Lam Rim — 2008-03-27

1 h 33 min · 5,986 words · 27 March 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide

Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Lam Rim — 2008-03-27
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Whether the Heart Sūtra counts as definitive or interpretive — the answer differing entirely by philosophical school — opens this 94-minute Lamrim commentary by Geshe Pema Tsering. He traces Madhyamaka and Mind Only definitions of both terms, then shows that practitioners already carry both scriptural and realization teachings in their mindstreams: the three trainings in morality, concentration, and wisdom are realization teachings accessible at every level, not distant attainments. He distinguishes analytical from placement meditation, urging beginners to prioritize analysis to build genuine certainty about impermanence and bodhicitta before settling into placement practice. The session’s sharpest point is a warning against sorting the Buddha’s words into good and bad — abandoning a class of sutras, the King of Concentration Sūtra declares, is graver than destroying every stupa in the world or killing arhats beyond number. A closing Q&A covers vow-breaking, pest control ethics, and how to distinguish intellectual knowledge from genuine realization, with the gradual fading of afflictions named as the reliable sign of real practice.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 06 2008 03 27 BP.mp3

UUID: ff6744c5-15a3-41f6-ac3f-75987c4a5906

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2008-03-27

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 93.7 minutes

Words: ~5,992

And again, Geshe-la says, so then those teachings which are suitable to be taken literally are those how can I say that? Pertain to the middle way consequentialist view. Can I say that? Those which take as the main subject, the middle way consequentialist view, those are the definitive sutras, the ones suitable to be taken literally. Then, those are interpretive, relating to the views of mind only schools and the schools below that.

How’s that? Did you get that? So then those sutras, the mind only schools and below, this way of dividing between definitive and interpretive, they say that a sūtra is definitive if it is suitable to be taken literally, and a sūtra is interpretive if it is not suitable to be taken literally. This is how the mind only schools and the two other schools of tenets, this is how they define interpretive and definitive. And the middle way consequentialist school of thought divides as: Those sutras which are definitive are those who teach the ultimate view.

Then those sutras which are interpretive are those who teach conventional truths. Ultimate one teach ultimate truth, and the other one teaches conventional truths. Okay? So then what is the Heart Sūtra, for example? The Heart Sūtra that we read every time before the class.

What is the Heart Sūtra? So is it definitive or interpretive? So then if for those who posit, who accept the middle way consequentialist view, then the the Heart Sūtra is a definitive sūtra because it mainly teaches about emptiness. And then Geshe-la was saying, so then now if if for a proponent of the mind only school, what is the Heart Sūtra? Is it interpretive or definite?

Geshe-la was then saying. For a proponent of the mind only school who does not posit that a definite sūtra a sūtra that mainly teaches ultimate truths which is teaching emptiness so even though the Heart Sūtra is mainly teaching about emptiness it is not a sūtra which is suitable to be taken literally so for them, it is interpretive. So then what is the Heart Sūtra? Definitive or interpretive. For the middle way consequentialist school, then it is definitive.

For the other schools, it is interpretive. And so all these all these things and interpretive and definitive sutras and all these things pertain to this this the, how to say, the scriptural teachings. And then Geshe-la was saying so then Geshe-la was explaining all these things about the scriptural teachings and now there’s the other sort of teachings which is the the realization of teachings and those are for example with the three trainings, for example. But also for the schools that posit the paths and the grounds, then the realizations are the paths and the grounds, the five paths and ten grounds of bodhisattva, so then the realization of emptiness, bodhisattvahood, and so forth. So for those schools that posit the the path on the grounds, the realization teachings are the realization of the paths and the grounds.

And for other schools, it will be the the the two trainings and so forth. It can be posited as the realization of teachings. And Geshe-la was saying, And then, Geshe-la was saying, again, regards to the Heart Sūtra, for example, the the Heart Sūtra, that teaching, that that realization is there in the actually there in the continuum in the mental continuum of of the buddha of Avalokiteśvara and Śāriputra who who were the ones who who expounded the sūtra we do don’t have this realization in our mental continuum just like they have what we have is by the force of our speech how can I say that By the force of our speech, we we have that we we have that as as a verbal expression of the Heart Sūtra? We have that we have the Heart Sūtra as a verbal expression. But yeah.

So in this way, we say And Geshe-la was saying so, then because we are followers of the Buddha, then we can say we say that we we have this we have this teachings of the Buddha. We have the scriptural teachings because we, for example, in the case of recite the Heart Sūtra. We verbalize the Heart Sūtra. So we have the scriptural teachings of the Buddha in our mind streams. And Geshe-la was in saying so then that that the Heart Sūtra, it was it was it was taught by the Buddha.

It is a it is a virtue that we that we cultivate. Was saying, no, that is how can I say that? Geshe-la was saying, is that the word of the Buddha? And that the word of the buddha? Geshe-la said: No, it is not the word of the buddha because the word of the buddha is what the buddha said at that time but that is what the buddha has said, that is what the buddha taught the difference being the two words in tibetan one is sung rab which makes reference to all the teachings that the buddha has given in the past and which is the actual speech of the Buddha, the actual words of the Buddha and so it is not the actual word of the Buddha because that was in the past but so it is a teaching of the Buddha.

It is a saying, something that the Buddha has said, expounded. And then Geshe-la was saying, as for the realization of teachings, we also have that. Even though we do not have the actual realizations themselves, because that will only start to attain when we first attain the path of accumulation, accumulation, then we have the actual realization itself. But we do have, for example, what we do have are those things which are concomitant, which are concordant with the actual realizations. I guess I wouldn’t say which are something like the three trainings which we do practice or the training morality, the training concentration, training wisdom.

And because we practice these trainings, and these trainings are concomitant, concordant with with the actual realization, then we say we can say that we we have the realization of teaching Geshe-la says again, Geshe-la poses that the three trainings as the realization of teachings. And and so the three trainings are the trainings in morality, the training in concentration, the training in wisdom. So in the case of the training morality, training morality is abandoning or giving up the ten non virtues. And in Geshe-la Wa Taisen, so if we practice well the training morality, then we get good results. Our practice is average, we get average results.

If our practice is little, if we protect, how to say, if we guard against just a little bit of faults then that’s the results we’re gonna get. Case I was gonna say, take, for example, the person who has only one vow that of not killing a human. So if but by avoiding the killing of humans, then even though it is only one vow, only one small practice, then that is the realization of training concerning pertaining to the training morality. So one has that training morality then. And, again, with regards to the training concentration, we also have that because all of us, and when we are not, we we all, how to say, train our minds, cultivate a single pointed placement of our minds.

It might be a single pointed placement of our minds in something like bodhicitta or impermanence or even when we are training in morality we single pointedly place our minds on the thought of not committing such and such non virtues. And that single pointed placement is concentration. That aspect of that we cultivate is concentration.. Mainly, Geshe-la was saying, when we’re talking about concentration, we are mainly we are talking most about we are talking about calm abiding, that we will call calm abiding, the training calm abiding or the attainment of calm abiding. So even though we might not have that, it’s still that aspect of our minds which is single pointedly engaged in the object, that is also concentration.

It can be said to be concentration. And again, Geshe-la says, with regards to the training wisdom, again, when we talk about the training wisdom, we’re mainly talking about the realization of emptiness. Even though we might not have that, again, something else which can be said to be called the training and wisdom. So everything, every sort of Geshe-la says, there are all sorts of minds of wisdom and even non virtues. So but those non virtuous minds, I guess, wouldn’t say but those which are virtuous minds of wisdom, they can start they they can start to be the training in wisdom.

So then and so then for example take for example when we are analyzing the teachings and saying oh this and such and such I should give up and such and such I should adopt and this comprehension, this sort of of understanding, this sort of this this sort of process, it’s called it’s called wisdom. And this is then our training in wisdom.. So then we do have these realizations of teachings in our mindstreams, isn’t it? And we do have the three baskets of teachings also in our mindstreams, isn’t it? By having those and practicing in these lines then we how to say better our practice and our knowledge more and more until we attain the final result.

So, again, Geshe-la says with going back to the text, what the text says, both scriptural and realization of teachings, and we saw right now how we do have both of them. And then again, just reading the final clause of that sentence, these two act as cause and effect. Causing if so both the scriptural teachings and the the realization of teachings, they act as cause and effect. The scriptural teachings are the cause, and the realization of teachings are the effect. Without the scriptural teachings as cause, there is no way for the realization to arise for the realizations realizations to arise.

And then again, to give an analogy, when there is a horse race, the horse is first shown the course. And afterwards, it runs there. It would be ridiculous to show that a course and then have the race elsewhere elsewhere. When it comes realizations, to attainments, how could it be appropriate to accomplish, to realize something after having determined something else through listening and real and and and through listening and contemplation and reflection? And again, just as as it is expressed in the in the stages of meditation by Kamalaśīla, then whatever has been realized by the wisdoms or the wisdoms that arise arise from listening and the wisdom that arises from contemplation is precisely what should be cultivated by means of the wisdom that arises from meditation, from practice, and and and not something else.

Just as a horse runs along the course that it has been shown, and Geshe-la pointed out to the analogy that has been given in the former paragraph of Lam Rim. And then, so then we we just finished that topic, which is how all the Buddha’s teachings come to to view as as personal instructions. So then we have covered previously in the previous teaching how all the teachings how to realize all the the teachings all the teachings as non contradictory, and now how all the teachings come into view as personal instructions, as shown above.. And then now we approach the next topic, which is teaching, how to say, analytical, an indication of analytical meditation as a means of making all teachings appear as instructions. Thus, through summarizing all the topics of the path set out in the excellent teachings and commentaries, starting from how to rely on a spiritual teacher up to calm abiding special insight, they are all condensed into the steps of practical application in terms of performing stabilizing meditation, where stabilizing meditation is required, analyzing with the wisdom of individual investigation where analytical meditation is required.

And, again, Geshe-la is then saying, then thereby, these instructions guide one so that all the teachings present themselves as instructions. Geshe-la was then saying, so then the teachings first, we we listen to the teachings. We study the teachings. Then having studied the teachings, contemplate the teachings. We reflect upon the teachings.

We do analytical meditation. We see this is this, and that is that. And then then that, we cultivate, how to say, placement meditation. We do the placement meditation on our understanding. And then Geshe-la says of of of the two types of meditation, there are then analytical meditation and placement meditation.

For us beginners, Geshe-la says, what the most important we should be practicing is analytical meditation, Geshe-la says. And that is because we haven’t found certainty yet about about anything yet. We haven’t found any certainty about impermanence. We haven’t found any certainty about bodhicitta. We haven’t found any certainty about emptiness.

We haven’t found any certainty about renunciation and so forth. So without having found any certainty because we haven’t found any certainty yet. That’s what we should be trying to establish, certainty about this this this subjects, these topics, and then analyze them through analytical meditation, then establish and develop certainty about them. And then, again, then the certainty develops that they should be understood as supreme instructions and the misconception that they should be understood as mere background knowledge for the Dharma rather than as actual instructions. This actual personal instruction is completely reversed in this way.

Geshe-la was saying so. When we start seeing when we start understanding that these teachings or every teaching is is personal instruction given to oneself, then again the thought will not occur that every single teaching is beneficial. The thought will not occur that there are teachings which are not beneficial. We’ll take every teaching, every single teaching as personal instruction to oneself. And then when we develop this condition, we will never think again of any teaching as not being important or or not being meaningful or not being beneficial and worthwhile and so forth.

So we’re following the next topic, which is then the greatness of allowing allowing one to easily discover to easily understand the conqueror’s intentions. So then the the greatness of allowing you to allowing you to easily discover the conqueror’s there’s two parts, which first, for beginners, the oral instructions. And then Geshe-la goes on, although the great texts, the teachings along with the commentaries form the supreme instructions completely, uneducated beginners cannot find the intended meaning even even though delving into them. I was gonna say again. So even though beginners put a lot of effort in them, they they they will not be able to perceive them as personal instructions.

And even and even if they find it, even if they find the meaning, the intended meaning, they spend a lot of time and enormous effort. And, again, the conqueror’s intention is found through a guru’s oral oral instructions. If they rely on a guru’s oral instructions and the like, it becomes easy to understand. Again, with the guidance of a lama and a guru, then one will be able to easily understand the meaning of the teachings. And again, so then the next topic, the fourth, which is the greatness of vices stopping by itself.

And there’s three parts with the first one saying that to say showing that the greatest the biggest mistake misdeed is abandoning the dharma. And Geshe-la was saying as for abandoning the dharma, there’s nothing worse than it because if one abandons the dharma, one will spend many lifetimes without meeting with the dharma and not meeting with the dharma that means that one will be engaging in all sorts of negativities and misdeeds instead and that presents obscurations and great obstacles for our progress all the listening and the contemplation that we have done if we do that and all that is all arrested, lost. And, again, showing the abandonment of the dharma as the biggest misdeed, as the greatest misdeed of all, as explained in the white lotus sūtra and the chapter and the chapter of the truthful one. It amounts abandoning the Dharma if you hold that some utterances of the Buddha are means of attaining Buddhahood, while others are obstacles to Buddhahood, dividing them into good and bad, appropriate and inappropriate, Mahāyāna and Hīnayāna and so forth. And thereupon holding that a Bodhisattva needs to train in some and not in others, all that amounts to abandoning the Dharma.

So then we say all that about the teachings because one fails to understand that all the words of the Buddha directly or indirectly teach the meanings of attaining Buddhahood. Saying all that because of this misunderstanding is all amounts to abandoning the Dharma. And then in the sūtra, gathering all the threads, it says that the karmic obscuration due to abandoning the Dharma is so subtle that it is hard to recognize. Again, Geshe-la says, because it is those are the the words of the Buddha, the teachings of the Buddha, they are said to be subtle and then different to understand. It is different than to understand this to see, to realize this karma, to know them as as as such karma, to know this karma obscuration.

So then concerning the grave, disadvantages to that ensue if you abandon the dharma, it says in the king of concentration sutras. Someone here in Jambudvipa tears down all the stupas all the stupas there are. Someone and and and and another one abandons a class of sutras. The latter’s misdeed is far more grave. And then again in english the meaning is is is just what we have here in the verse.

Again, if you take all the stupas in the world and you destroy that, and if you give up on on a class of sutras, then, again, giving up on a class of sutras is a greater misdeed than the than destroying all the stupas. And against someone someone even murders arhats as many as the same grains in the Ganges. Someone and another one abandons a class of sutras. The latter’s misdeed is far more grave. And Geshe-la was saying.

So, again, if if we kill only one arhat, one foe destroyer, again, that amounts to one of the five heinous deeds, very serious misdeed, and then again if you kill as many arhats as there are grains of sand in the Ganges River again, and if you abandon abandon the the class of sutras, the class of sutras, then the latter abandon the class of sutras is a is a graver misdeed. Although there generally appear to be many ways in which the dharma might be abandoned, the one described previously seems to be the greatest, which is why we should try hard to give it up. And Geshe-la is saying that we should it’s very important that we do not do that, that we do not abandon the dharma in this way we should how to say give up on abandoning the Dharma And Geshe-la is saying of what is being said here is that all these things that we say, the is good. The is bad. the hearer the hearer path is good.

The is bad. The is good. The is is good, and and the is bad. And all such distinctions that we make amounts to abandoning the Dharma. And of all and and as we saw, abandoning the Dharma is the greatest of all misdeeds.

So then, again, Geshe-la says, having understood that how all the teachings having realized how all the teachings are not contradictory, how all of them in one way or another then lead to Buddhahood’s to Buddhahood. And then having realized how all the teachings are personal instructions, viewing them viewing them all the teachings as personal instructions given to oneself, then we will be able to abandon, to give up this negativity this negativity of abandoning the Dharma. Will be able to not engage in this in this negativity of abandoning the dharma. And, again, so then following to the next topic, when there is realization along the lines of these first two greatnesses, the misdeed, this misdeed stops by itself. That is to say, since this is reversed simply by gaining certainty regarding what what was shown above, the misdeeds stops by itself.

So like Geshe-la just explained, realize to develop certainty in this regard from the White Lotus Sūtra and other texts. The certainty should be sought by studying the chapter of the truth of one, as well as the Sūtra of the Excellent Dharma’s White Lotus. The other way of abandoning the dharma should be learned from the sūtra gathering all the threads. Wants to stop here today, which is in the beginning of the next chapter. He’s wondering He’s wondering if you have any questions while he’s drinking his tea.

Yeah. Yeah. What what how do I say that? Interpret it again. So then for for the lower schools of mind only and below, who then accept that definitive teachings are those suitable to be taken literally, for them, this will be a definitive teaching.

And for the middle way consequentialist that asserts that an interpretive teaching is a teaching talking about conventional truths this will be an interpretative teaching from their point of view. You wanted to ask something? Yes. Actually, the sūtra, the excellent Dharma’s white lotus. Is that is that the lotus sūtra of the true law?

Of what? Is that is that also called the lotus sūtra? That is what is commonly referred to as the lotus sūtra. I I I don’t know, man. You guys mean in English.

The white lotus sūtra and There are probably there are probably many many sutras which have lotus in the in their names, in their titles, and it’s always it’s hard to tell how they translated it. You have to you have to look at the sutras themselves to figure that out. There’s so many There must be. Yes. There are many there are many sutras called lotus.

But this particular sūtra, the Excellent Dharma’s White Lotus Sūtra Yeah. Particularly emphasize emphasizes all Dharma teachings are really off one as I understand it. Is that right? So I guess I was saying in this in the context of this teaching here it is indicating is teaching us how abandoning the Dharma is a great misdeed is a great negativity and that’s in this context it was quoted in in in this context that we were instructed to read it, Geshe-la. In case I was then there there are many sutras.

There is the the the the king concentration sutras, the white lotus sūtra, and so forth. And and, generally speaking, there is those these are sutras that teach conventional truths. Me just does Let me see if I understood. If somebody has made a commitment to training morality, such as not killing any animal, and then having made a commitment, then engages in killing the animals, would that person have more negativities than the person who kills animals without having made a commitment? So then so even though both are killing and and and and and the killing of of the animal or or the human being is equally negativity, that person who has taken the vow and then and then broken the vow is is has a greater negativity to her or him yes And it is greater because, just as have this is probably understood already, it is greater because one has vowed not to kill.

One has previously vowed not to kill. Having vowed not to kill, it should then, you know, break that vow and and if you do if you do something that contradicts that vow, then then the the will will will amount to a greater negativity. Absolutely. So what you have is that, for example, killing is already a negativity of its own accord so you have practiced killing and you have broken a vow you have broken your vow of not killing so you have two negativities actually Okay? Yeah, go ahead.

Absolutely. It’s better. It’s better. Okay. Better to better to to take the vow.

Yes. Yeah. Between taking not taking the vow — it’s better to take the vow. Can I have something regarding the intention of killing? Or just gonna take an example.

Let’s say you got a bunch of birds in your garden killing the trees, and you know if you don’t take any action, they’re going to multiply, and eventually, they’re going to go in So better to kill the bugs. I guess that was the same. So then the best option is to engage in ways to stop the insects, or whatever is to come in the first place fence your garden away or the tree away or something like that that’s the best that’s the best course of action if if the the insects come in then you either engage in the killing of them which is a negativity all the way or or you just don’t care about the tree. Okay. There are options.

We do have options. Just now, Adam. Yes. Say that again? We were talking about very wrong and bad.

And The Buddhist teachings and not dividing them between good and bad. Yeah that’s a good question is in saying, what you said is is is right. Geshe-la says, the the the Buddha’s teachings from their own side, they are all good, and they are all beneficial. They’re all perfect. But we do not know that.

We cannot tell that. And what we have to do in order to be able to see if a teaching is beneficial or not good or not is that we have to study them we have to study we have to investigate we have to listen and reflect upon the teachings. It’s by studying that we will develop any certainty about the teachings being beneficial or not. If we do not understand, again, just because we don’t understand, we shouldn’t give up on them. So then, I said, there’s all the teachings of the Buddha, there’s no teaching of the Buddha which is not beneficial.

Even though it might not be apparently beneficial to us, it might it is beneficial to someone else. If it is not beneficial to that person, is beneficial to someone else. Because of that, we shouldn’t say this good, this teaching is good, and that one is bad, because that amounts to giving up, to abandon in the Dharma, and that’s a great negativity. We just we just cannot tell. Giving an example to us.

For example, take the the this this text that we have in our hands, the text, is in English. And Geshe-la says Geshe-la says he doesn’t know English. Right? So just because he doesn’t know English, he shouldn’t he wouldn’t just you know, this this is no good and just throw it away. You know?

And that’s that’s wrong. I mean, it’s it’s it’s he doesn’t know English, but it’s this text is still beneficial for us. So and it’s because it is the is a text there’s enough reason for him to to hold it high and show respect and reverence to it. And Geshe-la was saying, even we understanding it or not, understanding the teachings to be good or not beneficial or not, If we understand or not, it doesn’t make any difference. The teachings by themselves, they are beneficial.

That’s what we have to bear in mind. Okay? You wanted to add something? Yes? And Geshe-la is giving explaining it a bit further.

So for example the the english text that we have in our hands it is it does not benefit the Geshe right he doesn’t know english and now this default of of of this lack of benefit coming about is not from the Geshe, is not from the text, it is not from the It’s not from the side of the text. It is from the side of the Geshe who lacks the knowledge of the English language. And in the same way, we should we should relate to all the teachings of the Buddha, Geshe-la says. Okay? Please.

Yes. My question is related to goes back to the what’s talked for about scripture and realization. If the scripture provides for, let’s say, a do we have intellectual knowledge that you can learn, you know, mimic verbatim. But and what is realization? What’s the difference between the intellectual knowledge and the actual realization?

So what I I guess what I’m asking is how do we know something to be the truth in the lots of things that have held up to us all as being truth in one way or another. And given also that we’re, if you like, working with, you know, in faulty mechanism almost, you know, because all the, you know, poisonous rubbish that we’ve got in us through, etcetera. How how to realize And now you you have to help me here. Again, sorry. It sounds a bit simple, what Gustavo was saying.

Geshe-la was saying, look, generally, then which is the scriptural teachings, basically, the words are just the words that are, you know, expressing the teachings and and the path and what is to be accomplished and so forth. And the the realization of teachings, Geshe-la says, is the actual is the actual knowledge. Is the actual Geshe-la was saying using the word Sheppa. And I think he was using in in in all contexts, right? In terms of consciousness, in terms of awareness that is clear and knowing that which comprehends and understands the text, the words, the meaning of the words and so forth.

Is that basically what I said? Scriptural teachings are sound? Are sound? Sound words and the other one is the consciousness. Yeah.

That’s And then so and and if you if you if you’re watching the Geshe as as he was expressing himself and pointing out to the text that I have in my hands, Geshe-la is saying, when we’re talking about and the scriptural teachings, we’re not talking about the paper and the ink in the paper, not these things here. Out of this, there is the sound. I guess that’s quite literal in this respect. It’s the sound of the words. This is what we’re referring to as scriptural teachings.

So then you have the words themselves, the sound, and then that awareness, that consciousness of of those sounds, for example the word mi rtag pa comes forth, mi rtag pa, which is impermanence. Impermanence comes forth and contemplating that word, we develop that meaning or understanding in our minds, in our in our conscious awareness or knower or what have you, and that’s what will be the realization of teaching. Effect. So then first we have we have somebody who expounds the teaching to to us verbally, and we listen to those words, or we have or we read the words on the text or we recite the words on the text. So we have first the sound, the scriptural teachings, and then, in dependence on that, we contemplate that with our thoughts, with our minds, we contemplate the meaning of that, and we develop the realization of teachings in this way.

Is that okay? Does Geshe-la say that there is an extra aspect to the realization other than the intellectual part? Is there some kind of emotional aspect or or something greater than purely intellectual? Yeah. I’m I’m having my difficulty is with the word intellectual.

How how would I convey this meaning into? How can I do that? So then at first, so I was asking so we I was explaining to the Geshe. We, Westerners, we tend to read a lot, and then we think we know it all. Right?

We read about them, and we say, I know it all. I’ll teach you. And we do that, all of us. And and so but we do not practice. So is there a way to find out I was asking is there a way to find out if we if we are actually practicing correctly?

Is there a sign that’s going to come up? Is there an experience? There a is there a feeling or a taste to it? And it’s something palpable to it. And and Geshe-la wasn’t saying, look.

It’s just like the text was was was telling us. If you become a scholar on the teachings, you know it all, but you don’t actually practice it. You won’t get any benefit from it. Now if you practice the teachings that you have studied, then signs will come. And Geshe-la was explaining that the teachings will become clearer and clearer to you.

And then Geshe-la was giving an analogy. Okay? It’s just like when we were first learning the alphabet, a b c. In the beginning, it was very difficult to write a b and c, but nowadays, we write without even looking at the paper. We don’t have to think anything.

We just write. You know? It’s automatically second nature. So with time, the teachings become second nature to us just like that until the point we attain Buddhahood. To that, I’m going to make another question, which is related to decisions that we have in our hands here, which will come up later on.

But, again, there’s another way to approach So for example, just to give an illustration, Geshe-la was saying, so at first take you, for example at first when you heard the word impermanence in concept of bodhicitta you didn’t know what it meant at all and nowadays when you hear the word impermanence you know that this is making reference to momentary existence, momentary change of moment to moment. You want you have that clearer now. Then, again, with having having this understanding that you have right now of what impermanence is, if you again contemplate that, then that will become clearer and clearer until the point you to the point that you that you that you that you realize that you have that realization, the full realization. And then by merely seeing something, you understand that that it is changing. So you have that feeling.

You will have that having practice, by having actual practice. You will be able to realize that And then, again, again, if you if you for them, contemplating the the subject of impermanence, develop a clear clear but continue contemplating to develop a clear understanding of it. And you when you come to realize it and you see that whatever observation you have, it doesn’t remain unchanged for even a moment. It’s changing every time from moment to moment. Again, in this illustration, this example, again, you won’t see any reason to be attached to it.

You won’t see any reason to cling to it. So your attachment, for example, will diminish. And that is, again, another sign of the result of your practice that you have been actually practicing. So then again, generally speaking, then if you’re practicing the Dharma, then the afflictive emotions will diminish, or the afflictive emotions will consistently diminish. And so then, Geshe-la was saying, whatever virtuous Dharma you are practicing, is directly opposed to that non-virtue, which is opposed to that virtuous Dharma, that for which the Dharma is an antidote, that will diminish.

Again, there’s another sign. Yes. That’s that’s something. Is that is it? Because it’s time.

Right? Yeah. It’s quite past the time. Yeah. This time.

Oh, yeah.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Jambudvipa Rose-apple Land; dzam bu ling (Tib)
Of the four continents surrounding Mount Meru in Buddhist cosmology, this is the southern continent where human beings live. The other three continents are Godaniya in the west; Kuru in the north and Videha in the east. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Questions answered in this teaching

Does someone who vows not to kill animals and then kills them create more negativity than someone who kills without having made a vow?

Yes. Killing an animal or a human being is equally a negativity whether or not a vow has been taken, but the person who took the vow and then broke it has a greater negativity. This is because they previously vowed not to kill, and doing something that contradicts that vow adds to the negativity. Killing is already a negativity of its own accord, and breaking the vow of not killing is a further one, so the person who kills after taking the vow has actually created two negativities.

What is the difference between scriptural teachings, which can be learned intellectually, and the realization of the teachings?

Scriptural teachings are the words that express the teachings, the path and what is to be accomplished. They are not the paper and ink of the text but the sound of the words. Realization of the teachings is the actual knowledge: a clear, knowing awareness that comprehends the words and their meaning. For example, the word for impermanence arises, and by contemplating it we develop its meaning in our minds. The sequence is that someone teaches verbally, or we read or recite the text, giving us the sound of the scriptural teachings. Then, relying on that, we contemplate the meaning with our minds and develop realization.

Scroll to Top