44 min · 3,404 words · 10 March 2003 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The Womad festival picnic becomes an unexpected teaching aid as Geshe Pema Tsering explains the suffering of change — that weekend felt wonderful, but left everyone tired, hungover, and eighty dollars lighter. In this 44-minute introductory talk, he completes the ten non-virtuous actions of mind (covetousness, ill-will, and wrong views), explains the ten virtues as their active abandonment, and connects both to the second noble truth. He then covers karma and rebirth across the six realms, distinguishing the direct “throwing karma” from the supporting conditions that help it ripen — illustrated by seed, water, and sunlight. A Q&A takes up past-life logic, whether compassion can relieve others’ suffering, and whether Buddhism reduces to cause-and-effect. Suited to newcomers in an ongoing introductory series.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 02 ItB 2003 03 10.mp3
UUID: 50bd2147-a828-4e6a-8a12-874ab2a900ce
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: IB Introduction to Buddhism (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2003-03-10
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 44.8 minutes
Words: ~3,421
Affect the people you’re talking to? Just saying whatever, any old thing, for the sake of just saying something? So they they are called there for non virtuous actions of speech. The reason they’re called this is because they all rely on the the notion of speech. They all rely on speaking in order to be performed.
So that they they all lumped together into this idea of the four non virtuous actions of speech. Okay. So the the three nonvirtuous actions of mind are something is usually translated as covetous or and and the next one is a vicious mind and the third one is a wrong views. Okay. So the first one is when you see something that you really want, your mind goes, oh, I really want that.
You see it and think, oh, and then once you have this thought in your head of really wanting something, then you’ll go out and do a whole bunch of non non virtuous things in order to get it. Okay. So the next one, having, like, a vicious mind is the idea in your mind that you you wanna hurt someone. Often, when we’re talking about it in the four non virtuous actions of speech, there’s this concept of harsh words of speaking very harshly to people. What the the vicious or nasty mind is is is the thoughts of of nasty things towards someone.
So even at, like, a mental level, it’s considered non virtue. Okay. So the the third one wrong views is saying that that things that future and past lives don’t exist, that karma doesn’t exist, that the Three Jewels of Buddhism, which is like Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha, they don’t exist. The idea that the only things that exist are things that you can see is is considered a wrong view because, you know, the idea of I was there, therefore it exists, therefore I believe it. If it’s not there, I don’t see I can’t see it, therefore I don’t believe it.
So that means that you don’t believe in things like past lives or or, the workings of and things like that, then that’s considered a wrong views. So from a Buddhist perspective, these these ten non virtues need to be abandoned because they don’t cause anything but suffering. So in order to abandon suffering and not ex and not experience suffering, then the ten non virtuous causes of suffering need to be abandoned. Okay. So the the when we talk about the ten non virtues, the ten non virtues are sorry.
The ten virtues. The ten virtues are actually the abandonment of the ten non virtues. So we talk about the three non virtuous actions of body. The thought in the mind, oh, I don’t wanna do that. That’s not a good thing becomes a virtue.
So if we think I don’t wanna kill, killing is bad. That’s a virtuous action. If we think I’m not gonna steal, stealing is bad, then it’s a virtuous action. So these these ten virtues become the cause for happiness. They become the cause for pleasant pleasantness.
So therefore, they should be cultivated. Okay. So in in the terms of Buddhist practice and what Geshe-la tries to do is that have this in mind always that those ten non virtues cause suffering and that the ten virtues cause happiness. So therefore not to participate in the ten non virtues and try and participate in the ten virtuous actions because it comes down to a simple truth. The origin of suffering is negative karma and the origin of pleasantness and origin of happiness is positive karma.
So in terms of having this as an understanding, that means that you would refrain from doing the negative things and try and practice the positive. So what we’re talking about here, this whole this whole explanation actually comes into line with the second of the four noble truths that is the the truth of the origin of suffering. So this explanation of karma and the how karma and afflictive emotions work is is included within the second of the four noble truths. Okay. So often when teachings are given on the four noble truths, are then divided into what’s called the sixteen aspects of the four noble truths with each four each noble truth having four of its own aspects.
And the four aspects of the what do you call given to the to the second noble truth of the origin of suffering are the cause which you’ve been describing, the origin, which we’re also describing, the second one being the strong conditions, and then the the fourth one being very strong suffering. Okay. So the first one we’ve actually already talked about what we’re talking about with the ten non virtues and the ten virtues is the actual cause of suffering because it acts as the reason for suffering to come about. If there was no virtuous karma or there was no non virtuous karma, sorry, then then suffering would not come about. So it’s called the direct cause for suffering.
Yes. Okay. So the word origin actually means there’s a direct translation. It’s usually translated as origin. A direct translation would be the source of all instead of origin.
So therefore, the source of all suffering is this cause. That the next bit where it says origin, it means that there is it’s like a emphatic saying there is nothing that isn’t caused by non virtue. Okay. Sorry. I was having another accent problem.
The third one was I thought it was great or something like that, but it actually was what I thought it was originally, which was its conditions. So, yeah, I was struggling to guess its accent a bit. Sorry about that. Yeah, so it means conditions and what they mean by conditions is all do the things that help something come about. And in this presentation of things, condition and cause are actually mutually inclusive, they’re synonyms, they’re the same thing with a different way of describing a similar phenomenon, right?
So this means that in order for something come about it has like helpers help I think conditions that help it come about. So the next one is is it could be translated as, like, great suffering. That’s just the fourth of the different aspects of the second noble truth and that means that that’s like talking about aspect of suffering when suffering is really strong when people are in a lot of pain and they have a lot of problems. That’s that’s like the what they’re talking about here, the very strong, the extreme aspect of suffering. Okay.
So there is in Tibetan cosmology, there there there are six different realms of existence. The three lower realms of existence being the hell realms, the animal realm, sorry, the hell realms, ghosts, spirit realms, and the animal realms. Now depending on the strength of the negative actions, all negative actions can become a cause for being reborn in one of these realms. So if it’s a very strong negative action, it can be a cause for being reborn in a hell realm. If it’s a middling, really strong negative action, it can become a cause for being born in a spirit realm.
And if it’s a smaller negative action, it can become a cause for being born in a animal realm. Okay. But in order for us to be and actually to be reborn in one of these not so nice places, there’s more complicated process that goes on because there’s okay. They divide karma up into so many different little bits that first of all you have to talk about the three types of karma for being born into a lower realm. So that for example is there’s a throwing karma, throwing karma being a very direct cause for being reborn in a lower realm and it’s set for the realms of the animals, spirits and hell realms.
And then along with that there is also a more general cause for being born in a lower realm that would be so you have to have both of those. There’s things that can be a cause for being born in a lower realm, but if they don’t come along with a cause with a throwing karma, which is very strong cause, then they don’t actually manifest as being born in a lower realm. So if you do things that are negative, that may be the cause of being born in a lower realm, doesn’t necessarily mean you will be born in a lower realm because you need this other type of karma, which is the more direct stuff that comes along with it. Okay. So in the same way of putting positive karma, it doesn’t matter if you do something that’s really good.
It it has to be, have something that’s in general a really good thing as well as a, more direct cause. And these two different types of positive karma have to come together in order to take rebirth in what are they called the higher realms of existence, which is for example, a human or a god or a demigod, which the other three realms of Tibetan cosmology. Okay. So, yes, so that we’ll call leave it there tonight if anyone has any questions. So that is like a confusing place to leave it.
So if anyone has any questions about that stuff, then please ask Okay. Okay. So the direct, what’s called throwing karma would be, for example, if you wanted to grow an apple tree, the direct throwing karma would be the seed that you’re actually putting into the soil. And the the more general, the helping along karma, can’t think of a way to translate it properly, would be the water that you pour on it, the sunlight that it’s receiving, and, the nutrients that it gets from the soil.
Do you want? Is that okay? Yeah. Oh, just the word suffering. It seems that we often have a lot of good times in our life and that we if the Buddhist first teaching was that humans suffer, it seems to me that that conjures up in my mind lots of misery, lots of sadness, lots of depression, where in actual fact, you know, just being at Womad for the weekend seemed like a pretty good time.
Mhmm. So just perhaps a little more explanation of who is suffering. Okay. So the the reason that that it didn’t feel like you’re experiencing suffering at the weekend and you’re having a good time at the Womad, the only way I could translate it was picnic. Is that you didn’t actually and you don’t that perhaps you didn’t have an understanding of how suffering works?
In the Buddhist explanation there’s three different types of suffering there’s a suffering of suffering which is out and out suffering the suffering of change and the suffering of pervasive conditioning so the one that you would have been experiencing at Womad or at Womad would have been the suffering of change, which isn’t the same as out and out suffering, is what we normally refer to as suffering. Because we’re kind of as as wanderers in saṃsāra when we see when we see suffering and when we see the suffering of change and we see pervasive suffering, we don’t think they’re suffering. We think they’re fun. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. Just if you do encounter sort of suffering in your life, is it because of past life or because It’s it’s different different ones because you can have done negative things in your past life that can manifest in this life as suffering, and you can have done negative things in this life that can also manifest as suffering. Can it’s a combination. Nope. Does anyone have any more questions?
Is there a? Nope. Is there a a study? On this? Yeah.
I’m sure there’s heat. Yeah. Sorry. Was just like yeah. There’s a there’s a even a text by the Dalai Lama on the four noble truths, which is indirectly related to it.
And it’s little. There’s there’s different ones. There’s ones about, the what they call the graduated path, which is the graduated path to enlightenment, and then there’s also ones that are on the four noble truths, which may both be a benefit. He reckons if we sit here white, then you’ll think of a question. Yeah.
Okay. So So so okay. The suffering of change is actually what we usually think of as being happiness. So for example, if we’re if we if we wanna eat a really good bowl of a good plate of really yummy food, then we think that’s happiness. I’m really hungry and I get to eat a bowl of yummy food.
So the first mouth will be taking, this is still happiness. But by the time we got into the bottom, we’re so full we’re gonna be sick and it’s not happiness anymore. So and another example would be that people have been at the Womad Picnic and that’s and then we’re having a really good time and and and everything, but it only lasted three days and now you’re all a bit tired and hungover and less about eighty dollars. So that’s that’s kind of another example of this suffering of change. Something that was happiness doesn’t stay as happiness for ages.
It becomes suffering. Is there is there ever no suffering? Okay. So, yeah, the liberation or nirvana is is actually a pleasure that doesn’t change into suffering. So that when people have achieved liberation or achieved nirvana, they experience nothing but that pleasure or happiness.
And then you reach that. He said, you know how today tonight we’ve been talking about the ten non virtues and the ten virtues? Okay. When you’ve gotten completely rid of the ten non virtues and have have nothing in your mind or nothing in your actions apart from the ten virtues, that’s when you’ll receive it. So people like and teachers like the Tibetans in the Theravāda tradition, they were originally like us.
And then they got rid of doing all bad things, and they did nothing but meditate on good things. Sorry. They did nothing but the positive actions and did a lot of meditation and practice, and then they achieved this state of, of liberation and Buddhahood where they had no suffering. Or until. Can I ask you a question?
Yeah. If you come across somebody who is suffering greatly, is it possible to help them by being compassionate towards them? Is it possible He said it depends on the situation. So for example, if you have someone who’s very ill, if that’s what their suffering is, and if that person is is really ill and you give them medicine and you give them injections and you look after them and you try and help them then by your helping them then they can get better because their karma is that they can get better and you’ve helped them to get better. Then you find other situations where no matter how many how much medicine you give people or how much you help them because of the power of their previous negativities they’re still going to pass away so in that case you may be able to help them to relieve the pain a little but you can’t stop them from passing away and things like that because of the power of their previous karma so sometimes you can help them and sometimes you can’t ultimately help So, they’re in the same way, all all different types of suffering.
There’s some people you can actually help, to get to stop their suffering, their manifest suffering. And then some people you can’t actually, no matter how much you help, you still can’t take away their suffering. He said, yeah, that’s the same, but there’s usually there’s two types of people like that. There’s some people that there’s a cause for them being sad or there’s a cause for them having suffering mental suffering so if you can establish what the cause is and try and help them deal with the cause and they’ll stop being sad there’s other people that naturally have this disposition that they that they are sad and they and and they’re more difficult to help. So you you have to establish which type of person that you’re dealing with there and then try and do the best to help them.
Yeah. Yeah. If I if they don’t if they don’t achieve if they don’t achieve nirvana or have this liberation, then in future lives, they will experience all different types of situations no matter how much you help them now, even if you help them to a nicer existence now. In the future, they’ll still have to experience all different types of situations and they’ll achieve true peace and true happiness by achieving nirvana. How can you connect or understand a bit more about past life?
Okay. So the way to understand that past lives exist in terms of, the way it’s described in Buddhism is that we think of ourselves now as being here. They think, think, okay. This is me. I’m going here.
I’m doing this. I I I’m sitting I’m sitting here now. And this morning, I was doing something else. This morning, I was going here. I was going there.
And then two years ago, I was doing something. And and I remember what I was doing two years ago, and there’s this continual sense of me that that being me. And then we go backwards further and we have this understanding that what what at one stage we were a child, and then where did that child came from the child came from, from within the mother and then the where did the where did the being within the mother come from, which still has, we still have this sense of being I, that came from, the a moment of conception. Okay. So if we have this concept of I going all the way back to the moment of conception, then we have to say, well, where did the I at the moment of conception come from?
And the only explanation that could that could be logical is that it had to come from somewhere else because it couldn’t have just started then Because we have an idea that we were because of this whole chain that we have up from then up until now, then it can’t go we can’t have it just stop there. It has to come from somewhere else before that. And so their their Buddhist explanation is it comes from a previous life. So if if you meditate upon that and start it, can you perhaps remember? He said no. He doesn’t think that you can understand what you were in a past life, but you can establish logically the idea of past life. Oh, okay. Yeah. But trying to understand what you were in a past life, you can’t do it through this process. Yeah.
I’m not sure I’ve got the question, but is Buddhism just about the cause and effect and the sense of I I or is there more of a a structured way of things in terms of the big picture? And the reason I ask is that is that last year, I I came to the first know, six months ago, and I’m experiencing, you know, realization and understanding, and and I’m just in awe. And it’s just so is it just the timing wasn’t right? Uh-huh. Do you understand what I’m trying say?
So, yes. Hang on. But I’m I’m I think there’s two questions there, I was trying to link them. So the first one was like, how come you were like, oh, man. I don’t want any of this.
And now it’s like, cool. Yeah. That’s one question. And the other question was, is there more to Buddhism than just karma and and the sense of Yeah. Right.
Is that all these all they weren’t two questions, though, were they? Probably. No. I just I just wanted to get it clear. Alright?
Because I didn’t wanna, yeah, mess up your questions. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- six realms
- The general way that Buddhism divides the whole of cyclic existence; there are three lower realms (hell, hungry ghost and animal) and three upper realms (human, demigod and god). LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- ten virtuous actions gewa chu (Tib)
- Actions of body, speech and mind which are the opposite of the ten nonvirtuous actions, therefore, one refrains from killing, speaks the truth and so forth. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
If Buddhism teaches that life is suffering, why does a good time, like a weekend at a festival, not feel like suffering?
Enjoying a weekend does not feel like suffering because we may not understand how suffering works. Buddhism explains three types: the suffering of suffering, which is out-and-out suffering; the suffering of change; and the suffering of pervasive conditioning. A good time at a festival would be the suffering of change, which is not the same as out-and-out suffering, the kind we normally call suffering. As wanderers in saṃsāra, when we meet the suffering of change and pervasive suffering, we do not see them as suffering. We think they are fun.
If you experience suffering in your life, is it caused by actions in a past life or in this life?
Negative actions done in a past life can ripen in this life as suffering. Negative actions done in this life can also manifest as suffering. So the suffering a person meets may come from different sources, from past lives and from the present life together.
Is there ever a state in which there is no suffering?
Yes. Liberation, or nirvana, is a pleasure that does not change into suffering. People who have achieved liberation or nirvana experience nothing but that pleasure or happiness.
If you meet someone who is suffering greatly, can you help them by being compassionate towards them?
It depends on the situation. If someone is very ill, giving them medicine and injections and looking after them can help them recover, because their karma is that they can get better and the help supports that. In other situations, no matter how much medicine or help is given, the person will still pass away because of the power of their previous negativities. In that case you may relieve some of their pain a little, but you cannot stop them from dying. The same applies to all types of suffering: some people can be helped to stop their manifest suffering, while others cannot have their suffering taken away no matter how much help they receive.