44 min · 3,025 words · 20 August 2002 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 44-minute talk, Geshe Pema Tsering argues that a five-cent offering given with full motivation outweighs a ten-thousand-dollar gift made without it — the greatness of generosity depends entirely on the mind. He first lays the doctrinal groundwork: Tsongkhapa’s three types of suffering (suffering of suffering, suffering of change, and the subtler pervasive conditioning), how recognising them generates renunciation, and how renunciation turned toward all beings becomes bodhicitta. He then explains why bodhicitta alone is insufficient — wishing to reach India won’t get you there — and briefly maps the six perfections across the two accumulations needed for Buddhahood. He closes by examining generosity in depth: defined as a mental factor of willingness rather than the amount given, structured around motivation, execution, and dedication, and elevated further when paired with an awareness of emptiness.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 04 LR 2002 08 20.mp3
UUID: 1bc14080-f5d7-4b78-8758-f5e55096798a
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Lam Rim 2002 Bodhisattva Deeds (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2002-08-20
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 44.5 minutes
Words: ~3,019
The great master Tsongkhapa in his text called the Three Principal Aspects of the Path has stated that the beings in the cyclic existence or saṃsāra are saṃsāra leads to suffering and lacks happiness because of lacking or not understanding the renunciation or wish to free from cyclic existence. Therefore so therefore because of this, because of lacking the understanding of the renunciation and they abound in the suffering of cyclic existence and do not have any understanding or realizations of the the love and compassion, the perfect view or or the perfect view or the view of wisdom realizing emptiness. And so this is how the circles in the cyclic existence. So the in order to attain enlightenment or gain through all the develop the bodhicitta and so forth, first one has to develop so called the renunciation or wish to free from samsaric existence.
Therefore, from the very beginning of the practice should develop a renunciation. So in order to develop a renunciation, one has to see the faults or the disadvantages of cyclic existence. And to see the faults of the cyclic existence or disadvantages of the cyclic existence, one has to recall the sufferings of the cyclic existence, which are the main three sufferings of the cyclic existence are so are the suffering of suffering, suffering of change and suffering of pervasive conditioning. And out of those three sufferings, the first one, the suffering of suffering, is very easy to recognize or it’s easy to recognize even the animals, they can understand the suffering of suffering. And it is hard for us to see the disadvantages or the faults of the suffering of change and suffering of pervasive conditioning.
It is because because we mistaken those suffering as happiness due to this We don’t we we can’t see the faults of those. And the suffering of change which we mistaken them as happiness, it is because we always see them as happiness and happiness like having a great enjoyment or a wealth and attachment to it, the shapes or the appearance and self appearance and the worldly happiness which give a certain level or certain amount of comfort or the pleasure for the body and the mind. So for those which we see them as happiness but in reality by nature they are all in the nature of suffering. Hardest one is to this to to hardest one is to understand or see this the see the the faults of the sufferings of of pervasive conditioning. It is really subtle and hard to understand that the suffering of pervasive conditioning is the one we can either call it the contaminated body or call it subtle consciousness or a very subtle consciousness which enters mother’s womb or takes rebirth from the very beginning of the the Samsāra or the birth and which is the one that goes to the next life and will travel until one achieves the state of enlightenment or the nirvana, the arhathood.
So one has been tortured or tortured by these three types of sufferings from the very beginningless of the birth or saṃsāra, and one will still be tortured by those three types of sufferings unless one attains the liberation or. So therefore it is important for one to realize or recognize those three sufferings and after having realized those sufferings then try and then develop a wish to develop a wish. An uncontrolled wish to free from those sufferings and such a mind or wish is called the renunciation. So, such a mind is called the renunciation and until yep. And until so as far as one has not abandoned the three As far as one has not abandoned the the three types of sufferings, one will not be one will not reach liberation and will be will undergo through those suffering.
So up till now, we have not experienced the ultimate happiness or reliable happiness, which is the happiness of arhathood or liberation state and the enlightenment state. And so up till now we are not able to experience those. So now onwards, try to achieve those and also put efforts to develop a wish to free from those sufferings which is a renunciation. And yeah. So so whenever one develop that uncontrollable wish to free from those sufferings and then convert or change the direction of that wish towards the entire sentient beings, Because entire sentient beings are same as oneself, that they do not wish sufferings and they are same as oneself being tortured by the sufferings.
So and because they are same as oneself, try to develop a compassion to free those sentient beings from the suffering. And yeah. So by developing a great compassion, then wishing that, seeing sentient beings go through the suffering and wishing to free them from sufferings. And having developed such wish, then one will think or look for methods or ability that who has, how can one able to free those sentient beings from the suffering. And it is one who will come into the conclusion that the only the Buddha has ability or potential to free those motherly sentient beings from the suffering.
So by knowing so, then then one wish to develop a a wish, yeah, to attain enlightenment or become Buddha in order to free sentient beings from the suffering. And striving for that enlightenment or Buddhahood is is is is the ultimate ultimate goal or our final goal. So with the intention of wishing to attain enlightenment for the sake of entire sentient beings or in order to free sentient beings from the suffering. And and and and such a mind is called yep. Such a mind is called the bodhicitta altruistic intention and and the altruistic intention.
So with such intention, then all the the virtuous one have cultivated and dedicate all these virtues to become a cause to attain enlightenment for the sake of entire sentient beings. And so on such mind, is bodhicitta, which should we should do and we will do a meditation here. So the last last week or previous class, we stopped at this the third division, one of the main division, which is how to train in the deeds of Bodhisattvas after generating the altruistic intention. And so so what it means is now it is developing just developing a mere wish which is altruistic intention is not good enough and just by mere wish one will not attain to enlightenment or or yeah enlightenment. And so after having developed such a such a mind, the altruistic intention, now one has to engage in the actions or actions which are like a path to enlightenment.
So actions of the bodhisattvas. And for example, just by mere wish to go to India is not good enough to reach India. So having having having developed a wish or a thought, then one has to go through the have to travel through the parts or a way to get in India, otherwise you won’t get it. So likewise, you have to train in the Bodhisattva deeds in order to reach the Buddhahood. So our goal is to attain the two kayas of the Buddha or two bodies of the Buddha, so called the form body and the Dharma body.
And so in order to attain those two bodies of the Buddha, one has to collect the accumulations of both the merit and the wisdom and accumulation of merit is to attain to the form body of the Buddha and accumulation of the wisdom is to attain the dharmakaya or Dharma body of the Buddha And the accumulation of merit is is the merit, whereas accumulation of the wisdom is that one has to realize the emptiness, or rather, with the wisdom realizing emptiness. So in terms of the the deeds of the bodhisattvas are many, but it but those the deeds of the bodhisattvas can be subsumed under the under two which are called the wisdom and the method. And those wisdom and method should come together in order to attain Buddhahood. So how the bodhisattva deeds are are subsumed under the wisdom and the method is the the the first five perfection the perfections from the generosity to the concentration are subsumed under the method.
By training in the method or the first five perfections, by training in those five perfections, one attains the form body of the Buddha. And the sixth one, the perfection of wisdom. And that wisdom, perfection of wisdom, or wisdom realizing — you can call it wisdom realizing emptiness or the special insight, the Lhaktong, the special insight of realizing emptiness. And by meditating on that and through this one attains the second kaya, which is the Dharmakāya, the wisdom body, yeah.
Sorry. The sub the the headings I’m holding is of the Great Exposition of the Graduated Path. And with that and that one is from the liberation part. Anyway, it’s pretty much similar. Yep, so and it has the two divisions, the how to train in the Bodhisattva deeds in general and has two main divisions called the first one is how to train in the six perfections, which ripen your mental continuum, and the second one is how to train in the four ways of gathering disciples which ripens the mental continuum of others. And those are the two main subdivisions..
Now the first back to the first one, six perfections which ripens your mental continuum. What? I’ll just leave that one part. It’s a bit slight difference in a way. So as for the first one, how to train the six perfections, train in the six perfections which ripens your mental continuum has the two divisions, which is training your mind in six perfections in gen yep.
In general. And and then second division, which is called and and training your mind. Yeah. Particularly, it’s training your mind in the last two perfections. The last two of the six perfections.
Yeah. How far? There are three divisions. First one is training in the six perfection in general, and second one is training your mind particularly or specifically in the last two perfections. And the last one is training your mind in the Vajrayāna vehicle.
So now the first one, back to the first division, which is training your mind in the six perfection in general, and that is training through the six perfections, perfections of giving, ethical discipline, patience, enthusiastic efforts, concentration, and the wisdom. And now to the first one, of giving, and the generosity, or the it it’s also been called called generosity as well. So and the definition of the giving is a mental factor of willingness to give one’s body, possessions, and the virtues or merit, which is called the practice of giving or the generosity. People sometimes misunderstand. They think the substance of the giving or the generosity is the generosity in but it is not.
The generosity is is is the is the secondary mind or a mental factor that is willingness to give. Got it. So in because people misunderstand of thinking that the substance of the giving is the practice of giving or is the first perfection practice of giving, then due to this, people say, I have done a great practice, a great giving today or or somebody he or she did a great giving or generosity. But in real it is the yeah. Designating a name of the great giving is not depends on the amount of the substance you’re giving or the money and so forth.
It’s the the the greatness of the giving depends on one’s mind. So so the the greatness of the giving is depends on one mind and which means is whether the practice of giving, on the particular giving, whether it has entirely the consists of the three practices, the preparation or the motivation and the actual actual practice and the conclusion. If the practice, even for example giving a five cent to somebody, if that giving has consist of those three — the motivation, actual practice, and the conclusion — then that generosity has become a great or a big generosity. And if somebody gives ten thousand dollars or even more, but that practice didn’t consist of those three requirements to become a great practice, which is motivation, actual practice and conclusion, then it and that even though given a huge amount, but it won’t become a great generosity or big generosity. So and as a result of that practice or the what the the merit of practicing giving the ten thousand dollars will be the less lesser than the giving of five cent, which which has entire requirement.
So so yep. If the the practice of generosity include are are done with the consists of those three — the motivation, actual practice, and the the conclusion, then one’s practice of generosity becomes a great generosity and the the merit of doing that practice would be huge or immense. And here the first one, the motivation is the motivation should be a motivation of attaining enlightenment for the sake of entire sentient beings therefore of our practice in order to attain enlightenment for the sake of entire sentient beings I shall do this practice of giving that’s motivation. And then during the actual giving or actual execution, then then one should offer it with the respect of the three doors, body, speech and mind, and give it very happily or with great pleasure. And at the end, the conclusion that which is the dedication, thinking that I have had a very fortunate time today to have this chance to practice my generosity and the merit I have gained out of doing this practice, and dedicate all the virtues and merit you gain for the attainment of enlightenment, which is for the sake of all sentient beings.
And if any the generosity got done through this way, then even the fifty cents will become or giving of fifty cents become a huge generosity. And without this, you pay hundreds of thousands, but it’s not a big generosity. And then so doing giving our practice of giving through that way is a is a great giving. And if that along with that practice of giving and if that practice is adorned with the understanding of emptiness then it will become even greater that adorned with the emptiness here the visualizing or establishing the substance of the giving and the object to whom we give, where we give the fifty cents and the giver yourself, right? And the and the adorn with the emptiness which is thinking that all the the three objects here are the absence of inherent existence or are there empty of inherent existence, then then that practice will become even greater and such practice will become the practice of the the combination of wisdom and the method.
And now in terms of giving, because there are three types of giving, so it becomes the three types first, the practice of giving perfection of giving has three types of three divisions, which is called the the giving teachings, the protection from fear, and then giving material objects. So and the the the giving of material object is it’s yeah. The yeah. It’s a mental it’s a mental continuum. So Mental factor or a secondary mind, which we have explained earlier, that it’s the mind which willingness to give.
And of material gift, and then the greater one can give, give one’s body or entire possessions and so forth. And in lesser than this one spoonful of tsampa, which Geshe-la said, here, it could be equivalent of just one lolly. So it is important to practice of So and yep. It may be difficult to practice such, but if one trained or trained one mind in through the practices of giving, then it will help one to practice the practices of generosity. Like in in in the past, in our earlier rebirths, we have taken numbers of rebirths.
And when we have been the many we have been kings many times like universal kings and so called Indra, as we’re born as Indra, we have born as the Brahman, and in our past lives and have been and also being a very rich people, very wealthy and lots of possessions, but we haven’t practiced the practice of generosity. And as a result, we are here now. And and and and so that is the disadvantage of not practicing generosity. So if one practice a generosity, and yeah. Practice generosity, maintain ethical disciplines.
And then even from even one does not have much. But as a result of practicing generosity, one will have received the result in future. And yep. So by practicing generosity, and as a result, one will have a good result result. And but in act by doing so, it will one will receive the the the the results of the practicing generosity.
But when when one is doing the practice of generosity, one should not think of the taking and the result or the result, which means that that well I’ll give this and then and I’ll get that or the result which I should practice generosity in a future life I will have a good result of doing should not give it that way. But even if you don’t think of that, you practice generosity, the result will come. So, yeah, should not think of those and during the practice of generosity should always have motivation and doing it for the sake of attaining enlightenment for the sake of entire sentient beings or or should give it with the goal with your aim of achieving enlightenment. And so if one practice with the motivation of bodhicitta or altruistic intention, then even one give a mouthful of food or the spoonful of tsampa, all this practice will become the perfection, become a bodhisattva’s deed and will become a cause to attain enlightenment. And briefly speaking, then that practice will become a great practice of giving.
Key terms in this teaching
- dharmakaya truth body; chö ku (Tib)
- The ultimate reality of a buddha’s enlightened mind, which is unborn, empty of true existence, free from conceptual thought, naturally radiant, beyond duality and spacious like the sky. One of the three embodiments of a buddha. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- kaya ku (Tib)
- Buddha-body or holy body. A body of an enlightened being. LYWA
- rupakaya form body; zug ku (Tib)
- The form body of a fully enlightened being; the result of the complete and perfect accumulation of merit. LYWA
- three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
- The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA
- two accumulations sambharadvaya (Skt); tsog nyi (Tib)
- Also called the two collections or two types of merit, they are: the merit of virtue, which develops the method side of the path by practicing generosity and so forth, and the merit of (transcendental) wisdom... LYWA
- two kayas ku nyi (Tib)
- The classification of a buddha's body into two: dharmakaya (truth body) and rupakaya (form body). LYWA
- Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
- The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.