Four Noble Truths – 2014-05-21 – KR

1 h 18 min · 2,725 words · 21 May 2014

Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Four Noble Truths - 2014-05-21 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The teacher urges students to study Dharma by memorizing key definitions, reflecting on their meaning and debating or discussing them, rather than just taking notes. He then explains coarse and subtle impermanence, including the measure of an instant, and says that understanding impermanence counters dissatisfaction and the sense of lasting permanence, in the context of the Four Noble Truths.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 19m

UUID: 721c5ae8-802b-47ee-831b-71a97d26a281

Date: 2014-05-21

Words: 2,721

I would like to reflect with you somewhat on the meaning of study. Generally speaking, most of you have completed your professional studies, which is very good. For instance, I have always felt that the Tibetan Buddhist Dharma is rooted in the Tibetan language. However, there is a difference. We do say that someone who is learned in the Tibetan language is someone who has first studied grammar and then rhetoric and poetry.

This is not something which we would say about someone who is learned in Buddhism. Now for instance, if we take Tibetan grammar, Tibetan grammar is rooted in Tömi Sambhota’s treatise, the Sumi Sungchopa. Then when we study that treatise and we exercise or we train in calligraphy, the more we train in calligraphy, the better our calligraphy, but this has little or no impact on the mind. The same is true for a twenty first century education. We also study the verbal tenses, the past, the present and the future, and we learn to write either with a pen or typing into a computer.

This is not the case when one trains or studies dharma. In your cases, because of your education, you are accustomed to taking notes. This is not necessarily the way one studies down. I believe you must understand that it is extremely difficult to study Mahāyāna Buddhist Dharma through merely writing things down, through merely taking notes. Do you understand?

Then how should one study Buddhadharma? Most of the study of Buddhadharma occurs at home, at one’s domicile. And if we were to take the example of Lorig, of Buddhist psychology, if you were to study the sevenfold division of consciousness and awareness, then after consulting your notes, you would memorize the seven divisions of consciousness and awareness, and you would memorize their divisions. Your goal is for this knowledge to enter within, enter in your minds. Because of your education, you are accustomed to take notes.

However, this is insufficient. You must memorize the material ideally, memorize the subdivisions and memorize the definitions. If you are unable to memorize the material, then you should reflect by yourself on its meaning and understand its meaning. Let’s take the example of the definition of a direct valid cognizer in Lorig. A direct valid cognizer is a new and incontrovertible knowledge which is bereft of conceptuality.

Then after memorizing this definition, anew and incontrovertible knowledge which is bereft of conceptuality, one must then understand what each element of the definition includes or eliminates. What does bereft of conceptuality mean? What does incontrovertible mean? What does knowledge mean? Then in the monasteries, one would go to the debate courtyard, two hours in the morning, and six or seven hours a day in the evenings, and one would debate, one would discuss the meaning of these definitions.

Then this is an extraordinarily beneficial approach because as a result, these definitions dwell for a very long time in one’s mind since one might have debated about them, given examples or instances, engaged in question and answer on the topic. You don’t have the opportunity to engage in this type of intensive debate. You do not have the time. But in the context of what we are doing here, we gather for an hour and a half in the evenings once a week or twice a week, and here questions and answers are extremely important. Returning to the topic of or the example of Lorig, if you are able to memorize these divisions and definitions, then it is extraordinarily helpful.

For instance, when you go to work, while you are working, you can reflect on these definitions, Otherwise, if you haven’t memorized them while you’re working, your books are closed, you can’t do anything. In our cases, we do not have to go to work, so for us the study process is easier. Initially, we memorize the topics we are studying, then we reflect on their meanings. Then I think it would be very important if you could make an hour in your family life and dedicate that hour to family discussion of dharma. How’s that?

Good idea? In my case, I’m trying to find means for you to integrate the material. For instance, it will be very important for Aloha and Aaron to talk, let’s say for one hour, this topic. Really? 100100%.

Good, thank you. That I’ve just been volunteered. So if you have any questions, please feel free to email or telephone your translator. Please email. So you do not have the time to engage in the study process engaged in the great monasteries.

In the great monasteries, when one prepares for the Geluk examinations, such as the Geshe examinations, then one covers the material in one’s own room for hours on end, and then groups of 15 or so gather and debate over the material together. The way we should train is that we should study at home and then ask questions. It is really inappropriate to come to a teaching, open one’s notes, and without having looked at anything, ask a question from the top of one’s head. This is of no help to oneself or others. Instead, you should incrementally study and then ask questions.

For instance, here on Wednesdays at I think it’s 05:00, there is a group which gathers for discussion. Then this is something you should prepare before at home. For instance, if you’re going to study or discuss about death and impermanence, you must have studied the topics previously at home. If you’re going to study about the path of the being of the small scope, likewise. Then you are so accustomed to the contemporary style of education that you just take notes, and once you have closed your notebooks, nothing is left in the mind.

This is not how one should study Dharma. Otherwise, if you attend teachings and just take notes like this, you will be training your grammar. Then this is basically not terribly relevant. Things must enter into the head. Frankly, because of one’s habituation when one attends teachings in this way, it’s a hand which exercises.

The hand is accustomed to taking notes. Right? And therefore, after taking your notes, you must memorize the key points, the definitions, and then you must analyze each of the word of a definition is meaningful, you must understand its meaning. Then this is very much the case when one studies Lorig Buddhist psychology, Druptha, tenets, or sa lam grounds and paths. There are a lot of definitions and instances which must be memorized.

In the case of Lamrim, there are fewer definitions and instances to be memorized, so there are slightly different procedures. Both His Holiness the Dalai Lama and our holy teacher, Khensur Rinpoche, have emphasized the importance of study. It is not sufficient to have a center such as this one and to view it as part of your social life. It is necessary to put effort in study. His Holiness has emphasized this, and Khensur Rinpoche added that it is critical also to practice.

Therefore, we should take the essence of the instructions of these two teachers. It is critical when one studies the Lamrim to generate wholehearted resolve. This wholehearted resolve is something which comes from deep within the mind. This deep wish, I wish to at least generate my own happiness in the future, or ideally, I wish to generate the happiness for all sentient beings. Then with this as a motivation one should study.

Mhmm. At present we will generate this motivation. All of us are the same in being troubled by both physical and mental suffering, and all of us are the same in being convinced that the cause of physical and mental suffering are the basis of exterior things. In this respect, we are identical. Even though, however, we have the best of food and clothing, nonetheless, this is a point when mental suffering begins.

So you must understand that it is absolutely impossible to eliminate mental suffering through controlling exterior situations. Otherwise, if you truly believe that mental suffering can be controlled through controlling exterior circumstances, you will suffer greatly. You can see for instance that in the case of countries, wars occur out of this conviction that material circumstances are the foundation for happiness. And obviously, wars do not conclude anything, do they? They do not decide anything, do they?

What does this come from? This comes from misunderstanding of the origin of mental suffering and an attempt to eliminate it through physical means. Through understanding that it is impossible to better one’s lot through material objects, tensions which lead to war can be eliminated, and in turn, one’s own satisfaction and a decrease in attachment to objects will increase. What is the origin of these mental sufferings? They are rooted in the conviction that we will be around for a long time.

Out of this conviction that we will be around for a long time, we try to collect all the factors which are conducive to our happiness in the here and now and to eliminate all of the interfering conditions. Therefore, there is really no means to eliminate mental suffering apart from dharma. Those means which claim to truly eliminate mental suffering actually connect with dharma. What basically is the reason for which we are not contented with little happiness? The reason for which we are not contented with little happiness is our conviction in our own permanence.

It is this conviction in our own permanence that we will be here for a long time which leads to dissatisfaction. This can be countered through an understanding of the four noble truths which connects to impermanence. Specifically, impermanence is one of the four features of the four noble truths, which are impermanence, suffering, selflessness, and emptiness. The impermanence, which is one of the four features of the First Noble Truth, the Noble Truth of suffering, refers to coarse impermanence. It would seem however that through repeated familiarization with reflections on coarse impermanence, the understanding of subtle impermanence will improve.

From within the two subdivisions of impermanence into coarse and subtle impermanence, coarse impermanence can qualify living beings. It cannot qualify other composite phenomena. On the other hand, subtle impermanence is a characteristic of all composite phenomena without exception. Then you have some sort of a sense of impermanence probably. The fact that composite phenomena, phenomena which have parts, in other words, change incrementally, perhaps if you can perceive it instant by instant, if not at least sporadically.

The beings within this temple, for instance, would be clear instances of coarse impermanence. Now if we were to give an instance of subtle impermanence, The most beneficial is to reflect on one’s own subtle impermanence, one’s own disintegration instant by instant. It is far from obvious what the benefit might be to reflect on the subtle impermanence of buildings, objects and so forth. To understand what subtle impermanence is, we will start with the vast measures of times, which are years. Years are subdivided in months, months are subdivided in weeks, weeks are subdivided in days, days are subdivided in hours, Hours in minutes, minutes in seconds, seconds in instants, and according to Buddhist scriptures, one sixty fifth of an instant is the shortest measure of time.

Then since you want to understand what subtle impermanence is, you must understand that the subdivisions of change in annual, monthly, weekly, daily, hourly, by the minute, or by the second are all part of coarse impermanence. Subtle impermanence. How could one understand clearly subtle impermanence? Imagine that you are at midnight on the dawn of the New Year, the 01/01/2014, and within one sixty fifth of the time it takes to snap your fingers, which is one instant in Buddhist terms, within one sixty fifth of that period, change will have occurred. This is subtle impermanence.

Therefore, in the time it takes to snap your fingers on that midnight of the 12/31/2013, 65 instants would have elapsed. Within one instant is one sixty fifth of that duration, During that one sixty fifth of that duration, change will have occurred. This is what is referred to as subtle impermanence. According to various scholars, this is a measure of subtle impermanence. Then within one instant is one sixty fifth of the time it takes for a very strong man to snap his fingers.

Then you can see when you try to snap your fingers quickly that it’s not easy, but you have to ask yourself at present, is there a smaller interval of time than this one sixty fifth of an instant, this one sixty fifth of the period of time it takes a strong man to snap his fingers, or not? Then in your opinion, is there an interval of time shorter than one sixty fifth of the interval of a finger snap or not? According to Buddhist scriptures, this interval of one sixty fifth of a finger snap is the smallest interval of time. Whether this is the case or not, you must examine by yourselves. And we will think about this for some three minutes.

How was that? Really? Uh-huh. Do you mind it? Is there or not?

No. Do. Behind you Chris. I think there is because, if there’s a moment, whatever, it is whether it’s onesixty fifth, it must have a beginning, a middle and an end and if it has a beginning and a middle and an end, then the middle must have a beginning, middle and an end. So it seems that there cannot be one moment that’s quantified as the smallest.

So a continuum exists, however, if we posit the interval of time of one sixty fifth of a finger snap as an instant, what can you posit as something smaller than that? And he asked me what I thought about it, then in my opinion, there are there are infinitesimally shorter instants. Physicists have measured intervals of time of ten minus forty-two seconds, that’s zero with 41 zeros and one. So this interval of time is measured by instruments, but I think where the Buddhist teachings are correct is that the sensory organs cannot perceive data with within those intervals of time, and the sensory organ which can perceive the shortest interval of time is the eye sense organ, and that is approximately one sixty fifth. I timed it with my my father’s stopwatch.

It’s true. Sorry. According to Buddhist scriptures, an instant is one sixty fifth of the time taken for a finger snap. Now what precisely this refers to is, does this refer to for instance, only to the instant we physiologically can identify or not? That I do not know.

But then scientists have identified far shorter intervals of time, how these relate is something I would not enter into, you decide for yourselves. But what is the purpose of these teachings on subtle impermanence? Through understanding that these instants which follow each other are instants of continual change, we understand that we ourselves are changing continually, and this continual change leads to coarse change, coarse impermanence in death, and this leads us to the realization that we have no time to waste, but must take the essence of this rebirth of leisure and endowment. Then we have run out of time, this is what I wanted to say on subtle impermanence. If you have questions I will take one question tonight.

Chris, behind you, there’s already one question. Regarding impermanence and future events, if a person was to have a realisation of impermanence could that person ever have an incontrovertible reason that a future event would occur? So if you know that things are impermanent could you ever arrive at a valid inference or an incontrovertible state of mind that a certain event would or would not occur in the future? If you understood impermanence. No.

I mean, if you had direct realization of impermanence, you would have no certainty regarding which events, let’s say future lives would occur in the future. Just a quick announcement on the website, there’s a list of texts for the next Tuesday night teaching on the just click on the website and Ilya has just given us those. Puja at six on Friday.

Key terms in this teaching

Buddhadharma
The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
valid inference jepag tshema (Tib)
A new non-deceptive outer cognition directly generated in dependence on its support, a correct reason. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top