51 min · 3,508 words · 26 July 2005 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A question about computer screens opens this 52-minute Q&A with Geshe Pema Tsering: if a computer existed exactly as it appears, he argues, there would be nothing left to understand — no expertise possible, no change. That same logic drives the session’s core teaching on emptiness: things appear but don’t inherently exist, which is precisely why understanding can develop and suffering can shift. He then explains analytical meditation not as wandering between ideas but as turning one concept back on itself repeatedly — illustrated by searching for “Geshe-la” and finding nothing solid — until conceptual grasping dissolves. He distinguishes the conventional self (a person, fine to refer to) from the independently-existent atma that Buddhism refutes. The session closes on karma and perception: seeing one’s teacher as a Buddha requires clearing vast obscurations, described as very, very difficult.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2005 07 26Q Bodhisattvas Way of Life.mp3
UUID: d35b3387-c76c-4f58-9b10-8fccbc68cc67
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Bodhisattva Way of Life 2005 Mar -2007 (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2005-07-26
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 51.6 minutes
Words: ~3,501
Yes. Mhmm. Mhmm. I just realized something. That other word that I was saying emanations, if I translated magic into Tibetan, I’d have to use the same word.
But you don’t usually say magic. Anyway, go on. Yes. Magic. Electronic magic.
Cool. So in a way, it it doesn’t matter if it’s just, you know, observations or magic or what. What you see on the screen Alright. This is an obscure answer. So I’m warning you.
You have to think. He said So so I’m so the question was basically what it appears. Yeah. So does it matter whether it’s real or not, or is it how you experience it? Yeah?
How How how you interpret it? So Geshe-la said Uh-uh. Okay. Geshe-la said, it does matter how it appears because if if if it if a compute for instance, take an example of a computer. He said, if a computer existed the way that it appeared, we wouldn’t be able to work with it.
There would be nothing else to know. You couldn’t become a computer expert. Alright? That would be just it. If that was the way it appeared, that would be it.
There would be nothing else to know. There would be nothing you could do with a computer. There would be nothing you could learn from the computer. That was it. It would exist in a very solid way.
Alright? But if you became a computer expert, then you can understand what’s happening on the screen, you can understand why it’s happening on the screen, and you can react to it in a much more intelligent way. Yes? And so if things if it wasn’t just how we were related to it, but since things didn’t solidly exist, there’d be nowhere to go with that. There would be no understanding to come from that.
Alright? There would be no way that we could develop past our experiences if things existed in a in a fixed way. So it’s only the fact that things appear and don’t inherently exist that means that we can actually experience things differently. So the two things are interlinked. That.
Okay. Guess to say the point is that it’s not that we’re having individual experiences of it. It’s that we’re all seeing something that’s not there. Alright? So he said, when we relate to a computer, if we were interrelating with a computer, we forget that it’s actually it’s actually electricity and wiring and everything that’s functioning in there to create this screen.
Yeah. We if we unless we, think about it, we don’t remember that. We know it, but we don’t remember it, and we interact with it as if it’s really there. And he said we do the same thing with all of our experiences. We we relate to them.
We’re relating to something that’s not there, and by relating to something that’s not there, by pinning our hopes on something that’s not there, we’re going to experience suffering, and the suffering is the problem. So we may be seeing and experiencing all different things, But each of us is seeing something that’s not there. So everything that we experience, everything that we see, whether exists. Alright? When we go searching for it, we can’t find it.
Yeah. The main cause he says is is is electricity, but there’s many other causes and conditions that cause us to see something. But we put something onto that, something that we can work with, this that we call it this or we call it that, or we call it something else. But the point is that we’ve mistaken something that’s not there for something that is there. Something that we’ve mistaken something that isn’t there for something that’s there.
Us pushing the on button is a cause. Yeah. And then the the computer lights up or it wakes up, so it’s literally. It wakes up, and it shows us all different things. If it wasn’t coming into being through causes and conditions, yeah, if it did have an inherent existence, it would appear in a static way and no button pressing would change that and nothing would change on it.
The — it comes into life because we’ve hit a button. Alright? And that’s one cause, and that’s joined in with all of the others. It’s the same with anything that we see. It’s not so much that we are having an individual experience of it, as that all of us are projecting something onto something that’s not there.
It’s just that we’re not seeing it. We’re not seeing it. It’s just what we see, the inherent existence that we see and when we relate to objects is not there. Yeah. Yeah.
It appears, but it’s not there. Yeah. Yes. Uh-huh. So what do you mean by contemplation?
Thinking over things? Or Yeah. Just like Okay. Okay. Oh, he said you must be doing it wrong if that’s what happened.
So so the so the how doesn’t was the question was like, so why doesn’t conceptualizing about things, contemplating on things, rarify our ideas as opposed to or or solidify our ideas, instead of making them more solid and Yeah. Can I just tell you what Geshe-la said and then see if it answers it? Yeah. Okay. I’ll tell you what he’s saying.
Hang on. Can I tell you what he’s go tell him? I tell you what he said first before I forget? Alright. He said the idea is that you turn words and ideas on themselves.
Yeah? So that you take an idea and you turn it on itself and see where you can get with it. So he said, if I take the idea Geshe-la, alright, now it’s a very simple idea. He said, usually, people keep saying Geshe-la, Geshe-la, and then and then I think, okay, what’s Geshe-la? Right?
And if I think, okay, that’s one word. Yeah? And every time I think Geshe-la, an idea comes in my head. Yeah? And and you may have an idea that comes into your head if you think Geshe-la.
Alright? So you have an idea that comes into your head, but is that Geshe-la? Yeah? Is the idea that you have in your head Geshe-la? No.
So you gotta go looking for Geshe-la. Alright? And he said, you may think, okay, that’s him. Yeah? That that physical being is him.
And he said, but a body does not a Geshe make. Yes? He said, you can’t say a physical body is a Geshe. You can’t find a Geshe in a body. Yeah?
So he said, you gotta go looking for it, and if the in the body, there is only bones and everything like that, so you’re using the concepts you have to to get into the concepts to see that they’re not there. You’re turning the concepts back on themselves. Alright? And by turning the concepts back on themselves, you’re using your intellect to pierce through your conceptions. Yeah?
So he said you can’t see Geshe-la anywhere. You can’t find Geshe-la anywhere. And so once you’ve gone through that process, you’re left with something beyond concepts. Geshe-la. And Geshe-la disappears.
This is Geshe-la. Your intellect to to attack. Geshe-la, So once you’ve investigated once you’ve investigated in this way, the idea of Geshe-la disappears. Alright? So if you keep looking for Geshe-la and you don’t find him, your conception of that just evaporates.
Alright. So the idea is that you use your intellect, you use your intelligence to cut through to see the lack of something. Yeah? And if you didn’t do that, you might as well just go to sleep because that’s the only way that you’re gonna stop thinking, is to go to sleep. When you’re in deep sleep, that’s when you stop thinking, and that’s about the only time that you do.
So the idea is to use what you’ve got to pierce through your conceptions of things, to use your intellect to pierce through your conceptions of things. Alright. So the idea also with contemplating — what do you call it? Analytical meditation — is not to sit there and think about all sorts of different things. It’s to go over one thing again and again and again and again.
So the idea when you’re thinking about analytical meditation on emptiness is that when you look for things, you can’t find them. Yeah? And when you don’t look, they appear and that’s it. Alright? So you go over that again and again.
When I look for this, when I look for something that is this thing I’m focusing on, I can’t find it. When I don’t think about it, it appears. So therefore, it isn’t a a complete nullification of anything. It’s not, the extreme of nihilism, and it isn’t eternalism. Alright?
It’s it doesn’t not and it doesn’t it doesn’t it doesn’t not exist conventionally, and it doesn’t, ultimately exist inherently. So you’re going through those two things, and that’s it. You don’t go all over different things, you just go over the same thing again and again and again. It’s the same thing with doing analytical meditation on bodhicitta, you go over the same ideas again and again and again because the idea of meditation means familiarization. It doesn’t mean having different thoughts and wandering around in different thoughts, it means going over the same basic concepts again and again.
Is that okay? Woah. Joe. Mhmm. So That’s not a conventional thing, though.
Myself. Joe. Okay. Sky flower is not a conventional thing. Yeah.
But we can also say sky flower. Right. So We can use the words, but they don’t exist. They’re not a conventional truth. But hang on, Joe.
Because I’m thinking about how to translate this. You have to you’re changing between a thing and me, like an I. Alright? If you said this person and this book, that’s different to saying I and you. So you have to get clear what you’re asking because I can’t translate unless you’re clear.
If Oh, dear. People. Because the people exist. It’s the self or the atma that doesn’t exist. So if you’re talking about me as being a person, then that exists.
If you’re talking about self as being a like the atma, yeah, then that doesn’t exist. So if you’re he said if you’re sorry. Gotta finish. Otherwise, won’t remember. Gotta give let me do it.
And so if you have this if you have this idea of saying I did this and you do this because we’re talking about conventional reality, we’re not talking about necessarily the self then, we’re talking about the person. So so so you can have a conventional person, alright, and and there’s there is a conventional person, there’s a conventional me, and there’s conventional you. What’s a totally nonexistent like a sky flower is that or the that is a totally nonexistent thing. What’s saying? What’s he saying?
Is it got to be a child of confusion. Yes. What confusion? Yeah. According to the Buddha.
Yeah. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay.
Existence. Alright. Yep. Yeah. I I’m gonna I have to take a really obscure path to get to this.
Okay? Alright. So you have to bear with me. Oh. Like, the people from Shigatse, don’t ask me.
Okay. He said, there is a self that is a person. Hang on. Sorry. I need a new back.
There’s a self that is a person. Yeah? And that person conventionally exists. Yes? There is a self that goes, this self is going to the shop.
That’s a direct translation, and that says, this self is, going to go and eat my food. Yeah? That that’s something that appears. Yeah? So it’s something that we experience.
There’s also a self that is an atma, right, that we can think of as being a true that we have this idea of a truly existent self. Yeah? That’s something that doesn’t exist. So, basically, what you’re talking about is two different selves. You have a self that’s a person and that’s fine.
That’s a convention, that’s fine. You also have a self which is an idea of an independent, autonomous, singular, eternal entity, and that doesn’t exist. That’s what’s being refuted. So he said, if you think about it that way and there being two selves, one a conventional person, the other one an ultimately existent independent autonomous thing, then that’s the best way to think of it. And one of those conventionally exists and the other doesn’t.
Yeah. So it’s not there’s nothing like So the self that doesn’t exist is this thing that we consider to be so important that when we look for, we can’t find. So we have a self-cherishing mind. When we look for that self that we’re cherishing so hard, we can’t find it. So that’s the self that doesn’t exist.
Yeah. So things that aren’t established by their own definition produce things that aren’t established by their own definition, but neither the thing that is being the cause isn’t established by its own definition nor the thing that it is acting as a cause exist. So therefore exist inherently. So therefore, none of them actually come about from causes. But hang on.
It was that things aren’t don’t arise without Because they come the reason that they said that is that they are labeled, and that’s how they come into being. It’s not because they have another contingent cause, it’s because they come from a label, that’s the only way they conventionally exist, and that’s what the fourth one means, he said, they’re not coming from either. So that’s the the cause, but it’s not a real cause. Okay. So the so the idea is that that you’re going through an analytical process.
In the so in the fourth one when it says, they’re not come they don’t come from neither, then then that’s when you bring yourself back to thinking that they appear. Alright? So these things appear. So if they appear, then they’d be labeled. Yeah?
And this is the three you go through those four four processes, and the last one is when you bring yourself back to conventional reality. Yeah. So stop to go from this to the extreme of nihilism. Now are you okay? He wants to know.
You’re okay, but Natalie’s not. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Said, he’s he’s alright. You know, he’s Joe.
Yeah. Yeah. Uh-huh. Okay. So the idea was that there was people at the time of the Buddha who were in this peculiar situation, peculiar as in different, right?
Not peculiar as in weirdos, right? That they had the karma of being ordinary beings who had their perception to see a Buddha. That’s a very peculiar karma. Alright? And and even then, there was lots of people that didn’t see the Buddha as a Buddha.
They saw him as a fake. Even his cousin saw him as a fake and tried to kill him. Yeah? So there was people even at that time who saw Buddha, but didn’t have the the positive potential or the karmic, the karma, whatever, to see him as a Buddha. So at this time, it’d be very difficult for us to see someone as a Buddha without developing ourselves to the stage where we can clearly see them.
Even then, it was difficult, but it was it they’re in a very peculiar situation. Mhmm. So that’s why we we should be trying to get merit because that can happen to us. Yeah. Because they did.
They entered the path and then quickly changed realizations because all the causes came together with this perfect teacher and so on. So if we try and create merit now, that can happen to us. Oh, he said, yeah, probably there’s he said that there may even be one in the room that someone could see if they had the karma. If you if you have the karma, you can see Buddhas. If you have the merit or the positive potential, you can see Buddhas.
Yes. You can see the Dalai Lama. That’s what highly recognized teacher. Not the one. Right.
Okay. So we have really good karma in that we are able to see the the Dalai Lama as a we may see him as a really good monk, as a really good person, as a person even with realizations, but in order to see him as a Buddha, we need to have realizations. So, we don’t see him as a Buddha. We believe he may be a Buddha, but there’s a big difference between believing someone’s a Buddha and being able to see them as a Buddha. Being able to see them as a Buddha depends on having realizations ourselves.
And then, we can even look at the way that people relate to the Dalai Lama. There’s some people that can see him as a Buddha, alright? So, looks like they can see him as a Buddha. There’s others who believe he’s a Buddha, there’s others who think he’s a fraud, and there’s people who’ve been trying to kill him, alright? So, there’s all different levels of karma on how people relate to the Dalai Lama as well.
Yeah. Do you have realizations of guru devotion and the and a just a person as a realization of guru devotion is able to see the actions of their guru purely like a Buddha. Is that You’re saying like a Buddha? Yeah. But is that seeing the Buddha I mean, because if they are doing that, then the scriptures say that then all the Buddhas will enter the teacher to teach.
Mhmm. What question is, like, you know, what level do you have to be to be able to see to see the teacher, to see the Buddha’s Okay. Okay. Okay. There’s a big things Is that the case of when you attain perfect guru devotion that then you can see the guru as Buddha.
Can we start with asking what perfect guru devotion is? Yeah. Okay. What level that is? Yeah.
Because I was also thinking there’s a big difference in Tibetan between the words to look at your teacher as a Buddha and to your teacher as a Buddha. Right. A big difference. Yeah. I’m interested in it.
Because yeah. I’m actually having trouble with this word devotion because I don’t know which one you mean in Tibetan because there’s no word in Tibetan for devotion. There’s only word for relying. There’s a word for that okay. Mhmm.
Mhmm. Okay. Alright. So, Geshe-la, in order for us to attain a realization where we see our teachers as a Buddha is incredibly difficult. I kept Okay.
Alright. Okay. He’s not telling me. Uh-uh. Uh-uh.
Okay. I say, so is it about when you achieve realize emptiness is like, I don’t know. It could be any time like that. But he said it’s really hard. Whatever it is, whenever you do it, it’s really hard.
So, basically, you start with this idea of looking at your teacher as Buddha. Alright? You look at teacher as a Buddha, and then whenever you start working with this idea that things aren’t as they appear, so if I see anything that’s a fault, then that’s a fault that I’m projecting, and if I see anything and and and all of the activities is Buddha, is is is a activities of Buddha, and you keep working at that and working at that and working at that, and, eventually, you’re able to perceive that, to see it directly. After you’ve developed the idea of looking at them as, then eventually, you see it. Yeah?
So it’s something that you need to practice and practice and practice, and you have to get rid of incredible amounts of obscurations to be able to see it, and it’s it’s very, very difficult realization to achieve to be able to see your teacher as a Buddha. Let’s say it again. It’s very difficult. But if they were a Buddha and then you achieve that, then you’re seeing a Buddha. Even if they were, you wouldn’t see it.
So you either if if you were able to do that, then you would be way along the path to to to developing all the other realizations like the people at the time of the Buddha. Yeah. It’s very, very difficult. Very, very difficult. Very, very difficult.
He said about three times. Yeah. Yeah. That he said seeing teachers was very difficult, very difficult. Oh, he said it’d be about the same time as you start seeing Buddhas.
Okay. So you need to get rid of all your obstructions because if you saw him as a Buddha, you’d start seeing all the other Buddhas around the place. Him or her as a Buddha, you’d see the other Buddhas around the place. And again. Difficult.
That’s all for now. Time up.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- guru devotion
- After finding a fully qualified spiritual teacher and establishing a connection, the disciple trains in devotion using logical reasoning. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Does it matter whether things are real or not, or only how we experience them?
It matters how things appear. If a computer existed the way it appears, solid and fixed, there would be nothing to learn about it and no way to become an expert or respond more intelligently. Because things appear but do not inherently exist, we can experience them differently and develop beyond our experiences. The two are interlinked. Everyone is not simply having a private experience; all are seeing something that is not there. We forget that the computer is electricity and wiring, and treat it as really there. We do this with all experiences, and pinning our hopes on something that is not there brings suffering. Things arise from causes and conditions, such as pressing the on button.