General Teachings

2 h 4 min · 7,245 words · 9 June 2012 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
Other recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
General Teachings
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 124-minute talk, Ilia S. Durovic explores the philosophical foundations of emptiness through classical Buddhist commentaries, focusing particularly on the Yogacāra-Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school and Kamalaśīla’s refutation of external objects. He begins by distinguishing how different philosophical schools understand the selflessness of phenomena across the five aggregates and twelve sources of perception. Durovic then guides practitioners through the progression from Cittamātra philosophy—which denies external existence but posits mind as truly real—to the Madhyamaka view that even consciousness lacks inherent identity. He illustrates how mistaken perceptions arise from mental projections and distorted conceptions, drawing on Aaron Beck’s psychiatric observations to show how anger exaggerates negativity and attachment magnifies attractiveness. The teaching culminates in Durovic’s explanation of how combining analytical meditation with focused absorption gradually dissolves dualistic appearance, ultimately leading to direct insight into emptiness. He emphasizes that this understanding, when merged with bodhicitta and compassion, forms the complete path to Buddhahood. The talk is pitched at practitioners with foundational Buddhist study, combining classical scholarship with practical meditation instruction and contemporary psychological insight.

File metadata (for organising)

File: Introductory Buddhist Teachings; June 9, 2012 (Day 3 of 3) Video (HQ) Teachin….mp3

UUID: e336ab6b-3381-4c47-9eed-be2321311e20

Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic

Collection: General Teachings

Date: 2012 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~7,273

So just as we have discussed yesterday, the the within the the philosophical traditions of Buddhism, the philosophical schools, there are differences. There are different traditions. From the point of view of the physical philosophical views, we can have we have all these different philosophical schools. And so yesterday, we explained about the I explained about the selflessness of persons. And then now we have come to the explanation of the selflessness of phenomena, which starts in the text from this part where it says meditation on the selflessness of phenomena should also be done in the following manner.

Phenomena in short are included in the five aggregates, the five there’s 12 sources of perception, and the 18 elements, the physical aspects of it, the aggregates, sources of perception, and so forth. And so so all that are produced from causes and conditions, in other words, all that are composite phenomena come under the five the the different aggregates as well. And then here, the Kamalaśīla is following the Madhyamaka school called the Yogachara-Svatāntrika Madhyamaka School. And so because of that, he follows in his philosophy. He accepts the the non externality of things, that things do not exist externally, which is the the assertion of the Yogacāra school.

And so on the one hand, he accepts this, and then the the this helps to reduce one’s clinging to the externality of things, the external things. And so and then on top of that, he also accepts that the the Madhyamaka philosophical assertion, which is to say that’s the mind. In the Chitamantra, they say although that the the things do not exist externally, but then the mind or the consciousness has its true existence. And so from the point of the Madhyamaka, even that mind is without any true existence. And so whatever exists has no true existence at all.

And so they are empty of true And so first here to go over the the Cittamātra philosophy philosophical assertion, which rejects the externality of things. They say that, of course, when you look at things, we see that they function differently. They have their own identity and different functions and so forth. And so that shows that there is something out in the things themselves. But then, the the what they say is that things are not merely conceptually imputated, designated, but there must be something in them.

And so when they try to look for that thing in the different things, they say that if things were merely designated by our conception, by our thought, then they would be like anything anything could be existent when you think about something. For example, the horn of a rabbit, which does not exist, it has to exist because it’s it could be merely designated or imputed by our mind. And therefore, that is the they are not possible. And so they say that the because of this, the because things have some functions in themselves, therefore, the form, sound, and so forth do exist in in some kind of a way with the essence. Although there is nothing which exists externally, but when they try to make the analyze the things for for form and so forth, they say that they cannot be found externally because nothing when you break them up into smaller parts, there’s nothing that you can actually point to as being this or that in the subtlest particles.

And so down to the subtlest particles, there’s no partless particles, indivisible partless particles as well. And therefore, they say there is nothing externally existing. Although, we can see that the things have we can talk about the whole and its parts. But then, the the we if you if you without end doing any analysis into the parts and the whole, then you you will see that there is a whole a a thing there which has its parts. But then if you analyze critically analyze and try to find that whole and its parts, then you will not be able to find them.

And so they say, when you do this kind of analysis, then the the whole and the parts cannot be found. The whole cannot be found in any of the parts pervading in its parts. And so from this analysis, what they conclude is that there is no external existence and nothing exists externally. And therefore, although they say this, they still do not deny the existence of form and sound and so forth.

So and and nonetheless, they do not deny the existence of form, sound, and so forth. But how they exist is according to the Cittamātra philosophy. It’s merely as as the manifestation of the seeds or the imprints that are left on the mind of these things that we see and feel, can touch and so forth. And so within this the the imprints, they talk about different kinds of imprints, some imprints which are like the imprints for the designation of things, the the names, and imprints for clinging to self and so forth. And so the the form and so forth are the the the manifestations of those imprints which arise as the consciousness that see them perceive them arise.

And so therefore, in this way, the, the form and the perception that it which perceives it are will come from the same seed or same imprint, and therefore, they are non dual, in substance. And so the text goes on to say that this is because when they are broken into subtle particles and nature of the I’m sorry. This is because when they are broken into subtle particles and the nature of the parts of these subtle particles is indivisibly examined, no definite identity can be found. And then it goes on to say that, with regard to the imprints, the immature beings by the power of their attachment from the from time immemorial to the reality of physical forms and so forth, mind itself is perceived objectively outside as physical forms and other objects in the same way as the contents of a dream are perceived while dreaming. Yet, ultimately, all of these physical forms and other objects are nothing other than aspect of the mind.

Thinking this, reflect on the thoughts that all of this, the whole of the three realms is only mind. And once you understand that, all the phenomena you have examined are therefore mind alone. If you examine the mind, you’ll be examining the nature of all phenomena. Thinking this way, examine the nature of the mind.

Rags. And then all of a sudden, one fruits course, when you see the fruits, I mean, it’s not yours yet. And so because of that, when one of the fruits falls on the ground, you may say, oh, no. But then after buying the fruit, and if the fruit actually falls from, off your hands on the ground, then you’ll feel much more, sad and sorry for, that happening. And so that shows that has become your fruit now after buying it.

And therefore, you have some some greater attachment to it. And so this shows that we have we we have this kind of feelings towards things in relation to the self or the person. So meditation on selflessness of persons can help to reduce this kind of attachment. When you say that, oh, this self that I I I think that there is an I here, but then it doesn’t actually exist in the way it appears to me. And so it helps in this way to reduce your attachment to the self and other things.

And then not only that, if you could also think that the external things have no true existence. I mean, it’s only my perception, my projection that they have some kind of autonomous existence out there. And then, that also helps to reduce your attachments towards the external things. And so in this way, the from the when you when you think about things and yourself from the point of view of the Cittamātra philosophical position, then you can reduce to a certain degree the attachments to externality of things. But then what actually remains according to the Cittamātra view is that the mind is something truly existent.

And therefore, although things do not have external existence, still the mind has its true existence. And therefore, from the Madhyamaka point of view, they they would say that although okay. To the Chitamatras, they say they can say that, okay. It’s okay to say that you see what you assert that there’s no externality of things. But then what about the mind, which you posit as being truly existent?

And so to this, the the the author here goes on to say the answer. It says, in the ultimate sense, the mind too cannot be real. So this is what Cittamātra is actually thinking as being real. And how can the mind that affirms only the false nature of physical form and fall and so forth and appears in various aspects be real? Just as physical form and so forth are false since the mind does not separate from physical forms and so forth, which are also false, it too is false.

Just as physical form and so forth possess various aspects and their identities are neither one nor many. Similarly, since the mind is not different from them, its identity too is neither one nor many. Therefore, the mind by nature is like an illusion. So here, the it’s the presentation is given from the point of view of the Chitamantra’s view by all while rejecting the Chitamantra’s view that the mind has true existence. And so it says the mind cannot be truly existent.

Just as the external phenomena do not exist when you try to find their identity their true identity in them down to the slight smallest particles. Likewise, a mind cannot exist the way it it appears to exist to us. And so whether it’s the external phenomenon or the internal experiences that we have, it helps that when you think that there’s no externality of things nor the mind be has its any true existence, it helps to reduce our clinging to some kind of solidity or some kind of concrete form of external things as well as the mind. And then it’s the text goes on to say, analyze that just like just like the mind. The nature of all phenomena too is like an illusion.

In this way, the mind in this way, when the identity of the mind is fit specifically examined by wisdom in the ultimate sense, it is perceived neither within nor without. It is also not perceived in the absence of both. Neither the mind of the past nor that of the future nor that of the present is perceived. And so in this way, quotes, having said that the external things and and other people and so forth do not exist in in that we actually relate to and use do not exist in a truly independently. Truly, likewise, the experiences within ourselves also do not exist truly.

And so in this way, from the by using the Madhyamaka understanding of the mind itself also having no true existence as well as the things that we enjoy having no existence true existence, we can actually reduce this kind of clinging through such a way of existence of things, the way they appear to us, clinging to the way they appear to us. And so what then helps to also overcome is the wrong notion or wrong perception of things. And so Nāgārjuna says that liberation comes by ending or by overcoming completely the karma and disturbing emotions. And so when you end karma and disturbing emotions, you have reached that of nirvana or liberation. And then Nāgārjuna goes on to say that karma and delusions come from distorted conceptions.

And so the with regard to this distorted conceptions, of course, karma is brought about by our craving and grasping. And when having created the karma, through the the the craving and grasping, what you do is you reinforce the karma, and then you are reborn into another life, next life. So in this way, what he’s saying is that, you know, the the karma comes from the so the karma comes from delusions, the disturbing emotions, and these disturbing emotions in turn come from misconceptions or distorted views, distorted conceptions. And so with regard to this the the distorted conception, which gives rise to the different the the the delusions and which in turn gives rise to karma, What happens is one of this one of this western psychiatrist, a great renowned psychiatrist, perhaps, Beck,

So I I once met him when I he at that time, he was about 86 or something like that. And he said in in one of our meetings that when we are angry at somebody, we see the person as being totally negative. But then if you carefully check, he said, 90% of that negativity in the person is actually our own mental projection. So, of course, people have their negative sides or bad sides and good sides. But then when we are angry at somebody, when we hate somebody, the the we project, I mean, totally this kind of negativity totally on the person and see the person totally bad and negative.

And similarly, when we are attached to somebody, we become totally attached because of we exaggerate the beauty or the attractiveness in that person completely. And therefore, we have this kind of mental projections which see with because of which we see either the person to be unattractive or attractive. And Nāgārjuna says, these these distorted conceptions come from the mental fabrications. So with regard to mental fabrications, what we have is the fabrication of for example, the how things appear to us as if they have some kind of true existence. Independent existence is one thing.

And then there is also the elaboration of all the multiplicity phenomena things. And there’s also the the elaboration of the duality of things, as well as the seeing things through what is known as generic image. So these can be considered as the duality or the mental fabrication or elaborations. And then this is overcome, Nāgārjuna says, through or by the understanding emptiness. And so in this line, Nāgārjuna’s line, the fourth line can be read either and according to Sanskrit reading, there are too many different readings.

One is that the emptiness through the understanding of emptiness, you can overcome the mental fabrications. And the another reading is that by by realizing emptiness, actually, what you can do is all the disturbing emotions actually, this the the fabric mental fabrication, the disturbing emotions actually dissipate into that the nature or the the the suchness of the mind. So there are these two different ways of interpreting this fourth line according to the Sanskrit reading. And so when you are able to see that there is nothing there which exists truly, what this can help is that you find nothing to be clung to. And then this can help to reduce your attachment and hatred or anger to I mean, in a very forceful way.

So just a filler here. What Aaron Beck, the psychiatrist, has said is actually very true according to Nāgārjuna also because he says all these different misconceptions that we have come from this mental fabrications. Think about the we talk about those of the four distorted ways of looking at things such as in our existence, we have this way of looking at something which is impure as being pure, something which is in the nature of suffering as see seeing that as in the nature of bliss or happiness, and then also seeing something which is impermanent as being permanent, and something which has no self as having some self or Ātman. And so these are the four distorted ways of looking at the realities. And so but when you actually check whether things have some permanence or whether our, body and so forth are in the pure state or whether there is a self or

Whether there is real, true happiness in saṃsāra and so forth, of course, you’ll find that they do not, have this kind of existence the way they appear to us to have. And so the perfection of wisdom. In the of wisdom sutras, it is said after the Buddha goes through all kinds of topics beginning with the form and the and the form, sound, and so forth. And then he goes through the different part systems, the five five fold parts and what is outwards and so forth, and as well as the 10 bodhisattva grounds. And also, the 37 factors tending towards the the enlightenment and so forth.

And then he finally comes to the Buddha’s the resultant state of Buddhahood, where the Buddha is qualified by the 10 powers and for fearlessnesses and so forth. And so, in this way, first he presents all these different topics from the from form up to the omniscient mind, the resultant state of omniscient mind. And then and at the end of all these enumerations of these different phenomena, he says, all these two are merely name, merely designations, mere merely labels, and they do not have any true identity of their own. And so he doesn’t right away say that all these phenomena are empty by nature, but he says these are merely named and so forth. So this has its own significance.

So because when we think about all these things that are related to us, that have some effect and influence in our life, after having said that these all these things are there and these are empty and so forth, then the Buddha when the Buddha says they do not have any essence, of their own, but they are merely named and so forth, What it shows is that they he’s not denying the existence of these things form up to omniscient state of mind. And so what he’s saying is that if you carefully check these things, then you will not be able to find anything in that you can pinpoint as being this and that. And so now in other words, the Buddha leads us through the conventionality of things, understanding the conventionality of things, and then through that lead us to the understanding of the ultimate reality of them. And so, likewise, the Buddha Nāgārjuna says, without relying on the conventional nature of the things, conventionality of things, the ultimate cannot be realized. And so when you say there’s the goal there’s no identities, things are identity less or things are without self and so forth.

Of course, if there is nothing there, of course, we do not have to talk about the the these being empty of any essence or anything like that. But because the things are there, therefore, the the way they exist is different from where they look and where they appear to us. And so, therefore, the the what we are saying here is that things do not have any true existence as such. True. So the the the this is how they exist.

But the way they look to us, where they appear to us is that they have some kind of a independent true existence. And so that’s not the way it is. And therefore, this is what the the Sūtra is trying to get at. And in the text here also, that in the text it says, through such analysis, the beginning of the mind is ultimately not seen. The end of the mind is also the end of the mind is ultimately not seen, and the middle of the mind is ultimately not seen.

So if you were to look at the things that are outside I mean, the things like form and so forth, of course, they exist. And but then what he’s what Kamalaśīla is trying to say is that we they do not exist the way we actually project the the some kind of existence in them. So ultimately, if you try to analyze them, then you will not find them ultimately. So that’s the meaning. And then on page 45, it and then next it says, in this way, when the person does not ultimately see the identity of all phenomena through the wisdom through the the through the through wisdom, he will not analyze whether physical form is permanent and permanent empty or not contaminated or not contaminated, produced or non produced, and existent or nonexistent.

And he goes on to say, those who do not meditate on wisdom by analyzing the entity of things specifically, but merely meditate on the elimination of mental activity cannot avert conceptual thought and also cannot They cannot realize identitylessness because they lack the light of wisdom. So what this is trying to refute is that we had already talked about this earlier also. There were some Hashang, the Chinese monks who in Tibet in those days during the king the Tri Song Detsen’s time that they they think that by stopping all thoughts, by meditating on thoughtlessness alone, one can attain Buddhahood. And so with regard to thoughtlessness or being free from all elaborations, I mean, mental elaborations, I mean, there are very various ways of actually understanding it. And for example, in Nāgārjuna’s opening verses of homage to the Buddha, he says he he has this mention he he mentions that all these are devoid of or pacified of all elaborations.

So here, the pacification of all elaborations means that it shows, of course, that of a thoughtlessness. But the thoughtlessness that he’s talking about is different from the what the Hashangs are saying. The Hoshangs are saying that all kinds of thoughts must be stopped in order to reach enlightenment. So not thinking about even anything is the way to that omniscience. But then that’s what is rejected here.

And so with regard to this the the non fabrication of things or things being devoid of any mental fabrications, the seventh Dalai Lama also says. There’s all these things in the saṃsāra and nirvana are mere mere designate merely designated by the mind. But if you analyze the mind itself, that also is devoid of arising and cessation. And therefore, he says, Emma Ho. How how wonderful, I mean, this to see this true natural state of the mind.

And then he also goes on to say that these different experiences of external and internal phenomena, all these dissipate into the dissipate just like the the the cloud dissipates into the space and and the autumn in the autumn here, he’s talking about the autumn sky in in Tibet. Just as the autumn the clouds dissipate into the sky, autumn sky, likewise, the the mind and its nature become indivisible. And within that, all the experiences and impressions dissolve. So here here, when he talks about this, I mean, when he says this, he’s actually referring to the the indivisibility of the mind and its nature. Means that the mind, of course, has the nature of being empty by nature.

And so when you see the empty nature of the mind itself, that is the main focus of our meditation, which is also done in the Chagchen, the Mahāmudrā meditation as well as Dzogchen meditation. So you use the nature of the mind, the reality of the mind itself as the focus of your meditation. So when this nature of mind being empty of any elaboration is always been there and as the nature of the mind itself. So when you meditate on it, what you are actually doing is you’re actually being you’re trying to see your own mind’s nature, the true nature of it. And this is, when you’re totally absorbing it, then all kinds of elaborations, whether it’s mental elaborations or the different appearances of phenomena and so forth, all dissolve and, into this, the suchness of the mind.

A friend of mine once did some meditation for years. And then after the completing his meditation, he told me that after coming out of the meditation, it seems that his mind actually turned out to be duller than it used to be. And then I and then what I said to him was that perhaps perhaps this may be because you emphasize too much on the meditation on thoughtlessness and not emphasize not actually doing the analytical meditation that much. And so I told him that it’s important to for you to do both analytical meditation and focusing meditation together. They’re combining them.

And another friend of mine also had said that some people have after doing some meditation for years, having done that meditation, then they when they come out of it, they seem to be rather kind of insensitive for things or they don’t seem to have any kind of emotion. And so perhaps that also may be the case that in this case also, they lack the combination of both the the the focusing and meditation as well as analytical meditation. And so what we need is when you do when you do meditation or any kind of practice of, for example, cultivation of bodhicitta or cultivation of wisdom, realizing emptiness. In any of these practice, we you you have to be holistic in your approach. Otherwise, you fall into traps and you’re I mean, if you’re not able to you fall into some kind of a pitfall.

And so we should always avoid any pitfalls when you do meditation. And so, this is a very important thing to keep in mind, when we do meditation. So combining the method and the skillful means, both are I mean, is very important. Then you’ll be able to overcome or pacify all the mental elaborations. But in the beginning, of course, when you do meditation on such things, emptiness, what what there may be the appearances of things.

But as you keep doing your meditation more and more, you you progress further and further, then there will be a time when the the the sense consciousnesses, eyes and ears and so forth, will stop functioning. And then, call it, when you push yourself further along the the meditation, for example, in the meditation or emptiness, then there will be a time when you realize emptiness in the mode of generic image. And then when you progress further, when you reach, for example, the Mahāyāna path of preparation, there are the four stages as explained before. The you will have less and less dualistic appearance with regard to emptiness. And as you progress along this path of preparation, the four stages, the the the and the dualistic appearance fades more and more.

And then you enter into the state where you are totally free from all dualistic appearances. You are in you have reached the path of seeing of Mahāyāna. So when you you see emptiness directly without having any kind of dual

istic appearances whatsoever. And so this is what is referred by this part of the text, and there is nothing to be thoroughly examined and observed. And you are free from expression and with no with single pointed single fundamental engagement, you automatically enter into meditation without exertion. And in the case of developing this kind of absorption and emptiness, It is similar to those of the the development of your experience that was explained before in in relation to developing Shamatha, the calm abiding meditation, where you place your mind in on the object, emptiness, and and on the on the on the object, and then you call continue to focus your mind on it. And then at some point, you don’t need to put much effort.

The mind stays on the object of focus rather effortlessly. But then there is a time when you actually try to put effort. It’s a wrong way of approaching or doing your meditation. You should not do any kind of apply any effort or you should not exert yourself where there’s no need for anything. So similarly, in this kind of meditation on emptiness, have to follow this same thing.

And and these can be as you go along the path, your meditation experience develops and deeper and deeper, and this can be tell told from your own experiences. And thus, it says thus, you very clearly meditate on suchness and abide in it. And so the text begins at the unification of unification of calm abiding and insight. When both are equally engaged, keep still effortlessly so long as there is no physical or mental discomfort. So one should actually, what this is saying is that one should meditate until one feels physically tired or mentally tired.

And so when you feel tired, you should not keep pushing yourself, but break meditation and take rest. And if physical and so having done some this single pointed meditation, what this is showing is basically that of the the single pointed meditation where you are completely absorbed in the suchness or the reality of things or emptiness. The this is called the the sky like absorption. And then when that happens, what happens is that all the the sensory perceptions do not function. And then it goes on to say the next passage says, take rest.

So when you feel tired, you should take rest. And here, this is about the the post meditation session. During post meditation session practices where you have to emphasize more on the the practices of the method side of the practice. For example, bodhicitta, compassion, giving, so forth. So what happens is when you having done your meditation on emptiness, your mind being totally absorbed, wherein your mind is has been totally absorbed in emptiness, You see how things truly exist, how things actually exist in reality.

And then when you come out of your meditation, because of the impact of that meditation, what you’ll be able see is that things do appear to have some kind of independent existence. So objective existence from their own side. But then from your own experience, you can confirm that there is no such a way of existence. They’re empty of such a way of existence. And therefore, because sentient beings torture themselves by clinging to the way things appear, to the appearance of things, although they don’t want suffering, they are causing themselves suffering.

Although they want happiness, they are not able to attain happiness because of not being able to create the causes for that. And therefore, there’s every reason that you feel compassion for these sentient beings For being in that kind of conditions where they create causes for suffering which they don’t want. And so the this is in fact possible that compassion in fact arises because you see that there’s a possibility of attaining liberation from all these disturbing emotions that are are within oneself. And through your own experience, you can see this is possible. And therefore, when you are able to confirm from your own experience that liberation is possible because there is an antidote, there’s a counter counteracting force which goes against these negative emotions.

And therefore, when you when you look at sentient beings, they are unable to understand this nature of things. The the way things exist, which is that they are they exist not objectively, but way of designation and so forth. But then, they’re they’re they’re not able to develop or cultivate the antidotes to their disturbing emotions as well. When so you you can actually feel that the great compassion towards all sentient beings who are actually tormented by suffering. And, you feel this suffering they undergo as being something unbearable, totally unbearable to you, and therefore, you feel great compassion towards them.

And then, the text, again, So it says to take rest. Again, in the same way, engaging the single point of concentration on the non appearance of all phenomena. If the mind is discouraged, then similarly take rest. Again, when you do some meditation and after taking rest, you again go into the meditation and so that you can do it more properly. And then after taking rest, you again go into meditation and in this way, you alternate between post meditation sessions.

This is the path of engaging in the union of calm abiding meditation and special insight. It focuses on the object of meditation conceptually and non-conceptually. And then it goes on to say, thus through the this progress, a yogi should meditate on suchness for an hour, a half, or half a session in the night, and so forth. And so what this goes through is actually that you you can stay in meditation for however long you want. No.

On meditation on emptiness. And later on, you have come to the part of how things can exist conventionally as well. And then the next passage is what is emptiness, possessing the best of all qualities. Oh, yeah. That issue would have been yeah.

So what this is saying is that you have to combine both the method and the wisdom together, being able by being able to see everything as in being in the nature of illusion and come out of meditation so that you combine So what has been covered was basically what it says is that the bodhisattvas do not renounce the saṃsāra because of their compassion, their total compassion towards all sentient beings who are suffering in the world, in this unit in saṃsāra. And the the because of their compassion, they remain in saṃsāra. But then that doesn’t mean that they are not able to see the faults of saṃsāra. They are able to see the faults of saṃsāra as well. But then while they see the faults of saṃsāra, which is mainly of the the saṃsāra is brought about by our ignorance of the true nature of things.

And our although they see that what ignorance actually holds on to is not there at all, not existent, even in conventional terms, they are able to still go beyond saṃsāra as well as nirvana. So just as Bhāvaviveka has said in this in his Essence of the Middle Way, and the text here also mentions the same thing.

So the text begins at in this way, that become familiar with the generosity and the skillful means that are dedicated dedicated to the swift and perfect accomplishment of enlightenment, having the essence of emptiness and great compassion. So this shows the the the the means by which you can reach the state of enlightenment. And then and then the next so up to this point, it shows that different parts that leads to the state of Buddhahood, the the fruition. And then with regard to this, the fruition, it says in the text, those who have become familiar with compassion, skillful means, and the awakening mind of bodhicitta in this way will undoubtedly excel in this life. Buddhas and bodhisattvas will always be seen in dreams and so forth.

And so what this talks about is that when you have the very special experience of the realization of both the skillful means and the understanding of emptiness or the means and emptiness, then one is always happy. And so in in this case, there’s no greater means to to bring about some happiness within yourself, no greater fortitude or to to have courage to work for others than than of bodhicitta. So in other words, if you have self confidence, then you will have happiness within yourself. And then you will have courage to work for others, and you’ll be fearless and without anxiety and so forth. And so in the practice of bodhisattva yana, one can also go to the extent of praying and to having this determination to remain in saṃsāra as long as sentient beings remain.

As the prayer in Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra, the guide to the bodhisattva way of life says, as long as space remains and doers, as long as space essential beings remain to that extent, may I too remain to dispel the misery of the world. And also in the Guru Puja, Lama Choepa by Pänchen Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen, it says that there is this verse which mentions that for each and every sentient beings, may I be able to endure the the the fire of hell. Even if I if even if I need to stay in the hell realm, in the fire to the hell realm of fire for as long as that in order to complete my practice of the to perfect my joyous effort. And then when you engage in bodhisattva practices, of course, you will have that kind of courage and determination to work for others. But then sometimes you might feel and and to the little bit and like discouraged.

And when these kind of things happen, there’s also an inspiration that is given in bodhis in the guide to bodhisattva way of life where it says that which sensible person would not ride the horse of bodhicitta, which leads you from bliss to bliss without feeling any despondency or fatigue. And so when you think about these lines, I mean, it will give you more courage and inspiration to work for the others. And so if it’s a matter of whether you think about these lines, I mean, these practices or not. Otherwise, I mean, of course, the great bodhisattva practices are really amazing to it only where you you only think of benefiting others. But then as a byproduct of it, what you gain is your own fulfillment of your own goal as well.

So just as Tsongkhapa has said, although you think of benefiting others, you think of others, but then as a result of thinking of it about others’ well-being, you also fulfill the your own goal. Meditate on compassion, skillful means, and the awakening mind of bodhicitta for a long time with great admiration. The mind stream will gradually become thoroughly purified and ripened. Then like producing fire by rubbing together pieces of wood, you will accomplish your meditation on the perfect reality. You will thus achieve an extremely clear knowledge of the supreme phenomena from free from conceptual elaborations, the transcendent wisdom, free from the impeding nets of conceptual thought.

This wisdom of ultimate bodhicitta is stainless like an unwavering butter lamp undisturbed by the wind. Thus, such a mind in the entity of ultimate bodhicitta is included within the path of seeing . And perhaps the selfless nature of all phenomena. So what this shows is that of the ultimate bodhicitta, the understanding of emptiness directly. And then next, it goes on to say, through this achievement, you enter into the path focusing on the reality of things and then you are then born in the family of the Tathagatas.

You are you answer the stainless state of bodhisattva, turn away from all wandering states, abide in the suchness of bodhisattvas and attain the first bodhisattva level. And then you can find more details of these advantages in text on 10 spiritual levels. So the text goes on to mention the 10 Bodhisattva levels grounds. Prayers through to the end of this passage with ends with sentence. Everyone should endeavor to actualize these qualities.

So this shows the ultimate goal that we have to reach, which is buddhahood. The ultimate result of buddhahood and how you attain that. And so right in the beginning of the text, it said that one should in order to reach buddhahood, one should have compassion as the root, The great compassion as the root, and then one has to practice the six perfections, such as the perfection of generosity, morality, and so forth. But then mainly, the text emphasizes on the cultivation of the I mean, particularly, the the cultivation of Shamatha and Vipashyana. And so through this, the Buddha Buddhahood.

So with this, we end the teaching on this the middle stages of meditation. So having received the teaching from me, you should not leave this book just on on the side of your I mean, just on the side somewhere and not do anything about it. You should read the text over and over again and try to integrate the the the the content of this text within yourself and try to apply within within yourself. And then in order to gain more certitude about the what is mentioned in this text by Kamalaśīla, you can also read other texts to help you understand better and in deeper way, such as great writings by great masters from the Nālānda University and of ancient India, such as books like Bodhicaryāvatāra by Śāntideva and the Mūlamadhyamakakārikā by Nāgārjuna, and also texts such as Bhāvaviveka’s Madhyamaka Hridaya and Tarkajvala, which are the root text and its auto-commentary. And so whichever text I mean, the language these are available in, for example, Sanskrit or Hindi or whichever language you read, you should read these books as well to gain more certitude about their practices of the path.

And, of course, we need material development. Material development is necessary, but then not we should not pursue material comfort at the expense of these great writings of the great masters, your own ancestors, like, from the Nālānda University. They so you should if you leave at the x if you pursue your material development and material progress at the expense of these writings of the great ancestors, it’s quite sad. Then when you actually sit down for meditation in the morning or in in your daily life, just bring up in your mind the image of Buddha, and you can do that on a daily basis. And then when you have quite a good image of the Buddha in your mind, then you can sit down with them and doing by doing the the seven limb practice, such as offering and so forth.

And then you you should sit down and develop bodhicitta, generate bodhicitta within yourself. So when you think about the buddha, buddha is someone who has reached the full enlightenment. How he has reached that is by practicing love, compassion, understanding, emptiness, and so forth. And so when you think about that resultant state or the of buddhahood, I mean, you and how someone became becomes a buddha, I mean, naturally, you would also think of creating the causes which bring that that state about. And then having meditated on bodhicitta, which is wishing to become enlightened for the benefit of all sentient beings and doing meditation on Buddha and taking care of the causes which leads that compassion and so forth, then you can do meditation on emptiness.

And at the end of that meditation, you can actually dedicate the merits that you have gained. And of course, during the day in the morning, this should be done. And then during daytime, you can indulge in all sorts of things, fighting with others and so forth. And in the end, in the evening, again, go over your meditation.

Key terms in this teaching

analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
dzogchen
Literally "Great Perfection", the practice to attain the mind's natural, primordial state. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top