Lam Rim 2002 Bodhisattva Deeds — 2002-02-26

42 min · 2,570 words · 26 February 2002 · Buddha House Adelaide

Lam Rim 2002 Bodhisattva Deeds (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Lam Rim 2002 Bodhisattva Deeds (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Lam Rim 2002 Bodhisattva Deeds — 2002-02-26
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. “You Cannot Be Sure of Appearances” is the Lamrim section Geshe Pema Tsering unpacks in this 42.5-minute commentary. He opens by reviewing the three motivational scopes — small, intermediate, and great — before turning to the session’s central argument: karma so distorts perception that practitioners cannot trust their own judgments about their teacher’s faults. Candrakīrti’s image anchors the discussion — hungry ghosts see a river as blood and pus, humans see water, gods see nectar — followed by a string of illustrative stories: Asaṇga perceiving Maitreya as a mangy dog, Tilopa mistaken for a mad fisherman, a Tulku with hepatitis seeing his silver reliquary glow gold. Pabongka Rinpoche’s practical conclusion closes the session: when doubts about the guru arise, examine them carefully rather than suppress them, the way one checks a stain before washing.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 15 LR 2002 02 26.mp3

UUID: 3ddba20f-cd44-4fca-a3e9-a43b5966789f

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Lam Rim 2002 Bodhisattva Deeds (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2002-02-26

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 42.5 minutes

Words: ~2,566

So here, in the in the words of Atisha, he recommends that, firstly, this life, which is full of many attractions, attractions, many different things that appear of many varieties and so forth, is very short. This life is very short, and much that’s attractive. Many different things appear or experience in this life. Also, there’s much to learn. There’s many different things to learn, many different things to acquire knowledge of.

And yet even so, we don’t know how long we’re gonna survive just when this life will end. And what we need to do is separate the dharma from nondharma. I need to be able to recognize what is of value, like a duck or certain types of swan and so forth are said to be able to separate milk from water. So if there’s milk mixed with water, they can actually separate the milk out. We need similarly to be able to separate the dharma from nondharma in in our daily experience.

So this life is brief. It has a fixed limit even though we might live to a hundred years and so on. Still, it’s limited. And even though the life or this particular life is short, most beings are engaged in samsaric activities. So really, because our life is limited and the danger of being engaged in samsaric or worldly activities is great, we need to comprehend this and train in a Dharma, separate Dharma from what is nondharma, just like, for instance, a duck is able to separate milk from water.

So we need to practice Dharma. And the reason why we need to practice Dharma is that we seek happiness and don’t want unhappiness. So then in practicing Dharma, there are three motivations, the small, intermediate, and great scope. So it’s here that we need to train in these different types of practice. So therefore, in the practice of Dharma on the basis of any of these three motivations will mean that that practice becomes a dharmic practice and will have a positive result.

So here, what determines something to be Dharma or non nondharma really depends on the motivation by which the action is entered. So here, the results also is dependent on the motivation. Therefore, with the motivation of wishing to attain a state of enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, it achieves the result of Buddhahood itself. It is the motivation of great scope. Then we have this motivation to attain a state of liberation from saṃsāra.

So that achieves the intermediate result of liberation. That is an intermediate scope practice. Then for the small scope, is the motivation to attain higher or high rebirth in one’s next life, either high status or high rebirth. And that is a small scope practice, and it’s of the least level of motivation. So here for ourselves, we seek to develop the highest level of motivation that is the great vehicle motivation.

And so there we need to investigate the nature of this. So since we aspire to developing the motivation of the great scope, the motivation of bodhicitta, then we need to keep this in mind and regularly investigate whether we’re establishing the mind of bodhicitta internally. So therefore, now we do a little motivation, a little meditation, and we would generate the motivation that I seek to attain the state of enlightenment in order to liberate all sentient beings and engage in the study of this treatise, this text. So we’ll meditate on this for a few moments. So here, now we’re dealing with this section, the division, you cannot be sure of appearances.

Which is on page two eighty three. So here it says that we cannot be appearances are not definite, and various things may arise in relation to our teacher. But we shouldn’t trust in these appearances. We cannot be sure of these appearances. In fact, we assert here that our teacher or guru, lama, is actually the Buddha.

And even though other appearances may arise in relation to that being, in actual fact, they are a Buddha. So as it says in the text, we accept that our present teachers are actually Buddhas, and their works are the works of or their actions are the actions of Buddhas. Even though we must assert this, still we tend not to see our teachers as being Buddhas. In fact, we tend to claim that they are ordinary beings. I see them as ordinary because I see this fault and that fault and so forth.

I see various faults arising. So to us, it appears as if they’re not actually Buddhas. So here we need to reflect on what what we actually see is uncertain and untrustworthy. It can’t be relied on. And this is because our particular perspective is derived from the karma, our own particular measure of karma that we have, how things appear to us.

And we’ve acquired through in our past lives various types of karma, one type here, another type there. So we have a certain type of karma. And it’s not easy for us to able to be able to discern what type of karma we’ve actually established or accumulated from the past. And in this regard, Candrakīrti says in the Madhyamakāvatāra, a hungry ghost thinks a running river is pus, and a human will tend to see water as water, and a divine being will tend to see water as being nectar. If they were all to look at the same vessel filled with water or what would appear to be water to a human, then a hungry ghost would tend to see it as being blood and pus.

A divine being would tend to see it as nectar by the power of their karma. And not only this, to a hungry ghost, the moon in summer seems to be hot, whereas the in winter, the sun appears to be cold. So this is the particular result of karma that is experienced by hungry ghosts. And furthermore, in the Kālacakra tantra, the world, for instance, is described as being spherical, whereas in Abhidharma, the world is described as being square in shape in accordance with Mount Meru and so on. So this also is dependent on the particular karmic predispositions of those two types of disciple, where one type tends to see the earth as being spherical and the other as being square.

And these days, again, we have a further type of person who tends to discount, for instance, the existence of Mount Meru altogether. So science these days tends to negate the existence of Mount Meru. So there’s different teachings appropriate to beings with different types of karma. And again, another example is Ārya Asaṇga, who saw the venerable Maitreya as a dog. He appeared as a dog with paralyzed hind legs and afflicted by maggots and so forth.

Yeah. Then there’s another story about a particular monk called Buddhajñana who saw the Acharya Manjushrimitra, who was a virtuous being and a monk. But he saw him. He appeared as if he were a monk who lived with a woman, plowed a field, and ate soup made from worms. So this was an appearance that Buddhajnana actually experienced in relation to this other person.

And then also the great mahasiddha Tilopa was viewed by the local people as just a mad fisherman, someone who lived on the river and ate raw fish. But in fact, in actual reality, he was a great adept, a great practitioner. And even Tilopa’s disciple Naropa had the appearance of his master cooking raw fish, grilling up raw fish to eat. And also, there’s another story of a particular practitioner called Krishna Acharya who saw Vajravārāhī, this great being, as a leper woman. So to him, this great practitioner, Vajravārāhī, actually appeared in the form of a leper woman.

So therefore, we should be glad at present that our teacher appears in a form that’s accessible to us, that’s appropriate to us, and they don’t appear as an animal such a horse or a dog or a donkey. We actually see them as a human being, so we should rejoice in our fortune at having an appropriate appearance or having our teacher appear in an appropriate form. So here, the great practitioner has said that considering our great measure of evil karma that we’ve accumulated in the past and the resulting obscurations that arise, we can draw consolation in seeing the guru as a human. In fact, in the past, we’ve accumulated this vast number of negative actions which remain with us up until the present, this does act to obscure our vision, yet we should draw consolation from the fact that our teacher does appear as a human to us. So also, we have great merit not to see them as a dog or a monkey, and we pay reverence from our very heart.

We should pay reverence from our heart, oh you child of Śākyamūni. So this advice was given by Geshe Chekawa. Furthermore, the appearances are untrustworthy, as the text says. Since everything appears to be established truly existent, one might draw the wrong conclusion that therefore things truly exist. Therefore, appearances arise for practitioners.

Again, it’s said that once a thirsty monk who went in search of water actually came across a ghost who was walking on the river Ganges or the river Ganga. And even though they were thirsty and they were walking from the river, they didn’t realize that they were doing so. So they had the appearance that they weren’t walking on the river. And so various appearances arise according to the karma of different beings. And also, as the text continues, just because we cannot see ghosts or, in fact, Gandharvas or smell eaters, there’s no proof that they don’t exist.

And the reason why that is is that in the text called the Pramānavārttika, which is the commentary to valid awareness, there is a discussion on how we cannot accept simply because we don’t see something that it doesn’t exist. So this is very important in establishing that what we don’t see or things that we don’t see don’t necessarily not exist. And then further, at present, are not fortunate enough to see the teacher or the guru as a real Buddha because we do not have the the mental continuum of a person fortunate enough to do so because we lack that. Therefore, we don’t see things in that way. So in fact, here we don’t have the particular karma that would permit us to see the actual way our guru is.

Simply by not seeing them as a Buddha doesn’t mean that they are not a Buddha, or simply seeing them as a guru or as a Buddha doesn’t really mean that they are in fact a Buddha. Here, there is a certain degree of doubt that we have. So just because they don’t appear to be a Buddha doesn’t mean that they are not a Buddha. So here, there’s it’s there is doubt about whether one’s teacher is a Buddha even though he appears as ordinary. And even if he appears as a Buddha, there is some doubt about whether, in fact, he actually is a Buddha.

In other words, there is generally some level of doubt. As it says in the text, even when someone does not seem to be a Buddha, it need not follow that they are not a Buddha. And even when he really appears to be a Buddha, we cannot be sure that he is one. Once when the Arhat Upagupta, the fourth Buddhist patriarch in India, was teaching Dharma, a particular demon, Mara, caused a disturbance. And Upagupta, the Arhat, subdued the demon and said, I’ve never met the Buddha, so please emanate an exact likeness of him.

So they had this conversation, and Upagupta requested Mara to appear as Śākyamūni Buddha to him. And so the demon emanated in the form of the Buddha, complete with all the major and minor marks. But in seeing the vision of the Buddha in front of him manifested by Kamadeva, Upagupta, the arhat, who in fact was a liberated being, began to prostrate to that appearance of a Buddha, at which point the demon stopped the manifestation, preventing him from prostrating to him. So there such appearances can arise. Also, it’s said in ancient times, there were great masters like Nāgārjuna, and they appeared to be ordinary beings.

They appear to be ordinary monks. But in actuality, they were fully awakened Buddhas. So then the text further goes on to say that even then, still, if misconceptions about one’s teachers’ faults arise or one’s guru’s faults arise, we should not put an end to them right away. For example, before we wash dirty clothing, we first check the stains that exist in the dirty clothing to see just exactly what type of stain it is, what’s gonna get it out, and so forth. Similarly, we should allow such mis misconceptions about, our guru’s faults to arise.

We should allow these thoughts to manifest. And why is that? Because we don’t know whether the guru has these seeming faults or not. And as Pabongka Rinpoche said, he’s already pointed out, why shouldn’t karmic appearances be mistaken? So then as Pabongka says, as I’ve already pointed out, why shouldn’t karmic appearances be mistaken, and especially here in relation to one’s teacher and their faults and so forth.

For instance, then he says, a white conch appears yellowish to someone with a bile disease or someone with hepatitis and so on. And a person with wind disease or an excess of wind or lung can see a snow capped mountain to be bluish in color due to the imbalance of or an excess of wind. And to someone sitting in a boat, trees or someone sitting in a train or a car, the trees on the shore may seem to be actually moving instead of the boat and so on. And also that those that are afflicted by cataracts can have the appearance of hair falling in front of them. So this is an appearance that arises for those that have that type of eye affliction.

Although there’s no hairs falling, it appears as if they’re falling. So there’s many examples of mere appearance arising, which is mistaken. So then as Pabongka continues. So trivial and temporary causes of error can obscure much for us. So if that can be the case, why should we not be mistaken about existing things, since we are permeated with immeasurable causes of error such as karma and afflictions?

And Pabongka continues, that he knew a particular Tulku, or reincarnate lama, who went on pilgrimage, and there he contracted, probably contracted hepatitis. And with hepatitis, things began to appear yellow or with a golden hue. And he actually had what’s called a gao, which is this box in which one places one’s statues and other precious objects and often carries it around one’s neck or placed here in front of oneself. And so when he was sick, it appeared to him with a golden hue, which was very attractive. And later when he when he got better, it again began to appear silver, which was a little bit disappointing to him.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Mount Meru
The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
valid awareness pramana (Skt); tshema (Tib)
A new non-deceptive cognition. There are two types: valid perception, such as the eye consciousness seeing a flower, and valid inference, such as inferring fire from seeing smoke. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top