Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 1992-08-01 – Side 1 – Session 2 – KR.MP3
UUID: 93d6f784-b515-49c0-bc8c-b786b19f3c60
Teacher: Khensur Rinpoche
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 1992-08-01
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 46 min
Words: 4,338
Sunday morning meditation with mindfulness and breathing. So just focus on the natural breath without adjusting the breath in any way. Just continue to bring the mind back to the breath again and again and again. But toward the end, for the last few minutes of mindfulness of breathing, it might be useful to practice what is sometimes called choiceless awareness. If you use the techniques in helping you in your mindfulness of breathing of noting, that is, say, mentally noting what the mind is involved in from moment to moment.
For example, in the course of the breathing, knowing that you’re breathing in, to emphasize this fact, we can use the technique of noting. Simply a quiet gentle noting in your mind, in, that you are breathing out, emphasizing that fact by noting out. So you are noting in and out, in and out in your mind. When we practice choiceless awareness, we simply are going to allow the mind to be drawn to any object that it naturally tends towards. We’re not going to try to focus the mind on any particular object.
The mind is going to move to an object of itself, the strongest thing in this. It might be an external object such as sound. Could you turn the volume down a little bit just a slightly? Is that okay? Can you hear me in the back?
Yes. Just allow the mind to Allow the mind. Can you hear? Is it okay now? Down a little bit more.
Is it okay now? Can you hear me? It may be an external object such as sound or smell. Maybe an internal object, pain in your knee or thoughts. Simply note them, whatever the mind is involved in, thinking, hearing.
And the car goes by, hearing, hearing, hearing, it goes and you can’t hear any longer and the mind will move to another focus. Pain, pain, thinking, hearing, smelling, tasting, whatever. Just gently noting from moment to moment what the mind is involved in. Maintaining your awareness but in a choiceless manner. So if you take a comfortable but firm posture, it will begin with mindfulness of breathing.
Maybe you’re supposed to be first getting in touch with your body and noticing any tensions and the tightnesses, especially around the neck and shoulder. And bringing your conscious awareness to those areas and consciously relaxing, softening. You can almost feel tension moving down and out of your body into the ground. Your body becomes comfortable and soft, feels good and relaxed. The body becomes soft, comfortable, and relaxed.
Then gently bring the mind to the breath. Just the easy, even, in and out flow of the breath. Bring your mind back to the breath. Gently note the breath. Gently noting in your mind the in and out of the breath.
Now allow the mind to become involved in any object that it naturally tends to allow, but maintain your awareness, gently noting what the mind is involved in. Watch very carefully. Watch very carefully and gently note what the mind is involved in. Keep your awareness. Keep watching.
And bring your mind back to the breath. The easy, gentle, and even flow of the breath. If you’d like to stand up for a minute, just stretch. What do we mean by a Buddha? That’s all.
A loving, healthy, sane human being. Someone who is solving, has solved the problems of inherent in ego based existence within their own life and compassionately works without skillfully to be able to help others to do the same. That’s all. It’s not someone in the sky, but someone who’s living the possibility of life and all that it can do. It was actualizing the potential which we all possess within ourselves, who has gone beyond their own self containing limits and living on the boundaries and the possibility of being.
They fulfill this evolutionary possibilities of human existence, which we all can do, to some extent. But even as I was trying to improvise this morning, Just the trying that we can respect ourselves, that we have that dignity, that we can feel good about ourselves. That’s okay. So the inner purpose of our life becomes Buddha, the Buddha within, inside of ourselves. This becomes our orientation.
Essentially what this means is that our orientation becomes one of growth, that we choose the consistent choice, the alternative of what is going to help me develop myself as opposed to living a life which is controlled under the influence of hope and fear, in which we simply keep going around and around in the same circles, the same repetitive patterns out of fear, out of hope that things will get better without having to do anything about it, out of fear of an open fluid way of relating, somehow realigning our allegiance. If we make this refuge, if we take this orientation in our life, then we don’t have to worry. We don’t have to keep re shoring up our hopes for tomorrow because tomorrow will take care of itself if we take care of the present moment, if we’re always choosing growth. The inner focus of our life becomes Buddha by means of the Dharma, that which helps us to grow. There’s the truth, anything which assists our mind, some kind of key, whether it’s in a formal sense or all the lessons that reality is continually showering down upon us if we’re aware, if we’re open to those lessons.
And this occurs within the social context of a spiritual community that we are essentially social beings, that we have to acknowledge our connectedness with others, our dependence upon others, and that mental health is a social phenomenon, that we cannot attain mental health in isolation from others, as if some kind of gaining of realizations in isolation with others were possible and to be healthy and happy in isolation. Going beyond our sense of self centeredness, our sense of separation, our sense of self sufficiency, rugged individualism, whatever, and acknowledging the necessity that for life to be meaningful, it requires others in our life. Beginning to go beyond our own parochial needs and beginning to accept a greater, more universal vision of what we’re about as social beings and going beyond the narrow confines of the prison which we have constructed for ourselves and beginning to open yourself up to a wider world of other people and other people’s pains and people’s joys as a way of growth and a way of fulfilling the possibilities of a very important aspect of ourselves, that part of ourselves which exists in relationship to others. And we try to raise the level of our motivation such that we’re not doing this just for myself, just for my own piece of chocolate cake.
I think there was this quotation by Martin Buber in which he says, If I am only for myself, what am I? If I am not for myself, who will be? And if not now, when? So, you know, if we’re not for ourselves, if we don’t love ourselves, then there’s going to be no change. We’re never going to get sincere about ending our problems on a very profound level.
And without loving ourselves, there’s no way that we can begin to love others knowing our own pain, our own difficulties very immediately, very directly, and at best only knowing others difficulties vicariously, second handedly. Without developing the compassion for ourselves, how can we ever develop for others? If I am not for myself, who will be? And who can we ask if we cannot ask of ourselves to help ourselves? And if I’m only for myself, what am I?
What kind of prison are we creating for ourselves within our own egocentric existence, within our own exaggerated self concern? The walls, the barriers, the defenses, the alienation, the separation that we create for ourselves. And one of our central problems is that we’re completely absorbed in our own problem. And the moment we become aware that we are able to put our problems in perspective in a grander scale of things in terms of the problems which are just all about us, then there’s some kind of easing. We’re no longer compounding our problems like being completely absorbed in them.
Not only that, this allows for possibility of solution. It’s quite often it’s as if in our myopic vision we’re completely surrounded by cloud and there’s only me and my problem. It becomes tremendously magnified and there’s no solution, there’s no way out. But the moment we become aware that our problems are in some sort of grander perspective, it is not that we avoid our problems, it has to be solved. But if we can put it in some kind of perspective, then there’s a possibility for a solution.
Some kind of sun of wisdom can radiate within our own mind and help us to avail ourselves of our potential to work on that problem. Otherwise, the very self absorption becomes an obstacle to finding a solution. We’re not able to access by our intelligence. Love over and above other qualities we may be able to attribute to it. It is the way that we can access the greatest of our potential.
In that sense, it can be one of the greatest forces in the world. Helps us to access. It opens a potentiality within ourselves. And it’s like a key to love ourselves and to love others. It’s the only way that we can completely actualize our potential.
There’s no other way. That is why love and compassion are the basis of all spiritual practice, of all religion. Christ didn’t say to love your enemies, to do good things to those who hate you, to pray for those who maltreat you because he was either a romantic or he was foolish. He saw it as an extremely skillful and powerful method to become perfect as your Father in Heaven is perfect. And this is the same within Buddhism.
It is the means by which we can begin to actualize our complete potential. So the process becomes one of the inner focus of our life. It becomes that of Buddha, the Buddha within, inside of ourselves, to grow by means of the Dharma, which is able to move our mind, which is able to take us from where we are now, with all our hatred, with all our anger, envy, jealousy, and to move us toward higher orders of being, and take us from attachment to openness, from from hatred to love, from ignorance to wisdom, that which has that potentiality, key which opens up absolute access. In the social context of the spiritual community where others have really voluntarily chosen to associate with one another, where the prime focus of their life becomes enlightenment, becomes growth and supporting each other in whatever way will facilitate that growth. And we try to raise our motivation for this process to one of love, one of loving ourselves and loving others.
And thereby creating the contextual atmosphere whereby, you know, it’s like where all this process can take place in the most optimum manner. The force behind it all becomes one of caring and concerning communication. I go for refuge until I’m enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the Sangha. When the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections, may I attain the state of a Buddha to be able to benefit all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, the Dharma, and the highest assembly.
From the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections, may I attain the state of a Buddha to be able to benefit all sentient beings. I go for refuge until I am enlightened to the Buddha, to Dharma, and highest assembly. From the virtuous merit that I collect by practicing giving and the other perfections, may I attain the state of a Buddha to be able to benefit all sentient beings. Oh my goodness. I wouldn’t make a very good time management expert, obviously.
I was going to say a few words about selflessness in the sense of the wisdom of understanding selflessness, emptiness, and then we’re going to meditate on it. What can I say? We’ve been having a weekend discussing the Four Noble Truths. True sufferings are to be recognized, sources of suffering are to be abandoned, true cessations of suffering are to be actualized, and true paths leading to the cessation of suffering are to be cultivated. And within the latter of these four noble truths, the noble truth of the path, This can be explained in terms of the Eightfold Noble Path, the Three Higher Trainings, the Three Fundamentals of the Path.
Central to all of these is the wisdom, understanding, emptiness. And there are many levels that we can understand this on. And it’s like the rungs of a ladder. Understanding one level facilitates coming to an understanding of a higher level. And the one level that we can begin to look at it on, and I thought we had discussed, I’m just going to mention it and then we’ll meditate on it, is in terms of that we instinctively grasp to a singular, unchanging, independent self.
That we instinctively grasp, conceive of, try to hold onto, conceive of, grasp to, a very concrete, solid type of self. The fundamental characteristics of this self that we’re grasping at is that it’s singular, homogenous, a whole, doesn’t have any parts. It’s unchanging. It’s constantly the same quality and it’s independent. It doesn’t depend upon causes and conditions.
It doesn’t depend upon parts. It doesn’t depend upon my mind, my conceiving, my labeling process, my giving that name. It has these qualities somewhere in here, over here, on the side of the object. Have a sense that there is a self which is singular, unchanging and independent. This is the basis of all our problems.
We were discussing this a little bit yesterday. There is an empirical self. Human beings are model builders. Their minds operate in terms of symbols. So we have models of a self.
There is an empirical self which talks, which sits and listens, eats, which meditates, does all these various functions. So we have a particular model of that self which we call I. The thing about models, the thing about language is that they refer to something else. Are symbols. Symbols refer to something other than themselves.
Know, we use symbols to manipulate, to think. We manipulate symbols in order to come to understanding, to think about things out there as if in the real world. I can think and I can accurately predict, I can work things out, I can make decisions. Just simply manipulating symbols like numbers, I can come to conclusions. So we’re using symbols.
We have a symbol of the empirical I, the self. Just like for example, you know, there’s a famous expression called the map is not the territory. The map is not the territory. We don’t have enough time. You get a roadmap out and that roadmap corresponds to something out there.
You know, these little lines, you can’t drive on those little lines. And there’s little dots. There’s no restaurants where you can stop and have a meal, But you it does have significance because you can get to where you want to go by a correspondence between these little lines and these little dots and the real world out there. But this map is not the territory. And sometimes we confuse the two.
So this map, you know, like who was it, Tolkien? You know, he invented this world and he had maps. And it’s very complicated, very elaborate and very colorful world that he invented. But there’s no world, at least that I know of, that corresponds to that. But it’s very enjoyable to enter into that make believe world as it were.
But it doesn’t correspond to anything out there as it were. So there’s this map and we can make use of it to get to where we want to go to because it corresponds to something out there. But we also have, so this map is like a model. We have internal models of the I. Now we have an internal model of the I.
I think I’ll go the to movie tomorrow. You know, that’s quite useful to think in that way, to make a plan, that I will go to the movie tomorrow, it’ll get in the car and go down to the theater and buy a ticket and sit down in the chair. That I can do that, can perform that function. I which is going to a movie, there’s a model of an I, there’s a model of a movie, there’s a model of this meaning. We put them all together and we come up with some kind of plan that has some kind of meaning in our life.
That model of that I which is going to go to the movie, that corresponds to something in reality, just like the map corresponds to an actual territory. This model that we call I, that we’ve given the name I, corresponds to something out there which can go to movies, which can do all these kinds of things. But just as in the case of Tolkien’s map, which have no correspondence in reality, we have another map, a model in our mind, of a type of I. A type of I which feels threatened by death, which is easily hurt, which can, you know, which arises, we make use of in emotional experiences. This I, it looks, you know, we use the same name.
That’s of the problems. We use the same name to designate these two models. But the second, this one that arises that we make use of in the course of a very powerful emotional experience. I’m the most wonderful thing that ever happened since sliced bread came along. Or, I hate your guts, I can’t stand you.
That odd, right? That, when I say I can’t stand you, we’re making use of a particular model of an I. But that I is quite different than the eye which is going to planning and going to the movies. That eye doesn’t have anything which corresponds to reality. It’s like Tolkien’s map.
We can’t find anything which corresponds to it. But we believe it. Never checked up. We believe that it does just as the empirical model, model which actually goes to movies, which eats, sleeps and talks, that has a correspondence. We believe that this model of the I which can’t stand, the I that feels threatened, the I with all its fears, with all its guilt, feeling with all its shame, as if there is an I which corresponds to that in reality.
And we react and operate our life on a basis as if there really is something which corresponds to what is really a model of a type of I which has no correspondence in reality. Does that make sense? So, we have to begin to see through that though I hate your gut, there is simply a model that we’re operating, this I at that particular instant in that emotional situation, there’s nothing which corresponds to it. We have to look for to be able to see through. It’s merely a conception within our mind, a very elaborate model that we’re operating on, but there’s nothing which corresponds to it.
When I say, I’m sitting here talking to you, I can find somebody. When I say the words language, I have a model in my mind, I’m talking to you. That’s quite useful for me to be able to use these symbols, models, language. And I can not only do that, it corresponds to something which is happening in reality. I am talking to you.
So I can think of it in terms of my mind, I can have the map and it corresponds to the territory, something in reality. But when I say, I hate your gut, I can’t do anything right. What’s wrong with me? That I, that model doesn’t correspond to anything. We’re never going to find any corresponding something in reality which we can there is a correspondence to.
And this is the way we can begin to disbelieve. Though that model may appear to us, we say, Ah, it’s merely my conception. It’s merely a model I have in my mind. Actually, there’s no one there who feels ashamed. There’s no one there who feels this tremendous guilt.
I can’t do anything. We’re never going to be able to find that, anything which corresponds to that model. We can talk about pink elephants. Can think that three pink elephants minus two pink elephants equals one pink elephant. But we’re talking about anything reality.
There’s no pink elephant, but we can think, we’ve had many conceptions, many models which don’t correspond to the world. Nothing out there. We we the idea of pink elephant in it, that’s quite obvious, it? We just dismiss that. There’s nothing really like a pink elephant.
But when you say, Oh, I can’t stand you, that’s why we think it was very real and we have to begin to look through it. So, one way we can do it is if you have enough time to meditate. So, we’re not trying to identify the empirically existent I, the I which talks, which eats, sleeps. This I is not a problem. We’re trying to identify the I which arises in the course of extreme emotional situation.
What are we identifying? We’re identifying a model, aren’t we? A conception, a very elaborate model, a hypothesis, a symbol within our mind. When you have, when you, you know, I’m going to die someday, I’m so afraid, don’t want to leave all of this, and all my friends, that we’re operating with a model in our thinking, not only within our mind. We want to be able to identify that very clearly, what that model looks like.
And then once we’ve identified it, we’re going to look for to see if it corresponds to anything in reality. We’ve a clear roadmap, then we’re going to look for it to see if it really describes their territory. So first we have to really get an accurate conception view of that model that we’re operating on. And then we’ll look for it in reality to see if it corresponds, see if it refers to anything in fact or whether it’s just another pink elephant. So, the most important and most difficult is to identify the model that we’re working with.
So, we can sort of play around with this idea to induce either through imagination or one’s experience and memory some vivid remembrance or an experience of an emotional situation. You’re going up to the podium to receive the Nobel Prize and you fall flat on your face on your trip. Or something actually did happen to you, an argument. Somebody says stupid, you’re really stupid, and then something happens, something is under threat. What is it that’s that you don’t call me that.
I don’t know, I hate that. That I which feels hurt, the I which feels threatened. Induce some kind of emotional experience and then try to identify that I. The most difficult process, is this identification, recognizing this I, and then we’re going to look for it. I’m afraid just going to go through this very quickly because we don’t have enough time to do it slowly.
We’re going to go through the body where we see the I. You know, I don’t look for the I out on the street. I have a sense it’s over here. Somewhere over here, there’s an I which I feel very strongly. I sense very strongly.
And this is where we’re going to look for. And we’re going to look within the body and then we’re going to look within the mind in a very systematic method. So it’s such that we end up with a sense, I thought it was there but I can’t find it. And the meditator, again and again looking, again and again looking, getting a more and more clear idea of what he or she is looking for. Looking, not finding, looking, not finding, looking, finding, looking, looking, nothing.
Finally, it begins to dawn on the meditator. It simply doesn’t occur. I have a model of an I, but it doesn’t refer to anything, in fact. And then all of the tension, all of the distress which arises from this misconception that this model actually refers to something in reality which needs to be protected, which needs to be enhanced, is all because the cause has been removed. It is like seeing walking along in the evening and seeing what is in fact a striped rope, but seeing it as a snake.
And one generates fear and various emotions completely based upon misconception. There’s no snake there, but it appears there’s a snake there. So one shines a torch on that. Instantly, all of the fear, all of the various emotions which were based upon that misconception disappear because the cause has been removed. The cause was the mental fabrication to something which didn’t exist.
And likewise, with respect to the torch is like the wisdom of understanding, shining upon this and coming to an understanding that what one could see there was in fact, not there. And all the distress, all the anxiety and fears, which are based upon what is merely a mental fabrication, a conception, which doesn’t refer to anything in reality, disappeared because the cause has been removed. The cause was a misconception within our own mind. So let’s try that.
Key terms in this teaching
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- three higher trainings lhagpäi lab pa sum (Tib)
- The three higher trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom when conjoined with refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.