45 min · 2,288 words · 1995 · Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Dhawa Gyaltsen introduces the Buddhist philosophy of mind through an examination of mistaken consciousness in this 46-minute teaching. He opens with the foundations of bodhicitta—cultivating compassion and the intention to free all beings from suffering—then turns to his main focus: the nature of mistaken consciousness, the fifth of the five non-valid cognitions. He distinguishes two types (conceptual and non-conceptual) with concrete examples: a dream-mind perceiving blue when no color exists, or ordinary sight seeing a snow mountain as blue. He then divides all consciousness into three categories and examines conceptual consciousness in detail, using an extended vase example to show how the mind simultaneously grasps both the word vase and its meaning—the shape and function. He concludes by contrasting conceptions that hold objects as real with those that treat them as nonexistent. Pitched at practitioners with prior Buddhist philosophy training.
—
**Issues detected:** []
File metadata (for organising)
File: 17 Lo Rig.mp3
UUID: 5fb52714-c1bf-4975-b299-c4a9138059a9
Teacher: Geshe Dhawa Gyaltsen
Collection: Nature of the Mind (Geshe Dhawa Gyaltsen)
Date: 1995 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 45.9 minutes
Words: ~2,284
So in the teachings, the teachings taught by Maitreya Buddha in the Abhisamayālamkāra text. As it explains, the doorway to Mahāyāna’s path is the conventional bodhicitta. So here, conventional bodhicitta here, for that training, it can be done it’s a it can be done in three three different ways that one one way is like making prayer for yourself able to practice that. And then second is and which is like second is like training oneself, which is exchanging oneself with another. And then thirdly, third type of way of training is equalizing oneself with others.
So the first part which we say that as in making prayer for one’s self able to practice bodhicitta, which is the aspiration of bodhicitta. That that is like the wish to do the practice or wish to go to perform perform action. So for us to train in this this enlightened mind or the bodhicitta, one first as a ground, one as a foundation, one first need to train oneself in the practice of love and compassion, which is like wishing all sentient beings to have or to be free sorry, to be free from all the state of sufferings and wishing all sentient beings to be in the state of happiness. So on these two points, one has to train. So so on the on these two on the basis of these two, like, freeing all the mother sentient beings from the state of suffering and leading them into the state of happiness.
On on the on this basis, one generate this special insight, which is I myself will, like, do this for all mother sentient beings. So so to for oneself to do this to lead for oneself, like, taking the the whole responsibility to lead also into beings of to the state of happiness and free them from the state of suffering. To do that at at present one is unable to do and looking up looking to those higher beings who have this possible who who are able to do this perform this action. And, like, even the the heads of the gods, they are unable to do it. And even the, like, heroes, they are unable to perform these actions.
So, like, looking only that the fully enlightened Buddha is able to perform these actions that free all the sentient beings from suffering and and bring them into the state of happiness. So so for that purpose so for that, like for that Buddhas are only able to do that and for the for oneself to achieve the full enlightened state that that Buddha would, like generating a thought that I’m now training in this aspirational bodhicitta, aspirational bodhicitta, and we do short meditation on that. So last time, we talked about the non valid cognitions and there are five and we finish explaining up to four. So today, the fifth one, the mistaken consciousness or the wrong consciousness. So as a definition of mistaken consciousness, knower which engages in its object mistakenly.
Knower which engages in its object mistakenly. So, as an example to that is that apprehending that sound being permanent, sound as permanent. So, sound actually is impermanent but holding or apprehending that as being permanent. So the mistaken consciousness are that of two types, that of conceptual mistaken consciousness and non conceptual mistaken consciousness. So, as an example to the first one, like the conceptual wrong consciousness, it’s the same example that we gave to the mistaken consciousness, which is like apprehending sound being permanent or or or seeing rabbits like seeing rabbit’s horn.
So this, like, seeing rabbit’s horn, that is, what is it, mistaken consciousness, and it’s also conceptual. And one thing that horn of rabbit doesn’t exist. So then to the non conceptual mistaken consciousness has two that have that of mental mental and that of the senses. So, non conceptual what do you call? That non conceptual, mistaken consciousness that of the mental one.
As an example, So, dream consciousness apprehending blue as a real blue. So this dream consciousness apprehending blue as as a blue, a real blue. That is that is like a mental consciousness, and that is also known as this kind of wrong or mistaken consciousness, and it is non conceptual. So so the dream consciousness is one is is mental consciousness because in the dream in the dream during the time of dream, only the mental consciousness works. The rest of the sense consciousness stops functioning.
Mhmm. It stop it stops working. So so it is a what do you call? It is non conceptual. It’s non conceptual because it’s not conceptual which is that So, it is a knower which is which is separate or free from like, free from what is it?
No apprehending no apprehending, like, generality and meaning generality as what do call? As that both what we say? Which is the sound generality and meaning generality to be combined, which is the non conceptual is not, let’s see. Example is non conceptual because it’s not conceptual. And how it’s because it’s a knower which is free from conceiving the sound generality and meaning generality that which to be combined.
So that object that Let’s see. So the the the object that which, I would say, makes the mental consciousness perceive. So, like, there’s object or form that makes the mental consciousness perceive. So, to that to that that object has no, what is it, no color? Like, that object has no color, like red or blue?
So to the dream consciousness, so when it perceives blue, what for the dream consciousness comes to perceive is blue? So but but that blue actually doesn’t exist. So so it is said mistaken consciousness. So whatever is the color, whether it’s red, white, or whatever, is only perceived by the eye consciousness, not the mental consciousness. And this one, is Yeah.
So then the second one, which is non conceptual mistaken sense consciousness is as an example like apprehending the snow mountain as blue, apprehending or seeing snow mountains as blue or seeing the white as a yellow. So as like seeing the white conch shell as a yellow, that is known as mistaken and mistaking with regards to seeing what its color. That is the color of conch shell is white, but a person sees it’s yellow, so it’s mistaken. So that is known as the sense consciousness because is produced, that consciousness is produced by the uncommon empowering conditions of sense, the eye sense power. So again now the mind can again divide into three like as a first the conceptual mind or conceptual consciousness which holds conceptual mind, which holds the meaning generality as it’s it’s like a beheld object.
So then the second one is that non conceptual, non mistaken consciousness. That’s second kind. That is like a Okay. a then for consciousness apprehends its object as like a specifically characterized phenomena as its beheld object specifically characterized phenomena. So then the third one is that of the non conceptual mistaken consciousness.
And that is non conceptual mistaken consciousness apprehending non existent as its own beheld object. Non existent as its own beheld object or its own object. Yeah, beheld object. So So the first one that of the conceptual consciousness or conceptual mind as a definition that a conceptual mind a knower or conceiving the sound generality and the meaning generality that which can be combined. This one.
So we talk about the definition sound generality and the meaning generality is like sound generality as an example with the vase, the vase as the name. This one? As the sound generality. So to to whatever to the mind, like appearing the the sound which which which you call as a vase. That is like the sound generality.
So then the meaning generality is that to that mind again like a that sees what vase is like the functioning of the vase or like that which is round belly and sort of like the flat base. What it sees that the image of that is what the meaning generality is. So these two, two what is it? Appearance. These two appearance, what are like combining these two appearance in one.
Like how you Having the appearance of these two combined together. That is what the conceptual mind or conceptual consciousness. Suitable to be combined. I missed one word here. Suitable to be combined as combined.
So, as an example, this is like a suitable to be combined, these two generalities is that, as an example to a person, one who don’t know the term but sees the vase. For that person, like this the sound and the meaning generality is suitable to be combined. To a person again who knows the definition of the vase and who knows the term vase, his or her, to him or her, these two has like appearance like comes in, like sort of comes in combination together. So, it’s like these two to be combined together, combined, that one one need to know both, like, the vase and its definition. So, again, like, in the conceptual conceptual consciousness, again, there are three three types.
Conceptual conceptual consciousness, like apprehending only sound generality. And a conceptual what do you call conceptual consciousness apprehending only meaning meaning generality. And conceptual conceptual consciousness, let’s say, apprehending both the sound and the meaning. So as the example to the first one that which apprehends only the sound generality. To that person, that person doesn’t know vase is, like, is round belly and the flat base that’s like, which holds the water. The person don’t know that.
So so in other words, the the person who doesn’t doesn’t know the functioning of the vase just having the appearance of the vase just through mere name, just to the terms of vase. So that conception is the conceptual consciousness which is merely only to sound generality. Like, to only to, like, sound generality. So so it is known as the sound generality. That conception is because to that person appears the vase appears the appearance of the vase to that person appears one only to the sound generality.
So then the second one is conceptual consciousness, which apprehends only the meaning generality. So then example to the second one, in the conceptual consciousness apprehending only the meaning generality is that to a person like who sees the vase, who has the appearance of the vase but unable to use the term vase what what he or she sees. So his or her conception is known as known as that which is conceptual consciousness apprehending only the meaning. So so so it to that person, it only only, I wanna say, the appearance to that person of the vase is the what what vase the shape, what is it? How vase appears to to the person as an as an real object?
So so then the the third one, conceptual consciousness apprehending both generalities. That is a person who knows the term vase and also knows the functioning of the vase. So so again, is another another way of dividing the conceptual consciousness, which are up to. So which is conception connecting sound or name, conception connecting name and conception connecting meaning or its feature. So the conception of connecting name, which is the similar to the first, what we explained, like the sound generality, like knowing the vase just by the term vase.
So like this one, the first one which is conception connecting or conception connecting name. That conception is like connecting name to its object. Like giving a name to its object. So then the conception connecting the meaning that is again the same experience as we went to, like one who sees vase and knows what vase looks like, but not able to give it not not able to name it as a vase. So to it, that is like the appearance to the conception connecting meaning or feature to that person the feature or the shape of the vase that which appears to the person.
So then, person who knows like, what is it, both which is like the, what do you call, vase and its functioning round belly and flat base of the vase which are able to hold water and knowing its functions and the object is both vase and its functioning. That kind of conception or that kind of conception is both. That of conceptual consciousness connecting name or also connecting meaning about. So that is both because it perceives the vase or the object, the vase, and it also perceives the attributes or the feature of the object. So conception again can be divided in another way.
That is that is a two which is like a concordant conception and not concordant conception. So so the difference between like concordant conception and not concordant conception is that not concordant conception holds its object as nonexistent. Like, it holds an object as a nonexistent thing. So so then the concordant conception is that of its its object. Whatever it apprehends, it is something existing.
Whatever it apprehends is existing phenomena. So so that we number three in the very beginning, like we divide it. So to the consciousness or the mind, we divide it into three. That is like the conceptual mind or conceptual consciousness. And then second one is non conceptual, non mistaken consciousness.
So so non conceptual, non mistaken consciousness as a as a definition. No, that is not mistaken with respect to its, what you call, appearing objects. So, it’s appearing object here.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.