1 h 55 min · 8,132 words · 21 October 2009 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 115-minute morning session on day two of a three-day teaching, the Dalai Lama addresses questions from the audience before turning to the Four Noble Truths. He opens with remarks on Buddhism in Indonesia and the historical links between Tibetan Buddhism and Southeast Asian traditions, then discusses his own evolution from a sectarian practice of spirit worship to a non-sectarian approach, explaining the investigation and reasoning that led him to abandon that practice. He takes questions on attending teachings across Tibetan Buddhist traditions, dealing with sleepiness during instruction, and using personal suffering to develop renunciation and compassion, emphasizing the distinction between actor and action when extending compassion to those who cause harm. In the latter part, he shifts to teaching the structure of the Four Noble Truths and their function, explaining how things lack inherent existence and how this emptiness makes liberation possible, then moves into practical instruction on the thirty-seven factors leading to enlightenment, particularly the four establishments of mindfulness of body, feeling, mind, and phenomena, with detailed guidance on meditation methods and reflection on the repulsive nature of the body to reduce attachment.
File metadata (for organising)
File: The ; 21 October 2009 (Day 2 of 3; Morning) Video (HQ) Teachings on Tibetan B….mp3
UUID: 5c46f6fb-23f2-4918-ba53-b9d19098091f
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Four Noble Truths
Date: 2009 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~8,124
Thank you. Thank you. Actually, this is the first time, here hearing Heart Sūtra in Indonesian. First time. Of course, I think many people may feel a little bit surprised.
Indonesia is the was the the biggest Muslim country. I think the number of Muslim, I think first, Indonesia, then second, India. So but in Indonesia, a thousand years ago, once the Buddhism, I think in some part, maybe some part of the modern Indonesia, I think once very much flourished Buddhism. So like and some important Buddhist relics still, we can see there. And then we Tibetan, Tibetan Buddhism also is to have some connection, the Indonesian Buddhism because they I think tenth and eleventh century, around eleventh century, a teacher Atisha from Bengal came to Tibet, and he, as I said, start another or should they no.
Actually, he, I think, helped revive revival or, I don’t know, some kind of refreshment about Buddhism. Because the last few century last, I think, one or two centuries, there’s a lot of damage in Buddhism. So helped lot to revive that. So his main guru is Indonesian. So the history says from Bengal went to then they call.
One part of Thailand also, there is one area they call. But you see, his the Tibetan sort of literature mentioned when he traveled to the Suvarnadvīpa, the eighteen months it took eighteen months by boat. So then the Suvarnadvīpa part of Thailand, a very close from Sri Lanka. So most probably that the Indonesian at the Java site or this ITD site like that. So therefore, the actually receive intense intense sort of meditation with Lama Serlingpa in Indonesia.
Then eventually, even he received one sort of prediction from Lama Serlingpa that this Indonesian lama is your future. Lama is mentioned, your future, a place called land of snow. There, you can help. You can also, you can care you can spread Buddhadharma, including my teaching. So there are some connection like that.
So I’m very pleased here, Heart Sūtra recite by, Indonesian, an Indonesian language. Recently, some Muslim friend in even in Arab showing some interest about my approach, non sectarian sort of approach about compassion, about moral ethics. So some of my Muslim friend in Arab already is a day writing something. I think soon we will publish like that. One Palestinian Muslim, he he already translated some of my book.
So from some of his friend, even he received some criticism like that. But he he carries continuously to see this some sort of translation like that. So in any way but basically, I always believe religion religious faith is something very much related with emotion. And also, rigid religion also is a much influenced the local cultural heritage. So therefore, it is much safer and much better to keep one’s own religious faith.
In Muslim area, much better keep Muslim. And Judeo Christian sort of faith I mean, area where Judeo Christian faith isn’t sort of main or main main tradition and much safer. Remain with your traditional faith. That’s much safer. I often was telling one story.
In early sixty, there’s one Tibetan family. Actually, the husband was Tibetan lay official of Tibetan government with his wife and few children escaped from Tibet because he he posted somewhere close to the border. So he can easily he said, brought with his children or wife and children like that. So then soon, the husband passed away and wife and few children remain, very young children, very difficulties at that time. All Tibetan refugee community, then at that time refugees, you see some work, road as a road worker.
Road building. Ah, road building. Ah, road building. Very difficult. So so at that time, some Christian friends actually, as soon as refugee refugee reach in in East India, the Catholic Relief sort of service, as well as some other, I think, one one church, one Christian headquarter in Geneva.
And anyway, there’s a many Christian organization. You see, a tremendous of help for relief at the time.
So some Christian friend, some Christian missionary, is to help that put that family. So in in, I think, late sixty or early sixty one maybe, around that, she she came seeing to see me. And she then she told me her story, very sad story. And then she mentioned Christian friend, they help immensely and also take care of education for her children. So then she mentioned, so now for this life, now she become Christian.
But next life, she will be Buddhist. So this this shows confusion, isn’t it? True Christian. Then next life, go for the time being, in the coffin.
Coffin. For the time being, remain rest in the coffin, then eventually, hopefully, go to heaven. So but she she want another rebirth as a human being and then become Buddhist. So so such is a confusion as a I mean, take place. And then also, this is some ’56.
I’m during Buddhist religious liberation, I met some Buddhist nun, one European. I don’t know which country One European person dressed a Tibetan monk’s robe. So is she none? So then after 59, I inquired about that European Buddhist nun. And I know I was told she again is a turn to Christian and a lot of criticism towards Buddhism.
I heard. She criticized about Buddhism. I heard like that. So these are the sort of example. It’s much safer, much better, keep one’s own tradition like that.
So now, Question number six, please. No questions. Singapore. Are four sects in Tibetan Buddhism. Can a Buddhist How’s that?
There are four sects in Tibetan Buddhism. Can a Buddhist attend teachings or initiations from all four sects, or should the person decide and choose one sect and stick to it that? What do you mean Tibetan tradition? No. Sometimes it’s a four tradition Also, sort of, I should confuse because, in India, there are four different school of thought.
So sometimes, we refer it’s a four different, I should say, tradition. Now you are referring to better tradition. Tibetan Buddhism. Like that, isn’t it? So now here, in the past in past, many Tibetan masters, you see, follow nonsectarian principle.
At late beginning of twentieth century or even you see there in India, many great masters like the late Jamyang Khyentse and his main teacher, who passed away there in Gangtok. And the main disciple Ongtrul Rinpoche, Trizin Rinpoche. These are in principle non sectarian. They belongs numerous tradition, but they are since they are young age inside in Tibet, they already they should follow nonsectarian sort of principle and receive like when he was young in Kham. One occasion, he was invited by one lama in Amdo area.
So he give some teaching to that person, and he received some teaching, some sort of writing, which he received teaching from him in Amdo. I think in ‘9 in forties, I think. Like that. Then among Dalai Lama, the first Dalai Lama and the second Dalai Lama and third Dalai Lama, These three, according to the biography.
Biography. You see, they they have practice basically nonsectarian. They receive teaching from Kagyu, from Sakya. Of course, they basically belong to Gelug. Then fifth Dalai Lama, of course, well known in his writing.
Many Sakya teaching, Nyingma teaching, and Kagyu teaching, not much like that. But the second, his father, I think one holder of one like that. So and then late certain oh, the seventh Dalai Lama, then not much sort of connection with Nyingma tradition or Sakya tradition like that. Then the thirteenth Dalai Lama, he also, in principle, non sectarian. He received some Nyingma teaching from late Nyingma master, like that.
So his own some writing about Vajrakilaya. So on my what’s the one one of my assistants in dialectical philosophy, one Mongolian great scholar. His name, Unfortunately, 59, he remained there. Then eventually, he passed away.
Very sad. Top scholar and good practitioner. He’s one of his main sort of lama or teacher. The previous one, so he also practiced Nyingma, mainly. So then he told my assistant Assistant in philosophical debate.
So the Dalai Lama practice mainly is a two or two deities. One, Jiji, Vajrabhairava or Mahākāla? Yamāntaka. Yamāntaka. Yes.
One, Vajrakilaya. So like that, in principle, non sectarian. So there are many many sort of great masters. And then, of course, well known, very much was nonsectarian. He very much encouraged.
Isn’t that? That’s one tradition. One tradition is all about one. No. Traditions in English.
Traditions. Right? Yes. I don’t know. One one way of practice.
Then some, you see, strict strictly about their own tradition. Now, unfortunately, now problem. You know, I think some of you, I think, may have heard the. You see, those follower, those those people who worship this spirit, it’s a very strict sectarian. They believe and and there are some sort of I should say, literatures there.
The those people, including some Tibetan government official who belongs yellow hat set, once they committed receiving some teaching from Nyingma tradition, then this tradition then destroyed. So such stories there. So when I was young, I also received some warning, oh, you should not receive teaching from other tradition. You may harm. You may be harmed.
Harmed. Harmful from that sort of spirit. So one time, I developed desire to receive one one sort of tantric text in Nyingma tradition. That’s Then I already received teaching from late So he very much a nonsectarian. So I developed keen sort of desire to receive the oral transmission of this text of one important text of Nyingma tradition.
Then I, of course, I always ask my tutor who give me bhikṣu vow, bhikṣu ordination. He was my, yesterday, I mentioned the one of my senior lama that after his death, 13 remain in as a day in clear light state, as I mentioned earlier yesterday. So I always, you see, ask him whatever I I want to do. You see, firstly, I I always receive some permission from him for agreement. So as usual, I asked him, I want to receive oral transmission, that text.
Then Ling Rinpoche warned me, oh, be careful. Like that. Because at that time, myself, you see the sort of practice and worship of this spirit. Since ’51, I started this sort of worship because I also believe, oh, this is some real protector of yellow hat sect like that. So then, of course, I also use a follower or I received many teaching the the lineage from lama to lama So therefore, and my late another teacher, is very much fond about this this spirit.
So I also practiced. Then around ’75 or ’74, ’73 or ’74, I get some sort of suspicion. Then I carry a lot of sort of investigation and also including reading some history histories, including previous Dalai Lama sort of because I Biographies. Biographies. Then I noticed during this spirit developed during the fifth Dalai Lama.
One of his writing, he mentioned, is this spirit is evil spirit due to making wrong kind of prayers and aspirations. Due to that, sort of, I should say, negative emotion, he becomes evil spirit. Then you see that evil spirit very harmful for buddhadharma and people. Clearly mention that. So among yellow hats yellow hat sect sort of holder, like one very important, very famous lama actually who was the teacher main teacher of seventh Dalai Lama.
So he once he become the holder of Ganden Tripa, yellow hat sect leader, Ganden Tripa. You see, he actually, how should they, eliminated all the traces of that spirit in Ganden monastery, in his own biography, and also his student, and was a Right. Right. Biography wrote by disciple. It is available.
So in writing, it even mentioned the name of like that. So therefore so therefore, I I realized that’s mistake. So then through thorough investigation, and I developed a sort of conviction. It is negative. It is wrong.
So I stopped practice. And I told, at that time, both my tutor alive. So I told them, I told both all the stories what I’ve done. Then senior never never sort of connected with that. So told me, oh, now very good.
He himself, right from the beginning, little doubt. Now you you decide that. So he feel very happy. Then my junior tutor, he himself very much sort of worship that. So inside that, he fully agree of my investigate way of my investigation.
He he knows this is since my
16 year old, I took the responsibility about the Tibetan Kashag, Tibetan government, like that. So since then, every major decision is I always carry some investigation, spiritual way investigation. So fully convinced, you see, the way my sort of investigation. So then mentioned, oh, there must be some reason. So it is right.
Your decision is right. He agreed, fully agreed. So then I got the freedom, received teaching from different tradition, like and some other from newer tradition. And then, Sakya Khenchung, Sakya Trizin, late Sakya masters, how should they, masters, I received a lot of teaching and also some like that. So I think my own case, in early part, very strict.
Later part, I became Rimé. Non sectarian. Non sectarian. So please, you judge which is right. So like that.
So one reason I sort of what’s the day? Put some sort of restriction worship of that spirit is one main reason is that it is in opposition to promotion of nonsectarian. So nonsectarian is very, very essential. Now, actually, you see, Tibetan Buddhadharma now dying. Such period still fight in the name of different sort of sect.
It’s foolish. Wrong. So therefore, since my approach strictly nonsectarian, I think among Tibetan tradition, among Tibetan Buddhist community, I made some contribution. So still, the follower of the Shugden worshippers and the worshipper of that spirit. Is it they they’re very much angry towards me.
So sometimes they describe me as a destroyer of Buddhadharma. True, very strong emotion. Then, of course, their behavior also, you see, just behind you, see, just building. Three, one, very good scholar, very sincere person, two two of his student murdered. Which year?
1997. 1997. ’97. Oh, terrible. The local police, they realized the murderer come from Delhi.
And through, I think, some articles, they found the proof The murderer come from Delhi, the Shugden organization like that. And recently, in Saudi then then since then, quite quite a few occasion beating and try to murder few occasion. Then very late, recently, in South India, in Mundgod Doeguling, one monk was approached by two monks. One carry stone, one carry knife. Then Stabbed.
Stabbed the monk. And he he brought in hospital. So local police knows these things. So it is quite quite sad. Quite sad.
These people some of these people truly now acting like follower of evil spirit. It is quite sad. So the Tibetan and outside as well as inside, I think almost, I think, a 99% or 95%, more than 95%, even those people who traditionally used to worship that completely stopped, but a few still remain there. And then outside, I think some some in Singaporean also, I think, and Taiwan also some, and The United States, and England, as much as as the Slovenia, sorry, newly independent nation. Slovenia.
Slovenia. Slovenia. Oh oh. This area, very removed. Already, this is some follower of worshipper.
So there, like that. So so that I think another thing. Since the the now, of course, this is not a political sort of statement. Please don’t, you see, interpret as a political statement. Just as a fact.
The the the Peking government, the government of people’s problem with China, of course, name is very good, but actually the communist government actually, now I’m making this distinction. The totalitarian, authoritarian government and Chinese people. As far as authoritarian government is concerned, now things become more and more difficulties. But as well as Chinese people, we we have full faith. So as a result, we always, you see, meet them mainly through as an intellectuals and writers, particularly since last year.
Now over one year, I met, I think, a few 100 Chinese scholars, including some students and and many writers. They all of them showing solidarity with us. So like that. So so in any way so in any way, the totalitarian government oh, of course, it’s understandable, you see. Oh, one time because reporter.
Jonathan. Jonathan. Once he asked me, why is the Chinese government is so much sort of angry towards you? Then I answer, I’m not acting as a yes minister. Whatever they say, yes.
Yes, sir. Yes, sir. I’m not anything like that. I’m Buddhist monk. I have speak truth.
Isn’t it? So then he laugh, laugh, laugh like that. So so anyway so anyway, eventually, the the totalitarian government described me as a demon. One time at the last no. No.
No. I think early early early part of this year, I was in San Francisco. Some of American friend said this, I was just in meeting, a meeting sorry, a casual talk in my room in my room. He asked me, she asked me, why is the Chinese government sort of much sort of afraid? They are afraid of me.
Afraid of me. And I asked I I respond to him, because of my horn. Like that. So therefore so therefore, naturally, you see now the communist government, you see, manipulate every sort of group who little bit disagree with Dalai Lama. So they manipulate those Shugden worshipper.
Although we cannot prove, but there are signs they give some money, financial help. So now, of course, too long, my answer. In any way in any way, you see the please, please, I thought that please think the nonsectarian way. That’s much better. And my own sort of practice is concerned.
After I receive teaching from different Tibetan tradition, my understanding for example, the clear light understanding of clear light is clear light, immense help from teaching teaching. And when I look some teaching or teaching, the explanation about the different level of mind is extremely helpful. So as a result of practice of non sectarian and receive teaching from all tradition and read all traditions of text as much as possible and also meditate, It means help to get fuller understanding because of these different tradition. You see, I said from different angle to explain the same sort of what’s the topic or same sort of how do the same topic. No.
Theme. Same thing. Treasure. Topic. Same topic.
But explain way of explanation is from different angle. So learning all these sort of explanation from from different angle is immense help like that. Full stop. Now next question. What should we do when we experience sleepiness while listening to teaching?
Enjoy yourself. Next question. Well, I see sometimes I see the the tools as I used to tell, you see, audience, if you feel little boring, then okay, sleep. But but don’t. Snore.
Snore. Don’t snore. That creates some distance of your neighbor. Like that. That’s what said.
We often experience a lot of pain and suffering in life. So much so so much so that they have become part and parcel of our life. Oh, yes. How can we use such experience of pain and suffering to contemplate on the truth of suffering and develop a sense of renunciation? This is sometimes I response to some, you see, practitioner when they come to see me, particularly those actually, people who have some physical pains and physical difficulties.
And sometimes I responded sincerely because they already know something. So this body, Buddha stated the basis of suffering, basis of pain. Inside that, we consider this is very very sort of pleasant life or something something good. So it is sort of what I said, it is wrong because of the wrong view. So now since our self practitioner side fail to realize this is something basis of pains, basis of suffering, so now the body itself now telling us this is basis of pain and wrong.
Occasionally, when I meet some practitioner who complaining about their physical sort of illness, then I respond like that. So my own case, sometimes I feel some pains happen. Yeah? It is now the indicate from the body itself this is not reliable. This is not true friend.
Think more the cessation of this suffering. Rather look like that way. However, meantime, take full care, medication and some exercise. That’s important. Then different sort of sufferings, tragedy.
That also is a way that we should look these things as a nature of saṃsāra. When we think about this is a Tibetan tragedy from broader broader perspective, we’re still into saṃsāra. The Chinese, as a brothers, sisters, they are also as a full of ignorance. They’re fully dominated by suspicion, fear, and that brings anger. We can’t blame them.
And many Tibetan suffering because of their own karma. From Buddhist viewpoint, there is more reason to feel compassion, to feel sense of concern. Those people who create pains on other rather than victims. Victim? One bad karma, now one one chapter of bad karma now already closed, then finished.
But the other side who create this suffering, this problem, they just start one new chapter, new karma. They have to face this negative consequences long future. So there’s more reason feel concern about. Those who cause trouble. Perpetrator.
Perpetrator. Yeah. Perpetrators. Oh, other? Perpetrators.
Perpetrator. Like that. So take this time. Now you there you see the the I think different I think at least three way, three levels. One, when there is some suffering, some problems, some tragedy happen, think karma.
Due to your own past negative karma, this happened. You cannot blame on others just due to your own karma. Then second level, think this nature of saṃsāra. It helpful. According that view, from birth till death, some form of problems always there until the source of problem remain here.
Some some form of problems always happen. Then third is best. That’s one’s own sort of problem happen. Think more about 6,000,000,000 human beings problem. Then pray, my problem, my suffering.
You should think that through this, through this pain that I’m going through, may, this pain and suffering of others be reduced. One Indian master who visit Tibet, who eventually become teacher, he express, When I’m happy, I dedicate the happiness or the well-being for accumulation of merit. Mhmm. May space be filled with happiness. Mhmm.
And when I suffer, may I be able to dry up all the suffering of sentient beings. So these thinking of course, last year, when the, tenth March afternoon, tenth March two thousand eight, annual sort of was a day was a day.
Commemoration. Commemoration. Then came the march. After that, after lunch, I received some report or information from Lhasa. Now, some part of Lhasa, the local people already moving for demonstration and immediately, lot of worry, a lot of anguish anguish, anxiety.
The similar sort of anxiety and helplessness feeling and hopelessness which occurred on the tenth of March nineteen fifty nine. Same sort of feeling.. But then I deliberately try to meditate or analyze or analytical meditation as just I mentioned. It’s a perpetrator. Perpetrator.
Perpetrator. Perpetrator and victim, these two side. Then, you should deliberately try to keep compassion towards the perpetrator. And also, you see, meditation, taking and giving. Take means their fear, their anger, their what’s it, their ignorance, take myself and give my compassion, my spirit of forgiveness, these give them.
Of course, visualization. So in practical level, no help, but emotional level, immense help to keep, to sustain peace of mind. So therefore, such people who really facing a lot of difficulties, a lot of painful experience, think of this like that. Oneself, think karma and saṃsāra. And the third one, as I mentioned, the pains and pleasure pains and tragedy created by some other, then think of this thing.
That’s better. That’s the way. But here, we should know the forgiveness or compassion towards your enemy does not mean you accept their unjust sort of deed. Right? Deed, action.
Action. Now here we must make distinction, action and actor. As far as actor is concerned, there is sufficient reason to keep compassion. As far as the action is concerned, if unjust action there, then we have to oppose. Actually, that sort of opposition to their wrongdoing is actually helping them.
Clear. If let them wrongdoing continuously, they have to face consequences. So if this way to stop them, we must make measure to stop them. Buddha’s own stories, past past life story, there are such things there. So therefore, we must make a distinction.
Some people, sometimes as you feel or practice of compassion is a day is something like is demeaning because of it has a goggle. To boil down. Boil down. Not that. As I mentioned earlier, a genuine practitioner of compassion not necessarily be yes minister.
As I mentioned before, isn’t it? Like that. That’s I think important. In our day to day’s life, sometimes some people may take advantage If you’re very honest, very humble, compassionate, and some wicked people may take advantage, then think. Analyze the situation.
That’s really unjust, wrongdoing. Then we have to take measure without develop hatred towards that person. Hatred towards their action, not towards actor. That’s very important. Next question.
What is the common consequence if we spray our pets, cats or dogs, to prevent them to give birth to more cats and dogs. Now from looking, judging because of the local area. Locally, then it is wrong. It’s a birth control. But judging from because of the wider perspective.
Now for example, the human population are now already beyond 6,000,000,000. That according to nature resources and particularly now global warming under these circumstances. According to some some sort of some some specialists, say today’s today’s 6,000,000,000. Now next twenty years or thirty years may reach 9,000,000,000. I think too much.
Too much. So better, small quantity and good quality. I think that’s much better. Smaller number and more sort of happy and no longer because of the poverty. And now this is immense sort of, I should say, painful when we look poorest section of the people.
Look some part of Africa. The basic necessity, not sufficient. Facing starvation. And the same human being of the same planet and somewhere too much luxuries. This is not only morally wrong, but practically also source of problem.
We have to address very seriously, reduce this gap, rich and poor. Global level, national level, and India also see lot of poor people. But also, she then removed as a village. I think compare some of these with the poor people in in big street. I think they maybe build better as their their own small land like that.
So this rich and the China, immense sort of gap, rich and poor. So we have to think very seriously to reduce. I think in Hong Kong also, there’s some millionaires, billionaires. But at the same time, in the same town, some very, very poor workers, especially some come from Mainland China, I think. Isn’t it?
I think you know better. Like that. So so these are very, very serious matter now. So therefore, smaller number of human being and more equal, more prosperity is much better. So similarly, some Tibetan settlement include Dharamsala.
Now we already carry some program, birth control of dog, too much dog. Suffering and also danger of disease like that. So better. I want to to tell you half joke. In Japan, when you have a lunch or sometimes more ceremonial lunch, Quality very good but very small quantity, almost like decoration.
So I always ask them more rice, more rice, more rice like that. So food is concerned, quantity is very important. So human population is concerned, I think much better, smaller. Next question. How do we know if we found our root guru?
Can we have more than one teacher? Why do we have to chant our sādhana in Tibetan? Can we chant it in Chinese? Now it depend quality of the lama. It’s really qualified lama.
Then 100. Okay. 1,000, even thousand. Okay. And then other hand, not really qualified, then better rely on text.
One dog number, one great master or disciple of Atisha, Dromtonpa, once he nearly passed away, his disciple, one main disciple, Potowa, Dromtonpa, I mean, his student, now nearly dying, he said, put him on his lap. On his lap. On his lap. Then, literally, feel very sad and cry.
And some drop from his eye, you see, because of that. Fell on the head of the dying lama. Then the head lama, they said, look at him. Why?
Then he expressed, up to now, we can totally rely on you. We can receive teaching from you. Now you’re no longer there. What I I should rely? Then he said, rely on text, not person.
Unless you find a really reliable qualified teacher, you must take the text, the book, as your teacher. Think that’s very sound advice. So like that. But, of course, taking vows like bhikṣu vows or bhikṣuṇīs or these And also the tantric sort of initiation days, I think we should take from one living person.
So then no hurry. Wait till we met. This is really qualified, reliable lama. That’s important. Then chanting or res recitation.
Recitation, except for some mantra like we, although the text of read in Tibetan in in Tibetan language, but some mantra still we use Sanskrit word. I think I’m quite sure our pronunciation is not very correct, but we still use to recite the Sanskrit word like that. When I when I hear hearing the some scholars, Indian scholars, and particularly in in Varanasi, sort of university, and they chanting Sanskrit. Oh, such a wonderful So something very much is touched. So that sometimes I feel, oh, one of my previous life maybe in India, some of the great masters sort of disciple, I think stupid disciple, lazy disciple.
I sometimes I feel like that. So is it they are really wonderful when they recite Sanskrit And there’s certain chant there, certain tune really remarkable. So we never we can we never can see that because of that. Recite in that way. Recite that way.
So so similarly, I think and some mantra like or okay. Many Chinese difficult to pronounce properly. Allah, I think. And similarly, you see Tibetan also. Is it difficult to say, So I remember very clearly.
No. No. I did too long. Sorry. Sorry.
Apologize. In early six fifty nine when I met some people, some English speaking people, one of my translator, he’s still alive. So when when word is like France and that come And I say Tibetan? Okay. France.
Okay. Then he before he sort of speak English, he’s done. I like that. Make some special preparation for saying, France. So usually, it’s difficult to pronounce that like that.
So many Chinese in ’50 before ’59, this is some Chinese, my friend, you see, like a very close friend me, a friend friend of mine. You see, he found it very difficult to pronounce. So you see, chanting must be in Chinese language. Why? The very purpose of this this chanting, these words, is actually reminds the meaning.
So without knowing the meaning, no use. So must be in your own native language. Accept those mantra, because we believe this is some special blessing if you recite Sanskrit word. So that’s the exception. Otherwise, you must translate and read in your own.
So now I think then then what what what one? In what ways can Buddhist practice and especially individual practice contribute to solving the big problems of the world like poverty and long term intractable conflicts like Israel and Palestine? I think of Buddhism. I think firstly I think firstly, it’s quite obvious. Education, modern education, generally speaking, everywhere is a people sufficient to pay attention and learn and learning everywhere.
But then and technology also, I think, highly developed, but still including Palestine. And so many decades, still not yet as a fine solution. If both side, Israeli and the Palestine, both sides keep compassion, sense of concern, sense of well-being of other, I think the Palestine side, I should welcome those Jewish people, very hardworking with some expertise. I I have been to Jerusalem on a few occasions. The Palestine site because Palestine site still more like desert.
The Jewish site, more green. Same area, but due to his expertise and due to, let’s say, I mean, water because of scarcity of water there, but they use some special technique. Each plant, there’s some little drop in water like that, these kind of things. So they have the expert ex expertise.
Well yeah. So welcome them. Let them plant. Let them make more green. In meantime, the Palestine, they have their own tradition, their own culture.
Let them free and the land used commonly. Not much problem. Of course, unrealistic. My thinking is unrealistic, maybe. So more compassionate and sense of we not thinking, not stress importance of we and they.
Let’s stress that and think rest of the people, irrespective what nationality, what race, what religion, think part of we, I think much problem can solve easily. So there there there and also I think the gap is reaching for. If this concept of we, entire population, I think things can be different. And political side side also, political party. I think in Taiwan, DPP and the Kuomintang is sometimes too much emphasis we and they.
I think they should think more we, we political party of Taiwan, better, isn’t it? Like Mainland China and Taiwan also tend to be much better, much easier. So therefore, we really need effort to promote the broader sort of outlook. That’s really necessary. Now here, as I mentioned yesterday, the secular ethics is very essential.
Oh, one of my close friend, Kalam, former president of India, great man. Now my home now. Last fifty years, India is my home. So so the president, former president, Muslim, A.P.J. Abdul Kalam.
Abdul Kalam. Abdul Kalam. This this seed or base of the problem is I and me. Then recently, I met I met him. I seek audience with him in his home.
He keep or maybe maybe I think maybe his secret. Maybe he I I don’t want to go detail. But at at the that’s what I just have in there. Meeting. Our meeting, there also he emphasis, he express very strongly the many problem of this world.
The key factor is concept, too much strong concept of I and me. He’s scientist, Muslim background, but scientist, he looks things out more objectively. I think that’s that’s true. So now in order to develop concept of we, compassion is the basis. And also intelligence, knowing all our future depend on rest of the world and climate conditions, everything interrelated like that.
So their secular ethics, I think we should make effort promotion of secular ethics. Then in that respect, Buddhism, without talking about Buddhist religion or some of the Buddhist concept, I think Buddhist science can be useful for promotion of human values, secular values because Buddhism sometimes I I describe Buddhism and Jainism, these are sort of creation of human being. Monotheistic religion, creation of god. So this religion come from god. Buddhist religion come from human being as I mentioned earlier yesterday.
Buddha Śākyamūni originally just simple sort of sentient being just like us. Then with his sort of with with help of his teacher, Then gradually, from human level become Buddha. So Buddhist religion started from human level. So always talking about human values. So that means, therefore, Buddhism is some kind of humanism.
Okay. And some people, some western scholars describe Buddhism is not religion. Buddhism is science of mind. There’s some sort of point like that. So therefore, I think Buddhism can can make some sort of contribution for better world, more compassionate world.
So I think now now stop. Oh, yeah. Now now serious talk now. More serious talk. That in the for noble truth.
Now we have come to the third statement of the Buddha in terms of teaching on the four noble truths, which is the statement regarding the function and together with the results. And so during the third statement regarding the Four Noble Truths, the Buddha said, should know firstly, we should know the suffering the the noble truth of suffering, and then there is nothing to be known. And then we should overcome the causes or the origin of suffering. And then he says there is nothing to be overcome. And similarly, we should actualize that of truth of cessation, and then there is no nothing to be attained or actualized.
And finally, with regard to the path, he says we should cultivate the path, but then there is nothing to be cultivated as well. And so with regard to this now, within the context of the common vehicle, the principle which is shared by the greater and lesser vehicle, we may understand it in terms of the understanding of the non-self and that of the exhaustion of negativities. So with regard to this now, what is meant by that is once you have understood what suffering is and then you are able to overcome the causes of suffering, the suffering itself, there is nothing that needs to be overcome in terms of suffering it’s causes. And then once you have attained the cessation, there is nothing left to be attained after that. And then once you have cultivated the path and reached the goal, there is nothing to be cultivated.
And so in this way, we understand Buddha to be teaching the Four Noble Truths in terms of their function and the resultant state. And then in terms of the Madhyamaka treatises, What that refers to is Buddha is saying here is that he is referring to the ultimate nature of things, that things do not have any intrinsic existence right from the beginning. And this shows the intention or the thought of the Buddha is that we can overcome the suffering and its causes and can attain or achieve those of cessation and the path. Why that is so is because of the very nature of things being empty of any inherent existence. And so because things are right from the beginning empty of any intrinsic inherent or independent existence, therefore the delusions and those suffering that they bring about can be purified or eliminated from within our mind stream.
And so with regard to that, is also called the very this ultimate nature of things, this lack of intrinsic existence is also termed as natural nirvana. And within the nirvana, there are those natural nirvana and then nirvana with residue, without residue, and then finally, the nirvana, which is the exhaustion of all the negativities. No. This one? No.
And then with regard to the cultivation of the path, in terms of the shared path, the path which is shared both the Mahāyāna and Hīnayāna, called vehicles, there are those of the 37 factors leading to enlightenment. 37 factors such as those of the four types of mindfulness and then four types of right exertions and then four bases of supernatural power. Those are the seven Five. Five. Strengths and powers.
So and such as those of the the faith and so forth. And then the sevenfold path to that of enlightenment, and then the eightfold noble path. So these can in turn be understood in the context of the four paths, which are those are the paths of accumulation, path of preparation, path of seeing and path of meditation. And so with regard to the four mindfulnesses. With regard to the four mindfulnesses or establishment of mindfulness, we can understand this in terms of the general characteristics of the four Noble Truths and the particular characteristics of the Four Noble Truths.
What that means is in terms of the noble truth of suffering, we can talk about those characteristics such as the nature of being in the suffering and then those of that of being repulsive and then ugliness and then uncleanliness. This one? So the out of 37, The first four of mindfulness. Mindfulness, four mindfulnesses. First, mindfulness about body and mindfulness about feeling.
Third, mindfulness about consciousness of mind. Then mindfulness about phenomena, positive and negative, four things. So first mindfulness of body. If you think about nature of the body, then and some other sort of test.
You say, often is mentioned, this body essentially what should they? Full of filth. Full of filth. Full of. Filth.
Filth. Filth. In sixties, in late sixties, I think, I had opportunity to visit Thailand. As I mentioned yesterday, Singapore, at that time, I think Malaysia. So I I had opportunities in Thailand, I think, two or three times.
So one monastery outside the main hall, there’s one a few something like a big box, and then you can look to to. Yes. No. Oh, okay. So something something like this.
You see one big box, and then you see look through something glass like that. And then inside picture of dead body. Immediately after that, fresh dead body. Then another then you see they change the picture, then dead bod dead body after a few days. So that is the, you see, the practice of ugliness of the body.
So the immediate after death, more fresh, but although although already there is some sign of ugliness there. Then after a few days, oh, blue or something or very terrible, which we usually it’s in my body. It’s something very dear to answer and take every care. But that very body, very precious body, now become like that. So that reminds us the very nature of this body is filth.
Filth. Filth. I don’t know. In any way in any way, it’s very ugly, very bad. And then, of course, picture cannot sort of actually carry this matter.
Otherwise, if it were a real dead body in bad shape, it would terrify us instead of reducing attachment. Terrify. Fear. Then bad smell. If you lick, I think bad because of bad taste or maybe good taste.
I don’t know. You see some Tibetan who spent, you see, 20 years in Chinese gulag. He said, he’s so hungry. One officer now still here working in my office. Now one day, he’s so hungry.
And one of the prisoner who died, actually, he tried to eat his his body. But since his teeth not very strong, so fail is it to bite that dead bodies with the also the flesh flesh like that. So so in any way, taste maybe good. So in any way, these are the practice of mindfulness of ugliness of the body. That is reduced attachment of one’s own body and also there’s some someone who really beautiful, too much attraction, think very nature of the body.
Then you get that kind of sort of Also, the realization and that reduce attachment. Then as Śāntideva says, this body outside has color and shape and smoothness. You see, nice. But if you open this, there’s a lot of Skin. You would see the muscles.
Muscles. Muscles. And the veins. Further remove that, then skull. Skull.
Bone. Bone. Bones. Bones. Skeleton.
What? Skeleton. Skeleton. And then also, you see the no matter how beautiful sort of food, color nice, I say they taste nice, smell nice, but once go inside, then finally come from here. Bad smell.
I think bad because of that. I think bad taste. I think no. It’s all like that. So no matter what beautiful thing, ultimately, something rotten, something very bad.
At this body, I often used to telling people when I give teaching of the Śāntideva’s book, this body, Śāntideva mentioned, as a sort of factory to produce these, what’s it, stools or urine, you see, we consider dirty. This body actually, machine produced that. No matter how expensive and how beautiful all these foods and and drinks, actually, the source of this dirty thing. This machine, when machine work working well, then proper urine, proper sort of stool. And when you see, sometimes our machine goes wrong, then become something liquid like that.
Then sometimes it’s difficult to control that. So all this because of the this machine producer become wrong. So when we say, oh, oh, I’m good health. My position my health is very good. So that means produce well.
Unless we utilize this human intelligence properly, just taking food, shelter, and holiday, love has meaning. Isn’t it? Isn’t it? So that’s the way of mindfulness of this body. Then mindfulness of feeling.
Feeding always changing, moving. So pleasant feeling, again, change. And unpleasant feeling also change. So thinking once realize that there’s no basis to too much attachment about pleasant feeling. There’s not much reason to unhappy about suffering feeling like that.
So our mind then become more neutralized. Neutralized. Calm. Calm. By that.
And then also including breathing meditation. Just concentrate fully on breathing. That also useful. Our mind too much sort of attraction towards external thing. And sometimes we cannot concentrate on sort of deeper sort of study.
So for that initial sort of method is just forget about outside sort of seeing or hearing or smelling these things. Just concentrate breathing. A 100 time or eventually a few 100 times, your mind fully concentrate on it. So it is quite good. Compared to mind itself, breathing is more gross.
But compared outside object, breathing is more subtler. So that’s between there. So a little bit easier just to concentrate on breathing. Then your mind become calm. So that’s the second mindfulness.
Then third mindfulness, about mind. What is mind? Now here, we always talk about mind. But if you ask, what is mind? No answer.
A scientist also, no. No answer. Everybody, you see, everybody will have the experience of this sort of this phenomena. But precisely, what’s the definition of that mind, still difficult. So therefore, Buddhist Buddhist I think Buddhist or ancient Indians of thought, did describe or mind as just mere.
Knower. Oh, knowing, knower. Knower. And experience. Awareness.
Knowledge. Right.. It’s mere experience and awareness. Formless. Something like some kind of very clear clear clear light or something like that or mirror itself, nothing but reflect everything like that.
So in order to realize that, sit without moving, without movement, without movement, then also you see, deliberately stop memory about past and also deliberately try to stop thinking about visions or hopes and doubts about future, not not not go that that that field. Then that moment, at initial stage, you may get the feeling empty, nothing. That’s some kind of thoughtlessness. It’s not not some secret. Nothing.
Nothing important. Remain more time to to familiarization. Eventually, you get used to some kind of stillness. Stillness. Stillness.
Sensitive organs, no longer active. Mind also, not past memory, not thinking about future, no longer there. Just present. You feel something vast and open, empty. Then remain there longer period, then gradually you get the sort of feeling or experience just mere luminosity, sorry.
Luminosity. Luminosity. Yeah. Then try to familiarize yourself with that experience. Then there, also you get the experience of momentary change.
That’s third mindfulness. Fourth mindfulness, now phenomena. I think that already, you see, we talked yesterday and also today. This is the positive positive and negative or like these things and sort of analyze these things. So that’s So that was about the specific characteristics of the four mindfulnesses.
And then next, regarding the general characteristics of the mindfulnesses. All composite phenomena are impermanent. All contaminated things are in the nature of suffering. And all phenomena are selfless and empty. And nirvana is peace.
So the these I think these are the common what is the common definition of these four mindfulness. So now, it’s time for lunch. After lunch, we both speaker as a listener, both full stomach may be better unless there’s some more danger of sleep. Otherwise, you see that better. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- Kagyü
- The order of Tibetan Buddhism founded in the eleventh century by Marpa, Milarepa, Gampopa, and their followers. One of the four main schools of Tibetan Buddhism. Cf. Nyingma, Sakya and Gelug. LYWA
- Nyingma
- The old translation school of Tibetan Buddhism, which traces its teachings back to the time of Padmasambhava... LYWA
- oral transmission lung (Tib, Wyl)
- The verbal transmission of a teaching, meditation practice or mantra from guru to disciple, the guru having received the transmission in an unbroken lineage from the original source. LYWA
- path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
- The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How can we use our experience of pain and suffering to contemplate the truth of suffering and develop renunciation and compassion?
The body is the basis of pain, so physical pain shows it is not a reliable, true friend; reflect on the cessation of suffering while still taking medication and exercise. There are three levels of reflection. First, think that the problem arises from your own past negative karma, so others cannot be blamed. Second, see it as the nature of saṃsāra, where some problem always arises until its source is removed. Third, the best: think of the problems of all beings and pray that through your pain, their suffering may be reduced. Toward those who cause harm, practise compassion and taking and giving, taking their anger and ignorance and giving compassion and forgiveness.