31 min · 2,695 words · 14 June 2005 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. A student’s question about making a bathing offering feel “too real” opens this 31.5-minute Q&A with Geshe Pema Tsering. He clarifies that such offerings exist entirely for the practitioner: the visualization works as purification of obscurations and merit accumulation simultaneously, with respect — not sympathy — as the proper inner attitude. The session then pivots to emptiness: a student asks what remains of the mind when self is recognized as non-existent, and Geshe-la describes post-realization life as perceiving things only conventionally, like a dream, with no residual grasping or ups and downs. He briefly addresses whether practitioners may have glimpsed emptiness at death through the Tantric clear light mind, then closes by distinguishing Mahāmudrā and pristine awareness from a bare realization of emptiness: both point instead to the inseparability of the subtlest blissful mind and its empty nature — a fuller realization grounded in emptiness and the awakening mind together. Suited to practitioners already working through the Bodhisattva Way of Life text.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2005 06 14Q Bodhisattvas Way of Life.mp3
UUID: 85f1440d-8b16-46fc-a9d7-69612550407b
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Bodhisattva Way of Life 2005 Mar -2007 (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2005-06-14
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 31.5 minutes
Words: ~2,694
You need to get you know, indulge yourself a little darling. Okay. Okay. Okay. So the main reason that you make a bathing offering is that it’s symbolic of purification.
So in making a bathing offering to the Buddha, you’re purifying your own obscurations. This is the process that you’re going through. It’s a purification practice. So the the idea is that you’re purifying yourself, but because the purification practice that you’re doing is where you’re bathing Buddhas. Right?
And Buddhas are very important, more important than Maharajas that you want them to have the best bath that they can have. So the idea of all of these visualizations is that that you’re making offerings to the Buddha, means you can accumulate merit here, and you wanna make the bath the best it can be because that this is the best these people possess the best qualities that we can have. And so, in this way, you’re doing an act as purifying and you’re also accumulating merit at the same time. Yes. I said, so it’s not okay just to stick them in any old shower and guess they weren’t.
No. Alright. Buddhas don’t need them, but if we’re going to do a visualization practice, it’s a purification practice where we’re bathing the Buddhas. Alright? There is a very good way to purify you, you’re you’re in the same instance, you’re accumulating merit by having this thing of offering and you’re purifying by involving the cleansing aspect of it.
Alright? So if we’re going to do this practice, we need to give them the best bath possible. Alright? So it’s not for them. It’s not as if they need to have the best bath possible because it doesn’t mean that much to them.
We ask them to accept it because it’s on our behalf. It’s so that we can accumulate merit and it’s so that we can purify our obscurations. It’s not so they can purify this. And and it’s very important to remember this process. It’s important to remember that the bathing ritual that you’re visualizing in your mind is an act of purifying your negative actions.
Oh, sorry, your your obscurations. And it’s it’s important to remember when you’re offering the ornaments and you’re offering the clothes that this is a way for you is like his planting the karma or creating the seeds for you to develop positive qualities and activities and things like that. So you you think this is may this be a cause for me to attain the activities of a Buddha or develop the activities of Buddha or maybe this be a cause for me to attain qualities while you’re doing the visualization. That gets to say that’s the most important part that you’re concentrating on that aspect of it. So all the offerings to Buddhas are actually all for us.
Uh-huh. Is did that come through on the tape? Just one. Okay. So all the offerings to Buddhas are there for ourselves.
Individuals individual selves. Does that mean it’s more symbolic then? Did everyone hear that? She said, does that mean it’s more symbolic So Geshe says it’s important not to just think of it as being symbolic. It’s important to think of it as being real.
Right? Otherwise, you’re only offering a symbolic bath. Yeah. Oh, Yeah. I think yeah.
Yeah. Yeah. I think you’re first. I’m having trouble thinking of it as too real. I can visualize doing it with love as if it was my mother.
Yeah. But when I try and get too real, you’re getting too close to the Buddha’s and Great. That is so much fun. Alright. That’s a cool question.
They can be wearing clothes, he said. Yeah. Okay. So says he’s probably thinking this because you’re probably thinking this because you would feel quite uncomfortable if someone was giving you a bath. Alright?
Someone you didn’t know well was giving you a bath, you’d feel quite uncomfortable. But you that’s not the the part of it that you’re that you’re focusing on. Right? So anything that you could do where you you wouldn’t feel uncomfortable in that situation, you can do it and it’s your visualization. Alright?
But the idea is focusing on the fact that you’re offering something that’s cleansing. So I said, maybe part of the thing is that we tend to have showers if if not every day, then every other day. And we don’t consider it a very important thing. But in in India and in Tibet, it was a big deal to have a shower. Geshe-la said, yeah.
We didn’t consider it important. We only had showers twice a year. And then then they but but he said, so we weren’t having showers twice a year. We only had showers twice a year, but every day, we’d make offerings of baths to the Buddhas. So he said that he said, he knows from that experience then that if you don’t shower, if you don’t bathe, you don’t feel very good.
And when you have a bath, then if you if you if you haven’t had a chance and you have a bath, it’s it feels very good. So that’s what you’re offering. You’re offering that opportunity to cleanse themselves. So if you imagine that someone hasn’t had the opportunity to have a bath and you’re offering them a bath in this very, very pleasant environment, then that’s what you’re offering to the Buddhas, that experience. Yeah.
Hang on. Here, Pamela, was that hand up? And you’ve had a turn. Yeah. I actually yeah.
A mosaic. Start renovating your bathroom. Start renovating your bathroom. Yeah. Do you deal with that?
Uh-huh. Move to Tibet and have a bath twice a year. Alright. So Geshe-la said that’s part of the process of offering because you’re giving something that you consider to be very good. Alright?
And if you’re thinking, well, it’d be alright to be a Buddha because I get all this stuff, then you can remind yourself that Buddhas don’t actually even need this. They’re beyond that stuff. So the idea of giving is that you’re giving things that you’re attached to. That’s the process of giving. Yeah?
And then things that you you find good for yourself, that’s what you’re giving. And then the other part is that the Buddhas are so happy they’re beyond that. Anthony, did you have your hand up before? Because I think there was two people at the beginning. It’s alright?
Anthony, Yeah. May? Yeah. I have a question from last week, which we kind of ended on this point, and I thought about it during the week. It’s the question, what happens if you realize that you don’t have a self or an observer self?
What what happens to the the mind? Like, I I had the feeling that Geshe was gonna go on and talk about that a little more, but we stopped. What do you mean observer self? Like a self that’s, you know, a concrete I self that’s Yeah. So there’s no observer or self or I there.
I don’t understand this word observer. I don’t know how to translate it. Okay. We just go to self. Okay.
Because because because observer is getting into something different. It’s going into, like, the function of the mind and things like that. Alright. Yeah. Go to self.
Okay. Okay. So what happens is that, first, all of the thoughts that you had about what you would be thinking and when you did realize selflessness and all of them are gone. You don’t have the conceptualizations that are based on self. Right?
So, you don’t conceive of any of those ideas or wonder about any of those because they’re all based on self. And so what you’re left with is an understanding of the way that things only conventionally exist and that you relate to things as if they only conventionally exist. And in this way, there is no thought of what will I think then? Because that’s still based on self. They just stop.
They’re gone. So you’re existing you recognize things exist in a conventional way and with the way you relate to things is by seeing their true nature as lacking inherent existence and as only conventionally existent things. So there’s no attachment, there’s no even grasping for that what happened to that sense of self or anything. Is that do you does that make sense, you said? Yeah.
Must be a relief. Yeah. Yeah. Definitely. Yeah.
That’s the whole point of meditating on emptiness. So if you the the reason that we you work at developing an understanding of emptiness is because the way that we grasp onto things at the moment as being truly existent, including ourselves, creates suffering for us. It creates a a sense of what of I needing things and so on. If we get to the stage where we’ve perceived that to be incorrect and we see the way that things exist only conventionally, we stop grasping at them. So there’s no sense of I need this, I want this, all of that has just gone.
No everything disappears to us as if it was a dream. So we still see things, still interact with things, but there’s no attachment to any of them. It’s all it’s all pleasant. Yeah. There’s no ups and downs on it.
It’s all pleasant. And then eventually when you become a Buddha, so that’s the process after realizing that’s what happens after you realize emptiness. And then you work at getting rid of the obscurations that you still have so that your realization of reality in meditation and your perception of things as being dreamlike in post meditation both become subtler and subtler and subtler till eventually as a Buddha there’s no distinction between your meditation and your post meditation and you realize everything as you clearly see the lack of inherent existence in every moment, in everything. And have we been there before? Which bit?
Have we — have we had direct perception of emptiness before. He said he doesn’t know. He thinks he’s allowed to say no. And he knows for certain that he hasn’t realized emptiness, but he’s pretty sure most other people haven’t he he haven’t here as well. Okay.
There’s this thing. Right? Alright. So there’s there’s this thing that maybe he can he can say most of the most in most perspectives, I can say no. Alright?
But there is a element there is no. There is a one approach to Tantra that says, realizing the clear light mind at the moment of death is realizing emptiness. Some people say that’s true, a true realization of emptiness, and some people say it’s not really a true realization of emptiness, it’s something like it. Yeah? So you may have done that and forgot about it.
Yeah? And then there was some people would say, okay, so you have from one Tantra school’s perspective realized emptiness and forgotten about it, but most people say that that isn’t a true of emptiness. It’s a similitude of it. Right? So there’s different two different ways you can realize a clear light mind at the time of death.
One directly and one well, one directly where it has it’s like the same thing as really realizing emptiness, and there’s another not quite as subtle realization as that that some people say is realizing emptiness and some say isn’t. So you can realize that and forget about it, but generally realizing emptiness, you don’t forget about it. Does that make sense? Mhmm. Hiro, Hiro, was it you first or then Yeah.
Yeah. Because I think you and them yeah. Come on. Actually, I have the there’s a different types of offering to. It’s a different type, to develop our empathy.
Empathy? Yeah. I understand empathy. For the Buddhas? Consideration or sympathy. Consideration perhaps.
Mhmm. But empathy is like a you couldn’t really have sympathy for the Buddha because sympathy is like this idea of, oh, you poor thing. Okay. Consideration is good. We can work with consideration.
Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Those two work, not sympathy. And empathy would be a big call.
Okay. Okay. That’s one reason, but it’s almost as if consideration or respect for the Buddhas is the reason that you would make an offering. Is the is the not the reason. It’s the attitude with which you make the offering.
The reason you make the offering is to create merit, to purify your karma so you can become a Buddha. So the attitude you have is one of respect. Alright? So you respectfully make the offerings, but the reason you do it is to purify your negative karma and accumulate positive karma so you can become a Buddha. Are you busy?
Oh, he’s got he’s talking about your computer. I was like, what is he talking about? Yeah. Yep. Now I heard I could have missed one.
Mhmm. I could have missed one. More likely. That by making yourself a servant and going for refuge, you are protected. Yep.
And that this I read that. Gives you an ability to separate yourself from the tendency to gain to engage in negative actions, and this weakens the potency Uh-huh. Of past negative actions. Uh-huh. Now what does that say?
Yeah. I think so, but I can I can clarify something there? Yeah. The question related to that Mhmm. Mhmm.
I can understand how moving forward you would not be creating the you’re weakening weakening the tendency to do it again. Who said that taking refuge or following the advice of the Buddha includes purification. Right. Yeah. So if you’re if you’re turning yourself into a servant of the Buddha, then you’re what in that process, what you’re doing is purifying negative karma, and you’re not going to do it again.
Okay. I didn’t actually get the whole question out, but yeah. Can you just ask, Geshe-la, if pristine awareness or the crown of Mahāmudrā is the same as or means realization of emptiness? I don’t know what you mean by the crown of Mahāmudrā. I’ve never heard that expression before.
It’s just something I read. And I’ve had to translate a whole text on Mahāmudrā, I’ve never heard that before. But hang on. Yeah. The the final realization of Mahāmudrā or something.
Yeah. Yeah? Alright. And what was the other one? Pristine awareness.
Okay. Did everyone hear that? She want yeah? Okay. Crowned.
It may may have just been an expression, the Crown of Mahāmudrā said, that they say it in all different ways. Alright. So they’re not quite the same thing, because both of these things are not just talking about a perception or a direct perception of emptiness, but they’re talking about a practice based on a combination of a direct perception of emptiness and bodhicitta, in which you are able to rid yourself of the grosser levels of mind and using the subtlest type of mind or the subtlest form of mind, then that subtlest form of mind recognizes its own empty nature and the you and the inseparability of bliss from that empty nature and that’s like a synonym of Buddhahood in Tantra. Okay? So, in terms of the pristine awareness or the Mahāmudrā, that’s what that’s talking about.
So, it’s not a synonym of realizing emptiness, there’s actually more going on in it. It’s based on emptiness, based on bodhicitta, then you develop this perception. It is that perception. It doesn’t mean it’ll happen quickly. Alright.
You can’t say it’s that awareness. Right? Because awareness is only talking about one side of it. And I said, so Geshe-la isn’t it non dual? And he said, I wouldn’t even use the word non dual.
I would say inseparable. So it’s the inseparability. Alright? The inseparability of the subtlest form of mind, yeah, which is by nature bliss and it’s emptiness, the inseparability of it, alright? So it’s not awareness and it’s not emptiness, it’s the inseparability of those two things.
Yeah. Okay. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- Mahamudra chag ya chen po (Tib)
- The Great Seal; a profound system of meditation upon the mind and the ultimate nature of reality. LYWA
- real I
- The I that appears to exist inherently from its own side without depending on causes and conditions, parts or the mind's imputation. It is the object to be refuted. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Have we had a direct perception of emptiness before, in previous lives or at any earlier time?
Generally the answer is no, and most people have not realized emptiness. However, one approach to Tantra says that realizing the clear light mind at the moment of death is realizing emptiness. Some say this is a true realization of emptiness, while others say it is only something like it, a similitude. There are two ways to realize the clear light mind at death: one directly, which is the same as truly realizing emptiness, and another, less subtle realization that some call a realization of emptiness and some do not. So one may have had that second kind of experience and forgotten it, but generally when emptiness is truly realized, it is not forgotten.
Is pristine awareness, or the Crown of Mahāmudrā, the same as realizing emptiness?
They are not quite the same, and Mahāmudrā is not a synonym for realizing emptiness. Neither refers merely to a perception or direct perception of emptiness. Both refer to a practice based on a combination of a direct perception of emptiness and bodhicitta. In this practice the grosser levels of mind are removed, and the subtlest mind recognizes its own empty nature, together with the inseparability of bliss from that empty nature. This is like a synonym of Buddhahood in Tantra. So there is more going on than realizing emptiness: it is based on emptiness and bodhicitta, and from these this perception is developed. It will not necessarily happen quickly.