Bodhisattva Way of Life — 2008-07-28

1 h 45 min · 8,255 words · 28 July 2008 · Buddha House Adelaide

Bodhisattva Way of Life (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Bodhisattva Way of Life (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Bodhisattva Way of Life — 2008-07-28
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Geshe Pema Tsering opens this 106-minute commentary with a stark challenge: a human life spent only pursuing food, comfort, and pain avoidance is no better than a dog’s life — the genuine purpose of human existence is liberation and enlightenment, not survival. After establishing bodhicitta as the essential motivation and reciting the Heart Sūtra, the session resumes a detailed analysis of innate versus acquired conceptions of self, distinguishing the Prāsaṇgika school’s account of subtle selflessness from the lower schools’ coarser versions, and examining why partless particles and indivisible moments of consciousness are merely fabricated concepts. A pizza-on-TV analogy then illustrates how realized beings perceive phenomena without grasping at inherent existence. Audience questions address dreams and illusions as analogies for emptiness, and whether the total number of sentient beings can ever increase.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 01 2008 07 28 BW.mp3

UUID: 96dcc1fb-3305-43f2-8a3a-c04f8d07830c

Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering

Collection: Bodhisattva Way of Life (Geshe Pema Tsering)

Date: 2008-07-28

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 105.6 minutes

Words: ~8,251

So, again, Geshe-la is instructing just to give rise to a good motivation. If we give rise to a good motivation, then our spiritual practice will turn out well. It will be a good spiritual practice. And if we don’t have a good motivation, then our spiritual practice, our spiritual actions will not be good spiritual actions. So the qualities of our actions, again, they depend they depend on the qualities of the motivations that precede them.

So, again, in in of all the motivations, the best one is the motivation of the mind of enlightenment. So, again, we give rise to this intention, this wish that may all beings then again be endowed with every happiness and be free from every suffering. In order to accomplish that, I myself must accomplish that state, which is endowed of every happiness and free of every suffering, the state of Buddhahood itself. Again, this is the best motivation there is. Again, if without producing it, we don’t get the best results.

English, Geshe-la was saying we shouldn’t give in to such thoughts that think, again, I’m not gonna be able to attain this state of enlightenment. Again, there’s a lot of, there’s a lot of obscurations that need to be removed, need to be eradicated. There’s a lot of a lot of, qualities that need to be developed. A lot of good qualities that need to be developed. There’s a lot of work to be done.

There’s a lot of meditation that has to be done, so I’m I’m not gonna be able to do that. So, again, we shouldn’t give in to such to this kind of thinking. Again, all we have to do is to give up concerns for the things of this life. If we as I was saying previously, again, if we don’t give give up concern for this life, then, again, we don’t get a proper spiritual practice. So, again, while we need to we shouldn’t give up we shouldn’t give in to this type of thinking.

We should come to we should develop the understanding that, okay, we all have because Geshe-la was saying in the first person again. I have Buddha nature. You know, I can attain enlightenment if I do the work. If I if I do the work that is necessary, then I can attain enlightenment. So, enlightenment is possible, is attainable.

So, again, with this in mind and again, what what I need to do is to study and contemplate and meditate on these teachings on emptiness and and and in this way develop, cultivate the causal And, again, Geshe-la was saying if we if we can develop such thoughts, if we can develop these these these intentions in our in our hearts, then again, even though attaining enlightenment in this life is very difficult, it’s very difficult to accomplish that in this life. Yet we have by thinking this way, by acting this way, that Geshe has instructed us, and again, we we will be accomplishing the cause of enlightenment, of future enlightenment. And by by acting in this manner, we have made this one human life profound meaningful, greatly meaningful by acting in this way. Okay? So again, Geshe is then saying, so we need we need then to we have we have a lot of work to do.

We have we need to get rid of a lot of afflictions because right now, that’s most most of what we have in our in our minds, in our hearts are these afflictions. And so what we need to do is to cultivate those collections of merit. We need to cultivate a a a merit that which are those things which harm the afflictions, which weaken the afflictions, which help us get rid of the afflictions. So, again, we we need to cultivate those those antidotes to the afflictions, afflictions, and we need to do that progressively. Again, we need to this cultivation of these things, of these merits that, again, that oppose the afflictions that stop us from being able to accomplish the causes of enlightenment, which are very many.

Again, so we need to do this cultivation of these virtues very slowly, very gradually. There is no such thing as as accomplishing one huge virtue that will get the job done from one day to the next. That doesn’t happen. This this is a it’s a it’s a gradual process in which we cultivate all the causes. We gradually cultivate all the causes necessary to attain enlightenment, to develop enlightenment itself.

So so we need right now to the best of our knowledge, to the best of our ability, we engage in such deeds, in such actions, such activities. And the more we engage in them, the the stronger they get, the better they get, the clearer they get, and and and progressively we we get there. So, again, and if we if we can in this way then accomplish the cause of enlightenment, if we can accomplish causes of enlightenment in this life, then, again, we have we have made this life, this this human meaningful. We have made it very meaningful. On the other hand, if we spend the rest of our days just busy with the things of this life, pursuing only the things of this life, then our our this human birth will be no better than the birth.

This human body will be no better than the body of a dog, the birth of a dog. Again, because dogs also can live their lives pursuing entirely and only the things of this life, food, shelter, comfort, and avoiding discomfort and pain and so forth. That’s what dogs do. If that’s all that we are doing in this life, then this we we won’t be accomplishing the main thing that a human life can accomplish, which is liberation and enlightenment. And this human life will be no better than the life of a dog.

Alright? So, again, if and if we can instead accomplish these virtues again, that have our intent in future lives in enlightenment and liberation, then again then our lives will not be wasted, not be in vain, will not be just like the life of a dog, meaningless as the life of a dog, You know, by accomplishing the causes of enlightenment in this life, by accomplishing let put it this way. By accomplishing causes of enlightenment in this life, then in the future, what we will get is enlightenment. So one day in the future, we’ll get enlightened. And then and the greatest virtue of all, the one that is no no greater there’s no greater virtue than bodhicitta than the mind of enlightenment.

So bearing that in mind, and we produce this motivation of the mind of enlightenment. So, again, I must for the sake of all being for the sake of all being, the the the perfect welfare of all beings, I must attain enlightenment myself. And in order to attain enlightenment, I’m going to study these teachings, and I’m going to practice according to these teachings tonight. So, again, in this manner, then we produce this motivation, produce this this thought in our heart. And with that, we start with the preliminary prayers.

Alright? Thus did I hear one time, the Bhagavan was dwelling on massive Vulture’s Peak in Rajagriha together with a great community of monks and a great community of bodhisattvas. At that time, the Bhagavan was absorbed in the concentration on the categories of phenomena called profound perception. Also at that time, the Bodhisattva mahasattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara looked upon the very practice of the profound perfection of wisdom and beheld the five aggregates as empty of inherent nature. Then through the power of Buddha, the venerable Śāriputra said this to the bodhisattva, mahasattva, Ārya Avalokiteśvara.

How should any son of the lineage train who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom? He said that in the Bodhisattva mahasattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara said this to the venerable Śāriputra. Śāriputra, any son of the lineage or daughter of the lineage who wishes to practice the activity of the profound perfection of wisdom, should look upon it like this, correctly and repeatedly, beholding the five aggregates as empty of inherent nature. Form is empty. Emptiness is form.

Emptiness is no other than form. Form is also no other than emptiness. In the same way, feeling, discrimination, compositional factors, and consciousness are empty. Likewise, all are empties without characteristic, unproduced, unceased, stainless, nor without stain, nor deficient, nor fulfilled. Therefore, in emptiness, there is no form, no feeling, no discrimination, no compositional factors, no consciousness, no eye, no ear, no nose, no tongue, no body, no mind, no visual form, no sound, no odor, no taste, no object of touch, and no phenomenon.

There is no eye element and so on up to including no mind element and no mental consciousness element. There is no ignorance, no extinction of ignorance, and so on up to one including no aging and death and no extinction of aging and death. Similarly, there is no suffering, origination, cessation, and path. There is no exalted wisdom, no attainment, and also no attainment. Śāriputra, therefore, because there is no attainment, Bodhisattvas rely on and dwell in the perfection of wisdom.

The mind without obscuration and without fear, having completely passed beyond error, they reached the endpoint of nirvana. All the Buddhas who dwell in the three times also manifestly completely awakened to unsurpassable, perfect, complete enlightenment in reliance on the perfection of wisdom. Therefore, the mantra of the perfection of wisdom, the mantra of great knowledge, the unsurpassed mantra, the mantra equal to the unequal, the mantra that thoroughly pacifies all suffering should be known as truth, and it is not false. The mantra of the perfection of wisdom is declared. Bodhisattva mahasattva should train in the profound perfection of wisdom like that.

Then the Bhagavan rose from that concentration and commended the bodhisattva mahasattva Ārya Avalokiteśvara saying, well said, well said son of the lineage. It is like that. It is like that. One should practice the profound perfection of wisdom just as you have indicated. Even the Tathagatas rejoice.

The Bhagavan have even thus spoken the venerable Śāriputra, the bodhisattva, mahasattva, Avalokiteśvara. Those surrounding their entirety along with the world of gods, humans, asuras, and Gandharvas were overjoyed and highly praised as spoken by the Bhagavan. Then we move on to the of hindrances. I and all surrounding sentient beings go for refuge to the Buddha, go for refuge to the Dharma, for refuge to the Sangha. We prostrate to the Prajñāpāramitā, surrounded by all the children, by the assemblies of of Buddhas and Bodhisattvas of the ten directions.

By depending on my prostrations to all of you, may these words of truth be actualized. In the past, the deva king Indra dispelled the maras by reflecting on the profound meaning of the wisdom gone beyond and reciting the profound words in daily recitation. In that same way, also reflect on the profound meaning of the great Prajñāpāramitā and recite the profound words in daily recitation. May all diseases, spirit possessions, bad conditions, all the negative conditions, that which happens due to past karma and immediate conditions. May all these be dispelled, may become non existent, may be pacified.

So so today, we we have to pick up where we left last Tuesday. And so last Tuesday, we were talking about these two conceptions of of an inherent existence of apprehension of a self. And we have this this innate or also called co emergent, but usually translated as innate conception of a self. Inn innate. Before that, you said usually translated as Also, translate as innate or co emergent also.

Co emergent. Co emergent. Co means with? Yes. Yes.

What? Innate. Let’s let’s stick with innate. That’s a better translation. And then so Geshe-la was explaining, this innate conception of our self is that is that notion that we have is that sort of a a feeling notion that we have of the I, which arise which has with which we have been involved, involved, which has been with with which we have been we have been habituated since time immemorial.

We have been living with with that conception, the false conception since time immemorial, and it arises within our mind streams without us having to make any effort, without us having to make any deliberation, without us having to think about it at all. It’s it arises naturally, okay, Quote, unquote, naturally without any effort. And we don’t we don’t really have to think about it at all. It’s it’s that’s why it is called the innate conception of a self, the innate apprehension of a self. And then we have the other type of conception of our self, which is the acquired, the artificial conception of our self.

It’s a it’s a conception of our self that arises after we have thought about it, after we have reasoned about it, after we have elaborated about it. So we elaborate. We create it artificially through our own thoughts. That’s the one thing that was translated as the imputed self. And imputed here is that word that is has many translations to it.

It can be translated as artificial, fabricated, fabricated, mentally constructed, intellectually constructed. It’s something that we have fabricated. It’s a false conception. It doesn’t exist. That self doesn’t exist.

It’s a it’s a it’s a mere mental fabrication. Alright. And then so so we proceed exactly from where we stopped last Tuesday. I apologize for for anybody who is is getting it in the middle. It might be a bit difficult.

But so the next sentence of the commentary that Geshe-la is approaching right now is saying is talking about that the the existence of of of that of an innate conception of a self, of an innate apprehension of a self, which is that the independent sorry. The the the self sufficient, substantial is is the conception of a of a substantially no. Sorry. Self sufficient, substantially existent self, which that’s all there’s there is also an innate conception of a self. Okay?

And which explained the all the schools below the Madhyamaka Prāsaṇgika school of thought posit this conception of an self sufficient, substantial existent self as being the So, again, the is is elaborating. So again, the this that there is an innate conception. According to the lower schools of thought, there’s an innate conception of a self sufficient, substantial existence self. The lack, the nonexistence, the lack of such a self sufficient, substantial existence self is what these lower schools of thought refer to as the subtle selflessness of the person.

And then and then now the Madhyamaka Prāsaṇgika school posits this type of apprehension of a self, the apprehension apprehension of self sufficient, self sufficient self as a coarse apprehension of of of a self. And the lack of such a self sufficient, self sufficient self is a a coarse selflessness of a person, a coarse selflessness. And then the subtle what the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika posits as the subtle selflessness is the lack of a fully characterized phenomenon, the lack of a truly existent phenomenon, the lack of of a phenomenon existing or having any existence from its own side, the lack of inherent existence, the emptiness of inherent existence. That’s what the Madhyamaka Prāsaṇgika posit as subtle selflessness. So so what the text is saying is that amongst the apprehensions of a self of persons, we have this one type of apprehension of a self of person.

Is the that is, again, which is being referred to as a an innate apprehension of our self, conception of our self. And Geshe-la was saying is is the conception of a self. When we think of the I, right, when I think of I or me, I think of me. I think of I, and I and I I conceive of that. I am innately, naturally conceiving of that I.

I’m assuming that that I exist substantially and exist as an independent entity, a self sufficient entity, an entity that governs its own actions, that governs its own destiny, so to speak, an entity that does not depend on anything else in order to exist, in order to come into existence, in order to exist. That’s what is being referred to as a substantial existence, a self sufficient entity, a self sufficient self. Okay? So we think we have this conception also. We also think of the self.

A self that exists in this manner. So this conception also, we have an innate we have such a conception which is an an innate conception and such a conception which is an an acquired acquired conception, a fabricated conception, artificial conception. So this conception also comes about sort of naturally by the force of a long lasting habit. Again, without us having to think about it. We we this idea, this notion this notion of feeling naturally that arises in us of an independent substantially existent self sufficient substantially existent self.

And, also, having reasoned about it or or having engaged in reasoning and investigation and analysis, we also create we fabricate this notion of a a self sufficient substantially existent self. So we have these two versions also. We have of the self, an innate version and a fabricated fabricated and an acquired version of such a self. Conception of our self, which Geshe-la was saying, it it can be both innate and acquired and fabricated. And then we have also on top of that, on top of of such a concept of self, we have the the the notion also of a person, a self, which is the lord, the master, and and which commands the aggregates or the five aggregates as its servants, as its slaves.

And we we again, we apprehend such a self. We also conceive such a self, and it’s important understand we are told that this apprehend apprehension of such a self is only fabricated. We have to know that one to be only a fabrication or an acquired conception. So Geshe-la was gonna say, it is something that comes about only after we have thought about it. We have reasoned about it, and we come to this false conclusion that there is a person, there is a self that is the master of the aggregate that governs the aggregates.

And Geshe-la said, this is only fabricated. Alright? And, Geshe-la was gonna say now, as for this this later conception, okay, this later conception of a self which is the ruler of the aggregates, which governs the aggregates, again, there is a lot of debate about it being only acquired and not an innate conception. So the because I was saying there are there are many scholars who say that it is also an innate conception. But here, in this instance, this scholar here, this author here, this commentator is saying that it is not an innate conception.

It’s only an artificial and acquired conception. And then and then further on, the next sentence the next sentence is then telling us that in this in in the same way, likewise partless particles, partless atoms in indivisible particles of matter and part less units of of consciousness. So the apprehension of such things also, which is is conceived as as the as the self of phenomena, the apprehension of a self of phenomena from the lower schools of thought, that also is only only an acquired conception. Okay. So, again, so these these partless particles, they are the smallest units of matter that exists.

They are they are they are so small that you can they cannot be divided anymore. In the past, they used to be translated as atoms. But then, you know, with quantum physics, we figure out that atoms also have parts. So you think of the smallest particle of matter there is, and that cannot be for which we haven’t found anything smaller. And that is what is referred to as partless particles, the the the tiny little units of matter.

When you mentioned unit of consciousness, was another way of saying the same thing? No. No. That’s that’s that’s another thing. That’s the next one.

So then Geshe-la is explaining. So this this part partless particles, again, they are an acquired conception. Okay? They are fabricated, artificially fabricated, mentally fabricated, and they are posited by the lower schools of thought, the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika. They they posit such partless particles.

And now the the Prāsaṇgika and the higher schools of thought, they they do not accept such such partless particles, such things, such partless things. They say if it is an object of knowledge, if it is an existent phenomena, so if it is something that exists, is it necessarily has parts. Alright? Was asking, so now you have to think about it. Think about such such things.

Is there such a thing as a partless particle? So, again, they say that there is. And then if but if you think carefully about it and with all the necessary tools of knowledge that the Buddhists have, then you you you see that there is no such a thing that does not have parts. The smallest tiniest particle has a left side and a right side and inside and an outside, an upper side, a lower side. It has a part of it that is impermanent, another part of it which is which is not a part of it that exists, a part of it that doesn’t exist.

You can think it in so there’s so many reasonings that establish the fact that it is it has parts. We have in in the so many ways to establish that. If something exists, it has parts. If it is an object of knowledge, it has parts. It wouldn’t be a particle if it didn’t have parts, would it?

I I’m I I cannot get into the etymology of the of the English word. The Tibetan word is is a a partless speck of dust, a partless a partless unit of matter. That’s what they’re referring to. And we say and we the saying, you know, that such things do not exist. If it is an object of knowledge, if it is an existent phenomena, it has parts.

Again, you know, left and right, up and down, in and out, permanently permanent, and all that. Okay? And then then we have this other expression, this partless moments of consciousness. So we have a unit of consciousness which cannot be divided. Again, it’s a it’s a unit of consciousness so small that there is you cannot split it in anything smaller than that.

And Geshe-la was then saying there’s another way to refer to it as being the last moment of the consciousness consciousness of a person who is about to attain arhatship, the the the the enlightenment of a foe destroyer. Because there is Geshe-la is explaining as as that partless moment of consciousness, as a moment of consciousness of which there is no second. There’s no other moment of consciousness following that. So, again, the last moment of consciousness of a being who is about to attain the state of a foe destroyer. Again, having attained the state of a foe destroyers, that that continuum of consciousness is severed.

That’s how they posit it. It ceases. And so the way they posit it, the way the lower is posited is then indicating again that there is there’s a moment of consciousness of which there is no second. It’s the very last moment of consciousness of a being who is about to attain the state of a foe destroyer. And Geshe-la this this how Geshe was explaining it.

Is that from point of view of five, actually? Yes. Yes. The lower schools. Yes.

Absolutely. So such a thing also is a an acquired conception, a fabricated conception. So, again and again for the Mādhyamika Prāsaṇgika, such a thing does not exist. If it is consciousness, it necessarily has a continuation. It has a continuum.

So we have then Geshe-la was making these distinctions, more subtle distinction. So we have a discontinuation of afflicted, you know, afflicted minds. We have a discontinuation of the afflictive obscurations the obscurations to knowledge. Those those types of mind, they have an end to them. There’s a point in time when they cease to be.

We have eradicated them. But consciousness itself, that being that which is clear in knowing, which is the definition of shépa, consciousness, mind, knowledge, awareness. Again, it has existed again since time immemorial and will continue to exist all the way until enlightenment from the all the way up until now or from now all the way until enlightenment. And once we attain enlightenment, it continues to exist. Again, it is a a omniscient consciousness, a omniscient mind.

So there’s it it continues. Okay. So that which is clear and knowing continues. There is no such thing as the cessation or or a partless Mhmm. Consciousness.

So and then Geshe-la is further explaining there’s another point of debate Geshe-la was explaining so there is Geshe-la explained that Buddha explained that there are two types of nirvana. There is a nirvana with remainder and a nirvana without remainder. And that is something that is explained differently by the different schools of thought. So again, and and what’s this the lower schools of thought explain as this remainder or without remainder. Again, without remainder, that which that which has no remainder as being the complete cessation of consciousness.

That’s what they are referring to. Whilst the middle way consequentialists, the proponents of the middle way consequentialists, the they, again, they don’t they they explain it as being something different. If they explain it as there being a attainment of nirvana, which is still associated, which still has the former contaminated aggregates included in this continuum. And we have a nirvana a nirvana without remainder, with a nirvana that has of which this this mental continuum has been separated from these contaminated appropriated aggregates. And again, these these conceptions of a self of phenomena, which are which are these ideas ideas of partless particles and partless moments of consciousness.

Again, they are what we are told here, again, we have to know understand that they also are only acquired conceptions. They are artificially fabricated conceptions. It is not without having thought about it that one will come up with such ideas. Alright. And then so and then and then the next sentence is saying that in brief that those conceptions or both types of conception of a self, self of the person, self of phenomena that arise sort of naturally.

They are they are sort of innate in that they don’t depend on any investigation, on analysis that is on on the likes of tenets and so on, you know, logical investigations on that establishment of any engaging in reasonings and so forth. So those such concepts that arise in this manner, they are said to be innate innate conceptions. Alright? And every other conception of our self is an acquired conception of our self, a mentally created fabricated conception of a self. Alright?

Is that fun? This And then and then the text goes on. Sorry. The text goes on to tell us that this this the former object of apprehension, the former object of adherence, which is to be negated, is the principal one. And that being, again, the former here is the one that was explained first, the beginning of this commentary, again, which is the innate conception of a self.

The innate conception of a self then is the main object of negation, is the main object that is to be eliminated, eradicated. Alright. Let’s go. And then and then the latter object of adherence, is to be negated, again, is to be understood as being is to be known as being a branch of the negation of the former. So those are those are the words in Tibetan.

Okay? So so Geshe-la is then putting everything very explicit for us. And again, so the the acquired conception of a self is a branch or or is one of the steps steps necessary in the negation of the innate conception of ourself. That’s what it means. Okay.

So in order to negate the the innate conception of ourself, we have to go for this first branch, which is to negate, to eliminate the acquired conception of our self. Alright? In English, I wasn’t saying so so, again, the point of this sentient being that the main object of negation, the main object which is to be arrested, which is to be eradicated is the innate conception of our self. And then if we stop and ask, what the heck is this conception of our self that we’re talking about? And Geshe-la was saying, it is it is the the conception of a true existent self, a fully characterized self, an inherent existent self.

Again, conception of the self existing truly as it appears to exist. The conception of a self that has inherent existence completely independent of anything else. Has existence from its own side, that has fully characterized existence and that it has all the characteristics that it appears to have that is of existing from its own side and so on, independently and so on. This is the main conception that is to be eradicated, is to be eliminated, that is to be negated. And, again, so Geshe-la was saying, these are these are the this is the object that is to be negated.

This object of apprehension, which is the the the apprehension of an inherent existent self. Geshe-la was talking about the cup. Again, of an inherent existent cup, a fully characterized cup, a truly existent cup. So again, those are those expressions, even though the words are different, they mean exactly the same thing. And we are talking about just the fact that there is a conception that conceives that apprehends the cup as existing truly.

That appearance of the cup is a true appearance, that that that appearance is the true way in which that cup exists. That is it appears to exist from its own side. It appears to have independent existence, independence from anything else. It appears to have inherent existence, to have exist inherently from its own side, and so it appears to exist truly. And this then is this conception, which is this apprehension of phenomena, this mode of apprehension of the self of phenomena, self of the person is what is our main object of negation.

So again, we have and this is this mode of apprehension, this way of apprehending phenomena, the self of the person is what we are involved with. Alright. This is what pervades our minds right now. So this is the way we perceive every thing that appears. Right?

So then again, there’s there’s another the same word, which has different meanings in different slightly different meanings in different ones. We’re talking about appearances now. Everything that appears, every phenomenon, everything that exists, everything that we we all know what it is because it’s everything that we see, everything that we hear, everything that appears to to our consciousness. So we see things. We we see this.

We see that. We see the person going, the person coming back. We see all those things, all all of these, all phenomena, they appear, they appearances. Alright? And then we have and so and and we have the apprehension of those appearances as existing from their own side, as existing here and so on.

This one. Alright? So then, again, so we have both the we have this both both sides. We have the the appearances, what we perceive, and we have the adherence. This the word is called to to adhere.

So our consciousness adheres to them to sort of Geshe-la has explained this before as as an aspect of mind that is involved of of the same sort of the same same nature of attachment. So it adheres to those appearances as existing truly and so forth. So Geshe-la was saying, now Ārya beings do not have that. You know? Some Ārya beings only have the appearances, but do not have the adherence aspect from the side of their minds, their consciousness.

Others do not have either. So it’s like it’s like what we see on the television. So for example, if we see a the image of a pizza on the television screen, again, that image of the pizza is appearing to us, and yet we don’t adhere to it as being something real. There’s no adherence to it. From the side of our minds, there’s no grasping at it.

There’s no conception of it as being a real pizza. So that’s the the the analogy. Okay? So the the the pizza appears on the television, but it doesn’t exist in the way that it appears. And we realize that.

We realize that that pizza that is on the television screen doesn’t exist in the way that it appears. And the same applies to every other phenomenon. They appear, and they appear to exist truly, to exist inherent. They appear to exist in the way that they appear. And yet, we don’t realize that it doesn’t they phenomena do not exist the way they appear to exist.

They don’t exist truly or inherently. Alright? And so now we we can all we we can all think, okay, there is no we think, okay, I don’t realize. I there’s no way I can realize that phenomena don’t exist the way it appears to exist. I can realize that the pizza and the television that it doesn’t exist in the way that appears to exist because, you know, it’s just a product of electricity and and whatnot.

But I I don’t realize I don’t realize that other phenomena do not exist in the way that appears to exist. Order to be able to arrest that conception, to negate that conception, again, which is this conception that arises naturally effortlessly, Again, we have to we have then to arrest to negate this, which is referred to as the former object of apprehension, which is to be negated. Again, this innate conception of self, of inherent self and so on. When we realize the lack of such an innate conception of a self, that the such such an innate conception of a self is mistaken, wrong, and so forth, then we, again, we can get rid of that. And that is done through the realization of emptiness, by realizing emptiness.

So for for those who have realized emptiness, they they they sort of have again this is an analogy okay a broad analogy they sort of have the same feeling tone relationship with every phenomenon as we have with that pizza on the television screen. Again, we we they see they understand that every phenomenon does not exist in the way it appears to exist. Does not exist truly. And then again, Geshe-la is saying, and when when we realize that something does not exist in the way it appears to exist, it is not the case that we have realized that it doesn’t exist altogether, that it is in existent altogether. In the same way that when we realize that that pizza on a television screen doesn’t exist in the way that a pizza exists, we have not realized that it doesn’t exist altogether because pizzas do exist.

There are pizzas everywhere. There’s a plenty of pizza places around the place. Plenty of pizzerias around. So pizzas do exist. In the same in the same way, in the same vein, again, when we when phenomena are realized to not exist in the way that pizza exists, it is not the case that they are realized not to exist altogether.

That they’re not realized to be in existence because they do exist. You cannot realize that they do not exist because they do exist. So, again, Geshe-la is in a sense, so, again, when we realize that phenomena do not exist in the way they appear to exist, and yet they do exist, again, then we we we come to figure out how they exist. They exist as merely imputed merely imputed by name, by sound, and by concept. And then and then, again, some nice terms of of of phrase here, terms of language.

I’m trying to put it in English nicely. So, again, not every being realizes the lack of existence from its in the way they appear to exist. Not every being realizes realizes that phenomena do not exist in the way they appear to exist. Only this is for ordinary beings to realize. Ordinary beings realize that phenomena do not exist the way in the the way that they appear to exist.

Right? Now other beings fully enlightened Buddhas, they for them, they realize that phenomena exist in the way that they appear to exist. Because for them, they don’t for them, they don’t appear wrongly. It’s only it is only for ordinary beings to realize that phenomena do not exist the way they appear to exist. Fully enlightened beings, they they don’t they don’t realize that.

They realize that phenomena do exist the way that they appear to exist. They see it the right way. They apprehend it the right way from the from the beginning. Again, for ordinary beings, for us, phenomena do not exist the way that they appear to exist. For Ārya beings, for Ārya bodhisattvas, or fully enlightened Buddhas, phenomena do exist in the way that they appear to exist.

Because those beings, they realize that phenomena they fully realize, they fully understand the way that phenomena exist. They exist as merely imputed phenomena. And they do and and they lack any existence, any inherent existence, or any exist from the outside. That’s how they apprehend phenomena already. So for them, they phenomena exist in the way that they appear to exist.

This one. Alright? Alright. Stopping here today. We probably have questions.

No. Thought about you are. So, Geshe lah, was asking if you have any questions. I just find a bit typical to understand things that naturally exist, like stuff like that, maybe A tree. Tree or a lot.

Yeah. So the the way that this is explained in Tibetans is a very nice way. So for example, in the case of the tree, for example. Okay? When you when you look at the tree, again, there is the the eye consciousness that apprehends the tree, and there is the image of a tree that is appearing to the eye consciousness.

And then there is the the the concept of tree. There is a tree. There exists a tree over there that arises. And so that is the the label, the imputation. And so there’s and if you, again, if you stop to investigate, you will see that there is only that imputation.

There is no tree from its own side that shows up and says, I’m a tree. That’s that’s how it is said in Tibetan. Literally. There’s there’s no tree that says, I am a tree. There’s nothing from its own side showing off itself, appearing itself as this is a tree.

I’m a tree. This is a cup, and so on and so on. There’s only the imputation from our own from our side. That’s what is meant by again, that’s what is meant by mere label. There’s only the the mere imputation from our side, from the side of our mind, the concept, the words.

There’s And again, Geshe-la was saying that not only you it’s not only you that imputes tree upon upon the tree, that that that imputes that label, that concept. Everyone who apprehends the tree, who sees the tree, imputes. Tree, cause it, again, Tibetan, shindon. Shindon, a tree. And, again, that that that tree which arose came about due to very many causes and conditions, from a seed to a sprout and so on.

Again, there’s nothing there from its own side that says I am a tree. I am a tree. Karthang. Again, for for that non non analytical consciousness, again, the tree is there. The tree exists as a mere imputation.

Again, if you but if you investigate, if you analyze, then you will see that the tree came about in very due to very many causing conditions. And there was the seed, there was the water, there were the proper nutrients, the proper conditions for the tree to grow and bloom and so forth. So again, the same principles apply to the idea, the notion of a chair, for example, of which you can see that there are parts and you put the parts together and then you put the chair on it. Yet the chair also is made of the elements, you know, of water, fire, wind, and and and space. So all these parts also are made of of of the natural elements, composed of the natural elements and so on.

So it can be it can be seen. It can be looked at in just all these ways. Now this this this one lady here wanted to ask a question first. So what we have to do in order to realize in order to arrest or to eliminate that innate conception of a self, all we have to do is to realize emptiness. We have to exert ourselves in understanding and realizing emptiness, and we have to exert ourselves in cultivating an understanding of the lack of inherent existence of of phenomena or or lack of inherent existence of the self of the person, lack of inherent existence of the self of phenomena.

So what we have to do, again, the way that it appears to exist right now, it appears to us to exist inherently, to exist from its own side, to exist independently and so on. Those appearances are very distorted, very wrong. And what we have to then exert ourselves is in realizing the correct way that they exist, the ultimate way in which phenomena exist. We have to realize that their lack of having any inherent existence, their lack of having any existence from its own side, their lack of having any true existence. That is to say, we have to realize emptiness.

We have to exert ourselves in understanding realizing emptiness. And that’s how you eliminate that. Also, again and and again, and from all those things that we have to realize, we also have to realize that oneself doesn’t exist in the way that appears to exist. We have to engage in a lot of an analytical meditation. We have to engage in a lot of analysis, a lot of investigation, a lot of research, and and and then come to the understanding that oneself one’s self does not exist in the way that appears to exist and that’s what we as ordinary beings realize.

Other beings, they don’t realize that they realize that they exist the way that they appear to exist because they have already corrected their their perceptions. Alright? It’s important to do that because because you don’t phenomena appear as being inherent. Is that the reason why does the the seeing things like a dream or or seeing things as an illusion, does that try to Yeah. Stop one from seeing that inherent existence?

We say I’m just yes. I’m I’m gonna ask. I just I just want to put the right the right wording just to be more precise. They say we say phenomena exist like an illusion, like illusion, or phenomena exist like like dreams exist. Yeah.

Geshe-la? Sorry. So these these are Geshe-la was saying these are analogies that are given so that we can develop a a feeling for how to relate to to phenomena in general. Because because we can realize, because we do realize that even though dreams appear, they do not have any real existence. They do not exist the way they appear to exist.

Again, illusions appear. We all realize that illusions appear, but we know that illusions are illusions. They’re not real. So because so they they were given we’re given these as tools to start to be able to relate to phenomena in general. We have to think of phenomena as existing the same way that illusions exist or or or that dreams exist.

They do appear, but they do not exist in the way that they appear to exist. And again, also, Nick, you yourself do not you you yourself do not exist in the way that that you appear to exist. So, again, Geshe-la is saying. Again, nick also. Again, Geshe-la is saying, Nick, yourself.

Again, you you you think of yourself. You feel. You have this notion, feeling, or thought of yourself as being something that exists substantially, that exists independently of from anything else. I think you think I or you think me, and you have that that notion, feeling, I am Nick. You know, I and I exist.

And yet, Nick is exists only as as a mere imputation. There is there is all there’s all there’s there’s there is a all all existence there is to Nik is as a mere imputation. There’s no other existence than than being a mere imputation. So, again, again, you have to investigate. If you investigate, if you look into it, then eventually, you’ll be able to understand.

Oh. Okay. Yeah? I love that. The sentient do the numbers of sentient beings increase?

What? Do the numbers of sentient beings increase? Mhmm. Just because if sentient if if if beginning this time is if if time is beginning this, sentient beings have the potential to attain enlightenment and So, again, you cannot speak of sentient beings in those terms. We should always explain.

There is no such thing as there being an increase or decrease in sentient beings. You can you can you can talk about, you know, there being an increase or decrease in human beings, right, other beings. Oh. But generally speaking, in terms of of sentient beings in general, you couldn’t really come around to think or or conceive of it as as there being an increase or decrease. We talk about it as being numberless.

So then and then and then, like, elaborate further explaining. You couldn’t speak of sentient beings increasing, but you could say you could speak of sentient beings the number of sentient beings decreasing. Every time a being attains enlightenment, full enlightenment, then if one if one sentient being has attained full enlightenment, then there is one less sentient being. If a hundred beings have attained enlightenment, there are then there are hundred less sentient beings. And so you cannot speak we we say that the we talk we speak about beginning as time.

Time without beginning. Because there’s you cannot find a beginning. Okay? There’s no way you can find a beginning to time, to some cyclic existence. But we we can’t speak of sort of the end of time.

We can’t speak of of a time in which all sentient beings will be enlightened. Alright? So again Geshe-la says there is an end because there is a point, there will be a point in which all sentient beings will attain enlightenment. There is an end to that. Now the so you can but and yet and yet you cannot speak.

You cannot speak of the number of sentient beings increasing because if the number of sentient beings were to increase, then there will have to be a sentient being that has a rise and that has come into existence, which did not exist. And sentient beings exist in a continuum that goes all the way back since to from beginningless time to beginningless time. And so there couldn’t be logically speaking, there couldn’t be a sentient being that did not exist since beginningless time. Otherwise, that that would defeat the whole the entire reasoning scheme. So, again, Geshe-la is saying there there cannot be new sentient beings, so to speak, speak because the sentient beings do they do exist.

They have existed. They come into existence from a continuum of its own type that goes all the way back to time and memorial to beginningless time. And if there were such a thing as as the coming of a new sentient being or the increase of sentient beings, then there will there will also be such a thing as a fully enlightened Buddha having his or her qualities deteriorating so that it would cease to be a fully enlightened Buddha and be become an ordinary being, sentient being again. There’s no such thing. So you couldn’t couldn’t speak on those terms.

We cannot speak in those terms. So we cannot speak in in terms of sentient beings increasing, and yet we can speak of the number of sentient beings decreasing. Alright? Shall shall we shall finish? Yeah.

Your dedication, please, here.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
four maras du zhi (Tib)
The four external and internal hindrances or obstacles to our spiritual progress. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mantra ngag (Tib)
Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
object of negation gag cha (Tib)
An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
obscurations to knowledge jneyavarana (Skt); she drib (Tib)
One of the two obscurations, the more subtle ones that block enlightenment; also known as subtle obscurations, obscurations to enlightenment and cognitive obscurations (Berzin’s translation). LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top