Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1999-04-05 – 5A – 4 Noble Truths Retreat – KR.mp3
UUID: 4aed3296-da01-44ef-b5dd-a44fa2a692ef
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 1999-04-05
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 48 min
Words: 2,663
It’s been designated or labeled to to his mental and physical physical aggregates. So in the sense, so the I and so the body or the mental and physical which is the basis for this one imputed or one labeled I on, this physical and mental aggregate. So in the sense it entails that the I and which is imputed and the body or mental and physical aggregates are separate, are not one. So some some some people, they accept there is an I which acts inherently by itself without depending on the mental and physical aggregates. So the such an I does not exist because without without depending without the basis of the mental and physical aggregates, there is no I at all.
So so the the third one attribute is called emptiness because because the because the self and the aggregates, the mental and physical aggregates. Some people agrees that the mental and physical aggregates and the I is something totally different because they don’t depend on each other, but it is not. They are interdependent to each other. So that the mental and physical aggregates are the basis where one attributes or labels I on it. So does that in the sense it means they are dependent.
So this is how it is called the they are not so so they are they are dependent on each other and due to that, it’s called emptiness. Okay. And the fourth attribute of the attribute of the true self is the selflessness. And because because one circles in saṃsāra due to the grasping, the due ignorance which is the root of all the suffering and here ignorance is which is opposed to the wisdom realizing. The the one who who recognize or or assets that So the the root of the root of the root the root of all the suffering, which is ignorance and the holding or grasping self as inherently or self as truly existing, which is the ignorance as well as the root of all suffering.
So to abandon that wisdom grasping self self as a truly existent, to avoid that, it taught the four attribute of the true selflessness, taught the selflessness. I So so the the the wisdom grasping self as truly existent or the ignorance grasping self as truly existent is here because in we always establish our self and always things that I or self exist without depending on mental and any part of mental and physical aggregates and establish that the I or self exist or exist independently means without depending on any parts of mental and physical aggregates. Due to that, so and to avoid, so this is called the wisdom grasping, self grasping or self grasping wisdom, realizing self as truly or inherently existence. And to avoid that, to abandon that here, so one establish that selflessness because there is no such self self or I which exists inherently or exists by itself. So and so as for the the for the attribute, the selflessness is because by recognizing the selflessness and then due to that one one come to overcome this wisdom grasping of self.
And by abandoning that, one can eliminate the eliminate the disturbing emotion and the action or the the true origin of the suffering and due to that, one attains liberation. So so to to achieve to achieve liberation, to only liberation, one doesn’t need to realize the emptiness of One does not need the emptiness, wisdom realizing emptiness or the wisdom realizing the selflessness of phenomena. And to to to to attain only liberation, it’s one can one can liberate attain liberation by by only recognizing the wisdom realizing selflessness. These are the four attributes of the four true sufferings. True suffering.
And likewise, all the rest the next three truths, like true origin of the suffering and true cessation, true path has each has four attributes as well. So so the purpose of teaching teaching the four attributes of of of each each truth is because to understand the nature or to understand well of the four noble truths. If one understand the four attributes well, if one understand the four the four attributes of first truth is true true self and well then one can one can understand the understand one can understand correctly the nature of the true suffering and and one can abandon it. So likewise so for the others rest, the purpose of teaching for attributes of others, truths are also the same as the for suffering because they are taught to understand the nature of each truth well. Then, but for example, if one comes, if one understands the attributes of the true path then one can understand well, understand the nature of the true path and then through this one can overcome, one can achieve the true path as well.
So this the main purpose is to understand well of the nature of four truths. Yes. So we don’t have much time to go detail to one by one of the or each attribute. So but so we have just it’s good to just take a note of if 16 attributes here, and we have set the four attributes of the true suffering earlier just before. And now the four attributes of true origin. The first And the second attribute is called the origin of all.
It is called origin of all because the from from from it, from this, all the suffering comes. So due to that, it’s called the origin of suffering. Origin origin of all. And the third attribute of the true origin of the suffering is called the conditions. It is called because it acts as the condition for the suffering to rise.
It’s like the desire or attachment. It acts as a condition like the example gave prime minister and the president yesterday. This attachment is called the prime minister want who who does all the job. So here is the so this this is condition here. So it is called condition here because it it helps the suffering to grow or yield your suffering to grow.
Due to that, it’s called condition. So and the these four attribute is called the intense production or strong production. It is called intense or strong production because it gives huge huge strong influence or strong birth to origin of the suffering or which is karma action and the disturbing emotion. So due to that, it’s called a strong production or intense production. And now we we are on to the four attributes of true cessation.
And the first first one is called the cessation. It is called cessation because because it has abandoned all the it has ceased or eliminate all the sufferings, and due to that, it is called the cessation because it says it cease all the or abandon the to all sufferings. So it is called cessation. Why it is called cessation? It is called cessation cessation because it’s it cease or it stops or stop stops the suffering from from the root.
So due to that, it’s called cessation when it stops all the suffering. And the second is called pacification or or the peace because because because it has it has abandoned all the it is called pacification or peace because it has abandoned all the sufferings from its root, uprooted all the sufferings. So during that, it is called peace or pacification. And the third attribute is called the excellence or the high auspiciousness because because it is called high auspiciousness because because it it is free from all the all all it’s free from all the sufferings, and due to that, it it it can remain always happy or in or peaceful all the time. So due to that, it’s called the high auspiciousness.
And the fourth one is called the definite emergence. And it is called the definite emergence because because it has it has eliminate, abandoned, or stopped the stopped the the the suffering from these truths and and would never let sufferings to come back. So it means it’s free from suffering all the time. And it is definite that suffering won’t come back for that state again. So due to that, it’s called a definite emergence.
So and there is four attributes of the true path, which is the true path. And the the first attribute is of the true path is called the path. It is called path. And path here refers to the wisdom which directly realize the selflessness of a person.
So this it’s a the search wisdom is the path here. So such a path or this wisdom realizing directly realizing and self lessness of person is called the path because it is a path to liberation. So due to that, it’s called the path of liberation. Due to that, it’s called path. And this and second second attribute is called the the suitability or or it’s called suitable knowledge.
It is called the suitability or awareness because because it is a method to abandon or to stop the disturbing emotion. And it’s called the third attribute is called achievement. And, yeah, it’s called achievement. It is called achievement because because it is the because it realizes the reality, realizing And which which which because it it it’s realized, it directly realized the emptiness of the mode of the of existence. So, yeah, it it directly it directly realizes the mode of existence now.
And the the fourth attribute is called the deliverance. Deliverance. And it is called the deliverance or the definite freedom because it directly acts as an antidote towards the suffering and never give a chance to the suffering to grow or come back. These are the four attributes of the true path. So so so there are there are 16 attributes of the Four Noble Truths.
So I have just roughly explained or taught give you the four sixteen attributes of the Four Noble Truths. And, but it’s because of our time. We don’t have much time, I’ve been not able to give more detailed information of about the attributes. Yeah. We’ll stop here today.
So we, I mean, these things we are teaching according to, it’s not teaching through the schools of Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika School. We are talking through the systems or schools below the Autonomic Schools of Mādhyamika and then Sautrāntika schools and Vaibhāṣikas and Sautrantikas. And so we were teaching through the point of view or through the systems of these schools. And so what it said, so they agree that just to attain a mere liberation or arhat, and one does not need to cultivate a wisdom realizing wisdom realizing selflessness of phenomena because because just just just by mere by mere wisdom realizing selflessness of person can can achieve liberation or One does not need to cultivate the wisdom, the wisdom realizing selflessness of phenomena. So so it is they said it they said this because because it agrees the self is the or self-grasping is the root of cyclic existence.
And so to the grasping self, all right, the self grasping is the root of the cyclic existence. And so by cultivating the wisdom, realizing selflessness of a person or the every person has the root of this cyclic existence. So by cultivating or by recognizing selflessness of person, then one abandons the root of the suffering. And also this and this is how by abandoning that one attains liberation. This is how it says, by by only yeah.
This is how this is the reason they said this. Because they they they don’t establish the the the true existence of the phenomena as the root of cyclic existence. So due to that, one does not need to acquire cultivate the wisdom realizing of phenomena to to attain mere liberation or to attain because the the the true existence of phenomena is not the is not the root of the suffering. Is that correct? And the the the schools of the consequentialist or schools, they assert that to attain liberation, one needs to acquire, one needs to cultivate the wisdom realizing selflessness of phenomena because they establish the true existence of the phenomena are is the root of the cyclic existence.
The the first noble truth. Right? The first attribute is impermanence. It is called impermanence because it changes moment by moment. Second attribute is called the suffering.
It is called suffering because it it it is because it comes under the influence of disturbing emotion and the action or karma. And the third one is called the emptiness. And it is called empty because the self or I and the physical aggregates are the a or the empty of empty or the empty of truly existent? No? No?
And the fourth one is called the self selflessness. It’s called selflessness because it it it is not self sufficiently exist. Just just yeah. Yeah. So which emptiness you want?
The emptiness according to according to the attributes of the four first four noble truths or emptiness in general. And what I actually need to say here is it actually means that it’s called emptiness with the first attribute itself is empty because it doesn’t have a self other than the mental physical aggregates. This is how it’s called the emptiness. Alright? And this So which one you want?
Emptiness of this one or in general? Okay. Yeah. No. It’s the same spelling, same sound.
The difference it it it between there is a different meaning in the context. General. Actually, there are there are different ways of establishing selflessness and emptiness because it comes it’s because of the different because of the four different types of schools. So each each school has their own way of establishing selflessness and the and and emptiness. So if you speak through the schools of Prāsaṇgika, the consequential schools of Madhyamaka schools, which is considered to be the correct or the ultimate viewpoint of ultimate view in the Buddhist schools.
And so there in in these schools, it’s it says the it talked about the selflessness in a person and the selflessness of phenomena. And so it actually the selflessness and the self both the selflessness of emptiness, selflessness of phenomena and the selflessness of the person are the emptiness. They are they are both emptiness. But the difference here, it’s called the selflessness of person and selflessness phenomena is because the selflessness of the person he refers to the because the self is these are these are classified because of the basis of the way they’re designated or they get imputed. Example, like selflessness, the person comes because the self itself is being imputed or labeled on on the mental and physical aggregates.
And so it’s based on mental of mental and physical aggregates. And it is called selflessness because the self is empty selflessness of the person because it doesn’t have basis other than physical aggregates. But this is how it’s called the selflessness of the person. And selflessness of the phenomenon is more likely same because it bases are the phenomena other than mental and physical aggregates. And and the the school below the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika School, which is now school below is that Autonomic School of Mādhyamika Schools, and then the Cittamātra schools, Sautrāntika schools.
All they so their emptiness is established by saying that because the phenomena are empty of truly existent. And and then the the emptiness, which is not the the empty of truly existing is called the this it’s called the true existence of phenomena, which they assert. And as for the selflessness of selflessness of person, they are saying that they establish that that self is not sufficiently existent or self is not existing independently by its own accord. So due to that, it is called the selflessness of a person. It’s like a tongue twister.
Key terms in this teaching
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- selflessness of person gang zag gi dag me (Tib)
- According to the Prasangika Madhyamaka school, the most subtle view of selflessness of person is the lack of inherent existence of the person or self. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.