1 h 14 min · 7,228 words · 19 April 2005 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Using the Buddha’s image of saṃsāra as “sitting on a pin — never comfortable,” Geshe Pema Tsering opens this 74-minute commentary with a tour of all six realms, showing how each carries its own mode of suffering — including the gods’ “contaminated happiness,” bliss that collapses when its causes are exhausted. He then makes the subtler case that meditation without renunciation leads only to high-realm rebirth, still inside saṃsāra. The session pivots to bodhicitta: its two defining aspirations (attaining Buddhahood oneself and leading all beings to enlightenment), the distinction between aspirational and engaging bodhicitta, and four types classified by stages of the path. Geshe Tsering closes by sketching the five paths and ten bodhisattva grounds as a meditational map, noting that the full journey spans three countless eons and 144 progressive clear realizations.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2005 04 19 Bodhisattvas Way of Life.mp3
UUID: 3a4edc22-e652-4645-837b-db2ac021fd5b
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Bodhisattva Way of Life 2005 Mar -2007 (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2005-04-19
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 74.3 minutes
Words: ~7,227
Alright. And one of the sutras, the Buddha said, there is no there is no happiness. There is not an, an instance of happiness in saṃsāra. The experience of saṃsāra is like sitting on a pin. Right?
The last thing that goes to the surface: sitting on a pin is uncomfortable. It it pokes you. So that was that made me want to say it’s not comfortable. You’re never comfortable. He said, you’re never comfortable sitting on a pin.
Okay. So when it says, the beings in saṃsāra are uncomfortable now, these these two small words, the or three small words, beings in saṃsāra actually covers a lot because it covers every any existence that we can be reborn into in saṃsāra. So In terms of the type of places we can be reborn or the type of situations we can be reborn into in saṃsāra, in Buddhist cosmology there are only six. We have to be reborn in either the hell realms, the spirit realms, the animal realms, as a human, as a asura or like a titan or as a god. Alright?
Now if we’re reborn in the hell realms, we don’t need to talk about much about the sufferings of the hell realms because they are very self evident. The hell realms are characterized by intense, continually manifest suffering. Now the sufferings of the spirit realm are less well documented, but they are are less easy to understand, but they’re basically characterized by, constant, constant grasping or constant a constant sense of dissatisfaction. So, the spirits are always looking for something to eat, something to eat, something to drink, somewhere to be comfortable and never finding a moment of relief from that search. Now The animals, their suffering is mainly characterised by eating each other, either eating others or being eaten, constantly in a struggle for survival.
humans, to be their suffering is said to be, mainly characterized by, busyness, accompanied with a sense of not really, getting achieving what we want to achieve. The, the the realm of the or the demigods. They’re not really demigods, but anyway, I had a Greek person tell me that demigods are a cross between humans and gods. Right? So these guys aren’t demigods.
And they actually I’m more like titans, but you’re probably used to hearing demigods. But, anyway, they’re in between people, in between humans and gods. Their suffering is characterized by, by strife, by continually, trying to, attain more power and so on and fighting with the trying to trying to attain the state of a god. And the gods, experience is said to be characterized by, complete immersion in bliss so much so that they don’t strive to get out of that situation. So their suffering is said to be the suffering of inertia, not moving, not seeking to move from where they are.
This one. Mhmm. So from amongst these experiences, we may think that the God realm is the best best place to be reborn in Samsāra because it is it’s in it’s being reborn in the God realm means that we experience great bliss and great happiness all the time. And it’s true that beings in the God realm do experience great bliss and great happiness all the time. It’s just that the problem with the happiness that beings experience in the God realms or in the heavens is doesn’t last.
And because it comes into existence based on causes and conditions, when those causes and conditions have finished, then the experience of happiness or the experience of bliss finishes. Alright? And they have to move on. So in this way, the happiness of the God realms is said to be contaminated happiness. It’s happiness, yes, but it’s contaminated happiness.
Its nature is actually suffering. It may look to us as if it’s happiness, but its nature is actually suffering because it is compounded, because it comes into being based on causes and conditions. And when those causes and conditions cease to exist, it disappears. Right? And because it is and because we can’t rely on it in this way, then that means that it is by its nature is suffering.
It reverts to suffering. It leads to suffering. We can’t rely on forever existing in that state. So because it’s not reliable in this way, we say it’s a is a form of suffering, suffering of change. It changes into suffering.
So the same can be said for being a human. Now as a human, we have a relatively pleasant experience. We sometimes experience suffering, we sometimes experience happiness. The happiness we experience doesn’t last for as long as the the God realms. It changes more quickly.
So we may think that we can achieve happiness as a human, that we work really hard to experience happiness as a human. But, the thing is that the only way that we can experience happiness, even in a contaminated way, even in samsaric changing way, is through performing a positive action. So we achieve happiness because we’ve done positive things in the past and the repercussions of those positive things experience of happiness or experience of pleasure. But the experiences that we have of happiness or pleasure are tainted in that they are not permanent, are not true happiness or pleasure. And causes for those experiences are also tainted in that they are not true causes for happiness.
They are contaminated or confused attempts at creating the causes for happiness. So in this way, the things that we view in Samsāra as being happiness, as being pleasure, are only happiness and pleasure in a superficial contaminated way. They don’t last forever, we can’t rely on them, and because they’re based on a number of causes and conditions coming together when they dissipate, then the the experience is no longer there. So the problem with the the with our experience, why we have why we were in saṃsāra is because we don’t, on one hand, recognize that the happiness that we experience in saṃsāra isn’t true happiness. And and on the other hand, we don’t know what nirvana is properly.
If we knew what nirvana was, we’d be working towards nirvana. And if we understood the suffering of Samsāra, we’d be trying to get out of Samsāra. But not knowing these two things, in our quest to be happy, because all beings wanna experience happiness, we mistake the happiness of saṃsāra for true happiness and strive after it. And in striving after happiness in saṃsāra, we perpetuate saṃsāra. So if we want to get out of saṃsāra, we need to recognize what saṃsāra is, that the happiness of gods and humans isn’t actually true happiness.
It is changing. It disintegrates. It’s not something we can rely on. And we need to strive for the true happiness, the lasting happiness which is the state of nirvana or Buddhahood, which we can only achieve by getting out of Samsāra. And by recognizing now, cheers on the lovely.
And by recognizing the the suffering in saṃsāra, for what the pleasure of saṃsāra for what it is, which is truly suffering. Now, the reason that we can recognize we can recognize saṃsāra happiness as happiness or we see saṃsāra happiness as happiness and we don’t know about nirvana is because we are limited to our own experiences and we’ve experienced many times the happiness of saṃsāra. Many times we’ve been happy and we’ve had blissful experiences or very happy experiences and we’ve never experienced nirvana before. We’ve never experienced what it’s like to be completely free of suffering. And as we know about one and we don’t know about the other, then our tendency is to focus on the thing that we we know of, we know of, the thing we feel sure about, the thing we have faith in actually coming about, which is the happiness of of sense.
Uh-huh. Okay. So even if we were to oh, sorry. So the the experience that we have is that we don’t like suffering. We wanna experience happiness.
We don’t understand nirvana or we don’t understand Buddha. We don’t understand what that kind of happiness is. So we strive for the for happiness in a sensory way. Now this can even be in terms of the meditation and Dharma practice. We can still be doing Dharma meditation practice and in doing so hang on.
Not Dharma yeah. Dharma practice. Futile. Alright. Dharma practice.
Didn’t say Dharma. Talking to myself, I should shut up. Anyway, we just didn’t want to make a mistake. Okay. So our Dharma practice can still be contained within saṃsāra What we can do if we haven’t developed renunciation from Samsāra and this mind striving for enlightenment or nirvana, then we can spend many, many days, months, years meditating, developing our meditative abilities, and we can spend many days, months, and years developing our insight.
Alright? And if we don’t have a motivation of renunciation or a motivation of attaining enlightenment, where that leads us to, where just and developing insight leads us to, is actually being reborn again in Sansara, in the highest of the God realms, the form and formless realms, which are levels of levels that we were born into based on our meditative concentrated states, concentrated states of meditation. Alright? So we are born into those states through developing the capacity of our mind, but we’re still in saṃsāra. We’re in a very happy place in saṃsāra, and you don’t experience any suffering in those realms.
But because the motivation to get there wasn’t to get out of saṃsāra, wasn’t to attain Buddhahood, at some point, the karma runs out. At some point, the conditions that led you to that realm run out, and you end up back in some other place in Samsāra. Okay. So we’ve been in those states before. We’ve achieved the we’ve developed our mind.
We’ve developed our insight and be reborn in these form and formless realms before. We’ve experienced the bliss and happiness of being in those states, and our karma’s run out, and we’ve ended up in other parts of saṃsāra. So it didn’t really get us anywhere. Just meditating, just developing insight without the motivation of bodhicitta, without the motivation of renunciation didn’t get us anywhere. And it’s the same with being a human.
Sometimes we experience happiness as a human. Sometimes we experience suffering as a human. Sometimes the we experience the results of positive karma and sometimes the results of negative karma. Sometimes we in some lifetimes, we’ve created such a powerful positive force along with the motivation of being born as a human that we have very very happy human lives. In other ones, we don’t have so much happiness in a human life.
It keeps changing. We keep going from one situation to another. So, again, this hasn’t helped us very much. This has just perpetuated our experience with. So within saṃsāra, the law of cause and effect is infallible.
If we do something that’s positive, we experience positive results. If we do something that’s negative, we experience negative results. And even with understanding of karma, even when we understand this, most of our motivation for doing something positive is that we will experience happiness in saṃsāra. Right? That we’ll experience a rebirth as a human.
We won’t end up in the lower realms. We’ll experience a rebirth as a as a god. Even with an understanding of even if we understand karma, we’re not usually working to get out of saṃsāra. We’re usually working in order to have a pleasant rebirth, to have a good experience, to do something positive so that we can experience positive results. Now the reason that this is the this is usually our motivation is because we don’t understand nirvana and Buddhahood properly.
We don’t have an insight into them. We have an insight into positive experiences in Samsāra. So if we work on developing an understanding of karma, we’re going to want to do positive things that have positive results and try and refrain from doing negative things, so we don’t experience negative results. But then to go one step further and think, I need to get out of this process of sometimes being happy, sometimes being sad, sometimes creating positive karma, sometimes creating negative karma. To take that one step further and try and get out of saṃsāra is very is much more difficult than just developing an understanding of karma.
Because it means you’re Mhmm. And so the thing that we’re trying to work for is not just a personal liberation from saṃsāra, but the state of a Buddha. Because as Buddhas, we can lead other sentient beings or show other sentient beings how to get out of saṃsāra. So the state of a Buddha, Buddhahood, the state of being Buddha is described as being the complete cessation of faults and the complete development of positive qualities. Now the only person who can describe what that state is then is Buddha.
Alright? Unless that you have experienced that state, you can’t describe it. But thankfully for us, the Buddha did describe it. He did not only describe Buddhahood, but how to get there. And so then based on applying, contemplating, meditating, and learning the Buddha’s teachings, and we can develop an understanding of what it is to become a Buddha.
And by developing that understanding, developing that conviction in Buddhahood, then we can turn our minds towards achieving that goal. So the state of Buddhahood is where we achieve the goals of ourselves and others, to achieve the ultimate goals of self and others. So it means that we are able to do all we have accomplished all for ourselves, and we have developed ourselves ourselves into a being that is able to do the best for other beings, is able to benefit other beings in the best possible way.
So this is is what we need to develop conviction in because if we have conviction in the state of Buddhahood, then we’re going to want to work towards it. Right? Now, if this seems too big and too vast for us, then we can look towards our own liberation from suffering. Then our our own personal nirvana and use that as a motivation for doing anything. Right?
And if both of those things seem too difficult, then the the motivation that will still maintain us in saṃsāra, the one that incorporates the concept of karma is to work for a positive rebirth. Right? To abandon negative actions, perform positive actions, to get a positive rebirth. But that’s still within the bounds of saṃsāra. So the Buddha described two different types of liberation.
He described individual liberation from saṃsāra and the complete liberation of Buddhahood. Alright? And both of these experiences of liberation, what you’re being liberated from is saṃsāra. So in order to achieve either of those states of liberation, you have to see saṃsāra for what it is, an experience of suffering. So no matter how hard you work, you know, how how much positive energy or how many positive actions you do in order to achieve the results of the pleasant experiences of the god realms or the human realms.
There is no guarantee. There is no permanent experience of happiness in Samsāra. It’s constantly changing. There is no there is no way that we can achieve total happiness in Samsāra. Right?
So no matter how hard we work for Samsāra happiness, it’s not reliable. It’s constantly changing. So because of this and because we’ve been through all this before, because in many, many different lifetimes, we’ve been gods, we’ve been we’ve been in hell realms, we’ve been all over the place, and it hasn’t worked for us. We’re still stuck in saṃsāra. Then we need to try and find a different way.
We need to find a way to get out of that state, to get out of Samsāra either for for as it for our individual liberation or in as a Bodhisattva in order to benefit all sentient beings. So this one says he’s he’s he says, I’m sitting here saying, all all of the things that we consider happy in saṃsāra are actually moments of suffering, but I don’t think it’s going in anyone’s ears. He said, I don’t think it’s entering into the ears. Because it’s very difficult, said. It’s like all of the things that we consider to be happy.
I’m saying that all of them aren’t real happiness. Right? We grasp onto them as if they are happiness, but they’re not happiness. All of the things that we think make us happy don’t. Right?
They give us moments of happiness, but they don’t really make us happy. So that’s what I’m telling you. It’s hard to hear, so I don’t think it’s going in your ears. So this is the way it is. These things really can’t give us happiness no matter how much we try and convince ourselves that we that they can.
So what we need to keep reminding ourselves is this thing that I think is making me happy isn’t. It has no essence and is an instance of the truth of suffering. So anything good I’m doing, I’m not letting it I’m not letting it end up being result in that kind of thing. Alright? I’m not gonna the results of it aren’t gonna be that kind of thing.
The results of my positive actions are gonna be liberation and. Alright? This is what we need to keep reminding ourselves. And that the motivation for me doing something positive isn’t isn’t to achieve the good bits of saṃsāra. It’s to get out of saṃsāra.
We need to keep reminding ourselves of that. Because our tendency is to want the good bits in saṃsāra to grasp onto the the so called happiness of saṃsāra. So we have to make sure that we’re working on that. And the thing is, the other thing is that if we keep focusing on the the the positive aspects of we’re being really stupid because it’s not as if by attaining liberation that you’re not happy working towards liberation, you don’t become happy. Right?
Because it’s a strong and working towards working towards liberation. That motivation creates much more positive karma or much more positive potential than any other actions we’re doing. So by working towards liberation, we get happier. We get more pleasant experiences in. It’s just that if we just focus on, Samsāra, then we’re wasting the opportunity of positive of we’re wasting what could be positive results from our actions.
Sorry. I’ve gotta try and say that again. So we’re wasting no. We’re wasting the we’re wasting the opportunity to achieve much more powerful results if we were focused on liberation and Buddhahood than if we’re just focused on having a pleasant experience in saṃsāra. Oh, So we have to keep reminding ourselves that any of the so called happy things in saṃsāra are not the reason we’re performing positive actions.
That they are instances of the truth of suffering, and that they are not going to cause us to be truly happy. So by reminding ourselves of these, when we do experience these things, we can be happy about it. We just need to keep in mind that we’re not going to be truly happy from those experiences. We need to keep in mind that being attached to those experiences is going to help us perpetuate saṃsāra. Okay.
So if we do experience these moments of happiness, if we do experience things that make us really happy and then the best thing to do with those is not to pretend they’re not happening, not to try and turn them into suffering. It is to reuse them. So I guess I said if we experience some some if we get like, if if we get lots of things that make us happy, and we’re able to use them to make other people happy, then that can be a cause for us to attain Buddhahood. So we think, okay. Someone gave me lots of stuff.
I’m gonna share it with others. I’m going to let other people use it, whatever it is. And then by sharing it, by lending it, then that can come across for us to attain Buddhahood. Right? So we’re not wasting the happiness that we experience just for our own selfish gains.
So if we if we something makes us happy, then we’re able to to to share our happiness with others to to use it as another means for us to get out of saṃsāra, to attain liberation and Buddhahood. So we either can use something in a positive and a selfish way, or we can try and use it as a means to get out of saṃsāra. And if we use those happy experiences, those good things as a a means to get out of saṃsāra, then then we are perpetuating something. What we’re experiencing is the result of something we’ve done well in the past. You know, if we experience happiness, it’s because we did something well in the past.
So we can think, I must have done something well in the past. Be happy about it. We’re happy about the things we’ve done well in the past. That’s another way to use our happy experiences. So we can use all our positive experiences as a means to get out of saṃsāra.
Uh-huh. Geshe says, so this means that when even when you’re happy, can practice Dharma. Right? So it doesn’t have to be just for when you’re not happy. So when you you can think, okay.
I’m happiness. I’m sorry. I’m still practicing Dharma. May I use this happiness as a way to help other beings, as a way to help by helping beings make causes for attaining liberation. So, please, the final goal that we’re working towards is obviously enlightenment.
So, whatever we do, whether it’s transforming happiness, into a way to help others, whether it’s a, it’s coming to the teaching session. It’s going home and meditating on what we’ve learned. It’s a it’s a and making the effort to get here, making it and making it in other ways. And we should try and dedicate those actions to attain enlightenment. So if we can just try and meditate on that idea of attaining enlightenment for the benefit of sentient beings and having that as your motivation for a couple of minutes.
You said we need to know what is that we’re trying to develop. Right? So we need to know the nature of. And then that’s what we’re gonna be talking about. You know, what nature is, what what is the characteristic.
Now pardon me. Sorry. Can you hear now? Need to talk like this. Just go again.
Guess who said if you had your microphone in the wrong spot, then they’ve been trying to listen to you for three quarters an hour, and they wouldn’t have heard it. Okay. So, the definition or characteristic and characteristics of bodhicitta is that bodhicitta is the thought or the mind that seeks to attain enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings. Now, the way we seek to benefit sentient beings with bodhicitta isn’t just any old how. We’re not trying to just help them out a little bit.
We’re seeking to benefit sentient beings with bodhicitta by leading them out of saṃsāra, not taking them leading them out of the experience of sorrow and establishing them or establishing them in a state beyond sorrow. Alright? So that’s the first part of the motivation of bodhicitta. And in order to do that, we need to attain Buddhahood. We can’t show anyone how to attain Buddhahood.
We can’t explain Buddhahood. We can’t show anyone how to get there if we’re not Buddhas ourselves. So there’s these two different parts to bodhicitta. There is the wish to lead all sentient beings out of suffering, and there is the necessity of attaining Buddhahood in order to do that. So So it’s easy for us to have this idea.
I wanna attain enlightenment to benefit all sentient beings to have the thought. Right? But to actually believe it and to actually incorporate that into the way we think is kind of difficult. Right? So the if we think about it enough, we’ll have a lot of questions about it.
So we have this idea, I wanna attain enlightenment to lead all sentient beings to enlightenment. That’s the purpose of bodhicitta. So the ultimate purpose of bodhicitta is that all beings become Buddhas. Right? Now, if we think about all beings become Buddhas, we should have a lot of questions.
Like, when is that gonna happen? Right? If before that, we bring that about, we have to get ourselves to Buddhahood and how hard is that? Let alone all other sentient beings. We’re talking bugs, you know, and the hell beings, all sorts of beings.
How on earth are we gonna get all those beings to to Buddhahood? Right? So there’s many things that we could question or many doubts that perhaps will come up in our mind when we start examining bodhicitta closely. So there’s many things to think about. There’s many we have to be patient with our doubts.
We have to investigate a lot. Okay? So another question is, the Buddha said in order to become a Buddha, you need you need bodhicitta. You need to be motivated by liberating all sentient beings. Alright?
Leading all sentient beings to Buddhahood. But if all sentient beings are in are Buddhas, can you have bodhicitta? You can’t. Alright? You can’t be have the mind seeking to attain enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings when there are no sentient to attain enlightenment, you need to be motivated by the wish to liberate all sentient beings, but the Buddha hasn’t liberated all sentient beings.
There’s all of these different questions that we need to address when we are thinking about bodhicitta. We can’t just have a rough idea about it. We need to have a very clear understanding of it and deal with the doubts and the things that may come up in our mind when we’re looking at bodhicitta. Mhmm. Okay.
So the first question was when’s it gonna happen? When are all sentient beings gonna become Buddhas? Geshe-la said, like, so people ask the Buddha when are all Buddha if we have to attain enlightenment to lead all sentient beings out of suffering, when is that gonna happen? And the Buddha said, if you’re asking this question, you’ve missed the point. Alright?
The point isn’t when is it going to happen. The point is that it’s possible. Now the point is that all sentient beings have Buddha nature. All sentient beings have the capacity to become Buddhas. If they’re in a situation where they have the access to the path and they have the ability to put it into practice, they become Buddhas.
Alright? However long that takes isn’t the point. The point is that it’s possible. The point is that even ants, even hell beings, all of these beings have the capacity to become a Buddha. So the motivation of bodhicitta is that you wanna work to bring that about.
It’s not how long is it gonna take. Right? It’s that that it is possible. So the fact that it’s possible is what you’re working on, not how long is it gonna take. Is that okay?
So since you can’t say that some people can become Buddhas, some beings can become Buddhas and others can’t, since all beings, all sentient beings have Buddha nature, then it’s not appropriate to say, I’m gonna work for some beings and not others. I’m gonna work for the benefit of some beings and not others because that’s partiality. So this is where this idea of all sentient beings, working for the benefit of all sentient beings comes in. Because it’s not appropriate to say, some I’m gonna work for and others I’m not. If all Buddha if all beings have Buddha nature, then we need to work for all of them.
Alright? So this is that deals with this idea of how am I supposed to help all sentient beings. It’s the motivation because we have to focus on the motivation of helping all sentient beings because it is possible for all sentient beings to become Buddhas. Mhmm. So what we’re trying to develop, what we need to train our minds in is the motivation to attain enlightenment, to be a benefit to all sentient to to attain enlightenment by lead to lead all sentient beings to enlightenment by first becoming Buddhas ourselves.
Put it all the way around. Right? And to lead all sentient beings to enlightenment by first becoming Buddhas ourselves. So this is what we need to focus on. This is what we need to train in.
Because it’s possible, then we need to train in it. Because it’s possible to lead all sentient beings out of suffering. Because the elimination of suffering is possible, then this is really the only appropriate mind that you can approach Buddhahood with. Mhmm. So this means that bodhicitta is characterized by two different aspirations.
It’s characterized by a personal aspiration to attain Buddhahood and a the vastness of aspirations that is to lead all sentient beings to Buddhahood. So there’s it has two different aspirations that make it up, two different sections. Experience of these two aspirations arising in our mind, then that’s the mind of enlightenment. Alright? This aspiration to attain enlightenment for ourselves and to lead all sentient beings to enlightenment.
Now, what unfabricated means is it happens spontaneously. Now at the moment, we meditate a lot and we think about bodhicitta a lot, right, then we get a glimpse of it. It comes up, I wanna attain enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings. That’s what you call fabricated bodhicitta. We’re working and developing it.
We have instances where we can experience it, but it’s not an unfabricated spontaneous bodhicitta. Now, Geshe-la said spontaneous bodhicitta the we’d have the equivalent response to working for towards enlightenment to the benefit of all sentient beings that at the moment we have towards chocolate. Alright? So if we really like chocolate and someone says, here’s some chocolate, we’re like, ah, and we have an instant response to the chocolate. Alright?
So if we have unfabricated bodhicitta, we’d have that response. We go, ah, working for sentient beings. So we have an unfabricated response to chocolate at the moment if we like chocolate. Yeah? So in the same way, we now have an unfabricated response to chocolate.
We need to work towards having an unfabricated sense of working towards enlightenment to lead all sentient beings there. So that’s what bodhicitta is nature is. Now, by way of its characteristics or by way of its entities, there’s said to be two different types of bodhicitta. So that is aspirational and engaging bodhicitta. Now, what aspirational bodhicitta is is this thought, I’m gonna attain enlightenment to lead all sentient beings to enlightenment.
The thought, I’m going to do that. Right? That’s aspiring bodhicitta. Engaging bodhicitta is when you think, in order to lead all sentient beings to enlightenment, I first need to become a Buddha. In order to be a Buddha, I need to meditate, so I’m gonna meditate.
So this is the difference between the two of them. One is the aspiration to attain enlightenment for the benefit of all sentient beings. The second one is the intention to engage engage in activities in order to bring that about. Alright? So they both have a similar motivation, but they have slight difference.
There’s a slight nuance in nuance in the way that they are implemented. Mhmm. So okay. So by way of what’s by way by way of what accompanies them, there is what accompanies bodhicitta, they’re said to be twenty two different twenty two different types of bodhicitta. Now, Geshe-la said you could actually talk about hundreds of different types of bodhicitta by way of what accompanies them.
But in particular, the twenty two are described in the Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life. That means that bodhicitta in certain instances through when it’s accompanied by different level of realization is described in different ways, twenty two different ways. Okay. So by way of Okay. So the next thing says, by way of bhūmis, there is four different distinctions, and Geshe-la
I don’t think these guys have learned about bhūmis yet. Right? He said, that’s why we’ve got to explain it to them because it’ll be good it’ll be good inference on their mind stream. Alright. Borders?
Uh-huh. Bhumis as in grounds. Alright. Now, in there’s this this topic called grounds and paths, alright, which describes the paths and the stages that you go through all the way up to becoming a Buddha. Alright?
And at the edges of each of these grounds and paths is a bhūmi. Alright? So when you talk about the bhūmis, it means the times during process until you become a Buddha where something is relevant. Okay? So, by way of bhūmis, there’s said to be four different types of bodhicitta.
The first is, aspirational bodhicitta or, aspiring bodhicitta. No. Damn it. There’s two words usually translate the same in English and then can’t. The first so maybe we’ll try.
Instead of aspiring, we’ll say hopeful. Okay? There’s some hopeful bodhicitta, and that’s from the time of when you develop when you develop uncontrived bodhicitta, which is also the first of the five paths, the path of accumulation, up until you realize emptiness directly, which is the start of the path of seeing. Alright? So when you work from developing bodhicitta up until you attain a realization, a direct realization of emptiness.
K? So that’s the first type of bodhicitta by way of bhumis. From the path of accumulation up to the beginning of path of seeing. Okay? And it’s called hopeful bodhicitta.
Right? The second type of bodhicitta is called supreme insight or vipaśyanā bodhicitta. And this goes from the first moment of path of seeing where you perceive emptiness directly, right up until the seventh ground of the path of meditation, which is where you get rid of the last of your afflictive obstructions. Alright? So you realize emptiness, you’re getting rid of your afflictive emotions.
Last one’s gone. You hit the eighth ground. Alright? And this is when you move on to purely ripening bodhicitta. Okay?
And that goes from the eighth ground, the ninth ground, the tenth ground up until what’s called the last moments at the end of the continuum of a sentient being. Right? So the last moment you’re a sentient being before you become Buddha. Okay? What’s the function to say?
This is called purely or clearly ripening. Yeah. And then after that, on the fir from the first moment that you’re a Buddha, forever after, then you have what’s called bodhicitta free from the two obscurations. K? So that’s by way of bhumis.
Okay. So just, I guess, in case you guys haven’t come across it before, to quickly say what those paths and grounds are. Right? So it said that from the moment you attain bodhicitta, uncontrived bodhicitta, you progress through five different levels or five different paths until the last of those paths is what’s called the path of no more learning, which is a synonym for Buddha, for being a Buddha. So you don’t have to learn anything anymore because you’re a Buddha.
Right? So the last path is the path of no more learning. The first path is what’s called the path of accumulation, which you are said to have entered into or realized once you have developed I’m gonna — was just sitting here doing this to me. Once you’ve realized uncontrived bodhicitta.
Right? And then you move through to the path of preparation. Then after you’ve directly realized emptiness, you achieve or attain the path of seeing. Right? Then after the path of seeing,, you progress onto the path of meditation.
Alright? Which then flows into the path of no more learning. Okay? Now, what are called the ten grounds of a Bodhisattva start on the path of seeing. Okay?
The path of seeing is synonymous with the first ground of a bodhisattva. Then when you hit the second ground of the bodhisattva up until the tenth ground of a bodhisattva, you’re on the path of meditation. So it’s a description of the path to Buddhahood from the development of bodhisattva to getting rid of the last of of the obscurations. This one. Mhmm.
So the way that these paths and grounds work is like a map, right? A meditational map or a map of realizations. Once you’ve achieved, they show you what’s gonna happen next, where you need to go next, what’s the next thing that you’re getting rid of, what’s the next thing that you’re attaining and so on, all the way from in terms of the Mahāyāna path, all the way from developing uncontrived bodhicitta up until becoming a Buddha. Right? So, yeah, so the first moment you develop bodhicitta, you enter the path of Mahāyāna and that’s what’s called the path of accumulation, accumulating merit.
Right? Accumulating merit and wisdom. Now in that first moment of the path of accumulation, you only have what’s called this aspiring bodhicitta. bodhicitta. But then when you start so the way that you progress through these paths is by attaining realizations and getting rid of things you need to get rid of.
So there’s all these list of things that you get rid of on the path of accumulation before you move on to the path of preparation. And so once you get rid of the first thing that you need to get rid of on the path of accumulation, yeah, that’s when the engaged bodhicitta comes into effect. Okay. So the first thing that you abandon, the first negative state of mind that you abandon on the path of accumulation, when you do that, you start acting on bodhicitta as opposed to just thinking about it. Alright?
And so that’s the first moment that engaged bodhicitta comes into effect. When you get rid of what’s called that which is to be abandoned on the path of accumulation and is word in Tibetan. That which is to be abandoned on the path of seeing. So Geshe-la said that from the path of — on the grounds of a Bodhisattva, which is from when you achieve the path of seeing up until becoming a Buddha, it gives a there’s in different texts, there’s a very, very clear description of exactly what you are getting rid of and exactly what you need to meditate on in order to develop realization. Very, very specific and very, very clear in terms terms of there being a hundred and so on, a hundred or so things that you get rid of in the first stage of the path of seeing.
Alright? And very, very specifically. Now on the path of accumulation, there isn’t as much information about what you’re trying to do with your mind, what negative states you’re trying to get rid of. But there are things that you need to get rid of on the path of accumulation. They’re just not as specifically qualified.
So this means that what what it’s saying here is as soon as you put your bodhicitta into effect, right, as soon as you put that uncontrived bodhicitta into action, it becomes engaged bodhicitta. As soon as you do one thing in order to benefit sentient beings with uncontrived bodhicitta, it becomes engaged bodhicitta. Uh-huh. Okay. So there’s said to be, again, a division.
There’s said to be three different, levels of the path of accumulation. Now, the first of these is, just the development of the stage you go through where you just develop aspirational bodhicitta. Then when you start to put things effect, that’s when you start practicing engaged bodhicitta. Now this happens on what’s called the second level of the path of accumulation, the middling level of the path accumulation. So from the middling level of the path of accumulation, up until you attain enlightenment, it’s said in the sutras to take three countless eons.
Right? Okay. So Okay. So so three countless eons. I was like, what?
Okay. If they count less, why are there three of them? Right? And then so, yeah, I guess they said that each of them each of them were as long as all the numbers you could pile together in order to — so when you ran out of numbers, that was how long an eon was. Right?
And I said, we have computers, Geshe-la. That never happens. It can just keep going forever. And he goes, yeah, but there were no computers at the time of the Buddha. Right?
And in the Buddha’s sutras, he actually goes through a mathematical system where they describe different mathematical system and it’s different units. Right? And that has an end point. You can only calculate up to a certain point if we’re relying on billions and trillions and so on. Right?
You can only calculate up to an endpoint. So it says that one eon is just past the endpoint of that ancient Indian mathematical systems. Alright? Nothing to do with computers. Alright.
So then from the second section of the path of accumulation up until you become a Buddha. So basically, just when you start engaging in the practice of the six Bodhisattva up until you become a Buddha. Alright? It’s said to take three countless ancient Indian countless eons. Okay?
Then those three countless the work that you do in those three countless eons is said to be the development of a hundred and forty four, what are called clear realizations. Okay? Now, these clear realizations or these these Yes. And I tried to tell him that we don’t usually do that in here. Anyway.
Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Anyway, disturbing. So those are hundred and forty four clear realizations are what are described in a text that’s called the clear ornament of realizations.
Right? That’s or the Abhisamayālamkāra. So there’s a hundred and forty four different stages that are all set for were all set forth by Maitreya, that you go through realization, another level of realization, and they’re all described in the in the Clear Ornament of realization. So what someone would need to do in order to be able to practice that three countless eons path and become a Buddha motivated by bodhicitta is to have the motivation of bodhicitta and also understand the process the clear ornament of realizations sets out. Oh.
So there’s a whole page that comes next, which is a debate between a person and who wrote this text. And Geshe will say, we’ll just skip that. They don’t wanna know who said what to whom. We’ll just get on to the important bits. Oh, yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- buddha nature sugatagarbha, tathagatagarbha (Skt); desheg nyingpo, dezhin shegpe nyingpo (Tib)
- The clear light nature of mind possessed by all sentient beings; the potential for all sentient beings to become enlightened by removing the two obscurations: to liberation and omniscience. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- individual liberation
- The liberation from cyclic existence achieved by a hearer (shravaka) or solitary realizer (pratyekabuddha), as compared with the full enlightenment of a buddha sought in the Mahayana. LYWA
- path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
- The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- two obscurations dvi-avarana (Skt); drib pa nyi (Tib)
- Deluded mental states that block the attainment of liberation and enlightenment. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.