Bodhisattva Way of Life 2005 Feb-Mar — 2005-02-15

45 min · 4,540 words · 15 February 2005 · Buddha House Adelaide

Bodhisattva Way of Life 2005 Feb-Mar (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Bodhisattva Way of Life 2005 Feb-Mar (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Bodhisattva Way of Life 2005 Feb-Mar — 2005-02-15
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The butter lamp in the wind — Nāgārjuna’s image for practice without proper motivation — opens Geshe Pema Tsering’s 46-minute commentary from the 2005 Bodhisattva Way of Life series. He uses it to diagnose why Dharma practice stays inconsistent: self-cherishing keeps death abstract even for those actively dying, and without genuine death-awareness the motivation to practice never holds. He traces this through saṃsāra’s illusory happiness, the urgency of using a human rebirth well, and the three pillars of the path — renunciation, bodhicitta, and wisdom perceiving emptiness — before moving into close textual commentary on the opening lines of Śāntideva’s text. The term Sugata is unpacked, and three levels of abandonment attributed to Buddhas are distinguished, showing why their realization exceeds that of stream enterers, once returners, and Arhats. For practitioners already comfortable with Lamrim themes.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 07 WBS 2005 02 15.mp3

UUID: 8c33d14d-fc59-4bbf-be21-f20a64dd755c

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Bodhisattva Way of Life 2005 Feb-Mar (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2005-02-15

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 45.7 minutes

Words: ~4,543

So, in the Yuganaddha, the pandita Nāgārjuna said, without causes, something coming into being without causes and conditions is like trying to light a butter lamp in the wind, all right? So, that is to say, in order for something to come into being, it needs to have a cause for it to come into being and it needs to have the right conditions for it to come about. So, what this means is that in order for example for a lamp to be lit, it’s not enough just to have the idea of lighting the lamp, you need to have brought all of the things together that will enable the lamp to burn. Even though some of the causes may be there in terms of having the wick that you’re trying to light it, you need the complete set of causes and conditions in order for the to be lit or the butter lamp to be lit. You need to have not only a match but also calmness, so without all the right causes and conditions something doesn’t come into being.

So all compounded phenomena come into being based on causes and conditions, and so this is actually the same as the practice of the Dharma. Dharma comes into being based on motivation, based on the intention or the reason for which we do something. If we do something with the motivation to attain enlightenment, to attain liberation or to attain a positive rebirth, then what we do becomes dharma. Without this cause, it’s like trying to light a butter without this motivation, without this cause, it’s like trying to light a butter lamp in the wind. So, if we watch the way that we do things, if we watch our motivation for practicing Dharma, then we’ll actually see that this is actually very true, that it’s very difficult for us to practice Dharma.

Our practice of Dharma is a bit like trying to light a butter lamp in wind. Now, the reason for this is that most of our in order for us to practice Dharma we need to have one of these motivations. We need be motivated by either attaining a good rebirth, by attaining liberation, or by attaining Buddhahood, and if we are not motivated by this, if our thoughts are blown hither and thither by self-cherishing, by the things that we want to happen in the short term, then we’re not practicing Dharma. So, if we watch for the reason we do things, it’s mostly about what’s going to happen to us in the short term. We don’t remember death enough to be able to focus on even our future lives, let alone to focus on achieving liberation or Buddhahood, and because we convince ourselves that even though we’re gonna die, and so we may think, okay, it’s pretty obvious I’m gonna die, it’s not gonna happen soon.

So even if we do remember death, it is some far away thing that may happen to us at some stage in the future, and we don’t remember it as something that could happen to us soon and therefore as an inspiration to practice Dharma. Now, this reason that we don’t think about death is because of self-cherishing, because of holding on to this idea of who we are very tightly at all times. This becomes the main focus for everything we do. And if we watch the way we think, then all our thoughts are tainted by this idea of self, of holding on to self. And even if we were going to die in the next moment, if we came to the point of death, instead of thinking about death itself, we’d be thinking, I’ve still got a few moments more to live.

We’d still be holding on to those few moments left of life, we still wouldn’t be focusing on death. So, reason that we think like this is because we cherish ourselves, we hold on ourselves so tightly, and even if we’re thinking about death, we’re not really thinking about death, we’re thinking about the possibility of death or thinking about the death may come in the future, we’re not really thinking about death itself, right? Because and the reason we don’t think about this is because it’s very difficult for us to get there in our head because it means letting go of ourselves, of what we conceive to be ourselves. And this is true, you watch people when they’re dying and they’re like, can I have some more medicine? You know, may be dying in a few moments, but they’re still thinking of me, me, I need medicine, can you give me a needle, can you give me some pills, can you find some way to make me live for an hour longer?

So, the death is inevitable, and they’re facing death in the face, but instead of accepting death, many people will still be asking for something to prolong their life just a little bit, or to make themselves feel just a little bit better. So they may not know how to give themselves the needles, give themselves medicine, and they may be so out of it that they wouldn’t be able to even if they did know what they should take, but there is still this idea of there is still a very strong idea of me that these people experience, and they are still trying to find some way to make themselves feel better even at this stage. So, guess I said there’s a lot of people here, but if you went up to everybody in the room and said individually, Are you sure you’re not going to die tomorrow? Most people would say, Of course I’m not going to die tomorrow. Everybody here would say the same thing: There’s no chance of me dying tomorrow, of course not.

We can’t actually be certain about this, but this is the premise that we work from. So we don’t think about death in this way. We don’t think about the fact that it could actually happen tomorrow, and if someone said to us, are you going to die tomorrow? An instant response would be, of course not. But if they said to us, can you sign on the line saying that you’re not going to die, can you give me your signature that says there is nothing that’s going to happen to you in the next twenty four hours that could cause your death, then for us to actually be able to give that kind of one hundred percent guarantee is very difficult, especially when we consider the number of ways that we could die.

Even the things that we take to nourish our body to keep us alive like food and drink can be a cause for death, and we can take things in our food that we don’t know about that can actually be a cause for us to die, and that’s just one way we can die. We can die from internal diseases, we can die from external being hit and things like that. We can die from having having our air blocked, to having our airways blocked. There’s many, many different ways to die, and when we think about it, our bodies are quite fragile. Our bodies aren’t as stable as we think they are because any number of different things can cause them to expire.

So in this way, our bodies as well as our Dharma practice are like a butter lamp in the wind, because we don’t know at which moment they are going to get blown out, and we don’t know at which moment the causes and conditions for their existence are going to cease to exist, and therefore our body is going to expire, this life is going to expire. So there are many causes and there is no certainty about the time that when we are going to die. So if we think about death in this way over and over and over again, then we’ll become familiar with the idea. We’ll become familiar with the idea of impermanence, and we cling less to our body to this lifetime because we realize the inevitability of death. And by focusing on death in this way, by actually focusing on the fact that we could die at any moment, then that leads us to the practice of Dharma.

First of all, it leads to fear. There’s a fear of this natural fear of death, but then, if we think about what’s going to benefit us at death, then the only thing that really benefits us at death is dharma. And the other thing is, if we keep remembering death, then we’ll realize that the only thing that really benefits us is the Dharma because we can’t take any of the other things we work on with us into future lives. So the reason that we don’t think about death, and not thinking about death means that we don’t practice Dharma as insistently or as undistracted as we could is because we are attached to this lifetime, because we are focused on how we can make ourselves happy in this lifetime, and being attached to the ways we think that we can make ourselves happy in this lifetime, we have convinced ourselves that we’re not going to die anytime soon. So, we work on this premise that we’re not going to die soon and therefore we should focus on making ourselves happy in the short term.

Now, this distraction, concentration on trying to make ourselves happy in the short term stops us from practicing Dharma, stops us from actually working towards what will truly make us happy, and if we remember death, then we can come to a close understanding of what will truly make us happy. But forgetting death, once we forget death, then we don’t remember dharma. We get distracted by our habits and start focusing on what can make us happy in the short term. So the reason that we get that we’re too afraid to talk about death, no, we’re too afraid to think about death, and instead spend our time concentrated on the distractions of this lifetime and are really attached to the things that we think make us happy in this lifetime, is because we don’t understand true happiness. By not understanding true happiness, we settle or we cling to what we think is happiness, but is actually another form of suffering, the so called happiness of Samsāra.

Need to think about this, we need to look at this. If the happiness that we think is happiness in Samsāra was true happiness, it would be permanent, it would be unchanging and it would be completely satisfying. Now, our experience at the moment in Samsāra isn’t like this. Our experience of happiness isn’t lasting, isn’t completely satisfying, isn’t the complete extinguishing of suffering. If we want to achieve this, if we want to achieve true happiness, then we need to look to those who have already done it.

So those who have already achieved true happiness, those who have completely extinguished suffering, the Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas and the Arhats or the foe destroyers, through their practices, their meditation, a lot of effort, they have come to the state where they have completely destroyed their negative states and experience only true happiness. Now, if we want to be like them, thankfully that they have explained the path to becoming, to reaching this state, to becoming like them in many different texts, many different teachings, in many different ways. And we have access to this, we have access to this explanation, we have access to this path. So, what we need to do if we want to understand true happiness is to look at these things, study them, to develop and work towards developing an understanding of them. And once we’ve developed an understanding of them, if we put them into practice, then that will lead us to true state of happiness and unchanging, uncontaminated happiness.

It is possible for us to reach that state if we follow in the path that they have shown us, if we follow the path that they have shown us. So all of us want to experience happiness and none of us want to experience suffering. If we truly want to experience happiness and we truly want to be rid of suffering, we need to practice Dharma. And the reason that this verse from Nāgārjuna’s text talks about the instability of causes and conditions is because our life is like a lamp in the wind. When it’s going to finish we don’t know.

So if we want to be happy we need practice Dharma, and we need to practice Dharma quickly. We need to concentrate on it quickly because we don’t know when we’re going to die. And because we don’t know when we’re going to die, then any of the other pursuits that we may think can cause us happiness, can’t be sure about. We don’t know how long they’re going to benefit us, but we know that Dharma is going to benefit us, so we need to practice it quickly. We need to practice it quickly because we’re not certain of when we’re going to die.

We can die when we’re young, we can die when we’re old, we can die when we’re middle aged. Some people even some beings even die as soon as they’re born. There’s there’s absolutely no certainty at the time of death. And as there’s no certainty at the time of death, we need to do what we can while we can as soon as we can. Because the other thing to take into consideration is that at this stage we have a human rebirth, and with a human rebirth comes intelligence and discrimination.

Based on this intelligence and discrimination, we have the ability to do many things. We have the ability to practice Dharma, we have the ability to work towards attaining a good rebirth in the future, to work towards liberation, to work towards enlightenment. So we have the ability to work towards all of these things. We also have the ability to waste this opportunity that we have, frivolously chasing after happiness that’s not going to last very long and isn’t going to benefit us, especially at the time of death.

With a human rebirth, we have the ability to do any of these things, so it’s up to us what we do with it. So We need to use this ability that we have, though, instead of wasting it. If we use this ability that we have, then we have all of the resources to set ourselves up for either our next life or to attain Buddhahood or to attain liberation. We have the ability to do this, but we need to be focusing on that in order to bring it about. For us to have attained this state that we’re in now, for us to attain the human rebirth, we must have done something in the past to bring this about.

In the same way, what we do now will affect what happens to us in the future and future lifetimes. It’s not as if we can say, I’m not gonna focus on future lives and therefore they’ll disappear. Consciousness is a continuum and whether we focus on our future lives or not, we will experience future lives. So, it makes more sense to focus on something that is going to affect us longer than just this lifetime. At the most, we can spend a hundred years in this lifetime.

The life that we are born into now doesn’t usually last the type of life we’re born into now doesn’t usually last more than a hundred years, and if it does, it’s not much longer than a hundred years, and that isn’t very long when we consider it compared to the many, many lifetimes that we’ve lived. So, we can either waste the opportunity that we have now on the short amount of time that we have left or we can use it in order to attain either true happiness and Buddhahood in the future or even just a positive rebirth. So we can go through all this now. We can think about it, and then go, okay, that makes sense, this makes sense, that makes sense, but it’s not the way that we tend to think. We tend to naturally have this idea of, yeah, yeah, I might have a future life, but I don’t know what it’s gonna look like, and I certainly don’t remember my past life, so the only things that I know is what’s happening to me now, so that’s what I’m going focus on and that’s the only thing I’m interested in.

So in this way we’re kind of a bit No. No. No. It’s not short. No.

No. The word he used was more like, out ourselves. Oh, yeah. We’re a bit like, I’m cool. Yeah.

That is what of the yeah. Walking down the street thinking you’re great sort of that word. Because we think, you know, I know more about what’s going on than anybody else, and then it’s like a what I do is the most important thing. Me being happy is more important than anyone else’s happiness. What’s happening to me now is more important than what’s happening to me at any other it’s gonna happen to me at any other time.

So I’m gonna do what I can to make myself feel good at the moment. Alright? And I’m gonna make I’m gonna work hard to get myself a great house and have enough money and to look good and to have the right food and to have the right situation. In this way we’re really way too sure of ourselves, incredibly arrogant about our understanding and us knowing what’s the best for us. Through this arrogance, through this conceit, then we kid ourselves into thinking that we can change things.

We kid ourselves into thinking that we have the ability to make our life okay. We kid ourselves into thinking that if we work hard enough, then we can bring all the situations, all the causes and conditions together to make this life okay and to stop ourselves experiencing suffering, but it’s not the way it works. Every experience that we have, every dollar that we make, every business deal that we get that goes right is actually the result of countless causes and conditions coming together. So, if we don’t have the merit or we don’t have the collection of positive karma for that situation to come, no matter how hard we work is not going to happen, no matter how much effort we put into making money or to making ourselves successful in one way or another, if we don’t have the causes and conditions from previous lives, from previous positive actions, it is not gonna happen. And we can’t why we’re really arrogant, why we’re really conceited, why think we’re so good is because we think that we’re in charge of our world.

We think that we’re in charge of our lifetime, and it’s not true. We’re only in charge of our lifetime in that we create the causes for our lifetime. We’re not in charge of our lifetime in that we can override the causes and conditions we’ve already made. So if we wanna have good experiences in the future, it’s not so much working to try and we shouldn’t be so much focusing on using our situation at the moment to try and make ourselves happy now. We should be trying to create as much positive karma as we can, doing as much positive things as we can in order to be happy in the future.

So, the most obvious way that we can create positive karma, most obvious way that we can help ourselves is to work towards Buddhahood and liberation. The way that we work towards Buddhahood and liberation comes down to the formula of listening, contemplation and meditation. Means that we first of all, through listening and studying the Dharma, we develop an understanding of that, and then we contemplate on this until we develop certainty of it, and then we meditate in accordance with that certainty until we have thoroughly transformed ourselves based on that certainty. So, through this process, then we are working towards Buddhahood and enlightenment and, obviously, creating positive karma. So, the endpoint, what we’re trying to get to from all of this, why we will be trying to create positive karma, final outcome or the final goal as Buddhists is to become a Buddha.

Now, in order to become a Buddha, of course we need to create positive karma, but the main goal towards becoming a Buddha, the main goal towards which we are working at the moment is the development of the mind of enlightenment, the determination to achieve enlightenment in order to lead all sentient beings to that state. So in order for us to become Buddhas, we need this mind of enlightenment, this bodhicitta. So this is what we need to be focusing on now. We need to be working and doing what we can in order to develop this state in order to focus on leading all sentient beings, having the ability to lead all sentient beings to enlightenment by ourselves becoming Buddhas. Okay, so the main three points of the path that we need to focus on is renunciation, turning away from saṃsāra, from getting caught up in the things of this lifetime.

And the next part is bodhicitta and the final part is developing wisdom perceiving emptiness. Now, there’s many things we can say about those, but the main focus in terms of what we should have for our motivation for doing anything and the main one that we need to focus on from those three even is bodhicitta. So this means please develop, please focus strongly on developing an unwavering motivation and motivation that can’t be flickered out, like the flame in the wind. By listening to the teachings, attain enlightenment to benefit all sentient beings and focus on that idea for a few minutes. Meditate on that idea for a few minutes.

I just was like, and I just let you know, half the time’s gone. And he goes, oh, really? And then he said, oh, that’s okay. We won’t do that much then. Oh, yeah.

I’m talking about the actual. Okay, we’re still up to the first well, what is the first word in Sanskrit and Tibetan, but at least it’s five words in English. To those who go in bliss, alright? Or Sugata in Sanskrit. Now, what the bliss refers to here is goodness.

Bliss is not just being blissed out, it means having goodness. To those who go means that they have turned into this goodness or have it literally says they have traveled to the essence of this goodness but it means to have transformed into this goodness. So it means, as well as saying to those who go to bliss, it can also be translated as to those who abide in goodness. This is a we’re talking about the section in the first two lines of the Bodhicaryāvatāra, where it describes who he’s bowing down to. We’re dealing with the first thing, which is those who go in bliss.

This is a synonym for Buddha, for the Buddhas. As Buddhas they have completely gone to a state of goodness or bliss or happiness. Now, the reason that they have attained this state is what we were talking about last week which is that they have abandoned what needs to be abandoned and taken on what needs to be taken on. Now, in terms of that which is to be abandoned, there’s said to be three different ways that they have abandoned things. So, they have abandoned all afflictive emotions, they have abandoned things well, and they have abandoned things without exception.

Alright. Now, what this refers to is when they abandon all afflictive emotions, it’s the same as saying that they achieve nirvana, achieve liberation. To say that they abandon things well refers to the state of Bodhisattvas on the last part of the path to becoming Buddhas and when they say they have abandoned things without exception it refers to the fact that they have abandoned or they have gotten rid of all obscurations to Buddhahood. This means that they have fully attained Buddhahood. So this abandoning of the Buddhas, this getting rid of all things that can obstruct their understanding and act as a cause for suffering, is said to be superior to many other beings.

This is why they are a thing towards which Śāntideva is paying homage. They are said to be superior to those who have attained Samādhi or meditative states because beings who have attained Samādhi may be able to suppress their negative emotions. Is in meditate having developed meditative concentration they may be able to abide in meditative states for very long periods of time without negative states or negative emotions, afflictive states arising but they haven’t abandoned them because the possibility or the potential for those states to re arise is still in their continuum. The Buddha’s realization is said to be superior to their realization because the Buddhas have not only just suppressed their negative states through developing meditative concentration, but they’ve completely abandoned those states. So, from amongst the people who practice the Hīnayāna Paths, are different types of being.

Those who have achieved the realization of selflessness according to the teachings of the Hīnayāna, vehicle, they are what are called stream enterers and then the next state up after being a stream enterer is to become a once returner. So the abandonment of the Buddha that is called good, that means the state that they achieve when they have passed liberation while they’re working towards Buddhahood is said to be better than the stream enterers and the once returners because they have completely gotten rid of the afflictive emotions. Now, those who have attained the state of a stream enterer or the state of a once returner have gotten rid of manifest afflictive emotions because they’re having realized the emptiness of self, emptiness or selflessness, they don’t experience manifest negative emotions, but the potential to experience manifest negative emotions is still in their continuum. Because Buddhas don’t have this potential, their abandonment is said to be better than those of Arhats and sorry, not the Arhats, the stream enterers and once returners? The third abandonment of the Buddha, the complete abandonment, is said to make their realization and their understanding superior to those of Arhats because although Arhats have this abandonment of negative emotions and the abandonment of the good abandonment in that they have achieved liberation.

They haven’t gotten rid of the obscurations to knowledge. In this way, because Buddhas not only achieved liberation for themselves, but attain Buddhahood in order to benefit all sentient beings.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
compounded phenomena samskrta (Skt); du jä kyi chö (Tib)
Phenomena that arise due to causes and conditions. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
pandita khäpa (Tib)
Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
sugata Tib: de war sheg pa; Wyl: bde bar gshegs pa
An epithet for a buddha, literally “excellent (su) gone one (gata).” LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top