Nature of the Mind — 03 Lo Rig

46 min · 2,673 words · 1995 · Buddha House Adelaide

Nature of the Mind (Geshe Dhawa Gyaltsen)
Nature of the Mind (Geshe Dhawa Gyaltsen)
Nature of the Mind — 03 Lo Rig
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 46-minute session on the nature of the mind, Geshe Dhawa Gyaltsen explores the Buddhist philosophical framework of valid perception. He begins by contextualizing the teaching within the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life, explaining how non-virtuous actions rooted in the three poisons and self-clinging keep us in saṃsāra, but how training in renunciation, bodhicitta, and right view can free us. He then turns to the technical heart of the session: valid and invalid perception. He outlines four types of direct perception—sensory, mental, self-knowing, and yogic—and explains the role of uncommon empowering conditions in generating valid awareness. He distinguishes direct perception (non-conceptual, non-mistaken) from inferential perception, and divides direct perception into valid perception, subsequent perception, and non-ascertaining perception, illustrating each with concrete examples. The teaching concludes by exploring three ways mental direct perception is generated: alternating production, simultaneous production of three types, and production at the end of a continuum. Suited to practitioners with background in Buddhist epistemology.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 03 Lo Rig.mp3

UUID: c8321fe4-406e-48fc-94bb-3e3969ba8a60

Teacher: Geshe Dhawa Gyaltsen

Collection: Nature of the Mind (Geshe Dhawa Gyaltsen)

Date: 1995 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide

Duration: 46.1 minutes

Words: ~2,669

Quoting the line from the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life. It says in the line that the suffering that we experience is caused by those non-virtuous actions that we have done. And because of that, because of those non-virtuous actions, it causes or leads us to take rebirth into the lower realms. So this is what the Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life explains. And what non-virtuous actions that we do or what we commit — it’s like those of the three poisons.

The three poisons plus the other like those of the self-cherishing thought or the ego. And also the conception of truly existent person and truly existent phenomena. Like these are the things, these are the conceptions that cause or create — cause us to create the three poisons, and that leads us to the lower states. So these non-virtuous actions cause us to remain in saṃsāra, but then is it possible for us to become free from this state of saṃsāra? Then, yes, it is possible.

And looking to those past enlightened beings, like those of the enlightened beings of the three times, or like there are many enlightened beings that we can count — like those of the thirty-five Buddhas. And there are many other enlightened beings, those who are free from cyclic existence. And how they become free, how they freed themselves from this cyclic existence, or saṃsāra, is by training themselves in the three principal paths. That is the path of renunciation, bodhicitta, and the right view. So training on the path of renunciation, bodhicitta, and right view, that counteracts all types of delusions that we have.

And the delusions that we have are something that can be removed. Like, looking to our mind, the nature of our mind is something pure and clear. So those delusions that stay together with our mind are something that can be removed. And it can be done through the practice of the three capable beings. And like for the study, like those of studying the ten bhūmis or the ten grounds and the five paths, like gradually one comes to remove all types of delusions.

So right now, today, we have this precious human body, which we gained — this precious human body which is very rare and difficult to be found. And not only that, we also have met with the pure teachings which is very difficult to meet with. And teachings that come from Buddha and that come from Lama Tsongkhapa, which are very, very difficult for us to meet with. And so all of these necessary things that we have now. And with having all this, set your mind or set your motivation saying that I will train in these teachings in order to achieve the full enlightened state for the sake of all other sentient beings.

So now coming back to the topic that we talked about last time, we’re talking about the valid perception or the valid and invalid perceptions. So the explanation of valid — what valid means — there are different explanations. So according to the four different schools, that of the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika and Cittamātra, their explanations are the same, of what valid perception means. They have the same explanations.

And then there’s the Madhyamaka explanation and the Prāsaṇgika explanation of the same. So the explanations that the Madhyamaka explains and the explanation that Prāsaṇgika explains on valid perception are the same. So this valid perception, if you divide it, can be divided into two groups or two types. The one, direct valid perception, and another one, inferential valid perception. So in these two it can be divided.

So the direct valid perception — direct perception — is that which one doesn’t have to rely on reasonings. So like to see a vase or to perceive a vase directly. If you have a direct perception of a vase, that means you don’t have to rely on reasonings. So then the inferential perception or cognition is that which you come to experience through giving a reasoning. And how — for example, like by seeing the smoke on the top of a mountain, you can prove there is a fire.

So by giving this kind of reasoning, you come to experience or perceive the inferential perception or cognition. So they are like two. For direct perception and inferential perception, there are distinctions that are made also with these two. So what here is meant as a direct perception is that which is non-conceptual and non-mistaken — awareness that is non-conceptual and non-mistaken. That is what valid perception is. So with this direct perception, within that, it can be divided into four different kinds.

That of the sense direct perception and mental direct perception. And then there’s another one called self-knowing direct perception. And then the fourth one is yogic direct perception. These are the four kinds of direct perceptions. So then the first one, that of the sense direct perception — as a meaning, what it means is that the sense direct perception is that which is generated through its uncommon empowering condition — or there’s another translation they have also, they call it dominant condition.

So it is generated out of that — that kind of awareness which is non-mistaken and non-conceptual, free from conceptuality and non-mistaken awareness — that which is generated through its uncommon empowering condition or through its dominant condition. That is what sense direct perception means. So this uncommon empowering condition — for the eye consciousness, the physical eye sense power is what is the uncommon empowering condition. Physical — like the eye sense power.

And like this, the uncommon empowering condition applies the same with other senses like that of the nose sense organ. That is the uncommon empowering condition of nose consciousness. Uncommon empowering condition.

Or there’s another translation which they call it dominant condition. So that applies the same with other senses too. So it’s like the dominant condition — the eye sense organ — that is like, sort of, that’s the form, that’s something physical that we’re talking. So that is in the eye there’s a form or physical thing which causes the eye consciousness to be generated — the function of eye consciousness makes it work through this dominant condition. So this uncommon empowering condition or the dominant condition, which is the physical eye sense power.

Eye sense power is something physical but it’s not seen by our eye consciousness. It is only perceived by the mental consciousness. And that is what also Geshe-la explained last time. So then, again, we also talk about the same thing — the uncommon empowering conditions of the mental consciousness, the direct mental consciousness. And for that mental consciousness, what we posit as an uncommon empowering condition is that of just the immediate — like the prior moment of apprehending whatever you are apprehending.

Like, for example, with the vase — the second moment — like, for the second moment of mental perception, the uncommon empowering condition of the mental consciousness perceiving a vase — just perceiving a vase — is the first moment, or the prior moment, the earlier moment of that consciousness, which is known as the uncommon empowering condition. So of mental direct perception there are many different moments of mental direct perceptions. So the first moment of mental direct perception is the uncommon empowering condition of the second moment of mental direct perception.

So then for the third moment of mental direct perception, the second moment of perception is the uncommon empowering condition of the third moment of mental direct perception. So for direct valid perception, again, it can be divided. And it can be divided into three types, three kinds. The first one, valid perception. The second one is that of subsequent perception.

And then third, it is again divided — there is another division of a mind which is known as: appears but not ascertained, or it is like a non-ascertaining perception. These three are the divisions of direct perception. The direct valid perception, the first one — the valid perception which is direct — is the direct perception which is valid. That is like when you apprehend a form. When you apprehend a form, the first moment of apprehending a form is a valid direct perception.

So then the second moment and so on — all the other moments like second and third and fourth moments of apprehending a form — these are all subsequent perceivers, or just subsequent direct perceivers. So then the third one — appears but not ascertained, which is the third type — another translation is also translated as non-ascertaining perception. And for this one, as an example: the apprehending of a form to a person who is sort of completely attracted to a sound. And that apprehending of form — the apprehending of the form to a person who is completely attracted to a sound —

Sound, like a sound. That is like the third kind of direct perception which is appears but not ascertained. So that form appears but is not completely ascertained. So as another example, for example, in a crowd, if one is completely attracted or distracted by a pleasant song, by a sweet song, a pleasant song. At that very moment, if someone talks to you, you hear what they are saying.

Just that’s the sound you hear, but because your attention is completely on the song, you don’t understand the meaning. You don’t get — you are not aware of what he or she has said to you. So this is what is like which appears but not ascertained. So now we go to the mental direct perception. So again, mental direct perception — as a definition or as a meaning, mental direct perception is known as: free from conceptuality, non-mistaken awareness that which is generated through its uncommon empowering conditions.

That is like, again, the same thing as before. So which is non-mistaken in its meaning. Like here, mistaken — like you see — which you are mistaken as to its meaning of whatever it is.

It’s not clear. So it’s true, and it’s not mistaken in its meaning. For example, with the vase — when you have the conception of a vase, it is mistaken. How is it mistaken? Because when the conception of the vase appears to us, the sound of the word “vase” and the vase — the sound “vase” and the vase — appears together at the same time.

The vase itself and the sound “vase” — when you have a perception of a vase, it appears that it’s just the name, the term “vase,” and the vase itself sort of together at once. And that is like — that’s known as one of the conceptions. And this kind of appearance is known as mistaken. So now we go back again to the mental direct perception, which has its uncommon empowering condition or dominant conditions that we already explained before. And for mental direct perception, again it is divided into two.

So there are two: one division is that which is explained according to this context. And then another is that of the general explanation — sort of common and uncommon explanation of mental direct perception. So the uncommon — I want to say, uncommon explanations of — the uncommon divisions of the mental direct perception — its definition is like the sort of the same, it’s almost the same as the first one. It’s like almost the same as the definition of mental perception. So that is: free from conceptuality and non-mistaken — and non-mistaken other-knower — that which is generated through its uncommon empowering condition.

Of this. So this is just of this context, which is referring to the mental direct perception of this context. And I missed one, like, here. You have the — one another word which is “other-knower.” Like let me just go up from the beginning: which is free from conceptuality and non-mistaken other-knower which is generated through its uncommon empowering conditions of this context.

So this other-knower here means that which mainly observes outer phenomena, not as in personal internal — not as in being — that which mainly observes outer phenomena. And then there’s another one, the self-knower, which means mainly observing the internal, or mainly observing the being. And then for the enlightened beings or for Buddhas, like their perception of outer phenomena and inner phenomena — they are like — for their direct mental perception, for enlightened beings or for Buddha, their direct — I would say better — perception can perceive both outer and inner. Both outer and inner phenomena.

Now how, according to this context, is the mental direct perception generated? This will explain. So there are three ways — there are explanations which are explained in three different ways — that one can generate this mental direct perception. And one is explained that generating or production — there’s a translation it says alternating production, or like generating alternatively. And another, the second is that production of three types.

There’s like a sort of three things which sort of generate at once. And then the third one is that production only at the end of its continuum. These are three kinds that are used. So the alternating generation — or the alternative production, there’s two translations: alternating production or alternative generation. So this one — this mental direct perception is generated — is that first with the example of a vase, first we have the first moment of eye consciousness perceiving or apprehending the vase.

And then right after that the second moment is where you have the first moment of mental direct perception. And then when you have the second moment of eye consciousness apprehending the vase, then the second moment of mental direct perception apprehending the vase — so it comes alternately in that way. That’s how one perceives a vase. So like we talked about the uncommon empowering conditions of mental direct perception — so here in this example, like first when you have an eye consciousness apprehending the vase, that is like the first moment — that becomes the uncommon empowering condition of the mental direct perception of the first moment, like subsequently right after that.

You got it? So then the second way of the mental perception is that of — and that is the generation of three types or the production of three kinds. So this is like the second moment of apprehending a form or whatever object it is. And that plus the first moment of the mental direct perception. And then the self-knowing direct perception which experiences these two, which experiences these two.

These three sort of happen at the same time. And that is what the three types of generation or the production of three kinds is. The first one is the second moment of apprehending the form. And the second is that of the first moment of mental direct perception. And the third is the self-knowing direct perception, which experiences these two.

So then likewise, again, how it works with other things is that of like the third moment of the sense consciousness perceiving a form or apprehending a form. And then the second moment of mental direct perception perceiving a form, and the self-knowing direct perception that experiences these two sort of again comes together at once. Like the first one. So then the third one — the third type of production or generation of mental direct perception is — what was that? Production only at the end of its continuum.

That is the third one. And this is how it is generated, or how it is produced — it is said that just

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
three poisons dug sum (Tib)
Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
valid awareness pramana (Skt); tshema (Tib)
A new non-deceptive cognition. There are two types: valid perception, such as the eye consciousness seeing a flower, and valid inference, such as inferring fire from seeing smoke. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top