1 h 53 min · 6,770 words · 20 March 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A question about apparently contradictory teachings drives this 113-minute session: how can Buddhist schools asserting phenomena are truly established and those denying it both lead to enlightenment? Geshe Pema Tsering works through Atisha’s Lamrim text, explaining its three qualities — completeness across sūtra and tantra, ease of gradual practice, and a noble lineage through Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga — before dwelling on how every word the Buddha spoke, even a single term like “impermanence,” functions as personal instruction rather than abstract doctrine. He addresses the sūtra-tantra divide directly, arguing both require bodhicitta and the six perfections. Q&A covers the three vehicles and their distinct goals, objects of abandonment, and paths. The session closes with practical guidance: frame every spiritual action — meditation, offerings, prostrations — with bodhicitta motivation at the start and a dedication at the end.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 04 2008 03 20 BP.mp3
UUID: 5e292050-14df-428d-9f73-68e8ba5edc08
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Lam Rim (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2008-03-20
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 113.0 minutes
Words: ~6,787
So visualize in just instructing all of us to give rise to proper motivation now. Since you have already gathered together to to study before the teaching, it assumes that you have already given rise to a good motivation. Yes. Motivation is extremely important, I should say, so that’s why we have to give rise to a good motivation. So then with the intention of establishing all sentient beings in the state of enlightenment, then I myself must attain enlightenment in order to accomplish that.
One is going to study the teachings. Oh, yeah. So then we start with the recitation of the Heart Sūtra. Do you have a copy of this? K.
Good? Thank you. So we start. Just chant it one time. So Geshe-la is asking you if you have any questions that you would like to start with.
So if one is wants to start practicing and and one then wants to start with by giving rise to the motivation of being of small scope, with the intention then of attaining a higher rebirth as either a human or god in the future life, then the main practice that one has to engage in is in abandoning the ten non virtuous actions. So then this is then the path which is uncommon to the beings of small scope. Now the common path of beings of small scope would be the path which is, again, with the motivation with different motivation. With the motivation of attaining liberation and enlightenment, in order to accomplish that, then abandoning the ten non-virtues, understanding the four noble truths, and so forth. So then what is the difference is that what is common the thing that is common is the practice of abandoning the ten non-virtues, but the difference is in the motivation.
So one has the motivation of attaining liberation and enlightenment ment for that and to accomplish that, practicing the abandonment of the ten non-virtues. And the other one, the beings of small scope have a small motivation, a very small motivation. And so then the the goal of being of a small scope is then attaining a high rebirth, a future high rebirth. And then one has to gain the knowledge. One has to know what is the main practice.
The main practice is abandonment of the ten non-virtues. One has to understand what are these objects of abandonment, what are the ten non-virtues. One has to understand what is to be the objects which are to be adopted. In order to do all that, to accomplish all that, one has to study. Without studying the subject, one will not be able to accomplish any of that.
So is then saying so is then the the path of of of being of small scope. You understand that? And Geshe-la was then saying the difference being difference between the beings of small and and great scope and medium scope is in the in the goal and what aspiration that they they have in their minds, what they aspire for, what they aspire to attain, what they aspire to reach. And that’s that’s what is that’s where the difference comes from, That is the distinction.
Okay? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yes.
I knew it. It. Okay. Any more questions? How would I say that he’s realized?
So then by by studying the the lamp of the path to enlightenment, the lamp on the he was able to understand that the author of such a text is not only a great scholar, but also also realized being. So then by studying that text, the lamp illuminating the path, then attained many insights, many realizations himself in his mind stream. And by and by that, he knew for for certain that that person, the author of the text, was a realized being. So we also should do just the same by studying the lamrim text. We should study them and practice them according to to the instructions in the text.
And and when we we ourselves develop these insights and realizations, we will be able to understand to have the same understanding that was a realized being. And it is not without having some experiential realization that we’ll be able to understand that. Definitely. So Geshe-la was saying it is not without developing that experiential, that those experiences within our own giving rise to those experiences that are being taught in the text within our own mind streams that we’ll be able to understand that. It is not this this understanding, this understanding of Atisha’s realization in in this context.
It doesn’t come easily. And Geshe-la was saying no. Generally, we we think, oh, he he he seems to be a good person. Alright? Everybody says he’s a good person, and we think that he must be a good person.
A valid reason for establishing a an individual a being as a as a as a good good or bad person. That’s not a valid way of it’s not correct. Yes. Is that okay? Yeah.
Yeah. And this one. Is that okay? Yeah. So we we covered already the first topic of this Lamrim text, which was then showing the greatness of the teacher in order for the sake of generating respect for the teaching.
And now we have a next topic, which is showing the greatness of the teachings themselves in order to generate respect for these instructions. So we showed the greatness of Lama Atisha, and we are going to show the greatness of his teachings. So so we have these three so then as as for showing the greatness of the teaching, we have these three topics, and the first one of those these major topics is identifying the teachings themselves. So this the text from where this this spiritual instruction comes from is the lamp illuminating the path to enlightenment of Lama Atisha. Now the second topic of of showing the greatness of the teaching is showing how the teaching is endowed with these three qualities of being complete, being easy to put into to implement, to put into practice, and and and being especially or particularly noble system.
So then then as for this topic, because I was going through the text and explaining, although Atisha composed numerous texts, the lamp on the path of enlightenment, the lamp illuminating the path, is the perfect completion. Like, as as if it was a very root, the very root. As it indicates, all the points of both sūtra and tantra, in summary, it is complete in terms of its content, and Geshe-la was explaining. And and that is because most generally speaking, all sūtra texts do not make reference, do not explain points regarding to tantra, and tantra text do not explain points regarding to sūtra. And, again, as as it makes a gradual the gradual taming of the of the mind, its main topic, it is then easy to put into practice.
Because it teaches us, it shows us how to practice in all the proper stages, appropriate stages of practice, then it is implemented. We study it, if we gain this knowledge of it, then we will be able to understand it. And, again, lastly, because it is ornamented by the instructions of the two masters, Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, who were skilled in the systems of the two sorry, of the two masters who and Dharmarakshita were the teachers of Lama Atisha. These two masters who were skilled in the systems of the two trailblazers, the two trailblazers, which were Nāgārjuna and Asaṇga, it is a particularly noble system compared to others. So then the next topic is then present presentation of this text as possessing the four greatnesses.
And and we are told this this text then this instruction has this so called four greatnesses which are then the greatness of recognizing all teachings as non contradictory the greatness of all the buddha’s teachings coming to mind to view as as personal instructions, and the greatness of allowing you to easily find the meaning intended by the Buddha, and the greatness of vicious actions or grave misdeeds stopping by themselves. So then as for the first of those topics, which is then the the greatness of recognizing recognizing all the teachings as non contradictory, this topic alone has five subdivisions. It has five parts. The first one is identifying the teachings themselves, which says, as for that, the greatness, the teachings themselves are everything that the Buddha has said. Then as for how all the teachings are recognized as non contradictory, they all come to be understood as one person’s path to Buddhahood.
That is to say, some are primary points of the path, main points, and others are appropriate secondary points. So so we ourselves, we do not we do not realize how all the teachings are noncontradictory. And so we must we ought to realize that. We must realize that. And we realize that by understanding that some of the teachings of the Buddha are main points, primary points, and others are appropriate secondary instructions.
And and the main thing it says is to understand that everything that the Buddha said is a cause of enlightenment. And and then going through the next topic, which is how it is demonstrated through scripture and logic that it will be contradictory not to accept that. It is in this regard, and it is said, it is the Bodhisattva’s wish to work for the welfare of the world. For that purpose, it is also necessary to care for all three types of disciples, and then train in their respective paths. So, again, with regards to to to that, Geshe-la was then saying, generally speaking, are two main divisions of teachings.
There are the scriptural teachings and the realizational teachings. In this context, we are talking about the scriptural teachings, which are then the teachings of the Buddha. And one must understand that all the teachings that the Buddha has given were for the sake of benefiting a particular individual. So all of them are cause of enlightenment. There is nothing that the Buddha has taught which is not a cause for enlightenment.
Strange. We think the Vaibhāṣikas teach one thing. The Sautratikas teach another thing. The mind only school teach something else. And the middle way autonomous and the consequentialists teach different things.
They all teach different things. And and and it’s all very strange we think to ourselves. And this is how we do not understand. We lack this understanding, this realization that they are non contradictory. Some sutras say say that phenomena are truly established.
Some sutras say that phenomena are not truly established. And some sutras say at one point that phenomena are truly established and another point that phenomena are not really established. And all these sutras are teachings of the Buddha himself. So it is important to understand how they are actually not contradictory, Geshe-la. So Geshe-la says, so then the the the middle way consequentialist, then they they assert the phenomenon are not truly established.
And all the other proponents which are not middle way consequentialists, they answer the phenomenon truly established or have some some formal order of true establishment. And Geshe-la was saying that is is important to understand that this is said for them, for those who are not the middle way consequentialist, because they are not ready or not able then to understand the teachings of So then and that’s and that is because they wouldn’t they would not be able to accept the phenomena are not truly established and not truly existent. Because of that, because they would be unable to accept that, it was taught to them that phenomena are, in one way or another, truly existent, truly established. When they engage in this and try to understand how it the phenomenon exists as truly existent, and, ultimately, they end up realizing the phenomenon not truly existent. So in this way, by being taught in this way, they were able to benefit.
Generally speaking, have four schools, four different schools of tenets. All of these four schools, they are not contradictory themselves. We have to understand that all of them are going to lead to the ultimate goal of enlightenment, and they did in stages. So by realizing one, we are able to realize the other and so forth until we realize the ultimate goal of enlightenment. So, again, Geshe-la was going through the text again saying this how it is demonstrated through scripture and logic that it will be contradiction to accept this.
Geshe-la says again disregard that it is a wish to work for the welfare of the world. For that purpose, it is also necessary to care for all three types of beings and therefore train the respective paths. And as for the three types of beings, Geshe-la was saying, those are the hearers, the solitary realizers, and the And then we we we understand that this is known because it is explained by the that the knowledge of the paths of the three vehicles constitutes a means of realizing the Bodhisattva’s goals. And Geshe-la was in sense for this knowledge of the three paths of the three vehicles, and that makes direct reference to the three types of disciples. So then there’s three vehicles and three different types of disciples.
And this knowledge, knowing these three paths, Bodhisattvas are able to teach and then accomplish the So as for the next topic, which is establishing that the teachings are non contradictory, we are told in the Mahāyāna path, there is the common and the uncommon. The former are those that originate from the Hīnayāna collection of scriptures. So so then these these teachings of this collection of teachings of the lesser vehicle are then said to be the common the common teachings. And such Geshe-la was giving us an illustration, the sixteen the sixteen aspects of the four noble truths. The sixteen aspects of the four noble truths, which is a common teaching.
Oh, yeah. And this one. Los. And except we are told apart what is it? Except from from for some peculiarities that are not common to do with the thought of aspiring for individual liberation.
I guess that was the sense on the the thought of aspiring for one’s own liberation alone is is not common to all the vehicles. It is uncommon to the lesser vehicle only. So then this distinction is made on the basis of of one’s motivation, one the mind that one is holding the motivation that one is holding in one’s mind. So then by aspiring only towards one’s own liberation alone, then the the path then is said to be uncommon. That is what makes it uncommon.
And then when one has a different motivation while practicing that path, which is then intending to attain enlightenment, and then that becomes the common path.. This one. So then apart from that, we are told it is not that faults are partially ceased and qualities are partially completed in perfectly complete enlightenment, but rather all kinds of faults have been eliminated and all types of good qualities have been developed. So consequently, we are told as Mahāyāna that achieves this is also brings about the cessation of all faults and the development of all good qualities. The path of the Mahāyāna then comprises all the various aspects of the good qualities of abandonment and realization of all the other vehicles.
And in the same vein then, we have the lesser vehicles not developing all good qualities and not ridding, abandoning all faults. And in the same way, again, those the collection of scriptures of the lesser then teach only that. We’ll not teach we’ll teach only how to partially rid oneself of faults and partially accomplish the good qualities. This one? So then that is that is why the sections of the Mahāyāna path which brings about Buddhahood comprise all the Buddha’s Buddha’s teachings, for there is no utterance of the of the that does not cause the cessation of some fault or the development of some good quality.
And because it is not the case that all of this is not brought about by the by And Geshe-la was in sense, so then we after reading that, so then we can see how how not easy it is to accomplish the path of the Mahāyāna. It’s about this path is about clearing away all and endowing yourself with all good qualities. And the uncommon teaching or the uncommon path of the of the Mahāyāna, which accomplishes that is the mind of enlightenment. Now if one and so then when the next topic which is clearing clearing our doubts, if one thinks then that all this may be true for the for the but not for those entering the Vajrayāna. So then all that has been said about the path, including all the other the common Indian common paths with regards to the Mahāyāna, to the Pāramitāyāna that is the case for the Pāramitāyāna, but is not the case for those who are practicing the Vajrayāna.
And this sort of this sort of doubt, Geshe-la says, has has happened, has come up in in Tibet in the past. There were people in the past in Tibet who who would say the tantric teachings are good, and then they would completely disregard the sūtra teachings, and others would say instead that the sūtra teachings are the good ones, and they would completely disregard the tantric teachings. And then we are told, although the the way of training in the in the conduct of giving and the other perfections is different from the mantra from the mantra vehicle in the in the basis of conduct. Wasn’t saying right there, Geshe-la stopped and said, so there’s a different way to practice the conduct, this this this conduct of of the Mahāyāna in this in the Pāramitāyāna and the tantra. So in one in one way of practicing giving in patience and morality and so forth, the perfections.
This is perfections. And the other one, we are visualizing ourselves as the deity and and and making offerings and so forth. So then it is different. So even though it is different from mantra in the behavioral basis, the generation of the mind. And the So then in the And in in with respect to the generation of the mind of enlightenment and the course form of the path of training in the six perfections, the conduct is nevertheless approximately the same, and therefore, something which is shared by them.
So then, Geshe-la was going to say, so then there is there is a difference. We’re pointing out to the to this that sentence. There’s a difference in the course form of the path of training. This is perfection. This this course form is the same.
And and so then indicating that, one, the parametayana, there is a more coarse mind involved. In in the in the tantra, there will be a more subtle mind involved. And but Geshe-la points out to the fact that without having developed coarse form on the basis of coarse form, one cannot develop the subtle forms. And then we have in this text, a quote from a text, the Vajra Peak, which is a tantra which is a tantra, which says, not even to sustain one’s life should the bodhi mind be abandoned. So then not not even in the face of death should we give up bodhicitta loss.
And also And also the the same text, the same tantra says the practice of the six perfections must not ever be abandoned. So then we have, Geshe-la is pointing out, the fact that this tantra text is is saying that we we should we should not give up bodhicitta, and we should not give up the practice of the six perfections. So then we are practicing even we we do cultivate bodhicitta, and we do practice the six perfections. And and and the text goes on to say that this is also taught in in many other tantras. And points out now we have to understand that in in a logical way also in in terms of of reason.
So we have we have a scriptural quote explaining that, clearing away these doubts, but we have to understand that without the six perfections, the perfection of wisdom, and without great compassion, without bodhicitta, so without this, we cannot accomplish the tantric practices. If we think about it also, we will come to understand how we cannot go without bodhicitta and the six perfections. Also, in many in many authentic sources for the mandala ritual of the highest yoga tantra, it is said that a set of two vows must be must have been taken, a common and an uncommon one. And the former refers to the bodhisattva vows. And, again, Geshe-la says with regards to that, so then we it is clear again that we have to cultivate bodhicitta and engage in the six perfections.
This one. Again, we have the precious teacher also said, which is the precious. So then, again, with regards to the precious teacher, I also said my guru who knew how to accommodate all the teachings by means of the path as if in a square. And and this is a very difficult sentence to translate from the Tibetan, but Geshe-la was explaining that that person, the person who said that, understood all the teaching as non contradictory, like a square. Any way you place it, it fits alright, and they fit with each other alright.
And, again, the last the very last sentence is indicating that the these words are the basis of a major major investigations. And Geshe-la was then pointing out, meaning that this is not something easy to understand. It is not without a lot of investigation analysis that one will come to understand it. So we visualize in saying, again, that that that sentence itself, which is a very very obscure sentence even in English, my guru who knew how to accommodate all the teachings by means of the path as if as if in a square as as if as squares. This is not without a lot of investigation, a lot of analysis that will one will come to understand the meaning the full meaning of this sentence.
So then we have then concluded that the topic which is how all the teachings are non contradictory. And then one understands that by realizing how all the teachings, however big or small they may be, they were were given for the sake of benefiting of accomplishing the enlightenment of individuals. And so all of them are causes of enlightenment. And then And says that that alone is is is not is not easy to understand. It’s very difficult, isn’t it?
And then so then we approach the next topic then, which is the greatness of all the Buddha’s teachings coming into view as personal instructions. So this topic has three parts to it. So three parts to it. The first one being the distinction of the pure and pure manners of comprehension, of understanding. So whoever construing the great scriptures, and Geshe-la stop there, I’m saying, so the great explanations, perfection sutras, the Vinayas, texts on valid cognition and so forth.
So however, considering that the great scriptures to be explanatory teachings that do not contain points of practice, and that the guidance, advice indicating the meaning of the essential points of practice exists separately from them, not in these teachings, holds that even in the holy Dharma, the explanatory and the accomplishing teachings, the scriptural and accomplishing teachings are found in two different places, such a person will create an obstacle for the arise of deep respect towards the immaculate sutras and tantras as as well as the treatises clarifying their intent as well as the commentaries. This is a danger, and this is this is a common danger that we we all incur. So we we think that all these extensive texts, they are they are only for the scholars. They are only for those people who dedicate themselves to to studying this this logical treatise and so forth. And that we should we need only a small condensed version or commentaries of that because I wasn’t saying this is a mistake.
We we have to make an effort to understand and gain knowledge of all of all these texts, of all these scriptures. So the is saying and and, again, repeating the last part of that sentence, saying that one will not have respect for those the untainted sutras and tantras and the treatises and the commentaries. And Geshe-la was saying, so we we with such a mistaken understanding, one will put aside these texts and will not study them. I guess, I wasn’t saying by not studying them, one will not be able to practice. And by not practice, one will not be able to attain the results.
And, again, we’re starting to read that the next sentence that one should be aware of that the karmic obscuration of abandoning the Dharma is accumulated by despising them and saying that the they only outline external knowledge without presenting the inner meaning. So, again, was saying that without respect for the teachings, one developing the respect for the teachings, one will one will put them aside, one will leave them aside, one will not study them, and not studying them, when we not be able to practice and accomplish them. So then I guess I was going through the next sentence and saying, hence, for for those who want liberation, the infallible supreme instructions are indeed the great scriptures, are those texts themselves. Nevertheless, it is possible that due to poor intelligence or or and so forth, one cannot reach any certainty through relying only on the scriptures as supreme instructions, whereby one should seek certainty with respect to them. But if one cannot reach certainty through relying only on the scriptures as supreme instructions, one should seek certainty regarding them by relying on the excellent personal instructions.
And then one should not think that the great scriptures do not contain the heart of the matter because they only outline external knowledge while the practical guidance, those personal instructions are supreme because they present the inner meaning. We should not think in this way. Geshe-la says it doesn’t matter how big or small a teaching may be, as the text may be, one should put all of them into practice. And Geshe-la is pointing out to the fact and and if you if you watch Geshe-la’s gesture, which makes reference to the Tibetan word, which is personal instructions. So so whatever the text may be, whatever the the teaching of the Buddha may be, big or small, even if it is just one word, impermanence impermanence.
And then we we read impermanence, and put it aside. No. That word is there for us to reflect upon it. That word is telling us that we are impermanent and we should contemplate it. We should meditate upon it.
In the same way that only one word alone is such a teaching, such a personal instruction for our meditation practice, in the same way every other saying of the Buddha is a personal instruction. Geshe-la was pointing out his finger to me saying because it’s personal point, indicating this is a personal instruction for your meditation practice. You this is what you should be contemplating. This is what you should be meditating on, this and this and that. And then and again, in the same vein, when they said suffering, and then, again, that’s that’s that teaching, that word in the in the in the scripture or in the Sūtra of the Buddha, again, is is a teaching for one’s self.
One has to understand that this is being said to me. This is what the Buddha is telling me. And and then, again, one has to contemplate all the the how, you know, how everything is suffering and so forth. And in the same way, one approaches every other teaching of the Buddha in the same way with the same understanding. This is being said to me.
This is a personal instruction of the Buddha to me. And Geshe-la was saying, but we we do not understand that those teachings are really a personal instruction. We do not see those teachings as personal instructions, now do we? And Geshe-la says, when we see the teaching that all compounded phenomena are impermanent, and then we we just think it probably is the case that all compounded phenomena are impermanent. But we we we don’t go beyond that.
We stop there, and we do not actually go deeper into it. So then this is this is due to the fact that one has not realized the teaching as personal instructions. And when one has not realized the teachings as such personal instructions, then when we hear when we see in the teachings impermanence the teaching on impermanence, we think, oh, you know, he’s saying that generally, or he’s saying that to someone else. He’s not saying that to me. And so that that’s because we fail to see the teaching as a personal instructions.
And now also in the same way In the same way with the other seals when when when we are told that everything is suffering and and then that every Dharma is every phenomena is selfless, and then nirvana alone is peace. Again, with each one of them, we should contemplate them and and learn, for example, in the case of everything is suffering. We should understand that what what is being told what is being said to be suffering is that every phenomenon which is which arises out of contaminated actions and afflictive emotions and conceptions. And one has to understand, one has to contemplate the teachings on suffering are are saying that all phenomena arise out of suffering phenomena arise out of contaminated actions and afflictive emotion conceptions, and one has no power over oneself. One cannot govern oneself, and one has to contemplate is is this is this really the case?
Is the case that suffering phenomena arise out of actions and afflictive emotion conceptions? Is it really the case that I lack free will, that I have no power over myself, over my life, no control over my life, and so forth? Is it really the case? Is it or is it not? We have one has to investigate those things.
And, Geshe-la was gonna say, if we if we if we had power over our lives, if we had all this this so called free will and this and this independence, then we we wouldn’t experience any suffering because we do not wish to experience any suffering. So if we had really this freedom, this power over ourselves, then merely wishing we would obtain this freedom from suffering. And, also, we would obtain everything that we need, anything that we need. But we we do not we do not we do not experience it in this way. So that that indicates our lack of power over ourselves, our lack of ability to govern our lives.
So then by by reading, when one is in contact with the scriptures, by by contemplating that giving rise to the notion that they are personal instructions. This is a teaching given to myself. And then again and again giving rise to the to the notion, one will come to realize that? And, also, as Geshe-la points out, when it comes to realize that by studying the text this is one of the great qualities of the text. By studying text, we come to understand that all teachings are personal instructions.
And in the same way with the teachings of the Buddha himself, the Buddha, even though there might not have been more than than five people, five five disciples around the Buddha at the time of he gave a particular teaching, because his motivation was the mind of enlightenment, because he was giving a teaching in order to accomplish the enlightenment of all sentient beings, that makes that teaching also suitable for us, for all of us. So to accomplish the happiness of all beings. And one has to understand that the Buddha did not give up even even on on one being. He he he he he taught for the sake of the benefit of all beings without any exception whatsoever. And and with that mind, we understand how his teachings are for all beings lost.
Lost. Lost. So then so then with this understanding So so with this understanding, we understand how the Buddha also taught taught for me, taught for the Geshe. He taught for each one of us. The that his teachings are for each one of us.
So then we Geshe-la wants to stop here today. So it’s the second topic with the second of those topics, how all the Buddha’s teachings come into view as useful instructions. And that we start in the next Thursday. Sure. How do I injury?
Now, you probably have some questions. I missed Yeah. Yeah. Three types of the scopes. The three.
Where was that? What was that? To accept this? How will be demonstrated for scripture and logic? The three different types of students, the hearers, the solitary realizers, and the Mahayanists.
And then because there are these three types of disciples, the teachings were given of the three vehicles. So then, Geshe-la, with regards to that, there’s it could be a very extensive topic. So each one of them has the five paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation, no more learning. And then I was saying, well, maybe we don’t need to be that extensive. And Geshe-la was saying, look.
Every one of them, the hearer the hearer person or the solitary realizer person and the Mahāyānist person have which is an ordinary being and an ārya being. So then there is this this distinction because each one of them has a different object of abandonment or they have a different goal. They have a different object of abandonment, and they have a different path to accomplish that. Was then saying, the the goal, for example, of of the hearer is the hearer is liberation. The hearer is individual liberation.
And then and then said, the goal is only slightly different for the hearer and the solitary realizer. What he was saying with regards to that to that Now, the hearer. Yes. Yes.
Visualizing So then the goal of the hearer is the hearer is liberation. Then the the object of abandonment of the hearer is the afflictive obscurations, and the path is realizing the selflessness of the person, of the two. Selflessness — there’s selflessness of person and selflessness of phenomena. So the path is selflessness of person.. And then so then the the solitary realizer, again, is aiming at solitary realizer’s liberation.
He attains that by abandoning grasping at a self of phenomena, And he does that by realizing what was that? Realizing the the sorry? The the absence, the lack of Oh, yeah. Yes. By realizing what was that again?
Emptiness of externally established phenomena. Okay. Realizing the emptiness of externally established phenomena. And then as for the Mahāyānist, then his object of abandonment, when he wants to abandon the knowledge obscurations. He abandons that by realizing the lack of inherent existence of phenomena, and the the result of that, the goal is.
Does that make sense? So then we have three different types of of of beings, of disciples, three three different vehicles. We have three different paths, two different object of abandonment, three different goals, two different results. Okay. Okay?
Yeah. Yeah. Talk. Anything else? If a person of smaller scope, when this person attains a higher rebirth in the future life, would this person remember a in future remember hers or he his past life, his pre this this the the present life?
Will he will he will he she or he remember that there is a middling scope or or a greater scope, as that is? So, Geshe-la wasn’t look, we we have already attained that result, that goal of being of small scope. And we do not remember our our life, do we? Yes. So then we we have already attained right now, we have we have attained a precious human rebirth with all the the leisures and opportunities, isn’t it?
So and that’s that’s what being of small scope is aiming at. And then so it might be the case that even even a person a being might attain the state of of of a god, and it might be the case that such a being has some sort of extra sensory perception, but still their condition is basically the same as ours. Death life is over they are going to keep on going around the cycle of existence. So I guess, I was saying, don’t do not how do you say? Do not think like being of small scope.
You know? Give rise to to the to the being to the to the mental scope of a being of of a greater scope. And if you cannot do that, then at least aim at liberation. But but would better best if you would aim at if you were aiming at enlightened I would say, do not do not aim at the goal of being of of small scope. And then every every whatever virtuous activity, whatever spiritual action you are going to engage in, give rise to the intention of attaining enlightenment for the sake of enlightenment of all beings.
And if you cannot if you cannot do that, then at least aim at one’s own liberation. Whatever the spiritual practice might might be, then be it meditation, reading texts, making offerings, prostrations, and so forth. And if you are doing that for the sake of accomplishing enlightenment, then that’s the best way to go. I guess, I wasn’t saying that we we because we do not have because we do not have much courage, much strength strength of mind, you could say, we we we do not believe that we are able to attain enlightenment. We think to ourselves, I cannot do that.
I cannot accomplish enlightenment. So I will aim at something else. So I’ll aim at a higher rebirth of human or a god or something like that. And we shouldn’t do that. That’s a big that’s a big mistake.
Do you understand? Yeah. And then, Geshe-la was saying, we engage in a in a in a virtuous dharma, again, if we give rise to the motivation of bodhicitta, if we do that for the sake of the enlightenment of all, then Geshe-la says, then then that action will become a cause of enlightenment itself. And there is nothing that will be able to deteriorate power of that action. That action becomes a source of inexhaustible results, benefit..
So then, yeah, we ought to practice the Dharma, the the spiritual path of the Mahāyāna. And by doing that, we accomplish good results. And Geshe-la was saying, so we we we all want happiness, and we’re not and we no nobody wishes suffering. But we also in the same way, we we all practice spiritual practice. So in in order for our spiritual practice to become good and solid, we need a good motivation.
A good motivation of Whatever whatever virtuous action we are going to do, then we we should give rise to the motivation. Before we engage in the action, give rise to proper motivation in doing that for the sake of accomplishing enlightenment the enlightenment of all beings. That’s why I’m doing it. And then after one finishes, after one completes the practice, then one makes a proper dedication, may then this virtuous action become the cause of the enlightenment of all beings. And if one practices in this way, whatever it is, if one does it in this way, then one has accomplished a very good virtue, or what is literally said, a root of virtue.
Yeah. This is very important, Geshe-la says. The motivation and the dedication are extremely important. Like this one. Is that okay?
Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
- Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- selflessness of person gang zag gi dag me (Tib)
- According to the Prasangika Madhyamaka school, the most subtle view of selflessness of person is the lack of inherent existence of the person or self. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.