46 min · 2,918 words · 26 September 2002 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Pema Tsering opens this 46-minute session by probing a paradox at the heart of renunciation: we cultivate suffering because we mistake the suffering of change and of pervasive conditioning for happiness. He observes that even animals recognize ordinary pain and discomfort, but humans must use their intelligence to examine the body’s causes and see how karma and disturbing emotions perpetuate saṃsāra across lifetimes. He then pivots from personal renunciation to bodhicitta — the same wish to be free, now extended to all sentient beings — before turning to Chapter 9 of Śāntideva’s text, the Wisdom chapter. Here he explains that all six perfections were taught as preparation for wisdom realizing emptiness, then introduces the two truths through a concrete example: a vase is conventional truth; the vase’s freedom from inherent existence is ultimate truth. Suited to practitioners following the Bodhisattva Deeds series.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 71 BD 2002 09 26.mp3
UUID: 9d188529-e5c8-43fe-8884-71ccea764bdf
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Bodhisattva Deeds (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2002-09-26
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 46.1 minutes
Words: ~2,914
And the great master Tsongkhapa in his text called the Three Principal Aspects of the Path, it is said that without having a proper renunciation, there’s no way one can achieve the happiness of the liberation or happiness of the liberation due to this, because of not having So therefore, good master continues. Therefore, should try to develop, a renunciation. So to to develop a renunciation, there are or to develop an uncontrollable wish to free from cyclic existence. First, one needs to recognize or re understand the the the what is liberation. So and so by by understanding what is the liberation, then one will yeah.
In order to develop such an uncontrolled wish, one needs to understand what is liberation, as well as one needs to see the faults of the cyclic existence. Right? So one yeah. One needs to recognize the liberation. What is liberation?
And the liberation here is one is being liberated from the cyclic existence or this or the sufferings because the cyclic existence, its nature itself is a suffering. And so seeing the suffering nature of the cyclic existence is not easy because we are so accustomed to the happiness of cyclic existence, or seeing saṃsāra as happiness. And due to this due to this, sometimes if one if we do not really be careful or not really careful, always happen to be cultivating a saṃsāra instead of abandoning it. So we wish happiness and do not want suffering, but we cultivate the suffering because we see suffering as a happiness. And so, therefore, So the the nature of the nature of the Samsāra is suffering.
And we make mistake or yeah. Mistake to to mistake and can’t see the true nature of saṃsāra as suffering. And due to this, we we instead, we see them as a happiness and try to cultivate that happiness. And as a and because one is trying to work to attain that this this samsaric happiness and we yeah. And then along we cultivate numbers of karmas in order to attain that happiness.
Among those karmas, the most of the karmas are non virtuous. So so because they are non virtuous, then it becomes like that we are cultivating the suffering of suffering or causes of the suffering. Okay. And, yes, we practice and and we cultivate a method to achieve the happiness and and also the method to abandon the suffering. And and and and we also practice.
What happens most of the time, our practice becomes to abandon only the first suffering — the suffering of suffering — because we recognize that suffering of suffering as suffering, and then we practice. And for the next two sufferings, of change and of pervasive conditioning, we mistake and instead see them as happiness instead of suffering. And due to this, then we work to attain those next two sufferings. And as a result of that, we cultivate numbers of karma, mostly the non virtues, the yep, the negative karmas. And, yeah, this is how it happens.
And when we talk about those next two — the suffering of change and the suffering of pervasive conditioning — when we say they are suffering, sometimes people or most of us can’t really accept those, or feel discomfort in hearing those next two described as suffering because we see them as happiness. Yeah. So as for the first suffering of suffering, not only not only us, even the animals like cats and dogs, like pets, they can acknowledge and see suffering of the suffering as suffering. And because they do not wish to be to be sick and they don’t like to hear the unpleasant words or harsh words, and they want to have a happy So we are humans, not not an animal. Therefore, we have intelligence.
So one needs to make use of that intelligence, the mind, to investigate what are the happiness and what are the sufferings. So through true investigation, by using one’s intelligence, then one can understand what are the sufferings and what are the happinesses. And through such analysis, one can see not only the first suffering, but can also find the next true sufferings as suffering. And, yeah, so one should examine examine, for example, like this one’s own of the aggregates or the body. So we suffer all the three types of sufferings on the basis of this body.
And therefore, therefore, so if you find if you examine, then one can find the the the phenomena of the saṃsāra or particularly this body where on such body we on the basis of such body we suffers, experience all those sufferings. So if you go through the investigation, find out that so this yeah, it is a product. So what are the causes? Search for its causes and search for its nature and its function and results of its functions. So when one go through all this, then one can really see that saṃsāra is full of all kinds of sufferings.
Yes. So, yeah, therefore and so through investigation and what are its causes, the the and it causes the the karma and the disturbing emotions. So and which are yeah. The karma and the disturbing emotion, therefore, its causes are not good. And particularly, those karma and the disturbing emotions, those are the main obstacles for those who wish obstacle for the liberation or nirvana.
And by its nature, then in terms of its nature, its nature is suffering because it acts the basis of all the sufferings. And you prove it and in the previous life, as as a result of that and this current life as as one also, yes, suffers on the basis of such a body. And and due to this body, one cultivate all the all the karmas. On the basis of the on the basis of this body, one cultivate all this karma. You know?
You’re you’re to achieve the happiness and pleasant, good and so forth for this body and due to this. And all the karma’s been collected. And as a result of those karma, it produce they produce suffering in the future as well. But by by going through such investigation, then one come to know that that it has been suffered in the previous life as well as this life. Not only this life, it will also link to suffering in future as well.
Going through such such analysis, then one can see it is the saṃsāra. The it’s it’s it’s full of full of it’s full of faults and and can hardly find any qualities, good qualities. So yes. So if one wants to attain the liberation or nirvana, one has to abandon this saṃsāra or all this body or one which enters in the mother’s womb and that’s right. Which is the product or projected by the karma and the disturbing emotion.
And and it’s also called the the the it is the saṃsāra as well as it’s called it is the suffering of pervasive conditioning because because it pervades entire life yep. Entire lives from the very beginning to the And then the suffering of change are like having nice delicious meals or listening to good sounds, so forth. And those are the suffering of change. So we see both the suffering of pervasive conditioning and the suffering of change as mistakenly see them as happiness. So in order to develop the renunciation, one needs to see the faults of cyclic existence and develop an uncontrollable wish to be free from cyclic existence.
So which are those the things which we see them as happiness, in reality they are not, so should develop so whenever one develop uncontrollable wish to be free from those from the saṃsāra or those saṃsāra happiness or the things we mistakenly see as happiness. Whenever one develops such uncontrollable wish, one has developed a renunciation. And such a mind — the renunciation, the wish to be free from cyclic existence — then redirect or change the direction slightly: instead of oneself, and develop a wish to free those sentient beings from the suffering because they are equally or same as oneself, the wishing happiness, do not want suffering, same as what same same as oneself lacking happiness and and being tortured by sufferings. And then so by developing such wish to free sentient beings from the sufferings, then one will look for a method to do accomplish such wish and yeah. Accomplish such wishes, such wish, and one will come to know that the only it’s only the Buddhahood enlightenment.
By attaining that, one can free those sentient beings from these sufferings. By knowing this, then one will work to attain Buddhahood for the sake of entire sentient beings. So shall do a short meditation here that on a bodhicitta, I shall attain enlightenment for the sake of entire sentient beings. For that purpose, perform all these practices as well as the the the virtues I gain from such practice through the power of those may I attain enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings. Now to begin the ninth chapter: it has two main divisions, explaining the text and its parts.
And then the first one has two. The re brief yeah. Brief explanation of the reason why one needs to develop the wisdom. And the second one is expanding in detail or yeah. In detail.
The first one and the first one do I do do you want me to repeat it? No. That’s okay. Oh, this song. And the the first one explaining brief explanation, it had it’s been explained by the first single verse, which is yep.
All of those practice were taught by the mighty ones for the sake of wisdom. And the meaning is that the all the teachings set forth in the earlier chapters, like the the six perfections starting from generosity and so forth. So all these teachings set forth by the the mighty one, which is Lord Buddha Śākyamūni, is, yeah, is set forth for the purpose of developing a wisdom to develop a wisdom realizing emptiness, which is wisdom realizing emptiness wisdom realizing emptiness that the wis such wisdom which which abandons or clears the obscuration abandons the obscuration to liberation. So, the lord Buddha Śākyamūni has set forth the teachings on the set the teachings of wisdom, realizing emptiness or emptiness. The purpose of giving such teaching is is is, yeah, is to abandon the obscuration to liberation, the obscuration to enlightenment.
But it was set forth for that purpose, but not only for that, it also the the the the the it is also necessary to have wisdom realizing emptiness in order to attain to nirvana or yeah. nirvana or liberation because because without wisdom realizing emptiness, one cannot abandon the obscuration to nirvana or obscuration to liberation. So therefore, either obscuration to liberation in the sense Buddha Buddhahood is a liberation, but the lower ones. So the the both yep. Liberation and the enlightenment.
Yeah. The wisdom realizing emptiness should be developed in order to attain either of the liberations. So now to explain to the second one, explaining in details, it has four subdivisions now. And the first one is establishing the views or theories or views. And and and yeah.
Establishing the view, which is first one. And then how to meditate through yeah. Through yeah. Okay. And the second and third one is to to the discussions or of clarifying the the the, say, mistakes or the elaborations in the the logics which will come later.
And then the fourth one is then the purpose, the activities of of the wisdom realizing emptiness. And as with the first one, the first subdivision, establishing the views or theories, and it has three subdivisions as well. And yep. Ascertaining or or explaining the first one is oh, why am I yeah. Establishing the views, it has three subdivisions.
The first one is explaining the two truths and then avoiding or refuting or yeah. Refuting the debates on it and and establishing that the the excellence of the Mahāyāna or great vehicle. Right? And to now to the out of those three, the first one, establishing the two truths. Right?
And it has three subdivisions as well. Three divisions as well. The definition of the two truths and, again yep. And explaining or establishing the both individually, the the two truths and and explaining the person’s yeah. The the distinction or the difference or yeah.
The difference between the two between the person or a self. Probably, guess, like, picking on the translator now. What happens is is actually the two truths here. And yeah. Yeah.
And two truths, in Tibetan word, and it is the conventional and ultimate truth. But the I think a long time ago, one of the translators is not really used to the teachings or Dharma texts. And when the teacher said “deni,” he translated it as something like “two honesty” or “two honest” because “den” is a word which is like telling the truth or honest. So I think, you know, there’s too honesty or something like that. And yep.
And the the first Yeah. The first one, to explain the difference of the two difference between the two truths. That has been explained in the next two lines. Now speaking of this two lines, it’s very tricky in English now because I went through it and it’s not written as the the previous chapters, you know. So well, when you see there’s a number two on the page one three one, and it is yeah.
The half of the number two is the two words in a way. Right. So now yep. So the meaning is that the the the phenomena yeah. Phenomena is the basis where is the basis where the two truths have been divided or been, yep, separate yep, been divided.
And but all the phenomenas, the phenomena here means phenomena, the entire things or that can be acknowledged or can can be perceived by the wisdom. And so there are two truths, so called the conventional truth and the ultimate truth. And the convent conventional truths so yeah. All the persons, like self, and the bodies — conventional truths. Self and the bodies are the conventional truths and and free of free of inherent existence of the self and the bodies or aggregates, for example.
Yes. Say the aggregates are the ultimate truths. Okay? This one. No.
So the the the phenomena is very wide and you can’t hardly fit it all in one’s brain or one’s mind, but briefly speaking here, then all the phenomenas the conventional truth, the the phenomena, and so that includes the emptiness itself is the the the conventional truth. And all the all the phenomena as well as the emptiness itself are the free of inherent existence, and those free of free of inherent existence of the emptiness or the phenomenas are the conventional sorry, ultimate truth. So even though the phenomena is very wide, but they if they are they can be conclude or subsumed under two categories, the conventional and the ultimate truth. So and that such logic or that is can be applied on each and every phenomenon. For example, like the vase on the table, and the vase itself is the conventional truth.
And the emptiness of the vase — that is, the free of inherent existence of the vase — is the emptiness, which is the ultimate truth. So likewise, so the the self, oneself is the conventional truth and free of inherent existence of the person or oneself is the ultimate truth. You getting there? Okay. Okay.
So so when we say so there is both the truth in each and every phenomenon. This, yeah. The example has been demonstrated on the vase and the person with oneself. They’re speaking of this, and the person might ask, but how can there be a two truths on emptiness itself? Then it is because the the emptiness for emptiness, there is a the valid cognition, perception or a valid cognition which which which which use the emptiness itself as the object or basis on upon it that realize the emptiness itself is free of inherent existence.
And therefore, that upon the emptiness itself, the emptiness is yeah. So it becomes the conventional truth and the free of inherent existence of the emptiness is the ultimate truth. So this is how one divides the two truths, the conventional and the ultimate truth. The truth is, then one can apply that on each and every phenomenon, there is both the two truths, conventional and ultimate. By doing so, then one can understand that the the entire phenomena can be divided into two groups.
And now to the second division, which is subdivision which is to the definition of the two truths. It’s set forth that the that has been explained in the next two lines, and I’m finding out where these two lines are. They accept it as the two truths. Ultimately, It’s the the half of the the the verse two. It it’s a very hard topic, and that’s been the, yeah, translator has made written a note on the top of it how to read it, actually.
So ultimate truth and conventional truth, the minds — they are two types of minds.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
- As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- suffering of suffering duhkha-duhkhata (Skt); dug ngäl gyi dug ngäl (Tib)
- Aka the suffering of pain; the commonly recognized suffering experiences of pain, discomfort and unhappiness. LYWA
- three principal aspects of the path lamtso nam sum (Tib)
- The three principal realizations of the lamrim path: renunciation, bodhicitta and the right view (of emptiness). Also the title of a short prayer composed by Lama Tsongkhapa that is commonly recited during prayer services. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.