a certain amount of time, again, you have to when things are changing, the car isn’t disintegrating in a certain way, they’re changing in a certain way, and we see that with human beings, also with people. They start as as young kids or babies, and then they grow up. So there’s this change. There’s this constant disintegration happening.
And Geshe-la is pointing out as a text says, again, there are no external objects that do not point out impermanence to him or her. That that do not teach impermanence. They do not reveal impermanence. And Geshe-la was saying even though phenomena do reveal reveal themselves as impermanent, Geshe-la wasn’t saying, still, we do not think about it in that way. And we we do not think about impermanent phenomena as being permanent be by the force of our grasping to permanence.
Because we due the force of that view the grasps to permanence, Geshe-la was saying. We we keep on holding onto objects as if they were remaining as if they were going to remain the same, unchanged, stable, without disintegrating, without changing in any way. Geshe was going through the text again. Since this is thought, certainty arises if you consider it often from many angles. And Geshe-la and then goes goes the rest goes on again.
There is no benefit in thinking one has considered something several times, but still no certainty arose. As Kamalaśīla said, he says nothing has come about through contemplation. But when when did you contemplate? During the day, you indulge in distractions. At night, you sleep.
Don’t lie. And Geshe was it’s just a little bit Geshe-la was then saying again to to to those to those sentences. Again, if you if you if you contemplate just a little bit, then, again, you that certainty about about phenomena will not arise. And as Kamalaśīla is contesting, again, just we might say that just says again that when when we say that we have contemplated, we have thought about it, but, you know, this certainty, this understanding has not arisen. And and Kamalaśīla was saying, well, we haven’t really then reflected upon it.
We haven’t really contemplated. Then as as the text says, you just you just lays out or sleep indulge in distractions, so don’t lie about it. You you have not actually contemplated the subject in the first place. And, Geshe-la was just going through the text again. It is not just at the end of our lives when death overcomes us that we proceed towards another world.
For up until then, there is not a moment in which our lifespan does not diminish. Therefore, ever since. Therefore, ever since we entered the womb, we have been going straight towards a future life without remaining still, without remaining unchanged even for a single instant. And, Geshe-la was just saying how how this is actually so. It seems since the moment we were born, every moment that passes is a moment closer to death.
There’s not a moment that passes by that doesn’t make us closer to death. Whereas, Geshe-la was saying also, reading through the text, in the meantime life also wastes away and we go towards death led by the messengers of disease and aging. And again, Geshe-la points out, it turns back to our own lives. Again, how we we can see that in our own lives. How every moment we have been growing old, every moment we have that passes, we have gone through more and more sickness and illness.
So then again, in the meantime, life also wastes away as we go towards death led by the messengers of disease and aging. Therefore, do not rejoice in the view that you abide during your life without approaching future future lives, future worlds. It it is like the analogy that at the time of having fallen from a high mountain peak, the occasion of falling through the sky before crashing to the ground is not worthy of joy. Is that okay? Did you understand that?
And then so then Geshe-la is explaining how how again this is so with us. We we say that when we talk about death, Geshe-la was gonna say, we we think, oh, I’m not gonna die. I’m not gonna die yet. I’m not gonna die. Let’s not talk about it.
I’m not gonna die. And and you say, know, I I’m not gonna I’m I’m more I’m okay. Is everything okay right now? Everything is alright right now? And it’s like the analogy, again, of falling from a high peak and saying that the the space in between jumping off the peak or falling off the peak and hitting the ground in that space that you are in mid air is is is a joyful is a joyful moment.
And it was not actually the case because in the next moment you are hitting the ground and there’s no joy in that. And Geshe-la is saying how how when we if we were to fall off of a high mountain peak like that, that we wouldn’t there will be no joy. We would actually be very scared, isn’t it? And Geshe lah was saying the same applies to our life. Yeah.
I mean, we we already all of us here, we already we’re not children anymore. We all grow we all grown ups. We we we have we all have many many years on our backs. And English language is saying that we should we should actually be considering that soon we are gonna die. The time is approaching quicker, Geshe-la.
And, again, we have then this quote from the commentary on the four hundred verses. Hero of men, in in that night, at the very beginning, when someone comes to dwell in a womb in the world, starting from that point, he moves with each day without the pause of a step towards the lord of death. So, again, there is not a moment that we remain unchanged. Again, every every moment that passes since since the moment we are born, every moment that passes is a moment closer to death. Every step we take is a step closer to death.
And we read the next the next topic. You die without having had time to practice Dharma whilst alive. Even if you can live for for that long, it is inappropriate to think you have time. As is stated in in the sūtra of entering the womb initially during the first ten years of childhood it does not occur to you to practice the Dharma and at the end during the twenty years of old age you do not have the power to practice the Dharma. Of the time in between sleep having snatched away one half in illness and the like also having wasted much time, no more than a few opportunities remain to accomplish the Dharma.
And the meaning is very clear. Geshe-la just says again and this is again the case with all of us. And we waste a lot of time with our with our with our jobs. We waste a lot of time with sleep. Waste a lot of time.
A lot of time is is lost with with when we are sick or ill. And so that’s and then we don’t have much much time for practice in the end. So then we have the decision, which is the end of that first line of reasoning, the decision to practice the Dharma. And I was going for the the first line again. Since it is like this, at the time of death, all the excellences of this life will only be an object recollection, like the recollection of a happy experience in a dream after you have woken up.
And again, Geshe-la is pointing out how we spend our lives, again, all our activities that we are done that we do for the sake of of all the good things of this life, you know, all the all the our activities, our our work, and so forth. And, again, how at the time of death, you know, at the moment after death, all that becomes no more than than than a dream. And, again, Geshe-la is pointing out how this is actually the case with the knowledge of the dreams. Again, we we we dream of all sorts of things. We dream of having a lot of power, wealth, sorts of we have all sorts of dreams.
We have even also bad dreams and so forth. And, again, when we wake up, all of that is nothing but but a memory. And the same the same applies to this life. Again, it doesn’t matter how much wealth you one may have. Again, the moment after death, it’s all it’s all lost just like a dream, just like a memory.
And and again, Geshe-la goes on for the text. Why why would you be delighted by being beguiled by this life if the enemy who is death will certainly come? So then with with this thought in mind, you should make the decision that you decision that you definitely need to practice the Dharma. And then and then so again, Geshe-la is saying how how we we have to again, the text is saying, we and and reiterate this in the most feeling many times, and that’s that means that mean we’re we’re continually thinking, contemplating that the fact that I am going to die. I am going to die and reiterating that feeling, that thought that thought feeling constantly.
And we have this quote then from the Jātaka Tales. Alas, afflicted worldly beings, your stay is not stable. There is no joy. Even this water lily splendor will soon be but a memory. And then Geshe-la was just explaining again the the the the verse in Tibetan is very, you know, very literary.
Again, Geshe-la was just explaining the the whole meaning. But in English, it’s it’s basically the same thing. Again, afflicted worldly beings, which refers to all of us. All beings with afflicted emotions and conceptions. Again, this life is not stable.
This life does not remain unchanged. And because of that, there is no reason for us to take any joy in it. It is like a beautiful water lily, again, which which soon withers away and and and there’s there’s nothing left but a memory. And then we move on to the to the next major division division of this topic. Again, the the time of one’s death is uncertain.
The first one has three parts. The first one is the need to generate a mental state mindful of death every day. And, Geshe-la, I was just going through the first sentence again. It is certain that death will come between now and a hundred years from now, and it is not certain on which day in between it will come. Therefore, it is not definite on any day like today whether you will die or not.
And Geshe-la again points out how how this is actually so in our lives. So all of all of us here, we’re not gonna live more than a hundred years from now, from, you know, probably even less than that. And Geshe la is saying there is not and there is no way of telling when we are going to die. There is no way of telling if we’re going to die tonight, tomorrow, next week, next month, or in the next few years. There’s absolutely no way of telling when we are going to die or the time of our death is is completely uncertain.
So, again, it is is have you understood that it’s important then says to make the decision to practice and to practice now, to start one’s practice now. If we do not practice and and then we die, then there is a great fault to it. But if we start practicing now and we keep on practicing until the until the day we die, even though we we might end end up living another sixty, forty forty, fifty, sixty years, we have to keep on practicing until the day we die. And then that’s and there’s only profit coming out of it, only good qualities coming out of it, and no fault whatsoever if we act in this manner. English language, they’re saying so because of all that, because of all this information, again, we can even though we respective of if we are going to die tonight or not, we have to make the decisions the decision within our minds that we are going to die.
I’m going to die tonight. And then in this way, we we engage in practice. We do our practice. And, Krishna, I was going through the text again. Nonetheless, the mind signing to the idea of death, you must generate the awareness that thinks I will die today.
For if the mind signs with the idea of not dying with the thought I will not die today, you will constantly prepare staying in this life and will not prepare for future lives. Due to this, if you then get seized by the lord of death, in the meantime, you will you will have to die in anguish. However, if you prepare to die every day, you accomplish a lot that is meaningful for the future. So that even if you do not die, it is good to have done it. And if you and and if you die, it was all the more necessary.
Is that okay? And, Geshe lah, again, just pointing out to these facts. Say again first, Geshe lah, again, we should contemplate it, but we do not we do not think. We think I’m not gonna die. I’m not gonna die today.
And and because by the force of that thought, I’m not gonna die. I’m not gonna die today, then we go on, engage in all sorts of activities. You know? I go to, I don’t know, watch a show or go to work, make money, work for the sake of this life, and so forth. All due to the force of of of this thought, which which Geshe-la was gonna say, is a thought which is very stable in our minds.
And Geshe-la was gonna say but the all this and the reasons we we give when we say I’m not gonna die, we think, oh, I still you know, I’m still I’m still young. I’m still healthy. I’m feeling okay. We think like that. I’m, you know, I’m I’m not many years.
I’m not old. I’m not too old and so forth. We give all sorts of all sorts of of of different excuses. But all these reasons, all these excuses, they are they are very much unfounded. They’re very much deluded and distorted.
They’re completely incorrect, as Geshe-la was saying. And there is absolutely no absolutely no certainty of the time we are going to die. And I was then just saying that how conventionally we we have convinced that the actual actual death is that moment when the mind or the consciousness separates from the body, from the physical body. That’s what we we conventionally assert to be death, the actual death. But the the the fact of the matter is that we are dying every moment, Geshe was saying.
Every moment we die, every every new moment we have died to the previous moment. And there’s there’s not a moment when things are not changing, when things are not disintegrating. And and and Geshe-la was then saying, we have those moments, all those many moments, our consciousness has not been separated from the body, from the physical body, but there’s still there’s not a moment that remains the same. There’s not a moment that remain unchanged. And Geshe-la is pointing out how that that death, which is the separation of the consciousness and the body and the physical body that’s which is what we conventionally call death.
Geshe-la was saying that is that is the coarse, sort of a coarse type of death. And Geshe-la was saying there is a very subtle death, which is occurring moment to moment, which we are not able to see, but which Geshe-la was saying. But we we if we think about it, if we set set minds, we will be able to understand. And Geshe-la was saying how there is not a moment where the body and the mind do not do not remain unchanged. So from one moment to the next, body.
We have a different mind. Geshe-la was pointing out how the mind or the consciousness arises in dependence on on how can I say that? The the first the first moment of of the mind depends on the first moment of the of the body and and not on the second. And so and and Geshe-la, let me see if I can get this for you. So in Geshe-la was point, it was saying then how then in the second moment, because the body has already changed, it’s not the same body, and, again, it’s not the same mind.
And then I was saying so, again, we we I’m just I’m just pointing out because Geshe-la was talking about death. And I said, so I can understand how they change, but we’re talking about death. And Geshe-la wasn’t saying here, they they mean the same thing. Death and the change or the disintegration, the same word is used for both meanings. Here is meaning the same.
Is everybody following? Is that coming across? Yeah. Sorry. Oh.
Can I ask some Absolutely? Yes. You said that mind also would change. Yes. Yeah.
The mind and the consciousness is a different subject. Mind consciousness. Oh, I’m using it with the same meaning here. Consciousness and mind. Same thing.
Right right here. I’m using it exactly the same meaning. Yes. Is that okay? Consciousness.
And then again, and this I thought that maybe when I interpreted it was going just one way, and it goes both ways. Again, there’s not a moment that the mind changes that the body doesn’t change. There’s not a moment that the body changes that the mind also doesn’t change or or or the consciousness. They both change from moment to moment. They never there’s not a moment in which they remain unchanged.
Okay? And then Geshe-la was saying, all that in the context, for example, of us growing old and so forth, we can see from childhood. And Geshe-la is gonna say, so again, we we we don’t we never remain the same. We are constantly changing changing changing every moment. And and where where where is that gonna lead us?
Where where where is it where where is this going to end up? It’s gonna end up with the separation of the body and the mind. Was saying that that death, which is that separation of the body and mind of which which is which is so scary, which is which are are so we are so afraid of, that is what is referred to as the coarse impermanence. And then that momentary disintegration or the momentary change disintegration that happens from moment moment. Again, that is what is referred to as subtle impermanence, we have then two different types of impermanence, coarse and subtle impermanence.
Again, we have to contemplate. We have to think over and over about this this subtle impermanence, this momentary change, of of phenomena. And if we if we contemplate that long enough, again, we will develop a clear understanding of the the the fact that we are changing every moment. That there’s not a one moment that we remain unchanged, not disintegrating. And, again, if we continually contemplate in that way and and we consider where where is that gonna end up, it’s gonna end up at the coarse type of death, which is the separation of body and mind.
And, again, you can contemplate that, again, starting from the subtle impermanence to the leading to the coarse impermanence or to death and or or or the other way around from death backwards again. And so and this is how we have to continue to contemplate this subject, is mindfulness of impermanence and death. And Geshe-la was quoting one of the four seals that all phenomena are impermanent. Compounded phenomena, right, are impermanent. And Geshe-la was in saying so then this word, which is a negative particle, which is mi, which means not, or in the case of of permanence, impermanence as a negative.
Geshe-la was saying it means also not stable. Mi-tagpa, which means not permanent means also not stable in that it it never remains the same. It never remains unchanged. And that’s what it means. It’s constantly changing, constantly disintegrating.
One. And Geshe-la was saying how, again, we have to contemplate then both the subtle impermanence and death itself. So and then if we if we do contemplate, then we we can accomplish proper Dharma practice, proper spiritual practice. If we don’t, then we won’t be able to accomplish proper Dharma practice. And as I was pointing out how important it is to develop a certainty about subtle impermanence, about this momentary change because we we can already think about death.
We can already give rise to the thought of our death. Death. But in order to Geshe was saying, it is necessary to have also an understanding of this subtle impermanence so that way our conviction is is strong. And then we move on to the actual reasons pertaining to that to this topic, which is there is no certainty with regards to the lifespan in this continent of Jambudvipa, which is why the time of death is uncertain. Second, there are many conditions that lead to death and few that promote life.
And third, the body is extremely vulnerable and fragile, and the time of death, therefore, is uncertain. And I was going through them, the the first one the first one of those topics there. There is no certainty with regards to lifespan in Jambudvipa, which is why the time of death is uncertain. First, in general, the lifespan of of the beings in the continent of Uttarakuru is set and for most beings of the other continents there is more certainty even though we may not be sure that the full extent of the lifespan of each individual be reached. For the beings of Jambudvipa, the lifespan is extremely uncertain.
In the beginning, they they even reach reached immeasurable immeasurable years. Afterward, there is a maximum duration of ten years. And even nowadays, it does not seem certain whether they die in their old age, in their youth, or in the middle. And then, Geshe-la was reading the quote from the the treasury of knowledge. Again, here here, it is uncertain.
In the end, ten years, at first, immeasurable. And then again Geshe-la was just saying how that points out to the different lifespans that we have experienced in in this continent, and then he goes on to read the the rest of the text through taking to heart the fact that your gurus, your lamas, or friends, and so forth have died through sudden sudden internal or external conditions for death before reaching the end of their lives. You should think over and over again are to be of a similar quality. And, Geshe-la was saying how it will also be beneficial if we were to think to think that way, if we were to contemplate that. We refer to, you know, since from from our childhood up until now, again, we have seen many people.
We have known many people who have died, and they have died for for various reasons in different ages and for in different, by the force of different conditions or the force of diseases or whatever it may be. There are so many different reasons why people die and and and contemplating that can can be very beneficial. Conditions that lead to death and few conditions that promote life. And I was going through the text again, since there are many harmful influences, animate as well as inanimate to this life, you should thoroughly consider how it is threatened by human beings and nonhuman influences, how there are types of animals that endanger one’s body and life through manifold harm, and likewise, how both internal illnesses and external elements cause cause harm. And, again, if if if we think about it again, we will see how many conditions there are.
And then again, Geshe-la goes for the Thai saying, it is quite clear again. Furthermore, one’s body is necessarily formed from the four elements, and they too harm each other if their domains expand or diminish out of balance, thereby causing illness and ravaging one’s life. And and, again, since they exist simultaneous with oneself, Even though body and life appear to be stable, they cannot be relied cannot be relied on. This one. And we have this quote then from the parinirvāṇa Sūtra, the discrimination of death is that this life, constantly surrounded by hostile enemies, weakens in each moment and that there is nothing that increase it increases.
And and and again, Geshe-la is pointing out how this is actually so, how this is quite factual. From the moment we were born, we every moment that passes, we only get closer and closer to death. And there is no way there’s nothing that can be done to increase it. There’s no way that can give more time to us. And again, we have from the precious garland, we we have that quote, we live amidst the conditions for the lord of death like a butter lamp in a gale.
Geshe-la was just pointing out how how again how how how our lives again are just like this butter lamp. Again, in a moment in in a moment, moment, it it disappears. It comes to nothing. So again, pointing out how life is impermanent and then how how life is is unreliable. And and goes on to read the the next sentence.
Besides, life itself permeates the reality of death since many conditions for life are unreliable. And Geshe-la is pointing out how even those those things that that cause life are in the nature of death itself. For example, the the very fact of birth or or coming into existence, again, is the cause of death itself. Does that making sense? And, again, we have another quote from the precious garland which reads, there are many conditions for death.
Those for living are only few. Even they may well be deadly. Therefore, always practice the Dharma. And and, again, so all those things that that nurture life, that sustain life, which we you know, such as food and medicine and so forth. Again, even even those things cannot stop one from dying.
They are not really in the nature of of that of that life itself, of the life force itself. They they cannot stop one from dying even before it’s not separated or or or does not lack those things that one still still dies. And then Geshe-la goes on to the next topic. The body is extremely vulnerable, and at the time of death and and then the time of death, therefore, is uncertain. The body is as vulnerable as a water bubble.
Therefore, this and that, such as a a a thorn piercing, may occasion the destruction of life without the need for major harm. Thus, it is easy to overcome by conditions of death. And then we have this other quote from the precious garland so from the letter to a friend, which says that if if physical things, the ground, Mount Meru, the ocean, and so forth, are burned up by the seven blazing suns and even ashes are not left behind, what it is there to mention exceeding feeble human beings? And then, OGeshe-la moves on moves on to the next topic, which is then the decision. Following those reasons, again, the decision that is necessary to practice Dharma from now on.
And as I was going from the text again, at the end of of of at the end of thoughts like these, you should reiterate many times the inmost decision to practice the Dharma from this very moment for it is uncertain when the body and life will be overcome by the lord of death, and it should not be assumed that there is still time. As Shri Kamalashila said, O lord of earth, as long as this borrowed body abides in pleasure, not sick, not decayed, at that time, take its essence. Without the fears of illness, death, decay, in times of illness, old age and decay, you may be concerned, but to what avail? And then so then again, Geshe-la was just saying, again, it is explaining that verse. Just saying, again, it is at this time that we are healthy without any free of any illness and and and so forth that we should this is a time that we should be practicing.
Because when we get old and so forth and so forth again, we won’t be able to practice. So this is the time to do so. And then as a conclusion, again, among the three root thoughts, the thought about the uncertainty of the time of death is the most important, which is why you should make apply great effort in need.
Yeah. I was just asking. What date is the day? And Geshe-la says, today is seven because tomorrow is the eighth, the beginning of the Olympic. I just joking, saying that my TV broke, and it’s all I saying.
So I’m I’m a complete destitute. I have no more friends. No. Oh, Just so if I understood that Maybe you you know this better than, of course, better than me because I am not up to it. But, Geshe-la was saying that it was just these four guys, two American, one English, one Scottish, and they was were protesting about the situation in Tibet and put the flag up.
Isn’t it? Which flag is that? The Tibetan flag? Tibetan flag on the flag. Oh, He wants to give me that old television that you have in your house.
Good luck. Yeah. Don’t want that. I don’t want that. He says, you have I have to buy I have to buy a new television.
I said, no. Why? I don’t have the money for that. Go on the streets and you’ll find someone. You’ve seen many.
Oh. Those people in the back room are married. That’s a good one. They’ve also Buddha house. I cannot take that one.
Cannot take that one. Any any questions? Yes, please. Thank you. You’re welcome.
When we take a new body after we die, do we notice we have a new body, a different body? Or or do and and also, do we remember Geshe-la was saying no. To remember former lives is extremely difficult. It’s a different thing that that but Geshe-la acknowledges that there that there are a few people who do have some very strong imprints or some very strong propensities, and they and they might have some some idea about their previous lives. But but that is extremely difficult to remember that after the mind has separated from the body.
That’s very difficult. Also, if if somebody has attained to ability to recollect former lives. And Geshe-la is pointing out that in this in the current how to say, in this present life, in the present life that we have right now, this this the the mind or the consciousness that we have or the awareness that we have and there are infinite ways to translate that but this mind which is arises in dependence on this body is a very coarse mind. This mind that we have right now is a mind that arises in dependence on this body and is very coarse. Whilst if we train we are aware only of that mind.
If we train on meditation, if we train on calm abiding meditation so forth and we develop an awareness of the subtle mind, then again that subtle mind is a mind that does not, that remains quote unquote unchanged from life to life and and does not depend on the on this body so much. And if you can access that subtle mind, then you can you could start recollecting those things. Is that making sense? If you cannot remember the previous life, how can you recognize? No.
We cannot. And Geshe-la is imposing to you the question, do you recognize the difference? No. We don’t. Is that okay?
That’s an answer. Yes? Does a does a Buddha have the same experience of impermanence, change, and and death as someone who hasn’t achieved Buddhahood? That’s a good question. So it’s it’s like this, and it might become a bit technical, but the whole idea is yes the Buddha, a Buddha is also impermanent, is also momentary so in that it also changes from moment to moment but there’s a there’s a difference because the body of a Buddha or the whole being of the Buddha is uncontaminated, not contaminated.
It means that those changes are not occurring by the force of contaminated actions and afflictive emotion conceptions as as it occurs to us. So so that answers the first half of your question. Is do they experience impermanence or or the momentary change? Yes. There is this basic fundamental difference.
Then so and I said, and do they die? And guess what I was gonna say? And that’s up they die if they want to. It’s up to them. Is that okay?
Did that answer the question? Yeah. I I don’t understand the second part of the answer. Say that again. This I I didn’t understand the second part of the answer.
Which is? That they die if they want to. So and Geshe-la is just giving us an illustration. For example, when the Buddha Śākyamūni, he came to this planet, And then and then and then he he passed away. He he died.
And and, again, that that was because he he saw no more benefit in him staying. So he saw benefits the other way around and him and him passing away. So so because there were no more more more benefit and he’s staying around, he’s hanging around for his students, for his disciples, so forth, he passed away. If there were still benefit to to ensue from his presence, then he would stay. He would remain.
Can I ask one more question about that? Yeah. If if if if, conventionally, we understand death by the the the separation of the consciousness from the body. What does that mean? Does that mean That his consciousness separates from his body?
Yes. They separate us. Yes. That was in the the case of Buddha Śākyamūni, again, his his body and mind separated. Yes?
How do we go about it? So, yes, this is all that we do here, basically. And, again, the virtuous virtuous actions and virtuous activities that we engage in, they they enable us to attain a precious human rebirth. And, again, our practice our practice practice that we make, they they implant or they they create imprints. And let me put it this way.
They create habitual imprints. They create the habits. And, again, you meet those habits in in in the more virtues you you practice, the more imprints you have, the more habitual tendencies to engage in virtue you have in future lives. More. So, again, we we also have to you know, we we engage in virtuous actions, virtuous activities, and then we we also we make aspirational prayers that the the those virtues become the causes of our attaining, you know, a precious human rebirth, of our meeting with the lamas and the buddhas, and our our engaging in the Dharma, practicing the Dharma, and continuing this work.
And that’s how we go about it. Okay? Does does the first instance of consciousness in a new life come from the last instance of consciousness in the previous life, or does it sort of go or does the last instance of consciousness in the previous life sort of go through that intermediate state. You know? I mean, logically, one instance of consciousness comes from a previous one, it?
Mhmm. Nothing. So does it go through from, say, from last moment of consciousness in a death? Does that sort of go through, you know, the intermediate state and come through, or does the first instant come from So there are there are two ways. There there’s a the answer is yes and yes.
It comes in in dependence on the last moment of the previous life and also comes in dependence on the last moment of the intermediate state. Difference is in the causal in explaining the causal relationships, one is the direct cause, the actual cause, and the other one is the indirect cause. So the last moment of one’s existence in the intermediate state before one was born into this life is the direct cause. And that that moment of the previous life before you went into intermediate state, the last moment of the previous life before you enter the intermediate state is an indirect cause. But the causal relationship is the the cause of chain is is the same.
So that present consciousness of first moment of consciousness of this life, of the present life, arise in dependence on the last moment of consciousness of the last life, and there is an indirect relationship there. And also arise in dependence on the last moment of consciousness of the intermediate state life, and there’s a direct relationship there because of the proximity. Consciousness of of the mind or of of the present of the present day, it comes in dependence on the last moment of of of the mind or the consciousness mind or the consciousness of yesterday. Right? And they and that’s the, you know, the direct relationship, the direct causation there.
And then if you can you can go on as far back as as you wish all the way to childhood and all the way into previous lives, and one moment flows from the next, from the previous one. One moment falling from the previous one. And and and all those moments all the way to previous lives they are indirect causes they have this indirect causal relationship one comes in dependence on the other is that okay Indirect. Yes. Okay?
No. Oh, you know, like, the last moment of mine before you die would be similar to I’m just saying Before falling asleep. Before you go to sleep. You know? Yes.
So it’s such a subtle consciousness in the in Yeah. So, yeah, you could apply this analogy. If I wasn’t saying yes, you know, they have a coarse mind when you are awake, then you have a a type of subtle mind when we are asleep. It’s not exactly they are they are subtle minds. The both the mind of the intermediate state and the mind of of sleep.
They’re not the same because the the mind of sleep is still connected to the body, whilst the mind of the intermediate state is separated from the body. The connection is severed. So, yeah, the analogy applies. Yes. Question.
Can a a a deep awareness of the subtle moments of death, you know, the subtle death, does that can that actually give rise to an understanding of emptiness? So, you know, the the. Absolutely. So Geshe-la is explaining it in this way, and I’m not sure if that’s what you meant, but that this this this is one way to to answer that question, which is which is pretty easy. Geshe-la was gonna say, yes.
It does benefit because when you have realized subtle impermanence, you have generated a very strong conviction on on impermanence and death, and that leads you to engage in Dharma practice, in Dharma studies and practice, and having that that leads you to develop renunciation. And having developed that renunciation, a wish to be free again, you you make all the effort that is necessary to accomplish the goal of of liberation, and that and that and that naturally leads to eventually realizing emptiness. So it it does benefit you, understand, but I think that’s not what you meant, is it? You meant by seeing the momentary Yeah. By actually seeing those moments Yeah.
Moments of of of subtle of death in every moment. If you Of birth and death. The momentary of the arising and the disintegration of phenomena. Seeing that understanding or a deep concentration You mean you mean that with a deep concentration, you can see. You can actually see that.
Is that where you might find an understanding or at least begin to find The three is I I want to yeah. It’s that. Right? That’s what she think that’s what she Yeah. You know, there’s obviously a moment by moment death.
Every moment dies and a new one begins, doesn’t it, in a moment? That’s You know, sound everything changes in a moment in a momentary level. And I’m wondering if you have a deep awareness of the death of those moments passing and finding it, I don’t know, perhaps some space in between and understanding those moment to moment deaths. Am I elaborating too much here that you might have a concept or begin to have an understanding of emptiness? I’m just wondering if that’s a place to seek to look for an understanding.
Do you understand? I do I do know what you’re talking about. Yes. And I think you you got something right there. Okay.
So, look, it’s an excellent question. It’s a very difficult and technical thing also. So the whole thing is so Geshe-la is explaining there’s there’s a one way of explaining this this momentariness from the the lower schools, the lower tenet schools of Buddhism, which talk about the birth or the arising of a phenomenon, the abiding, and the disintegration of the phenomenon. So the birth, the abiding, and the death of the phenomena moment by moment. This is the the lower schools.
They they assert that there is these three moments, so to speak. And in the Middle Way Consequentialist, we don’t assert we assert that in the very moment of arise or the very moment of birth is the very same moment of disintegration of death. Now I was saying so then for the force of our concentration, for the force of, you know, having attain calm abiding, in dependence on the calm abiding, if you can if you can actually directly see that disintegration, does that benefit your realization of emptiness? And Geshe-la was saying? Well, no.
And his answer is gonna become very clear and not not nothing to be disappointed about. It is going to help you to get rid of the view that grasps to permanence, which is a very important realization. But it’s not gonna help you specifically realize emptiness because whilst you are realizing the momentariness of phenomena, you are not realizing the fact that whilst you search for the way of existence of phenomena, you cannot find it. You’re seeking two different things there. Yeah.
So you you are gonna realize what you are seeking, which is impermanence. Yeah. Okay. Does that make sense? Yeah.
I wonder. Okay. Yeah. Which On the other hand, if you have realized calm abiding to that point that you can realize impermanence, wow. Go for it.
You can realize anything in a minute. Does that make sense? Is that correct? You want to add anything to that? You want to question him?
And so then I just just to and then just to say again, Geshe-la was saying again, making clear that there’s not a a a direct causal relationship there. If you are if you are meditating on calm abiding or especially special insight, it doesn’t mean that necessarily you’re going to realize emptiness just because of that. You have to actually apply yourself to the question or or the object to seek the particular object of meditation, and then you can do that. So, Geshe, I was pointing out that the the the way of of holding the object in whilst you are meditating on calm abiding or whilst you are meditating on subtle impermanence, is a different way of holding the object — it’s a different object altogether. So you you get what you seek, basically.
But still, I know I was making and then I was trying to make the point. But still, if you have attained calm abiding, you have attained special insight, if you were able to realize subtle impermanence, then if you want and you end up studying emptiness and so forth then for you who have already attained calm abiding it will be easier for somebody who has not attained calm abiding. It I don’t I do that, and I don’t even think of death. Whether I would take a shower or not. Because if I die, nobody will care that this body taken a shower this morning or haven’t had a shower for weeks.
And I don’t really bother to cook good food for myself because if I die tonight, I don’t I don’t care this body that the stomach is full, half empty, or completely empty. Okay. So So if I’m thinking about all those and I leave that day and I go into the the extreme, not And Geshe-la was was saying if if that is all that occurs to you, then then, yes, there is there is an extreme. There is not the middle way. But the actual realization of impermanence and death, again, if you have actually realized that very deeply in your heart and you become a real chöpa, a real Dharma practitioner.
If you are such, then yes, you will leave all those silly activities behind, but you will practice Dharma and unstoppably, the best Dharma practice ever. And the fact is, and Geshe-la is just pointing out, that the fact is that we are not real chöpas. We are not real Dharma practitioners because we have not realized impermanence properly and and and and consistently. Is that making sense? Is that okay?
We are we are not such real chöpas, real Dharma practitioners in that sense. Because if we if we have really realized that impermanence and death, and, again, we will have given up any concern or interest for this life, and we’ll be practicing Dharma. That’s and that’s for real. That’s the real thing, Geshe-la was saying. And this one.
What was that? For for this last topic? Which which page is that? Decision to. Practice Dharma.
From now on, you know, you didn’t Oh, you you die without having had to practice Dharma. I just we just saw that. Did you understand? You mean to say that this is a reason to practice the Dharma but not to realize impermanence and death? Yeah.
Doesn’t establish the certainty of death. Okay. What is this? I’m very weak at debate. Yeah, death is certain and then there is the three reasons and Geshe-la was saying that the third reason that we will not have time to practice Dharma in this life Does not establish the certainty of that.
And there seems to be a conflict of interest because the and and this is there seems a conflict of of of in terms of logic. But in terms of of of what it was meant to accomplish, what accomplish, it still works. So that seems How can I say that? If if you take the subject, death is certain, and and you put the argument which is this argument here that you don’t have time to practice Dharma in this life. He says, we’ll talk about it later.
Okay. It seems that yeah. You talk you talk later. Irrespective of of what it may it may seem logically, logically, it is still the whole point is that it it does all of it that is here helps us to practice to be better people. Life goes quicker.
Yeah. Yeah. But I do know what you’re talking about because it seems to be including the fear that we’re not gonna be able to practice the Dharma. But having already realized that we’re gonna die quick, if we’re gonna die, we’re gonna die quick, and then yeah. But it but it seems to establish a different argument.
But it’s okay. It’s all it all works.
Key terms in this teaching
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- four seals
- The four basic tenets that define Buddhism. They are: all compositional phenomena are impermanent, all contaminated phenomena are by nature suffering, all phenomena are empty of self-existence and nirvana is true peace. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- Jambudvipa Rose-apple Land; dzam bu ling (Tib)
- Of the four continents surrounding Mount Meru in Buddhist cosmology, this is the southern continent where human beings live. The other three continents are Godaniya in the west; Kuru in the north and Videha in the east. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- parinirvana
- The final nirvana the Buddha attained when he passed away in Kushinagar, India. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
When we take a new body after death, do we notice it is a different body, and do we remember our previous lives?
No, we do not notice the difference, and remembering former lives is extremely difficult. A few people have very strong imprints or propensities and may have some idea of their previous lives, but remembering after the mind has separated from the body is very hard. The mind we have now arises in dependence on this body and is very coarse, and we are aware only of that mind. Through meditation, such as calm abiding, one can develop awareness of the subtle mind, which remains unchanged from life to life and does not depend so much on this body. If one can access that subtle mind, one could start recollecting past lives.
Does the first moment of consciousness in a new life arise from the last moment of the previous life, or from the last moment of the intermediate state?
Both. The first moment of consciousness in this life arises in dependence on the last moment of the intermediate state, which is the direct cause because of proximity. It also arises in dependence on the last moment of the previous life before entering the intermediate state, which is an indirect cause. The chain of causation is the same. Likewise, today's consciousness arises directly from yesterday's consciousness. One can go back as far as one wishes, through childhood and into previous lives, with each moment flowing from the one before. All those earlier moments in previous lives are indirect causes, each arising in dependence on the other.
Can a deep awareness of the subtle moments of death give rise to an understanding of emptiness?
Yes, it benefits one, though indirectly. Realizing subtle impermanence gives a very strong conviction about impermanence and death. That conviction leads a person to engage in Dharma study and practice, and this in turn leads to developing renunciation, a wish to be free. Having developed renunciation, one makes all the effort necessary to accomplish the goal of liberation, and this naturally leads to eventually realizing emptiness. The answer was given as one straightforward way of responding, though the speaker wondered whether it was what the questioner actually meant.
If we deeply perceive the momentary death of phenomena through calm abiding, does that give us a realization or understanding of emptiness?
Not directly. Perceiving momentary disintegration helps remove the view that grasps at permanence, which is an important realization, but it does not specifically realize emptiness. Realizing momentariness and realizing emptiness seek different objects: in the first you realize impermanence, while emptiness is realized by searching for how phenomena exist and finding that it cannot be found. You get what you seek. Calm abiding or insight does not necessarily cause realization of emptiness; you must apply yourself to that particular object of meditation.